Probing The Mind Of A Suicide Bomber
In the instance of suicide bombers, according to some research, they are not mentally ill or unhinged, but acting rationally in pursuit of the ‘benefits’ they perceive from being part of a strict and close-knit religious enterprise.
"Suicide bombing is just an extension of this self-sacrifice — the ultimate extension," said Dr David Stevens from the University of Nottingham. Stevens originally released his findings in 2007. "The benefits are perceived to be so great as to justify the action. Fortunately this is so only in extreme instances, under certain circumstances," he noted at that time in a press release.
All this means, according to Stevens, that it is not accurate to hold the widely-held view of suicide bombers as brain-washed religious fanatics, who are vulnerable through youth and poverty.
Stevens' statement is supported by others, such as Michelle Maiese who in "Suicide Bombers. Beyond Intractability." noted that "if only those with some kind of psychopathology could be terrorists, terrorism would not be the large problem that it is. Research shows no indication that terrorists are crazy or psychopathic or that they lack moral feelings."
Stevens notes that contrary to popular opinion, poverty, isolation and lack of education are not typical features of the bomber profile. Mohammad Sidique Khan, for example, who blew himself up in London on July 7, 2005, murdering six people in the process, was a 30-year-old with a young family of his own and a job working in primary schools with special needs children.
Likewise it is a common misconception that suicide bombers are mentally ill or irrational, because it would make them a liability to the terrorist groups with which they were involved, Stevens claimed.
Instead, the key, according to Stevens, is religion, noting that there are few instances of non-religiously motivated suicide attacks — the suicide bomber is also driven on another level by a rational thought process. This is the desire to be part of a group that engenders strength and solidarity from strictness, and encourages members to submit totally to the collective aims of the group.
"Those who maintain that suicide attacks are motivated by religious ideology suggest that the bombers believe that God has sent them on a mission," according to Michelle Maiese. " They are motivated primarily by the promise of a happy afterlife and heavenly reward and the threat of heavenly retribution Their rationale is that by blowing themselves up in a crowd of people, they are making themselves martyrs and forging their own gateway to heaven."
According to Maiese," Terrorists tend to have an apocalyptic worldview and to see the world as precariously balanced between good and evil. They believe that through their actions, they can uphold their values of family, religion, ethnicity, and nationality and bring about the triumph of the good. Acting on God's behalf to defend these values is viewed as more important than life. For example, Muslim fundamentalists often fear that their religious values and culture are in danger of being overwhelmed by the secularism and military and economic power of the West."
There are others, however, that note politics and religion in some instances have become intertwined.
Interestingly enough, according to the Oxford University sociologist Diego Gambetta, suicide bombing may have nothing to do with Islam or the Koran, as noted in a Psychology Today article, that claims "it (suicide bombing) may have nothing to do with the religion, politics, the culture, the race, the ethnicity, the language, or the region. As with everything else from this perspective, it may have a lot to do with sex, or, in this case, the absence of sex."
"What distinguishes Islam from other major religions is that it tolerates polygyny. By allowing some men to monopolize all women and altogether excluding many men from reproductive opportunities, polygyny creates shortages of available women. If 50 percent of men have two wives each, then the other 50 percent don't get any wives at all," according to the same article, which further claims that the "other key ingredient is the promise of 72 virgins waiting in heaven for any martyr in Islam."
According to documentary film-maker Pierre Rehov, the typical suicide bomber is between 15 and 25 years old and has been "fed with religion. They usually have a lack of developed personality. Usually they are impressionable idealists. In the Western world they could easily have become drug addicts, but not criminals."
"Interestingly they are not criminals as they do not see good and evil the same way that we do," Rehov added.
Being part of an exclusive group with very strict beliefs requires intense commitment, and engenders a deep belief in shared experience and self-sacrifice, according Stevens.
To put it in other terms, suicide bombers are motivated by a "simple cost-benefit analysis", in which the ‘benefits’ of self-destruction outweigh the cost. The benefits are perceived by the terrorist to be so great — in terms of membership of the group, achievement of collective goals, the promise of benefits in the after-life, and so on — that they outweigh the cost.
In this way there is a ‘marriage’ of violence and religion, via the suicide bomber’s participation in the group, according to Stevens.
"Seen in this light, suicide bombing is explicable in terms of rationally motivated actions, and not in terms of theological and/or irrational motives," he said. "To gain the collective benefits of participation in a strict group requires self-sacrifice, often of extreme levels."
"But then suicide bombing is in actual fact very rare. Rare, that is, when it is remembered that extreme religious groups make up only a tiny fraction of religious groups as a whole, and 99.99 per cent of those groups are in fact peaceable," Stevens said. "Statistically, then, finding one or two people willing to make such a sacrifice is incredibly rare. However, given the nature of suicide bombing, it only takes one or two."
The attractions of intense solidarity don’t only apply to fringe Islamic sects, but also to other extreme religious groups.
Many members of other such groups — from the Moonies to the Branch Davidians — explain their decisions to join, and as importantly to leave, in terms of the costs and benefits of participation rather than in the context of a ‘brainwashing’ process.
Stevens said, "From purely an organizational point of view, working with deranged individuals is extremely hazardous. Terror organizations go to extreme lengths to keep their activities and set-up secret. The costs of discovery are immense for all involved.
"Under such circumstances, who would want to work with someone completely unpredictable — a maverick, a loose cannon — someone likely to give the game away at any stage through an act of sheer madness," Stevens said. "Even terrorists don’t want to work with those with a death-wish — you achieve very little that way."
Sources:
- Information provided by The University of Nottingham
- Maiese, Michelle. "Suicide Bombers." Beyond Intractability. Eds. Guy Burgess and Heidi Burgess. Conflict Research Consortium, University of Colorado, Boulder. Posted: June 2005
- CNN interview with Pierre Rehov, July 23, 2005
- "Ten Politically Incorrect Truths About Human Nature". Psychology Today, By: Alan S. Miller Ph.D., Satoshi Kanazawa Ph.D.


























0 comments:
Post a Comment