Competition, Competitiveness, Growth: New Impetus For EU

Saturday, April 10, 2010

Speech of Joaquín Almunia Vice-President of the European Commission responsible for Competition Policy Competition, competitiveness, growth: a new impetus for the European Union Address at Confindustria Conference - "Liberta e Benessere – l'Italia al Futuro" Parma, 9 April 2010

***

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here today: 100 years after Confindustria was founded, you represent the best of Italian industry and enterprise. Your success lies, I believe, in your commitment to free enterprise, your hard work, your creativity and your skills.

To address such an impressive gathering of representatives of the Italian enterprises gives me a unique opportunity to present here some of my ideas around the very important question of how best to overcome the crisis and to achieve lasting and sustainable growth in Europe.

I think that one key element of the answer to this question lies with open and competitive markets, in which business is given the opportunity to prosper.

Some take the contrary view – arguing that Europe cannot be competitive abroad as long as it imposes on itself a competition policy discipline in the internal market. They believe that the way forward is for the State to protect national markets, promote national champions, set up public barriers to competition and hand out public money to prop up inefficient businesses.

Let me be crystal clear: I believe that this is a recipe for failure.

On the contrary, in order to make Europe more competitive what we need to do is to promote Europe's capacity for research and development, for innovation and for entrepreneurship. This will make European goods and services more attractive. We have great examples of that in Italy and indeed here in the room – where Italian innovation, design and quality are the foundation for the success of world-class companies.

We need to continually improve the quality of our human resources, by improving education and training.

We need to make sure that business can take full advantage of our European Single Market. And they must also be in a position to take up opportunities to access markets beyond Europe.

These objectives are in line with the Europe 2020 strategy recently put forward by the Commission and endorsed by the European Council. A strategy for achieving a new period of growth and dynamism in Europe. Innovation and competitiveness are fundamental to the 2020 Strategy, alongside protection of the environment and social inclusion. They are part of our vision for the European economy for the 21st century.

How can we achieve these objectives?

How does competition policy help contribute to these objectives and make European and Italian business more competitive?

First, I would like to emphasize the benefits of competition for business.

Competition encourages companies to innovate. They cannot rest on past successes. Instead, they are forced to come up with new and better products so as to retain old customers and gain new ones. Companies are encouraged adapt their business strategies to customer demands and to make investments for the longer term.

Competition encourages companies to allocate their resources in the most efficient way.

Competition contributes to achieving more choice, better quality and lower prices for consumers – and it is worth remembering that businesses are consumers too, and that they benefit from competition in all the goods and services they purchase.

Ultimately, competition helps boost productivity, growth and job creation.

Telecommunications is one of the best examples of a sector that has been very successfully opened up to competition in recent years – to the benefit of business as well as individual consumers. As a consequence of liberalisation and technological change, the price businesses in Europe paid for international telephone calls went down 45 per cent between 1998 and 2003.

Air transport is another sector where increased liberalisation has led to very concrete benefits for business and consumers, since the frequency of flights has gone up by 78 per cent, while the standard cost of flights has gone down by 66 per cent.

The application of an EU-wide competition policy helps create a level-playing field for business across Europe. It creates opportunities for companies, which have access to a wider market for their goods and services. It also creates challenges that improve their performance, as they find themselves competing with companies from across the EU.

At the same time, competition enhances companies' ability to compete globally. Businesses will be in a better position to compete outside our borders if they are capable of investing, innovating and creating jobs within the internal market. Therefore, those who think that protecting domestic firms from competitive pressures enhances their productivity gains are completely wrong.

In order to promote competition and competitiveness in Europe, we have three sets of competition policy instruments at our disposal: the EU Treaty rules on State aid, on anticompetitive agreements and abuses of dominant position, and those governing mergers between companies.

The purpose of these rules is not to drown business in red tape or raise obstacles to business. To the contrary. These are tools that serve you well, by making markets more competitive.

State aid policy

Indeed, the point of the EU State aid rules is not to ban all state support. It rather sets up a framework that helps ensure that State aid is appropriate to its goal, of correcting a market failure or achieving a particular policy objective, and that it does not unduly distort competition.

Aid granted by Member States in the context of the financial and economic crisis is a case in point. From the start, the Commission acted under the State aid rules to facilitate government measures to support the financial markets, while ensuring that they were based on EU wide criteria. Thanks to this decision, distortions of competition in the financial sector were kept to a minimum, and helped preserve the internal market.

Since the beginning of the crisis the Commission has adopted over 150 decisions authorising approximately 3.600 billion euros of support measures for credit institutions. We also adopted a Temporary Framework under the State aid rules to enable Member States to facilitate access to finance by the "real" economy, which is being squeezed as a result of the crisis.

But the aid instruments adopted in the context of the crisis were designed to meet the needs of the crisis: the need to preserve the stability of financial institutions and to restore liquidity for the real economy.

Going forward, our State aid policy should contribute to the viability of the banking sector – for instance by insisting on restructuring measures for certain financial institutions.

Of course, aid must be phased out gradually, taking account of market conditions and the requirements of financial stability. But there should be no doubt about our goal: we want to achieve an exit from state support and a return to normal market functioning for all market players as soon as possible.

Once the exceptional framework adopted at the beginning of the crisis is phased out, normal State aid instruments should continue to play a key role in helping the European economy emerge from the crisis.

Through a centralized European-wide control we can ensure that subsidies are not used by the richer Member States to the detriment of the poorer ones, but that they intervene to sustain key sectors of the European economy.

In this sense, horizontal aid measures create less distortions of competition than individual aid measures.

EU State aid rules include a clear framework which clarifies how Member states can lawfully support research and development aid in the EU. People sometimes believe that because of our "restrictive" State aid rules, support for R&D&I is lower in the EU than elsewhere. In reality, public support for R&D&I in the EU, calculated as a percentage of GDP, is very similar to the levels of support in Japan and the US. And our research suggests that the vast majority of support for R&D&I provided in the US, Japan, China and South Korea, would also have been allowed under the current EU framework. Therefore, the EU deficit lies in the private contribution to our total R&D&I spending, not in the public part of it.

EU state aid policy contributes at several levels to jobs and cohesion. The goal of increasing cohesion within the EU underpins our rules on aid to firms in disadvantaged regions. And EU State aid rules provide Member States with a range of options to encourage employment related measures, for instance linked to investment projects by SMEs, or by companies established in disadvantaged regions.

EU State aid policy can also contribute to achieving environmental objectives – to help us move towards a greener Europe. To take a recent example, the Commission has just authorised 30 million euros worth of support by the German government to ArcelorMittal for a project called "Top Gas Recycling". It involves a technology that will enable considerable reductions in CO2 emissions in the steel sector.

Ultimately, the EU State aid rules help keep the Single European market open, integrated and competitive. They help maintain a level playing field for business and avoid Member States engaging in subsidy races – to the detriment of all.

Antitrust and merger control

At the same time, our antitrust and merger control instruments also have a very important role to play, in maintaining competition, helping make markets work better, and promoting the competitiveness of European business.

It is crucial that we maintain a policy of vigorous enforcement against cartels and other anticompetitive behaviour. The crisis cannot be an excuse to weaken the way we use our competition policy instruments. Just the opposite.

Cartels cause an enormous amount of harm to the economy as a whole, by artificially raising prices for consumers and businesses. If trade between Member States in the EU were eliminated, for instance as a result of market sharing agreements between companies or State imposed restrictions on competition, it is estimated that average productivity may fall by 13 per cent. Sealing off markets from outside competition would only allow companies to raise prices and restrict output, which would further slow growth

Competition helps us realise the potential of network industries in the most efficient way.

Energy is one of the most interesting sectors because of its crucial importance for the European industry as a whole, and because it is a sector in which evidence suggested that in spite of liberalisation measures, competition was not delivering all the benefits it should. As a result, the Commission carried out an inquiry into the energy sector between 2005 and 2007, under the EU antitrust rules. The outcome of that inquiry was to help identify obstacles to competition resulting from problems with market opening and market integration.

These findings were fed into the new package of measures for achieving a European internal market for energy (the Third Energy Package), as well as a number of antitrust enforcement cases relating to anticompetitive agreements and potential abuses of market power by energy companies.

For example, in 2009 the Commission adopted a decision against German energy company E.On and French energy company GDF for market sharing on German and French gas markets. We imposed fines of over 500 million euros on each company.

Another case involves ENI, which is dominant on gas transport and supply market into Italy. Our preliminary finding was that ENI may have abused its dominance by refusing to supply capacity on international pipelines leading into Italy, and by strategically limiting investment in its international pipeline system, which could result in competitors being excluded from the market and harm to consumers. In order to resolve the Commission's concerns ENI is proposing to divest its share in these pipelines. This proposal has been market tested and is under consideration.

These are a couple of examples of where the application of the EU antitrust rules could really improve the level of competition in energy markets, to the benefit of customers, while at the same time helping ensure security of supply.

Finally, I should mention merger control. The EU merger control essentially helps to ensure that market structures in the EU remain competitive. Potential mergers that would remove or significantly reduce effective competition in the market are not allowed to proceed. What we provide is a one stop shop for mergers of a certain size in Europe, thus contributing to keep costs down for business and to provide legal certainty.

Where a potential merger raises competition problems, the Commission works very closely with the parties to find a solution. What we always must do is to seek effective, viable, and sustainable solutions to competition problems.

But we also have to make sure that Member States do not seek to impose unjustified conditions on European takeovers, so as to protect national champions.

Conclusions

Let me conclude.

In order to be able to start growing again, European, and thus Italian industry, needs to be competitive. This means they must be in a position to compete for business across the EU Single Market and globally.

I do not believe that European industry can get itself into shape by relying on short-term measures, such as State subsidies to prop up failing businesses, State measures to protect markets or indeed private measures to protect markets and ward off competition. We need to have the courage to move away from this type of measure.

The only way to be competitive and succeed globally is to compete on the basis of ideas, creativity, efficiencies and innovation.

Through a rigorous European-wide implementation of EU competition rules we can help your industry achieve these long term goals of competitiveness and growth.

But the Commission, and the national competition authorities, cannot do this alone. Business must take responsibility too. And an organisation such as Confindustria has an important role to play. I count on you to take forward this message about the benefits of competition and to orient yourselves again down the path towards competitiveness, economic recovery and growth.

As you did extremely well in the past.

I am convinced that you, and all your colleagues throughout Europe, will succeed.

Thank you.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • MySpace
  • LinkedIn
  • Live
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • Sphinn
  • Propeller
  • Slashdot
  • Netvibes

0 comments:

Post a Comment




Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search