It's Not About The Money: Antinomianism Is The Word
Everybody in the know knows professor Niall Ferguson just produced an article in Foreign Affairs destined to be praised as a great capture of the zeitgeist, and thereby hangs a tale. Everybody in the know knows that, in the rarest of events in the conservative think-tank world he has paired up with the famed Dutch anti-Islamist of Somali origin Ayaan Hirsi Ali, and thereby hangs another tale. Finally, everybody, in the know or not, knows that living above your means is the best way to call for trouble, and thereby hangs the most important tale of all.
Mr Ferguson, drawing on an interesting metaphor with Thomas Cole’s five paintings called The course of Empire, goes on to show that all Empires collapse but that rather than doing so because of a set of causes determined by a series of clear-cut events, the extreme complexity of their decay turns out to be suddenly compounded by a single, maybe not at all great, occurrence that sends them to oblivion. A common pattern, however, is found by Mr Ferguson, and contended to be of paramount importance in the death of Empires: the accumulation of debt. Empires grow up to be so complex that their collapse comes with the bankruptcy that overwhelms them when they try to keep on financing their ever-increasing needs. Such a time as now shows the US – and the Western world for which it stands - going down such a road.
Mr Ferguson analysis is brilliant in many ways and there is no doubt that it may end up being as momentous as other successful essays have been in the recent past depicting the evolution of affairs in the Western world such as, to name a few, Mr Huntington’s Clash of Civilizations, Mr Fukuyama’s The End Of History or Mr Kagan’s Of Paradise and Power. However, and apart from the disputable thesis that it is indeed very particular events that dramatically speed changes rather than evolution – what the ever polemical Glenn Beck would call revolution rather than evolution theory – it can be said that, there is not so much new in Mr Ferguson’s contention.
Not so long ago a series of respectable writers and historians made the point that Europe, not the US indeed but the other half of the Western world, was in the midst of a crisis of civilization that could well end up in its final demise. For instance, the historian Walter Laqueur produced the hardly secretive title The Last Days of Europe, while the colourful Mark Steyn went on to write America Alone. It could even be argued that the trend had started long before when Pope John Paul II published his Encyclical Ecclesia in Europa, not long ago reconsidered by George Weigel, himself a precursor in European decline oeuvres with his sensible The Cube and the Cathedral.
Admittedly these are works distinguishing Europe from the US and the above mentioned Paradise and Power could also fit in this category. In that sense, they seem to leave out the US from the current of decline. However, going back to an article published by the late Richard John Neuhaus about a dissent on this literature written by Philip Jenkins, it would be well to remember that many of these calls of attention where intended to draw the Americans attention to the fact, so that it would not happen to them, or, as Santayana’s famous dictum would have put it: know history, albeit other’s, in order not to repeat it. Incidentally it was George Weigel’s first take on the subject, a 2004 article bearing the title: Europe’s Problem and Ours, that made room in the table of operations for the dissection of two possible corpses, not just Europe’s but the US’s as well.
The last to come up with such a comparison would certainly have to be Charles Murray’s The Pursuit of Happiness where the sudden appearance of President Obama as a Suede – in the startling portrayal of Charles Krauthammer – is indeed telling as far as eventful occurrences go.
And so it is that, somehow, Mr Ferguson’s article could not strike as being particularly original but rather the cherry on a pie that had been long in the cooking, or that having been simmering was now brought to a boil. Therefore if capture of the zeitgeist there is, and there might well be, Mr Ferguson’s article would turn out to be the meaningful event speeding up the chain of reaction, but it would certainly reach the top having climbed on the shoulders of relevant predecessors that have by no means been all mentioned here.
As for the glamorous side of the affair, or the affair on the side of the glamour, if you will, there also hangs a tale worth telling. Ms Hirsi Ali is, quite apart from a beautiful woman, a very clever one, and, to pick a line from Vice-president Biden, rather articulate in Dutch for a Somali. She has indeed become part of the history of the Netherlands by completing a brilliant literary and political career in her host country, that went bust when, trapped by a TV program in an interview she confessed to some elements of her asylum request that were viciously used by the political establishment to get rid of a troublemaker in the quiet pond. Suffice it to say that members of the Hofstadt Group – the Islamist colleagues of Mohamed Bouyeri, who assassinated Theo Van Gogh for the movie he made following Ms Hirsi Ali’s script – left chocolates and flowers at the door of the TV station as a sign of their gratitude for making it possible to throw her away from the country. This was of course, after a judge had decided she had to move because of the danger she caused to her neighbours having been marked by Bouyeri as next in line to pay – with her life - for her denunciation of the situation of women in Islam.
It is hard to call it then a blessing in disguise for such a woman to have to renounce her acquired Dutch nationality – although she regained it later in a political twist that would be comic if the whole affair had not been tragic – and go to the US to try and have, finally, a life. As rich in experience and example her past has shown to be. But then again none of this is new either, and Ms Hirsi Ali’s thereabouts are pretty well known and documented before her exile to the US, even in her books.
And yet, what is new, the core of the crisis, is nowhere to be seen in Mr Ferguson’s view, or around it. Far from being the debt the cause of the troubles, it is the opposite that is true: the abandonment of all orthodoxy, the deliberate attempt to reach goals against all norms, is what has been piling up the expenses. That is the last tale that has to be told.
In a long book about the Prophets, Norman Podhoretz, after much saying over their theological, historical and metaphysical meaning, has a concluding chapter dealing with the Prophets and Us. What could they say, if anything, to the liberal minded postmodernist that makes much of the Western world? Striking as it may seem, coming from the leading neoconservative intellectual, the Prophets have something to say not only to the believer – be it Christian or Jewish -, but to the unbeliever as well. And to make his point, ever the literary critic, he goes on to quote an obscure Saul Bellow novel.
In it, an agnostic character in an atheist’s book, talks of a line of conduct that:
We know, that we know, we know, we know.
That is: we do know. Men of all beliefs and none at all are still endowed by their Creator with a certain inalienable knowledge about what is right and wrong; of the very truth that reality answers to a certain code, and that this, for a Jew, comes in the form of a covenant, a Law. This indeed is what the Prophets were always bringing to the attention of their contemporaries; sometimes even against their human wills: that idols or paganism amounted to a blinding towards God shown in a violation of the Law.
This brings us back to Charles Murray’s The Pursuit of Happiness where, when comparing the US to Europe, he lists four vital – and private - characteristics as key to a healthy public life. These are vocation, religion, community and family. In every one of them, he asserts, the Europeans have failed by putting them too much in the hands of the state and permitting it to take too much out of life: its problems as much as its rewards. By making a deal with the security the state can provide, individuals in Europe, have abandoned the pursuit of happiness being bereft in the process, of all the meaning of a life truly lived. Can there be a direst violation of the Law? Is this not the very apple we were told not to touch?
But being more specific about the Prophets, the first thing they have to say is this: “that the highest spiritual and moral states to which human beings are capable of attaining can best – or possibly even only – be reached through engagement with the affairs of the world around one, emphatically including what seem to be, or even are, transient or petty or trivial.”
The second thing they have to say is this: “concerning the vision of a perfect world…if one believes in God, one can – indeed must – accept that it is in His power to bring about so miraculous a transformation at the End of Days. But if one believes in God, one must by the same token also accept that it is only in His power to perform theses miracles, and not in the power of mere mortals like ourselves.”
The third thing they have to say – and here comes the Bellow allusion – is that: “we need not believe in heaven and hell… in order to accept that our lives are governed by laws whose ‘terms’ we all know in our ‘inmost hearts’; that people who obey those laws will be blessed; and that people who disobey them will be cursed.”
And then Podhoretz says the dirty word: “the idea that the moral realm is governed by law becomes something more than an empty abstraction when placed against the background of a culture that has for all practical purposes denied or repudiated that idea. The technical term for the denial or repudiation of law is ‘antinomianism’, and it is antinomianism by which, more than any other single force, our culture has been shaped for some time, and is still being shaped today. But there are other names for antinomianism. The one under which the classical prophets so relentlessly fought it was idolatry. The one that historians give it is paganism or polytheism. Today we know it as relativism.”
Yet if the law is dismissed, bad things happen: “In the language of today, this says that the moral law is instinctual (Bellow’s ‘we know, we know, we know’). We are still as free as ever to violate it in one way or another (…). But there are inexorable consequences, even if they are not always immediately apparent: the punishment is not always directly traceable to the sin nor… does the punishment always fit the crime. Something… goes wrong inside.”
“Inverting everything, Podhoretz adds, is the key to antinomianism”. And he reminds of the powerful inversion of politics that Communism was in the slogans of Orwell’s 1984: “WAR IS PEACE/ FREEDOM IS SLAVERY/ IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH”. He finally lists the antinomianisms of the Twentieth and Twenty First centuries, including: the counterculture of the sixties, the relativistic philosophy of today who professes not to be able to distinguish between good and evil; and of course: political correctness, deconstructionism, multiculturalism, environmentalism. He sums up the idol of the antinomians, not without quoting Whitman in between, as the proclamation of Self: narcissism. And he concludes:
“The classical prophets always clung to the hope that the doom they envisaged could be averted by repentance. So can it be with us. But only if we still have ears to hear what they are saying, and only if we – and again I include non-believers – can summon up the courage to translate what they meant by repentance into the language of today.”
Is that what Ferguson just did, or not? Let’s invite Whitman again to the fore:
Old age superbly rising! O welcome, ineffable grace of dying days!
Not because they would be days of reckoning, as Irving Kristol was suggesting when saying that there was nothing so wrong in America that could not be solved by a good economic crisis, but rather as a call to arms to remind of all the broken laws and all the stood-up orthodoxies, of an economic nature too, that brought us to the verge of Cole’s last painting.
Complexity and Collapse is therefore exactly right and yet it fails to include the reason why it is so. To wit: antinomianism preceded the debt escalation, because antinomianism caused it.
When Nineteenth Century Jews were emigrating to America they spoke of it as a goldene medina, but its cities were not paved with gold and it was liberty and opportunity they were referring to. Turns out when freedom was on the march, it dramatically altered the tyrannical landscape of the Middle East, the foreigner’s gift was spread so that, in the words of Bernard Lewis, they do not destroy us. Turns out when the basic tenets of capitalism and the sound principles of no interventionism were being respected the economy gave, and despite of all, continues to provide, luxuries unimaginable in not so distant times.
When in the course of human events it becomes necessary to say no to all determinism, no to the inherent complexity that is bound to doom us, and yes to the realm of culture and ideas, it is because we have started to hear the real tale of the times, of which Ms Ali’s life, because of what it tells about the customs and ways of postmodernist Europeans and Americans alike, is, incidentally, not a bad example. So, to sum up: it’s not about the money, Mr Ferguson; antinomianism has been the name of the game. And the only relevant question is therefore this one: will we summon up the courage and the tone to fight it to its death before it overwhelms the last painting on the wall?
This article was originally published by Grupo de Estudios Estratégicos / Strategic Studies Group (GEES) and is reprinted with permission.


























0 comments:
Post a Comment