In The Guardian: Terror Deportation Debate Misses The Point
For the Guardian’s Comment is free, “An uncivilized society” is an article I wrote analyzing the new coalition government’s first major test of its commitment to long-established legal principles, and to Britain’s human rights obligations. As I also explained in a previous article, these were tested on Monday when, in the Special Immigration Appeals Commissions (SIAC), Mr. Justice Mitting ruled that two Pakistani students, Abid Naseer and Ahmad Faraz Khan, who were seized last April in connection with an alleged terror plot (for which no evidence of an actual plot was found) cannot be deported because they face the risk of torture in Pakistan, even though, in the judge’s opinion, they pose a threat to the national security of the UK.
As I explained in the Guardian article, the hysterical response of right-wing commentators to this ruling is unsurprising, given that the Labour government, by using secret evidence in terror cases and holding men without charge or trial, created a kind of legal black hole in which fearmongering, whipped up by innuendo, was allowed to thrive.
As I also pointed out, however, critics of the absolute prohibition on torture, to which Mr. Justice Mitting deferred, miss the point when they think that it has anything to do with soft options for terrorists enshrined in the Human Rights Act. The Act, which Labour introduced in 1998, has no power to undo the legally-binding agreement on which it was based — namely, the European Convention on Human Rights (PDF).
Certain Tories — and others of an authoritarian bent — have long had a mistaken belief that, as Peter Oborne described it last October, the Act is “part of an anti-democratic conspiracy that undermines the sovereignty of parliament and hands British liberties over to a foreign court.” In fact, as Oborne explained, the ECHR was introduced by Tories (Winston Churchill and David Maxwell-Fyfe), and contains “deeply Conservative” rights that are “absolutely fundamental to the British common law tradition”, including “the prohibition of torture, first enacted by the Long Parliament in 1640” and “the right to a fair trial, which dates back to Magna Carta.”
Moreover, the prohibition on returning people to countries where they face the risk of torture (the principle of “non-refoulement”) is enshrined in the UN Convention Against Torture, to which the UK — and every other country on earth that claims to be civilized — is a signatory.
As a result, behind the macho chest-beating by advocates for torture, the only plausible solution to a case like that of Abid Naseer and Ahmad Faraz Khan is for them to be kept under surveillance or put under control orders — and it seems, at present, that the former is the preferred option, as Nick Clegg explained yesterday. Although he conceded that it was a “source of great regret” that a lack of a formal agreement with Pakistan regarding the two men had led to the judge’s ruling, he also pointed out, “The law is very clear that it is wrong to deport people where there is risk they will be seriously mistreated, tortured or even killed, however uncomfortable it may be to defend them from time to time,” and added that Naseer and Faraz Khan would be “kept under surveillance … in a manner that means they cannot do harm to the British people.”
This was a remarkably refreshing — and, frankly, unprecedented — announcement by a senior politician regarding issues related to terrorism, but in the long run the only sensible response to this kind of perceived threat is for the government to put terror suspects on trial, and to do that they need to break the intelligence services’ opposition to the use of intercept evidence in courts. As I explained on Tuesday:
Outside of Britain’s particular myopia on this issue, the fact is that most of the world has taken this useful step, and there have been eight reports over the last 14 years in the UK on this very subject, including one by Sir John Chilcot. Moreover, suitable safeguards for protecting sensitive material and sources have also been proposed for many years, and in painstaking detail, by reputable organizations including JUSTICE, the all-party law reform and human rights organization (PDF).As in the US, where defenders of the rule of law are up against torture advocates claiming that Miranda rights are inappropriate for terror suspects, who, in their opinion, should be waterboarded and sent to Guantánamo, those who believe in fair trials in the UK — facilitated by the admission of intercept evidence — are confronted by hysterical commentators who would prefer, instead, that we actively advocate the use of torture and withdraw from binding laws preventing it, while pretending — with no justification whatsoever — that we are “soft on terrorists.”
Andy Worthington is the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison (published by Pluto Press, distributed by Macmillan in the US, and available from Amazon — click on the following for the US and the UK). To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to his RSS feed (he can also be found on Facebook and Twitter). Also see his definitive Guantánamo prisoner list, updated in January 2010, and, if you appreciate his work, feel free to make a donation. This article is reprinted with permission.


























0 comments:
Post a Comment