Lukashenka Turning Belarus Into 'A North Korea In The Center Of Europe’

By Paul Goble

Faced with mounting economic difficulties at home and increasing isolation abroad, Belarusian President Alyaksandr Lukashenka is transforming his country into “a North Korea in the center of Europe,” an effort that involves ever more repression against the Belarusian democracy movement and the possibility of a political explosion against him.

Over the last week, the Charter 97 organization reports, Belarusian KGB and militia officers have fanned out across the country confiscating equipment and publications of the Belarusian opposition and arresting activists not only in Mensk but in all other major Belarusian cities (charter97.org/ru/news/2010/5/18/29082/).

But those actions are only a symptom of a broader problem, Belarusian commentator Yuri Baranchik says, Lukashenka’s efforts to convert his country into “a kind of analogue of North Korea in the center of Europe” in advance of presidential elections which are supposed to be held before the end of the year (fondsk.ru/article.php?id=3043).

The reasons behind this drive, Baranchik says, are to be found in the country’s current economic difficulties and the likelihood that they will get worse over the next months, developments that almost certainly would undermine the support the Belarusian leader has generated on the basis of his past ability to maintain Belarusians’ standard of living.

Belarus’s foreign indebtedness has grown so rapidly over the last few months, the analyst says, that “several days ago A. Lukashenka [was forced] to sign a decree increasing the state debt limit from 9.5 to 12 billion dollars.” Moreover, the current economic situation means Mensk has had to put off its plans to sell euro-denominated bonds abroad.

Worse, Belarusian industries are increasingly unable to sell their production, with most of them having three to four months of unsold inventory, Baranchik continues. And “the lost of the Russian market [ -- something that is happening now -- ] is bringing with it especially great risks for the Belarusian economy.”

Mensk has been forced to reduce pensions over the last six months, and it has frozen wages and salaries, especially difficult that inflation is far higher than the 10 to 12 percent that the Belarusian government claims and that is hitting people at all levels of the income pyramid because of the rising cost of the standard market basket of goods.

Meanwhile, Baranchik says, the country’s gold reserve has fallen by 50 percent to only 11 billion US dollars, and it faces the threat of even greater losses if Moscow routes oil across Ukraine rather than Belarus and thus stops paying the transit fees on which Lukashenka and his regime have relied.

Moscow has a particular interest in cutting back these payments because of “the adventurist foreign economic projects” Mensk has gotten involved with, including the purchase of Venezuelan oil, a product it doesn’t need and now can’t sell either to Europe or to Ukraine, following Kyiv’s rapprochement with the Russian Federation.

Even if Moscow does not stop all transit of oil, the Russian government this year will end its transfer of three to five billion US dollars a year. “Next year, these funds will not be coming” to Mensk. That almost certainly means that the standard of living of Belarusians will fall and that some of them will step up their efforts to oust Lukashenka.

In that event, Moscow would be unlikely to do anything to help the incumbent president, especially since he has refused to go along with Russian policy on many questions and has not shown any interest in building the union state with the Russian Federation that Belarusians have twice voted for.

Indeed, there have been rumors that Moscow might even be interested in orchestrating Lukashenka’s ouster (www.nr2.ru/policy/283265.html), although the likelihood that a successor to Lukashenka would be more pro-Russian and more anti-European than he has been off and on is far from certain.

Consequently, because of these economic trends and his personal fears, Lukashenka is circling the wagons much as the leaders of North Korea have done. But it is clear that his past bet on “economic nationalism” and “self-sufficiency” has not worked and that even before the presidential elections, the Belarusian president may be forced to declare his country in default.


Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .   
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kazakhstan Reopens Border With Kyrgyzstan

Kazakhstan reopened its border with Kyrgyzstan on Wednesday after closing it in April due to violent unrest that led to the ouster of Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek Bakiyev, the Kazakh Foreign Ministry said.

Kyrgyzstan was rocked by massive protests in early April, with more than 80 people killed as an interim government took power and Bakiyev fled the capital and then the country. His supporters later hit back at the new authorities in an attempt to regain power. Several people were killed and scores were injured in new wave of violence.

"Considering the difficult social and economic situation in Kyrgyzstan and taking into account multiple calls from the people of our friendly country, Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev has ordered the government to lift all temporary limitations on the Kazakh-Kyrgyz state border," a statement from the ministry said.

The ministry said, however, that the work of border, customs and migration bodies will be tightened.

On Wednesday, the prime minister of Kyrgyzstan's provisional government was given presidential authority until elections are held in the country.

The government adopted a decree delegating power to an interim president until December 31, 2011. The document named interim Roza Otunbayeva as the provisional president, but also envisaged a nationwide referendum on the issue as an option.

Source: RIA Novosti
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

At Least 1 Killed, 16 Injured In New Kyrgyzstan Protests

At least one person was killed and another 16 injured on Wednesday in new clashes in the ex-Soviet Central Asian republic of Kyrgyzstan, spokeswoman for the Kyrgyz interim Health Ministry Svetlana Baytikova said.

Up to 3,000 supporters of ousted president Kurmanbek Bakiyev took part in the protests in the southern Kyrgyz town of Jalalabad.

The protesters were demanding a judicial inquiry into the actions of the leader of the local Uzbek community, Kadyzhan Batyrov, who they accuse of setting fire to houses belonging to relatives of Bakiyev and encouraging his supporters to use guns during uprisings in Jalalabad's central square on May 14.

Eyewitnesses said gunshots were heard near the University of Peoples' Friendship, which is headed by Batyrov. They said police and Special Forces officers, who initially cordoned off the university buildings, retreated for their own safety.

The Kyrgyz interim government fears ethnic conflicts in the region because of the large numbers of ethnic Uzbeks residing there.

Kyrgyz interim Prime Minister Roza Otunbayeva said the situation in the south of Kyrgyzstan had deteriorated again.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government led by Roza Otunbayeva took power on April 7 amid violent protests in which more than 80 people died. President Bakiyev fled the country and resigned.

Since then, Kyrgyzstan has seen two waves of riots between supporters of the deposed leader and backers of the interim government, in which a total of seven people were killed and more than 90 were injured.

Source: RIA Novosti
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyz Interim Government Braces For New Opposition Riots

Supporters of Kyrgyzstan's ousted president are preparing to provoke a new round of unrest in the Central Asian state, the interim government's deputy head Azimbek Beknazarov said on Tuesday.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government led by Roza Otunbayeva took power on April 7 amid violent protests in which more than 80 people died. President Kurmanbek Bakiyev fled the country and resigned.

Since then, Kyrgyzstan has seen two waves of riots between supporters of the deposed leader and backers of the interim government, in which a total of seven people were killed and more than 90 were injured.

"We are waiting for the third wave. According to our information, a group of bribe-takers and supporters of Bakiyev are trying to provoke interethnic clashes," said Beknazarov, who oversees law enforcement agencies in the interim government.

He said "certain politicians" were trying to ignite interethnic clashes between Kyrgyz and Uzbeks in the south of the country. "We know who is behind this, but to preserve stability we will give them time to think again," Beknazarov said.

He suggested, however, that the opposition would try to sabotage the June 27 referendum on the adoption of a new constitution.

"They will take active steps so that the referendum does not take place," Beknazarov said.

The new constitution is set to change Kyrgyzstan from a presidential to a parliamentary republic, reducing the power of the president.

Source: RIA Novosti
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyzstan Leaders Say They've Regained Control of Their Country

By Jessica Golloher

Kyrgyzstan's interim government says it has regained control of three southern provinces after supporters of deposed President Kurmanbek Bakiyev took over government buildings. Meanwhile, Moscow has also pledged to help the volatile former Soviet Republic.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government, lead by former foreign minister, Roza Otanbayeva, says that it has restored power. This after supporters of ousted President Kurmanbek Bakiyev stormed government buildings in the provinces of Osh, Jalalabad and Batken.

Witnesses say demonstrators used sticks, guns and rocks during the clashes that drew hundreds of protesters throughout the southern part of the country, seen by many as Mr. Bakiyev's power base.

Moscow and Washington have both voiced their concern over the turmoil in the mostly Muslim Central Asian state. Both the United States and Russia have military bases in the country.

The Russian government was so worried about the tense situation in the neighboring region that Russian President Dmitry Medvedev sent a special envoy to the former Soviet Republic in a show of support.

Vladimir Rushailo, a former interior minister and security council secretary, has been put in charge of improving relations with Kyrgyzstan.

Rushailo says Moscow will do its part to help quell violence in the region.

He says Russia's aim is to provide help in all areas of the Kyrgyz state.

Ms. Otanbayeva praised Moscow's show of support.

She says Russia came to help us. Russia is with us. She said Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev made it clear and said Russia will support us both politically and financially through this difficult period. Ms. Otanbayeva quoted Presdent Medvedev as saying Kyrgyzstan has to come out of this dead end, it has to protect the integrity of the country and keep the control in the government's hands and Russia will be there together with Kyrgyzstan during these difficult days.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government claims Mr. Bakiyev orchestrated the unrest in the southern areas, which officials are calling a coup attempt.

Mr. Bakiyev fled the country, to Belarus in April, after the opposition staged demonstrations in the capital of Bishkek. They demanded that he step down over claims of rampant corruption. They also demanded that Mr. Bakiyev remove his many family members from office. At least 85 people were killed in the violent clashes.

Source: VOA
Saturday, May 15, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Belarus Suppresses Gay Parade

Attempts to carry out a gay parade in downtown Minsk on Saturday were suppressed by special police forces.

The Belarusian gay community had previously asked the country's authorities and President Alexander Lukashenko for permission to hold the parade, but it was denied.

Nevertheless, dozens of members of Belarusian and Russian gay organizations still gathered on the capital's main street.

Police arrested 10 activists for "disorderly behavior," the city's information and public relations department said.

The event also attracted anti-gay protestors, who threw eggs into the crowd.

Source: RIA Novosti
Saturday, May 15, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Clashes In Kyrgyzstan, Interim Government Holds Emergency Meeting

The Kyrgyz interim government is holding an emergency meeting following clashes in the country's southern city of Jalal-Abad, an interim government spokesman said on Friday.

"Today, May 14, at 14:00 [12:00 GMT], the Kyrgyz interim government will hold an emergency meeting in the Jogorku Kenesha Square Hall on the situation in the country," a statement said.

Clashes broke out on Friday in the southern Kyrgyz city of Jalal-Abad between supporters of deposed President Kurmanbek Bakiyev and backers of the interim government.

Local media has reported fights between around 400-500 Bakiyev supporters and 4,000-5,000 backers of the interim government near the city's administration building. At least 28 people have been injured.

Bakiyev supporters said earlier on Friday they were expecting 10,000 people to gather in Jalal-Abad in support of the ousted president.

The interim government said the rally was "an attempt by Bakiyev's supporters to gain revenge and destabilize the country".

The situation in Kyrgyzstan, where bloody uprisings led to the overthrow of the government in early April, worsened on Thursday when administrative buildings in three southern regions were stormed by Bakiyev supporters.

The south of Kyrgyzstan has long been considered Bakiyev's stronghold and he initially took refuge in the region during the uprisings, before fleeing to neighboring Kazakhstan and then Belarus.

Source: RIA Novosti
Friday, May 14, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

The Courage Of Clandestine Video Journalists

By Kavi Chongkittavorn

(DVB) -- On 27 September 2007, the international community was shocked to see the video clip of Kenji Nagai, a Japanese video journalist, shot dead by a Burmese soldier on the streets of Rangoon. For weeks, the brutal death of this journalist was broadcast repeatedly, reminding us of the danger faced by journalists reporting the news.

This famous clip was clandestinely filmed from a rooftop by a young Burmese video journalist (VJ) working for Democratic Voice of Burma (DVB). He was able to send the clip almost immediately via a portable satellite to his headquarters in Oslo, norway. Within two hours, the incident went global, with TV news networks splashing their news bulletins with this image.

Meanwhile the Burmese junta leaders tried in vain to figure out how the clip penetrated their solid wall of censorship.

The shooting and attacking of journalists and VJs is not restricted to Burma.

Video clips and photos taken by amateurs who were in the right place at the right time take us behind the walls of these fortified countries, by using their camera phones or mini video cameras to record events. However, to film secretly and report news professionally undercover in a country controlled by one of the world’s most brutal military juntas is a different story.

As the video clip of Nagai demonstrated, it required a well-trained journalist who can capture the news without being captured himself. Video journalists now fill the important gap, replacing a news vacuum behind the iron curtain of dictatorship. DVB trains video journalists before they go into the field undetected and unrecognised, even by their colleagues.

To do their jobs, they are armed with mini video cameras, satellite phones and other new media technology. In addition, they are also trained to survive in hostile environments. However, even minor carelessness could put one’s own life and those of others in jeopardy. A young female DVB journalist was recently jailed in Burma for 27 years for simply reporting the news.

Exiled journalist communities from Iran, Zimbabwe, Sri Lanka, Gambia, North Korea, Tibet, Tunisia, Belarus and Uzbekistan are now sharing each other’s experience. Facing the same restrictions at home – news bans and no access to information – these exiled communities are following in the footsteps of their Burmese colleagues, who are well-versed in using new media technologies, coupled with personal versatility to get fresh news out.

Iranian journalists have benefited from the experience of Burmese VJs, who were featured in the 2010 Oscar-nominated documentary, Burma VJ. With the protests following the disputed Iran elections in 2009, the internet was flooded with video clips taken by mobile phones and mini video cameras.

VJs are now flourishing in many countries. Underground reporters inside North Korea have also increased. Using smuggled phones from China, they report the news to exiled radio stations based in China and South Korea. Underground journalists from Zimbabwe managed to smuggle video clips and news reports out of the country after Mugabe’s government censured any reporting of the news.

International news organisations are far less likely to put their own journalists in such jeopardy, and over the coming decade, the VJ will become a vital cog in the 24/7 newsreel, supplying news and images to publishers, broadcasters and exiled communities alike.

The international community owes a lot to these courageous and faceless journalists, who constantly risk their lives to report the news.


Kavi Chongkittavorn is a respected journalist and current chair of the Southeast Asian Press Alliance in Bangkok. With more than twenty years experience reporting on human rights and press freedom issues in Southeast Asia, he writes on the everyday struggles of clandestine journalists who dare to report the news in countries afflicted by censorship. Using new media technologies such as camera phones, these brave journalists bring the news to the outside world. On World Press Freedom Day, 2010, Kavi writes for WAN-IFRA, the World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers.
Tuesday, May 04, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Bagapsh ‘Cautiously Optimistic’ Over Abkhaz Recognition By Ukraine, Belarus

(Civil.Ge) -- Abkhaz leader, Sergey Bagapsh, said on April 29 that he was “cautiously optimistic” about possible recognition of Abkhazia by Ukraine and Belarus, Abkhaz news agency, Apsnipress, reported.

“Of course, it is important for us that Ukraine recognizes Abkhazia, that Belarus finally closes this issue, especially if we take into consideration that we had already held negotiations with them. I understand well that each country has its own problems, [each governments has] its opposition, there is influence of the West, financial structures… If it [recognition] happens we will be very happy, because Belarus, Russia and Ukraine as well as other CIS countries are our friendly states. We do not ask unconditional recognition, we offer to build relations,” Bagapsh was quoted by Apsnipress.

He said for gaining international support, Abkhazia would require to build “a real democracy.”

Speaking at a news conference, Bagapsh also hailed border guard forces of the Russian Federal Security Service, which were deployed in the breakaway region a year ago.

“Russian border guards protect not only the borders of Abkhazia, but also Russian borders. We have invited them to ensure peace and stability here. It is not only about Abkhazia; it is about how the situation will develop in the entire Caucasus.”

He also added that Russian border guard service in Abkhazia “is ready to recruit Abkhaz citizens, who are willing to serve in Russian border guard troops.”
Friday, April 30, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

The Unequal Sides Of The Slavic Triangle

By Nikolai Troitsky

On Tuesday April 27, the parliaments of Russia and Ukraine ratified an agreement extending by 25 years Russia's lease of the base in Sevastopol, where it's Black Sea Fleet is stationed. This agreement is the clearest sign yet of the two countries' rapprochement. Russia's relationship with Belarus, on the other hand, is veering off course.

In fact, this "Slavic triangle" has never been isosceles. Until recently, Russian-Ukrainian relations were essentially frozen. The tension was only punctuated with periods of downright hostility. Moscow's alliance with Belarus seemed stable in comparison; the two countries even established the Union State with its own joint governing bodies.

Ukraine and Belarus have unexpectedly reversed roles. Russia's relations with Ukraine are improving with each passing day, while its Union State partner - who should be more than a mere ally - is making unfriendly statements about Moscow with ever greater frequency. Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko told Reuters in February that Russia is displaying the same imperial ambitions in its foreign policy as the United States. That is a breathtaking accusation.

Condemning Russia's "imperial ambitions" was a favorite pastime of former Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko. Unsurprisingly, Russian-Ukrainian relations were strained during his tenure. Now that he has been replaced by Viktor Yanukovych, bilateral relations are on the upswing. As for Belarus, the government has not changed hands there for a long time. Lukashenko has been running the country since 1994. During those 16 years, he seemingly failed to notice Russia's "imperial ambitions". What changed his mind? Why is it that Russia's long-time partner and faithful ally, as Lukashenko once positioned himself, has changed his rhetoric so abruptly?

Lukashenko's rhetoric continues to grow more and more aggressive. On April 25, the Belarusian leader said, "the Commander-in-Chief of the Russian Armed Forces seems to have forgotten that there are two Russian bases in Belarus: one near Baranovichi and the other near Vileika. Let me remind him that unlike for Sevastopol, Russia doesn't pay us a single ruble or kopeck in rent for these bases." Were it not for the long-standing alliance between Russia and Belarus, this "reminder" might have sounded an awful lot like blackmail. But Lukashenko did not stop there. "Russia has no friends in the West except for the Belarusian army," he added.

Lukashenko made this statement right after Russia and Ukraine signed the agreement on the Sevastopol base. Russia will be able to keep its Black Sea Fleet in Ukraine, but at a price of several billion dollars. True, if the lease had not been extended, the cost of relocating the fleet to a new base in Novorossiysk would have been much greater. But this would have been Russia's problem, not Ukraine's.

Could it be that Lukashenko's grudge is rooted in the fact that Belarus makes no profit from Russian military bases? This is not even the first time he raised the issue of money. "Russia will have to pay hard currency for something it is used to get free of charge," Lukashenko said in February. He also claims that Belarus has lost a total of $5 billion since January 1, when Moscow introduced export customs duties on refined oil products and petrochemicals supplied to Belarus. This dispute has been taken up by the CIS Economic Court. In any case, it's strange to see two members of a Union State squabbling over money.

Was it a coincidence that the dispute escalated just as Russian-Ukrainian relations finally began to improve? Hardly. Lukashenko is an experienced and shrewd politician. He has always been adept at exploiting Belarus's role as Russia's only friend in a hostile environment and its geographical position as Russia's gateway to Europe. Lukashenko was not troubled by the New Year's gas wars between Moscow and Ukraine. Instead he saw an opening to pressure Moscow for even more generous subsidies.

Now the situation has reversed. Lukashenko has lost his unique role now that Moscow has settled its gas dispute with Ukraine and signed a range of agreements, including the extension of the lease on the Sevastopol base and a gas supply agreement with an enormous 30% discount for Ukraine. Perhaps this is why Lukashenko recently launched a broadside against Russia's policy toward Kyrgyzstan.

Lukashenko decided to try on the role of defender of the CIS. He began in February with his accusation that Russia was "paying little notice" to the former Soviet republics, taking it for granted that they will remain "attached" to Russia forever. In April, he granted asylum to Kyrgyzstan's ousted president, Kurmanbek Bakiyev, and harshly criticized the CSTO for standing by as the Kyrgyz coup unfolded: "If the CSTO continues on like this, the organization has no future."

It is not clear why Lukashenko believes the CSTO should meddle in Kyrgyzstan's internal affairs. This was not even the first time a president was overthrown there. When Askar Akayev was forced out five years ago, Lukashenko did not seem too concerned about his fate or the situation in the newly-independent Central Asian republic. Things are different this time around: Lukashenko is so fond of his new high-ranking refugee that in addition to granting Bakiyev asylum, he announced that Belarus still recognizes him as the legitimate president. Nor was Lukashenko embarrassed by being completely alone in this position, as the other CIS states all established contact with the interim government in Kyrgyzstan.

Far from strengthening the CIS, Lukashenko's game threatens to take this delicate structure down from within. Perhaps Lukashenko saw what happened to Bakiyev and wondered if he's next. Lukashenko may even be hoping to use Bakiyev as a bargaining chip against Moscow, weak though it is.

One thing is clear: the Belarusian president's position has been weakened by the rapprochement between Russia and Ukraine, once again proving that old adage that nations have no permanent friends or permanent enemies - only permanent interest. The Slavic triangle is no exception.

The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article was first published.
Wednesday, April 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Russian Web Site Highlights Resistance In Baltics, Ukraine And Western Belarus

By Paul Goble

A new Russian website intended to ensure no one forgets what it calls “the victims of nationalist terror in the Western regions of the USSR” unintentionally calls attention to the strength of resistance to the imposition of Soviet power in the Baltic states, Western Ukraine and Western Belarus after World War II.

The site, lists.historyfoundation.ru/, includes data, admitted to be as yet far from complete, on 3294 civilians (2298) and military (996) who were killed (2444), wounded (505), kidnapped (293) or disappeared (52) between 1944 and 1947. The number of victims was 190 in 1944, 2641 in 1945, 204 in 1946, and 258 in 1947 (www.rus-obr.ru/blog/6429).

Victims of all categories, the site goes on, totaled 1945 in Western Ukraine, 423 in Western Belarus, 251 in Estonia, 168 in Latvia, and 507 in Lithuania. And the site can be searched by both name and location, something that will allow interested individuals to find out about their relatives or friends.

And the site also includes hypertext links to the full text of “Everyday Terror: The Activity of Nationalist Formations in the Western Regions of the USSR, Book I” (in Russian; Moscow, 2009, 232 pp., ISBN: 987-5-9990-0004-0), and to other collections of archival documents as well, from which some of the site’s data entries are taken.

In presenting the site, its compilers note that “during the course of long years, the history of the activity of armed nationalist formations on the territory of the Western regions of the Soviet Union remained a prohibited theme for investigators” because it did not fit “into the Procrustean bed of official ideology.”

“After the collapse of the Soviet Union, the history of the harsh ‘war after the war’ in the Western regions of the USSR appeared at the center of attention of the political elite of the independent states,” where those who participated in the fight against Soviet power were presented as national heroes.

Thus it should come as no surprise that “in the last decade and a half, the activity of the nationalist armed formations became in the Baltic republics and in Ukraine one of the most actively investigated pages of Soviet history,” the site’s editors say. But these investigations, the editors add, were far from objective.

“The opposite site of making heroes of ‘the forest brothers’ and the militants of the OUN and UPA was the neglect of their numerous victims, a large part of which were not Red commissars but peaceful residents who were local to Soviet power.” According to the editors, 85 percent of the more than 25,000 killed by the Forest Brothers in Lithuania were Lithuanian.

These victims and the thousands more in Western Ukraine and Western Belarus are being intentionally forgotten, dismissed as “Soviet agents” or classified as victims of the Soviet NKVD. That must end, the Historical Memory Foundation says, and to that end, it has launched this website.

“We are certain,” the editors say, “that the memory of the innocent victims of nationalist terror must be carefully preserved and kept alive just as the memory about the innocent victims of Soviet political repressions are.” And consequently, they have launched the site in the hopes that those with information about the victims will contribute to it.

“Recognizing that the problem of preserving the memory about the victims of nationalist terror is important for Belarus, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Russia and Estonia, the Historical Memory Foundation has begun the realization of the project of the creation of a generally accessible electronic data base” of the victims of “nationalist terror.”

The primary source for the site, its organizers is, are the NKVD and MVD data bases housed in the State Archive of the Russian Federation, which include materials draw from the daily reports to NKVD Deputy Commissar S.N. Kruglov of these agencies during the course of their struggle with “banditism.”

And the site’s introduction concludes with the note that in order to present “the fullest data on the victims of nationalist terror,” the site’s editors “have considered it correct not to include in the lists the soldiers of the Red Army and organs of internal affairs and state security who died in the course of the operations for the liquidation of nationalist armed formations.”

Many Russians who visit this site may learn for the first time just how strong was the resistance to Stalin’s imposition or re-imposition of Soviet power in the Western borderlands of the USSR and the occupied Baltic countries, something that will do little to promote positive attitudes among them to the peoples of these now independent countries.

At the same time, many of the peoples in these countries will be able to use this site to learn more about the national resistance in their past than many of them have up to now, a knowledge that will also affect how they view the Soviet system and those who continue to apologize for some of its worst periods and personalities.


Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .
Wednesday, April 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyzstan,: Bakiyev Says Pressured Into Writing Resignation Letter

Kyrgyzstan's deposed president, Kurmanbek Bakiyev, said on Friday he was pressured into writing his resignation letter.

"When I was writing a resignation letter, there was a threat from those who seized power in the military takeover," he said at a news conference in Minsk.

After Bakiyev left Kyrgyzstan last week, the interim government announced he had written a resignation letter, which was published in the media.

On Wednesday, however, Bakiyev said he had not resigned and called on the international community not to recognize Kyrgyzstan's interim government.

Source: RIA Novosti
Friday, April 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Ousted Kyrgyz President Bakiyev Denies Resignation

Ousted Kyrgyz president Kurmanbek Bakiyev, has denied his resignation from the presidential post.

Bakiyv, who is currently in the Belarusian capital, Minsk, had fled Kyrgyzstan amid mass national protests.

He has expressed his condolences to the families of those who died in the uprisings and said he is ready to answer to the law.

"There is no power which will make me resign from the presidential post," Bakiyev said. "Kyrgyzstan will not be anyone's colony. It will continue to build a democratic state."

He also called for world leaders not to recognize the Kyrgyz interim government.

Source: RIA Novosti
Wednesday, April 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyzstan's Bakiyev In Belarus

Deposed Kyrgyz president Kurmanbek Bakiyev is currently in Minsk under the protection of the authorities, the Belarusian president said on Tuesday.

"Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek Bakiyev and his family are in Minsk under the protection of our state and under my personal [protection]," Alexander Lukashenko said in his annual state-of-the-nation address, adding that Bakiyev had arrived in Minsk late on Monday.

Bakiyev, who was ousted amid violent anti-government protests on April 6-7, fled from Kyrgyzstan to neighboring Kazakhstan on April 15, after the opposition, which had taken power in the country, lifted his presidential immunity and threatened to arrest him.

Media reports said on Saturday that Bakiyev had left Kazakhstan, but his whereabouts remained unknown until Tuesday. Lukashenko said on Sunday Belarus was ready to host Bakiyev and give him and his family whatever help they need.

Kyrgyzstan's interim authorities have said they consider Belarus a friendly state and expect Minsk to ensure the security of the ousted president until a trial can be held.

"We ask Belarus and the country's authorities to ensure Bakiyev's security before he faces trial for numerous crimes against the Kyrgyz nation," said Edil Baisalov, the interim government's chief of staff.

Source: RIA Novosti
Tuesday, April 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Ousted Kyrgyz president welcome In Belarus

Belarus is ready to receive former Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek Bakiyev and give him and his family whatever help they need, Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko said on Sunday.

"If the president of Kyrgyzstan and his family need support and assistance at this difficult time, they will get it in Belarus," Lukashenko told journalists.

"If he wants to come - today, tomorrow, or the day after tomorrow - we are ready to receive him here in Belarus," he said.

Bakiyev fled Bishkek on April 7 amid violent protests in the Kyrgyz capital that killed more than 80 people and saw the opposition take power. He flew to Kazakhstan on Thursday and reportedly resigned on Friday.

The interim government in Kyrgyzstan says it will set up an international investigation into alleged crimes committed by Bakiyev. Charges have already been filed against some of his relatives.

Lukashenko said Bakiyev was in Kazakhstan with his 5-year-old son, daughter and wife, and rejected reports that he had resigned.

"For me, today he is the president of the country. It is not right to trust the signature on the letter of resignation, which is now being shown in the media," the Belarusian president said.

Bakiyev had refused to step down as the interim government was demanding, but reports on Friday said a resignation letter had been faxed from a location in Kazakhstan to the authorities in Bishkek. A statement was published later on Friday by the Kazakh state news agency Kazinform.

Source: RIA Novosti
Sunday, April 18, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

One Russian in Four Now Goes Online Daily Prompting Moscow To Consider Draconian Restrictions

By Paul Goble

Nearly one Russian in four now goes online on a daily basis, and almost half of those who do use the Internet to get their news, a challenge to the Kremlin’s control of much of the electronic media and a development that is prompting some of the powers that be to look at the way in which Belarus and Turkmenistan are trying to control the web.

Today, the All-Russian Center for the Study of Public Opinion (VTsIOM) released the results of its latest poll on Russian use of the Internet. According to the firm, 46 percent of Russians now have a personal computer, and 40 percent of the population uses them to connect to the Internet (wciom.ru/novosti/press-vypuski/press-vypusk/single/13386.html).

More than four out of five of those going online do so at home rather than at work, thus limiting the ability of employers to control the way in which Russians make use of the web, even though most respondents in the VTsIOM survey say that they use the Internet “chiefly for work or study.”

Increasingly over the last several years, the poll found, Russians use the Internet for email, 51 percent now compared to 42 percent in 2008, for getting news, 49 percent compared to 48 percent, to find people with similar views, 28 percent compared to nine percent, and for entertainment and purchases of goods and services.

Not surprisingly, Internet use is highest in the capitals, among younger and more educated people, and among those who are financially better off, but use of the net appears to be spreading to other groups in the population relatively rapidly, with the share of people saying they never use the Internet falling dramatically.
Given that access to the Internet reduces the ability of the Russian powers that be to control the messages the citizenry receives, Moscow is increasingly considering adopting draconian measures like those in Turkmenistan and Belarus to limit access to the net or at least to intimidate some so that they will not make use of it for news.

In an interview with Baltinfo.ru this week, Aleksey Vlasov, an influential Moscow analyst says that “Russia is step by step approaching the models of many countries of the post-Soviet space” regarding control over information and especially the Internet (www.baltinfo.ru/tops/Terroristy-v-SMI-Kollektivnyi-dogovor-protiv-zakonodatelnoi-palki-137827).

Discussions about control of the information space in post-Soviet countries are “far from new,” Vlasov continues. Governments engage in it “for various reasons but by similar measures. Thus, in Kazakhstan, it was recently required that all sites be hosted only on the territory of the republic so that the owners of Internet portals could be found.”

Belarus and Turkmenistan have gone the furthest, the Moscow analyst says, but “Russia step by step is moving toward these republics in a the understanding of the Internet sphere as an ‘out of control’ element which must be put in order and held under tight control,” even if there is no agreement yet on just what methods to adopt.

The current anti-terrorist “hysteria,” he suggests, is likely to cover major moves to control access to the Internet in the name of defending “state interests” and the population from future terrorist attacks. That is all the more likely if more information comes to light about the use of the Internet by terrorist groups.

But one of the main issues that will have to be addressed soon is whether the blogosphere is “a mass media.”
If Russian officials ultimately decide that it is, then they will be in a position to demand the closure of “hundreds of blogs,” something that would seriously restrict what is now the freest part of the Russian media.
Even if the powers that be take that step, Vlasov concludes, it is still “unknown how far [they might yet go to impose] total control.” At the very least, moves to tighter government control over the Internet in Russia will set off another competition between offense and defense in this area much as they have in other countries.

Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .
Tuesday, April 06, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

China In Nuclear Energy Talks With Belarus, Pakistan

Officials have conducted talks on Chinese involvement in civil nuclear power projects in both Belarus and Pakistan, where Chashma 3 and 4 now look closer to reality.

Earlier this month China's Vice President, Xi Jinping, met Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko in Minsk. Belarus has been progressively preparing itself for the use of civil nuclear power over the last few years and Lukashenko took the opportunity to raise the possibility of nuclear cooperation with his Chinese visitor.

Belarus publicised a range of contracts worth some $3.4 billion, as well as a loan for $1 billion and aid from China worth $60 million. Official announcements said that Lukashenko had proposed to cooperate with China in nuclear power, including on the construction of a power plant although Chinese official sources did not confirm the conversation. Xi however recalled a 2005 bilateral between the nations that "symbolized a new phase of comprehensive development and strategic cooperation." Russia has real interest in the Belarusian project and its ambassador to the country quickly responded to the idea of Chinese involvement. While Russia would not object to Chinese finance, the involvement of Chinese companies and the possibility of technology transfer was not acceptable, according to quotes attributed to Alexander Surikov by the BELTA news agency.

According to Pakistani media, China has also moved forward with cooperation in that country, signing a new deal to construct two new pressurized water reactors at the Chasma plant. A detailed report in the Daily Times said China had agreed a low-interest loan to Pakistan for 82% of the $1.912 billion cost of two 320 MWe units. It added that the cabinet had approved Pakistan's share of the spending.

Chasma 1 was imported from China in the late 1990s with unit 2 following in the early 2000s and still under construction. In March 2009 Shanghai Nuclear Engineering Research and Design Institute announced that it was proceeding with the design of Chasma 3 and 4, with China Zhongyuan Engineering as the general contractor.

However, questions remain about China's supply of Chashma 3 and 4. Contracts for units 1 and 2 were signed in 1990 and 2000, before 2004 when China joined the Nuclear Suppliers Group, which maintains an embargo on sales of nuclear equipment to Pakistan as a country without full-scope safeguards on nuclear technology and materials.

Source: Researched and written by World Nuclear News
Saturday, April 03, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Russia Union With Belarus: Political Surrealism?

By Konstantin Simonov

When Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko issued a decree on February 12 affirming the Belarusian-Russian intergovernmental protocol whereby Minsk would import oil from its eastern neighbor and allow oil to be transported across Belarus for 2010, many analysts thought that the oil conflict between Belarus and Russia had run its course.

In fact, nothing could be further from the truth; Lukashenko was merely buying time. The fact of the matter was that the Belarusian president had been forced to come to terms because his country's refineries had only enough oil for a few days. Lukashenko clearly intended to revisit the issue, and now he has done so with a vengeance.

Alexander Lukashenko is intentionally fighting back against Russia with everything he's got. First, there was the scandalous agreement whereby Belarus would import around four million metric tons of oil a year from Venezuela. Of course, this doesn't measure up against the more than 20 million tons Belarus imports from Russia, and even if Belarus paid full price for Russian oil, the Venezuelan equivalent would still be more expensive. But the public relations impact was monumental. The louder the better.

Furthermore, in an interview with one Argentinean newspaper, Lukashenko revealed that Venezuela could perhaps be involved in the privatization of Belarusian oil refineries, which, in light of the fact that Russian officials have long tried to persuade the Belarusian president to sell these refineries to Russian companies, means the situation has become absurd.

Russia plans to invest $12 billion in Venezuela's Junin 6 project, while at the same time Venezuela plans to buy assets that Russia has long had its eye on. And let's not forget the scandalous lawsuit in the Economic Court of the CIS regarding the legality of customs duties on Russian exports of oil products and petrochemical raw materials to Belarus. It is clear that the lawsuit is groundless, and moreover many people only heard of the court's existence after this incident. Nevertheless, the lawsuit has caused quite a commotion.
And the latest news is that Alexander Lukashenko has instructed his First Deputy Prime Minister Vladimir Semashko to begin negotiating with Ukraine to connect Belarus with the Odessa-Brody pipeline, a move clearly intended to give Minsk access to Venezuelan oil.

This idea cannot fail to irritate Moscow for at least two reasons: First of all, tankers from Venezuela would have to cross the Mediterranean and pass through the already overcrowded Bosporus, where Russian vessels headed in the opposite direction are periodically delayed by traffic jams. Second, the Odessa-Brody pipeline was built in 2001 to transport Caspian oil to Europe - an obvious snub to Russia.

Nevertheless, it turned out that the pipeline was completely unfeasible. Even Orange Ukraine had to grit its teeth and eat crow when the pipeline stopped transporting oil from Odessa to Brody and began transporting oil - Russian oil - from Brody to Odessa. Now suddenly Lukashenko has decided to revive a project that even supporters of the Orange Revolution refused to support. The economic rationale for importing oil from Venezuela is non-existent, a fact that becomes clear with just one look at a map of the world.

Sure, these projects could be left unrealized. It is even safe to say that they will most likely remain rhetorical. But the aftertaste remains, the allegations multiply and there is a new scandal every week.

Then there is still the issue of natural gas. The price of natural gas for Belarus in the first three months of 2010 was $168 per thousand cubic meters, which is almost half of what Ukraine pays. Moreover, Minsk is exempt from paying the 30% export duty. But even that is not enough! It continues to pay $155 per thousand cubic meters for gas and still it has run up a debt of $94.5 million for gas. Gazprom recently finalized a deal to buy 50% of Beltransgaz, and now it must address the very pressing issue of how to restructure the company's leadership.

And here we come to the main issue at hand. What should be more important in our relations with our post-Soviet brothers? Should we integrate with the Slavic nations of the CIS while trying to strengthen our geopolitical position? Or should we simply pursue a more practical approach to our relations with our neighbors?

The dilemma is not new. It's just that it's becoming abundantly clear that combining these strategies is very difficult, because neither political nor practical gains seem easy to come by. Lukashenko is a prime example of this. Our relations don't seem brotherly at all. The times when a union state or at least a common currency was up for discussion are long gone. And we get no particular economic dividends, either. And so we lose money and the list of disagreements only grows. Meanwhile, there is a sense of some kind of political surrealism. Lukashenko is ostensibly a political ally, so we make economic concessions for him. But since we are still ostensibly pragmatists, these concessions are not comprehensive. Consequently, Lukashenko starts to openly embarrass us, staging ever more outrageous publicity stunts. We try not to notice, and this only seems to encourage him.


Konstantin Simonov is director general of the National Energy Security Foundation. The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article first appeared.
Friday, April 02, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

EU Issues Warning To Belarus Ahead Of Elections

The European Union issued a warning to Belarus ahead of that nation's late April election, expressing "grave concern" over what it views as the recent harassment of representatives of independent media, civil society and opposition organisations, including restrictions on the freedom of assembly, association and expression, as well as continued difficulties with the registration of NGOs and opposition parties.

In a sttement, the EU said it "urges Belarus to address the concerns regarding the democracy, situation for human rights and fundamental freedoms in the country."

Additionally, the EU said the current trends are particularly worrisome in the run up to the 25 April local elections.

"The European Union attaches great importance to their good conduct and expects that the Belarusian authorities do their utmost to ensure the necessary environment for democratic elections that meet OSCE and other international standards," the EU said, adding that "It regrets that the way of setting up local election commissions raises questions on adequate representation of democratic and independent NGOs.

The EU sait it will follow closely the conduct of the local elections.
Thursday, April 01, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Moscow’s ‘Imperialist’ Attitudes Pushing Belarus And Other Non-Russian Countries Away

By Paul Goble

Russia’s counterproductive and off-putting approach to Belarus as well as other former Soviet republics reflects “the presumptuous imperial thought which still has not left the heads of certain Russian politicians,” according to a senior Minsk official close to President Alyaksandr Lukashenka.

In a 4,000-word article in “Belaruskaya dumka,” Anatoly Rubinov, a former Lukashenka aide and current deputy chairman of the Council of the Republic of the Belarusian National Assembly, says that Belarusians have changed their attitude toward a union state with Russia over the past decade (beldumka.belta.by/isfiles/000167_770398.pdf).

Ten years ago, Rubinov writes, Belarusians believed that such a union would play a major role in helping both countries overcome the consequences of the collapse of the Soviet Union, but now, he argues, they would welcome it only if other countries were members as well and only if Russia itself changed its approach.

The reasons for that shift, he says, are to be found less in the ongoing development of Belarus as an independent and self-confident country with its own system and with increasingly important ties to Western Europe, the United States and China than in Russia’s “short-sighted” and “egotistical” approach to cooperation.

Examples of that abound, Rubinov says. Thus, “instead of building a second branch of the Yamal-Europe gas pipeline, Russia is prepared to expend enormous sums only in order to leave Belarus at the side of gas transit,” and immediately after Belarus joined the Tariff Union with Russia and Kazakhstan, Moscow introduced new tariffs on oil.

But these are symptoms of a much larger problem, he continues. On the one hand, Russia’s current “excessively pragmatic position does not correspond to its historic traditions but rather reflects the fact that “today, on the expanses of Russia rules [only] one idol – money and super profits.”

And on the other, Moscow today insists that it alone as the right to exploit natural resources on its own territory even if a union state with Belarus is finally established, while in Soviet times, the central powers that be said that the resources of the union state belonged to all the peoples of the state.

By making that shift, Russia has demonstrated that it is almost exclusively interested in the pursuit of its own interests and no one else’s. But when Belarus tries to do the same and develop relations with the European Union or with Asia, Moscow gets angry and views such steps as anti-Russian.

“At the same time,” Rubinov says, “it is impermissible not to note that Belarus pays dearly for its faithfulness to its ally Russia.” That very faithfulness has made it more difficult for Minsk to develop relations with the West, which routinely accuses Belarus of “an absence of democracy, a dictatorial regime, and Soviet methods of administration.”

“The development of democracy,” he argues, “is not a simple or rapid process. But Belarus is far from the last place in that regard among post-Soviet countries.” Nonetheless, it is routinely attacked as if it were, and the reason for that is the consistent interest Minsk has shown in a union state with Russia.

And from that it follows, Rubin says that “all the unpleasantness of Belarus in its relations with Western countries is not because of Belarus itself but because of its allied relations with Russia.” Invariably, “Belarus has drawn fire on itself” and done so out of a desire to fulfill its allied “obligations and interests.”

But Russia “unfortunately understands these interests in an extremely pragmatic and one-sided way,” as a comparison with American policy toward Georgia, Poland, and the Czech Republic show. Washington “finances” them “not in exchange for material goods but entirely for political loyalty,” something Russia won’t do at present.

Moscow has failed to see that Belarus, which could have allowed NATO forces on its territory, has not done so, a turn of events which Russians see as “completely unbelievable.” But Rubinov points out that it should be recalled just how “unbelievable” at one point was the collapse of the Soviet Union. But that happened.”

“Therefore,” he continues, Moscow “must not build its policy on the basis of petty immediate economic interests. One must directly say that the position of Russia toward Belarus as by the way to other neighboring states is a reflection of the presumptuous imperial though which has still not left the head of certain Russian politicians.”

Belarus could under circumstances move in the direction of the Baltic states, Georgia or Moldova, Rubinov says, and asks rhetorically “has no one in Russia up to know understood that possibility?” He goes on to say that the future of the Union state thus depends “not so much on Belarus but on the position of Russia,” implicitly suggesting that Moscow must change course.

The future of that formation “also to a large degree depends on Ukraine,” Rubinov says, “If Ukraine moves toward a rapprochement with Russia and enters the Tariff Union with Russia, Belarus and Kazakhstan, if on this basis appears a common economic space, then of course the formation of a confederative or super-state union structure is completely possible.”

In that arrangement, he points, “Belarus would not be left one on one with Russia, and with the establishment of fraternal relations with Ukraine and Kazakhstan, its political possibilities would broaden and strengthen.” But that will require a different Russian policy toward all these states than the one now on offer.

Meanwhile, Rubinov says, Belarus will continue to seek “the maximum rapprochement with the European Union.” It is after all “at the center of Europe, not only geographically but by the level of development of science, education, culture, technology and economics – indeed by all parameters it is a typically European country.”
And Rubinov concludes in this way: “Both in the West and in the East people must clearly understand that Belarus over the course of recent times has developed into an independent sovereignty state which will not under any circumstances become part of another state or sacrifice even a small part of its sovereignty.”
“Belarus is an independent country,” he writes. “It does not have any imperial world political ambitions. It is interested only in mutually profitable cooperation and trade with all, including the United States, the European Union countries, Japan, China, South Korea and others."

“We are Belarusians!” he says. “And this is the main unifying idea. Independently from his ethnic membership, the citizen of Belarus must feel himself to be a representative of the Belarusian people. And Belarus must nowhere be confused with a Ukrainian or a Russian. We have our own country, our own self-consciousness, our own culture and our own pride.”

Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .
Tuesday, March 30, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...



Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search