Bulgarian Extradited From Poland To US For Money Laundering Scheme

A Bulgarian man appeared in federal court in the District of Columbia today to face charges related to his alleged role in managing a money laundering network for a transnational criminal group based in Eastern Europe, announced Assistant Attorney General Lanny A. Breuer of the Criminal Division.

According to court documents, in less than one year, the criminal conspiracy allegedly netted nearly $1 million from U.S. victims.


Georgi Vasilev Pletnyov, 49, of Svishtov, Bulgaria, was extradited from Poland to the United States on Friday, May 21, 2010. U.S. Magistrate Judge Alan Kay today ordered Pletnyov detained pending a hearing scheduled for May 28, 2010. Pletnyov is charged with one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering. If convicted, he faces a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison.


According to the indictment, Pletnyov allegedly participated in a scheme that operated from July 2005 through May 2006, which involved the posting of advertisements on eBay and other websites, fraudulently offering expensive vehicles and boats for sale that the conspirators did not possess. The indictment alleges that when the U.S. victims expressed interest in the merchandise, they were contacted directly by an e-mail from a purported seller. According to the indictment, the victims allegedly were then instructed to wire transfer payments through “eBay Secure Traders”—an entity which has no actual affiliation to eBay but was used as a ruse to persuade the victims that they were sending money into a secure escrow account pending delivery and inspection of their purchases. Instead, the victims’ funds allegedly were wired directly into bank accounts in Hungary, Slovakia, the Czech Republic and Poland that were controlled by co-conspirators.



Pletnyov was originally charged on Jan. 9, 2008, along with five additional defendants: Roman Teodor, Ivaylo Vasilev Pletnyov, Nikolay Georgiev Minchev, Georgi Boychev Georgiev and Antoaneta Angelova Getova. On Dec. 2, 2009, Ivaylo Vasilev Pletnyov and Nikolay Georgiev Minchev were sentenced to four years and 30 months in prison, respectively, for their roles in the money laundering conspiracy. Georgiev pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering on May 13, 2010, and is scheduled to be sentenced on July 23, 2010. The United States continues to work with foreign counterparts regarding the remaining defendants.

An indictment is merely an accusation and the defendants are presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty at trial beyond a reasonable doubt.

This investigation was conducted by the FBI – Hungarian National Bureau of Investigation Organized Crime Task Force located in Budapest, Hungary (Budapest Task Force). The Budapest Task Force was established by the FBI in April 2000 to address the increasing threat of Eurasian organized crime groups to the United States.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Siemens Signs Four Wind Power Service Agreements In U.S.

Siemens Energy said Tuesday it has been awarded service contracts for four wind farms located in the states of Washington and Oregon in the U.S.

Under a four-year contract signed with the Cannon Power Group, Siemens will be providing warranty maintenance services for a total of 114 SWT 2.3 93 wind turbines in the Windy Flats and Windy Flats Extension wind farms in Washington.

In Oregon, Iberdrola Renewables has awarded Siemens a five-year extension on service, warranty and maintenance contract for the 44 wind turbines in their Klondike III wind project.

In addition, Summit Power has extended an existing service contract for 89 wind turbines at its White Creek wind farm in Washington by another two years. The contracts for these four wind farms have a total value of around USD 55 million.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

World Biodiversity Day: Thousands Connect With Nature Through EU Campaign

Saturday is World Biodiversity Day and despite efforts around the globe, studies show that biodiversity – the rich variety of life on this planet – is diminishing at a startling rate.

An innovative EU campaign to highlight this message is engaging thousands of people across the European Union and beyond. The campaign website has already received more than half a million visits, while over 56,000 people have shown their support for the campaign on Facebook. The Commission is marking World Biodiversity Day with a series of events in six focus countries: Spain, the Netherlands, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland and Italy.

Environment Commissioner Janez Potočnik said, "It is good to see how this campaign is capturing people's imagination. We must keep up the momentum and translate this interest into real action and real policies. to safeguard the rich variety of life on Earth."

Campaign captures public attention

People of all ages are connecting with nature through the biodiversity campaign's interactive website and social media. In the first six weeks of the campaign the website, which is available in all EU languages, registered more than 550,000 page views with the number growing daily. Some 56,000 people from more than 120 countries have declared their support on the biodiversity Facebook pages.

Built around the slogan, ‘Biodiversity – we are all in this together’, the campaign aims to raise awareness of the problem of biodiversity loss and show the implications of these losses in our daily lives.

The campaign has an educational component that reveals the benefits biodiversity brings, and stresses in particular the idea of ecosystem services and the dangers of their disappearance. The theme that returns repeatedly is the idea of connectivity and interdependence.

The latest element to be added is a powerful video clip which sends a stark message about the urgent need for action. The clip aims to highlight how the loss of any link in the chain of life, however insignificant it may appear, can upset the whole balance of nature.

The campaign has a special focus on countries where action is considered especially useful. Successful launches have taken place in Spain, the Netherlands, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland and Italy with PR actions and street art. Family activity events will also take place in all six focus countries as part of World Biodiversity Day celebrations.

From awareness to action

As well as raising awareness, the campaign is also focusing on making citizens more aware of the role they can play in slowing and preventing biodiversity loss. This aims to get people doing something – on their own or in projects – to protect and care for nature.

The website is already actively engaging the public in learning about how we are interconnected with nature. As well as making friends with living organisms and species, members of the public can also create a biodiversified image of themselves on Facebook.

The hope is that by discovering more about the natural world which we so often take for granted, we will learn to take greater care of it.

A new viewer for Natura 2000

The European Commission, with the support of the European Environment Agency (EEA), has launched a new IT tool to bring the public closer to Natura 2000, its flagship network of protected areas.

Natura 2000 is the key instrument to protect biodiversity in the European Union. It is the largest ecological network of protected areas in the world, consisting of more than 25, 000 sites and covering 17% of the EU's land territory. Natura 2000 aims to ensure the survival of Europe's most valuable species and habitats, and safeguards numerous ecosystem services.

Using GIS (Geographical Information System) technology, the interactive viewer allows users to locate sites and related information on species and habitats of interest, using street maps, photographs, satellite imagery and background documents about the regions in question. The tool should raise awareness among the general public, and provides a useful instrument for developers, land use planners, landowners, government authorities, NGOs and researchers.
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

U.S. And NATO Accelerate Military Build-Up In Black Sea Region

By Rick Rozoff


In the post-Cold War era and especially since 2001 the Pentagon has been steadily shifting emphasis, and moving troops and equipment, from bases in Germany and Italy to Eastern Europe in its drive to the east and the south.

That process was preceded and augmented by the absorption of former Eastern Bloc nations into the North Atlantic Treaty Organization beginning in 1999. In one of the first nations in that category, Poland, the initial contingent of what will be over 100 U.S. troops arrived in the town of Morag this week, as near as 35 miles from Russian territory, as part of a Status of Forces Agreement between Washington and the host country ratified this February.

Also in February, the governments of the Black Sea nations of Romania and Bulgaria confirmed plans for the U.S. to deploy a land-based version of Standard Missile-3 anti-ballistic interceptors on their territory.

The U.S. Sixth Fleet, headquartered in Italy, has deployed warships to the Black Sea with an increased frequency over the past few years, visiting and conducting joint drills with the navies of Bulgaria, Romania and Georgia.

Last autumn it was revealed that the Pentagon planned to spend $110 million dollars to upgrade and modernize a base in Bulgaria and another in Romania, two of seven such newly-acquired installations in the two nations.

The air, naval and infantry bases in Bulgaria and Romania have been employed for the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and, although not publicly acknowledged, doubtlessly for arming Georgia before, during and since its five-day war with Russia in August of 2008.

The Pentagon's Joint Task Force-East has all but officially been assigned to the Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield in Romania and also makes regular use of the Romanian Army's Babadag Training Area and the Novo Selo Training Range in Bulgaria, the latter near the strategic Bezmer Air Base and the Black Sea port city of Burgas (Bourgas).

Last year Joint Task Force-East conducted a series of military trainings with Bulgarian and Romanian counterparts from August 7 to October 24. The immediate purpose of the combat drills was for "downrange" operations in Afghanistan, but the lengthy and extensive nature of the maneuvers demonstrated the longer-term and longer-range intents of the U.S. and its NATO allies. The latter also have free use of the Bulgarian and Romanian military bases.

Two squadrons from the 2nd Stryker Cavalry Regiment were among the 2,000 American troops who participated in last year's war games in the two nations.

American Admiral James Stavridis, commander of U.S. European Command and NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Europe, visited Romania on April 27 and 28, meeting with the country's president and defense minister. The main topics of discussion were NATO's new Strategic Concept and its war in Afghanistan, but the issue of stationing U.S. interceptor missiles was surely touched upon as well.

NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen was in Romania on May 6 and 7 to meet with the president, defense minister, foreign minister and top military commander. The U.S.-NATO missile shield project and the war in Afghanistan were major subjects on the agenda.

Five days after Rasmussen left the capital the Romanian Foreign Ministry announced that "A round of technical US-Romanian talks on Romania's inclusion in the Phased Adaptive Approach of the European missile defense system took place in Bucharest" a day earlier, May 11. [1]

The NATO chief arrived in neighboring Bulgaria on May 20 for similar discussions. The local press announced in advance that "The construction of a common missile defense system and Bulgaria’s accession into it, along with reforms in the Bulgarian army and NATO’s new strategic concept – these will be some of the issues that NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen is going to discuss with his Bulgarian partners during his two-day visit to Sofia beginning on Thursday, May 20." [2]

In fact, while in the Bulgarian capital Rasmussen met with the nation's prime minister, president and defense minister and, according to a Bulgarian news source, the top issue discussed was "the planned installation of an anti-missile defence system in the region, as Brussels plans to deploy anti-missile units in Bulgaria and negotiations are set to be launched following the Portugal Nato summit" in November. [3]

Rasmussen reiterated the demand that all Balkans nations be incorporated into NATO, which would dictate the inclusion of Bosnia, Serbia, Macedonia, Montenegro and Kosovo. (As NATO recognizes the last-named as an independent state.)

The host nation's foreign minister, Nikolay Mladenov, spoke after the meeting with NATO's secretary general and linked the North Atlantic bloc's collective military assistance article with U.S.-led missile deployments and anti-Russian energy transit projects. He specifically highlighted "setting up the anti-missile defence shield as a part of Article 5 against new threats" and "the inclusion of energy security to key security issues." [4]

On May 14 Chairman of the NATO Military Committee Admiral Giampaolo Di Paola was in Romania to meet with Defense Minister Gabriel Oprea, and the "current stage of NATO-led military actions in Afghanistan and Romania’s participation in Alliance missions were the main subjects" of deliberation. Romania's defense minister said, "Romania’s prompt response to the proposal to install missile shield elements on its soil is a confirmation of the responsibility whereby Romania approaches national, South-East European and Alliance security issues." [5]

The nation, which lost another soldier to fighting in Afghanistan this week, has recently confirmed plans to deploy 600 more troops for the South Asian war, bringing the aggregate number to 1,800.

On May 17 the U.S.'s Black Sea Rotational Force 2010 three-month series of military exercises was launched at Romania's Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield.

Several days before "more than 100 Marines from across the United States put boots on the ground in Romania and stepped into history as the first Security Cooperation Marine Air-Ground Task Force in the Black Sea region.

"The Marines were deployed to build partnerships with nations in the Black Sea, Balkan and Caucasus regions...." [6]

The Black Sea Rotational Force 2010 drills are being conducted in eastern Romania in Constanta on the Black Sea and Tulcea, also on the Black Sea and close to the border with Moldova, and include over 300 troops from the U.S., the host country, Ukraine and Macedonia.

The U.S. Marine Corps deployment is "the first of its kind for United States Marines to the Black Sea region." [7]

The commander of the Black Sea Rotational Force Security Cooperation Marine Air-Ground Task Force (MAGTF), Lieutenant Colonel Tom Gordon, spoke at the opening ceremony at the Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield. His comments included the following: "Our mission over the next three months will be to conduct multilateral security cooperation activities with partner nations in the Black Sea, Balkan, and Caucasus regions in order to enhance our collective professional military capacity, promote regional stability, and build enduring relationships with our partner nations. As a MAGTF we will simultaneously engage with Romanian Land, Naval, Air, and Special Forces throughout our deployment."

A Romanian officer present said, "This is a great opportunity for us to know the Marines. I expect my men to show they are prepared to fight with America in Afghanistan." [8]

In advance of the maneuvers, the U.S. Marine Corps moved military vehicles from a base in Norway, part of Marine Corps Prepositioning Program Norway.

"The Marine Corps and Norway have developed a unique relationship for the storage and care of prepositioned equipment and supplies. The method of storage to support the prepositioned assets for a MAGTF is a series of six caves in the Trondheim region of central Norway."

To illustrate both the range of military networks stretching from old to new NATO states and where their ultimate downrange destinations are located, a Marine website supplied additional details:

"Norway relies on the Marine’s prepositioning program as a major cornerstone of the nation’s internal defense plan. With deep-water ports in close proximity to the storage caves, equipment can quickly be loaded aboard available shipping for operations in threatened parts of Europe, Africa or the Middle East. This capability was demonstrated by the supplying of equipment and ammunition in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom." [9]

U.S. Marines will be occupied "working in the Black Sea, Balkan and Caucasus regions" to "build enduring partnerships and build the capacity of partner nation’s military forces" until the end of July, by which time NATO's largest military offensive of the nearly nine-year-old Afghan war - the assault on Kandahar province - will be underway.

Shortly before the above-described war games began, U.S. Air Force personnel were deployed from the Ramstein Air Base in Germany to Romania for Operation Carpathian Summer 2010, an air force medical evacuation exercise. "Held at Otopeni Airfield, near Bucharest, Operation Carpathian Summer 2010 was designed to strengthen the partnership between the U.S. and Romanian air forces, while elevating their capability to work together.

"Though this is not the first time American airmen have worked with the Romanian air force, the 86th AES [Aeromedical Evacuation Squadron] has never before joined in the training with their Romanian colleagues." [10]

At the same time Romanian troops joined colleagues from the U.S., Britain, Belgium, Croatia, France, Germany, Hungary, Norway, Poland and Slovakia at the Joint Multinational Readiness Center in Hohenfels, Germany to engage in joint military training with soldiers from the Afghan National Army.

On May 19 the Stars and Stripes armed forces publication reported that "Rapid expansion of the Army's unmanned aircraft fleet has prompted the service to begin offering initial training in Europe, instead of sending troops to the U.S. to learn...." Among the drones that will be used for the training are the Extended-Range Multi-Purpose MQ-1C Warrior, "which can fly for more than 20 hours and launch air-to-ground missiles," and the RQ-11 Raven small class unmanned aerial vehicle used by the U.S. and NATO allies.

The news source added that "a course next month at Grafenwohr Training Area, will, for the first time, offer initial operator training on the Raven UAS [Unmanned Aircraft System] in Europe.

"The Army is looking at flying the Raven in Romania and possibly Bulgaria, and attempting to open a range in Italy for the 173rd Airborne Brigade's unmanned aircraft." [11]

From April 12-16 a U.S. Air Force team at the Aviano Air Base in Italy, "in an effort to improve an already established military relationship," provided aircraft maintenance training to the Bulgarian and Romanian air forces. [12]

On May 18 200 U.S. airmen and ten F-15 multi-role strike fighters spearheaded the launching of Operation Sentry Gold at the Graf Ignatievo Air Base in Bulgaria. "The exercise is designed to provide the U.S. Air Force and Bulgarian air force the opportunity to learn from each other and increase their respective NATO interoperability."

The American commander involved in the maneuvers emphasized that the Bulgarian air force still uses Russian MiG-21s and MiG-29s, saying: "We simulate fighting MiGs all the time. Being here allows us to really see them in action."

A Bulgarian officer said of the drills, "Sentry Gold increases the realism of our combat training. We get to see how a unit with a tested and proven combat history does things," and added, "Training together with [U.S. Air Forces in Europe] and the U.S. pilots moves us closer to NATO standards." [13]

As noted earlier, NATO chief Rasmussen arrived in the Bulgarian capital on May 20. Five days earlier the nation's defense minister, Anyu Angelov, affirmed that "We will file a request to join the common European missile shield during NATO Secretary-General Anders Fogh Rasmussen's visit to Sofia...." [14]

The Bulgarian defense chief also said that his ministry will allot funds to upgrade the nation's air defense system and that "Brussels has promised to co-finance the initiative, while NATO will allocate US $7.5 million to complete the construction of the Graf Ignatievo airbase." [15]

On the eastern shore of the Black Sea, senior Georgian military officials met with the permanent representatives of all 28 NATO member states at a sitting of the NATO-Georgia Commission (created the month after Georgia's war with Russia in 2008) on May 5. A week later NATO's South Caucasus liaison officer Zbigniew Ribatski announced that the military bloc will open a representative's office in Georgia this summer.

On May 14 the Georgian press reported the launching of a U.S.-funded military training simulation facility in the country: "The Simulation Training Center has been formed through the framework of US-Georgia cooperation. The United States, under the ongoing collaboration, donated the Center with the cutting-edge technical equipment and developed special training programs for it." [16] The inauguration was attended by new U.S. ambassador John Bass and NATO nations' military attaches.

Even Ukraine under its new president Viktor Yanukovich remains within NATO's Black Sea plans. The prohibition against the presence of foreign military forces for exercises in the nation, effected by the former opposition against Yanukovich's pro-U.S. predecessor Viktor Yushchenko, has been reversed, and U.S. and fellow NATO states' troops may resume Sea Breeze exercises on Ukraine's Black Sea coast.

The establishment of U.S. and NATO naval, air and infantry bases and interceptor missile installations in Black Sea nations is the prototype for expansive and permanent military build-ups in Eastern Europe and into former Soviet space, which is being replicated in the Baltic Sea region. An imaginary Iranian threat is the subterfuge employed to justify the presence of U.S. and NATO warplanes, warships, troops, mechanized and airborne units, missile batteries, training centers and radar facilities in the Black Sea and Baltic Sea regions.

Iran does not border either of the two seas and has neither the ability nor any reason to threaten nations that do.

Recent news reports from both sides of the Atlantic speak of a warming of relations between Russia and the United States, between Russia and NATO. If so, Russian political leaders won't have to extend their hands far to clasp those of their alleged Western friends and allies. They need merely reach across their southwestern and northwestern borders on the Black and Baltic Seas.

Rick Rozoff is a journalist and blogger and many of his articles may be found at the Stop NATO blog.

Notes:
1) HotNews.ro, May 12, 2010
2) Standart News, May 16, 2010
3) Sofia Echo, May 20, 2010
4) Focus News Agency, May 20, 2010
5) The Financiarul, May 14, 2010
6) Xinhua News Agency, May 13, 2010
7) United States European Command, May 17, 2010
8) Ibid
9) Marines.mil, May 12, 2010
10) U.S. European Command, May 14, 2010
11) Stars and Stripes, May 19, 2010
12) U.S. Air Forces in Europe, April 20, 2010
13) U.S. Air Forces in Europe, May 18, 2010
14) Standart News, May 15, 2010
15) Ibid
16) Georgia Ministry of Defence, May 14, 2010
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

EU Financial Aid For Closure Of Bulgarian Nuclear Plant Extended

The EU is planning to prolong its financial support for the decommissioning of four blocks of the nuclear power plant at Kozloduy in Bulgaria until the end of 2013. On Thursday MEPs backed proposals to earmark €300 million for site cleaning and safe treatment of radioactive waste but they also called for stricter financial controls and more investment in energy efficiency.

During its negotiations to join the European Union, Bulgaria agreed to the early closure of Units 1-4 of the Kozloduy nuclear power plant and the EU agreed to provide financial assistance up to 2009 for the decommissioning. Since the process is not yet complete, the Commission has drafted a regulation enabling the programme to continue at least until the current multi-annual EU budget ends in 2013. Parliament is being consulted on this regulation.

Funding the alternatives to reduce carbon footprint

MEPs would like a clear commitment that, of the proposed total sum of €300 million for the Kozloduy programme in the next three years, €180 million should be spent on decommissioning and €120 million on energy saving measures. MEPs want the regulation to include a detailed breakdown of the programme's individual projects, such as technical assistance, salaries for employed experts, construction of the radioactive waste disposal facility, and treatment of dismantled waste.

The early closure of Kozloduy has already led to significant additional greenhouse gas emissions, so even though the programme's primary goal remains decommissioning, it must also contribute to modernisation of energy production, including renewable energy, new sustainable jobs and industries, says Parliament.

Stricter auditing, detailed reporting

The programme will be monitored by the Commission and may be audited, either by the Commission or outside qualified auditors, at any time during the programme. However, MEPs also want the Parliament and the Court of Auditors to have the same rights of access to the beneficiary’s offices and want OLAF to be able to carry out on-the-spot checks.

Finally, Parliament believes that the ex-post evaluation of the project must contain a complete and precise budget of the costs for decommissioning a nuclear power plant, including an analysis of the economic, social and environmental costs.

Parliament's legislative resolution, drafted by Rebecca Harms (Greens/EFA, DE) for the EP Industry Committee, was adopted by 518 votes to 17 with 73 abstentions.
Thursday, May 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Who Is The Syrian Released From Guantánamo To Bulgaria?

By Andy Worthington

On May 4, two prisoners were released from Guantánamo — one to Spain and one to Bulgaria. Spanish media revealed that the former prisoner offered a new life in Spain (following the arrival of Walid Hijazi, a Palestinian, in February) was a Yemeni, but no further information has yet been revealed regarding his identity. However, the identity of the ex-prisoner released in Bulgaria — the first to be offered a new home in the Balkan state — was revealed in the national media.


Soon after his arrival, RTT News explained, “Neither [Bulgarian Interior Minister Tsvetan] Tsvetanov nor the Pentagon disclosed his identity, but local media reported that the man was a 38-year-old Syria-born Kurd named Masum Abda Mohammed.” The news report added that Tsvetanov has stated that Mohammed was “accompanied by his relatives,” which, if confirmed, will demonstrate a certain generosity of spirit on the part of the Bulgarian government, and will augur well for his psychological adjustment to life after Guantánamo in a new and unknown country.

While the release of prisoners in Western Europe — or even the suggestion of it — has generally provoked ferocious media attention, reporting in Eastern Europe has been noticeably more muted — as with the release of a prisoner in Hungary in November, and three prisoners in Slovakia in January this year, where the anonymity of the men appears to have been thoroughly preserved (although whether this is a good thing or not is difficult to ascertain, as, without outside scrutiny, there appears to be no way of knowing whether their resettlement is proceeding smoothly or not).

However, with the identity of the man released in Bulgaria exposed, I thought it would be useful to explain what is known of his story, to dispel any doubts that might linger, in Bulgaria or elsewhere, regarding whether or not he poses any threat. As I have learned though conversations with journalists in Georgia, Slovakia and Switzerland, it is easy for people in host nations to be influenced by the Bush administration’s enduring propaganda regarding the prisoners — that they were “the worst of the worst” — and not to appreciate that the majority of the men were sold to the US military by their Afghan and Pakistani allies, often very far from any battlefield, and that, moreover, the Obama administration would not release prisoners that officials regard as a threat to the US or to anyone else.

Part of the problem is that documents detailing the US authorities’ supposed evidence against the prisoners are readily available, without any editorial comment, even though they should be stamped with a warning, to indicate that much of the information is not necessarily accurate. This is because much of it — as judges have been discovering while examining prisoners’ habeas corpus petitions — is untrustworthy information, masquerading as evidence, which was extracted through the coercive interrogations of the prisoners themselves, or of their fellow prisoners.

In this, the case of Masum Abda Mohammed (who was identified in Guantánamo as Maasoum Abdah Mouhammad, but who stated that his name was Bilal) is typical. What is certain is that he and three other Syrians, who had been sharing a house in Kabul at the time of the US-led invasion in October 2001, were seized while crossing the Pakistani border in December 2001, and subsequently transferred to US custody.

After that, the US authorities began interrogating them — for “actionable intelligence,” as they did with all the prisoners — and, along the way, began collecting information, in a shockingly haphazard manner, which, essentially as a by-product of the interrogations’ main purpose, established narratives that purported to justify their detention. Discovering how much of this information is true is a puzzle that I have been deciphering for years, that judges have been grappling with in US courts for the last year and a half, and that the Obama administration’s interagency Task Force dealt with last year in Mouhammad’s case, when, while reviewing all the prisoners’ cases, they concluded that there was no reason for him to be held.

Whether the Task Force reached a similar conclusion about the other three men seized with him — 24-year old Ahmed Ahjam, 19-year old Ali Shaaban, and 20-year old Abu Omar al-Hamawe — is unknown, but it is possible, as three of the seven remaining Syrians in Guantánamo had been cleared by the Task Force last October, and several dozen more prisoners were cleared after that date, although to the best of my knowledge the other men are still held. Certainly, the impression given by Mouhammad, and by the other three men, is that they were essentially economic migrants, who had left Syria for the opportunities — spurious or otherwise — that were advertised in Afghanistan, and were caught in the wrong place at the wrong time.

As Mouhammad explained at Guantánamo, and as I described it in my book The Guantánamo Files:
[He and the others] had been living together in a house in the Wazar Akbar Khan area of Kabul. This was one of the more upmarket areas of the capital, where most of the embassies and other grand houses had been taken over by senior figures in the Taliban and al-Qaeda, but although the Americans described their house as “a safe house where five to 20 personnel armed with AK-47 rifles could be found at any time,” which was used for “money and document forging operations” for al-Qaeda, Mouhammed described it as “a normal house, a place to eat, drink and sleep.” Al-Hamawe added that it was close to the Pakistani embassy and that their neighbors, who worked for the Red Cross, “knew that all of us were not fighters or Taliban, just refugees.”
As I also explained:
The four men certainly matched the profiles of economic migrants, drifting from country to country in search of employment, and drawn to Afghanistan by its Arab-influenced reputation for welcoming Muslims from all around the world. They said that only seven people lived at the house (themselves, the owner, and two other Syrians), and that they all put money in to keep the place running. Al-Hamawe worked at a store in Kabul, but planned to move to Pakistan when a friend sent him money from Syria, Mouhammed, who had been a policeman and a grocer in Syria, had saved some money while working, and planned to move on to Jordan, Shaaban had been an ironsmith in his father’s store and went to Afghanistan because he wanted to move there, and, according to US intelligence, Ahjam worked for al-Wafa [a Saudi humanitarian aid charity, which the Bush administration regarded as being tied to al-Qaeda, although no proof of this was ever forthcoming, and almost all of those who worked for the charity, including its Saudi director, were subsequently released].
In disputing Mouhammad’s story, the authorities not only alleged that the house was a safe house, which he “operated,” but also, over the years, built up a picture involving claims that he “trained in al-Qaeda camps” and “was a fighter in the Tora Bora region of Afghanistan” (where a showdown between al-Qaeda and the US military took place around the time of his capture). These are typical allegations leveled against those seized crossing the Pakistani border, but in the courts — the only objective forum in which allegations like these have been tested — judges have often dissected them and found them to be unpersuasive.

In Mouhammad’s case, he was never given an opportunity to clear his name in a courtroom, because he was released before any ruling was delivered regarding his habeas petition. As a result, he remains, officially, tagged as an “enemy combatant,” but it is to be hoped that, in Bulgaria, if his story ever surfaces, those who try to construct a narrative from the collection of uncorroborated statements and allegations in his file realize that the best indicator of the reliability of the Bush administration’s supposed evidence is that Obama’s Task Force authorized his release, having concluded, presumably, that his own account was more reliable than the one concocted by the authorities in Guantánamo after years of pointless interrogations.

The Bulgarians are, moreover, to be congratulated for offering Maasoum Mouhammad a new home, and for recognizing that a Kurdish Syrian refugee, deprived of eight years of his life in Guantánamo, could only expect far worse treatment had he ended up back in Syria, whose prisons — full of the most ill-defined dissidents — are amongst the most feared, and least accountable in the world.

POSTSCRIPT: Saba, the Yemen News Agency, reported that the Yemeni released in Spain is named Yasin, and that he was released after he “was found cooperative with the authorities.” This suggests that he may be Yasim Basardah (aka Yasin Basardh), who won his habeas case last March.


Andy Worthington is the author of The Guantánamo Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal Prison (published by Pluto Press, distributed by Macmillan in the US, and available from Amazon — click on the following for the US and the UK). To receive new articles in your inbox, please subscribe to his RSS feed (he can also be found on Facebook and Twitter). Also see his definitive Guantánamo prisoner list, updated in January 2010, and, if you appreciate his work, feel free to make a donation. This article is reprinted with permission.   
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

AMHRC/MHRMI Condemn Bulgaria FM's Statement No Macedonian Minority Exists In Bulgaria

The Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee (AMHRC) and Macedonian Human Rights Movement International (MHRMI) condemn the statement by the Bulgarian Foreign Minister, Nikolay Mladenov that a Macedonian minority does not exist in Bulgaria.

On 6 May 2010 the Bulgarian Foreign Minister, Nikolay Mladenov, during an official visit to the Republic of Macedonia, stated as follows in reply to a journalist’s question about the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria:

"There is no Macedonian minority in Bulgaria. In Bulgaria there are no minorities of any sort, however there are people who have human rights and our constitution is based on the individual rights of people and not collective rights”.

Foreign Minister’s Mladenov statement is not only factually incorrect, but disturbing as it comes from an eminent representative of a country which claims that it is committed to basic human rights principles such as freedom of speech, assembly and association as well as the right to self-identification.

It is well known that the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria lives compactly in the Pirin region and ethnic Macedonians are found in significant numbers in other regions of Bulgaria. From 1944-1948 the distinct ethnicity of the Macedonians in the Pirin region and Macedonian immigrants in other parts of Bulgaria was officially recognised. In 1947 the Bled Agreement between Yugoslavia and Bulgaria was signed regarding cultural cooperation between the then People’s Republic of Macedonia and the Prin region within Bulgaria. This agreement in effect granted cultural autonomy to the Macedonians in Pirin and ushered in a period of cultural renaissance during which the Macedonian language and history were widely taught.

This period of cultural autonomy was brought abruptly to a halt in June 1948. From then on the Bulgarian state reverted to its pre-September 1944 position whereby Macedonian history, language and culture were misappropriated and presented as an integral part of Bulgarian national and historical development. This policy of denial and forced assimilation of the Macedonians in Bulgaria has continued to the present day and as a result the number of those willing to declare as Macedonians has significantly reduced or been deliberately underreported.

From 1956 onwards the Macedonian nationality all but disappeared from Bulgarian public life, official documents and census figures. In 1950 Hristo Kalaydzhiev reported to the Conference of Cultural and Educational Societies that the number of Macedonians in Bulgaria was about 500,000. The official census of 1956 established that 178, 862 Macedonians (or 63.7% of the total population of the Pirin region) live in the Pirin region. However, the 1968 census only registered 7-8,000 Macedonians in all of Bulgaria at a time when emigration was severely restricted under the Communist regime. At the last census held in 2001, 5071 persons declared that they were of Macedonian ethnicity; however the Bulgarian Prime Minister at that time, Simeon Saxcoburgski, indicated that such persons were Bulgarians with a Macedonian regional identity.

The ability of Macedonians in Bulgaria to enjoy their basic human rights is severely limited. Even though they are not subjected to the brutal treatment meted out to them under the Stalinist Zhivkov regime, Macedonians in Bulgaria are subject to significant official and societal discrimination and harassment when they attempt to assert their rights. Macedonian political parties such as OMO-Ilinden-PIRIN and OMO Ilinden remain unregistered. Those who assert a Macedonian ethnic identity encounter discrimination in employment, education and cultural life. The Macedonian language is not taught at any level in the education system. Macedonian human rights activists are subjected to official harassment when attempting to legally and peacefully carry out their activities.

Given the widespread human rights violations to which Macedonians in Bulgaria are subjected, it is disingenuous in the extreme for Foreign Minister Mladenov to assert that Bulgarian citizens-including those who identify as ethnic Macedonians- are accorded full enjoyment of their human rights.

It is even more absurd for him to claim that there are no minorities in Bulgaria. Bulgaria has signed and ratified all major international human rights instruments and conventions and importantly on 7/5/1999, it ratified the Council of Europe’s Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities which states at Article 3:

“Article 3

1. Every person belonging to a national minority shall have the right freely to choose to be treated or not to be treated as such and no disadvantage shall result from this choice or from the exercise of the rights which are connected to that choice. 2. Persons belonging to national minorities may exercise the rights and enjoy the freedoms flowing from the principles enshrined in the present framework Convention individually as well as in community with others”.

In the light of this undertaking, it is absurd for Mladenov to firstly claim that there are no minorities in Bulgaria by referring to the fact that the Bulgarian Constitution does not recognise minorities’ collective rights and secondly, by refusing to recognise the sizeable Macedonian, Turkish, Roma, Armenian and Pomak minorities which exist within Bulgaria’s borders. The existence of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria is an objective reality which no amount of obfuscation by Sofia can conceal.

Moreover we strongly urge that Foreign Minister Mladenov and the Bulgarian state implement the recommendations made in the report on Bulgaria released by

Thomas Hammarberg, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe on 9 February 2010. Namely, as indicated at paragraph 52 of the report:

“52. The Commissioner believes that domestic law potentially restricting freedom of association should be precise and its application proportionate to the aims pursued in the context of a democratic society. Regardless of the outcome of the new applications lodged with the Court, the Commissioner considers necessary the establishment by the authorities of an open, sincere and systematic dialogue with all minorities in Bulgaria, including the Macedonian one, in line with the Council of Europe standards. Furthermore, it would send a positive signal to all minority groups if the domestic law, including the Constitution, could be amended in such a way that the rights to freedom of association and assembly enshrined in the European Convention on Human Rights were better safeguarded in practice for minorities.”

The Australian-Macedonian Human Rights Committee (AMHRC) and Macedonian Human Rights Movement International (MHRMI) call on the international community to apply pressure on the Bulgarian government to observe its obligations towards all minorities that exist within its borders; to implement the recommendations of Commissioner Hammarberg in his most recent report and to cease its policy of denial and assimilation of its Macedonian minority in order to enhance regional stability and peace in the Balkans.

For all those who are interested in contributing support to the Macedonian human rights movement in Bulgaria, please contact the AMHRC or MHRMI via the means offered below.

Established in 1984 the Australian Macedonian Human Rights Committee (AMHRC) is a non governmental organisation that informs and advocates to governments, international institutions and broader communities about combating discrimination and promoting basic human rights. Our aspiration is to ensure that Macedonian communities and other excluded groups throughout the world are recognised, respected and afforded equitable treatment. For more information please visit www.macedonianhr.org.au, or contact AMHRC at macedonian_rights@hotmail.com or via +61 3 93298960.

Macedonian Human Rights Movement International (MHRMI) has been active on human and national rights issues for Macedonians and other oppressed peoples since 1986. For more information, please visit www.mhrmi.org, or contact MHRMI at 416-850-7125, or info@mhrmi.org.
Monday, May 17, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Turkey’s Gas Deal With Azerbaijan Fuels EU Hopes

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, on a visit to Azerbaijan today (17 May), is due to sign a EU-backed gas deal that is expected to unlock Azeri gas reserves for the West and eventually trim Europe's energy dependence on Russia, the press in the region reports.

Precise details of Monday's expected deal are unknown, but it should at least resolve pricing differences over 6 billion cubic metres of gas Azerbaijan currently sells to Turkey, The Moscow Times writes.

Azeri Energy Minister Natik Aliyev is quoted as saying the two sides had agreed in principle on volumes Turkey would receive from the Shah Deniz II gas field in the Caspian Sea, which will produce an additional 16 billion cubic metres per year on top of the current 9-10 bcm from Shah Deniz I.

Turkey has requested 6-7 bcm of gas from the second phase, and Azerbaijan will look to accelerate the start of production to 2014, he said.

European buyers are looking for volumes from the second phase of production at Shah Deniz, which is operated by BP and Statoil and is due to come online between 2014 and 2017.

That would free up volumes of gas to flow to Nabucco, or initially to ITGI, the Interconnection Turkey-Greece-Italy favoured by Italian company Edison. ITGI represents a cheaper version or a 'first phase' of the more ambitious Nabucco gas pipeline (EurActiv 27/04/10).

The deal is pivotal to the future of both the ITGI and Nabucco projects. Elio Ruggeri, head of gas infrastructure at Edison, recently said that if Azerbaijan were to sell its gas to Russia instead, Europeans "should say goodbye" to the Southern gas corridor, which is designed to decrease the Union's dependence on Russian gas.

Turkish daily Zaman writes that Erdoğan's visit to Baku will also address difficult issues such as the 'frozen conflict' of Nagorno Karabakh, in which Ankara is siding with Azerbaijan against Armenia. Erdoğan said Turkey would never open its border with Armenia unless there were a notable breakthrough in the Nagorno-Karabakh problem.

The leaders are also expected to take decisions on lifting the visa requirement between the two countries.

A monument in Baku to the founder of modern Turkey, Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, will be inaugurated during Erdoğan's visit, the local press writes.


Source: EurActiv
Monday, May 17, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

The Economic Crisis, Greece And The Balkans

The economic crisis – which has eroded the EU's solidarity and diluted its appetite for further enlargement – will serve to fuel populism and undermine the resolution of outstanding conflicts in the Balkans.

By Florian Bieber

The economic crisis has hit the Western Balkans particularly hard. The region was hit hard in absolute terms, a result of half-hearted economic reforms and the elites denial over the economic crisis reaching the region (a number of government ministers across the region predicted that their country would be spared).

The region was also hit hard psychologically, as growth has been sluggish or started from such a low level that the perceived benefits by most citizens are limited. As a result the reservoir of patience is small.

Who will benefit from the crisis? There are no clear winners or losers. However, overall populism is likely to gain ground. Good evidence of this is the media exchange between Germany and Greece, with the German media going for some good old Balkan stereotypes and the Greek media dragging out World War Two to counter German criticisms of the Greek economy. For the German media, Greeks are cheating, stealing Balkanites – which of course bodes well for the enlargement of the region – whilst Greek media like to draw parallels between the EU and Nazi occupation.

In Bosnia, it seems to disadvantage the established nationalists, especially in the Bosniak-Croat Federation, but might help new nationalists/populists, such as the tycoon, Fahrudin Radoncic (the owner of Dnevni Avaz, the largest daily newspaper), who recently suggested that non-Bosniaks should not be working for the Federation's public broadcaster. In Serbia, it is likely to help the populist Progressive Party.

Whilst no elections are scheduled in the region this year except for Bosnia, governments are likely to adopt populist policies. At least at the moment, it does not appear that the opportunity to clean up their act – particularly in terms of inefficient public administration – is being seized upon. Unlike in Greece, the unions are mostly weak and fragmented in the region, so paralysis is unlikely to come from the streets.

Altogether, the economic crisis motivates political elites to claim political successes on other fronts. Unfortunately, this is unlikely to benefit the resolution of outstanding conflicts, from the name dispute between Greece and Macedonia, to relations between Serbia and Kosovo.

In particular, the prospects of resolving the name issue between Greece and Macedonia seems as remote as ever. While the Papandreou government has been more pragmatic than its predecessor, it seems improbable that it has the courage to move a solution forward in the context of the deep economic crisis and faced with the fact that the leader of the main opposition party, New Democracy, is Antonis Samaras, whose hard line over Macedonia brought the downfall of the Mitsotakis government in 1993.

Possibly the most important aspect of the economic crisis is the policy of the EU. We have seen a serious erosion of solidarity among current EU members, and the economic crisis in Greece is likely to disadvantage the countries of the region - whether they are members, such as Bulgaria, who are now less likely to be admitted to the Euro-zone, or countries in the Western Balkans, who are now likely to be scrutinized more extensively than they would have been previously.


Florian Bieber is a Lecturer in East European Politics at the Department of Politics and International Relations of the University of Kent, Canterbury, UK. This article was published by TransConflict and is reprinted with permission.
Monday, May 17, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Bulgaria Suspended From CO2 Emissions Trading

Bulgaria will be suspended from carbon emissions trading under the Kyoto Protocol as a result of poor transparency and untrustworthiness, the country's environment minister said on 13 May. The decision represents a heavy blow for the government in Sofia, which expected to receive €250m in revenue from the scheme this year, according to Dnevnik, EurActiv's partner publication in Bulgaria.


Bulgaria will be suspended from the scheme as of 30 June if a United Nations' committee revokes its accreditation under the treaty. A formal decision is expected by the end of June. Environment Minister Nona Karadzhova said there was no chance of any reversal.

The suspension, which is expected to last until at least November, comes after UN checks had shown that Bulgaria's national system for recording greenhouse gas emissions, which is key for ensuring compliance under Kyoto, was not transparent and trustworthy, Karadzhova explained.

She said the ban would prevent Bulgarian companies from trading on greenhouse gas emission schemes under Kyoto, and would also affect their participation in the European Union's emissions trading scheme (EU-ETS).

"The UN Convention report is devastating. We are likely to lose our accreditation as of 30 June, due to the criminal inaction of the previous government," Karadzhova said.

Over 130 Bulgarian companies, which waited for over two years to begin trading under the ETS, will now only be able to sell their free quotas until 30 June. The government will most likely not receive a single euro of the so-called Assigned Amount Units (AAUs) that it has accumulated, Dnevnik writes.

The news comes as a heavy blow for the Bulgarian government, which had earmarked €500m of such revenue for financing anti-crisis measures.

Just one person responsible for supervision

Foreign experts revealed that just one person, who works in the environment agency, deals with the country's yearly reports. The young female employee reportedly could not maintain consistency in the information included in the reports.

"It's a young woman. She had worked well, but in fact she was on maternity leave during the [foreign experts'] check and we had to call her to come to the office," Karadzhova said.

Her predecessor Dzhevdet Chakarov, now a member of parliament, responded to accusations of negligence by the previous government by saying that throughout his term, nobody had questioned the consistency of the reports.

Bulgaria's suspension from CO2 trading is the "merit" of the current government, he said.

Small impact on EU carbon market

A European Commission spokeswoman said the suspension would have only a limited effect on Bulgaria's participation in the EU emissions trading scheme.

"The suspension would not extend to trade in [EU carbon] allowances, but would temporarily prevent the delivery of allowances," the spokeswoman said in an email, quoted by Reuters.

"In the short-term, the only effect would be that allowances could not be moved into and out of the Bulgarian [emissions] registry, which would hamper spot trading in allowances for Bulgarian companies, as allowances could not be delivered until the suspension is lifted."

Spot trading in EU permits and Bulgaria's share of permits both only account for a small proportion of the total EU carbon market.

"It could impact day-to-day volatility but I don't think it will have a significant effect on prices," said Trevor Sikorski, director of carbon research at Barclays Capital.



Source: EurActiv
Saturday, May 15, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

NATO To Continue Open Door Policy In Balkans

By Marian Chiriac

(BIRN) -- NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen said on Friday in Romania that the Alliance will continue its open door policy as regards countries in the Balkans and would like all the states in the region to join the European Union and NATO.

Rasmussen, who is on a two-day official visit to Bucharest, added that Ukraine and Georgia could also become NATO members if they want to and if they meet the necessary criteria.

"Our position concerning future members, decided at the Bucharest summit in 2008, remains unchanged. The Membership Action Plan, MAP, does not guarantee future NATO membership but it is a framework and an opportunity for a country to take the path of reform to meet the criteria required for membership," Rasmussen said.

Last month, NATO extended a MAP to Bosnia, but attached conditions to its implementation.

Membership action plans are intended to expedite candidate countries' progress toward joining the 28-member military alliance and are seen as a key stepping stone on the way towards full membership. Under the plan, the NATO membership aspirants are provided with individually-tailored advice and support. The plan also serves as a means to monitor their progress and provide feedback on reforms.

NATO comprises 28 member states, including the Balkan countries of Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, Greece, Romania, Slovenia and Turkey.

Bosnia and Macedonia hope to join the alliance in the near future, while Serbia has still not firmly established whether it will seek NATO membership.
Saturday, May 08, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

The ASEM Dialogue: Opportunities For Southeast Asia?

Tuli Sinha for IPCS

Indonesia’s participation in the sixth Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) interfaith dialog held in Madrid, Spain from 7-9 April, themed as "Consolidation of Religious Freedom and of Mutual Knowledge of Societies through Inter-religious and Intercultural Dialogue" sent across the message of a gradually strengthening Europe-Southeast Asia bilateral relations. The three-day meeting brought together 200 delegates from ASEM partners, and was co-hosted by Spain and Pakistan and sponsored by 14 ASEM partners, including Austria, The Netherlands, Bulgaria, Denmark, Finland, Britain, Germany, Italy, China, Japan, Indonesia, South Korea, and Thailand. It becomes imperative to analyse this dialogue for political and economic connotations, specifically for Indonesia which is the largest Muslim, pluralistic country among the initiators of the dialogue.

The Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) is an informal get-together that addresses political, economic, and cultural issues with the objective of strengthening the relationship between the two regions in a spirit of informality and equal partnership. Recently, these issues have been further broadened to include human rights, rule of law, global health threats, sustainable development, and intercultural and interfaith dialogues. Apolitical and cultural dialogues become important as they hold the prospect of improving bilateral relations between countries.

To begin with, there is a need to explore the various facets of this dialogue and its working. The key characteristics of ASEM include four main pillars. First is the ‘informality’ which provides an open forum for policy makers and officials to discuss any political, economic, and social issue of common interest rather than duplicate the work already being carried out in the bilateral and multilateral forums. Second is the ‘multi-dimensionality’ which covers the full spectrum of relations between the two regions and devotes equal weight to political, economic, and cultural issues. Third is the ‘emphasis on equal partnership’ which eschews any aid-based relationship. Last, is the ‘Dual focus’ on high-level and people-to-people contact which provides a platform for a meeting of the heads of the states, and an increasing focus on fostering contacts between societies in all sectors of the two regions.

Although it creates a multilateral forum for a much encompassing cooperation in terms of issues among the members, a critical assessment of the ASEM Dialogue exhibits a rather dismal picture of its role and existence. First, the only permanent physical institution of ASEM, the Asia-Europe Foundation (ASEF) established in the year 1997 has never been in the limelight or used as a concrete platform for discussions on serious issues.

Second, Interfaith Dialogue is a tricky and consequently rarely tackled subject in Europe. European countries are diversely populated and some of them – like France, Germany, Denmark or Belgium – currently question their relation with their Muslim populations and its links with immigration, unemployment, and extremism issues. Therefore, it becomes imperative for Europe to develop some kind of an intra-European dialogue simultaneously to provide a platform for the religious, ethnic, and cultural issues of people within the region rather than imparting all the attention to a multilateral dialogue with Asian nations. Could the ASEM Interfaith Dialogue, if taken seriously by all participants, be a first step towards a better understanding within Europe? Does Asia serve as a role model on that matter? And what can Indonesia specifically bring to the Dialogue?

The inter-religious organization, ASEM fails to shed any light on this. The dialogue does discuss issue of economic cooperation and transaction of meagre grants from Europe to Asian nations. This is very nominal taking into account the lump sum deals among European Union and Indonesia or with any other Asian member. Therefore, ASEM needs to prioritize and choose issues of relevance rather than expanding the list with human rights, rule of law as they are purely political in character.

It is important to remember that ASEM is not a substitute for existing bilateral or multilateral forums between Asia and Europe. However, through the ASEM dialogue, Indonesia can garner collaborative synergies and optimally utilize them as a catalyst for enhancing overall Southeast Asia-Europe relations. It is evident from the past ASEM dialogues that this level of informal engagement with Europe holds great significance for the Indonesian Foreign Policy. It acts as a bridge to reduce the existing economic gap between the two regions. ASEM can also be utilized by Indonesia as a medium to strengthen its position among the Asian countries.

ASEM has definitely helped Europe and Asia in having a more global vision and promoted the overall Asia-Europe relations on international and inter-regional issues of common interest. By bringing together different cultures and civilizations, ASEM fosters common understanding and dialogue and this should be encouraged.


Tuli Sinha is a Research Officer for SEARP, IPCS and may be reached at tuli@ipcs.org. This article was published by IPCS.
Friday, May 07, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Macedonia, Bulgaria "Should Focus On Future"

By Sinisa Jakov Marusic

(BIRN) -- Macedonia and Bulgaria should focus on the future, not the past, is the joint stand of the countries' foreign ministers, Macedonia’s Antonio Milososki and Bulgaria’s Nikolay Mladenov, who met in Skopje on Wednesday.

Milososki and Mladenov told a joint press conference that their meeting aimed at discussing the signing of a mutually acceptable agreement on friendship and cooperation.

“Priorities should be defined. Macedonia and Bulgaria need to determine whether the priority is to have a railroad line and more mutual investments or to give importance to smaller and sometimes insignificant historical issues,” said Milososki.

Mladenov publicly assured Skopje that Sofia has no hidden agenda regarding the proposed friendship document and that for the Bulgarian state Macedonia is an independent and sovereign country, as well as a neighbour and friend.

“Bulgaria has no territorial claims towards Macedonia and I believe that Macedonia has no territorial claims towards Bulgaria. We hope that Macedonia will join the EU and NATO in due time and these questions will be irrelevant,” Mladenov said.

He underlined that Bulgaria, as a NATO and EU member, would continue its support for Macedonia with respect to its development and Euro-Atlantic integration.

Media recently revealed that Sofia has offered Skopje a draft friendship treaty suggesting increased cooperation in many fields and pushing for the elimination of hate speech between the people and media of both countries. Skopje has said it is reviewing the document.

However, some ethnic Macedonian organisations oppose the treaty, expressing concern that it will be based on unequal terms and give Sofia the more privileged position.

Bulgaria was the first state to recognise Macedonia’s independence from Yugoslavia in 1991, and the country recognises its neighbour under its constitutional name (i.e. the Republic of Macedonia rather than the Former Yugoslav Republic Of Macedonia – in contrast to countries such as Greece which insist that Macedonia should change its name in order to avoid any references to possible territorial claims).

However, Sofia has not recognised the existence of a Macedonian language separate from the Bulgarian and many Bulgarian historians say that the Macedonians are part of the Bulgarian nation.

In addition, the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria often complains that it is being unfairly treated by the state while Sofia has objected to Skopje’s treatment of Bulgarians living in Macedonia.
Thursday, May 06, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Redefining The EU-Japan Relationship

By Herman Van Rompuy, President of the European Council
Remarks in the context of the EU-Japan Summit, Tokyo, 28 April 2010

Japan and Europe have a lot in common today. We, as civilian powers, are both committed to the value of democracy and the principles of the market economy. After 1945, both Western Europe and Japan lived under the military protection of the United States. In the Cold War, the Americans helped us to defend ourselves against communist Russia and against communist China, respectively.

This post-war alliance with the U.S. also allowed both of us to develop economically. What’s more, Europe–America–Japan became the fundamental triangle in the global trade system. These trade relationships were sometimes tumultuous, but also very stimulating and beneficial to our welfare.

Now, this post-war world has transformed after 1989 and the end of the Cold War. Russia has undergone a fundamental political rebirth and became a member of the G7, now the G8. China, even with its political system, has become an integral part of the world trade system. The relationship America has with both Europe and Japan is no longer one of existential dependence but rather an evolving partnership. For Washington there is much less at stake; the more so since new actors arrive on the scene. In this respect also, we Europeans and you Japanese find ourselves in the same boat. We are both in the process of redefining our relationship towards the United States, and vice-versa. Although I am not familiar with the intricacies of the Japanese political system, this seemed to be one element explaining the result of the Japanese Lower House elections of September 2009.

But what is the effect of this changing strategic landscape on our bilateral relations? Are we mere spectators or do we perhaps have an important opportunity in front of us to engage relations more closely between Europe and Japan? I will have an opportunity to discuss this with Prime Minister Hatoyama later this week, but let me just say that in my view politics is not a spectator sport. When history offers an opportunity, it is the politicians' responsibility to translate it into not only a joint vision but also to joint action to help creating a new reality.

Let me first talk briefly about our side of the EU–Japanese relationship. In the European Union, we just have a new Treaty between the 27 Member States, the Lisbon Treaty. We discussed a long time about it, but since five months it is in place.

A main driving factor behind the Lisbon Treaty was the wish of the Member States to have a stronger European foreign policy. The EU has had, ever since the 1960’s, a common foreign trade policy; it was a necessity because of our internal economic integration. Now, Europe wants to be able to deal with the world not just economically, as a trade partner, but also politically.

In this respect, the two main innovations of the Lisbon Treaty are the creation of two permanent posts: the High Representative for Foreign Affairs, the mandate assigned to Catherine Ashton, and the permanent President of the European Council, the post I occupy.

Prior my new permanent job, we had a rotating Presidency: every six months another Prime Minister of President of a Member State was at the helm. By contrast, I will be president not just for six months, but 2,5 or 5 years, so five or ten times longer. It has also become a full-time job, and so I stepped down as Belgian Prime-minister. The Permanent President is responsible for organisation of the work of the European Council of Heads of State or Government in the medium and long term. This is a fundamental change, aimed at ensuring stability, continuity, and predictability. Please allow me to say some words on recent developments in Japan. I find them very interesting.

Whereas last year’s renewal on our side was the Lisbon Treaty, the renewal on your side has been a change of government via the ballot box, a rare thing. It would not be appropriate for me to comment on this issue. In voting the Democratic Party into office, the Japanese people showed that they wanted change. It simply is a fact. Did the call for change arise for domestic reasons? Or also because of Japan’s place in the changing world? Maybe it is hard to distinguish between the two, since the elections took place in the midst of the global financial crisis...

I consider three aspects of Prime Minister Hatoyama’s policies very interesting. From an outsider’s perspective, they seem to point in the same direction: an effort to bring more politics into the Japanese system.

First aspect: the effort to restrain the power of the bureaucracy somewhat in favour of those who are elected and responsible in parliament. This is no doubt difficult, but highly commendable.

Second aspect: the redefinition of Japan’s relationship with the United States, the bilateral alliance, but still as an ally. Again, it would not be appropriate for me to comment on this delicate issue. Let me just say that, in view of the almost symmetrical situation we have in Europe, I will follow the developments with a particular interest (even if the main institutional partner of the Americans in this respect is NATO, not the EU).

Third aspect, a most interesting one as well: Prime Minister Hatoyama’s call for an East-Asian Community. A cooperative partnership including Japan, China and South-Korea would be a formidable break-through. A clear end to a long history of conflicts between your peoples. Is it possible? Well, at least, it is not impossible. Thanks to the human capacity for freedom, age-old patterns can sometimes be overcome. The European Union itself is a good example, as Mr Hatoyama is aware of. In two weeks time, we will celebrate in Europe the 60th anniversary of the Schuman Declaration. This was the call by the then French Foreign Minister to build common European institutions for the mining sector. Although apparently on a technical, economic issue, this declaration was – just five years after the end of the Second World War – a highly political act. It was a courageous act of reconciliation and peace between the age-old enemies France and Germany. Nobody knew it at the time, just as nobody knows today what will happen to an eventual East-Asian Community. Every revolution begins with a small step.

Now, this brings me to the upcoming Summit. I am delighted that Japan is to be the first country with which the EU holds a summit outside Europe after the entering into effect of the Lisbon Treaty. We have important steps to take together. Therefore I am looking forward to meet Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama later today; so do, undoubtedly, Commission President José Manuel Barroso and High Representative Ashton, who shall both join me.

It must be clear by now why the moment is very appropriate to re-energize the relationship between Japan and the EU. We defend the same values and the same type of societies. We are both adapting to a rapidly changing global world. As a consequence, both Europe and Japan need to be not only global economic actors, but also global political actors. We are both getting ready for this. It is of utmost importance that our collaboration should reflect this new context. Our bilateral relationship should not only be about trade, but expand to more political domains. Fortunately, this is already happening. For all these reasons, in European-Japanese relations, 2010 can be the year of a new beginning!

To finish, I should like to briefly mention four issues where our relationship could become more intense: trade, foreign policy, network security, climate.

Let’s start with trade, because it will remain the backbone of our relationship. Of course, an obvious way to intensify the trade between our two blocks would be a Free Trade Agreement. Japan has asked for a feasibility study. In the European Union, some feel it is a little premature to commit ourselves to this. Many so-called non-tariff barriers to trade remain in place, which hamper access to the Japanese market. Therefore we could perhaps take some more time to first identify the objectives both parties want to reach. The benefits of abandoning tariffs should not all fall on way side. But we are open to discuss it, and I will say so to the Japanese government.

Secondly, foreign policy. As I said, it is important to develop the political, strategic side of the relationship in parallel to the economic aspects. We are seeking to cooperate closely on a range of global issues and to have a close political dialogue covering the full gamut of foreign and security policy. This ranges from the situation in East Asia, in Afghanistan, the Middle East or Africa to questions such as terrorism, piracy, nuclear non-proliferation, the fight against poverty, the promotion of human rights or the security aspects of energy supply and climate change.

It can be more than dialogue. Take Afghanistan. We are very keen to discuss and cooperate with Japan on reconstruction and reconciliation efforts in Afghanistan, for instance in working together in police training.

Thirdly, network security. The challenges facing the world today are not only traditional threats. Threats of a new kind undermine the security of our free societies and the networks these societies are built on. Our societies live by the grace of a free flow of goods, people and information.

Networks are the arteries of the global economy. Think of the internet and telecommunications, banking and money transfer systems, airports and energy grids. These networks are vulnerable.

Cyber attacks against these nodes of modern life are no fantasy: they can happen (and do happen) every day. We must enhance our resilience against these. Both Japan and Europe are so deeply embedded in global networks that we must do this together.

Fourth and finally, global climate politics. I already mentioned the Copenhagen Climate Summit of December 2009, where both Europe and Japan were sidelined. However, in the run-up to that Summit, we Europeans noticed with satisfaction the policy change of the Hatoyama government.

Whereas the EU pledges to reduce CO2-emissions with 20 percent (30 percent if others make comparable efforts), Japan went from minus 5 to minus 25 percent. Thus, both Europe and Japan set the example. It was a pity that the other actors did not follow us. I am also disappointed to hear that some big countries reject the Copenhagen Accord as the basis for further work. Japan and the EU are not only at the forefront in terms of emission reduction: in Copenhagen, the EU and Japan committed for 80% of the fast- start finance to developing countries (30 billion for 2010-2012). As the two major donors, maybe we could reflect on how to coordinate the implementation of our commitment?

In all these issues, we will be stronger in facing the challenges of a changing world, if we work together. To share the burden and to lead the way, we need to team up with each other. I believe that the EU and Japan, with our combined economic and political strength, can help make a difference in an increasingly globalised world. That is why I am really looking forward to our Summit.
Wednesday, April 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

South Stream Pipeline Will Pass Through Romania

By Marian Chirac

(BIRN) -- After years of opposing the project, Romania is now ready to join the Russian-backed South Stream gas transit pipeline, officials in Bucharest said.

"We have been able to start a dialogue, including with Russia. South Stream will pass through Romania," the country's Economy Minister Adriean Videanu said during an on-line interview Thursday with local media.

He didn't want to further elaborate.

Early this year, Russian gas giant Gazprom invited Romanian state-run gas pipeline operator Transgaz to join the South Stream.

Romanian authorities, who in recent years have expressed their reluctance to take part in the project, have not commented further on the proposal, but local analysts said that Romania is interested in participating in the
pipeline.

The South Stream pipeline is mainly backed by Russia, which will supply gas from Russia’s Black Sea coast through Bulgaria and Serbia to Hungary, Italy and Greece.

Romania has been a strong supporter of Gazprom's direct competitor, the Nabucco project, which aims to reduce European reliance on Russian gas by providing access to supplies from Azerbaijan and other central Asian countries.

The projected Nabucco route runs through Turkey, Bulgaria, Romania and Hungary to its final destination in Austria.
Saturday, April 24, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Russian Threats, American Missiles And Bulgaria's Choice

By Alexander Atanasov for FPIF

President Barack Obama decided to cancel the plans for missile defense based in the Czech Republic and Poland this past October. Washington has since worked on an alternative that Obama calls a "stronger, smarter and swifter defense" that "best responds to the threats we face." The new system is built around sea-and-land-based SM-3 missile interceptors.

The perceived threat is Iran. Tehran says its missile development program is solely for scientific, surveillance, or defensive purposes. Both the West and Iran's neighbors, however, feel that the development of the Iranian nuclear and missile development programs carry the risk of use of nuclear weapons.

This new missile defense system will include numerous European countries, including Romania and Bulgaria. Talks between Sofia and Washington have already begun.

Russia, however, opposes the new European defense system. The Russian government was infuriated with the old missile defense plans in the Czech Republic and Poland. Russian President Dmitry Medvedev welcomed the U.S. decision to stand down with the initial defense plans and called it a "responsible move." But the new plans aren't easily accepted by Russia either. Russia is now putting pressure on Bulgaria to cancel its plans for European defense collaboration with the United States.

At stake here is more than just disruption of local European politics. The missile shield is of fundamental importance for the newly shifting balance of two major world powers — America and Russia. These two countries no longer operate in the bipolar Cold War world. They're both struggling to navigate in a new multilateral global reality and shape that world to their own ends.

Bulgaria as Pivot

The concept of Bulgaria as a Russian satellite predates World War II. For the last 150 years Bulgaria was on the lookout for a world power to guarantee its security; its first "protector" was Russia. After handing Bulgaria its independence in 1878, following a war with the Ottoman Empire, Russia was the undisputed champion of Bulgarian freedom.

The relationship, however, soon turned sour. Russia essentially abandoned newly independent Bulgaria to fend for itself. Later, in the early 20th century, Russia attempted to dictate Bulgarian internal and external policy numerous times. Ever since, Bulgarian foreign policy has swung between pro- and anti-Russian arguments.

Since the fall of the Berlin Wall, Bulgarian foreign policy has been oriented again toward the West. Bulgaria joined NATO and recently the European Union, so it's only natural that the government will seek protection from those two organizations. The EU, however, has created rather weak foreign policy and security institutions.

To further complicate things, NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen, recently said that the EU must put more money and muscle into defense if it wants to become a global player, and that Europeans shouldn't take the transatlantic alliance with the United States for granted. Rasmussen urged European countries to cooperate with Russia on missile defense at every opportunity.

But European countries are not necessarily enthusiastic about missile defense. "Given the cost of a missile defense system and given limited defense budgets," said French Defense Minister Herve Morin, "my deeper concern is that missile defense would come at the expense of the military capacity of Europeans, which is already often a European weakness,"

This means that Bulgaria, despite its EU membership, is still dependent on Russia.

Russia Returns

Russia announced its return as a world power with a bang. The military campaign in Georgia shattered the short era of unilateral U.S. domination of world politics. Russia demonstrated that it too could act unilaterally, and largely with impunity.

Since then, Russia has continued to show its political muscles. It blocked gas delivery for half of Europe last year. It secured a deal for its Black Sea fleet to stay in Ukraine, thanks to a new pro-Russian government in that country. And now Russia is trying to block the improvement of Europe's defensive capabilities.

If Russia made a compelling case against missile defense as part of a new defense strategy for Bulgaria, the pro-Russian segment in Bulgarian society could have supported the initiative. Unfortunately, Russia is simply trying to impose its will, meddling in Bulgarian foreign policy without providing a viable, mutually beneficial alternative. As such, the Bulgarian government would be unwise to yield to the Russian government's demands.

But that's not the end of the story. Bulgaria is at the center of several conflicting agendas. America and NATO support missile defense — which is really a form of missile proliferation — as a response to the Iranian nuclear threat. Russia is afraid that missile defense will undermine its nuclear arsenal and thus resort to the usual threats. NATO encourages Europe to support the U.S. initiative, arguing that Europe will never have the military capabilities to be a global power. And France does not want to pay for expensive military projects.

After Obama and Medvedev signed the New START, the United States and NATO are now responding to Iran's nuclear ambitions and a potential increase in the number of nuclear weapons in the world with...further missile proliferation. Bulgaria isn't strong enough to defy the United States, NATO, and Russia. Until multilateral agreements can restrain Iran's nuclear weapons ambitions, resolve the U.S.-Russian disagreement over missile defense, and preserve the security of small countries like Bulgaria, great power politics will still hold sway.

FPIF contributor Alex Atanasov is a PhD candidate, researching international law and international relations. He holds LLM (Durham University, UK) Maîtrise en Droit (University Toulouse, France). He is also an intern with Foreign Policy In Focus, where this article was first published.
Tuesday, April 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

NATO: Pentagon’s Gateway Into Former Warsaw Pact, Soviet Nations

By Rick Rozoff

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization was founded in April of 1949 by a country not on the European continent, the United States, and eleven subordinates which had fought on both sides of the World War that had ended four years earlier: Belgium, Britain, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway and Portugal. Greece and Turkey were added in 1952 after their service in the Korean War and West Germany joined in 1955.

Five days after the inclusion of the Federal Republic of Germany on May 9, in contravention of the 1945 Potsdam Agreement between Britain, the U.S. and the Soviet Union which explicitly demanded and meticulously detailed plans for the demilitarization of Germany, the Soviet Union established the Warsaw Treaty Organization (Warsaw Pact) in response. Fellow members were Albania, Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, the German Democratic Republic (East Germany), Hungary, Poland and Romania. Albania formally withdrew in 1968, though it had not been a participating member since the early 1960s, and Romania had been a member in name only for at least twenty years before the pact’s formal disbandment.

With the accession of Spain into the “military alliance of democratic states in Europe and North America” in 1982 the U.S.-led military bloc grew from its original 12 to 16 members. By that time the Warsaw Pact had shrunk from eight to seven members and some of the remaining ones were only selectively involved.

NATO regularly held large-scale military exercises in alleged defense of Norway, Denmark and other members, but never deployed forces or conducted operations outside member states’ territories, counting on the thousands of American nuclear warheads in European NATO states to respond to the Warsaw Pact’s conventional military superiority in the event of armed confrontation. [1]

Military forces from the Warsaw Pact intervened in Czechoslovakia in 1968 and in the early 1980s it appeared they might do so again in Poland, and the Soviet Union sent troops to Hungary in 1956 after Prime Minister Imre Nagy withdrew his nation from the Warsaw Pact.

The Soviet Union’s justification for those actions was that nations in Eastern Europe gravitating toward the West could be transformed into sites from which NATO, and especially its dominant member the U.S., would present a military threat on or near its borders.

In 1999, eight years after the formal dissolution of the Warsaw Pact and the fragmentation of the Soviet Union itself, the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland were brought into NATO as full members during the bloc’s fiftieth anniversary summit in Washington, DC, while NATO was conducting its first large-scale military operation outside the territory of its member states and its first major armed conflict: The almost three-month Operation Allied Force air war against Yugoslavia, which had not been a member of either Cold War military alliance.

The accession of three former Warsaw Pact nations in 1999 was the largest one-time expansion in NATO’s history. Five years later at the Istanbul summit seven new members were inducted, six former Warsaw Pact countries, including three ex-Soviet republics, and a former federal republic of Yugoslavia: Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia.

With the earlier absorption of East Germany into NATO with German reunification in 1990, by 2004 every member of the erstwhile Warsaw Pact outside the Soviet Union except short-term member Albania had been brought into the Western military alliance. Albania was incorporated into NATO at the Strasbourg-Kehl summit last year.

The worst suspicions harbored east of the Cold War divide had been confirmed. Not only have all of the Soviet Union’s previous allies in Eastern Europe been recruited into a Washington-dominated military bloc that for eleven years has been actively waging wars in Europe and beyond Europe in Asia, but territory of what had been the Soviet Union itself now contains a NATO air base (Lithuania) and a cyber warfare center (Estonia).

Once Soviet Republics like Ukraine, Georgia, Azerbaijan and Armenia are being actively pursued by NATO, which has held military exercises in those countries.

In 2007 NATO selected the Papa Air Base in Hungary for its first Strategic Airlift Capability (SAC) operation in support of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq (for the present). In the same year the Alliance announced it would open its first training center in a former Warsaw Pact country, in the Polish city of Bydgoszcz.

Starting the year after they were admitted as full NATO members, Bulgaria and Romania were approached by the U.S. to offer the Pentagon access to several major military bases. [2] Both countries had turned their air bases over to Washington in late 2002 and early 2003 for the invasion of Iraq, but in 2005 and 2006 Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice signed formal agreements for the acquisition of military bases with Romania and Bulgaria, respectively. The Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base and training and firing grounds in Babadag, Cincu and Smardan in Romania, and the Bezmer Air Base, the Graf Ignatievo Air Base and the Novo Selo Training Range in Bulgaria were locked into initial ten-year agreements. The Pentagon is not planning to leave, surely not after spending billions of dollars to modernize the facilities.

The deployment of between 5,000-10,000 U.S. troops to the bases at any one time is the first Pentagon presence in former Warsaw Pact nations. And the seven Bulgarian and Romanian installations are the first American military bases in any of those countries. Neither the troops nor the bases were the last.

The U.S. has moved its Joint Task Force-East, whose name alone indicates its purpose, to the Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base in Romania, and in the words of the unit’s deputy commander in 2008, “We are building a permanent forward operating station here….” [3]

The worst fear of the Soviet Union during the Cold War years was not just of NATO in general but of the U.S. in particular moving its military personnel and hardware toward its borders. Anyone who experienced a nightmare of that occurring twenty years ago and only woke up decades later would have difficulty realizing it was no longer just a dream.

NATO is, simply put, the major mechanism for moving the U.S. military into the territory of what had been the Warsaw Pact. And the Soviet Union. Permanently and aggressively.

By 2006 the advance of the Pentagon into Eastern Europe under the banner of NATO had become apparent enough – inescapably so – that quite far from the continent a Chinese military analyst, Lin Zhiyuan, deputy office director of the World Military Affairs Research Department of the Chinese Academy of Military Sciences, wrote that “new military bases, airports and training bases will be built in Hungary, Romania, Poland, Bulgaria and other nations to ensure ‘gangways’ to some areas in the Middle East, Africa and Asia [for] possible military actions in the years ahead.” [4]

As a major American news agency described the plans in 2007, “The bases are part of an ambitious plan to shift EUCOM’s [European Command's] fighting brigades from western Europe – mostly Germany – to forward bases closer to the Caucasus, the Balkans, the Middle East and Africa, for a quicker strike capability.” [5] [6]

The Bezmer, Graf Ignatievo and Mihail Kogalniceanu air bases in Bulgaria and Romania are being upgraded to serve as part of a series of new American strategic air bases outside the U.S. Aimed toward the east and the south.

In Poland, the activation of an Advanced Patriot Capability-3 interceptor missile battery manned by at least 100 U.S. military personnel has been scheduled for later this month. The troops will be deployed only 35 miles from Russia’s isolated enclave of Kaliningrad and will be the first foreign forces stationed in that nation since the end of the Warsaw Pact.

They will not be the last. After U.S. President Barack Obama met with the leaders of eleven new Eastern European NATO states – Bulgaria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, and Slovenia – in Prague on April 8 following the signing of a Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (START) II agreement with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, Polish President Donald Tusk told reporters “From the perspective of [President Obama] and the U.S. the signing of the START 2 treaty has no influence on the work on the SM3 anti-missile shield.” [7]

Tusk was not speaking of the short- to medium-range Patriots missiles that may arrive in his country any day, but of Standard Missile-3 longer-range anti-missile and anti-satellite interceptors that will be adapted from sea-based to land-based use. In Pentagonese, the Aegis Ashore component of the Phased Adaptive Approach for progressively longer-range missiles in Eastern Europe, ones which in the third phase could cripple Russia’s ability to launch a retaliatory response to a first strike.

This February 27 the now late Polish President Lech Kaczynski ratified a Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) with the U.S. for the stationing of the latter’s troops on his nation’s soil.

On March 5 the Polish armed forces launched combat training exercises with the participation of “scores of U.S. Army soldiers.” [8]

Going backward in time, in August of 2008 the U.S. signed an agreement with Poland which includes a “commitment for both states to come to each other’s assistance in case of military threats.” [9] What certainly appears to be a mutual defense pact.

In 2002 Poland signed the largest military purchase agreement in its history: 48 F-16 multirole jet fighters, the first of which were delivered in 2006. They were the first U.S. fighters provided to a former Eastern Bloc nation.

In 2005 Poland became the first former Warsaw Pact state to assume control of the NATO Baltic air patrol established immediately after Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania joined the bloc in 2004. Polish warplanes took over from U.S. F-16 Fighting Falcons. Poland will again take control of the mission next month with four warplanes operating out of and 100 troops stationed at the Lithuanian Air Force base at Siauliai.

In 2007 the Pentagon announced plans to sell Romania 48 F-16s as well, 24 new and 24 refurbished older jet fighters, for $4.5 billion, without doubt the most expensive military purchase in that nation’s history also. Late last month the Romanian government confirmed its decision to buy the 24 second-hand F-16s, beating out competition from France’s Dassault (Rafale), Sweden’s SAAB (Grippen) and the European Aeronautic Defence and Space Company (Eurofighter).

Early this month U.S. arms manufacturer Textron disclosed it would jointly produce armored vehicles with a Romanian counterpart, as “Romania is planning to buy about 800 armored vehicles.” [10] Romania’s NATO accession has proven invaluable for the Pentagon’s plans to expand deployments and operations from Europe to the east and the south and has been correspondingly lucrative for U.S. arms firms.

In March the Czech press revealed that “the Czech Republic is in discussions with the Obama administration to host a command center for the United States’ altered missile-defense plan.” [11]

During the recently-concluded Nuclear Security Summit in Washington, DC where a number of decidedly unrelated agreements were reached including one with which the U.S. secured the right for military overflights from Kazakhstan [12], Czech Defense Minister Martin Bartak disclosed that his meetings in the American capital included one with Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Michele Flournoy and Under Secretary of State for Arms Control Ellen Tauscher, the latter a long-time advocate for and organizer of U.S. missile shield projects in Eastern Europe.

In addition to being pressured by his American interlocutors to provide more troops for the Afghan war, Bartak said the three talked about Washington’s interceptor missile system, specifically that “The Czech Republic may be a part of a new warning system against possible enemy missile attacks,” personally adding that “the Czech Republic is prepared to participate in the system.” To demonstrate that the deliberations were not of an abstract nature, the Czech defense chief also mentioned the “sharing of data from commanding and observing elements placed in two locations in the Czech Republic.” [13]

Both the missile shield command center and the surveillance sites would include, in fact would be run by, American military personnel.

As will the (presumably) Standard Missile-3 interceptor missile sites offered to the U.S. in February by the Romanian and Bulgarian governments.

In Hungary, the world’s first multi-national strategic airlift operation was activated last July at the Papa Air Base. Although established under the auspices of NATO and jointly operated by twelve NATO and all-but-acknowledged NATO members – the U.S., Bulgaria, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Romania and Slovenia and Finland and Sweden – it is not under NATO command. It is an American project for the expanding war in Afghanistan with, as one U.S. officer assigned to the command put it, a “24-hours-a-day, seven-days-a-week” operation which “recently moved 2.1 million pounds of equipment essential to surge operations supporting the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan.” [14]

U.S. Air Force personnel are deployed there for the indefinite future, as their fellow service members are in Bulgaria and Romania and soon will be in Poland.

In former Soviet space, in addition to the participation of American warplanes over the Baltic nations of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and the regular participation of troops in NATO Partnership for Peace and other war games in Ukraine, Azerbaijan and Armenia, the Pentagon has established a permanent presence in Georgia since 2002, first with a Train and Equip Program and since then with U.S. Marines there on an ongoing basis and a steady parade of Marine commanders in and out of the capital of Tbilisi. Most recently Lieutenant General Richard F. Natonski, Commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Command, and Brigadier General Paul W. Brier, Commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Europe (and of U.S. Marine Forces Africa) earlier this month. [14]

U.S. troops and equipment were in that nation during the five-day war with Russia in August of 2008 and are there now.

The U.S. guided missile frigate USS John L. Hall arrived at the Georgian Black Sea port of Poti on April 14 for a week of joint exercises.

In turbulent Kyrgyzstan the U.S. runs one of the largest transit operations for the war in Afghanistan. In March U.S. Special Representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan Richard Holbrooke stated that 35,000 American troops pass through the air base at Manas each month on their way to and from Afghanistan, and U.S. Central Command has acknowledged that the number reached 50,000 last month.

In neighboring Kazakhstan, the U.S. gained military flyover rights with the government on April 11 which include for the first time the transit of combat troops and lethal military equipment.

A Kyrgyz news source revealed that in discussions between Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev, U.S. President Obama and his main Russian and Eurasian hand Michael McFaul, the last-named proposed the establishment of an American military base in Kazakhstan to either supplement or replace if need be the Transit Center at Manas in Kyrgyzstan. [15]

Retired Russian general Leonid Ivashov has stated that new U.S.-Kazakh military cooperation plans “threaten the interests of Russia and other countries, notably China and especially Iran against which the United States is preparing a military operation,” particularly if as seems increasingly likely the U.S. opens “a military base in Kazakhstan similar in size to the Kyrgyz facility.” [16]

In the post-Cold War period the Pentagon through bilateral agreements, but even more so through NATO partnerships, has ensconced itself in former Warsaw Pact and Soviet nations from the Baltic Sea to the Black Sea to Central Asia. From the Balkans to the Chinese border.


Rick Rozoff is a journalist and blogger and many of his articles may be found at the Stop NATO blog. 

NOTES:

1) NATO’s Sixty Year Legacy: Threat Of Nuclear War In Europe Stop Nato, March 31, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/08/27/natos-sixty-year-legacy-threat-of-nuclear-war-in-europe
Bulgaria, Romania: U.S., NATO Bases For War In The East Stop NATO, October 24, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/bulgaria-romania-u-s-nato-bases-for-war-in-the-east

2) Black Sea: Pentagon’s Gateway To Three Continents And The Middle East
Stop NATO, February 21, 2009 http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/08/27/79

3) United States Army, July 24, 2008
4) People’s Daily, December 5, 2006
5) United Press International, May 18, 2007
6) Bulgaria, Romania: U.S., NATO Bases For War In The East Stop NATO, October 24, 2009

http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/bulgaria-romania-u-s-nato-bases-for-war-in-the-east

7) Polish Radio, April 9, 2010
8) U.S., NATO Intensify War Games Around Russia’s Perimeter Stop NATO, March 6, 2010
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2010/03/06/u-s-nato-intensify-war-games-around-russias-perimeter

9) Bloomberg News, August 15, 2008
10) Agence France-Presse, April 9, 2010
11) Prague Post, February 10, 2010
12) Kazakhstan: U.S., NATO Seek Military Outpost Between Russia And China
Stop NATO, April 13, 2010 http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2010/04/15/kazakhstan-u-s-nato-seek-military-outpost-between-russia-and-china

13) Czech News Agency, April 14, 2010
14) United States Air Forces in Europe, April 2, 2010
15) U.S. Marines In The Caucasus As West Widens Afghan War Stop NATO, September 3, 2009

http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/09/04/u-s-marines-in-the-caucasus-as-west-widens-afghan-war

16) 24.kg, April 12, 2010
17) Nezavisimaya Gazeta, April 14, 2010
Friday, April 16, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...



Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search