Wen: China Will Not Shield Attacker of S. Korean Warship

By Kurt Achin

China's number two official has assured South Korean authorities that Beijing will not obstruct justice in the sinking of a South Korean naval ship. Premier Wen Jiabao paid a state visit to Seoul on Friday, where officials lobbied him for cooperation in punishing Pyongyang at the United Nations Security Council.

A South Korean presidential spokesman quoted Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao Friday as saying Beijing "will not protect" those responsible for sinking South Korea's patrol ship, the Cheonan, in March.

The Cheonan was patrolling waters west of the Korean peninsula near a maritime border long disputed by North Korea when a sudden explosion tore it in half and sunk it, killing 46 sailors. International investigators concluded that it was beyond doubt a North Korean submarine had fired a torpedo at the ship.

In a Seoul meeting with President Lee Myung-bak, Premier Wen was quoted as condemning "any act that destroys the peace and stability of the Korean peninsula."

South Korea and the United States are urging China to join them in punishing North Korea with action at the United Nations Security Council. China, however, has not directly said it thinks Pyongyang is responsible.

Eric Olander is co-director of the U.S.-based consulting firm China Talking Points. He says Chinese leaders face a difficult balancing act between their deepening relationships with Seoul and Washington, and their need to prevent instability in neighboring North Korea.

"The Chinese are seen as the glue that holds all this together, so whatever resolution they end up passing in New York will have to be broad enough and flexible enough in its language to accommodate all those objectives," said Olander.

Premier Wen and President Lee will be joined this weekend by Japanese Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama on South Korea's Jeju island for a three-way summit. While the meeting originally was meant to primarily discuss economic issues, North Korea is likely to top the agenda.

Tokyo tightened its own sanctions on Pyongyang this week, restricting the flow of money to North Korea and passing legislation that empowers its Coast Guard to inspect North Korean cargo in international waters.

At the tense inter-Korean border, South Korean businessmen employed at a joint North-South industrial zone began trickling back into the South. Pyongyang says it may block access to the zone, located in the North Korean city of Kaesong.

Returning from Kaesong, South Korean worker Shin Sam-ho said tensions there are noticeable. He says the factory zone feels tense. Instead of their usual cloth caps, he says, the soldiers guarding the zone are wearing battle helmets, in apparent preparation for combat.

South Korean Unification Ministry spokeswoman Lee Jong-joo says South Korea will not tolerate interference with its citizens at Kaesong.

She says ensuring the safety of South Korean people is the most important thing in the zone's operation. If North Korea infringes on their safety even a little, she says, the South has no choice but to take more resolute and strict measures.

Source: VOA
Friday, May 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

BYD And Daimler Form JVTo Develop Electric Vehicles In China

China's BYD Company Limited and Daimler AG have signed a contract creating a 50:50 research and technology joint venture called “Shenzhen BYD Daimler New Technology Co. Ltd,” that will develop an electric vehicle for China.

BYD and Daimler will invest RMB 600 million to use as registered capital for the Joint venture. The new generation of electric vehicles developed by the joint venture will capitalize on Daimler’s know-how in electric vehicle architecture and safety as well as BYD’s excellence in battery technology and e-drive systems. The vehicle will be marketed under a new brand jointly created and owned by Daimler and BYD.

According to Mr. Wang Chuanfu, Chairman and President of BYD, “Together with Daimler we are making excellent progress identifying opportunities to utilize the strengths of both companies to create a new brand of electric cars for China. This is a unique and exciting initiative and together we are pushing hard to bring this new electric vehicle to market as soon as possible.”

Dr. Dieter Zetsche, Chairman of the Board of Management of Daimler AG added, “Our new joint venture is well positioned to make the most of the vast potential of electric mobility in China. We are fortunate to have excellent joint venture partners in China and the establishment of this research and technology center with BYD adds another dimension to our growing presence in this important market.”

Chairman Wang and Dr. Zetsche signed the joint venture contract Thursday in Beijing. This follows the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding on March 1. Engineers, designers and other executives from both companies established working teams after the signing of the MOU to begin working on the vehicle concept. The business license for the new joint venture is subject to relevant government approval.
Friday, May 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

European Parliament President Buzek Meets Chinese Prime Minister Wen Jiabao

"'One tree is not enough to build a temple': we need multilateral governance - we need China as a strong partner," said EP President Jerzy Buzek after his meeting with China's Prime Minister Wen Jiabao in Beijing. "I explained that the European Parliament represents 500 million citizens of the EU who deeply believe in respect for fundamental political rights and freedoms."

During his visit to China, President Jerzy Buzek discussed with Chinese leaders economic and trade relations, the financial crisis, energy and climate change, the enhancement of political relations and the joint tackling of major global security issues.

President Jerzy Buzek said: "We want to engage China and we want to engage with China.

'One tree is not enough to build a temple': we need multilateral governance - we need China as a strong partner. We must face the challenges of climate change, energy and financial crisis together.

China plays an important role in the world economy. We very much appreciate its steady commitment to macroeconomic stability and its recent development.

I think we need to finish constructing a solid bridge between China and Europe and we need to build this bridge from both sides. There is one essential element to finish this bridge: respect for rule of law, civil rights and minorities."

During the meeting with Prime Minister Wen Jiabao President Buzek mentioned specific cases.

Buzek said, "I explained that the European Parliament represents 500 million citizens of the EU who deeply believe in respect for fundamental political rights and freedoms."

President Buzek reminded that over ten years ago China signed the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, a document still to be ratified.

Buzek said, "I came in a spirit of friendship and I'm looking for progress in all areas, which will help us to become stronger global partners."
Friday, May 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Noth Korea "Masking" Burma Weapons Trade

By Francis Wade

(DVB) -- North Korea has been using various "front companies, middlemen and other ruses" to sell nuclear and missile technology to so-called rogue states, including Burma, the UN has said.

The tactic is designed to circumvent sanctions implemented on the pariah state in 2009 that ban trade in weapons, according to a UN panel that has released a 47-page report outlining concerns about Pyongyang's activities.

Other countries listed as beneficiaries of North Korea's weapons market include Iran and Syria, both of which are also subject to tight UN sanctions.

The various "masking techniques" used to avoid export detection include mislabelling the contents of shipping containers, falsifying information about the origin and destination of goods and “use of multiple layers of intermediaries, shell companies, and financial institutions”. This includes the building of assembly factories in importing countries.

An investigation last year by the South Korea news agency Chosun Ilbo found that Pyongyang had illegally exported weapons to Burma via overland routes through China to avoid naval detection or interception. This followed reports that a North Korean ship, the Kang Nam 1, was being tracked by the US navy on suspicion that it was carrying weapons destined for Burma.

US intelligence agencies believe that Pyongyang has exported weaponry to Iran, Syria, Laos and Burma totalling $US800 million since 2000.

And fears have recently resurfaced about apparently warming relations between North Korea and Burma and the possibility that Pyongyang is now supplying nuclear technology to Naypyidaw.

Rumours about possible weapons exports from China and North Korea to Burma in mid-April prompted a warning from a senior US envoy Kurt Campbell that the US "maintains the right to take independent action" on Burma.

The efficacy of UN sanctions on North Korea that were implemented following its nuclear test in May 2009 is now being questioned; one UN diplomat told Reuters that “the details in the report are not entirely surprising”.

Australia-based North Korea expert Leonid Petrov told DVB that "no sanctions can be effective with a country like North Korea".

"It's a totalitarian state - and actually sanctions help such regimes to survive because they use it to mobilise their own population."

The problem is compounded by the continued alliance with countries such as China and Russia, which both hold significant clout in the UN security council and provide an economic crutch for the North Korean regime.

"In economic terms, still China and Russia are strategic allies and they have bilateral agreements and can always bypass [restrictive measures]," Petrov said. "So unless China and Russia really join those sanctions in earnest then I don't think it's possible [for sanctions to be effective]."
Friday, May 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Wave Of Suicides Continues At Foxconn Plant In China

Another man committed suicide at Foxconn plant in China bringing the toll of suicides at the Taiwanese hi-tech company to five this month only and to an overall of 10 from the beginning of the year, local media reported.

Xinhua news agency reported that company's employee fell to his death from a dormitory building in a Shenzhen plant just hours after President of Foxconn Terry Gou arrived at the plant in China to show it off to 300 Chinese and foreign journalists in order to restore the image of the world's largest provider of electronics manufacturing services (EMS).

In all, 12 suicides were attempted at the plant since the beginning of the year, but two people survived and sustained severe injuries.

Terry Gou said the suicides are not connected with working conditions at the plant and they are the result of employees' personal problems.

According to media reports, some 400,000 people work at two Foxconn plants in Shenzhen with most of them from remote Chinese areas. They work on the average 12 hours daily and their monthly salary is estimated between $130-150.


Source: RIA Novosti
Thursday, May 27, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

China, US 'Moving Faster Than EU' On Innovation

Martin Schuurmans, chairman of the newly-formed European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT), says he is "not pessimistic" about Europe's ability to lead on research and innovation. But it needs to speed up if it wants to keep up with global competitors, the EIT chairman told EurActiv in an interview.

According to Dr. Schuurmans, Europe is not in a bad position when it comes to research and innovation.

"If you look at it from the perspective of research and technology in – let's say environment technology and energy – clearly Europe belongs to the leaders in the world. So, we do have a very good starting point."

However, he says Europe is at risk of losing ground in relation to other countries. "Many of our competitors – and you mentioned China and the United Sates – are moving more quickly than we are," Schuurmans warns.

"I am not pessimistic but we need to speed up, speed up, speed up."

According to the Dutchman, who was appointed chairman of the European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) in July 2008, the EIT's modest budget – €309 million up to 2013 – means it is just one of the many tools that Europe will need to respond to the innovation challenge.

"Will there be other contributions? I am sure there will have to be. But I think we can still pull this off."

Knowledge and innovation communities

The EIT's first major decision, taken in December last year, was to launch a set of three innovation clusters, called Knowledge and Innovation Communities (KICs), which will bring together academia and private businesses around the following fields of research:
  • Climate change mitigation and adaptation
  • Sustainable energy
  • Future information and communication society

But Schuurmans says a little patience is required before the KICs start to produce their first results, as private partners are still holding discussions with the EIT on finalising the contracts for this year and beyond.

"The KICs are still very much in the planning process," he says. "They are not yet fully up and running."

One of the keys to success, Schuurmans says, is that KICs are sustained over a long period of time. "In principle, the KICs will be moving forward for a period of 13 years. And innovation - as you know - can be a slow process and so there will be money available for a long period of time. So that is the key."

However, he says there should be results throughout the life duration of the KICs. "What we expect is a business plan that will describe goals for the long term but then there will also be intermediate delivery steps on a yearly basis."

But according to the EIT chairman, entrepreneurship represents the key to the KICs' success. "We have always said that for us, a key driver of the knowledge triangle is entrepreneurship. We believe it is not only the glue but also the driving force that will lead to new business creation."

Private funding crucial

Schuurmans believes it is too early to say whether the EIT will manage to attract private funding, which will be a major benchmark for measuring the success of the Budapest-based institute.

But he said the amount must stand up to comparisons with EU funding for the institute, which stands at a modest €309 million for the next four years. "If it is much, much smaller than that, then you cannot speak about private funding," he warned.

The hunt for money has only just begun, he says, with an EIT foundation set to be launched this autumn to attract private funding. "We are looking at every source of funding possible. There are many organisations in Europe: not only businesses, but also foundations."

Source: EurActiv
Wednesday, May 26, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

North Korea: Obama In A Quandary

By B. Raman

The increasingly adventuristic policies and actions of North Korea and China's reluctance to tame North Korea to oblige President Barack Obama have placed him in a quandary where the US will be damned if it acts against North Korea for sinking the South Korean naval ship Cheonan in March last and will be equally damned if it does not.

Nothing brings out the helpless state of the US under Mr.Obama more dramatically than the reported plea of Mrs. Hillary Clinton, the US Secretary of State, who has just completed a high-profile visit to Beijing for a bilateral strategic dialogue. News agencies have quoted her as saying: "The US and China must work together to fashion an effective response to the sinking of the Cheonan. Maintaining peace on the Korean peninsula is a shared responsibility between the countries."

Ever since Mr.Obama assumed office as the President in January 2009, there has been a weakening of the US will and readiness to act independently in crisis situations -- whether these related to the global economic melt-down or peace and security in regions of vital interest to the US or nuclear proliferation or counter-terrorism. The beneficiaries of Mr.Obama's lack of will to act firmly and independently have been rogue states such as Iran, Pakistan and North Korea.

In foreign policy matters, the US has practically been reduced by Mr.Obama to the position of a dependency of China -- depending on the goodwill and co-operation of China for dealing with these States and for protecting vital US national interests-- whether in the Pacific region or in the Af-Pak area or in the Gulf.

The inability of Mr.Obama to fashion a coherent and deterrent response to the rogue states has further encouraged the nuclear ambitions of Iran and North Korea and strengthened their determination to go ahead with their nuclear projects without having to worry about a robust US response. Both Iran and North Korea have convinced themselves that they don't have to worry about the response of the US so long as they have the support of China.

It is amazing that in less than 18 months, Mr.Obama has reduced the US to the position of a mediocre Pacific power, which has to depend on China for protecting its regional interests. The policy of containing China followed under Mr.George Bush has given way under Mr.Obama to one of pathetically courting China to spare Mr.Obama the dilemma of having to act against the rogue States. Mr.Obama's power-sharing willingness in the Pacific has given China an importance which it had never dreamt of having till 2020.

So long as the rogue States have the confidence that China will not let them down, the US is going to find itself confronted more and more with Cheonan-like situations. North Korea's action in sinking the Cheonan without worrying about the implications dramatically illustrates the contempt that it has for the US power in the region. It is not bothered about condemnation by the UN Security Council or by the likelihood of international sanctions.

Fears of a US determined to act even at the risk of a military confrontation are what kept States such as Iran and North Korea under some control in the past. The disappearance of these fears and the US-encouraged rise of the Chinese influence and role led to the adventuristic naval action by North Korea in March last and could one day lead to an adventuristic Iranian action against Israel.

The fear of the US Pacific Fleet once acted as the deterrent. It no longer does so. The result: The US finds itself with zero options in the Pacific either for acting against North Korea or for enforcing its will in the region as a whole.

B. Raman is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt. of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai, and Associate, Chennai Centre For China Studies. E-mail: seventyone2@gmail.com
Wednesday, May 26, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Stock, Oil Prices Hammered By Korean Tensions, European Debt

Prices fell sharply on Asian and European stock markets Tuesday, as investors worried that the European debt crisis and tensions between North and South Korea could hurt the economy. U.S. stock indexes were down for a while, losing as much as three percent before recovering to end the day with little change.

Worried investors sold euros and sought the perceived safety of dollars, which had the effect of cutting world oil prices more than $2 a barrel at one point in New York trading.

The downturn was partly triggered by reports that North Korean leader Kim Jong Il had put his military on higher alert after South Korea accused the North of sinking a South Korean ship.

The Korean tensions add to worries about Europe's debt problems affecting Greece and other nations. Those concerns grew Monday as the International Monetary Fund urged Spain to make urgent reforms to its labor market and banking sector. Spanish officials had just finished taking over a failing bank.

Europe's problems were discussed by top Chinese and U.S. officials in talks on economic issues in Beijing Tuesday. U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner said Washington and Beijing support Europe's policy reforms and other efforts to cope with the crisis.

Source: VOA
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

US-China Talks Wrap Up In Beijing

By Margaret Besheer

Two days of wide-ranging economic and political talks between the United States and China have wrapped up in Beijing. No major agreements were announced, but both sides said they had candid discussions and reaffirmed their commitment to building a strong and enduring relationship.

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said the U.S.-Chinese relationship recently hit a rough patch over disagreements on Tibet, Taiwan and China's currency. But the two superpowers overcame their differences because their leaders have opened communication through these political and economic talks.

"Earlier this year, our relationship faced uncertainties, and many questioned the direction we were heading. Now, in an earlier era, we might have experienced a lasting set-back," said Clinton. "But this dialogue mechanism and the habits of cooperation it has helped create, along with the confidence it has built help put us rapidly back on a positive track."

Chinese State Councilor Dai Bingguo also mentioned those differences and said it is impossible for the two countries to agree on everything, but there is a determination to have a strong relationship. He is heard here through a translator:

"We believe that the China-U.S. relationship is critical to both countries and the whole world, said Dai Bingguo. "The two sides also believe that to cultivate and deepen China-U.S. strategic mutual trust is important to the advancement of a China-U.S. relationship in the new century," he said.

U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner led the economic track during the Beijing talks. He said differences remain, but the U.S. and China made progress in helping create a more level playing field for American companies operating in and exporting to China.

"China has affirmed its commitment to abide by the principles of non-discrimination; market competition; open trade; intellectual property rights protection; and leaving the terms of technology transfer and production processes to agreements between enterprises," said Geithner.

The two sides also signed several cooperation agreements focusing on customs and border protection, energy resources, nuclear safety, environment and health.

Secretary Clinton stressed that "people-to-people" relationships are just as important as government-to-government ones. At a side event at the National Center for the Performing Arts - which is also known as "the Egg" because of its oval shape - Clinton and State Councilor Liu Yan Dong announced expanded student exchange programs for both countries.

The United States plans to send 100,000 students to China during the next four years to study Mandarin and learn the culture, while China plans to send 10,000 graduate students to America.

Clinton also sat down for a 40-minute television interview with state broadcaster China Central Television, where a studio audience asked her questions ranging from bilateral trade restrictions and the international financial crisis to her daughter Chelsea's upcoming wedding.

From Beijing, Secretary Clinton travels to Seoul for meetings with President Lee Myung-bak to discuss an international response to a North Korean torpedo attack that sank a South Korean warship in March.

Source: VOA
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

ASEAN And SAARC: Intra Regional Trade Forums

By Tuli Sinha for IPCS

This article evaluates ASEAN and SAARC as two pivotal regional platforms for actuating economic cooperation in South and Southeast Asia. A comparative study reveals that despite asymmetrical sizes AFTA has surpassed SAFTA in terms of trade benefits and value addition to the overall regional economic growth. Therefore, it is pertinent to examine AFTA and SAFTA relatively and ascertain reasons for the failure of SAARC and SAFTA in relation to ASEAN’s initiatives. Why has SAARC failed to forge conditions of cooperation on the economic and political fronts? What have been the probable impediments in the growth of SAFTA as compared to AFTA? What can be done to restructure and revive the SAFTA to propel the South Asian economy towards greater economic integration and regional consolidation? What was decided in the 16th SAARC Summit in terms of regional trade cooperation?

The European Union (EU) is spearheading the process of developing inter-regional economic networks among other regional organizations of the world. However, many factors are responsible for the success of ASEAN Free Trade Agreement (AFTA) which realized the logic of an apropos economic group consciousness which completely lacked in SAARC. It is a collective effort by ASEAN member countries to reduce tariffs on intra-ASEAN trade in the goods sector. The primary objective of AFTA is to enhance ASEAN’s position as a competitive production base producing for both regional and global markets. An analysis reveals that the formation of AFTA has led to a remarkable expansion of intra-ASEAN trade since its inception. The statistics so far substantiates the fact that Intra-ASEAN trade has been consistently increasing over the years from US$81.98 billion in 1993. Today, the intra-ASEAN trade incorporates approximately 25 per cent of the total external trade in comparison to merely 2 per cent of the intra-SAARC trade.

Among the countries, Singapore continues to be a major contributor in the intra-regional trade, accounting for 39.5 per cent of the total intra-ASEAN trade, followed by Malaysia (24.2 per cent), Thailand (15.6 per cent), Indonesia (9.5 per cent) and the Philippines (5.7 per cent). Also, the role of great power interventions especially of the US has been vital in determining the fate of AFTA. ASEAN has been an important economic partner for the United States; shared convergent commercial interests are a major driving force for ASEAN and the success of its forums. For the last two years, the cumulative American investment in ASEAN has been greater than the total investments in China, Japan and Korea. ASEAN receives the fifth largest share of US foreign investment and this is rendering a subtle counter to the China block in Asia. Such an external pressure in terms of performance is completely missing in SAARC.

Moreover, despite initial gains, SAFTA has not really achieved much in terms of internal or external trade. It is interesting to observe incessant efforts by the SAARC members, especially India, being the most prosperous, to ameliorate conditions of intra regional trade in South Asia. The robust rise in India’s total imports from SAARC has been underpinned by the sharp increase in imports from Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, and Bangladesh. India generally maintains a positive trade balance with the other SAARC member countries, and the trade surplus has risen from US$2.3 billion to US$5.0 billion until recently. Sri Lanka is again the leading partner, accounting for 31 per cent of India’s total imports from the region, followed by Pakistan (21 per cent), Nepal (20 per cent), Bangladesh (15 per cent) and Bhutan (9 per cent). The region also lacks the impetus to incur the unforeseen costs and investments to initiate any new agenda for economic prosperity unlike ASEAN.

Although SAARC has been working towards enhancing its regional trade, it certainly requires a structural revival. There are several steps that should be incorporated in the working process of SAFTA and SAARC on the whole to improve the conditions of trade. First, SAFTA experiences high trade deficit in terms of its global trade, thus more emphasis could be given to boost exports from the region. Second, SAARC countries are mainly exporting agricultural commodities and agro-based products. With trade being competitive and identical, more diversification of goods is extremely essential. Third, while SAARC countries have effected reduction in tariff levels, it can be reduced even further to increase the benefits of the trade bloc in future. Adequate steps could also be implemented to attract more FDI into the region from other sources. Fourth, the direct relationship between bilateral exports and GDP in the SAARC region reveals the potential for export-led growth in the region. With further opening of the economy, the bilateral exports will also increase. As there is a positive relation between the bilateral trade agreement and bilateral export flows in the SAARC region, the creation of bilateral agreements in the region must be encouraged. Finally, strengthening of economic relations can be used to reinforce improving political relations in the region, for instance, the relationship between India and Pakistan, as economic ties could help improve political relations to a great extent.


Tuli Sinha is a Research Officer for SEARP, IPCS and may be reached at  tuli_sn@yahoo.com. This article was published by IPCS.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

PetroChina Selects Siemens Wet Air Oxidation Technology

Siemens Water Technologies will provide Zimpro wet air oxidation technology to treat wastewater at PetroChina Company Limited’s (PetroChina) Daqing ethylene plant projects in Heilongjiang Province, China.

PetroChina Company Limited is the largest oil and gas producer and distributor in China and one of the largest oil companies in the world. 

The system will be used to treat sulfidic spent caustic wastewater streams generated in the production of ethylene. The energy-efficient wet air oxidation systems will destroy odorous sulfide pollutants and generate a biodegradable effluent that can be discharged to conventional biological wastewater treatment. The Daqing system will treat approximately 22.7 m3/h of wastewater.

Wet oxidation is the oxidation of soluble or suspended components in an aqueous environment using oxygen as the oxidizing agent. When air is used as the source of oxygen, the process is referred to as wet air oxidation (WAO). The process will oxidize odorous reduced sulfur species such as sulfides and mercaptides. The system will also break down complex organic contaminants, such as phenols, to either carbon dioxide and water, or biodegradable organics.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Dr. Manmohan Singh: Illusions Towards Pakistan And Excuses for Non-Action Against Maoists

By B. Raman

The Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh, addressed a press conference on May 24, 2010, to mark the completion of one year of his second tenure as the Prime Minister. Hopes that he will be more forthcoming than he usually is on matters of concern to the people such as the internal security situation and India's relations with Pakistan were belied. He was evasive and avoided going into specifics. This has led to considerable criticism.

It would be unfair to say that Dr. Manmohan Singh has not had achievements to his credit during the six years he has been in office. He has had. The economy has been in good shape without being affected seriously by the global melt-down. Greater attention has been paid to the problems of the common man. India's relations with the US have improved without affecting its relations with Russia. It has maintained its interest in Afghanistan without being deterred by terrorist attacks on the Indian mission in Kabul and without letting itself be forced by the US pressure to reduce its presence in that country to address Pakistani concerns. Frictions over border and security-related issues have not been allowed to come in the way of the developing economic relations with China. Following the Copenhagen summit, the comfort level between India and China has increased. Relations with Sri Lanka have improved and India has played a quiet role in ensuring the defeat of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) by the Sri Lankan Government without losing sight of the interests of the Tamils. Relations with Bangladesh are in a better shape than before with greater attention to India's security concerns by the Government in Dhaka. Despite misunderstanding with the Maoists of Nepal, India has not lost the goodwill of the political class in Nepal. The low-profile relations with Myanmar have served India's security interests. Relations with Bhutan, the Maldives, the ASEAN countries and Japan continue to improve. While maintaining its interest in the countries to the East of India, India has been paying more attention to the countries to the West of India. The Look East policy has been supplemented by a much-needed Look West policy. India has been playing an important role in multilateral institutions and mechanisms -- whether in matters relating to the economy or regional security. India is accepted as a benign regional power though there is continuing skepticism over its capability to play the role of a global power on par with China.

Lack of public enthusiasm over his policies have been confined to his handling of Pakistan's use of terrorism against India and the increase in the activities of the Maoists, who pose a challenge to the political stability and internal security of India. His desire for better relations with Pakistan in spite of its continuing use of terrorism against India to achieve a change in the status quo in Jammu & Kashmir and to keep India weak came out clearly at the press conference. No one can question his interest in keeping the dialogue going with Pakistan in the hope of one day persuading the Pakistani leadership to realise the folly of using terrorism to serve its national agenda. What one finds disturbing is his tendency to romanticise India's relation with Pakistan and his ill-conceived assertion that India's emergence as a major power depended on better relations with Pakistan.

His remarks linking India's future as a major power with an improvement in its relations with Pakistan are likely to be misinterpreted in Islamabad as indicating that its use of terrorism against India has started paying dividends. There will be more and not less terrorism as a result of Dr. Manmohan Singh's penchant for softness towards Pakistan. Ever since he took over as the Prime Minister in 2004, one has not come across a single statement of his indicating in clear terms what India can do and what it will not do to improve relations with Pakistan.

There has been an unfortunate impression in Pakistan that Dr. Manmohan Singh does not attach the same seriousness to Pakistan's use of terrorism against India as large sections of our public and political class do. As a result of Dr. Manmohan Singh's perceived softness towards Pakistan and his disinclination to use the stick against Pakistan, there is an impression in Pakistan's military and intelligence circles that Dr. Manmohan Singh lacks the will and the desire to be tough with Pakistan and , hence, they can do anything against India and get away with it so long as he is the Prime Minister.

Unless this impression is corrected through a clear enunciation of our policy, we are not going to have any respite from Pakistan-sponsored terrorism. India has suffered two acts of mass casualty terrorism emanating from Pakistan during the tenure of Dr. Manmohan Singh---- the July 2006 attack on suburban trains in Mumbai and the 26/11 attacks in Mumbai--- and more are likely so long as our Prime Minister does not act to remove this impression of Pakistan.

Unwilling to strike and hesitant to wound Pakistan. Repeated expressions of goodwill towards Pakistan seem to be more important to him than assurances to his own people that he will not tolerate any more act of mass casualty terrorism against his people from Pakistan.

This is not an argument against talks with Pakistan. This is an argument to hold our feet firmly to the ground while talking to Pakistan and to avoid talks based on illusions. This is an argument to underline that Dr. Manmohan Singh, as the Prime Minister, has an important responsibility to protect the lives and property of his people from acts of terrorism sponsored by Pakistan. The exercise of this responsibility should have greater priority over any goodwill for Pakistan.

His conviction that India's rise as a major power depends on better relations with Pakistan is not totally correct. Better relations with Pakistan will definitely help, but the absence of it will not mean the end of the world for India. We have reached where we are today despite our bad relations with Pakistan and we can continue to keep moving forward even if there is no significant improvement in the bilateral relations. Talk to Pakistan, but avoid the defeatist impression that talking to Pakistan is the only salvation for India. It is not.

His remarks on the Maoist challenge brought out clearly the bureaucrat-turned-politician in him and not the statesman. The realisation that the Maoist problem is no longer a localised regional problem was missing in his remarks. It has become a political and humanitarian challenge and a security problem with pan-Indian dimensions that has to be dealt with at a pan-Indian level. A pan-Indian response to this challenge has to come from New Delhi and the Prime Minister has to play the leadership role in the search for such a response.

Instead of admitting his responsibility and expressing his determination to exercise that responsibility, he sought to pass the buck on to the States by projecting it as still in the stage of a localised, regional problem which has to be handled by the affected States to the best of their ability with the required assistance from the Govt. of India.

His remarks on relations with Pakistan and on the Maoist issue do not bode well for our success in dealing with these two challenges to our national security in an effective manner.

B. Raman is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt. of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai, and Associate, Chennai Centre For China Studies. E-mail: seventyone2@gmail.com
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Strategic And Economic Dialogue Opening Session In Beijing

Hillary Rodham Clinton, US Secretary of State; President Hu Jintao; Vice-Premier Wang Qishan; Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner; State Councilor Dai - Great Hall of the People, Beijing, China, May 23, 2010

VICE-PREMIER WANG: (Via translator) Secretary Clinton, Secretary Geithner, dear colleagues, today marks the opening of the second round of the China-U.S. strategic and economic dialogues. As the special representatives of President Hu Jintao, State Councilor Dai Bingguo and I wish to extend a warm welcome to President Obama's special representatives, Secretary Clinton and Secretary Geithner, and to all members of the U.S. delegation.

(Applause.)

VICE-PREMIER WANG: (Via translator) Both our presidents attach great importance to this round of the S&ED. President Hu Jintao will join us and deliver an important address. We will also hear an important message from President Obama.

To build a positive, cooperative, and comprehensive China-U.S. relationship for the 21st century it is important agreement is reached between our two presidents that represents the common desire by our two peoples and constitutes the core objectives of the S&ED.

Based on this agreement, the first round of the S&ED was successfully held in Washington, D.C. last year. It has played a positive role in enhancing our cooperation in various fields, facilitating our joint response to the international financial crisis, and promoting world economic recovery -- the global governance structure.

The current round of the S&ED will cover a broad range of issues, giving full expression to the overarching strategic and long-term nature of our dialogue. Under the theme of ensuring the continuation of a mutually beneficial economic partnership, our two sides will have in-depth discussions in economic dialogue on a number of major issues, including macro economic policies, trade and investment, financial market stability, and reformed international financial architecture.

This will enable us to further our cooperation to solidify the positive trend of our two economies, and promote strong, sustainable, and balanced growth of the global economy. China-U.S. economic ties are a major cornerstone of our overall relationship. As China presses ahead with reform and opening up, China-U.S. economic trade and financial cooperation has enjoyed a dynamic growth. With increasingly close links, our two economies have become inseparable. This has been particularly true since the outbreak of the international financial crisis, when our two countries have been acting together to (inaudible) over the difficulties. What has happened shows that a high economic complementarily can only make China and the United States partners for a win-win cooperation, not rivals in a zero-sum game. So long as the two sides engage in candid communications, (inaudible) common ground, while resolving differences, we will prevail over any difficulty that may lie ahead.

The world economy is now at a critical juncture for further recovery, and the situation remains highly complex. Both China and the United States are faced with many challenges and deep-seated problems. I am confident that, through the common ground of the S&ED, we will expand common ground, narrow differences, and work to push forward the sound and steady growth of China-U.S. relations.

I wish the second round of the S&ED a great success. Thank you.

(Applause.)

SECRETARY CLINTON: Good morning. I want to thank State Councilor Dai and Vice-Premier Wang for their very warm hospitality. It is a pleasure for our entire delegation to be here in Beijing. And it is an honor to join my colleague, Secretary Geithner, and the many officials from across our government in representing the United States at this second round of the strategic and economic dialogue.

I first visited China in 1995, and I have been privileged to return since then. Every trip to China offers fresh insights and images of the dynamism of this country and its people, the pace of change, and the possibilities for the future. Back in 1995, trade between our two nations was measured in the tens of billions of dollars. Today it is counted in the hundreds of billions. Few people back then had cell phones, and almost no one had access to the Internet. Today China has the world's largest mobile phone network, and more Internet users than any other country on earth.

In 1995, both our countries signed on to the Beijing platform for action to advance equality and opportunity for women. And while there is still much to do in both of our countries, I know that Chinese women have made real progress in education, health care, and employment. Hundreds of millions of men, women, and children have been lifted out of poverty. And China has flourished in so many ways. Freer trade and open markets have created jobs in both our countries, and given Chinese consumers access to new goods and to higher standards of living.

The United States welcomes China's progress and its accomplishments. And by establishing patterns of cooperation, rather than competition between our two countries, we see the opportunity, as we have just heard from Vice-Premier Wang, for win-win solutions, rather than zero-sum rivalries, for we know that few global problems can be solved by the United States or China acting alone. And few can be solved without the United States and China working together.

With this in mind, I would like to read a few lines of a letter from President Obama that I will be personally handing to President Hu Jintao. President Obama wrote: "Our relationship with China is guided by the recognition that we live in an inter-connected world. One country's success need not come at the expense of another. Our progress can be shared. Indeed, the United States welcomes China as a strong, prosperous, and successful member of the community of nations."

Over the past 16 months, we have worked together to lay the foundation for that positive, cooperative, and comprehensive relationship that President Obama and President Hu have committed our nations to pursuing. We launched the strategic and economic dialogue last year in Washington, as the premier convening mechanism in our relationship. And this year we have assembled an even broader and deeper team, here in China, to address our growing agenda. We have built avenues of cooperation and identified areas of mutual interest.

Our job, moving forward, is to translate that common interest into common action and, in turn, to translate that action into results that improve the lives of our people, and contribute to global progress. Over the long term, these results are how our relationship will be measured.

We are conscious that meaningful progress against great global challenges is the work of years, not days. We know that this gathering, in and of itself, is a foundation for ongoing cooperation that has to take place every day at every level of our government. And so, we will blend urgency and persistence in pursuit of shared goals.

We have already begun to see progress on some of the key areas of common concern that we laid out in our first dialogue last year. But there is much work to be done.

First, on international security challenges, the United States and China have consulted closely on the challenge posed by Iran's nuclear program. The prospect of a nuclear-armed Iran concerns us all. And to address that threat, together we have pursued a dual-track approach of engagement and pressure, aimed at encouraging Iran's leaders to change course. The draft resolution agreed to by all of our P-5+1 partners and circulated at the Security Council sends a clear message to the Iranian leadership: Live up to your obligation, or face growing isolation and consequences. As we continue to cooperate in New York, the burden is on Iran to demonstrate through its actions that it will uphold its responsibility.

North Korea is also a matter of urgent concern. Last year we worked together to pass and enforce a strong UN Security Council resolution in the wake of North Korea's nuclear test. And today we face another serious challenge, provoked by the sinking of the South Korean ship. So we must work together, again, to address this challenge and advance our shared objectives for peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula. We asked North Korea to stop its provocative behavior, halt its policy of threats and belligerence towards its neighbors, and take irreversible steps to fulfill its denuclearization commitments, and comply with international law.

Now, beyond these two pressing challenges there are other shared security concerns that I look forward to discussing, including the fight against violent extremism in Afghanistan and Pakistan, counter-piracy efforts, and deeper military-to-military cooperation.

Second, on climate and energy, we have built on the memorandum of understanding signed at the last round of the dialogues, collaborating on new, clean energy research, including a center. We have committed ourselves to an electrical vehicle initiative, and a renewable energy partnership, and more. At Copenhagen, for the first time, all major economies, including both the United States and China, made national commitments to curb carbon emissions and transparently report on their mitigation efforts. Now we must work to implement the Copenhagen accord with balanced commitments that are reflected in the ongoing negotiation.

And on behalf of Secretary Steven Chu, I extend his regrets. He was unable to be with us, because he had to stay and work very urgently on the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico.

Third, on education, health, and development, tomorrow I will meet with State Councilor Lio to launch a new dialogue on educational and cultural exchanges that will deepen understanding and cooperation between our people. I am very pleased that Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius has joined us this year to expand cooperation on infectious diseases and other international health challenges. Our ambassador for global women's issues, Melanne Verveer, is also here because we recognize that the roles and rights of women are central to many of the issues we face, including devising a global strategy for development that is both sustainable and effective.

The Obama Administration has worked to advance a long-term investment-driven approach to development. And Administrator Raj Shah is leading our efforts. We have elevated development as a core pillar of our foreign policy, and we seek to coordinate with China and other donors to meet country-led needs and to comply with internationally-agreed standards.

Finally, we have worked together and seen progress on promoting global economic recovery and growth. Secretary Geithner, Secretary Locke, Ambassador Kirk, Chairman Bernanke, and the rest of our economic team will be talking in greater depth about how we can develop a more balanced global economy that will produce prosperity that reaches further and deeper for both the Chinese and American people.

Now, our discussions in these few days are unlikely to solve the shared challenges we face. But they can and should provide a framework for delivering real results to our people. We will not agree on every issue. But we will discuss them openly, as between friends and partners. And that includes America's commitment to universal human rights and dignity, and so much else that is on both Chinese and American minds.

There is a Chinese proverb that speaks of treading different paths that lead to the same destination. Our two nations have unique histories. China is home to an ancient civilization, as I saw in the Chinese Pavilion when I visited, with the scroll that has been made to come alive, showing life in this city 1,000 years ago. America is a young nation. But we know that our future, both our challenges and our opportunities, will be shared. We have traveled different paths, but that shared future is our common destination and responsibility. And, ultimately, that is what this dialogue is about.

So, again, let me thank State Councilor Dai and Vice-Premier Wang, and I look forward to our discussions in an open and candid exchange of views. Thank you very much.

(Applause.)

STATE COUNCILOR DAI: (Via translator) Secretary Clinton, Secretary Geithner, Vice-Premier Wang Qishan, ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, good morning. In this blooming and enchanting month of May, I feel truly pleased to get together with Vice-Premier Wang Qishan, Secretary Clinton, and Secretary Geithner in Beijing to co-chair the second round of the China-U.S. strategic and economic dialogues. And I look forward to joining you for the address of President Hu Jintao, who will soon be with us in the opening session, and for the message from President Obama.

So many Chinese and American friends that care for and are devoted to the world of China-U.S. relations have gathered today for candid and in-depth dialogues on strategic, long-term, and over-arching issues in China-U.S. relations. I believe this is, in itself, a pioneering undertaking in state-to-state relations.

I warmly welcome our American friends, especially those who have never been to China before. I hope you will feel at home, and even better than your life at home.

I recall that last year, when the world was haunted by the international financial crisis, President Hu Jintao and President Obama (inaudible) of the prospects of the 21st century, agreed to build a positive, cooperative, and a comprehensive China-U.S. relationship for the 21st century, and the partnership to cope with common challenges. They decided to take a major strategic step by setting up the mechanisms of the China-U.S. strategic and economic dialogues. In so doing, they sent a (inaudible) signal to the world that China and the United States would join hands to (inaudible) difficulties and work together for better future of China-U.S. relations and the world at large.

One year later, as we gather again and look at the world around us, I believe we all view more keenly that we are now at a crucial historical juncture in the development of mankind and China-U.S. relations. Our two countries not only need to answer the question of whether we can build a new type of relationship between major countries in the 21st century, but also face a strategic choice as to what kind of a century China and the United States, together with other countries, will leave to our peoples, to our children, and our children's children.

The last century the people of our generation have come through has witnessed a lot of progress made by mankind. It was still a century in which the zero-sum rule prevailed, and lines were drawn along ideologies. It was a century far from being tranquil. It was characterized by incessant confrontation between (inaudible) and cold wars. It was accentuated by disasters and diversities.

But what has happened has lingered on to the 21st century. Through problems old and new are intertwined, (inaudible) changes have taken place in our world. What sets this century apart from the previous one is that countries are becoming increasingly inter-dependent and their interests are, more than ever, inter-connected. Like it or not, we residents of earth have, in fact, become inseparable from one another. Be it in good times or bad times, we are bound together by common interests and have a common destiny to share.

We are faced in such a world with a rising multitude of global issues, with common challenges that no individual country or handful of countries can tackle alone. And with significant and thorny issues concerning the sustainable development of mankind, regardless of a difference in social systems and cultural traditions and (inaudible), no country -- no major country in particular should (inaudible) things that have become outdated.

We have to let suspicion, confrontation, and war give way to communication, cooperation, and the pursuit of peace. We have to learn to respect each other, conduct cooperation under equal footing, make concerted efforts (inaudible) harmonious coexistence. This is our only choice. We are convinced that, in this 21st century, neither the Chinese and American peoples, nor people of other countries, will allow history to repeat itself, or the cause of development to backpedal. No attempt to stir up confrontation (inaudible) war, be it a hot war, a cold war, or even a warm war will be popular in today's world. Nor will such an attempt lead to anywhere.

China and the United States, being the biggest developing and developed country in the world, should have its (inaudible) judgment of the development trend of our world, and go along with the tide of history. We should remove (inaudible) disruption and unswervingly follow the direction charted by our two presidents to do a positive, cooperative, and comprehensive China-U.S. partnership for the 21st century.

In this era of globalization, we should foster a new type of relations among major countries, characterized by mutual respect, harmonious coexistence, and win-win cooperation of countries with different social systems, cultural traditions, and development stages. This will contribute to the sustained and common development, and the prosperity of our two countries, and serve the interest of our two peoples and the people around the world.

We do not believe that world affairs should be determined by one or two individual countries. Yet, should China and the United States not be able to build and development such a new type of relation, the chance for peace will be seriously undermined in the 21st century. To build a new type of China-U.S. partnership will, without doubt, be a (inaudible) and a pioneering undertaking. (Inaudible) plain sailing or trouble free. But past experience has proven that this is the path that we must take, and it will lead us to success.

Looking back decades ago, who could have imagined that leaders of the elder generation in China and America could have that handshake that (inaudible) in the world? Who could have imagined that China-U.S. relations could witness such huge comprehensive and profound developments, only 31 years after the establishment of diplomatic relations? Who could have imagined that China and the United States, two major countries with different social systems, could join hands to tackle the (inaudible) their international financial crisis?

Along this line, we can well foresee that in the 21st century the statesmen and people of our two countries will have sufficient will, wisdom, and capacity to overcome all difficulties and to break new ground in establishing a new type of partnership between our two countries.

You may have watched a movie called Babel. It is an American movie. (Inaudible) and trust of utmost importance in the new century. I believe that it also applies to state-to-state relations. I believe that the strategic and economic dialogue should be an important and effective bridge in promoting communication, understanding, and trust between China and the United States, and should contribute to the beauty of a positive, cooperative, and a comprehensive China-U.S. partnership. This should be the unique function and value of our dialogue mechanism. And it is what our leaders and people expect of us.

I am ready to work with my Chinese and America colleagues to live up to that expectation, and to our common mission. Thank you.

(Applause.)

MODERATOR: (Via translator) Now let us welcome Secretary Geithner to speak.

(Applause.)

SECRETARY GEITHNER: Vice-premier Wang and Councilor Dai, I want to thank you for the respect and the courtesy you have shown us on this visit to Beijing.

Since last April, when President Hu and President Obama launched this new chapter in our relationship, we have worked very hard to build a stronger partnership. When we approach our relationship in the spirit of cooperation and mutual respect for our core interests, with determination at the highest levels to overcome differences, we have had great success, from leading the global response to the financial crisis, to forging a global accord on climate in Copenhagen, to charting a common response to the challenge to international security posed by Iran.

Our common interests lie in a stronger and more resilient world economy, where growth is more balanced, both within and among nations. As we reform the U.S. economy to promote savings and investment, China is reforming its growth model to promote domestic demand and consumption.

Our common interests lie in building a more stable global financial system, one less prone to crisis. The United States and China are working to build financial systems that channel resources more efficiently to support investment and innovation that is critical to future economic growth. And the United States Senate last week passed sweeping reforms of the financial system of the United States to provide better protection for consumers and investors, and better prevention against future crises.

Our common interests lie in supporting a more open global trading system, with a fair balance of benefits and responsibilities in which countries are able to compete on a level playing field. Our two countries have benefited greatly from open trade and investment, and we welcome a more open China today. Innovation holds the key to a more prosperous future. But innovation flourishes best when markets are open, competition is fair, and strong protections exist for ideas and for inventions.

Our common interests lie in building a stronger global framework for cooperation in the group of 20 and in the international financial institutions. We will continue to work closely together to equip these institutions with the right tools and the right governance structure to confront global challenges like climate change, development, and future financial risks.

The world economy is now coming out of crisis. Economic growth in the U.S. and China is broader and stronger than many had anticipated even a few months ago. And even with the challenges of reform and growth facing some of the nations of Europe, we are together, the United States and China, along with India, Brazil, and the emerging economies of Asia and other regions, in a much stronger position today to overcome the challenges ahead.

Now, we are two different countries with very different political systems, different traditions, different views about the role of government in society and in the economy, different views about the relationship between the individual and the government. We each have our various challenges and our many strengths, and our strengths are complementary.

We welcome this opportunity to work closely with Vice-Premier Wang and with Councilor Dai and with their colleagues, to pursue our common interests and to seek solutions to these challenges. We approach these issues in a spirit of mutual respect for the traditions, values, and interests of the United States and China. Our approach reflects the insight in the Chinese saying, (speaks Chinese). When we work together in the face of adversity, our people are better off, and the world is better off. We are stronger together. Thank you.

(Applause.)

MODERATOR: (Via translator) Ladies and gentlemen, I would like to ask you to kindly rise to welcome President Hu Jintao of the People's Republic of China.

(Applause.)

PRESIDENT HU: (Via translator) Secretary Clinton, Secretary Geithner, distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, the second round of the China-U.S. strategic and economic dialogues opens in Beijing today. Let me, first of all, extend a warm welcome to our American friends coming from afar.

The second round of the S&ED takes place at an important moment, when new developments are unfolding in the international, political, and economic landscape, and when China and the United States face new opportunities to further the bilateral relationship. It is of great significance for both of our two countries to achieve positive outcomes at this round of dialogues. I hope that, through a candid and in-depth discussion on over-arching strategic and long-term issues of mutual interest, the two sides will (inaudible) and further push forward China-U.S. cooperation.

Ladies and gentlemen, over one year ago, President Obama and I met the first time in London. We agreed to work together to build a positive, cooperative, and comprehensive China-U.S. relationship for the 21st century, setting up the goal for the development of China-U.S. relations in the new year. Since then, President Obama and I have met on many occasions. During President Obama's successful visit to China last November in particular, the two sides issued a China-U.S. joint statement offering a policy framework for the development of our bilateral ties.

In a spirit of solidarity, China and the United States have worked together to counter the extremely severe international financial crisis. We have coordinated macro economic policies, and facilitated efforts to bring about positive outcomes at the G20 financial summit, making important contributions to world economic recovery.

We have furthered our economic and trade ties, and stepped up mutually-beneficial cooperation in new and clean energy, energy conservation, emissions reduction, and energy efficiency enhancement to solidify the foundation of our exchanges.

China and the United States have maintained communication and coordination on major regional and international issues. We have worked with other parties to properly address regional hot spot issues. The two countries have also worked with other parties to manage the growing number of global issues, and played a positive role in putting up an international response to such challenges as climate change, proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, and natural disasters.

Admittedly, China and the United States differ in national condition, and it is only natural that the two sides may disagree on some issues. What is important is to respect and accommodate each others' core interests and major concerns, appropriately handle the sensitive issues, and strengthen the foundation of mutual trust.

Ladies and gentlemen, the world is in the midst of major developments, major changes, and major adjustments. The trend toward (inaudible) and economic globalization is gathering momentum. The impact of the international financial crisis continues to be felt. Global issues are becoming more pronounced, and regional and international hot spot issues keep cropping up.

To further advance mankind's noble cause of peace and development requires greater cooperation among people of all countries. As permanent members of the UN Security Council, and the largest developing country and the largest developed country, China and the United States face common tasks and shoulder important responsibilities, ranging from promoting full recovery and sustainable growth of the world economy, to the managing of regional hot spots, meeting global challenges, and safeguarding world peace and security.

China attaches great importance to its relations with the United States. To develop long-term, sound, and steady China-U.S. relationship is a shared desire of our two peoples (inaudible) and contribute to peace, stability, and prosperity in the Asia Pacific Region and beyond.

We need to stick to the right direction of China-U.S. relations. No matter how the international situation may evolve, and what difficulties and interferences we may encounter, we should always follow the strategic and long-term perspective, and speak to and safeguard the goal of working together to build a positive, cooperative, and comprehensive China-U.S. relationship for the 21st century. We should foster strategic mutual trust, strengthen strategic cooperation, appropriately handle differences, and step up communication, coordination, and cooperation on bilateral, regional, and global issues.

We should respect each other's core interests and major concerns. Sovereignty, independence (inaudible) integrity are a country's most basic rights, recognized by the norms governing international relations. To the Chinese people, nothing is more important than safeguarding national sovereignty and territorial integrity. I trust that it's not difficult for the American people, who went through the American Civil War in their history to understand how important and valuable unity is to a nation.

We should respect the right of each and every country to independently choose its development path. We should recognize differences in countries' cultural traditions, social systems, values, and development concepts, and encourage different civilizations and development models to learn from and reinforce each other, so as to achieve common development. It is not advisable to use one model to measure the diverse and colorful world we live in.

We should maintain close interaction at the top and other levels. Full communication is an important basis for enhanced cooperation. Not even the most sophisticated telecommunication technology can replace face-to-face exchanges. In my meeting with President Obama in Washington on 12 May this year, we both agreed to stay in close touch through meetings, phone calls, and correspondence. We should also step up strategic dialogues and consultations to deepen understanding, expand common ground, and promote cooperation.

We should develop a pattern of mutually beneficial and win-win cooperation. China and the United States should step up macro economic policy coordination, and promote sustained world economic recovery. The two sides should increase exchanges in cooperation in such areas as economy and trade, energy, the environment, counterterrorism, non-proliferation, law enforcement, science and technology, education, agriculture, health, and quality inspections, and actively develop cooperation in such new areas as civil aviation, high-speed railway, infrastructure construction, and space exploration. In this way, we will lend fresh impetus to the growth of China-U.S. relations, and enable our peoples to reap tangible benefits of China-U.S. cooperation.

We should strengthen coordination on regional hot spots and global issues. China and the United States should step up communication and coordination on regional hot spot issues through bilateral channels and multilateral mechanisms. The two sides should increase (inaudible) and cooperation on such global issues as climate change, nuclear security, energy security, food security, disaster reduction, and (inaudible) fighting trans-national crimes, and prevention and control of serious communicable diseases. China and the United States should work with the rest of the international community to make the international system more just and equitable.

We should deepen mutual understanding and friendship between our peoples. This provides an enduring driving force and broad foundation for the growth of state-to-state relations. China and the United States will establish a mechanism of people-to-people exchange. I believe this mechanism will contribute to the cultural, scientific, technological, and educational exchanges and cooperation between our two countries. The two sides should support youth exchanges so that the cause of China-U.S. relations will be carried forward by the younger generation. We should also scale up exchanges and cooperation between the business, academic, and media communities, and between local authorities and institutions to build a broad bridge of friendship between our two people.

Ladies and gentlemen, since the founding of the People's Republic of China over 60 years ago, and particularly (inaudible) opening up, earth-shaking changes have taken place in China. Yet we are keenly aware that China remains the world's largest developing country. We still have a very long way to go before we can fully build a moderately prosperous society of a higher level that will benefit over one billion people, and achieve basic modernization to bring common prosperity to all our people.

We will continue to pursue reform and opening up so that our economy will register greater growth, our democracy will be further enhanced, our science and education will make bigger strides, our culture will get more prosperous, our society will become more harmonious, and our peoples' lives will be better off. China will continue to pursue a win-win strategy of opening up. We will expand market access in keeping with established international, economic, and trading laws, support the improvement of the international trading and financial system, and advance trade investment, liberalization, and facilitation.

China will accelerate the transformation of its economic development pattern. We will make great effort to expand domestic demand and increase household consumption, vigorously promote sound and balanced growth of external trade, and reject protectionism in all manifestations. China will continue to steadily advance the reform of the formation mechanism of the RMB exchange rate under the principle of independent decision-making, controllability and gradual progress.

China will remain committed to the path of peaceful development and pursue friendly cooperation with all countries on the basis of the five principles of peaceful coexistence. We will not interfere in other countries' internal affairs, or impose our own will on others. We will work with all other countries to build a harmonious world of enduring peace and common prosperity.

Ladies and gentlemen, to build a positive, cooperative, and comprehensive China-U.S. relationship for the 21st century is in the fundamental interest of our two countries and two peoples. It also meets the need to promote world peace and development. Let us work together to open up even broader prospects for China-U.S. relations.

(Applause.)
Monday, May 24, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Clinton: US Support For South Korea 'Unequivocal'

By Margaret Besheer

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton says the United States fully supports the measures South Korean President Lee Myung-bak's has announced in response to a North Korean attack on one of the south's warships. Speaking in the Chinese capital Monday, Clinton said if the evidence warrants, the United States could put Pyongyang back on its list of states that sponsor terrorism.

Secretary Clinton says Washington and Seoul are in close consultation on the situation. Echoing a White House statement, she says the steps President Lee took were "prudent and entirely appropriate."

President Lee announced Monday his country would sever most trade ties with the North and bar its ships from its waters. He also said South Korea would seek to get the issue raised at the United Nations Security Council, where Pyongyang could face new sanctions.

Secretary Clinton says the U.S. firmly supports those moves.

"First, we endorse President Lee's call on North Korea to come forward with the facts regarding this act of aggression and, above all, stop its belligerence and threatening behavior," said Clinton. "Second, our support for South Korea's defense is unequivocal, and President Obama has directed his military commanders to coordinate closely with their Korean counterparts to ensure readiness and to deter future aggression."

She says the United States and South Korea will explore further enhancements to its joint military posture on the Korean Peninsula.

Additionally, she says that President Barack Obama directed U.S. government agencies to review their existing authorities and policies related to North Korea, to ensure that they have "adequate measures in place," and to identify areas where adjustments would be appropriate.

When asked by a reporter if that included possibly re-designating North Korea as a state sponsor of terrorism, she said the United States will "apply the law as the facts warrant."

"If the evidence warrants, the Department of State will take action," she said.

Secretary Clinton was speaking in the margins of high-level political and economic talks between the United States and China. China has come under some criticism because it has been slow to respond to the attack on South Korea and has not publicly accepted that the North is to blame.

Clinton says that she having very intensive consultations with the Chinese government on the issue, but will not discuss the details of those discussions. She did say that Beijing recognizes "the gravity of the situation" and understands South Korea's reaction. She added that the situation is highly precarious and the United States is working hard to avoid an escalation of belligerence and provocation.

An international investigation determined last week that a torpedo fired from a North Korean submarine sank the South Korean warship last March, killing 46 sailors.

Source: VOA
Monday, May 24, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

CNPC Buys 35% interest In Syria Shell Petroleum Development

Shell and the China National Petroleum Corporation (CNPC) concluded earlier this week an agreement under which CNPC has acquired a 35% interest in Syria Shell Petroleum Development (SSPD), currently 100% owned by Shell. SSPD has interests in three production licences including Deir-Ez-Zor, Fourth Annex and Ash Sham that are operated by the Al Furat Petroleum Company (AFPC) (Shell interest 31.25%).

The agreement strengthens the partnership between Shell and CNPC. Both parties will look to continue growing and investing in attractive opportunities in Syria’s upstream industry.

The licences cover some 40 oil fields, production in 2009 was 23 thousand boe/d (Shell share). Shell has a long history in Syria. It has had a presence in the country since the 1940s and been a shareholder in AFPC for some 25 years.

CNPC already has an interest in the production licences and in AFPC through its 50% ownership of Himalaya Energy Syria BV.
Sunday, May 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Trade Dependence, Economic-Political Vulnerability Vary Among BRIC

By Markus Jaeger, analyst for Deutsche Bank Research


Trade openness benefits economies in terms of medium-term economic growth and wealth generation, even if, admittedly, the empirical evidence on this score is somewhat mixed; it also benefits less advanced economies relatively more than advanced ones. On the flipside, greater trade openness exposes economies to greater economic volatility and potentially resulting social instability. More open, less advanced economies are typically more sensitive than less open, more advanced economies. Due to the greater opportunity costs of trade closure and protectionism, it also renders the former more vulnerable to protectionist threats, especially by the latter.

In terms of trade openness, China and Russia are more exposed to international trade than Brazil and India. In terms of social stability, China and India are, ceteris paribus, more exposed than Brazil and Russia. Lower per capita incomes and the relatively greater labour intensity of their exports tend to magnify the impact of trade shocks on social stability. In this very simple framework, China would be the most, and Brazil the least vulnerable BRIC economy – the latter’s non-negligible dependence on volatile commodity exports notwithstanding. This may appear somewhat counter-intuitive given China’s recent economic performance, but one must not forget that economic growth did slow down dramatically in the last quarter of 2008 before the authorities launched a massive stimulus programme.

Greater openness in China and Russia also translates into higher “opportunity costs” of trade closure, and thus a higher susceptibility to protectionist threats, especially from large, less open, developed countries. This susceptibility, however, is mitigated or enhanced by a country’s trade structure. For instance, Russia is less susceptible due to the EU’s dependence on Russian energy imports, while China’s significant dependence on commodity imports increases its susceptibility. While both China and Russia are significant net importers of agro-products, China’s dependence on fuel and mining imports is very substantial. More arguably, China’s export profile does not give it a great deal of leverage vis-a-vis other countries, while the geo-graphic concentration – almost 40% of exports go to the US and the EU alone – render it more vulnerable, not least because the EU and the US are significantly less dependent on Chinese imports than China is on exports to the EU and the US. Export processing trade notwithstanding, China is the country most vulnerable among the BRIC countries to trade disruptions (or the threat thereof) on account of trade openness, its labour-intensive export sector and its trade structure.

China’s potential vulnerability is further enhanced by the fact that it, like Russia but unlike Brazil and India, has a more “complicated” relationship with its main trading partners (esp. the US). For now, Beijing and Washington are neither “strategic partners” nor “strategic competitors”. Beijing is therefore mindful as regards the potential risks stemming from foreign trade protectionism and commodity dependence. The sense of potential vulnerability is compounded by China’s pursuit of a commodity- and energy-intensive investment- and export-led growth strategy that is highly dependent on commodity imports. Manifest concerns about potential social instability in the event of a trade (disruption) induced economic slowdown will further exacerbate this vulnerability in the eyes of the Chinese government.

aBeijing’s significant financial resources may help mitigate somewhat its concerns about economic security, including vis-à-vis Washington. Not surprisingly, however, Beijing is seeking to mitigate commodity supply risk by establishing long-term supply relationships (e.g. loan-oil deals with Brazil and Russia), by supporting the acquisition of natural resource assets by domestic companies (e.g. “going global”) and, more generally, by fostering friendly diplomatic relations with commodity-rich countries (e.g. Africa, Asia). The recent wrangling over iron ore prices and foreign opposition to the acquisition of natural resource assets by Chinese companies will have done nothing to alleviate Beijing’s concerns about economic security. Beijing is fully aware that if push ever came to shove (e.g. Taiwan), China’s trade dependence would be an important source of economic, political and strategic vulnerability, especially vis-à-vis advanced, relatively closed economies (read: the US).

All said, China is the BRIC economy that benefits the most from international trade; but it is also the one most vulnerable in terms of trade protectionism and access to strategically important commodities, its strong international financial position notwithstanding. More so than any other BRIC country, China has an interest in fostering free trade and opposing protectionism. At the same time, Beijing also faces far greater incentives to mitigate and pro-actively manage its trade dependence, especially as regards access to strategically vital natural resources. Maintaining an open trading system and creating a level playing field as regards foreign direct investment will remain a central plank of Chinese economic diplomacy.
Sunday, May 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

North Korea Public Kept In Dark Regarding Escalating Tensions

The North Korean public appears unaware of escalating international tensions surrounding a new report that blames Pyongyang for the sinking of a South Korean warship, according to residents of North Korea interviewed by telephone.

Ordinary North Koreans are oblivious to the threats of “extreme measures, including all-out war” made by North Korean authorities, including the National Defense Commission (NDC), in response to the May 20 report issued by the South Korean government.

The United Nations announced Friday it will convene a special committee to review the investigation accusing North Korea of attacking the South Korean patrol ship Cheonan.

According to a North Korean resident of Northern Hamgyong province, contacted by telephone, “even border guards are leisurely walking around villages,” apparently ignorant of the heightened inter-Korean tension.

“When was such a statement released? I haven’t heard about it yet,” said the North Korean, who asked not to be named, when asked his opinion about the remarks made by the NDC spokesman.

“Here [in North Korea], TV broadcasting begins at 5 p.m., so probably we’ll hear something around that time, but the power may just go out, and in that case, we won’t be able to watch TV or hear anything about it,” he said.

Unusual strategy

North Korean authorities declare a state of emergency each year when the U.S. and South Korea conduct joint military exercises.

The apparent lack of public awareness in North Korea following the Cheonan incident is strangely irregular, residents said, and may indicate that Pyongyang is trying to downplay the severity of the situation inside the country.

According to a resident of Hyesan city in North Korea’s Yangang province, in similar situations in the past authorities have prepared the public for a nationwide broadcast.

The Hyesan city resident said he “had not heard about the statement by the NDC” and added that in critical situations, “managers or lower-ranking Workers’ Party officials would have informed people during the regular morning meeting—but such action was not taken.”

When asked if the announcement had been made on closed circuit broadcasting, via speakers installed in homes, the Hyesan resident said:

“Who listens to closed circuit broadcasting these days? Nowadays, closed circuit broadcasting hardly works anywhere in North Korea.”

He said that even if central authorities had attempted to convey the information to the public by telephone in a special broadcast, no one would know because “effective [May 20], people are being mobilized to work in agriculture and they are all busy preparing for their farming duties.”

“All over North Korea, everyone in middle school, third grade or older, has been ordered to perform ‘voluntary’ farm work, and all of them have no choice but to engage in that activity,” the resident said.

“Even if war broke out, the [North Korean] military wouldn’t be able to fight, because they have no rice…Wouldn’t one need food in order to fight a war?”

‘Evidence overwhelming’

The U.N. Command’s Military Armistice Commission, which has overseen a truce between the North and South since 1953, said it will launch an inquiry into the incident separate from the investigation that announced its results May 20, in the South Korean capital Seoul.

That South Korean-led team, which included members from the United States, United Kingdom, Australia, and Sweden, concluded that the Cheonan was sunk on March 26 by a North Korean torpedo, killing 46 of 104 South Korean sailors aboard.

Arriving in Tokyo ahead of a visit to Beijing and Seoul, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called evidence that North Korea was responsible for the incident “overwhelming and condemning” adding that the U.S. “strongly condemns this act of aggression.”

While it is “premature” to announce a response without consulting regional governments most affected by Pyongyang’s actions, Clinton said an international response is needed to “send a clear message to North Korea that provocative actions have consequences.”

On Thursday, South Korean President Lee Myung Bak said the sinking was a "military provocation" that violated the U.N. Charter as well as the truce that ended fighting between the two Koreas, but he called for a cautious response.

Seoul's 10 million residents are vulnerable to large stores of North Korean artillery located just across the border.

A raised awareness

North Korean refugees living in the U.S. said they have long anticipated that North Korea was responsible for the sinking of the Cheonan.

Kim Kwang Jin, a North Korean defector and researcher with the Washington-based U.S. Committee for Human Rights in North Korea, said the incident has highlighted security concerns for the South after years of engagement with the North.

“The current situation constitutes a turning point in awakening our people in the Republic of Korea regarding the security situation on the Korean peninsula.”

According to Kim, once President Lee Myung Bak revisited the decade-long reckless policy of unconditional giving to the North Koreans, Pyongyang restructured its Reconnaissance Bureau and spy agencies—a signal that such provocations might occur.

Kim said the South Korean government must now make clear to North Korea the advantages of democracy, and that the transparent multinational investigation and U.N. involvement will help to do so.

Cho Jin Hye, another North Korean refugee, said that she and other defectors had assumed that Pyongyang was responsible for the attack all along.

Cho said the incident was an attempt by North Korea to make its presence felt and to express dissatisfaction with the tougher stance recently adopted by South Korea and the U.S.

“North Korea’s intention was probably to say…‘let’s make our presence felt,’ and, since South Korea is very keen on protecting human rights, North Korea sees that as a weakness…it knows that South Korea can’t go to war.”

“One can no longer adopt a conciliatory policy of appeasement towards the North Korean regime of Kim Jong Il. One must show North Koreans that democratic societies are stronger. If that is not done, North Korea will always have more demands.”


Original reporting by Sung Hwi Moon and Hee Jung Yang for RFA’s Korean service. Korean service director: Bong Park. Translated from the Korean by Grigore Scarlatoiu. Written for the Web in English by Joshua Lipes. Edited by Sarah Jackson-Han. Copyright © 1998-2009, RFA. Used with the permission of Radio Free Asia, 2025 M St. NW, Suite 300, Washington DC 20036. http://www.rfa.org.
Sunday, May 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

The Financial Crisis And Leviathan

By Robert Higgs

Since the early twentieth century, periods of real or perceived national emergency have been “critical episodes” in the growth of government’s size, scope, and power in the United States and in many other countries. Hence, the concise conceptualization: Crisis and Leviathan (the main title of my 1987 book on the growth of government in the United States from the late nineteenth century to the late twentieth century).

In the past century, the first five such critical episodes in the United States were: World War I; the Great Depression; World War II; a multi-faceted set of crises associated with the civil-rights revolution and the Vietnam War, roughly coincident with the presidencies of Lyndon B. Johnson and Richard M. Nixon; and the post 9/11 events associated with the so-called War on Terror and the U.S. attacks on and occupations of Afghanistan and Iraq. We are now amid another such critical episode, which springs from the housing bust that began in 2006, the economic recession that began late in 2007, and the financial debacle that reached its climax in September 2008.

The current troubles are complex and raise a multitude of questions. Many books and articles no doubt will be written to analyze these various issues in scholarly depth and detail, and certainly anything we might say today must be regarded as preliminary, at best. I focus here on a few aspects of the present episode that relate closely to my own research on the growth of government, a field of study to which I have returned again and again over the past thirty years.

I

The current recession has elicited many comparisons with earlier business downturns, especially with the Great Depression. Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke is often described as an expert on the Great Depression who takes its lessons, as he understands them, deeply into account as he formulates and implements Fed policies. Likewise, many other economists have revisited the Great Depression recently in search of lessons applicable to current policy-making. In all of these reflections, the mainstream economics profession in general has distinguished itself by an astonishing superficiality of historical knowledge and lack of theoretical prowess.

The swiftness with which a great many mainstream economists have reverted to the simplistic “vulgar Keynesianism” that had its heyday from the late 1940s to the late 1960s has been nothing short of shocking, given that by the end of the 1970s such old-fashioned Keynesianism seemed to have been completely discredited and superseded in the leading echelons of the mainstream economics profession. Now it has come roaring back. Of course, the general public, whose understanding of such matters is always primitive, and the politicians, who are always looking for plausible intellectual rationales to excuse their insatiable spending, borrowing, and power-grabbing, had never abandoned vulgar Keynesianism, so they were elated to find that the economic “experts” were again confirming their own self-interested inclinations.

From such vulgar Keynesian thinking flowed the succession of “stimulus” spending measures, beginning with the Bush administration’s, carried out in the spring of 2008. Other governments have gone down the same foolish path. Of course, as any competent economist could have testified even fifty years ago, such temporary government-spending surges give people money that, for the most part, they save or use to pay off debts, rather than spending it along the lines envisioned by Keynesian “multiplier” analysis to set in motion an upward spiral of income, expenditure, real output, and employment. Much of the so-called stimulus spending in the United States has served only to bulk up the pay and benefits of government employees (federal, state, and local), effectively transferring income from the private sector to the government sector, and to reward other groups, such as the United Auto Workers and low-income home buyers, for their support of the Obama administration—past, present, or future.

At the same time, Bernanke and other central bankers, obsessed by an irrational fear of deflation, set in motion liquidity-enhancing measures so vast that no one could reasonably have anticipated them. Excess reserves of depository institutions in the United States now substantially exceed $1 trillion, as the banks have simply absorbed the effusions of dollars the Fed has spent to acquire an unprecedented variety of “securities,” including various “toxic” assets that Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and other ill-managed firms had acquired during the housing boom and later.


Bernanke and his colleagues in other central banks are taking credit for saving the financial system and even for saving the world from a repetition of the Great Depression—claims that must be treated with extreme skepticism. In any event, however, they have certainly created the potential for rapidly accelerating consumer-price inflation, should the banks become less apprehensive about their balance sheets and employ their vast excess-reserve balances to resume their lending and investing on a more normal basis.

Bernanke expresses confidence that he has the “tools” to rein in such potentially inflationary bank action, mainly by raising the interest rate the Fed pays banks on their deposits at the Fed, but one may well doubt whether he will be able to use those tools effectively. When interest rates begin to rise substantially, as they must sooner or later, great political pressure will be brought against tighter-money actions by the Fed and other central banks; the politicians will protest increases in interest rates at a time when unemployment remains at an elevated rate and other aspects of the recession linger, as well. So, even if Bernanke has the effective tools he claims to have, the question remains as to whether he will have the personal courage and the political support required to use those tools effectively.

II

One aspect of the current crisis that has come as anything but a surprise is that the politicians and their supporting coalition of crony capitalists and other backers have certainly not (in the immortal words of Barack Obama’s chief of staff Rahm Emanuel) allowed “a crisis to go to waste.” The past two years have witnessed one power-grab or institutional takeover after another, most notably of AIG, Fannie, Freddie, General Motors, and Chrysler. Under the TARP scheme, the Treasury has taken ownership positions in hundreds of large banks by acquiring preferred shares and warrants. Virtually all residential mortgage lending now ultimately springs from the secondary market and guarantees provided by Fannie, Freddie, Ginnie Mae, FHA, and VA. This aspect of the government’s power-grab has been especially important because by continuing to pump funds into dodgy mortgages, the government is preventing the necessary restructuring of the housing-construction industry and the mortgage-credit sector, propping up unqualified and underwater borrowers and ill-managed and even insolvent lenders, and thereby creating great potential for a second round of the housing/housing-finance bust in the near-term future.

As the huge recent expansion of the government’s size and scope has proceeded, the Treasury’s fiscal condition has deteriorated badly. The federal deficit jumped from an amount equal to about 3 percent of GDP in fiscal 2008 to an amount equal to about 10 percent of GDP in fiscal 2009, and even the government’s forecasts now project deficits in the neighborhood of $1 trillion per year for the next decade. Thus, the U.S. government’s debt has exploded, and will continue to rise relentlessly—or, it will do so as long as willing buyers can be found for bonds promising only modest nominal yields, a market that Uncle Sam can no longer assume will persist indefinitely. (The Chinese and other major buyers are already grousing and insisting that the U.S. Treasury act more prudently.)

While the government proper was expanding its size, scope, and power, the Fed was greatly expanding the magnitude and scope of its own balance sheet and, in effect, engaging in “industrial policy” by singling out particular firms and industries for assistance, while steering clear of others in equally dire condition. If the Fed is not “picking winners,” it is certainly deciding who will be spared a market-determined fate as a loser. Fed officials insist that they intend to withdraw from many of the new areas they have recently entered, once the crisis has passed, but it will be surprising if the recent “emergency” policies do not remain in the Fed’s arsenal, bulking up its power, and equally surprising if it sloughs off all of the unusual types of “securities” it has acquired in the past two years.

At the moment, the Fed is seeking—and it, the FDIC, or another government regulatory entity may well be given—wide-ranging statutory authority to reorganize preemptively any seemingly failing firm (not only banks) whose failure would pose, in the Fed’s estimation, a “systemic risk.” Such authority would greatly expand the Fed’s current power as a monetary central planner by adding a role as risk-management central planner. Regardless of whether the Fed, the FDIC, or another government regulatory entity ends up the winner of the current power scramble, the possible repercussions of this expanded power on the operation of the capital markets is frightful to contemplate.

III

As the current troubles have led many economists and others to revisit the government’s policies during the 1930s, some have concluded that even though the New Deal’s hodgepodge of policies never brought about full recovery, the action that most economists believe did effect a full recovery—in Paul Krugman’s words, “the large public works program, otherwise known as World War II, that ended the Great Depression”—suggests a remedy for today’s recession along similar lines. In retrospect, it is clear that this belief in the creation of “wartime prosperity” by massive government spending and deficit financing did more than anything else to bring about acceptance of the Keynesian paradigm in the 1940s and 1950s. Even today, not only the general public but most professional economists remain firmly convinced that, as the familiar saying maintains, “the war got the economy out of the Great Depression,” and hence a serious recession such as the present one naturally causes them to recall this supposed “lesson” of economic history. Among many lesser lights, Martin Feldstein, one of the country’s most eminent and influential economists, has recently proposed what amounts to an exercise in military Keynesianism as a stimulus measure.

The fly in this ointment, however, is that the lesson almost everyone has drawn from the events of the 1940s is false; the common belief is a myth. When we take apart the simplistic Keynesian analysis of the war’s effect on the economy and look carefully at what actually happened to the various components of the labor force, the capital stock, and the gross domestic product, we see that the economic events of the war years represent a classic case of a command economy’s sacrificing butter—not to mention life, liberty, and property—for the sake of producing and deploying more guns.
 
A single graph suffices to give us a more accurate portrayal of the economy’s performance in the 1930s and 1940s (for a complete analysis, see the first five chapters of my 2006 book Depression, War, and Cold War).


As the graph shows, real GDP dropped sharply in the early 1930s, then recovered rapidly after 1933, but it did not reach its high-employment growth trend until 1941, when the nature of the economy’s output (shifting rapidly into war production) was beginning to obscure the meaning of data that purport to measure “real output.” If we accept the standard data, a huge war boom appears to have occurred during the war years, followed by a sharp downturn, concentrated in 1946, after which the economy moved closely along its high-employment growth trend (shown in the figure by the straight line connecting the [logarithms of the] values for 1929 and 1948).

Looking at the private part of GDP—the part with a much clearer meaning, owing to its derivation from freely-made consumer and investor choices about the use of privately owned funds—we see a similar pattern during the 1930s, but a completely different pattern during the 1940s. After 1941, private output of both consumer and investor goods fell to much lower levels and remained submerged far below the high-employment growth trend throughout the war years. Private real output did not exceed its 1941 rate until 1946, when it shot up by about 30 percent in a single year. Afterward, the private economy moved closely along its high-employment growth trend. Real prosperity had been achieved at last, for the first time since 1929.

But wait, the critics protest: didn’t the war wipe out mass unemployment? Of course, it did. However, this elimination of mass unemployment had nothing to do with Keynesian fiscal policy (or, for that matter, with the concurrent, highly expansive monetary policy) and everything to do with the military draft, which pulled the equivalent of 22 percent of the prewar labor force into the armed forces. If the economy has 5–7 million persons unemployed, then drafting 10 million prime-age workers (and thereby inducing millions of others to enlist “voluntarily”) will “solve” the unemployment problem every time. To use the same policy today, the U.S. authorities need only to conscript about 30 million men—not, I daresay, a political idea whose time has come.

Indeed, the idea is preposterous, and so, more generally, is looking to the government’s alleged “large public works program, otherwise known as World War II” as a model of how to deal with today’s economic crisis. Rather than allow ourselves to be mesmerized by a statistically spurious bulge of real GDP during World War II, we are better advised to recall the wartime rationing of many ordinary consumer goods, the shortages or complete production closures of many consumer goods (e.g., automobiles, most consumer durables), the preemption of public transport by the military authorities, and the wage, price, and rent controls that caused, among many other undesirable consequences, drastic deterioration in the quality of many goods and services. Whatever else the war might have accomplished, it certainly did not produce conditions that we may properly describe as genuine prosperity.

IV

Even if policy makers decline to adopt World War II-type policies as remedies for the current recession, the immense magnitude of the present-day military-industrial complex certainly complicates all efforts to effect a recovery, by draining more than $1 trillion a year from the economy’s potential to produce private consumer and producer goods. The current long-running wars and military occupations in Afghanistan and Iraq, which will probably never end, although eventually they may be scaled back somewhat, only add to the economic drain on U.S. resources. So far, more than $1 trillion has been expended for these ill-fated adventures, and their total cost may eventually cumulate to several times this amount, not simply because they, like the U.S. military presence in Japan, Korea, and various European countries, will continue indefinitely, but also because of the need to care for a multitude of physically and psychologically disabled veterans over a span of several decades.

Even if the wars in the Middle East were concluded overnight, however, a huge distortion would continue to affect the U.S. economy, owing to the normal operation of the military-industrial complex and the maintenance of the current armed forces and their far-flung empire of more than 800 large overseas bases. This military hypertrophy reflects not an attempt to pump up the macroeconomy, as military Keynesians would have it, but rather the devotion of U.S. ruling elites to the maintenance of global military hegemony, ultimately capped by the attainment of “full-spectrum dominance”—“control of land, sea, air and space and all attendant resources” over the entire world.

Why do U.S. policy makers seek such god-like control of the planet? To the extent that the military leadership itself contributes to shaping national-security policies, this o’erleaping ambition merely expresses the latest phase of the military’s longstanding maniacal quest for total power—the undoubted ability to win any and all conceivable wars. Among the civilian leadership, the motives range more widely. An important impulse, though it is never mentioned frankly in polite company, is to maintain a foreign military presence configured so as to make the state of Israel as secure as possible. Another abiding interest is to control the worldwide distribution of petroleum, if necessary by bribing, intimidating, or taking military action against the governments of important oil-producing countries, especially in the Persian Gulf region.

Related to this wholly unnecessary quest to control the world’s oil-distribution channels—after all, it does not serve the interests of the oil producers to withhold their product from the world market—is the ambition to play the Great Game by throwing up barriers to the expanding influence of China and India and the residual potential of Russia in southwest Asia, especially in the Caspian Sea region, where vast stores of oil and gas remain to be tapped and brought to market. For more than half a century, U.S. leaders have been obsessed with projecting their country’s power into petro-military adventures of all sorts. However senseless this fixation might seem in a purely economic perspective, we can scarcely deny that the coziest crony capitalists in the oil and related industries have reaped a great deal of income along the way, and owing to their extraordinary political clout, they have every expectation of continuing to reap such income in the future, with the vital assistance of U.S. diplomats and armed forces to grease the skids.

Although the military-industrial-congressional complex is one of the most powerful interest groups in U.S. politics, and we may certainly expect it to struggle forcefully to retain or even to increase the flow of wealth placed at its disposal, the U.S. government’s increasingly precarious financial condition may compel even this powerful coalition to settle for a smaller space at the trough, especially if stagflation sets in as the U.S. economy’s normal condition during the next decade (as I suspect it will). If America’s economic future turns out to be even worse than I now foresee—for example, with rapid inflation, price and capital controls, and a flight from the dollar—then even greater retrenchment of the U.S. military presence abroad will be unavoidable. Such economic ruin would be a heavy price to pay for reining in America’s global hegemony, but, nevertheless, the military retrenchment itself would be a consequence that most of the world’s people would celebrate.


Acknowledgment: This commentary was originally prepared for presentation at a meeting convened by Diapason Commodities Management S.A. in Venice, Italy, April 30, 2010. I am grateful to Sean Corrigan and his colleagues at Diapason for inviting me to speak at this meeting.

Robert Higgs is Senior Fellow in Political Economy for The Independent Institute and Editor of the Institute’s quarterly journal The Independent Review. He received his Ph.D. in economics from Johns Hopkins University, and he has taught at the University of Washington, Lafayette College, Seattle University, and the University of Economics, Prague. He has been a visiting scholar at Oxford University and Stanford University, and a fellow for the Hoover Institution and the National Science Foundation. He is the author of many books, including Depression, War, and Cold War. This article was published by The Independent Institute  and reprinted with permission.
Sunday, May 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...



Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search