The ASEM Dialogue: Opportunities For Southeast Asia?
Tuli Sinha for IPCS
Indonesia’s participation in the sixth Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) interfaith dialog held in Madrid, Spain from 7-9 April, themed as "Consolidation of Religious Freedom and of Mutual Knowledge of Societies through Inter-religious and Intercultural Dialogue" sent across the message of a gradually strengthening Europe-Southeast Asia bilateral relations. The three-day meeting brought together 200 delegates from ASEM partners, and was co-hosted by Spain and Pakistan and sponsored by 14 ASEM partners, including Austria, The Netherlands, Bulgaria, Denmark, Finland, Britain, Germany, Italy, China, Japan, Indonesia, South Korea, and Thailand. It becomes imperative to analyse this dialogue for political and economic connotations, specifically for Indonesia which is the largest Muslim, pluralistic country among the initiators of the dialogue.
The Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) is an informal get-together that addresses political, economic, and cultural issues with the objective of strengthening the relationship between the two regions in a spirit of informality and equal partnership. Recently, these issues have been further broadened to include human rights, rule of law, global health threats, sustainable development, and intercultural and interfaith dialogues. Apolitical and cultural dialogues become important as they hold the prospect of improving bilateral relations between countries.
To begin with, there is a need to explore the various facets of this dialogue and its working. The key characteristics of ASEM include four main pillars. First is the ‘informality’ which provides an open forum for policy makers and officials to discuss any political, economic, and social issue of common interest rather than duplicate the work already being carried out in the bilateral and multilateral forums. Second is the ‘multi-dimensionality’ which covers the full spectrum of relations between the two regions and devotes equal weight to political, economic, and cultural issues. Third is the ‘emphasis on equal partnership’ which eschews any aid-based relationship. Last, is the ‘Dual focus’ on high-level and people-to-people contact which provides a platform for a meeting of the heads of the states, and an increasing focus on fostering contacts between societies in all sectors of the two regions.
Although it creates a multilateral forum for a much encompassing cooperation in terms of issues among the members, a critical assessment of the ASEM Dialogue exhibits a rather dismal picture of its role and existence. First, the only permanent physical institution of ASEM, the Asia-Europe Foundation (ASEF) established in the year 1997 has never been in the limelight or used as a concrete platform for discussions on serious issues.
Second, Interfaith Dialogue is a tricky and consequently rarely tackled subject in Europe. European countries are diversely populated and some of them – like France, Germany, Denmark or Belgium – currently question their relation with their Muslim populations and its links with immigration, unemployment, and extremism issues. Therefore, it becomes imperative for Europe to develop some kind of an intra-European dialogue simultaneously to provide a platform for the religious, ethnic, and cultural issues of people within the region rather than imparting all the attention to a multilateral dialogue with Asian nations. Could the ASEM Interfaith Dialogue, if taken seriously by all participants, be a first step towards a better understanding within Europe? Does Asia serve as a role model on that matter? And what can Indonesia specifically bring to the Dialogue?
The inter-religious organization, ASEM fails to shed any light on this. The dialogue does discuss issue of economic cooperation and transaction of meagre grants from Europe to Asian nations. This is very nominal taking into account the lump sum deals among European Union and Indonesia or with any other Asian member. Therefore, ASEM needs to prioritize and choose issues of relevance rather than expanding the list with human rights, rule of law as they are purely political in character.
It is important to remember that ASEM is not a substitute for existing bilateral or multilateral forums between Asia and Europe. However, through the ASEM dialogue, Indonesia can garner collaborative synergies and optimally utilize them as a catalyst for enhancing overall Southeast Asia-Europe relations. It is evident from the past ASEM dialogues that this level of informal engagement with Europe holds great significance for the Indonesian Foreign Policy. It acts as a bridge to reduce the existing economic gap between the two regions. ASEM can also be utilized by Indonesia as a medium to strengthen its position among the Asian countries.
ASEM has definitely helped Europe and Asia in having a more global vision and promoted the overall Asia-Europe relations on international and inter-regional issues of common interest. By bringing together different cultures and civilizations, ASEM fosters common understanding and dialogue and this should be encouraged.
Tuli Sinha is a Research Officer for SEARP, IPCS and may be reached at tuli@ipcs.org. This article was published by IPCS.
Indonesia’s participation in the sixth Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) interfaith dialog held in Madrid, Spain from 7-9 April, themed as "Consolidation of Religious Freedom and of Mutual Knowledge of Societies through Inter-religious and Intercultural Dialogue" sent across the message of a gradually strengthening Europe-Southeast Asia bilateral relations. The three-day meeting brought together 200 delegates from ASEM partners, and was co-hosted by Spain and Pakistan and sponsored by 14 ASEM partners, including Austria, The Netherlands, Bulgaria, Denmark, Finland, Britain, Germany, Italy, China, Japan, Indonesia, South Korea, and Thailand. It becomes imperative to analyse this dialogue for political and economic connotations, specifically for Indonesia which is the largest Muslim, pluralistic country among the initiators of the dialogue.
The Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) is an informal get-together that addresses political, economic, and cultural issues with the objective of strengthening the relationship between the two regions in a spirit of informality and equal partnership. Recently, these issues have been further broadened to include human rights, rule of law, global health threats, sustainable development, and intercultural and interfaith dialogues. Apolitical and cultural dialogues become important as they hold the prospect of improving bilateral relations between countries.
To begin with, there is a need to explore the various facets of this dialogue and its working. The key characteristics of ASEM include four main pillars. First is the ‘informality’ which provides an open forum for policy makers and officials to discuss any political, economic, and social issue of common interest rather than duplicate the work already being carried out in the bilateral and multilateral forums. Second is the ‘multi-dimensionality’ which covers the full spectrum of relations between the two regions and devotes equal weight to political, economic, and cultural issues. Third is the ‘emphasis on equal partnership’ which eschews any aid-based relationship. Last, is the ‘Dual focus’ on high-level and people-to-people contact which provides a platform for a meeting of the heads of the states, and an increasing focus on fostering contacts between societies in all sectors of the two regions.
Although it creates a multilateral forum for a much encompassing cooperation in terms of issues among the members, a critical assessment of the ASEM Dialogue exhibits a rather dismal picture of its role and existence. First, the only permanent physical institution of ASEM, the Asia-Europe Foundation (ASEF) established in the year 1997 has never been in the limelight or used as a concrete platform for discussions on serious issues.
Second, Interfaith Dialogue is a tricky and consequently rarely tackled subject in Europe. European countries are diversely populated and some of them – like France, Germany, Denmark or Belgium – currently question their relation with their Muslim populations and its links with immigration, unemployment, and extremism issues. Therefore, it becomes imperative for Europe to develop some kind of an intra-European dialogue simultaneously to provide a platform for the religious, ethnic, and cultural issues of people within the region rather than imparting all the attention to a multilateral dialogue with Asian nations. Could the ASEM Interfaith Dialogue, if taken seriously by all participants, be a first step towards a better understanding within Europe? Does Asia serve as a role model on that matter? And what can Indonesia specifically bring to the Dialogue?
The inter-religious organization, ASEM fails to shed any light on this. The dialogue does discuss issue of economic cooperation and transaction of meagre grants from Europe to Asian nations. This is very nominal taking into account the lump sum deals among European Union and Indonesia or with any other Asian member. Therefore, ASEM needs to prioritize and choose issues of relevance rather than expanding the list with human rights, rule of law as they are purely political in character.
It is important to remember that ASEM is not a substitute for existing bilateral or multilateral forums between Asia and Europe. However, through the ASEM dialogue, Indonesia can garner collaborative synergies and optimally utilize them as a catalyst for enhancing overall Southeast Asia-Europe relations. It is evident from the past ASEM dialogues that this level of informal engagement with Europe holds great significance for the Indonesian Foreign Policy. It acts as a bridge to reduce the existing economic gap between the two regions. ASEM can also be utilized by Indonesia as a medium to strengthen its position among the Asian countries.
ASEM has definitely helped Europe and Asia in having a more global vision and promoted the overall Asia-Europe relations on international and inter-regional issues of common interest. By bringing together different cultures and civilizations, ASEM fosters common understanding and dialogue and this should be encouraged.
Tuli Sinha is a Research Officer for SEARP, IPCS and may be reached at tuli@ipcs.org. This article was published by IPCS.
Friday, May 07, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Moscow, Oslo, Copenhagen: Nordic problems
By Andrei Fedyashin
On April 26, President Dmitry Medvedev depart Moscow for his "Nordic tour", which will take him to Norway on April 26 and 27 and to Denmark on April 27 and 28.
Incidentally, Norway is the only NATO country that celebrates the end of World War II on the same day as Russia, May 9. In Norway it's called Frigjoringsdag 1945, or Liberation Day 1945. The north of the country was liberated by the Soviet Army, and Medvedev will lay a wreath at the memorial to the Soviet soldiers killed in Norway.
Russia's relations with its Nordic neighbors have never been smooth, with periods of freezes and thaws, friendship and tension. Medvedev's upcoming visits apparently indicate that relations are warming.
The Oslo talks will focus on our traditional "set of Nordic issues" - further delimitation of border in the Barents Sea, energy cooperation, fishing, cooperation between law enforcement agencies, "northern" regional problems and developing the resources of the Arctic.
In July 2007, Russia and Norway signed an agreement delineating the offshore zones in Varangerfjord in the Barents Sea; now it is time to discuss other borders in the Barents Sea. This is an extremely important issue, as the area is rich in offshore oil and gas reserves. The countries should take their time and be precise. The talks could result in an agreement on another border section occupying nearly 175,000 sq km in the disputed northern part of the Barents Sea. Norway initially proposed a "simple" solution that would draw the border along lines of longitude. But Russia did not acquiesce, in a show of Nordic tenacity, and now a solution is being worked out for each specific section of the border.
Energy will certainly be a major focus of the talks between the President Medvedev and Norwegian Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg. Norway is the world's third largest oil exporter after Saudi Arabia and Russia, and it has abundant natural gas reserves. Norway is now keenly interested in Russia's Shtokman field in the eastern part of the Barents Sea. Norway's StatoilHydro holds a 24% stake in Shtokman Development AG, which is the developer of the Shtokman field. Gazprom holds a controlling 51% stake, while the French company, Total, owns 25%. Norway has been trying to persuade Russia to let it join the project as a partial owner, but Russia has so far resisted.
Shtokman holds an estimated 3.8 trillion cubic meters of gas and 37 million metric tons of gas condensate, which is enough to keep the field producing for 50 years.
The uncertainty surrounding Shtokman has Norwegian businesses seriously concerned. The start date of the project has been pushed back several times already. Currently, the first supplies of liquefied natural gas (LNG) are expected in 2014. Pipeline gas is expected to first reach consumers in 2013. However, Medvedev said the final decision on pipeline gas would be made in March 2011, while the decision on LNG would come even later in the year. This means that pipeline gas production and transportation may begin as late as 2016, with the production of LNG following in 2017. The Russian president cited the global economic and financial crisis as the cause of the delays.
Fishing is another major stumbling block between Russia and Norway. Norwegians complain that Russian poachers often fish in its waters using nets with mesh sizes that are under regulation. They estimate that Russia catches $154 million worth of fish a year in Norway's exclusive zones, mainly around Svalbard. Russian fishermen allegedly catch 100,000 tons of illegal cod alone.
For their part, Russian fishermen claim that Norway has no right to extend its laws to the exclusive economic zones around Svalbard, as these zones are regulated by clauses of the Spitsbergen Treaty, signed in Paris in 1920, that authorize all signatories, Russia included, to fish in those waters. Thirty-seven other countries share Russia's position and do not recognize Norway's claims to the waters around Svalbard.
Norway's claims smack of a covert attempt to oust Russian fishermen from the area, so that the Norwegians can have it all for themselves. Considering the fact that most of the fish, especially cod, ends up at Norwegian ports anyway, there can be no other explanation. But Russia still has some leverage over Norway when it comes to fish: seafood accounts for 69% of Norway's exports to Russia.
As for Copenhagen, no Russian leader has visited the Danish capital since Nikita Khrushchev went in 1964. President Medvedev is set to discuss expanding trade and Danish investments in Russia's energy and agricultural sectors, as well as a new structure for European security.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article first appeared.
On April 26, President Dmitry Medvedev depart Moscow for his "Nordic tour", which will take him to Norway on April 26 and 27 and to Denmark on April 27 and 28.
Incidentally, Norway is the only NATO country that celebrates the end of World War II on the same day as Russia, May 9. In Norway it's called Frigjoringsdag 1945, or Liberation Day 1945. The north of the country was liberated by the Soviet Army, and Medvedev will lay a wreath at the memorial to the Soviet soldiers killed in Norway.
Russia's relations with its Nordic neighbors have never been smooth, with periods of freezes and thaws, friendship and tension. Medvedev's upcoming visits apparently indicate that relations are warming.
The Oslo talks will focus on our traditional "set of Nordic issues" - further delimitation of border in the Barents Sea, energy cooperation, fishing, cooperation between law enforcement agencies, "northern" regional problems and developing the resources of the Arctic.
In July 2007, Russia and Norway signed an agreement delineating the offshore zones in Varangerfjord in the Barents Sea; now it is time to discuss other borders in the Barents Sea. This is an extremely important issue, as the area is rich in offshore oil and gas reserves. The countries should take their time and be precise. The talks could result in an agreement on another border section occupying nearly 175,000 sq km in the disputed northern part of the Barents Sea. Norway initially proposed a "simple" solution that would draw the border along lines of longitude. But Russia did not acquiesce, in a show of Nordic tenacity, and now a solution is being worked out for each specific section of the border.
Energy will certainly be a major focus of the talks between the President Medvedev and Norwegian Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg. Norway is the world's third largest oil exporter after Saudi Arabia and Russia, and it has abundant natural gas reserves. Norway is now keenly interested in Russia's Shtokman field in the eastern part of the Barents Sea. Norway's StatoilHydro holds a 24% stake in Shtokman Development AG, which is the developer of the Shtokman field. Gazprom holds a controlling 51% stake, while the French company, Total, owns 25%. Norway has been trying to persuade Russia to let it join the project as a partial owner, but Russia has so far resisted.
Shtokman holds an estimated 3.8 trillion cubic meters of gas and 37 million metric tons of gas condensate, which is enough to keep the field producing for 50 years.
The uncertainty surrounding Shtokman has Norwegian businesses seriously concerned. The start date of the project has been pushed back several times already. Currently, the first supplies of liquefied natural gas (LNG) are expected in 2014. Pipeline gas is expected to first reach consumers in 2013. However, Medvedev said the final decision on pipeline gas would be made in March 2011, while the decision on LNG would come even later in the year. This means that pipeline gas production and transportation may begin as late as 2016, with the production of LNG following in 2017. The Russian president cited the global economic and financial crisis as the cause of the delays.
Fishing is another major stumbling block between Russia and Norway. Norwegians complain that Russian poachers often fish in its waters using nets with mesh sizes that are under regulation. They estimate that Russia catches $154 million worth of fish a year in Norway's exclusive zones, mainly around Svalbard. Russian fishermen allegedly catch 100,000 tons of illegal cod alone.
For their part, Russian fishermen claim that Norway has no right to extend its laws to the exclusive economic zones around Svalbard, as these zones are regulated by clauses of the Spitsbergen Treaty, signed in Paris in 1920, that authorize all signatories, Russia included, to fish in those waters. Thirty-seven other countries share Russia's position and do not recognize Norway's claims to the waters around Svalbard.
Norway's claims smack of a covert attempt to oust Russian fishermen from the area, so that the Norwegians can have it all for themselves. Considering the fact that most of the fish, especially cod, ends up at Norwegian ports anyway, there can be no other explanation. But Russia still has some leverage over Norway when it comes to fish: seafood accounts for 69% of Norway's exports to Russia.
As for Copenhagen, no Russian leader has visited the Danish capital since Nikita Khrushchev went in 1964. President Medvedev is set to discuss expanding trade and Danish investments in Russia's energy and agricultural sectors, as well as a new structure for European security.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article first appeared.
Monday, April 26, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
EU Says Passenger Rights Continue To Apply Even Amid Volcano Disruptions
he volcanic ash cloud is a very significant threat to air safety, and national authorities are required to take decisions to ensure safety under international law, such as closure of airspace and airports, without discrimination between airlines, said EU Transport Commissioner Siim Kallas.
In a statement issues Thursday night, Kallas said, "This is a situation which is causing immense difficulties for passengers travelling throughout Europe. It can be considered a very exceptional circumstance. Nevertheless, it is important to remind passengers and airlines that EU passenger rights do apply in this situation."
Kallas was speaking following the closure of airspace and airports in more than eight EU counties including Ireland, UK, Netherlands, Belgium, Norway, Sweden, Denmark and Finland, due the volcanic eruption in Iceland.
Passenger rights, he noted, include the right to receive information from airlines (about the situation as it evolves, cancellations and length of delays), the right to care (refreshments, meals, accommodation as appropriate), and the right to chose between reimbursement of fares or be re-routed to final destination.
In an exceptional circumstance such as this, passengers are not however entitled to additional financial compensation that would be the case where delays or cancellations are the fault of the airline, noted the statement.
Source: KUNA
In a statement issues Thursday night, Kallas said, "This is a situation which is causing immense difficulties for passengers travelling throughout Europe. It can be considered a very exceptional circumstance. Nevertheless, it is important to remind passengers and airlines that EU passenger rights do apply in this situation."
Kallas was speaking following the closure of airspace and airports in more than eight EU counties including Ireland, UK, Netherlands, Belgium, Norway, Sweden, Denmark and Finland, due the volcanic eruption in Iceland.
Passenger rights, he noted, include the right to receive information from airlines (about the situation as it evolves, cancellations and length of delays), the right to care (refreshments, meals, accommodation as appropriate), and the right to chose between reimbursement of fares or be re-routed to final destination.
In an exceptional circumstance such as this, passengers are not however entitled to additional financial compensation that would be the case where delays or cancellations are the fault of the airline, noted the statement.
Source: KUNA
Friday, April 16, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Iceland Volcano Ash Grounds European Flight Traffic; UK Shut Down
A large part of the European airspace in the North of Europe has been grounded or experiencing delays due to the risk posed by clouds of ash from the volcanic eruption on Iceland. As of noon all non-emergency flights in the UK were cancelled.
In addition, flights in Sweden and Finland have been cancelled, as is Norway’s Oslo airport. Denmark plan to close its airspace this afternoon. Flights out of the Netherlands and Brussels were also experiencing delays.
Some experts said European flights could be disrupted for days.
According to experts volcanic ash can damage engines and causing them to jam. According to an AFP article, "volcanoes are a much-feared peril in civil aviation, disgorging fine ash that can damage jet engines, choke the hi-tech probes used in modern avionics and scour a plane's windscreen to the point of invisibility."
"From midday today until at least 6pm, there will be no flights permitted in UK controlled airspace other than emergency situations," said NATS, the agency which controls UK flights.
The NATS statement continued: "This has been applied in accordance with international civil aviation policy. We continue to monitor the situation with the Met Office and work closely with airline customers and adjoining countries. We will review the situation later today to understand what further action will be required. It is very unlikely that the situation over England will improve in the foreseeable future."
According to Free Internet Press, Icelandic authorities evacuated about 800 people early Wednesday when a volcano erupted beneath the Eyjafjallajokull glacier, said an emergency spokesman.
In addition, flights in Sweden and Finland have been cancelled, as is Norway’s Oslo airport. Denmark plan to close its airspace this afternoon. Flights out of the Netherlands and Brussels were also experiencing delays.
Some experts said European flights could be disrupted for days.
According to experts volcanic ash can damage engines and causing them to jam. According to an AFP article, "volcanoes are a much-feared peril in civil aviation, disgorging fine ash that can damage jet engines, choke the hi-tech probes used in modern avionics and scour a plane's windscreen to the point of invisibility."
"From midday today until at least 6pm, there will be no flights permitted in UK controlled airspace other than emergency situations," said NATS, the agency which controls UK flights.
The NATS statement continued: "This has been applied in accordance with international civil aviation policy. We continue to monitor the situation with the Met Office and work closely with airline customers and adjoining countries. We will review the situation later today to understand what further action will be required. It is very unlikely that the situation over England will improve in the foreseeable future."
According to Free Internet Press, Icelandic authorities evacuated about 800 people early Wednesday when a volcano erupted beneath the Eyjafjallajokull glacier, said an emergency spokesman.
Thursday, April 15, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Spain Hosts 6th Asia-Europe Interfaith Dialogue
Coinciding with the Spanish Presidency of the EU, the cities of Madrid and Toledo hosted the 6th Asia-Europe Interfaith Dialogue, the aim of which is to promote relations and mutual respect between cultures and creeds from both regions.
The working sessions, which were held at the IFEMA exhibition centre in Madrid, dealt with three main issues: religious freedom and human rights; respect and mutual understanding; and dialogue between cultures and religions as a bridge between societies.
Delegates from 27 of around 50 countries which make up the Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) attended the meeting, titled 'Consolidating religious freedom and mutual understanding through interfaith and intercultural dialogue'; the meeting, which was set up in 1996, is a high-level forum between the governments of both regions.
The Asia-Europe Interfaith Dialogue has taken place every year since 2005, either in Asia or in Europe, and brings together diplomats, senior officials connected with interfaith matters, leading academics and religious leaders from different faiths.
This year's dialogue was jointly organised by Spain and Pakistan, and was sponsored by 15 European and Asian countries: Germany, Austria, China, South Korea, Denmark, the Philippines, Finland, Indonesia, Italy, Japan, Malaysia, Netherlands, Poland, Singapore and Thailand.
The eventwas held in Spain in response to the announcement made in this regard by the President of the Government, José Luis RodrÃguez Zapatero, at the ASEM Summit in Beijing in 2008. The city councils of Madrid and Toledo and the regional government of Castilla La Mancha helped the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation to organise this 6th ASEM Interfaith Dialogue.
The closing ceremony took place Friday in the city of Toledo.
The working sessions, which were held at the IFEMA exhibition centre in Madrid, dealt with three main issues: religious freedom and human rights; respect and mutual understanding; and dialogue between cultures and religions as a bridge between societies.
Delegates from 27 of around 50 countries which make up the Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) attended the meeting, titled 'Consolidating religious freedom and mutual understanding through interfaith and intercultural dialogue'; the meeting, which was set up in 1996, is a high-level forum between the governments of both regions.
The Asia-Europe Interfaith Dialogue has taken place every year since 2005, either in Asia or in Europe, and brings together diplomats, senior officials connected with interfaith matters, leading academics and religious leaders from different faiths.
This year's dialogue was jointly organised by Spain and Pakistan, and was sponsored by 15 European and Asian countries: Germany, Austria, China, South Korea, Denmark, the Philippines, Finland, Indonesia, Italy, Japan, Malaysia, Netherlands, Poland, Singapore and Thailand.
The eventwas held in Spain in response to the announcement made in this regard by the President of the Government, José Luis RodrÃguez Zapatero, at the ASEM Summit in Beijing in 2008. The city councils of Madrid and Toledo and the regional government of Castilla La Mancha helped the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation to organise this 6th ASEM Interfaith Dialogue.
The closing ceremony took place Friday in the city of Toledo.
Saturday, April 10, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Many Countries Seeking Arctic Access
By Andrei Fedyashin
Although Arctic issues and those of the Arctic Ocean have only been discussed by the few littoral nations until now, it appears that the region will soon be reorganized on a grand scale.
On March 29, Chelsea, Canada hosted a meeting of Arctic Ocean Foreign Ministers from Canada, the United States, Russia, Denmark and Norway that share the shores of the Arctic Ocean.
One thing is clear from the meeting: many other countries want access to the region. Nobody would dare tell China, who is openly eyeing the resource-rich Arctic, to keep out. The eventual re-division of the area's mineral resources seems inevitable.
It is high time everybody stopped wondering how many non-Arctic nations want access to the region, including its oil and gas deposits. I addition, the Arctic has a unique natural feature giving it natural-monopolist status. Due to global warming, Arctic sea passages in northern Russia and Canada remain ice-free for increasingly longer periods.
Year-round navigation would shorten merchant-marine traffic routes from China to Germany or the U.S. East Coast by 6,000-7,000 km in one direction.
A carefully orchestrated effort by Ottawa to show international leadership on polar affairs by hosting an Arctic summit near Ottawa ended awkwardly Monday after U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton criticized Canada for excluding aboriginal leaders and three northern nations, Iceland, Finland and Sweden, as well as representatives from other indigenous groups, from attending.
"We need all hands on deck because there is a huge amount to do, and not much time to do it," Clinton said.
She said Iceland, Sweden and Finland were also Arctic nations and had the same rights to resources in the Arctic Ocean and its seabed as the delegates of the upcoming conference on Arctic cooperation called "The Arctic: Territory of Dialogue" scheduled for April 22-23 in Moscow.
This unprecedented Arctic forum will become the first large-scale project of the resurgent Russian Geographical Society, with RIA Novosti acting as manager. The conference is expected to include discussions on prospecting operations and the development of natural resources, including the Arctic shelf, environmental protection issues and expanding the region's transportation infrastructure.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov had to explain that the Arctic summit did not infringe upon the Arctic Council, a high-level inter-governmental forum addressing issues faced by the Arctic governments and the indigenous people of the Arctic.
Established in 1996 at the initiative of Finland, the Arctic Council is considered the main regional organization comprising Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Canada, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the United States. In reality, the Council is even larger because the United Kingdom, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Spain, China, Italy and South Korea have already received observer status with it.
Washington did not rebuke Ottawa and defend the uninvited parties for nothing. The United States and Canada have long been wrangling over large sectors of the Beaufort Sea. Consequently, any prospective allies could help settle this territorial dispute prior to the Arctic's division when claims will be voiced by almost everyone.
Denmark regularly quarrels with Canada for staking claims in Danish-controlled Greenland. Canada also argues with the United States for the same reason. At the same time, Norway lays claim to 175,000 sq. km. of Russia's continental shelf in the Barents Sea.
Moreover, Russia and the United States have not yet reached a consensus on a 1990 bilateral maritime boundary agreement in the north Pacific, also known as the Baker-Shevardnadze line/agreement, after the officials who signed the deal, the Soviet foreign minister Eduard Shevardnadze and the US Secretary of State James Baker.
Beijing which is also shifting its gaze in the direction of the Arctic has started converting its theoretical Arctic research programs into applied research. China's completely modernized Soviet-era Ukrainian-built Xuelong or Snow Dragon icebreaker, the largest conventional icebreaker in the world, currently plies Arctic waters.
Although China has no right to own Arctic shelf deposits, it would like littoral countries to establish legal rules in polar seas, as well as transparent and understandable navigation regulations, to demarcate borders, oil and gas fields, etc.
Consequently, China, the world's largest economy, would be able to more easily invest tremendous amounts in regional projects, to export its products and to receive imports accordingly.
Russia, Canada, the United States, Denmark and Norway have always held a special interest in the Arctic Ocean by "right of birth." From now on, they will have to coordinate their "hereditary claims" with others. And this will be even more difficult than discovering the North Pole.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article first appeared.
Although Arctic issues and those of the Arctic Ocean have only been discussed by the few littoral nations until now, it appears that the region will soon be reorganized on a grand scale.
On March 29, Chelsea, Canada hosted a meeting of Arctic Ocean Foreign Ministers from Canada, the United States, Russia, Denmark and Norway that share the shores of the Arctic Ocean.
One thing is clear from the meeting: many other countries want access to the region. Nobody would dare tell China, who is openly eyeing the resource-rich Arctic, to keep out. The eventual re-division of the area's mineral resources seems inevitable.
It is high time everybody stopped wondering how many non-Arctic nations want access to the region, including its oil and gas deposits. I addition, the Arctic has a unique natural feature giving it natural-monopolist status. Due to global warming, Arctic sea passages in northern Russia and Canada remain ice-free for increasingly longer periods.
Year-round navigation would shorten merchant-marine traffic routes from China to Germany or the U.S. East Coast by 6,000-7,000 km in one direction.
A carefully orchestrated effort by Ottawa to show international leadership on polar affairs by hosting an Arctic summit near Ottawa ended awkwardly Monday after U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton criticized Canada for excluding aboriginal leaders and three northern nations, Iceland, Finland and Sweden, as well as representatives from other indigenous groups, from attending.
"We need all hands on deck because there is a huge amount to do, and not much time to do it," Clinton said.
She said Iceland, Sweden and Finland were also Arctic nations and had the same rights to resources in the Arctic Ocean and its seabed as the delegates of the upcoming conference on Arctic cooperation called "The Arctic: Territory of Dialogue" scheduled for April 22-23 in Moscow.
This unprecedented Arctic forum will become the first large-scale project of the resurgent Russian Geographical Society, with RIA Novosti acting as manager. The conference is expected to include discussions on prospecting operations and the development of natural resources, including the Arctic shelf, environmental protection issues and expanding the region's transportation infrastructure.
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov had to explain that the Arctic summit did not infringe upon the Arctic Council, a high-level inter-governmental forum addressing issues faced by the Arctic governments and the indigenous people of the Arctic.
Established in 1996 at the initiative of Finland, the Arctic Council is considered the main regional organization comprising Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Canada, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the United States. In reality, the Council is even larger because the United Kingdom, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Spain, China, Italy and South Korea have already received observer status with it.
Washington did not rebuke Ottawa and defend the uninvited parties for nothing. The United States and Canada have long been wrangling over large sectors of the Beaufort Sea. Consequently, any prospective allies could help settle this territorial dispute prior to the Arctic's division when claims will be voiced by almost everyone.
Denmark regularly quarrels with Canada for staking claims in Danish-controlled Greenland. Canada also argues with the United States for the same reason. At the same time, Norway lays claim to 175,000 sq. km. of Russia's continental shelf in the Barents Sea.
Moreover, Russia and the United States have not yet reached a consensus on a 1990 bilateral maritime boundary agreement in the north Pacific, also known as the Baker-Shevardnadze line/agreement, after the officials who signed the deal, the Soviet foreign minister Eduard Shevardnadze and the US Secretary of State James Baker.
Beijing which is also shifting its gaze in the direction of the Arctic has started converting its theoretical Arctic research programs into applied research. China's completely modernized Soviet-era Ukrainian-built Xuelong or Snow Dragon icebreaker, the largest conventional icebreaker in the world, currently plies Arctic waters.
Although China has no right to own Arctic shelf deposits, it would like littoral countries to establish legal rules in polar seas, as well as transparent and understandable navigation regulations, to demarcate borders, oil and gas fields, etc.
Consequently, China, the world's largest economy, would be able to more easily invest tremendous amounts in regional projects, to export its products and to receive imports accordingly.
Russia, Canada, the United States, Denmark and Norway have always held a special interest in the Arctic Ocean by "right of birth." From now on, they will have to coordinate their "hereditary claims" with others. And this will be even more difficult than discovering the North Pole.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article first appeared.
Tuesday, March 30, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Putin Defends Russia's Arctic Rights, Calls For Dialogue
Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin justified on Monday Russia's claims for the Arctic continental shelf and urged other nations to resolve all controversial issues through dialogue.
The Arctic territories, believed to hold vast untapped oil and gas reserves, have been at the center of disputes between the United States, Russia, Canada, Norway, and Denmark as rising temperatures lead to a reduction in sea ice and make hydrocarbon deposits under the Arctic Ocean increasingly accessible. This has made the extent of the continental shelf a matter of national interest.
"There has been much ado around the Arctic region. You know how the [Russian] flag was erected [on the seabed] and how negatively our neighbors reacted to this. Nobody has ever stopped them from erecting their own flags. Let them do it. But we work under the rules established by the United Nations and in line with international maritime laws," Putin told members of the Russian Geographic Society.
Russia along with other Arctic Council nations will take part in an international conference on the Arctic on April 22-23 in Moscow.
Putin expressed hope that the participants of the conference "will discuss the existing disputes in a calm and neighborly manner...will listen to each other rather than exchange threats on non-existing issues."
Under international law, each of the five Arctic Circle countries has a 322-kilometer (200-mile) exclusive economic zone in the Arctic Ocean.
However, under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, if a country can show its continental shelf extends beyond the 200-mile limit, it can claim rights to more of the ocean floor.
Russia has undertaken two Arctic expeditions - to the Mendeleyev underwater chain in 2005 and to the Lomonosov Ridge in the summer of 2007 - to support its territorial claims in the region.
Russia first claimed the territory in 2001, but the United Nations demanded more evidence.
Russia has said it will invest some 1.5 billion rubles ($49.7 million) in defining the extent of its continental shelf in the Arctic in 2010 in order to prove its right to more of the Arctic floor.
Source: RIA Novosti
The Arctic territories, believed to hold vast untapped oil and gas reserves, have been at the center of disputes between the United States, Russia, Canada, Norway, and Denmark as rising temperatures lead to a reduction in sea ice and make hydrocarbon deposits under the Arctic Ocean increasingly accessible. This has made the extent of the continental shelf a matter of national interest.
"There has been much ado around the Arctic region. You know how the [Russian] flag was erected [on the seabed] and how negatively our neighbors reacted to this. Nobody has ever stopped them from erecting their own flags. Let them do it. But we work under the rules established by the United Nations and in line with international maritime laws," Putin told members of the Russian Geographic Society.
Russia along with other Arctic Council nations will take part in an international conference on the Arctic on April 22-23 in Moscow.
Putin expressed hope that the participants of the conference "will discuss the existing disputes in a calm and neighborly manner...will listen to each other rather than exchange threats on non-existing issues."
Under international law, each of the five Arctic Circle countries has a 322-kilometer (200-mile) exclusive economic zone in the Arctic Ocean.
However, under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, if a country can show its continental shelf extends beyond the 200-mile limit, it can claim rights to more of the ocean floor.
Russia has undertaken two Arctic expeditions - to the Mendeleyev underwater chain in 2005 and to the Lomonosov Ridge in the summer of 2007 - to support its territorial claims in the region.
Russia first claimed the territory in 2001, but the United Nations demanded more evidence.
Russia has said it will invest some 1.5 billion rubles ($49.7 million) in defining the extent of its continental shelf in the Arctic in 2010 in order to prove its right to more of the Arctic floor.
Source: RIA Novosti
Monday, March 15, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
ClimateTarget Divides EU Environment Ministers
EU environment ministers are meeting today (15 March) to debate their strategy for international climate negotiations, but no consensus is emerging about whether the EU should raise its target for greenhouse gas emission reductions for 2020.
One of the central topics to be discussed is whether the EU should hold on to its pledge to reduce emissions by 30% by 2020 only if other countries make similar moves, or make the upgrade unilaterally, diplomats said.
Eastern European countries are taking the approach that the EU must first come up with a methodology to analyse how other countries' pledges compare, one senior official said. Other sceptics of a unilateral move include Italy and Finland.
Their approach is contrasted by a group of Western member states including the UK, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden, which think it is in Europe's own interest to move to 30%, the diplomat explained.
Currently, the EU has a unilateral goal of reducing its emissions by 20% by 2020.
France, for its part, has positioned itself somewhere in the middle, taking the view that upgrading the target remains a credible objective. But this should not be done without first eliminating the risk that European businesses could end up at a competitive disadvantage, the official added.
Little movement is expected in either direction, with member states appearing to be in 'wait-and-see' mode until the European Commission has presented a new impact assessment of how much it would cost Europe to move towards 30%. The global downturn has forced down European production, and consequently emissions, and a tighter goal is now expected to be attainable at a lower cost than when the original 20% target was agreed, the diplomat pointed out.
"Nobody knows how to go to 30%," another diplomat said, stressing that this would raise a lot of questions, including on the admissibility of credits for preserving forests that act like a carbon sink.
He added that French President Nicolas Sarkozy would in the meantime keep pressing for carbon border tariffs that levy a tax on imports coming from countries where carbon regulation is not as stringent as in Europe. While the mechanism is talked up as a way to level the playing field for EU companies, most EU countries have dismissed it as a protectionist measure that could lead to a backlash.
Keep or ditch Kyoto?
Another difficult debate will concern the Kyoto Protocol and what to do with it after its expiry in 2012. EU countries all want to use two separate negotiating tracks for developed and developing countries, but there are disagreements about whether the Kyoto Protocol should be continued post-2012 when the treaty expires.
The mood as regards continuing with the Kyoto Protocol seems to be shifting in the EU as a result of the Copenhagen climate conference, which did not go according to the EU's plans.
The European delegation went to the Danish capital with the intention of replacing the Kyoto Protocol with a new international climate agreement that sets obligations for all countries and - most importantly - includes the United States. But this was not well received by developing countries, which would be quite happy to continue with the Protocol, under which they have no obligations.
"One failure in Copenhagen was that the EU was accused of killing Kyoto," one diplomat said, arguing that the Union would want to avoid ending up in a similar situation again.
"This has of course had an impact on the internal discussions," he added.
Poland and many other EU member states, mainly in Eastern Europe, would like to see the Kyoto Protocol continued in order to safeguard their large stocks of surplus emission credits, the official said. The restructuring of their industrial sectors after the collapse of Communism led to a significant drop in their emissions, which has now left them in possession of significant assets in unused credits.
In its strategy for reinvigorating global climate talks, the European Commission warned last week (9 March) that the "hot air" created by the accumulation of 10 billion tonnes of unused emissions credits would reduce the ambition of current emission reduction pledges significantly
Source: EurActiv
One of the central topics to be discussed is whether the EU should hold on to its pledge to reduce emissions by 30% by 2020 only if other countries make similar moves, or make the upgrade unilaterally, diplomats said.
Eastern European countries are taking the approach that the EU must first come up with a methodology to analyse how other countries' pledges compare, one senior official said. Other sceptics of a unilateral move include Italy and Finland.
Their approach is contrasted by a group of Western member states including the UK, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden, which think it is in Europe's own interest to move to 30%, the diplomat explained.
Currently, the EU has a unilateral goal of reducing its emissions by 20% by 2020.
France, for its part, has positioned itself somewhere in the middle, taking the view that upgrading the target remains a credible objective. But this should not be done without first eliminating the risk that European businesses could end up at a competitive disadvantage, the official added.
Little movement is expected in either direction, with member states appearing to be in 'wait-and-see' mode until the European Commission has presented a new impact assessment of how much it would cost Europe to move towards 30%. The global downturn has forced down European production, and consequently emissions, and a tighter goal is now expected to be attainable at a lower cost than when the original 20% target was agreed, the diplomat pointed out.
"Nobody knows how to go to 30%," another diplomat said, stressing that this would raise a lot of questions, including on the admissibility of credits for preserving forests that act like a carbon sink.
He added that French President Nicolas Sarkozy would in the meantime keep pressing for carbon border tariffs that levy a tax on imports coming from countries where carbon regulation is not as stringent as in Europe. While the mechanism is talked up as a way to level the playing field for EU companies, most EU countries have dismissed it as a protectionist measure that could lead to a backlash.
Keep or ditch Kyoto?
Another difficult debate will concern the Kyoto Protocol and what to do with it after its expiry in 2012. EU countries all want to use two separate negotiating tracks for developed and developing countries, but there are disagreements about whether the Kyoto Protocol should be continued post-2012 when the treaty expires.
The mood as regards continuing with the Kyoto Protocol seems to be shifting in the EU as a result of the Copenhagen climate conference, which did not go according to the EU's plans.
The European delegation went to the Danish capital with the intention of replacing the Kyoto Protocol with a new international climate agreement that sets obligations for all countries and - most importantly - includes the United States. But this was not well received by developing countries, which would be quite happy to continue with the Protocol, under which they have no obligations.
"One failure in Copenhagen was that the EU was accused of killing Kyoto," one diplomat said, arguing that the Union would want to avoid ending up in a similar situation again.
"This has of course had an impact on the internal discussions," he added.
Poland and many other EU member states, mainly in Eastern Europe, would like to see the Kyoto Protocol continued in order to safeguard their large stocks of surplus emission credits, the official said. The restructuring of their industrial sectors after the collapse of Communism led to a significant drop in their emissions, which has now left them in possession of significant assets in unused credits.
In its strategy for reinvigorating global climate talks, the European Commission warned last week (9 March) that the "hot air" created by the accumulation of 10 billion tonnes of unused emissions credits would reduce the ambition of current emission reduction pledges significantly
Source: EurActiv
Monday, March 15, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Nord Stream Gets Approval For Link To European Network
The operator of the Nord Stream gas pipeline project said on Thursday it had received approval from German authorities to connect the trans-Baltic pipeline to the European gas network.
The permission was obtained by Opal Net Transport, a subdivision of Wingas, a joint venture between Russian energy giant Gazprom and Germany's Wintershall, the Nord Stream operator said in a statement.
Opal's section will connect Nord Stream to the European gas distribution network in Southern Brandenburg at the German-Czech border, the statement said.
The Nord Stream pipeline, which will pump gas from Siberia to Europe under the Baltic Sea, bypassing East European transit countries, will be 1,220 kilometers (760 miles) long.
Nord Stream will have two pipelines, each with a capacity of 27.5 billion cubic meters a year, on the Baltic Sea floor stretching from Russia's Vyborg near the Finnish border to Greifswald on Germany's coast.
Construction of the first pipe is to begin in April, with pumping of gas expected to start in late 2011, while the second line is to come online in 2012.
Nord Stream received its final permit earlier this month, confirming approval for the route from Finland, Russia, Germany, Sweden and Denmark, the five countries whose waters the pipeline will pass through. The operator has changed the originally proposed route to ease environmental concerns.
Source: RIA Novosti
The permission was obtained by Opal Net Transport, a subdivision of Wingas, a joint venture between Russian energy giant Gazprom and Germany's Wintershall, the Nord Stream operator said in a statement.
Opal's section will connect Nord Stream to the European gas distribution network in Southern Brandenburg at the German-Czech border, the statement said.
The Nord Stream pipeline, which will pump gas from Siberia to Europe under the Baltic Sea, bypassing East European transit countries, will be 1,220 kilometers (760 miles) long.
Nord Stream will have two pipelines, each with a capacity of 27.5 billion cubic meters a year, on the Baltic Sea floor stretching from Russia's Vyborg near the Finnish border to Greifswald on Germany's coast.
Construction of the first pipe is to begin in April, with pumping of gas expected to start in late 2011, while the second line is to come online in 2012.
Nord Stream received its final permit earlier this month, confirming approval for the route from Finland, Russia, Germany, Sweden and Denmark, the five countries whose waters the pipeline will pass through. The operator has changed the originally proposed route to ease environmental concerns.
Source: RIA Novosti
Thursday, February 18, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
A Somali Version Of Operation Mickey Mouse
By B. Raman
An as yet unnamed (by the Danish Police) 28-year-old Somali, resident in Denmark, was arrested by the Danish Police on New Year's Day after they had promptly intervened and thwarted an attempt made by him to trespass into the house of Danish cartoonist Kurt Westergaard in the city of Aarhus with an alleged intent to kill him with an axe and a knife. He allegedly tried to attack the intervenig police party before he was overpowered. He thus faces two charges of attempting to kill the cartoonist and attacking the police.
The cartoonist had incurred the wrath of some sections of the Muslim Ummah in 2005 for drawing a cartoon of Prophet Mohammad sporting a bomb in his hair. Since then, the cartoonist has been under high protection by the Danish Police and Intelligence. He escaped the attempt on January 1,2010, thanks to his alertness in noticing the intending assailant and calling the police through a pre-arranged drill. The credit for the failure of the attempt should go to the cartoonist himself as well as to the Police. Both acted as per the drill for physical security laid down by the police after he started receiving threats in 2005.
It goes to the credit of the police and the Danish intelligence that they had not allowed the absence of any attack since 2005 to make them self-complacent. Moreover, the Danish Police and intelligence were doubly alert after the arrest of David Coleman Headley and Tahawwur Hussain Rana of the Chicago cell of the Lashkar-e-Toiba (LET) by the USA's Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) in October,2009.
The pre-arrest electronic surveillance of these two LET operatives----- both of Pakistani origin, with Headley holding the US nationality and Rana the Canadian nationality--- and their post-arrest interrogation brought out that the 313 Brigade of Pakistan headed by Ilyas Kashmiri and the LET were planning to use Headley for another major terrorist strike in India and for an attack on the Danish paper, which had published the cartoons in 2005. The LET was keen on the Indian attack and the 313 Brigade on the Danish attack, which had been code-named Operation Micky Mouse.
At the instance of Ilyas Kashmiri, Headley had visited Denmark twice to collect operational information to facilitate the attack. He was arrested by the FBI on October 3,2009, before he could leave Chicago for Pakistan along with the operational details collected by him. A perusal of the affidavits filed by the FBI before a Chicago court showed that while Ilyas Kashmiri was interested in a spectacular strike in Copenhagen similar to Mumbai 26/11, Headley himself preferred an assassination of the journalists responsible which, he felt, would be more feasible.
What Ilyas and Headley failed to achieve due to the alertness of the FBI, the Somali, not yet named by the Danish police, sought to achieve on New Year's Day. The thwarted attempt of the Somali illustrates once again the homing pigeon tactics of Al Qaeda, which keeps persisting in its jihadi trajectory despite failures and set-backs. The timely arrest of Headley did not lead to its giving up its objective of taking revenge against the cartoonist.
The following details of the arrested Somali are presently available:
(a), He has been residing in Denmark for some time with a legal permit, but one does not know when he moved to Denmark and from where.
(b).The media has quoted Jakob Scharf, who heads the Danish intelligence service PET, as saying that the attack was "terror related" and that the assailant had close contacts with Al Shabaab. He had been under surveillance for activities unrelated to Westergaard. Al Shabaab is considered the Somali wing of Al Qaeda. Scharf added : "The incident once again confirms the terrorist threat that is directed against Denmark and against cartoonist Kurt Westergaard, in particular".
At a news conference in the Somali capital of Mogadishu, Sheikh Ali Mohamud Rage, who has been described by the media as a spokesman of Al Shabaab, reportedly said, "We are very happy with the Somali national who attacked the house of the Danish cartoonist who previously insulted our prophet Mohammed. This is an honor for the Somali people. We are telling that we are glad that anyone who insults Islam should be attacked wherever they are." Thus, the organisation has expressed its approval of the attempted attack without claiming responsibility for it.
The Danish Police and Intelligence will now be investigating the background and links of the arrested Somali. A question, which should be of interest to investigators in Denmark, the US and India is: Did he have any contacts with Headley? Did Headley meet him during his two visits to Denmark?
This may be read in continuation of my earlier article of December 4,2009, titled "The Somali Front of the Global Jihad" at
http://www.southasiaanalysis.org/papers36/paper3534.html , which is annexed for easy reference
B. Raman is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt. of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai. E-mail: seventyone2@gmail.co
ANNEX
The Somali Front of the Global Jihad -- International Terrorism Monitor --- Paper No.584 ( December 4, 2009)
By B. Raman
Al Qaeda looks upon its continuing jihad against the so-called Crusaders --- thereby meaning essentially the US, Israel and their supporters--- as a global intifada waged on many fronts and through many means. In this global jihad, Afghanistan, Somalia and Algeria are seen as battle fronts, which will determine the ultimate outcome. Afghanistan is seen as the core of the battle, Somalia as its southern front and Algeria as the Western front.
2. In a message disseminated on December 20, 2006, Ayman al-Zawahiri, the No.2 to Osama bin Laden in Al Qaeda, said: “Brothers in Islam and Jihad in Somalia: know that you are on the southern garrison of Islam, so don’t allow Islam to be attacked from your flank, and know that we are with you, and that the entire Muslim Ummah is with you. So don’t lose heart, or fall into despair, for you must dominate if you are true in faith. And know that you are fending off the same Crusade which is fighting your brothers in Islam in Chechnya, Afghanistan, Iraq, Palestine and Lebanon. So be resolute, be patient and be optimistic, for by Allah beside whom there is no other God, even if your enemies possess thousands of tons of iron and explosives, in their chests lie the hearts of mice. So be severe against them like Muhammad was. "
3. To keep the jihad going in Somalia is one of its important objectives. For this purpose, it uses not only recruits from the impoverished local population, but also from the Somali diaspora in the West----including the US--- as well as jihad-hardened cadres sent from the battle fronts in the Af-Pak region. The Tablighi Jamaat (TJ) of Pakistan has had a long history of contacts with the Muslim population in Somalia and East African countries just as it has with the Muslim population of Chechnya and Dagestan. Though the TJ itself does not indulge in acts of terrorism, it plays an important role in facilitating the ideological motivation of the population on behalf of Al Qaeda.
In September 2009, Al Shabaab, meaning “The Lads”, an organization of Somali youths, was reported to have disseminated through Islamic web sites usually identified with Al Qaeda a 48-minute video documentary in which it proclaimed its allegiance to Osama bin Laden. It derives its name “The Lads” from the fact that it used to be the youth wing of a fundamentalist organization called the Union of Islamic Courts (UIC), which had established control over some parts of Somalia and was ultimately crushed by invading Ethiopian troops in 2006. While the elders of the UIC disappeared after being defeated by the better trained and better armed Ethiopian troops allegedly inspired and aided by the US, the Al Shabaab replaced the UIC as a born-again jihadi organization, which was determined to continue the jihad against the troops of the African Union, which had replaced the Ethiopian troops, and of the UN-backed local Government, which it viewed as apostate.
Though Somalis had participated in acts of suicide terrorism on behalf of Al Qaeda in other countries, suicide terrorism was unknown in Somalia itself till Al Shabaab made its appearance in 2006. Even though it proclaimed its loyalty to bin Laden only in September, 2009, it had carried out a number of acts of suicide terrorism against local Government targets as well as the peace-keeping troops of the African Union ever since the AU troops took over their peace-keeping responsibility in Somalia. Al Shabaab has been waging a two-front jihad---- against the AU troops and the local Government being protected by the AU troops. The first act of suicide terrorism took place on September 18, 2006. Since then, there have been 13 suicide attacks--- two in 2006, four in 2007, two in 2008 and five this year.
The Al Shabaab cadres, many of whom had allegedly served with the Afghan Mujahideen, the Taliban and Al Qaeda in the Af-Pak region, look upon their jihad as similar to the jihad waged by the Afghan Mujahideen against the Soviet troops and those of the Government of the then President Najibullah in the 1980s and the early 1990s.
In a serious attack of suicide terrorism, a male suicide bomber dressed as a woman managed to find his way into a graduation ceremony of medical students in a Mogadishu hotel on December 3, 2009, and blew himself up killing 19 persons, including three Ministers of the Cabinet of Prime Minister Omar Sharmarke of the UN-backed Government. Even though no organization has so far claimed responsibility for the attack, Al Shabaab is strongly suspected by the local authorities.
Though there is so far no evidence of any nexus between Al Shabaab and the Somali pirates, the dangers of money earned from piracy going to the coffers of Al Qaeda and the availability in Somalia of sea-faring people who could be used by Al Qaeda for future acts of maritime terrorism cannot be ignored.
A Reuters report carried on December 4, 2009, by the “Daily Times” of Lahore has quoted Bethuel Kiplagat, who used to be Kenya’s special envoy to the Somalia peace process from 2003 to 2005, as saying as follows: “Suicide bombings are a worrying trend not only for Somalia but also the region. There has been a rise in fundamentalism in Somalia coming from the Middle East and Pakistan. There’s a worry Al Qaeda may be looking at Somalia as a new sanctuary.”
On March 16, 2009, Mohamed Mohamed of the BBC’s Somali section, reported as follows: “As well as alleged links to al-Qaeda it is said to have Arabs, Asians, other Africans and - America's FBI believes - Westerners among its ranks. These foreigners are said to be involved in training Al Sabaab recruits in various aspects of guerrilla warfare, including suicide bombings and booby traps.”
On February 29, 2008, the then US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice designated Al Shabaab as a Foreign Terrorist Organization under Section 219 of the Immigration and Nationality Act.
An as yet unnamed (by the Danish Police) 28-year-old Somali, resident in Denmark, was arrested by the Danish Police on New Year's Day after they had promptly intervened and thwarted an attempt made by him to trespass into the house of Danish cartoonist Kurt Westergaard in the city of Aarhus with an alleged intent to kill him with an axe and a knife. He allegedly tried to attack the intervenig police party before he was overpowered. He thus faces two charges of attempting to kill the cartoonist and attacking the police.
The cartoonist had incurred the wrath of some sections of the Muslim Ummah in 2005 for drawing a cartoon of Prophet Mohammad sporting a bomb in his hair. Since then, the cartoonist has been under high protection by the Danish Police and Intelligence. He escaped the attempt on January 1,2010, thanks to his alertness in noticing the intending assailant and calling the police through a pre-arranged drill. The credit for the failure of the attempt should go to the cartoonist himself as well as to the Police. Both acted as per the drill for physical security laid down by the police after he started receiving threats in 2005.
It goes to the credit of the police and the Danish intelligence that they had not allowed the absence of any attack since 2005 to make them self-complacent. Moreover, the Danish Police and intelligence were doubly alert after the arrest of David Coleman Headley and Tahawwur Hussain Rana of the Chicago cell of the Lashkar-e-Toiba (LET) by the USA's Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) in October,2009.
The pre-arrest electronic surveillance of these two LET operatives----- both of Pakistani origin, with Headley holding the US nationality and Rana the Canadian nationality--- and their post-arrest interrogation brought out that the 313 Brigade of Pakistan headed by Ilyas Kashmiri and the LET were planning to use Headley for another major terrorist strike in India and for an attack on the Danish paper, which had published the cartoons in 2005. The LET was keen on the Indian attack and the 313 Brigade on the Danish attack, which had been code-named Operation Micky Mouse.
At the instance of Ilyas Kashmiri, Headley had visited Denmark twice to collect operational information to facilitate the attack. He was arrested by the FBI on October 3,2009, before he could leave Chicago for Pakistan along with the operational details collected by him. A perusal of the affidavits filed by the FBI before a Chicago court showed that while Ilyas Kashmiri was interested in a spectacular strike in Copenhagen similar to Mumbai 26/11, Headley himself preferred an assassination of the journalists responsible which, he felt, would be more feasible.
What Ilyas and Headley failed to achieve due to the alertness of the FBI, the Somali, not yet named by the Danish police, sought to achieve on New Year's Day. The thwarted attempt of the Somali illustrates once again the homing pigeon tactics of Al Qaeda, which keeps persisting in its jihadi trajectory despite failures and set-backs. The timely arrest of Headley did not lead to its giving up its objective of taking revenge against the cartoonist.
The following details of the arrested Somali are presently available:
(a), He has been residing in Denmark for some time with a legal permit, but one does not know when he moved to Denmark and from where.
(b).The media has quoted Jakob Scharf, who heads the Danish intelligence service PET, as saying that the attack was "terror related" and that the assailant had close contacts with Al Shabaab. He had been under surveillance for activities unrelated to Westergaard. Al Shabaab is considered the Somali wing of Al Qaeda. Scharf added : "The incident once again confirms the terrorist threat that is directed against Denmark and against cartoonist Kurt Westergaard, in particular".
At a news conference in the Somali capital of Mogadishu, Sheikh Ali Mohamud Rage, who has been described by the media as a spokesman of Al Shabaab, reportedly said, "We are very happy with the Somali national who attacked the house of the Danish cartoonist who previously insulted our prophet Mohammed. This is an honor for the Somali people. We are telling that we are glad that anyone who insults Islam should be attacked wherever they are." Thus, the organisation has expressed its approval of the attempted attack without claiming responsibility for it.
The Danish Police and Intelligence will now be investigating the background and links of the arrested Somali. A question, which should be of interest to investigators in Denmark, the US and India is: Did he have any contacts with Headley? Did Headley meet him during his two visits to Denmark?
This may be read in continuation of my earlier article of December 4,2009, titled "The Somali Front of the Global Jihad" at
http://www.southasiaanalysis.org/papers36/paper3534.html , which is annexed for easy reference
B. Raman is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt. of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai. E-mail: seventyone2@gmail.co
ANNEX
The Somali Front of the Global Jihad -- International Terrorism Monitor --- Paper No.584 ( December 4, 2009)
By B. Raman
Al Qaeda looks upon its continuing jihad against the so-called Crusaders --- thereby meaning essentially the US, Israel and their supporters--- as a global intifada waged on many fronts and through many means. In this global jihad, Afghanistan, Somalia and Algeria are seen as battle fronts, which will determine the ultimate outcome. Afghanistan is seen as the core of the battle, Somalia as its southern front and Algeria as the Western front.
2. In a message disseminated on December 20, 2006, Ayman al-Zawahiri, the No.2 to Osama bin Laden in Al Qaeda, said: “Brothers in Islam and Jihad in Somalia: know that you are on the southern garrison of Islam, so don’t allow Islam to be attacked from your flank, and know that we are with you, and that the entire Muslim Ummah is with you. So don’t lose heart, or fall into despair, for you must dominate if you are true in faith. And know that you are fending off the same Crusade which is fighting your brothers in Islam in Chechnya, Afghanistan, Iraq, Palestine and Lebanon. So be resolute, be patient and be optimistic, for by Allah beside whom there is no other God, even if your enemies possess thousands of tons of iron and explosives, in their chests lie the hearts of mice. So be severe against them like Muhammad was. "
3. To keep the jihad going in Somalia is one of its important objectives. For this purpose, it uses not only recruits from the impoverished local population, but also from the Somali diaspora in the West----including the US--- as well as jihad-hardened cadres sent from the battle fronts in the Af-Pak region. The Tablighi Jamaat (TJ) of Pakistan has had a long history of contacts with the Muslim population in Somalia and East African countries just as it has with the Muslim population of Chechnya and Dagestan. Though the TJ itself does not indulge in acts of terrorism, it plays an important role in facilitating the ideological motivation of the population on behalf of Al Qaeda.
In September 2009, Al Shabaab, meaning “The Lads”, an organization of Somali youths, was reported to have disseminated through Islamic web sites usually identified with Al Qaeda a 48-minute video documentary in which it proclaimed its allegiance to Osama bin Laden. It derives its name “The Lads” from the fact that it used to be the youth wing of a fundamentalist organization called the Union of Islamic Courts (UIC), which had established control over some parts of Somalia and was ultimately crushed by invading Ethiopian troops in 2006. While the elders of the UIC disappeared after being defeated by the better trained and better armed Ethiopian troops allegedly inspired and aided by the US, the Al Shabaab replaced the UIC as a born-again jihadi organization, which was determined to continue the jihad against the troops of the African Union, which had replaced the Ethiopian troops, and of the UN-backed local Government, which it viewed as apostate.
Though Somalis had participated in acts of suicide terrorism on behalf of Al Qaeda in other countries, suicide terrorism was unknown in Somalia itself till Al Shabaab made its appearance in 2006. Even though it proclaimed its loyalty to bin Laden only in September, 2009, it had carried out a number of acts of suicide terrorism against local Government targets as well as the peace-keeping troops of the African Union ever since the AU troops took over their peace-keeping responsibility in Somalia. Al Shabaab has been waging a two-front jihad---- against the AU troops and the local Government being protected by the AU troops. The first act of suicide terrorism took place on September 18, 2006. Since then, there have been 13 suicide attacks--- two in 2006, four in 2007, two in 2008 and five this year.
The Al Shabaab cadres, many of whom had allegedly served with the Afghan Mujahideen, the Taliban and Al Qaeda in the Af-Pak region, look upon their jihad as similar to the jihad waged by the Afghan Mujahideen against the Soviet troops and those of the Government of the then President Najibullah in the 1980s and the early 1990s.
In a serious attack of suicide terrorism, a male suicide bomber dressed as a woman managed to find his way into a graduation ceremony of medical students in a Mogadishu hotel on December 3, 2009, and blew himself up killing 19 persons, including three Ministers of the Cabinet of Prime Minister Omar Sharmarke of the UN-backed Government. Even though no organization has so far claimed responsibility for the attack, Al Shabaab is strongly suspected by the local authorities.
Though there is so far no evidence of any nexus between Al Shabaab and the Somali pirates, the dangers of money earned from piracy going to the coffers of Al Qaeda and the availability in Somalia of sea-faring people who could be used by Al Qaeda for future acts of maritime terrorism cannot be ignored.
A Reuters report carried on December 4, 2009, by the “Daily Times” of Lahore has quoted Bethuel Kiplagat, who used to be Kenya’s special envoy to the Somalia peace process from 2003 to 2005, as saying as follows: “Suicide bombings are a worrying trend not only for Somalia but also the region. There has been a rise in fundamentalism in Somalia coming from the Middle East and Pakistan. There’s a worry Al Qaeda may be looking at Somalia as a new sanctuary.”
On March 16, 2009, Mohamed Mohamed of the BBC’s Somali section, reported as follows: “As well as alleged links to al-Qaeda it is said to have Arabs, Asians, other Africans and - America's FBI believes - Westerners among its ranks. These foreigners are said to be involved in training Al Sabaab recruits in various aspects of guerrilla warfare, including suicide bombings and booby traps.”
On February 29, 2008, the then US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice designated Al Shabaab as a Foreign Terrorist Organization under Section 219 of the Immigration and Nationality Act.
Sunday, January 03, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...









