Alleged Coup D’etat In Kyrgyzstan Leaked Onto Youtube

A recording of a conversation between what appears to be Kyrgyzstan’s ousted president’s son and brother was posted on Youtube. The recording reveals plans to topple the interim government and return the ousted regime.

The audio was allegedly sent as a media file from a Kyrgyz number registered to an employee of the US Embassy in Kyrgyzstan. The Embassy has, in turn, denied any involvement in the matter.

“We need 500 low-lives who could raise hell,” the man, who sounds like Maksim Bakiev, son of former President Kurmanbek Bakiyev, says in the recording. “You know, walk into the White House…claim power. They just have to call themselves the interim government and say they already signed some decrees for peace and stuff.”

Most of Bakiev's family had high posts within his government, and as the recording points out, could be now planning to return to power.

One is, however, naturally tempted to wonder if the recording may be a hoax. But Ruslan Milchenko from the Federal Information Centre says the quality of the recording leads one to trust its authenticity.

“As an audio expert, I can give you almost a 100% guarantee that this is not fake,” Milchenko said. “The quality of the recording, the evident lack of editing – all this makes me believe this is the real deal. Of course, I can't say whose voices these are; only a full-on audio analysis and comparison can do that. But taking into consideration the point of this dialogue, the things being said, and the current political situation in Kyrgyzstan – the dialogue makes sense. It feels real.”

While this may settle the question of the recording's authenticity, an even bigger question of who may have recorded the conversation still remains.

Could it have been the interim government keeping an eye on potential enemies?

“Pretty much anyone can listen in to a cell phone conversation. It calls for some pricey equipment, but it can be done,’ said Milchenko. “So these people should have probably looked out their windows more often. They would have seen a little black van there – it would have given them a hint."

If one of the voices on the tape really is Bakiev's bother, it is somewhat strange that he – a man who was once in charge of state security services – himself became the object of surveillance.

The recording is also clearly aimed at an international audience since all of the 40 minutes of the conversation are fully subtitled in English.

If indeed authentic, however, the recording could be a sign of desperation from the Bakiyev clan, experts say.

“They are going to try many things to win back power,” said an expert on Kyrgyzstan’s political affairs, Sanabar Shermatova. “They are clearly cornered, and so they will attempt anything they can think of. This specific plan, of course, is somewhat raw, because it is only the taking of the White House, and that’s is not enough to rule the country.”

The Bakiyev family already has a few tricks up their sleeves.

“We need to keep the situation destabilized. We need people to constantly wreak havoc in the country,” Maksim Bakiyev appears to be saying in the recording.

Source: RT
Saturday, May 22, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Bishkek Fears Russia Wants A Protectorate Over Kyrgyzstan

By Paul Goble

Continuing violence in Kyrgyzstan, especially in the south, and Russian moves that some in Bishkek see as intended to discredit the Provisional Government have prompted some in Kyrgyzstan and elsewhere to speculate that Russia wants to establish a protectorate over Kyrgyzstan in order to restore order.

But according to an analysis posted online in Moscow today, the Russian government is extremely reluctant to move in that direction, having been chastened by the costs financial and political of its recognition of and assumption of responsibility for Abkhazia and South Ossetia after the August 2008 war with Georgia.
Writing for Stoletiye.ru, Aleksandr Shustov, a frequent commentator on Central Asia, says that increasing violence in Kyrgyzstan has “increased concerns about the possibility of the introduction of ‘external rule’ or ‘a protectorate’” by Russia or some combination of powers (www.stoletie.ru/rossiya_i_mir/moskve_navazyvajut_protektorat_nad_kirgizijej_2010-05-20.htm).

The Moscow analyst suggests that people who were part of the former Kyrgyzstan government have as their “tactical goal” the “seizure of power in three southern oblasts which they to all appearances in the case of irresoluteness or slowness on the part of the Provisional Government, they count on holding.”

The “strategic” goal of these people, Shustov continues, citing media reports, is the maintenance of control over economic interests so that they can play this “card” in future relations with Bishkek regardless of whether it succeeds in stabilizing the situation or ultimately fails to do so.

Toward those ends, the Russian commentator says, “the opponents of the Provisional Government are attempting to use [the latter’s] lack of legitimacy and consequently the shaky legal status of the governors it has assigned in the southern regions,” as well as discontent among non-Kyrgyz nationalities, Islamist radicals, and criminal groups with ties to the drug trade.

Two days ago, Azimbek Beknazarov, the vice president of the Provisional Government who has been tracking developments in the south, said that “we are predicting the third wave of the counter-revolution in Kyrgyzstan,” a prediction that the clashes between Kyrgyz and Uzbek groups in Jalal-Abad yesterday appears to confirm.

According to the Provisional Government leader, “the next attempt at destabilization of the situation will be undertaken on an inter-ethnic basis,” with the regime’s opponents seeking to exploit ethnic tensions between Kyrgyz and Uzbeks in the south. The events of the last 24 hours suggest his prediction was accurate.
But because of this instability, Shustov continues, rumors are circulating in Bishkek “about the possible introduction of “foreign rule’ or a protectorate which Russia and Kazakhstan may establish.” These rumors have been sparked by the appointment of Vladimir Rushaylo, the former Russian interior minister, as special representative of Moscow and Astana.

Moreover, as Elmira Nogoybayeva, the head of the Kyrgyz Polis Asia Analytic Center has noted, “there has been a consistent campaign in the mass media of Kazakhstan and Russia aimed at discrediting the image of Kyrgyzstan, all the more so after the Provisional Government announced a draft constitution calling for a parliamentary form of government.

Such a regime if established would by its very nature, she argued, represent a challenge to the authoritarian presidential regimes in both Kazakhstan and the Russian Federation. But criticism of Bishkek’s plans, she insisted, represents “crude interference in the internal affairs of sovereign Kyrgyzstan.”

According to Shustov, “the idea of introducing a Russian protectorate in Kyrgyzstan came from beyond the ocean” in an analysis prepared by Nikolay Zlobin of the Washington Institute of World Security. The Russian-American analyst suggested that a protectorate might be the only way to save the situation and prevent an unwelcome Chinese intervention. .

But according to Shustov, this idea does not currently enjoy “particular enthusiasm” either in Kyrgyzstan where it might lead to the extinction of independence or in Russia where it would mean the assumption by Moscow of “all responsibility for the situation” in that Central Asian republic.

People in Moscow have not forgotten the enormous expenses it assumed and continues to pay for in South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and they know that “support of the much larger and more populous Kyrgyzstan, a republic without a common border with Russia would require much greater expenditures.”

But even more important, any such Russian move would not only force Russia to use its own forces to control the situation but could trigger a new outburst of hostility toward Moscow much as the August 2008 war in Georgia did. And consequently, Shustov concludes, it is “not accidental” that Rushaylo has insisted that he “does not intend” to interfere in Kyrgyz affairs.


Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .  
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

OSCE Calls For Restraint After Deadly Kyrgyz Unrest

(RFE/RL) -- The Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) is urging all parties in Kyrgyzstan to avoid further violence following clashes in the south of the country that left at least two people dead.

The call came as thousands of people rallied again today in Jalal-Abad.

The Kyrgyz interim government declared a state of emergency and imposed a night curfew in the southern city of Jalal-Abad following the May 19 violence. The state of emergency began on May 19 and will run through June 1 and sets a curfew from 8 p.m. to 6 a.m.

The violence included shots being fired as protesters tried to storm a university in Jalal-Abad that serves as a focal point for the local ethnic Uzbek minority. It was not clear who opened fire.

The incident has prompted fears of possible ethnic tensions in the Kyrgyz city, which has a sizeable community of ethnic Uzbeks.

In a statement, Kazakhstan's Foreign Minister Kanat Saudabaev, who currently chairs the OSCE, said "conflicts on ethnic grounds are especially unacceptable" and that overcoming the crisis in Kyrgyzstan will require that "public safety, rule of law, peace, and stability be ensured."

Saudabaev said he had spoken by telephone with Kyrgyzstan's interim government head Roza Otunbaeva and expressed concern about the continued unrest that has followed last month's ouster of President Kurmanbek Bakiev in violent protests.

The interim government announced on May 19 that Otunbaeva has been named interim president of the country. Officials in Bishkek said that Otunbaeva, who has headed the government since Bakiev was forced from power, would remain head of state until December 2011.

Otunbaeva condemned what she termed attempts to "sow the seeds of discord among our people, especially between Uzbeks and Kyrgyz."

"I want to assure you that we are monitoring the situation and we have engaged all the necessary forces," she said.

The interim government has accused Bakiev supporters of trying to stir up ethnic violence in the country.

'No One Here Came To Support Bakiev'

But at least one demonstrator, Bolot Jooshbaev, told RFE/RL that the protesters were not marching in support of Bakiev, but against a local Uzbek minority leader, Kadyrzhan Batyrov.

"No one here came to support Bakiev. We are just demanding that Kadyrzhan Batyrov be brought here, or acting Governor Bektur Asanov, or some chief of security forces," he said. "But so far, nobody has come out to talk to us."

An RFE/RL correspondent at the scene, Rysbai Abdraimov, said the latest protest started peacefully at the local horse-racing track.

Demonstrators chanted slogans against Batyrov, accusing him of provoking tensions in the area. They also accused Batyrov supporters of setting fire to Bakiev's family home in the nearby village of Teyyit in recent days.

Then protesters marched toward the Friendship of Nations University, which is funded by Batyrov.

Batyrov, a wealthy businessman and former lawmaker, enjoys support among Jalal-Abad's Uzbek community. He has officially backed the interim government in the south, where Bakiev has his strongest support.

Special police forces stationed around the university building shot into the air trying to disperse the crowd, which was throwing stones toward the building, smashing windows. Abdraimov says some protesters were also throwing stones toward police officers.

Special troops are also stationed around the provincial government office, which was the scene of violent protests last week, when Bakiev supporters took over the government building.

Our correspondent said it was not clear who the organizers of the latest protests were.

Ergash Khuja, an ethnic Uzbek in Jalal-Abad, told RFE/RL that the Uzbek community was "anxious" about the latest events. However, he said, "It seems government forces are capable of preventing" any possible attacks.

"Uzbeks live in this city in large numbers," Khuja said. "Now they are gathering in small groups in their neighborhoods, watchful of anyone who would try to enter their neighborhoods."

Officials in Bishkek say they see a link between the events in Jalal-Abad and last week's violent protests in the south. On May 12-14, Bakiev supporters staged demonstrations in Batken, Jalal-Abad, and Osh, briefly occupying provincial government buildings in all three places.

Bakiev was toppled in the aftermath of antigovernment protests that killed at least 85 people in the capital, Bishkek, in April.


Written by Farangis Najibullah in Prague with contributions from RFE/RL Kyrgyz Service correspondent Rysbai Abdraimov in Jalal-Abad and agency reports. Copyright (c) 2009. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
Thursday, May 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kazakhstan Reopens Border With Kyrgyzstan

Kazakhstan reopened its border with Kyrgyzstan on Wednesday after closing it in April due to violent unrest that led to the ouster of Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek Bakiyev, the Kazakh Foreign Ministry said.

Kyrgyzstan was rocked by massive protests in early April, with more than 80 people killed as an interim government took power and Bakiyev fled the capital and then the country. His supporters later hit back at the new authorities in an attempt to regain power. Several people were killed and scores were injured in new wave of violence.

"Considering the difficult social and economic situation in Kyrgyzstan and taking into account multiple calls from the people of our friendly country, Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev has ordered the government to lift all temporary limitations on the Kazakh-Kyrgyz state border," a statement from the ministry said.

The ministry said, however, that the work of border, customs and migration bodies will be tightened.

On Wednesday, the prime minister of Kyrgyzstan's provisional government was given presidential authority until elections are held in the country.

The government adopted a decree delegating power to an interim president until December 31, 2011. The document named interim Roza Otunbayeva as the provisional president, but also envisaged a nationwide referendum on the issue as an option.

Source: RIA Novosti
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyzstan's Otunbayeva Handed Presidential Authority

Leader of the provisional Kyrgyz government Roza Otunbayeva was given presidential power on Wednesday until elections are held in the country.

The government adopted a decree that delegates power to an interim president until December 31, 2011. The document named interim Premier Otunbayeva as the provisional president, but also envisaged a nationwide referendum on the issue as an option.

The decree stipulates the provisional president may not participate in the forthcoming presidential elections. From now on Otunbayeva has no right to "be a member of a political party, must keep political neutrality and refrain from any actions supporting political parties."

The interim government is currently discussing the final draft of the Constitution of Kyrgyzstan. A referendum on the new Constitution is slated for June 27.

The interim government took power in Kyrgyzstan on April 7 after mass protests. Ex-president Kurmanbek Bakiyev fled the country and later resigned. He has taken refuge in Belarus.

Source: RIA Novosti
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

At Least 1 Killed, 16 Injured In New Kyrgyzstan Protests

At least one person was killed and another 16 injured on Wednesday in new clashes in the ex-Soviet Central Asian republic of Kyrgyzstan, spokeswoman for the Kyrgyz interim Health Ministry Svetlana Baytikova said.

Up to 3,000 supporters of ousted president Kurmanbek Bakiyev took part in the protests in the southern Kyrgyz town of Jalalabad.

The protesters were demanding a judicial inquiry into the actions of the leader of the local Uzbek community, Kadyzhan Batyrov, who they accuse of setting fire to houses belonging to relatives of Bakiyev and encouraging his supporters to use guns during uprisings in Jalalabad's central square on May 14.

Eyewitnesses said gunshots were heard near the University of Peoples' Friendship, which is headed by Batyrov. They said police and Special Forces officers, who initially cordoned off the university buildings, retreated for their own safety.

The Kyrgyz interim government fears ethnic conflicts in the region because of the large numbers of ethnic Uzbeks residing there.

Kyrgyz interim Prime Minister Roza Otunbayeva said the situation in the south of Kyrgyzstan had deteriorated again.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government led by Roza Otunbayeva took power on April 7 amid violent protests in which more than 80 people died. President Bakiyev fled the country and resigned.

Since then, Kyrgyzstan has seen two waves of riots between supporters of the deposed leader and backers of the interim government, in which a total of seven people were killed and more than 90 were injured.

Source: RIA Novosti
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Is Kyrgyzstan Ready For A Legal Islamic Political Party?

By Ulan Temirov

Some believers in Kyrgyzstan think the political upheaval that brought down Kurmanbek Bakiyev’s administration has created a new opportunity to mix faith and politics. There’s even talk these days that Kyrgyzstan could become the second Central Asian state, after Tajikistan, to feature a legally operating Islamist political party.

The Bakiyev administration was perceived as hostile to most forms of Islamic religious expression, especially anything with a political message.

The provisional government, which assumed power amid the early April upheaval in Bishkek, is seen as more open to incorporating the views of moderate believers into the political process.

Kyrgyzstan’s citizens are predominantly Muslim, at least culturally. Taking a step to acknowledge this fact, the provisional government invited Muslim leaders to provide input in the drafting of a new constitution. The new basic law may well raise Islam to the level of state religion. The text of the draft constitution is scheduled to be released May 19. It is slated to be put to a popular referendum on June 27.

One member of the constitutional commission, Duishon Abdyldaev, head of Akyl-Es-Ruh-Yiman (Wisdom-Spirit-Faith), a religious movement seeking to unite believers under a traditional form of Kyrgyz Islam, said the new constitution should consider the needs of the faithful. But he stopped short of endorsing an Islamic party.

“We want the new constitution to reflect the interests of millions believers in Kyrgyzstan,” he told EurasiaNet.org. “The acting constitution was outdated because, after the collapse of the Soviet Union, Kyrgyzstan adopted a constitution for an atheistic society and state. That is not the reality any longer, as the lion’s share of the population is Muslims and Orthodox Christians.”

Abdyldaev’s views appear to widely resonate throughout Kyrgyz society. Though religious practice among Muslims and Christians is on the rise, many believers are reluctant to endorse the creation of an Islamic political party. Many fear that such a party could end up becoming a source of radical Islamic activity, which, in turn, would fan instability, and even terrorism.

Abdyldaev suggested Kyrgyzstan should look to the United States for inspiration on how to keep religion and the state separate, yet make faith an electoral issue. “That will help bring more honest and devoted people to power,” he said.

Despite the widespread concern about the potential growth of radical Islam, some religious activists want the new constitution to pave the way for a party based on Islamic precepts.

“With proper constitutional amendments and Kyrgyzstan’s new political path towards a parliamentary republic, it is very possible that, gradually, some political party will be established that will attract people based on moral and religious principles,” said a member of Tabligh Jamaat, one of the largest international Islamic movements in Kyrgyzstan, speaking on condition of anonymity. He downplayed the radical Islamic threat by pointing to the existence of moderate, religious-oriented parties elsewhere, including the Justice and Development Party in Turkey and the Islamic Renaissance Party of Tajikistan.

Also speaking on condition of anonymity, an imam at a Bishkek mosque said he would like to see politics and politicians grow closer to Islam. His fear, however, is that politicians would manipulate faith in order to pursue their own ends. “Though we do not have legal structures for religious political parties, it would be great to have religion in Kyrgyzstan as a core of moral values and principles in our politicians,” the imam said.

Officials do not appear to share such hope. Many are steadfast in their desire to see Kyrgyzstan remain secular.

Kanybek Osmonaliev, who served as director of the State Committee for Religious Affairs until May 14, told EurasiaNet.org days before his dismissal that the state must protect secularism to ward off increasing religious tensions. “According to our constitution, the creation of parties based on religious principles is prohibited,” he said.

Kyrgyzstan's state-run Muftiyat – a board of Islamic clergy governing all official mosques throughout the country – has supported Osmonaliev's position. “The level of education and preparedness for political activity among believers is inadequate to match contemporary challenges,” said Loma Yusur, an advisor to the Muftiyat. Simultaneously, he recognized that “Muslims are also citizens and a part of the electorate. Thus, in order to protect the interests of electorate, it should be written in the constitution that a majority of the population is Muslim,” he told EurasiaNet.org.

The time is not yet right for the creation of a religious party, agreed Kadyr Malikov, head of the independent analytical center Religion, Law and Politics, a widely respected observer of religious affairs. Kyrgyz society is too easily susceptible to secularist fears, he said, and religious figures are not ready for the responsibility of leading a party.

“Political parties in Kyrgyzstan, both in opposition and in power, are ideologically colorless. That's why the political elite plays up [the threat of radical influence from] Afghanistan to intimidate the population from accepting an ideological religious party. Secondly, Muslims are not ready for public and political activity. There are not many educated lawyers, politicians and economists among Muslims,” he said. “I am afraid that if an Islamic party was created today, it would hurt the perception of religious parties.”

Still, Malikov believes the state must create an official place for sincere discourse with believers. “Such a political platform and dialogue between the state and Islam will [help] avoid extremism,” he concluded.


Ulan Temirov is the pseudonym for a journalist based in Bishkek. Copyright (c) 2003 Open Society Institute. Reprinted with the permission of the Open Society Institute, 400 West 59th Street, New York, NY 10019 USA, www.EurasiaNet.org or www.soros.org.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyz Interim Government Braces For New Opposition Riots

Supporters of Kyrgyzstan's ousted president are preparing to provoke a new round of unrest in the Central Asian state, the interim government's deputy head Azimbek Beknazarov said on Tuesday.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government led by Roza Otunbayeva took power on April 7 amid violent protests in which more than 80 people died. President Kurmanbek Bakiyev fled the country and resigned.

Since then, Kyrgyzstan has seen two waves of riots between supporters of the deposed leader and backers of the interim government, in which a total of seven people were killed and more than 90 were injured.

"We are waiting for the third wave. According to our information, a group of bribe-takers and supporters of Bakiyev are trying to provoke interethnic clashes," said Beknazarov, who oversees law enforcement agencies in the interim government.

He said "certain politicians" were trying to ignite interethnic clashes between Kyrgyz and Uzbeks in the south of the country. "We know who is behind this, but to preserve stability we will give them time to think again," Beknazarov said.

He suggested, however, that the opposition would try to sabotage the June 27 referendum on the adoption of a new constitution.

"They will take active steps so that the referendum does not take place," Beknazarov said.

The new constitution is set to change Kyrgyzstan from a presidential to a parliamentary republic, reducing the power of the president.

Source: RIA Novosti
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyzstan Leaders Say They've Regained Control of Their Country

By Jessica Golloher

Kyrgyzstan's interim government says it has regained control of three southern provinces after supporters of deposed President Kurmanbek Bakiyev took over government buildings. Meanwhile, Moscow has also pledged to help the volatile former Soviet Republic.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government, lead by former foreign minister, Roza Otanbayeva, says that it has restored power. This after supporters of ousted President Kurmanbek Bakiyev stormed government buildings in the provinces of Osh, Jalalabad and Batken.

Witnesses say demonstrators used sticks, guns and rocks during the clashes that drew hundreds of protesters throughout the southern part of the country, seen by many as Mr. Bakiyev's power base.

Moscow and Washington have both voiced their concern over the turmoil in the mostly Muslim Central Asian state. Both the United States and Russia have military bases in the country.

The Russian government was so worried about the tense situation in the neighboring region that Russian President Dmitry Medvedev sent a special envoy to the former Soviet Republic in a show of support.

Vladimir Rushailo, a former interior minister and security council secretary, has been put in charge of improving relations with Kyrgyzstan.

Rushailo says Moscow will do its part to help quell violence in the region.

He says Russia's aim is to provide help in all areas of the Kyrgyz state.

Ms. Otanbayeva praised Moscow's show of support.

She says Russia came to help us. Russia is with us. She said Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev made it clear and said Russia will support us both politically and financially through this difficult period. Ms. Otanbayeva quoted Presdent Medvedev as saying Kyrgyzstan has to come out of this dead end, it has to protect the integrity of the country and keep the control in the government's hands and Russia will be there together with Kyrgyzstan during these difficult days.

Kyrgyzstan's interim government claims Mr. Bakiyev orchestrated the unrest in the southern areas, which officials are calling a coup attempt.

Mr. Bakiyev fled the country, to Belarus in April, after the opposition staged demonstrations in the capital of Bishkek. They demanded that he step down over claims of rampant corruption. They also demanded that Mr. Bakiyev remove his many family members from office. At least 85 people were killed in the violent clashes.

Source: VOA
Saturday, May 15, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyz Provisional Government Regains Control Of Southern Cities

By David Trilling and Alina Dalbaeva

Clashes in southern Kyrgyzstan on May 14 left at least one person dead and 63 wounded. The political violence came as the provisional government in Bishkek reasserted its authority in the South less than 24 hours after supporters of former president Kurmanbek Bakiyev seized government buildings in three regional capitals.

In Batken, Jalal-abad and Osh, provisional government supporters regained control of local political institutions, restoring governors to power who had been driven from their offices the previous evening. [For background see EurasiaNet’s archive]. Followers of the Ata-Metken Party, a member of the provisional governing coalition, spearheaded the efforts in Osh and Jalal-abad to put down the pro-Bakiyev uprising.

By evening, the provisional government had deployed Interior Ministry troops and Army special forces to maintain order in Osh, southern Kyrgyzstan’s largest city. A sense of relative calm settled over both cities by nightfall. In one neighborhood on the outskirts of Jalal-abad, outdoor cafes were filled with people.

Earlier in the day, Jalal-abad had been the scene of intense firefights. At least 26 people sustained gunshot wounds, local news outlets quoted Ministry of Health representatives as saying. The street battles involved hundreds of partisans on both sides, armed with everything from rocks to Kalashnikov automatic rifles and Molotov cocktails.

Jalal-abad’s regional administration building, in which Bakiyev supporters had holed up for a good portion of the day, suffered extensive damage.

Bektur Asanov -- the provisional governor in Jalal-abad, who had himself been roughed up as Bakiyev supporters removed him from office on May 13 -- visited some of the injured in a local hospital. An aide to Asanov said that the provisional government was in full control of the city.

Late on May 14, Defense Minister Ismail Isakov arrived in Jalal-abad to hold security consultations with Asanov.

In the capital Bishkek, leading figures in the provisional government were quick to blame Bakiyev, along with his family members and political allies, for fomenting the trouble. [For background see EurasiaNet’s archive]. Speaking at a May 14 news conference, General Prosecutor Azimbek Beknazarov announced that Usen Sydykov, a former Bakiyev aide, had been arrested on charges of organizing the southern uprising. The provisional leadership is in possession of phone recordings that allegedly catch Sydykov issuing instructions concerning the take-overs of government buildings in Osh and Jalal-abad, Beknazarov said.

Meanwhile, Keneshbek Dushebaev, the provisional head of the State Committee for National Security, insisted that the former president’s son, Maxim Bakiyev, along with Bishkek’s former mayor, Nariman Tuleev, were financing the uprising in the South, according to a report distributed by the 24.kg news agency. Dushebaev also castigated Kazakhstan, alleging that officials in Astana were aware that the younger Bakiyev and Tuleev were in Almaty, and were not willing to apprehend them and extradite them back to Kyrgyzstan, 24.kg reported.

Beknazarov cautioned that Bakiyev elements were also trying to destabilize the capital. “Followers of the ex-president are giving money to residents of Bishkek, calling them to organize mass unrest,” Beknazarov said in public comments.

While the provisional government has regained the helm in southern provinces, its ability to govern remains tenuous, some experts say. They point out that the reliability of security forces in southern provinces remains a big question mark. Police officers and Interior Ministry personnel who were ostensibly loyal to the provisional government offered feeble resistance, and in some instances stood aside, when Bakiyev loyalists stormed government buildings on May 13.

“This is a major point of concern. The regime has no grip on the country, they are relying on factions to retain informal support,” Paul Quinn-Judge, the Central Asia Project Director for the International Crisis Group, told EurasiaNet.org.

In an indicator that the situation in southern provinces remains volatile, five homes reportedly belonging to Bakiyev family members in the village of Teyit, in the Jalal-abad Region, were set on fire late on May 14 by a mob of about 100, the AKIpress news agency reported.


David Trilling is EurasiaNet’s Central Asia news editor. Alina Dalbaeva is a freelance writer based in Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan. Copyright (c) 2003 Open Society Institute. Reprinted with the permission of the Open Society Institute, 400 West 59th Street, New York, NY 10019 USA, wwwEurasiaNet.org. or www.soros.org.
Saturday, May 15, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

EU Calls For Calm In Kyrgyzstan

(KUNA) -- European Union Foreign Policy Chief Catherine Ashton has expressed "serious concern" over the deteriorating security situation in Kyrgyzstan, after one person was killed and 37 wounded on Friday in violence between supporters of ousted President Kurmanbek Bakiyev and those backing the interim government in the south of the country.

"I call on all political actors within and outside the provisional government to refrain from violence and unlawful action in this difficult period in the interest of stability of the nation," she said in a statement here today.

Ashton urged them to do everything to calm the situation and not to escalate it further.

"I am convinced that, in the present situation, there is no alternative to the way chosen by the provisional government to return to full constitutional order in the country," she said.

Ashton called on all political actors to concentrate their efforts to put a fully legitimate government in place, to finalise the draft constitution, bring it to popular vote in a referendum and, on its basis, hold fair and transparent elections, through which the Kyrgyz people will determine its new leadership.
Saturday, May 15, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Fresh Clashes In Kyrgyzstan Prompt Call For Restraint From UN Chief

Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon has issued a call for calm and restraint as reports of violence and loss of life emerge from Kyrgyzstan, where clashes have broken out between supporters and opponents of the Provisional Government.

One person was reportedly killed and at least 58 wounded in the seizures of Government buildings in Osh, Jalalabad and Batken in southern Kyrgyzstan.

“The Secretary-General urges all concerned to show restraint and to resolve issues peacefully through dialogue,” Mr. Ban’s spokesperson, Martin Nesirky, stated.

“He underlines the need to respect the rule of law and appeals for calm.”

The Provisional Government has been in place in the Central Asian nation since last month, after President Kurmanbek Bakiyev was ousted in a bloody uprising in which dozens of people died.

An arrangement reached between the Provisional Government and the former leader enabled him to leave the country for neighbouring Kazakhstan.

Source: UN News
Friday, May 14, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Clashes In Kyrgyzstan, Interim Government Holds Emergency Meeting

The Kyrgyz interim government is holding an emergency meeting following clashes in the country's southern city of Jalal-Abad, an interim government spokesman said on Friday.

"Today, May 14, at 14:00 [12:00 GMT], the Kyrgyz interim government will hold an emergency meeting in the Jogorku Kenesha Square Hall on the situation in the country," a statement said.

Clashes broke out on Friday in the southern Kyrgyz city of Jalal-Abad between supporters of deposed President Kurmanbek Bakiyev and backers of the interim government.

Local media has reported fights between around 400-500 Bakiyev supporters and 4,000-5,000 backers of the interim government near the city's administration building. At least 28 people have been injured.

Bakiyev supporters said earlier on Friday they were expecting 10,000 people to gather in Jalal-Abad in support of the ousted president.

The interim government said the rally was "an attempt by Bakiyev's supporters to gain revenge and destabilize the country".

The situation in Kyrgyzstan, where bloody uprisings led to the overthrow of the government in early April, worsened on Thursday when administrative buildings in three southern regions were stormed by Bakiyev supporters.

The south of Kyrgyzstan has long been considered Bakiyev's stronghold and he initially took refuge in the region during the uprisings, before fleeing to neighboring Kazakhstan and then Belarus.

Source: RIA Novosti
Friday, May 14, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Former Kyrgyz President's Supporters Take Over Government Building In Osh

(RFE/RL) -- Kyrgyzstan has been thrown into volatility once again after supporters of ousted President Kurmanbek Bakiev raided and seized the provincial government building in the southern city of Osh.

The incident comes a month after opponents of Bakiev took power in Bishkek following his ouster in a violent uprising.

Some 300 protesters gathered in front of the local government headquarters in Osh this morning, demanding Bakiev's return. After a scuffle with guards, the protesters entered the building, forcing the provincial governor to flee.

Supporters of the interim government also gathered in Osh. Reports say that members of the two factions brawled, but there were no immediate reports of serious injuries.

The interim government says it has sent the defense minister to Osh.

Meanwhile, RFERL correspondents say an estimated several thousand Bakiev supporters have also held a protest in the city of Jalal-Abad, some 130 kilometers from Osh.

Battle Between Governors

RFE/RL correspondents at the scene say Sooronbai Jeenbekov, who was appointed Osh provincial governor by Kyrgyzstan's interim government last month, left the building surrounded by his guards.

Our correspondents say former Osh Governor Mamasadyk Bakirov and his deputy then entered their "offices."

Later, both Bakirov and Jeenbekov addressed the crowd outside the government building, where supporters of the interim government also gathered.

Protesters have demanded the return of Governor Mamasadyk Bakirov (right in March photo).
Bakirov called for the restoration of legality and the return of Bakiev. Jeenbekov called for calm and promised that the interim government would meet people's social demands and carry out reforms.

Interior Ministry spokesman Bakyt Seitov told RFE/RL's Kyrgyz Service that police were maintaining order in the city.

Seitov said that after Bakirov supporters demanded Jeenbekov step down, the new governor "is holding negotiations with the crowd outside the office. There was no outstanding abuse of public order there. The staffers of the Osh city police are controlling public order there."

Bakiev's 'Revenge'

The interim government in Bishkek says it will take measures to restore its authority in Osh, a region where support for the ousted president has been strongest.

Roza Otunbaeva, the head of the interim government, said it would not allow the ousted government to try to "take revenge."

Interim government deputy leader Azimbek Beknazarov, too, described the latest developments in Osh as an intensified attempt by "antirevolution forces" to take revenge.

Beknazarov told RFE/RL that any such attempt was doomed because the interim cabinet enjoyed support among the people.

"We can say that the situation is complicated because there is an attempt by counterrevolutionary forces to merge. They are trying to exact some kind of revenge," Beknazarov said. "After the revolution, there were different forces. But now they are starting to unite."

Extradition Demands

Bakiev, who was toppled by bloody antigovernment protests in early April, is now based in Belarus on President Alyaksandr Lukashenka's invitation.

The interim authorities have asked Belarus to extradite Bakiev to stand trial in Bishkek in connection with the deaths of protesters and for abuse of office. Some 85 people were killed during the April uprising.

Kyrgyz media reported today that relatives of the victims staged demonstrations in front of the Belarusian Embassy in Bishkek demanding Minsk hand over Bakiev to the Kyrgyz authorities.

The demonstration was organized by Meken Sheyitteri (Martyrs of the Land), a group set up by parents of the slain protesters. Demonstrators said that if Lukashenka did not extradite Bakiev, they would go to Minsk to protest in front of the Belarusian government building.

Today's developments came a day after hundreds of people gathered in Bishkek to demand the recently ousted mayor -- Nariman Tuleev, known as a Bakiev supporter -- be returned to office.


Written by Farangis Najibullah based on RFE/RL Kyrgyz Service material and agency reports. Copyright (c) 2009. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
Thursday, May 13, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Supporters Of Ex-Kyrgyz President Storm Regional Administration Office

Supporters of ex-Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek Bakiyev stormed on Thursday an administration building in the southern city of Jalal-Abad, eyewitnesses said.

They said up to 700 Bakiyev supporters had forced their way into the building. The acting governor has fled the scene.

The interim Kyrgyz government must work to avoid further tension and possible violence, the Russian foreign minister said on Thursday.

"We believe that the most important thing today is to prevent a new surge in political tension, establish legitimate bodies of state power and return the country to normalcy as soon as possible," Sergei Lavrov said.

He said it was also essential to deal with pressing socio-economic issues and that the Kyrgyz interim government was working along those lines.

Meanwhile, protesters opposed to the new government have seized a provincial administrative building in Osh, and say they are heading to other large cities in the south of the country to hold demonstrations and replace regional administrators appointed by the new authorities in Bishkek.

Ousted President Kurmanbek Bakiyev took refuge in Belarus after fleeing Kyrgyzstan last month. The interim authorities, who took power amid violent unrest in early April, accuse him of involvement in the shooting of civilians during the riots in the Central Asian country.

Source: RIA Novosti
Thursday, May 13, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyzstan May Be Opening The Way For Islamic Revolution

By Paul Goble

In order to reinforce its secular image abroad, the Kyrgyz Provisional Government has adopted a hands off approach to religious issues, one that has already led to the opening of a split “between the secular powers that be and the religiously inclined majority of the population” and could spark an “Islamic revolution,” some analysts say.

In a commentary on Portal-Credo.ru, Yekaterina Shtolts argues that Rosa Otunbayeva and her regime have compounded this danger by the way in which they have dealt with those charged and in some cases incarcerated for a mass fight that took place in the Kyrgyz city of Nookat in 2008 (www.portal-credo.ru/site/?act=comment&id=1744).

In October of that year, Shtolts recounts, a group of Muslims clashed with local officials during the Orozo-Ayt (Uraza-Bayram) religious holiday when the authorities refused to allow the celebrants to hold their meeting in the city center. As a result, approximately 100 people threw stones at the militia and city hall.

Following these clashes, the local militia detained 32 people, charging them with involving minors in the commission of crimes, mass disorders, intentional destruction of property, and attacks on government officials. “As a result,” the Moscow analyst says, “all the arrested were given gigantic prison terms – from five to 20 years incarceration.”

After the Bakiyev government was overthrown, the Provisional government agreed to amnesty these people. Aziza Abdirasudolova, head of the Kylym Shamy Human Rights Center, said that was appropriate because Nookat officials used this occasion not to punish those directly involved but to arrest those suspected of being members of Hizb ut-Tahrir.

As a result of the Provisional Government’s actions in this case, that Muslim party, which officially calls for “the peaceful construction of a caliphate,” not only recovers some of its leaders who likely were radicalized while in prison but also “more than 100 others,” who will no longer be pursued abroad.

According to Shtolts, “a great many specialists on Islam viewed and continue to view the Nookat events” as a reflection of “the irresponsibility of local officials. One who holds that view, she says, is Kadyr Malikov, director of the Religion, Law and Politics Center at the University of Madrid.

Malikov told her, Shtolts continues, that the Nookat officials acted as they did because “they complete failed to take into account that already 98 to 99 percent of the population of the South defines themselves as Muslims.” If the authorities had allowed the official Islamic leadership to be involved, things might have been different, but the powers that be didn’t.

And by their actions, these officials made the Hizb ut-Tahrir Party a hero in the eyes of the people, who the Madrid-based scholars says, began as a result of the Nookat events “to sympathize with the Hizb ut-Tahrir leaders and were converted into the potential supporters” of this movement. The release of such people will only strengthen those feelings.

Because of poverty and the Kyrgyz state’s inability to fund many parts of the social sector, the population already has a reason to turn to the Hizb ut-Tahrir. Government institutions of social support are completely inactive, Shtolts points out, and the Muslim party is winning backers by filling in the gap and could do well in any upcoming elections as a result.

Trying to contain Hizb ut-Tahrir by arrests or repression is “ineffective,” Shtolts says. Instead, she and Malikov argue, the government must address social problems and ensure that pro-Provisional Government meetings are not marked by drunkenness, something never found in Hizb ut-Tahrir actions.

Obviously, the Provisional Government is aware of the importance of dealing with Muslims, but to date, she writes, it has “consistently avoided making contacts with the religious sphere, thus spiritually cutting itself off from the people. As a result, a civilizational split has taken place between the secular powers and the religious majority.”

The only way out, Shtolts argues, is for the Government to build its ties with “official Islam,” something it has not yet done, and do more in the social sphere, something Bishkek appears to lack the money for. But if it does not take those steps, others like Hizb ut-Tahrir or even more radical groups are going to gain and the current regime is going to lose support.

Unfortunately, as M.Nurmagambetov, a Kyrgyz blogger observes today, the regime is under pressure to burnish its secular credentials with foreign governments. Indeed, it has no choice but to do so if it hopes to get the funds it needs to deal with the enormous social problems of Kyrgyzstan (www.centrasia.ru/news.php?st=1273475640).

Given its desperate situation, the Provisional Government will say whatever it has to, but as it does, Nurmagambetov continues, “the character of the dissatisfaction of the Kyrgyz crowd has begun to acquire a religious dimension,” and that in turn means “a spectre is haunting Kyrgyzstan, the spectre of religious extremism.”

And given the weakness of Bishkek, “in a large part of the country, religious fanatics striving for power dominate the scene,” a situation that he too suggests in the near future “could lead to the next revolution,” one in which people like Otunbayeva and her colleagues would be swept away.


Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .
Monday, May 10, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Putin, Not Medvedev, Remains Master Of Russian Foreign Policy

By Alexander Osipovich

Two years after the inauguration of President Dmitry Medvedev, analysts say his powerful predecessor, Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, still wields control over Russia’s foreign policy -- especially the Kremlin’s efforts to reassert influence in the former Soviet Union.

Legally speaking, this should not be the case. Under the Russian Constitution, the president oversees foreign policy while the prime minister handles the economy and most domestic matters. But few Kremlin-watchers believe that Moscow’s foreign policy is shaped by Medvedev, who took office on May 7, 2008, and is now marking the halfway point of his presidential term.

“The leading role still clearly belongs to Putin. This reflects the unspoken agreement that was reached between Putin and Medvedev,” said Yevgeny Volk, an independent political analyst in Moscow.

“There have been some nuances and accents that have changed since Medvedev’s arrival. But these are mostly stylistic differences,” Volk added.

Medvedev regularly flies around the world to attend summits and international meetings in far-flung countries. But his role at such events is often ceremonial, while Putin, often working behind the scenes, appears to achieve the meatiest results. And that plays into the “good cop, bad cop” pattern that has long characterized the two men’s relationship: Medvedev, with his image as a liberal modernizer, is more palatable to the West, while Putin is the tough guy ready to play hardball to assert Russia’s interests.

On April 8, for instance, Medvedev was in Prague signing a nuclear disarmament treaty with US President Barack Obama -- a historic, though largely ceremonial event -- while Putin was in Moscow dealing with the rapidly unfolding crisis in Kyrgyzstan. On that day, Putin became the first foreign leader to call Roza Otunbayeva, the head of the new provisional government that took power after violent protests led to former president Kurmanbek Bakiyev’s ouster. Putin’s quick move advanced Russian interests in the strategically important Central Asian state, and he followed it up a few days later by pledging 50 million dollars in loans and aid to the Kyrgyz interim government.

“There are strong economic levers in Putin’s hands,” Volk said, describing loans and energy assistance as two of the prime minister’s key tools.

Putin was also a critical player in Moscow’s other major foreign-policy triumph in April: the surprise agreement with Ukraine that allows Russia to maintain its Black Sea Fleet in Crimea for 25 more years. Kyiv offered the base extension in exchange for a 30-percent discount on its purchases of Russian natural gas. Though the agreement was signed by Medvedev and Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych, it came only after a flurry of meetings between Putin and his Ukrainian counterpart Mykola Azarov.

“In the latest Russian foreign-policy success with Ukraine… I think there is little doubt that Putin is the central figure,” said Maria Lipman, an analyst at the Carnegie Moscow Center.

“Formally, it is Medvedev who attends meetings at the presidential level. But de facto, the most important decisions in foreign policy are at the very least decided jointly, and I think it is possible that Putin’s word carries more importance,” Lipman said.

The maneuverings of Russia’s ruling tandem have been especially convoluted when they have dealt with Moscow’s arch-foe Georgia.

In August 2008, when Georgia attempted to retake control of the Moscow-backed separatist region of South Ossetia, it was Putin -- not Medvedev -- who gave the first public reaction, even though Putin was attending the Beijing Summer Olympics at the time. Later, as Russia started to deploy massive force against Georgia, Putin paid a dramatic visit to North Ossetia to meet soldiers and refugees, reinforcing his image as a man of action.

But it was Medvedev, as the commander-in-chief of the Russian military, who gave the formal order for the so-called “operation to force peace” on Georgia, and who signed the ceasefire accord brokered by French President Nicolas Sarkozy that ended the five-day conflict. [For background see EurasiaNet’s archive].

Sergei Mikheyev, an analyst at the Center for Political Technologies in Moscow, argues that this elaborate two-man performance showed that Putin and Medvedev shape foreign policy jointly.

“Some roles were filled by Medvedev, others by Putin. To say that Putin or Medvedev decided anything by themselves would be naïve,” Mikheyev said.

More recently, Putin opened a new front in Russia’s relations with Georgia by meeting a key leader of the Georgian opposition, former parliament speaker Nino Burjanadze, in early March. Burjanadze -- a fierce critic of Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili -- had a friendly meeting with Putin, who does not disguise his hatred for the pro-Western Saakashvili these days.

“Russia is trying to find people to talk to in Georgia other than Saakashvili, and Burjanadze is one such person,” Mikheyev said.


Alexander Osipovich is a Moscow-based writer who specializes in regional affairs. Copyright (c) 2003 Open Society Institute. Reprinted with the permission of the Open Society Institute, 400 West 59th Street, New York, NY 10019 USA, www.EurasiaNet.org or www.soros.org.
Sunday, May 09, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Interview: Up To Kyrgyz To Decide How To Build Their Democracy, Obama Adviser Says

(RFE/RL) -- Michael McFaul, a top foreign-policy adviser to U.S. President Barack Obama, arrived in Bishkek on May 4 and has held several meetings with members of Kyrgyzstan's interim government and representatives of nongovernmental organizations.

McFaul, who is also senior director for Russian and Central Asian affairs at the National Security Council, spoke with Gulaiym Ashakeeva of RFE/RL's Kyrgyz Service in Bishkek about his visit to Central Asia.

RFE/RL: You have mentioned a "window of cooperation" during your visit to Bishkek. Could you just describe the possibilities, direction, and format of such cooperation?

Michael McFaul: I believe and the Obama administration believes that what happened in your country in April was a terrible tragedy. Innocent lives were lost. There will be a time and a place for figuring out what happened there on all sides, and there needs to be accountability for that. But from that tragedy comes possibility as well.

What your people are doing -- and I deliberately use the word "people," not provisional government, but what your people are doing -- the possibilities here are real to establishing a real, democratic system of government in Kyrgyzstan. From the position of the Obama administration, we want to be helpful in whatever way we can to try to support that process.

It's a unique historical opportunity. It is a very challenging opportunity, many difficulties. Creating democracy is never easy, but it's a constant struggle.

What is happening now in Kyrgyzstan most certainly, first and foremost, has implications for Kyrgyzstan, but it could also be a model for other countries about how to establish democratic institutions. We want to be partners with the people of Kyrgyzstan, not any individual leader, not any individual party. That's your business, not our business. But to help establish the democratic rules of the game, we want to support that process as much as we can.

RFE/RL: In your opinion, will the strategy of "soft power" proposed by Obama's administration be effective for post-Soviet countries, including Kyrgyzstan?

McFaul: The notion that through the power of our example, we can influence and have better relations with countries is something that President Obama firmly believes. He often times uses the words "mutual respect" in dealing with other countries and other peoples. He calls for engagement with governments and has been very active in seeking to re-engage the government of the United States in world diplomacy.

But at the same time, we seek direct engagement with the people of the world, including the people of Kyrgyzstan, not just mediated through the government, and in particular, to facilitate relations between our civil society and our people and Kyrgyz civil society and Kyrgyz people so that they can have a dual-track engagement. That's his strategy, that's our philosophy. It's a fundamentally new approach to foreign policy.

Taking Sides In Kyrgyzstan

RFE/RL: The Kyrgyz Prosecutor-General's Office has already launched a criminal investigation against companies supplying fuel to the transit center at Manas Airport. What kind of actions can we expect from the U.S. side?

McFaul: We are seeking to be as transparent as possible with all the payments, all the money affiliated with the transit center and all of American governmental activities in Kyrgyzstan. We've done this already, but I think we can do more. And in the future, we want to have websites, we want to have information that goes directly to independent media and directly to the Kyrgyz people so that everybody knows who is getting paid what. We think that's good for us, that's good for the government of Kyrgyzstan, and for the people of Kyrgyzstan.

Regarding specific allegations of corruption during my trip here in meeting with the provisional government, I have handed over a list of various instruments, both American instruments and international instruments that we have at our disposal, for tracking assets and finding out where the money went and what happened. And we're fully prepared to cooperate with the provisional government, and once we hear responses from them, we'll cooperate with them in whatever way we can.

RFE/RL: In 2005, former Kyrgyz President Askar Akaev and his allies accused the U.S. government of supporting the Tulip Revolution here. And now, the current provisional government is criticizing your government for not supporting democratic changes in Kyrgyzstan. What is the truth and what is the U.S. position in this regard?

McFaul: The position of the United States and the Obama administration is very clear. We have a strategic priority to support the development of democratic institutions and we have a variety of programs, we have a variety of American organizations that work in Kyrgyzstan that do that. They are supported by the American taxpayers, they are American organizations that are independent, but their sources of funding are supported by the American government and ultimately, therefore, by the American taxpayers.

That has been a policy that we've had in Kyrgyzstan for a long time. We've been working for decades -- hundreds of millions of dollars have been spent in the name of that project.

Under the Obama administration, with this philosophy of dual-track engagement, we will continue to work with the government -- and right now the provisional government of Kyrgyzstan -- to advance democracy and to support democracy, but in parallel we're also going to engage directly with civil society, with independent media, with legal organizations to also help to advance and support the democratic process here in Kyrgyzstan. It has to be both tracks; it cannot be one or the other.

We don't support one individual or one political view and we most certainly don't support an American-style democracy. That's not our policy at all. There are lots of varieties of democracy around the world. There is no one truth, there is no one way to build democracy. Ultimately, it's the people of Kyrgyzstan that have to decide their fate, the way they want to build their democracy.

Security vs. Democracy

RFE/RL: Will regional security interest dominate human rights and democratic concerns in the U.S. policy toward Central Asian countries?

McFaul: When people say you either have to support security or democracy, that is a false choice, both historically and I would say today. President Obama said that very explicitly in its speech when he received the Nobel [Peace] Prize. He said people push us into a corner and say we have to support out security interests or our values, and he disagrees with that. Fundamentally, he believes that support of our values is also support of our national security interests. When it comes to this region or any other region, we believe democratic governments are stable, long-term partners of the United States of America.

The goal in Afghanistan is also to nurture democratic institutions. Now, there are times when we also have to have another track, which is in Afghanistan -- military force -- right? And right now we are fighting forces in Afghanistan in a war. We are not trying to convince them to accept democracy.

But I want to underscore, that's not just an American interest. That's a Kyrgyz interest, that's a Russian interest. We have a common interest here in fighting extremist forces in Afghanistan. And the women and men that travel through [Kyrgyzstan] to then go on to fight in that war, they are fighting what we consider to be a common enemy of the American people, the Kyrgyz people, the Russian people, the Uzbek people. And we have to see it that way. President Obama has been very clear, he categorically rejects the notions of "sphere of influence," "the great game."

RFE/RL: The next stop in your Central Asian trip is Kazakhstan. What are the goals of your visit there?

McFaul: One of the issues I'll be discussing there is relations between Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan, and the United States. We want to facilitate relations, talking about the border -- these are things that we, the Obama administration, are already involved in. We see that as being very important to the development of stability here in Kyrgyzstan.


Copyright (c) 2009. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
Friday, May 07, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Kyrgyzstan: Much Work To Be Done

By Chris Rickleton

One of the most notable pieces to surface  on local media platform Kloop last week was posted by Burul Usmanaliev, and related to an attack on the ownership of a trout farm in the village of Vorontsovka, just outside Bishkek. The attack took place at around 4.30 am on April 24, and occuring less than a week after the land conflicts in the village of Mayevka.

Usmanaliev's post features disturbing photos of the victim of the attack, a 35-year old employee of the trout farm. He suffered burns to his face, hands and torso when a petrol bomb was thrown into the building by an unidentified assailant. The attack is not thought to be without premise, as Usmanaliev reports [ru]:
” On April 8, more than 70 young men from neighboring villages came here [the trout farm] demanding various benefits and free trout, to which the employees were forced to obey.  On 15 and 21 April the  “guests” again visited. According to employees whou could not name these “guests”, said: “Now our people - Atambayev, Sariev came to power, you drink our water, Osh, you now have to pay us tribute.”
This remark is thought to have been in relation to the owner of the trout farm who is from the Alai region of Osh oblast, in southern Kyrgyzstan.

Usmanaliev notes that such behaviour does not represent the views of the vast majority of Kyrgyzstan's citizenry,  and challenges the new provisional government to put an end to the North-South schism which has disrupted the development of the state over the course of its 19-year independence.
‘We are proud of the apricots of Batken, of Issyk-Kul and Arslanbob, Suleiman's  mount, Manas, Genghis Khan, Kurmanzhan Datka, the tolerance and wisdom of our people and other common symbols of our homeland. Yet some people want to divide the country on the basis of geographical origin. Can the new government to curb this division?'
Such instances however, exist only as rare repositories of the uprising of April 7-8 . As a whole the situation in the country is quiet, and questions of how to move forward are now dominating minds and news space in the Kyrgyz Republic.

Erkind,   for instance, considers [ru] the experience of electronic voting in the Philippines as a model that could theoretically be applied in Kyrgyzstan, negating balot-stuffing opportunities and helping guarantee free and fair elections in the republic. The Provisional Government has already set a date for the elections - October 10 - and efforts are underway to ensure that the Central Electoral Commission is staffed by publically palatable figures. Well known human rights advocate Tolekan Ismailova has already refused the opportunity to head the CEC.

The one potential pitfall of the system proposed by Erkind is its cost. According to the user it  cost $150 million in the Philippines, and while this sum might seem modest, it is considerable in a country where the state coffers have been practically emptied by years of misgovernance.

Nakulia reported on a tele-conference between Kyrgyz expatriates living in the West and members of the Youth Party of Kyrgyzstan [ru]:
” The Teleconference ‘The future of Kyrgyzstan' was held between citizens of Kyrgyzstan who live abroad the leaders of the Youth Party, on April 24. The main topic of video-conference was “What can I do for my country?'
The organizers pushed off from John F. Kennedy quote: “Ask not what my country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country!”

The young people  at first expressed condolences to the families [of those killed in the April disturbances] and  shared their shock and their feelings. However, the question: “Are you ready to come and work for country now?” was met with an uncertain answer [by the expatriates]. Immediately the audience began spilling charges of betrayal, lack of patriotism and individualism.”

Elsewhere Afina [ru], a blogger who posts updates about the activities of mobile phone networks in the country, wrote of a meeting between provisional government Chairman Rosa Otunbayeva and the Kyrgyzstani business community, held in the Hyatt Regency hotel in Bishkek. Andrei Silich, Chairman of the communications network leader Megacom, was also in attendance.
“Businessmen representing  the banking system, the mining sector, tourism and other industries, talked about the problems they are currently experiencing.  The head of the provisional government tried, whenever possible, to give answers to all statements and proposals. Also Rosa Isakovna promised to send all  entrepreneurs' requests to the appropriate department in order to to take concrete decisions”, Afina writes.
Freedom of the press  has unsurprisingly been at the forefront of discussion in the past week, and this theme is likely to continue to attract attention from bloggers, reaching a crescendo during the build-up to and coverage of the proposed elections in October.

Kyrgyzstan fell [ru]/[eng] to 159th place (its lowest since independence) in Freedom House's official ratings scheme published earlier this month. Recently discussions [ru] have been underway to convert the state television and radio company into a ‘public', television and radio company; a step welcomed by many journalists.

Recalling a letter he sent to a Russian journalist asking for balance in the Russian media's coverage of events in Kyrgyzstan, Kloop Media Foundation President and co-founder Bektour Iskender[ru] noted the following positive outcomes of the April events:
“In fact [Kyrgyzstan] in some degree, has become much safer. Police officers, many with fear, have begun using the word “please” when they talk with citizens. The NSS [National Security Service] has not yet turned into a ministry to stifle freedom of speech and, hopefully, will not become such.

Processes [in Kyrgyzstan] have been horribly distorted in the Russian media. The Kyrgyz Republic could become the first country in Central Asia, where the president will not be the absolute authority, where there will not be a visa regime for the majority of foreigners, and the blocking Web sites will be outlawed.”
Yet the false depiction in of Kyrgyzstan as the “Wild East” is unlikely to abate in Russia anytime soon. A photo spotted by Nurbina [ru] in which a resident of Moscow holds up a placard reading “Don't awake the Kyrgyz in us” at a protest against a new general plan for the Russian capital, has been met with a mixture of shame, pride and sense of humour.


Chris Rickleton is an editor for Global Voices Online. This article was originally published by Global Voices Online, a website that translates and reports on blogs from around the world.
Friday, May 07, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Push For Kyrgyzstan Federalization Seen Having Dangerous Consequences

By Paul Goble

A new push by supporters of ousted Kyrgyzstan president Kurmanbek Bakiyev to federalize that troubled Central Asian land with Bishkek retaining control only over finances and security could lead to the fragmentation of the country, the rise of an Islamist threat there, or even the absorption of one or the other part of Kyrgyzstan by a neighboring state.

In an article in “Novaya politika” today, Andrey Areshev says that the appearance of broadsides in Southern Kyrgyzstan calling for the federalization of the country, issued in the name of a shadowy “Peoples’ Front Opposed to the Provisional Government” almost certainly reflect a move by Bakiyev (www.novopol.ru/-bomba-dlya-kyirgyizstana-text84296.html).

That is suggested, Areshev continues, by the statements of Tolon Dyykanbayev, a Bakiyev supporter and the head of this Front to Radio Liberty last week. In his remarks, Dyykanbayev said his group will propose this federal plan to the commission drafting a new constitution.

The possibility that Kyrgyzstan might split in two after the latest change in power in Bishkek, Areshev points out, has been frequently discussed, but “the absolute majority of political groupings have refused to seriously discuss such a prospect understanding the consequences it could entail.”

One outcome that some have mentioned, the analyst continues, is the inclusion of the northern part of Kyrgyzstan in Kazakhstan and the southern in Uzbekistan, a notion that was raised a decade ago. But that idea is “only one of the possible scenarios,” Areshev says, and not the most explosive.”

If the federal plan proceeds and if Bishkek’s power over the Osh and Jelal-Abad oblasts declines further, then it could happen that Islamist groups like the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan (IMU) would move in. Indeed, he says, “certain sources” are already reporting that IMU fighters are already planning to move from Afghanistan to Southern Kyrgyzstan.

Should they do so, Areshev continues, the Uzbek government would respond, possibly intervening and taking control of a large part of southern Kyrgyzstan, a development that could lead other countries to move as well or that could trigger the spread of the conflict inside Kyrgyzstan to other Central Asian republics.

As a result, Areshev says, “one can agree with the assessment of Bulat Sultanov, the director of the Kazakhstan Institute of Strategic Studies that Kyrgyzstan risks becoming a second Afghanistan,” a view he put forward last week at a roundtable in Almaaty on “Challenges and Threats to Security in Central Asia.”
That danger could prompt either the Organization of the Collective Security Treaty or the Shanghai Cooperation Organization to intervene, given that Kyrgyzstan is a member of both. But so far, neither organization has provided any indication that it has any plans in that direction, something Areshev implies could soon change.

This absence of reaction “does not mean,” he says, “that there has not been any concern in Moscow about the uncontrolled developments in one of the formally allied states.” Clearly the Russian powers that be assume that they need to provide assistance in order to prevent the situation from getting out of hand.

But it certainly appears that things are rapidly moving toward a climax, Areshev says, given that there are reports that “the provisional government does not exclude the return to the country of former president Askar Akayev” and that “certain social groups have been putting forward the idea of making Kyrgyzstan a part of the Russian Federation.”

Areshev’s analysis is likely overly alarmist, but it is important not only for Central Asia but more general. On the one hand, it appears to reflect real fears in that region about the fate of Kyrgyzstan. And on the other, it will likely make it more difficult for Moscow to push for and Kyiv to accept any plans for a serious federalization effort in Ukraine.


Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .
Thursday, May 06, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...



Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search