Israel's Disappeared
By Nadia Hijab
At first it seemed bizarre. Israel slapped a blanket gag order to prevent media coverage of the May 6 arrest of Ameer Makhoul, a prominent Palestinian citizen of Israel who heads Ittijah, a coalition of 64 major civil society organizations. Yet in no time at all the news had shot round the world, and Facebook pages were up calling for his freedom and for a demonstration in Haifa to demand his release.
So is there a point to such gag orders? It turns out there is. Unlike Makhoul's case, the news about some arrestees remains unknown for weeks. As people mobilized for Makhoul, reports began to surface about another Palestinian citizen of Israel, Omar Said, who was arrested on April 25 on his way to Jordan.
Said holds a PhD from Israel's Technion, and his innovative work at the Antaki Center for Herbal Medicine was featured in Haaretz in 2007. Legal sources affirmed that there was also a gag order against media coverage of his case and that, like Makhoul, he has not yet been allowed to see a lawyer.
Then of course there is the now famous case of Anat Kamm, the journalist who was held secretly under house arrest for more than three months earlier this year, accused of having leaked Israeli military documents concerning the premeditated killing of Palestinians in the occupied territories.
How many more are there? So wonders Didi Remez, an Israeli Jewish human rights advocate who blogs at Coteret. How many indeed? As Remez notes, Makhoul's prominence may now draw attention to a much more widespread phenomenon. Writing about the Kamm case, The Jerusalem Post reported that the Israeli police ask the courts for a gag order about 100 times a year.
Although Israel on Monday lifted the gag orders against both Makhoul and Said, the question of "how many more" is now posed with urgency, given the Israeli state's growing crackdown on its citizens -- crackdowns that are enthusiastically supported by the settler movement as it remorselessly colonizes Palestinian land.
The Israeli Palestinian community is clearly at risk. Israel has now accused Makhoul and Said of spying for Hizbullah -- similar accusations drove former Knesset member and community leader Azmi Bishara into self-imposed exile to avoid ending up in prison. Still. the community is determined to stand its ground. "We won't be silent," Ynet quoted Adalah, the legal center for Arab minority rights, and others as saying, but will struggle against "the 'legal' persecution by the Israeli government against the Arab sector."
But Jewish human rights advocates are at risk too. Israeli rightwing groups have targeted both Naomi Chazan, head of the New Israel Fund, along with Adalah in the same billboard campaign.
One outcome of the crackdown may be growing Israeli Palestinian and Jewish collaboration in defence of basic rights and freedoms: Adalah and the Association for Civil Rights in Israel together protested the Makhoul gag order to the Supreme Court. As Moshe Yaroni wrote in Zeek, a progressive American Jewish online magazine, "The erosion of rights is a dynamic that threatens every Israeli," And, he predicted, "Israel is moving toward a very frightening future; a future where most Jews will no longer be able to support Israel."
Frightening is the word that best describes the state of a person completely cut off from his world, without recourse or rights. The soft-spoken, steel-willed Makhoul has played a major role in defending Palestinian rights and identity in Israel -- indeed, Ittijah's member groups have doubled over the past few years. Makhoul's dedication has now landed him in jail. His wife, feminist scholar Janan Abdu, writes bravely on her Facebook page, "No prison in the world can absorb a whole nation." But the family must be frantic with worry -- as must other community activists. Who will be next?
Not many countries claiming to be democracies "disappear" their own citizens and deny them due process. Ironically the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, which sets democracy as a condition of membership, just welcomed Israel into its midst. By so doing, the OECD sent a terrible signal that state power trumps human rights. Further, by not holding Israel accountable for its ongoing violations in the occupied Palestinian territories, its member states risk rendering themselves complicit in its crimes.
Ever since its attack on Gaza in 2008-2009, Israel has mounted a major public relations campaign to counter popular outrage and the growing boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement calling on it to uphold international law. It accuses its critics of anti-Semitism -- even the fast-growing Jewish communities working for equality and justice. Wouldn't it be easier to admit that maybe, just maybe, Israel is doing something wrong? And that until it respects equality, justice and freedom at home and abroad, it will not secure the legitimacy it craves?
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.This article was published at Counterpunch and reprinted with permission.
At first it seemed bizarre. Israel slapped a blanket gag order to prevent media coverage of the May 6 arrest of Ameer Makhoul, a prominent Palestinian citizen of Israel who heads Ittijah, a coalition of 64 major civil society organizations. Yet in no time at all the news had shot round the world, and Facebook pages were up calling for his freedom and for a demonstration in Haifa to demand his release.
So is there a point to such gag orders? It turns out there is. Unlike Makhoul's case, the news about some arrestees remains unknown for weeks. As people mobilized for Makhoul, reports began to surface about another Palestinian citizen of Israel, Omar Said, who was arrested on April 25 on his way to Jordan.
Said holds a PhD from Israel's Technion, and his innovative work at the Antaki Center for Herbal Medicine was featured in Haaretz in 2007. Legal sources affirmed that there was also a gag order against media coverage of his case and that, like Makhoul, he has not yet been allowed to see a lawyer.
Then of course there is the now famous case of Anat Kamm, the journalist who was held secretly under house arrest for more than three months earlier this year, accused of having leaked Israeli military documents concerning the premeditated killing of Palestinians in the occupied territories.
How many more are there? So wonders Didi Remez, an Israeli Jewish human rights advocate who blogs at Coteret. How many indeed? As Remez notes, Makhoul's prominence may now draw attention to a much more widespread phenomenon. Writing about the Kamm case, The Jerusalem Post reported that the Israeli police ask the courts for a gag order about 100 times a year.
Although Israel on Monday lifted the gag orders against both Makhoul and Said, the question of "how many more" is now posed with urgency, given the Israeli state's growing crackdown on its citizens -- crackdowns that are enthusiastically supported by the settler movement as it remorselessly colonizes Palestinian land.
The Israeli Palestinian community is clearly at risk. Israel has now accused Makhoul and Said of spying for Hizbullah -- similar accusations drove former Knesset member and community leader Azmi Bishara into self-imposed exile to avoid ending up in prison. Still. the community is determined to stand its ground. "We won't be silent," Ynet quoted Adalah, the legal center for Arab minority rights, and others as saying, but will struggle against "the 'legal' persecution by the Israeli government against the Arab sector."
But Jewish human rights advocates are at risk too. Israeli rightwing groups have targeted both Naomi Chazan, head of the New Israel Fund, along with Adalah in the same billboard campaign.
One outcome of the crackdown may be growing Israeli Palestinian and Jewish collaboration in defence of basic rights and freedoms: Adalah and the Association for Civil Rights in Israel together protested the Makhoul gag order to the Supreme Court. As Moshe Yaroni wrote in Zeek, a progressive American Jewish online magazine, "The erosion of rights is a dynamic that threatens every Israeli," And, he predicted, "Israel is moving toward a very frightening future; a future where most Jews will no longer be able to support Israel."
Frightening is the word that best describes the state of a person completely cut off from his world, without recourse or rights. The soft-spoken, steel-willed Makhoul has played a major role in defending Palestinian rights and identity in Israel -- indeed, Ittijah's member groups have doubled over the past few years. Makhoul's dedication has now landed him in jail. His wife, feminist scholar Janan Abdu, writes bravely on her Facebook page, "No prison in the world can absorb a whole nation." But the family must be frantic with worry -- as must other community activists. Who will be next?
Not many countries claiming to be democracies "disappear" their own citizens and deny them due process. Ironically the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, which sets democracy as a condition of membership, just welcomed Israel into its midst. By so doing, the OECD sent a terrible signal that state power trumps human rights. Further, by not holding Israel accountable for its ongoing violations in the occupied Palestinian territories, its member states risk rendering themselves complicit in its crimes.
Ever since its attack on Gaza in 2008-2009, Israel has mounted a major public relations campaign to counter popular outrage and the growing boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement calling on it to uphold international law. It accuses its critics of anti-Semitism -- even the fast-growing Jewish communities working for equality and justice. Wouldn't it be easier to admit that maybe, just maybe, Israel is doing something wrong? And that until it respects equality, justice and freedom at home and abroad, it will not secure the legitimacy it craves?
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.This article was published at Counterpunch and reprinted with permission.
Friday, May 14, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Bending The Rules For Israel
By Nadia Hijab
Israel's inexorable accession to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development country club -- is set to be confirmed this month barring last-minute hitches. Although several OECD members have doubts about Israel's qualifications both on technical grounds and lack of shared values, no state has dared publicly oppose.
Instead, public opposition has been left to a loose and unusual network of Palestinian and Jewish organizations that have been hard at work lobbying European countries, Turkey, the United States, and other members. It has also provided a rare point for common action between Palestinian official and civil society organizations.
The "technical issues" that worried the OECD include corruption, particularly in the arms industry; intellectual property rights, particularly in the drugs industry; and the occupation.
More specifically about the occupation, Israel included data covering its illegal settlements and annexed territories in its economic report, according to a leaked OECD document cited by 18 Irish parliamentarians who called on their government to oppose Israel's membership. The OECD has apparently resolved this issue by inserting a disclaimer. It will use Israeli data without prejudice to the status of the occupied territories, as Avi Shlaim and Simon Mohun wrote in their Guardian comment calling for OECD conditions on Israeli membership.
However, prominent legal experts have raised serious problems regarding state obligations under the Fourth Geneva Convention if OECD member states pursue this planned course of action. And this may still throw up a last-minute hurdle.
Besides, as Israeli economist Shir Hever of the Alternative Information Center has pointed out, the data give an unrealistic picture of Israel's standard of living because settlers receive more services than Israeli citizens within the Green Line. He also notes that were the Palestinians under occupation to be included Israel "would have to be refused accession because of the enormous disparities in wealth."
Most seriously, from a human rights perspective, the OECD has completely ignored its own Road Map for Israel's accession, which states that Israel has to demonstrate a commitment to pluralist democracy based on the rule of law. Indeed, only a democracy can join the OECD. A 17-point memo to the OECD by the worldwide Palestinian coalition BNC (the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions National Committee) listed the many ways in which Israel does not uphold the rule of law at home or abroad.
As if on cue, Israel has just provided a compelling illustration by arresting one of its most respected citizens - Ameer Makhoul - and depriving him of due process. The indefatigable Makhoul heads Ittijah, the coalition of 64 major civil society organizations representing the Palestinian citizens of Israel. He was seized at 3 am and separated from his wife and two daughters as the police ransacked their home.
In formalizing Makhoul's detention, Israel's security forces ordered him deprived of an attorney for at least two days. Israel recently prohibited Makhoul from travel for two months. In an article he had just written about the ban -- published by Electronic Intifada on the day of his arrest -- Makhoul pointed out that the accusations against him are based on "secret evidence that I am not allowed to see." In yet another suspension of democratic norms, Israel imposed a blanket media gag on the arrest -- a bizarre move since the news spread round the world in minutes, and a Facebook page was established within hours.
The OECD hopes to influence Israeli behavior from within the organization, according to groups lobbying against accession. Who knows? Maybe the OECD will have better luck than the United Nations. Israel pledged to let Palestinian refugees return home when it become a UN member state. Sixty-two years on, we're still waiting…
Outrageous though it is, OECD member states are swayed more by economic than political arguments. Indeed, the OECD has praised Israel for liquidating the welfare state, privatizing government assets and undermining workers' negotiating power.
"It's like a trade agreement so it's not used to lobbying based on human rights," explained Miri Weingarten, who heads the London-based JNews, a platform for news and comment by anti-occupation Jewish groups. Anti-occupation -- and in some cases -- anti-Zionist groups opposing Israeli actions have flowered in Europe since the Israeli attack on Gaza in December 2008. Several have joined in the European Jews for a Just Peace network, which has led the effort against OECD membership for Israel until it upholds the law.
The determined, multifaceted outreach to member capitals in Europe, Asia and the United States had chalked up previous successes. For example, the European Union's planned upgrade of relations with Israel was put on hold in the wake of Israel's Gaza attack. Intensive lobbying by several churches and non-government organizations -- including three Israeli human rights organizations, B'Tselem, HaMoked and Physicians for Human Rights -- has helped prevent it from being acted on since.
Despite the OECD setback, parliamentarians and civil society are now mobilized in their demand that governments use economic measures to hold their peers accountable. As Ameer Makhoul wrote just before his arrest, "Injustice unites us; we are all together in this struggle."
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Israel's inexorable accession to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development country club -- is set to be confirmed this month barring last-minute hitches. Although several OECD members have doubts about Israel's qualifications both on technical grounds and lack of shared values, no state has dared publicly oppose.
Instead, public opposition has been left to a loose and unusual network of Palestinian and Jewish organizations that have been hard at work lobbying European countries, Turkey, the United States, and other members. It has also provided a rare point for common action between Palestinian official and civil society organizations.
The "technical issues" that worried the OECD include corruption, particularly in the arms industry; intellectual property rights, particularly in the drugs industry; and the occupation.
More specifically about the occupation, Israel included data covering its illegal settlements and annexed territories in its economic report, according to a leaked OECD document cited by 18 Irish parliamentarians who called on their government to oppose Israel's membership. The OECD has apparently resolved this issue by inserting a disclaimer. It will use Israeli data without prejudice to the status of the occupied territories, as Avi Shlaim and Simon Mohun wrote in their Guardian comment calling for OECD conditions on Israeli membership.
However, prominent legal experts have raised serious problems regarding state obligations under the Fourth Geneva Convention if OECD member states pursue this planned course of action. And this may still throw up a last-minute hurdle.
Besides, as Israeli economist Shir Hever of the Alternative Information Center has pointed out, the data give an unrealistic picture of Israel's standard of living because settlers receive more services than Israeli citizens within the Green Line. He also notes that were the Palestinians under occupation to be included Israel "would have to be refused accession because of the enormous disparities in wealth."
Most seriously, from a human rights perspective, the OECD has completely ignored its own Road Map for Israel's accession, which states that Israel has to demonstrate a commitment to pluralist democracy based on the rule of law. Indeed, only a democracy can join the OECD. A 17-point memo to the OECD by the worldwide Palestinian coalition BNC (the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions National Committee) listed the many ways in which Israel does not uphold the rule of law at home or abroad.
As if on cue, Israel has just provided a compelling illustration by arresting one of its most respected citizens - Ameer Makhoul - and depriving him of due process. The indefatigable Makhoul heads Ittijah, the coalition of 64 major civil society organizations representing the Palestinian citizens of Israel. He was seized at 3 am and separated from his wife and two daughters as the police ransacked their home.
In formalizing Makhoul's detention, Israel's security forces ordered him deprived of an attorney for at least two days. Israel recently prohibited Makhoul from travel for two months. In an article he had just written about the ban -- published by Electronic Intifada on the day of his arrest -- Makhoul pointed out that the accusations against him are based on "secret evidence that I am not allowed to see." In yet another suspension of democratic norms, Israel imposed a blanket media gag on the arrest -- a bizarre move since the news spread round the world in minutes, and a Facebook page was established within hours.
The OECD hopes to influence Israeli behavior from within the organization, according to groups lobbying against accession. Who knows? Maybe the OECD will have better luck than the United Nations. Israel pledged to let Palestinian refugees return home when it become a UN member state. Sixty-two years on, we're still waiting…
Outrageous though it is, OECD member states are swayed more by economic than political arguments. Indeed, the OECD has praised Israel for liquidating the welfare state, privatizing government assets and undermining workers' negotiating power.
"It's like a trade agreement so it's not used to lobbying based on human rights," explained Miri Weingarten, who heads the London-based JNews, a platform for news and comment by anti-occupation Jewish groups. Anti-occupation -- and in some cases -- anti-Zionist groups opposing Israeli actions have flowered in Europe since the Israeli attack on Gaza in December 2008. Several have joined in the European Jews for a Just Peace network, which has led the effort against OECD membership for Israel until it upholds the law.
The determined, multifaceted outreach to member capitals in Europe, Asia and the United States had chalked up previous successes. For example, the European Union's planned upgrade of relations with Israel was put on hold in the wake of Israel's Gaza attack. Intensive lobbying by several churches and non-government organizations -- including three Israeli human rights organizations, B'Tselem, HaMoked and Physicians for Human Rights -- has helped prevent it from being acted on since.
Despite the OECD setback, parliamentarians and civil society are now mobilized in their demand that governments use economic measures to hold their peers accountable. As Ameer Makhoul wrote just before his arrest, "Injustice unites us; we are all together in this struggle."
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Tuesday, May 11, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
How Obama Must Deal With Israeli Avoidance Methods
By Nadia Hijab
As Barack Obama seeks leadership of the nuclear nonproliferation cause this week, the long shadow cast by the Arab-Israeli conflict is close by. And a proliferation of peace plan advice is coming his way, inspired by reports that his administration may be planning to issue its own plan.
So far, the heaviest hitters' advice is that from former national security adviser Zbigniew Brzezinski and former Congressman Stephen Solarz, in their jointly written editorial in The Washington Post. They call on Obama to make a dramatic gesture: To travel to Jerusalem with world leaders and declare a four-point plan. This would, they argue, make it possible for Israeli and Palestinian leaders to deal with their recalcitrant elements.
I hope the president doesn't listen to them. On the face of it, the Brzezinski-Solarz plan-for-Obama's-plan looks eminently reasonable and even-handed, with bitter pills dished out to "both sides." But it puts the United States in a needlessly exposed position.
It is one thing for former government representatives to airily dismiss international law as regards Palestinian refugee rights in exchange for an Israeli agreement to share Jerusalem, which is not legally Israel's to share. It is quite another for the highest American official to do so.
The United States should indeed have a clear idea of its bottom line because it simply cannot leave the matter to be negotiated by the two sides, given the vast imbalance of power. But it should not publicly announce a peace plan. What it should publicly announce is that it will not recognize any changes Israel has made beyond the Green Line, and that it will encourage its partners to do the same.
For starters, Obama could dust off that 1979 State Department ruling that Israeli settlements are "inconsistent with international law." Never revoked, it peeps through the verbiage every now and then. Now it needs to be rearticulated forcefully.
Further, the Administration should begin public investigations of how much of its own aid -- and that of U.S. non-profits -- supports settlement activity, with a view to stemming that flow.
This will send the clearest message yet to the Israeli government -- and to the settlers -- to stop settlements and begin to pull back. Buying property there will become unattractive while supporting settlements would be a risky enterprise for law-abiding Americans.
Concurrently, the Obama administration should continue the steady if unglamorous task of pushing for a final and comprehensive agreement, albeit at a much, much faster pace and backed by clear costs for Israel for not ending its occupation. And it should call on Europe -- Israel's largest trading partner -- to help make the costs of occupation clear. This will lessen the heat on the Administration and present Israel with a determined united front that says: Yes, to security for the citizens of Israel, No to occupation, injustice, and inequality.
There is a pressing reason to go public with such a stand. The Israeli government and settlers are rapidly changing the nature of the West Bank and East Jerusalem by expanding settlements, roads, and barriers, according to the people impacted by them. And it is becoming increasingly untenable for Palestinians to hang on to their lands and homes or to a decent living, in spite of the happy spin sometimes spun about the occupied territories. Only U.S. pressure can put a stop to this, and it needs to be done now: Post-November's midterm elections may be too late.
Any attempt to cajole Israel into better behavior and to seek incremental improvements will be met with well-honed Israeli avoidance methods, as the Administration discovered over the past year. Here are just three examples of such methods.
First, they keep everyone on the run. For example, as Ha'aretz just revealed, a new Israeli military order will enable the deportation of thousands of West Bank and East Jerusalem Palestinians. Israel benefits even if the order is never implemented: Attention will undoubtedly shift to this new emergency, sucking up time and energy now spent on Jerusalem and settlements.
Second, they dig in their heels for as long as possible, and only offer minor concessions while carrying on business as usual -- as with the unconscionable siege of Gaza.
And third, they use diversionary tactics -- lately, it is the Iranian 'nuclear threat', which even defense minister Ehud Barak said is not an existential threat to Israel.
So, as Obama sifts through the peace plan advice coming his way, he would do well to keep his intentions tucked up his sleeve, go public on what America will not support, and in other ways put a brake on Israel's fast creation of facts on the ground -- while remorselessly pushing the process to a conclusion. This approach won't be easy. But it is more likely to succeed.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.This article first appeared at Counterpunch and is reprinted with permission.
As Barack Obama seeks leadership of the nuclear nonproliferation cause this week, the long shadow cast by the Arab-Israeli conflict is close by. And a proliferation of peace plan advice is coming his way, inspired by reports that his administration may be planning to issue its own plan.
So far, the heaviest hitters' advice is that from former national security adviser Zbigniew Brzezinski and former Congressman Stephen Solarz, in their jointly written editorial in The Washington Post. They call on Obama to make a dramatic gesture: To travel to Jerusalem with world leaders and declare a four-point plan. This would, they argue, make it possible for Israeli and Palestinian leaders to deal with their recalcitrant elements.
I hope the president doesn't listen to them. On the face of it, the Brzezinski-Solarz plan-for-Obama's-plan looks eminently reasonable and even-handed, with bitter pills dished out to "both sides." But it puts the United States in a needlessly exposed position.
It is one thing for former government representatives to airily dismiss international law as regards Palestinian refugee rights in exchange for an Israeli agreement to share Jerusalem, which is not legally Israel's to share. It is quite another for the highest American official to do so.
The United States should indeed have a clear idea of its bottom line because it simply cannot leave the matter to be negotiated by the two sides, given the vast imbalance of power. But it should not publicly announce a peace plan. What it should publicly announce is that it will not recognize any changes Israel has made beyond the Green Line, and that it will encourage its partners to do the same.
For starters, Obama could dust off that 1979 State Department ruling that Israeli settlements are "inconsistent with international law." Never revoked, it peeps through the verbiage every now and then. Now it needs to be rearticulated forcefully.
Further, the Administration should begin public investigations of how much of its own aid -- and that of U.S. non-profits -- supports settlement activity, with a view to stemming that flow.
This will send the clearest message yet to the Israeli government -- and to the settlers -- to stop settlements and begin to pull back. Buying property there will become unattractive while supporting settlements would be a risky enterprise for law-abiding Americans.
Concurrently, the Obama administration should continue the steady if unglamorous task of pushing for a final and comprehensive agreement, albeit at a much, much faster pace and backed by clear costs for Israel for not ending its occupation. And it should call on Europe -- Israel's largest trading partner -- to help make the costs of occupation clear. This will lessen the heat on the Administration and present Israel with a determined united front that says: Yes, to security for the citizens of Israel, No to occupation, injustice, and inequality.
There is a pressing reason to go public with such a stand. The Israeli government and settlers are rapidly changing the nature of the West Bank and East Jerusalem by expanding settlements, roads, and barriers, according to the people impacted by them. And it is becoming increasingly untenable for Palestinians to hang on to their lands and homes or to a decent living, in spite of the happy spin sometimes spun about the occupied territories. Only U.S. pressure can put a stop to this, and it needs to be done now: Post-November's midterm elections may be too late.
Any attempt to cajole Israel into better behavior and to seek incremental improvements will be met with well-honed Israeli avoidance methods, as the Administration discovered over the past year. Here are just three examples of such methods.
First, they keep everyone on the run. For example, as Ha'aretz just revealed, a new Israeli military order will enable the deportation of thousands of West Bank and East Jerusalem Palestinians. Israel benefits even if the order is never implemented: Attention will undoubtedly shift to this new emergency, sucking up time and energy now spent on Jerusalem and settlements.
Second, they dig in their heels for as long as possible, and only offer minor concessions while carrying on business as usual -- as with the unconscionable siege of Gaza.
And third, they use diversionary tactics -- lately, it is the Iranian 'nuclear threat', which even defense minister Ehud Barak said is not an existential threat to Israel.
So, as Obama sifts through the peace plan advice coming his way, he would do well to keep his intentions tucked up his sleeve, go public on what America will not support, and in other ways put a brake on Israel's fast creation of facts on the ground -- while remorselessly pushing the process to a conclusion. This approach won't be easy. But it is more likely to succeed.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.This article first appeared at Counterpunch and is reprinted with permission.
Friday, April 16, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Parsing Petraeus
By Nadia Hiijab
The ripples from General David H. Petraeus' testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee continue to spread. Mingled with excitement (or apprehension) about the administration's tough words in response to recent Israeli expansionist plans, it may signal an end to America's unconditional support for Israel.
However, less attention has been paid to the second half of this much-quoted sentence from the Petraeus testimony: "The enduring hostilities between Israel and some of its neighbors present distinct challenges to our ability to advance our interests in the AOR" (Area of Responsibility).
Yet this also raises valid questions: What are America's interests in the AOR -- where 20 countries are home to half a billion people? Is it a good thing to advance them? For answers, it is instructive to study the full 56-page testimony.
This is how Petraeus describes the AOR: "[ONE] contains vital transportation and trade routes.... [TWO] ... encompasses the world's most energy-rich region." He notes that the Arabian Gulf and Central Asia account for at least 64 and 46 percent, respectively, of the world's known petroleum and natural gas reserves, and 34 percent of crude oil production.
Thus, the United States "has substantial strategic interests in, and related to, the region." Specifically, the security of U.S. citizens and their homeland; regional stability; international access to strategic resources, critical infrastructure, and markets; and the promotion of human rights, the rule of law, responsible and effective governance, and broad-based economic growth and opportunity. The rest of the testimony describes how the U.S. armed forces in Central Command use the taxpayer money allocated by Congress to advance these interests.
In a flattering 11,000-word profile in the May 2010 of Vanity Fair, Petraeus comes across as a brilliant and dedicated man, more genuinely concerned about the peoples of the AOR than other Bush appointees.
But the testimony appears riddled with blind spots due to the framework within which the U.S. establishment functions: In the final analysis, the way the United States defines its interests trumps the way the people of the region might define their interests.
Applying a non-establishment framework reveals contradictory and unachievable AOR goals: To promote regional stability, for example, CENTCOM aims to secure host-nation populations; conduct counterinsurgency operations; and help reform or build government capacity.
But what if host-nation populations don't want to be secured by U.S. forces and those of non-democratic and corrupt governments? What if members of those host populations become collateral damage? What if they prefer indigenous forms of government to those of the United States and its partners? The United States would have to continue to impose stability, which would continue to provoke resistance.
Petraeus lists many factors directly provoking instability in the region from Afghanistan and Pakistan through Iran, Iraq, and Yemen. Yet his report is silent on the U.S. role in creating instability, whether its support of the Mujahideen to entrap the former Soviet Union in Afghanistan, or its invasion of Iraq, or the green light for Israeli attacks on Lebanon and Gaza. These realities are all within the region's living memory, and U.S. claims of concern for regional stability ring hollow.
Moving on to the security of U.S. citizens and their homeland, it can be argued that U.S. overseas interventions expose its armed forces to harm while doing little to protect the homeland. Homeland security is better, and more cheaply, achieved at home through reliable intelligence within constitutional protections, rather than by draining the economy to maintain a costly global network of over 800 military bases.
International access to strategic resources and markets? The region has traded internationally since time immemorial: Everyone buys and sells with everyone else. When markets and trade routes have been affected -- e.g., the closure of the Suez Canal in 1956, or 1967, or the oil embargo of 1973 -- this has been the result of foreign intervention.
Broad-based economic growth? This has yet to be achieved in the United States itself, so how can the U.S. army and foreign service achieve such a goal in distant lands, especially as development is an incremental process that takes generations? Nor can one promote human rights and the rule of law through the barrel of a gun.
Reading Petraeus' testimony, one is overwhelmed by how strongly the United States sees the region as its to command. In earlier decades, U.S. imperial designs were more discreetly exercised. The United States is now like Israel, directly occupying large parts of the region. Indeed, U.S.-Israeli tensions can be seen as a clash between the interests of two occupying powers.
The best way for America to achieve its goals would be to seek a definitive end to Israel's occupation and other human rights violations; to itself get out of the occupation business with its attendant violations; and, to scale back its global military presence.
Many in the region remember a time when U.S. embassies were small, attractive and easily accessible places and U.S. influence was exercised through cultural centers and institutes of higher learning. It is time to roll back. For America abroad, less is more. Much more.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.This article first appeared at Counterpunch and is reprinted with permission.
The ripples from General David H. Petraeus' testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee continue to spread. Mingled with excitement (or apprehension) about the administration's tough words in response to recent Israeli expansionist plans, it may signal an end to America's unconditional support for Israel.
However, less attention has been paid to the second half of this much-quoted sentence from the Petraeus testimony: "The enduring hostilities between Israel and some of its neighbors present distinct challenges to our ability to advance our interests in the AOR" (Area of Responsibility).
Yet this also raises valid questions: What are America's interests in the AOR -- where 20 countries are home to half a billion people? Is it a good thing to advance them? For answers, it is instructive to study the full 56-page testimony.
This is how Petraeus describes the AOR: "[ONE] contains vital transportation and trade routes.... [TWO] ... encompasses the world's most energy-rich region." He notes that the Arabian Gulf and Central Asia account for at least 64 and 46 percent, respectively, of the world's known petroleum and natural gas reserves, and 34 percent of crude oil production.
Thus, the United States "has substantial strategic interests in, and related to, the region." Specifically, the security of U.S. citizens and their homeland; regional stability; international access to strategic resources, critical infrastructure, and markets; and the promotion of human rights, the rule of law, responsible and effective governance, and broad-based economic growth and opportunity. The rest of the testimony describes how the U.S. armed forces in Central Command use the taxpayer money allocated by Congress to advance these interests.
In a flattering 11,000-word profile in the May 2010 of Vanity Fair, Petraeus comes across as a brilliant and dedicated man, more genuinely concerned about the peoples of the AOR than other Bush appointees.
But the testimony appears riddled with blind spots due to the framework within which the U.S. establishment functions: In the final analysis, the way the United States defines its interests trumps the way the people of the region might define their interests.
Applying a non-establishment framework reveals contradictory and unachievable AOR goals: To promote regional stability, for example, CENTCOM aims to secure host-nation populations; conduct counterinsurgency operations; and help reform or build government capacity.
But what if host-nation populations don't want to be secured by U.S. forces and those of non-democratic and corrupt governments? What if members of those host populations become collateral damage? What if they prefer indigenous forms of government to those of the United States and its partners? The United States would have to continue to impose stability, which would continue to provoke resistance.
Petraeus lists many factors directly provoking instability in the region from Afghanistan and Pakistan through Iran, Iraq, and Yemen. Yet his report is silent on the U.S. role in creating instability, whether its support of the Mujahideen to entrap the former Soviet Union in Afghanistan, or its invasion of Iraq, or the green light for Israeli attacks on Lebanon and Gaza. These realities are all within the region's living memory, and U.S. claims of concern for regional stability ring hollow.
Moving on to the security of U.S. citizens and their homeland, it can be argued that U.S. overseas interventions expose its armed forces to harm while doing little to protect the homeland. Homeland security is better, and more cheaply, achieved at home through reliable intelligence within constitutional protections, rather than by draining the economy to maintain a costly global network of over 800 military bases.
International access to strategic resources and markets? The region has traded internationally since time immemorial: Everyone buys and sells with everyone else. When markets and trade routes have been affected -- e.g., the closure of the Suez Canal in 1956, or 1967, or the oil embargo of 1973 -- this has been the result of foreign intervention.
Broad-based economic growth? This has yet to be achieved in the United States itself, so how can the U.S. army and foreign service achieve such a goal in distant lands, especially as development is an incremental process that takes generations? Nor can one promote human rights and the rule of law through the barrel of a gun.
Reading Petraeus' testimony, one is overwhelmed by how strongly the United States sees the region as its to command. In earlier decades, U.S. imperial designs were more discreetly exercised. The United States is now like Israel, directly occupying large parts of the region. Indeed, U.S.-Israeli tensions can be seen as a clash between the interests of two occupying powers.
The best way for America to achieve its goals would be to seek a definitive end to Israel's occupation and other human rights violations; to itself get out of the occupation business with its attendant violations; and, to scale back its global military presence.
Many in the region remember a time when U.S. embassies were small, attractive and easily accessible places and U.S. influence was exercised through cultural centers and institutes of higher learning. It is time to roll back. For America abroad, less is more. Much more.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.This article first appeared at Counterpunch and is reprinted with permission.
Tuesday, April 13, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
The Trouble With Gender
By Nadia Hijab
It’s another big week for women at the United Nations. March 8, International Women’s Day, falls halfway along a series of events marking the 15th anniversary of the Beijing Conference -- the last of four world conferences on women. The Commission on the Status of Women is taking stock, and no less a personage than Hillary Clinton will be speaking at the end of the woman-intensive fortnight on March 12.
Thank goodness it’s all about women. True, several speakers are addressing progress towards “gender equality,” but gender is a concept most people still have trouble with, even though it’s been in circulation for nearly 20 years. By contrast, everyone knows what a woman is.
There were good reasons to switch from talking about “women in development” -- the catchphrase of the 1970s and 1980s -- to gender. In its day WID, to use one of the many acronyms the development business trails in its wake, did a lot to move the world away from treating women as welfare cases or appendages of men.
By focusing on women’s abilities and needs, the WID movement promoted legislation to uphold women’s rights, including the convention to end all forms of discrimination against women. CEDAW (another unhappy acronym) has been signed by most world countries -- even Saudi Arabia; the United States remains a glaring exception.
But the WID approach also had some big down sides. Planners went overboard setting up special projects for women that made them marginal to national development. There was little questioning of the development process itself, which leaves hundreds of millions below the poverty line and concentrates resources among elites. Plus, WID didn’t really enable women to come to grips with the roots of discrimination and challenge entrenched patriarchal power structures.
So along came gender, to get to the core of things and show how social relations can result in discrimination against both women and men. Gender experts (myself included) earnestly preach that the term sex refers to the biological differences between women and men, while gender refers to social roles that can and do change. Neither sex should experience discrimination because of preconceptions as to how each should or should not act. The goal is to achieve gender equality within a society that upholds the rights of all citizens.
Sadly, most people still find gender a fuzzy concept. It doesn’t help that gender experts quickly slide into talking about women’s rights. This is understandable: Women’s rights have yet to be achieved the world over given the backlog of centuries of discrimination. Women partly fear that, if they start talking about the rights of men, then men will suck up all the space. Moreover, for some of those who do understand it, gender is a threatening concept. Many women as well as men resist changes in established roles, where rights and obligations are clear, in exchange for an unknown world.
As a result, “gender equality” is often used interchangeably with “women’s equality.” And, in spite of a burgeoning gender industry, development activities are rarely examined from the perspective of whether they accord women and men equal treatment and opportunities.
Another thing lost along the way is sex. I realized how far things had gone when, at a party in the early 2000s, a male friend exclaimed, “You’re not being fair to my gender.” Visa forms and landing cards started using gender instead of sex. This all muddies the conceptual waters.
Gender is potentially an essential concept. Men and women are imprisoned in roles that stymie their full potential and circumscribe their rights. No matter how backbreaking or humiliating the work, men are still expected to be the main family provider. Only a few countries entitle men to paternity leave to share in some of the joy of rearing their babies. Even though men carry out many domestic duties -- shopping, cooking, taking children to school -- women are still “naturally” expected to play those roles. When women enter the job market, they are expected and indeed still gravitate to areas related to their “natural” functions, such as education, health care, and social services -- and are paid less.
Understanding and addressing gender roles can lead to true partnership and equality of rights and responsibilities. But for this to happen, the term must be defined and used correctly.
A timely booklet has just been produced by the International Center for Research on Women, What Men have to Do with It: Public Policies to Promote Gender Equality. It summarizes the results of research on policies that promote more cooperative relations between women and men, while calling attention to men’s gender-related vulnerabilities.
This is a long overdue shift in discourse to include men as partners in the struggle for a just and equal world where neither sex experiences discrimination. If this discourse takes hold, there may yet be hope for gender equality.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
It’s another big week for women at the United Nations. March 8, International Women’s Day, falls halfway along a series of events marking the 15th anniversary of the Beijing Conference -- the last of four world conferences on women. The Commission on the Status of Women is taking stock, and no less a personage than Hillary Clinton will be speaking at the end of the woman-intensive fortnight on March 12.
Thank goodness it’s all about women. True, several speakers are addressing progress towards “gender equality,” but gender is a concept most people still have trouble with, even though it’s been in circulation for nearly 20 years. By contrast, everyone knows what a woman is.
There were good reasons to switch from talking about “women in development” -- the catchphrase of the 1970s and 1980s -- to gender. In its day WID, to use one of the many acronyms the development business trails in its wake, did a lot to move the world away from treating women as welfare cases or appendages of men.
By focusing on women’s abilities and needs, the WID movement promoted legislation to uphold women’s rights, including the convention to end all forms of discrimination against women. CEDAW (another unhappy acronym) has been signed by most world countries -- even Saudi Arabia; the United States remains a glaring exception.
But the WID approach also had some big down sides. Planners went overboard setting up special projects for women that made them marginal to national development. There was little questioning of the development process itself, which leaves hundreds of millions below the poverty line and concentrates resources among elites. Plus, WID didn’t really enable women to come to grips with the roots of discrimination and challenge entrenched patriarchal power structures.
So along came gender, to get to the core of things and show how social relations can result in discrimination against both women and men. Gender experts (myself included) earnestly preach that the term sex refers to the biological differences between women and men, while gender refers to social roles that can and do change. Neither sex should experience discrimination because of preconceptions as to how each should or should not act. The goal is to achieve gender equality within a society that upholds the rights of all citizens.
Sadly, most people still find gender a fuzzy concept. It doesn’t help that gender experts quickly slide into talking about women’s rights. This is understandable: Women’s rights have yet to be achieved the world over given the backlog of centuries of discrimination. Women partly fear that, if they start talking about the rights of men, then men will suck up all the space. Moreover, for some of those who do understand it, gender is a threatening concept. Many women as well as men resist changes in established roles, where rights and obligations are clear, in exchange for an unknown world.
As a result, “gender equality” is often used interchangeably with “women’s equality.” And, in spite of a burgeoning gender industry, development activities are rarely examined from the perspective of whether they accord women and men equal treatment and opportunities.
Another thing lost along the way is sex. I realized how far things had gone when, at a party in the early 2000s, a male friend exclaimed, “You’re not being fair to my gender.” Visa forms and landing cards started using gender instead of sex. This all muddies the conceptual waters.
Gender is potentially an essential concept. Men and women are imprisoned in roles that stymie their full potential and circumscribe their rights. No matter how backbreaking or humiliating the work, men are still expected to be the main family provider. Only a few countries entitle men to paternity leave to share in some of the joy of rearing their babies. Even though men carry out many domestic duties -- shopping, cooking, taking children to school -- women are still “naturally” expected to play those roles. When women enter the job market, they are expected and indeed still gravitate to areas related to their “natural” functions, such as education, health care, and social services -- and are paid less.
Understanding and addressing gender roles can lead to true partnership and equality of rights and responsibilities. But for this to happen, the term must be defined and used correctly.
A timely booklet has just been produced by the International Center for Research on Women, What Men have to Do with It: Public Policies to Promote Gender Equality. It summarizes the results of research on policies that promote more cooperative relations between women and men, while calling attention to men’s gender-related vulnerabilities.
This is a long overdue shift in discourse to include men as partners in the struggle for a just and equal world where neither sex experiences discrimination. If this discourse takes hold, there may yet be hope for gender equality.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Friday, March 12, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
A Tale of Two Richards - Mr. Goldstone And Mr. Falk
By Nadia Hijab
They hail from opposite parts of the globe, but they have much in common: Jewish; experts on and passionate defenders of international law; and pummeling bags for Israel and the Palestinian Authority. And the future of the law of war lies at the heart of the campaigns against them.
Richard Goldstone, whose international stature was cemented as chief prosecutor in the Yugoslavia and Rwanda tribunals, has been excoriated by Israel and its allies ever since his team submitted the report on the Gaza war requested by the United Nations Human Rights Council in September 2009. The steady stream of invective (the report is "full of lies," and he has "used his Jewishness to jeopardize the safety and security of Israel" are just two of the milder attacks) has also targeted his family and taken a toll on the publicly stoic judge.
Richard Falk, professor emeritus at Princeton University and UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in Palestinian territories occupied since 1967, has been attacked by Israel for years. But now, in a new twist, he is being hung out to dry by the Palestinian Authority. This, perhaps, the unkindest cut of all.
The PA pummeling is more discreet. It has quietly suggested to Falk himself that he resign. One reported reason is that Falk can't do his job because Israel will not allow him into the country -- though this should, one would have thought, be all the more reason to defend him.
And the PA has asked the Human Rights Council to take Falk's report off the March 22 agenda and "postpone" it to June, which the Council has done. The PA-appointed representative to the UN in Geneva insists that there are simply more important reports than Falk's on the agenda -- yet at the same time he says the PA has "many" reservations about the Falk report. The real reasons seem to be that the PA did not like the mention of Hamas in Falk's report and his earlier criticism when the PA tried to "postpone" the Goldstone Report in September under pressure from Israel and the United States. A public outcry among Palestinians reversed that decision.
The attacks on Falk and Goldstone are hard for the two men to bear. And they tear at the very fabric of international law and the mechanisms put in place to uphold it. The Human Rights Council has stepped on a slippery slope by agreeing to postpone Falk's report. Instead of listening to the PA (and Egypt) the Council should have backed its special rapporteur. If it does the unthinkable and relieves Falk of his duties because the PA does not want him, the system of independent special rapporteurs would be undermined, just as it would if the Council gave in to Israeli or American pressure.
Undermining the Goldstone Report would be an equally harsh blow to the human rights system. Several earlier reports have called for the application of international law to the Arab-Israeli conflict, including the International Court of Justice's seminal opinion on the illegality of Israel's separation wall in the West Bank. But the Goldstone Report has been published at a time when people are ready to listen, which is partly why Israel is fighting it with such ferocity and on so many fronts.
On one of those fronts, Israel is trying to change international law itself, as Israeli human rights advocate Jeff Halper reveals in an important article, "The Second Battle of Gaza." Halper identifies the Israeli figures leading the campaign "to alter international law in ways that enable them -- and by extension other states involved in 'wars on terror' -- to effectively pursue warfare amongst the people while eliminating both the legitimacy and protections enjoyed by their non-state foes."
No one is more aware of the dangers to international law than Palestinian human rights advocates. Their organizations have acted as a group to support the implementation of the Goldstone Report and to protect Falk and his role.
Last month, 11 Palestinian human rights groups wrote to the High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay expressing dismay at the PA actions against Falk. His reports have provided "powerful instruments to advocate for Palestinian people's rights" they said, urging Pillay to ensure that Falk enjoyed the highest level of support from her office. They also called on her to reinforce the independence of the special rapporteurs from UN member states so as to protect the UN's own credibility.
More recently, 19 Palestinian groups wrote to PA president Mahmoud Abbas criticizing Falk's treatment and pointing out the repercussions for the Palestinians' internationally recognized human rights.
If the attacks on the two Richards succeed, the Palestinian cause will suffer and the world will be a poorer and more dangerous place -- one in which the might of the strong is legally allowed to prevail against the rights of the weak.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
They hail from opposite parts of the globe, but they have much in common: Jewish; experts on and passionate defenders of international law; and pummeling bags for Israel and the Palestinian Authority. And the future of the law of war lies at the heart of the campaigns against them.
Richard Goldstone, whose international stature was cemented as chief prosecutor in the Yugoslavia and Rwanda tribunals, has been excoriated by Israel and its allies ever since his team submitted the report on the Gaza war requested by the United Nations Human Rights Council in September 2009. The steady stream of invective (the report is "full of lies," and he has "used his Jewishness to jeopardize the safety and security of Israel" are just two of the milder attacks) has also targeted his family and taken a toll on the publicly stoic judge.
Richard Falk, professor emeritus at Princeton University and UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in Palestinian territories occupied since 1967, has been attacked by Israel for years. But now, in a new twist, he is being hung out to dry by the Palestinian Authority. This, perhaps, the unkindest cut of all.
The PA pummeling is more discreet. It has quietly suggested to Falk himself that he resign. One reported reason is that Falk can't do his job because Israel will not allow him into the country -- though this should, one would have thought, be all the more reason to defend him.
And the PA has asked the Human Rights Council to take Falk's report off the March 22 agenda and "postpone" it to June, which the Council has done. The PA-appointed representative to the UN in Geneva insists that there are simply more important reports than Falk's on the agenda -- yet at the same time he says the PA has "many" reservations about the Falk report. The real reasons seem to be that the PA did not like the mention of Hamas in Falk's report and his earlier criticism when the PA tried to "postpone" the Goldstone Report in September under pressure from Israel and the United States. A public outcry among Palestinians reversed that decision.
The attacks on Falk and Goldstone are hard for the two men to bear. And they tear at the very fabric of international law and the mechanisms put in place to uphold it. The Human Rights Council has stepped on a slippery slope by agreeing to postpone Falk's report. Instead of listening to the PA (and Egypt) the Council should have backed its special rapporteur. If it does the unthinkable and relieves Falk of his duties because the PA does not want him, the system of independent special rapporteurs would be undermined, just as it would if the Council gave in to Israeli or American pressure.
Undermining the Goldstone Report would be an equally harsh blow to the human rights system. Several earlier reports have called for the application of international law to the Arab-Israeli conflict, including the International Court of Justice's seminal opinion on the illegality of Israel's separation wall in the West Bank. But the Goldstone Report has been published at a time when people are ready to listen, which is partly why Israel is fighting it with such ferocity and on so many fronts.
On one of those fronts, Israel is trying to change international law itself, as Israeli human rights advocate Jeff Halper reveals in an important article, "The Second Battle of Gaza." Halper identifies the Israeli figures leading the campaign "to alter international law in ways that enable them -- and by extension other states involved in 'wars on terror' -- to effectively pursue warfare amongst the people while eliminating both the legitimacy and protections enjoyed by their non-state foes."
No one is more aware of the dangers to international law than Palestinian human rights advocates. Their organizations have acted as a group to support the implementation of the Goldstone Report and to protect Falk and his role.
Last month, 11 Palestinian human rights groups wrote to the High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay expressing dismay at the PA actions against Falk. His reports have provided "powerful instruments to advocate for Palestinian people's rights" they said, urging Pillay to ensure that Falk enjoyed the highest level of support from her office. They also called on her to reinforce the independence of the special rapporteurs from UN member states so as to protect the UN's own credibility.
More recently, 19 Palestinian groups wrote to PA president Mahmoud Abbas criticizing Falk's treatment and pointing out the repercussions for the Palestinians' internationally recognized human rights.
If the attacks on the two Richards succeed, the Palestinian cause will suffer and the world will be a poorer and more dangerous place -- one in which the might of the strong is legally allowed to prevail against the rights of the weak.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Tuesday, March 09, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Jerusalem's Battle Of The Graves
By Nadia Hijab
I carried a handful of ashes from my father's cremates into the occupied Palestinian territories a few years ago, hoping to take them to his hometown, Nablus. At the border, the only available taxi was driven by an Israeli Moroccan Jew. Delighted I was an Arab, he immediately plunged into conversation and pointed out various landmarks along the way to Jerusalem.
"That road," he said at one point, "leads to Nablus," indicating the tarmac cutting through the rocky soil as we drove through a desolate area. I asked him to stop the car. Israel often kept Nablus under curfew for weeks on end and I didn't know if I'd be able to get there during my short trip. On the road to Nablus, I laid the ashes and paid my respects. Back in the car, the puzzled driver wondered what I had been doing. When I told him he asked hesitantly, "Don't you have rites like ours, including visiting loved ones' graves?"
I stared at the back of his neck, as brown as my own, as I sought a response. We do have similar rites. It is rare for a Muslim to seek cremation, as in our father's case, part of the enforced modernity of exile. In fact, at no time is the loss of Palestine more piercing than at a loved one's passing, reinforcing the realization that, Muslim or Christian, Palestinians are as scattered across the globe in death as in life. But how could one explain 100 years of history in a cab ride? "Yes, but you've made it impossible for us to practice ours."
So it is with special poignancy that I have followed the latest twist in the battle over Jerusalem's Mamilla Cemetery, a Muslim cemetery known in Arabic as Ma'man Allah, where the US-based Simon Wiesenthal Centre intends to build a Museum of Tolerance, a project stalled by legal and other protests since it began in 2004.
Mamilla is estimated to be over 800 years old and was in continuous use until 1948 when the Western part of Jerusalem was conquered as Israel was created. In the latest Palestinian challenge, representatives of 60 of the oldest and most prominent Jerusalemite families have petitioned several bodies at the United Nations to uphold the international legal obligation to halt the project.
The battle over Mamilla encapsulates many aspects of Israel's approach to Palestinian rights since the conflict began, and it is worth considering five here.
First, the use of legal garb to shroud illegal acts. In this case, for example, Israel's High Court ruled in favor of the museum project in 2008. However, it turned out that the Israeli Antiquities Authority had withheld its own Chief Excavator's conclusion that the site should not be approved for construction. Calling the Authority's conduct an "archeological crime" the Chief Excavator noted, among other things, at least four unexcavated layers of Muslim graves dating back to the 11th century. However, the court has refused to reopen the case.
Second, the over-reach. The move on Mamilla spotlights not just Israel's occupation of Arab East Jerusalem in 1967, but also its original take-over of West Jerusalem. The international community still does not accept Israeli sovereignty over West Jerusalem because the basis for the establishment of the Israeli state -- the 1947 United Nations partition plan -- provides for a corpus separatum for Jerusalem, as the European Community reminded Israel in 1999.
Third, the ongoing creation of facts on the ground to erase evidence of the indigenous inhabitants. As former Israeli leader Moshe Dayan told Technion University students back in 1969, "There is not one place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population."
Fourth, the Orwellian use of language to mean the direct opposite of what is intended: for example "tolerance" for "discrimination." Indeed, the plans for the Museum of Tolerance are replete with irony. At one point, it was suggested that a horizontal barrier be built to separate the museum and the graves to show "respect" -- a horizontal separation of the dead comparable to Israel's vertical separation barriers in the West Bank and Gaza.
Fifth, the delegitimization -- not of Israel, which is a secure member state of the UN -- but of the Zionist ideology that resulted in Israel's creation. These actions remind the world that one people was displaced by another. The project architect, the renowned Frank Gehry, has since withdrawn his plans. Further international attention to the Mamilla case can only add to the growing global campaign to boycott Israel until it upholds international law.
Mamilla is not just about family history but also a nation's history, as Dyala Husseini-Dajani -- who comes from one long-established Jerusalem families and married into another -- told a journalist while at the cemetery to say a prayer to her forebears. She added, "One day I want to be buried here. And I want my grandchildren to come and say this prayer for me." As I read those words, I wished the Moroccan Jewish taxi driver would read them too.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
I carried a handful of ashes from my father's cremates into the occupied Palestinian territories a few years ago, hoping to take them to his hometown, Nablus. At the border, the only available taxi was driven by an Israeli Moroccan Jew. Delighted I was an Arab, he immediately plunged into conversation and pointed out various landmarks along the way to Jerusalem.
"That road," he said at one point, "leads to Nablus," indicating the tarmac cutting through the rocky soil as we drove through a desolate area. I asked him to stop the car. Israel often kept Nablus under curfew for weeks on end and I didn't know if I'd be able to get there during my short trip. On the road to Nablus, I laid the ashes and paid my respects. Back in the car, the puzzled driver wondered what I had been doing. When I told him he asked hesitantly, "Don't you have rites like ours, including visiting loved ones' graves?"
I stared at the back of his neck, as brown as my own, as I sought a response. We do have similar rites. It is rare for a Muslim to seek cremation, as in our father's case, part of the enforced modernity of exile. In fact, at no time is the loss of Palestine more piercing than at a loved one's passing, reinforcing the realization that, Muslim or Christian, Palestinians are as scattered across the globe in death as in life. But how could one explain 100 years of history in a cab ride? "Yes, but you've made it impossible for us to practice ours."
So it is with special poignancy that I have followed the latest twist in the battle over Jerusalem's Mamilla Cemetery, a Muslim cemetery known in Arabic as Ma'man Allah, where the US-based Simon Wiesenthal Centre intends to build a Museum of Tolerance, a project stalled by legal and other protests since it began in 2004.
Mamilla is estimated to be over 800 years old and was in continuous use until 1948 when the Western part of Jerusalem was conquered as Israel was created. In the latest Palestinian challenge, representatives of 60 of the oldest and most prominent Jerusalemite families have petitioned several bodies at the United Nations to uphold the international legal obligation to halt the project.
The battle over Mamilla encapsulates many aspects of Israel's approach to Palestinian rights since the conflict began, and it is worth considering five here.
First, the use of legal garb to shroud illegal acts. In this case, for example, Israel's High Court ruled in favor of the museum project in 2008. However, it turned out that the Israeli Antiquities Authority had withheld its own Chief Excavator's conclusion that the site should not be approved for construction. Calling the Authority's conduct an "archeological crime" the Chief Excavator noted, among other things, at least four unexcavated layers of Muslim graves dating back to the 11th century. However, the court has refused to reopen the case.
Second, the over-reach. The move on Mamilla spotlights not just Israel's occupation of Arab East Jerusalem in 1967, but also its original take-over of West Jerusalem. The international community still does not accept Israeli sovereignty over West Jerusalem because the basis for the establishment of the Israeli state -- the 1947 United Nations partition plan -- provides for a corpus separatum for Jerusalem, as the European Community reminded Israel in 1999.
Third, the ongoing creation of facts on the ground to erase evidence of the indigenous inhabitants. As former Israeli leader Moshe Dayan told Technion University students back in 1969, "There is not one place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population."
Fourth, the Orwellian use of language to mean the direct opposite of what is intended: for example "tolerance" for "discrimination." Indeed, the plans for the Museum of Tolerance are replete with irony. At one point, it was suggested that a horizontal barrier be built to separate the museum and the graves to show "respect" -- a horizontal separation of the dead comparable to Israel's vertical separation barriers in the West Bank and Gaza.
Fifth, the delegitimization -- not of Israel, which is a secure member state of the UN -- but of the Zionist ideology that resulted in Israel's creation. These actions remind the world that one people was displaced by another. The project architect, the renowned Frank Gehry, has since withdrawn his plans. Further international attention to the Mamilla case can only add to the growing global campaign to boycott Israel until it upholds international law.
Mamilla is not just about family history but also a nation's history, as Dyala Husseini-Dajani -- who comes from one long-established Jerusalem families and married into another -- told a journalist while at the cemetery to say a prayer to her forebears. She added, "One day I want to be buried here. And I want my grandchildren to come and say this prayer for me." As I read those words, I wished the Moroccan Jewish taxi driver would read them too.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Thursday, February 18, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Aiding Yemen
By Nadia Hijab
It was the fall of 2005, and we were sitting in the former minister of planning's large office -- "we" being two international consultants and the local representative of an international development agency. We were there to evaluate a $200,000 project to strengthen human rights.
The minister responded to all our questions with that sharp intelligence characteristic of so many Yemenis, but also politely wondered why we were there at all. He gently reminded us that earlier that year leaders from developed and developing nations had adopted the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness, a resounding commitment to respect national leadership and to coordinate aid accordingly. Why was he being asked to spend his time on a small, standalone, donor-driven project? A little shame-faced, we nevertheless pressed on with our agenda -- and on to our meeting with the minister of human rights.
This issue may not sound like much against the backdrop of problems plaguing Yemen -- including corruption, poverty, illiteracy, environmental degradation, and two major internal conflicts. But after last month's failed airline attack, Western interest in Yemen is surging, as more military support -- and more aid -- is promised.
British prime minister Gordon Brown is convening a high-level meeting at the end of January to help Yemen tackle the "terrorist threat" by extending military support and development aid. And in the United States, Hillary Clinton has been promoting an "integrated approach" of diplomacy, defense, and development ever since she took office.
So setting aside for the moment a discussion of whether it is actually possible to bomb countries with one hand and develop them with the other -- as the United States and its allies are already trying to do in Afghanistan and Iraq -- it is important to ask the question: Why is Yemen still a least developed country (LDC) after decades of donor assistance?
LDCs are countries where the per capita income is under $750 a year. There are 49 of them around the world, mostly in Africa. Haiti is the only one in the Americas. Although these countries face different development challenges, they share the problem of weak human capacity. That is why in Yemen, as in other LDCs, foreign aid can actually impede progress.
It goes like this: Yemenis get their degrees and start looking for work. The best go into business or gravitate to the local offices of foreign aid agencies, where they are paid much better than in government service. Others set up non-governmental organizations that attract funding for areas donors love to support, such as gender and human rights.
Meanwhile, the government itself is staffed by poorly-paid professionals. And to make matters worse, much of the government's time and effort is sucked up in servicing the requirements of these aid agencies -- tons of paperwork and many meetings generated by dozens of donors' procedural requirements.
The new head of the U.S. Agency for International Development, Raj Shah, acknowledged the problem at one of his first press briefings. He said it was very hard to expect a health minister to offer leadership if he or she was spending "half or two-thirds of their time having visitors from different donor agencies... that are working in a way that's not coordinated or coherent." Well, yes.
When I visited Yemen again last year, I was happy to see that the minister of education was imposing coordination on the donor community, though with mixed success given his ministry's still weak capacity. That was one bright spot in an otherwise gloomy picture.
The point is, that without strong capacity to manage development LDC governments are unable to set their own agendas, and instead remain at the mercy of whatever approach is being peddled by international organizations -- structural adjustment, poverty reduction, and the like.
The solution? Most of it is right there in the Paris Declaration. And there has been some progress. For example, in some cases donors pool their budgets to support entire sectors of the country rather than just managing projects. But change has not gone far enough. The way the aid business works, Western donor agencies need to be visible to show their taxpayers that they are doing something with their money. And inter-governmental organizations need to be visible to donor governments -- otherwise they would not attract funding and would cease to exist.
There is much that is good about aid and much that is problematic -- including, of course, the problems of a political nature. (For example, the distorted role of aid in the Palestinian territories helps to perpetuate the Israeli occupation by minimizing its costs to Israel.)
What is crucial at this moment is that there needs to be a deeper discussion about aiding Yemen. Otherwise that country's problems may just be beginning.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
It was the fall of 2005, and we were sitting in the former minister of planning's large office -- "we" being two international consultants and the local representative of an international development agency. We were there to evaluate a $200,000 project to strengthen human rights.
The minister responded to all our questions with that sharp intelligence characteristic of so many Yemenis, but also politely wondered why we were there at all. He gently reminded us that earlier that year leaders from developed and developing nations had adopted the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness, a resounding commitment to respect national leadership and to coordinate aid accordingly. Why was he being asked to spend his time on a small, standalone, donor-driven project? A little shame-faced, we nevertheless pressed on with our agenda -- and on to our meeting with the minister of human rights.
This issue may not sound like much against the backdrop of problems plaguing Yemen -- including corruption, poverty, illiteracy, environmental degradation, and two major internal conflicts. But after last month's failed airline attack, Western interest in Yemen is surging, as more military support -- and more aid -- is promised.
British prime minister Gordon Brown is convening a high-level meeting at the end of January to help Yemen tackle the "terrorist threat" by extending military support and development aid. And in the United States, Hillary Clinton has been promoting an "integrated approach" of diplomacy, defense, and development ever since she took office.
So setting aside for the moment a discussion of whether it is actually possible to bomb countries with one hand and develop them with the other -- as the United States and its allies are already trying to do in Afghanistan and Iraq -- it is important to ask the question: Why is Yemen still a least developed country (LDC) after decades of donor assistance?
LDCs are countries where the per capita income is under $750 a year. There are 49 of them around the world, mostly in Africa. Haiti is the only one in the Americas. Although these countries face different development challenges, they share the problem of weak human capacity. That is why in Yemen, as in other LDCs, foreign aid can actually impede progress.
It goes like this: Yemenis get their degrees and start looking for work. The best go into business or gravitate to the local offices of foreign aid agencies, where they are paid much better than in government service. Others set up non-governmental organizations that attract funding for areas donors love to support, such as gender and human rights.
Meanwhile, the government itself is staffed by poorly-paid professionals. And to make matters worse, much of the government's time and effort is sucked up in servicing the requirements of these aid agencies -- tons of paperwork and many meetings generated by dozens of donors' procedural requirements.
The new head of the U.S. Agency for International Development, Raj Shah, acknowledged the problem at one of his first press briefings. He said it was very hard to expect a health minister to offer leadership if he or she was spending "half or two-thirds of their time having visitors from different donor agencies... that are working in a way that's not coordinated or coherent." Well, yes.
When I visited Yemen again last year, I was happy to see that the minister of education was imposing coordination on the donor community, though with mixed success given his ministry's still weak capacity. That was one bright spot in an otherwise gloomy picture.
The point is, that without strong capacity to manage development LDC governments are unable to set their own agendas, and instead remain at the mercy of whatever approach is being peddled by international organizations -- structural adjustment, poverty reduction, and the like.
The solution? Most of it is right there in the Paris Declaration. And there has been some progress. For example, in some cases donors pool their budgets to support entire sectors of the country rather than just managing projects. But change has not gone far enough. The way the aid business works, Western donor agencies need to be visible to show their taxpayers that they are doing something with their money. And inter-governmental organizations need to be visible to donor governments -- otherwise they would not attract funding and would cease to exist.
There is much that is good about aid and much that is problematic -- including, of course, the problems of a political nature. (For example, the distorted role of aid in the Palestinian territories helps to perpetuate the Israeli occupation by minimizing its costs to Israel.)
What is crucial at this moment is that there needs to be a deeper discussion about aiding Yemen. Otherwise that country's problems may just be beginning.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Monday, January 25, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Gaza And When Does It Become Genocide?
By Nadia Hijab
During a visit to Ramallah a year ago while the Israeli bombardment of Gaza was underway, I shared my fears with a close Palestinian friend. "It may sound insane, but I think the Israelis' real objective is to see them all dead."
My friend told me not to be silly, the assault was horrific, but it was not mass killing. I said that wasn't the issue: This was a population already very vulnerable to disease, ill-health, and malnutrition after years of siege, with its infrastructure rotted, its water and food contaminated. Israel's war would surely push the people over the brink, especially if the siege was maintained -- as it has been.
In other words, Israel would not directly kill tens of thousands of Palestinians, but it would create the conditions for tens of thousands to die. Any epidemic could finish the job. My friend fell silent at these words, but still shook his head in disbelief.
Two things have changed since last year: More people have started to apply the term "genocide" to what Israel is doing to Gaza. And not only is Israel being directly accused but also, increasingly, Egypt.
Is it genocide? "The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide" -- a clear, concise document adopted by the United Nations in December 1948 -- states that genocide is any of five acts committed "with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group."
Three acts appear to apply to the situation in Gaza: "(a) Killing members of the group; (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part."
Legal scholars disagree about how to interpret the Convention's articles and it has proven difficult, over the years, to define crimes as genocide, let alone to prevent or end them. In line with the Bosnia precedent -- the only authoritative legal treatment of genocide to date -- it would be necessary to establish deliberate intent for an accusation of genocide against Israel to stand up in court.
Israel's leadership has not, of course, issued a declaration of intent. However, many leading Israeli officials can be said to have done so. For example:
• Putting the Palestinians of Gaza "on a diet" -- Dov Weisglass, chief aide to Ariel Sharon, in 2006.
• Exposing them to "a bigger shoah (holocaust)" -- Matan Vilnai, former deputy defense minister, in 2008.
• Issuing religious edits exhorting soldiers to show no mercy -- the Israeli army rabbinate during the actual conflict.
Such declarations echo at least three of the "8 stages of genocide" identified by Genocide Watch president Gregory Stanton in the 1990s after the Rwanda genocide: Classification, dehumanization, and polarization.
Then there is the deliberate destruction or barring of means of sustenance as Israel has done on land and at sea. Already, the Goldstone Report has said that depriving the Gaza Palestinians of their means of sustenance, employment, housing and water, freedom of movement, and access to a court of law, could amount to persecution.
Since the December-January assault, there have been many authoritative reports by human rights and environmental organizations on the impact of the war and the ongoing siege on the people, soil, air, and water, including the increase in cancers, deformed births, and preventable deaths. The death toll in Gaza from swine flu reached nine in mid-December and 13 a week later -- an epidemic in waiting.
The eighth stage of genocide Stanton identifies is denial by perpetrators "that they committed any crimes." Ironically, Stanton headed the International Association of Genocide Scholars during the conflict, which shut down discussion of Israel's actions despite protests by, among others, genocide scholar and author Adam Jones. Jones and 15 other scholars had posted a declaration stating that Israeli policies were "too alarmingly close" to genocide to ignore and calling for an end to the silence.
Alarmingly close is right. Here is how Raphael Lemkin, the Polish-Jewish legal scholar who pushed for the genocide convention, defined it in 1943:
"genocide does not necessarily mean the immediate destruction of a nation.... It is intended rather to signify a coordinated plan of different actions aiming at the destruction of essential foundations of the life of national groups, with the aim of annihilating the groups themselves. The objectives of such a plan would be the disintegration of the political and social institutions, of culture, language, national feelings, religion, and the economic existence of national groups, and the destruction of the personal security, liberty, health, dignity, and even the lives of the individuals belonging to such groups."
It is hard to conceive of a better description of what is going on in Gaza.
All UN member states have the duty to prevent and stop acts of genocide. What is needed is a country brave enough to take the lead, before it is too late.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
During a visit to Ramallah a year ago while the Israeli bombardment of Gaza was underway, I shared my fears with a close Palestinian friend. "It may sound insane, but I think the Israelis' real objective is to see them all dead."
My friend told me not to be silly, the assault was horrific, but it was not mass killing. I said that wasn't the issue: This was a population already very vulnerable to disease, ill-health, and malnutrition after years of siege, with its infrastructure rotted, its water and food contaminated. Israel's war would surely push the people over the brink, especially if the siege was maintained -- as it has been.
In other words, Israel would not directly kill tens of thousands of Palestinians, but it would create the conditions for tens of thousands to die. Any epidemic could finish the job. My friend fell silent at these words, but still shook his head in disbelief.
Two things have changed since last year: More people have started to apply the term "genocide" to what Israel is doing to Gaza. And not only is Israel being directly accused but also, increasingly, Egypt.
Is it genocide? "The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide" -- a clear, concise document adopted by the United Nations in December 1948 -- states that genocide is any of five acts committed "with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group."
Three acts appear to apply to the situation in Gaza: "(a) Killing members of the group; (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part."
Legal scholars disagree about how to interpret the Convention's articles and it has proven difficult, over the years, to define crimes as genocide, let alone to prevent or end them. In line with the Bosnia precedent -- the only authoritative legal treatment of genocide to date -- it would be necessary to establish deliberate intent for an accusation of genocide against Israel to stand up in court.
Israel's leadership has not, of course, issued a declaration of intent. However, many leading Israeli officials can be said to have done so. For example:
• Putting the Palestinians of Gaza "on a diet" -- Dov Weisglass, chief aide to Ariel Sharon, in 2006.
• Exposing them to "a bigger shoah (holocaust)" -- Matan Vilnai, former deputy defense minister, in 2008.
• Issuing religious edits exhorting soldiers to show no mercy -- the Israeli army rabbinate during the actual conflict.
Such declarations echo at least three of the "8 stages of genocide" identified by Genocide Watch president Gregory Stanton in the 1990s after the Rwanda genocide: Classification, dehumanization, and polarization.
Then there is the deliberate destruction or barring of means of sustenance as Israel has done on land and at sea. Already, the Goldstone Report has said that depriving the Gaza Palestinians of their means of sustenance, employment, housing and water, freedom of movement, and access to a court of law, could amount to persecution.
Since the December-January assault, there have been many authoritative reports by human rights and environmental organizations on the impact of the war and the ongoing siege on the people, soil, air, and water, including the increase in cancers, deformed births, and preventable deaths. The death toll in Gaza from swine flu reached nine in mid-December and 13 a week later -- an epidemic in waiting.
The eighth stage of genocide Stanton identifies is denial by perpetrators "that they committed any crimes." Ironically, Stanton headed the International Association of Genocide Scholars during the conflict, which shut down discussion of Israel's actions despite protests by, among others, genocide scholar and author Adam Jones. Jones and 15 other scholars had posted a declaration stating that Israeli policies were "too alarmingly close" to genocide to ignore and calling for an end to the silence.
Alarmingly close is right. Here is how Raphael Lemkin, the Polish-Jewish legal scholar who pushed for the genocide convention, defined it in 1943:
"genocide does not necessarily mean the immediate destruction of a nation.... It is intended rather to signify a coordinated plan of different actions aiming at the destruction of essential foundations of the life of national groups, with the aim of annihilating the groups themselves. The objectives of such a plan would be the disintegration of the political and social institutions, of culture, language, national feelings, religion, and the economic existence of national groups, and the destruction of the personal security, liberty, health, dignity, and even the lives of the individuals belonging to such groups."
It is hard to conceive of a better description of what is going on in Gaza.
All UN member states have the duty to prevent and stop acts of genocide. What is needed is a country brave enough to take the lead, before it is too late.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Tuesday, January 05, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
The Plight of the Right of Return
By Nadia Hijab
The whirlwind of summiteering on climate change, non-proliferation, the economy, and Iran swept the Arab-Israeli conflict off the news -- but not before Barack Obama had spoken of a "just, lasting and comprehensive peace in the Middle East." That startling turn of phrase -- used just before his trilateral with Mahmoud Abbas and Benjamin Netanyahu - is a throwback to a much earlier era of American peacemaking.
A focus on justice would be a welcome break with the sterile Oslo attempts to strike a deal on land percentages and refugee numbers.
The question is: Who defines what constitutes justice today? In his speech at the United Nations the next day, Obama sounded more like Bush junior, who is not often associated with the rule of law. Obama spoke of "a Jewish State of Israel, with true security for all Israelis; and a viable, independent Palestinian state with contiguous territory that ends the occupation that began in 1967." Instead of achieving justice, this outcome would actually undermine it.
Take the terms "viable" and "contiguous." For some years, these uninspiring words have been appended to "Palestinian state." Imagine a Palestinian declaring "I have a dream: contiguity!" or "I have struggled for 100 years to achieve viability." The Israelis, who've achieved sovereignty, yearn for security and recognition. The Palestinians strive for self-determination, freedom, justice, and equality.
Terms like contiguous and viable hint at an unpleasant truth: that the 42-year occupation may have made free and sovereign statehood impossible. Palestinians could well end up with a state that is viable (economic activity), contiguous (tunnels under illegal settlements and Jewish-only roads), and "independent" (a seat at the U.N.) while Israel maintains ultimate control over policy and resources.
Obama further undermines justice by speaking of Israel as a "Jewish State" as Netanyahu wants. A Jewish state would continue to privilege Jews over non-Jews and would exclude Palestinian refugees and exiles. And here we come to the crux of the matter. The rights of Palestinian refugees have been at the heart of the conflict since 1948. In fact, this is what justice means to a Palestinian. Can the Arab-Israeli conflict be solved without implementing the right of return? It might have been, in the early, heady Oslo days given Yasser Arafat's stature and the desire by some of the younger generation to build a sovereign state in the occupied territories. But Israel missed that opportunity and Arafat died in 2004, imprisoned in his presidential compound by Ariel Sharon.
Since Oslo, the right of return movement has grown considerably stronger. Karma Nabulsi, Professor of International Relations at Oxford University and an expert on Palestinian refugee communities, says the right of return is now a point of unity among Palestinians living under occupation, in exile or in Israel, whether they are refugees or non-refugees and it is upheld by all political parties and civil society.
Nabulsi recalls that the Oslo years raised the hopes of Israelis across the political spectrum "that the refugees would disappear off the map when they disappeared off the negotiating table." They were shocked to find, for example at Camp David in 2000, that what had been shelved as a final status issue still needed to be substantively addressed.
Nabulsi insists it is crucial to engage the refugees and exiles -- who constitute the majority of Palestinians -- in the discussion about implementing their rights. It is also important to educate both sides about what this would mean for them.
I reflected on the challenges of educating around the right of return. Israelis would need to see how this would work in practice and that it would entail neither the destruction of Israel nor its Jewish ties. Palestinian refugees need information on how Israel looks and functions to make informed choices on whether to return or to opt for another country.
Palestinians have begun to openly challenge their leadership on the issue. For example, in a recent piece the respected Palestinian author and journalist Fouzi El-Asmar politely but firmly reminded Abbas that he does not speak for all Palestinians. El-Asmar says Abbas was right to step in after Arafat's death. Yet, while he was elected president of the Palestinian Authority in his own right, he is just the interim chair of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the only body authorized to negotiate with Israel. Until the Palestinian National Council is reconstituted to elect a PLO chairman, El-Asmar underscores, no one has the authority to compromise on Palestinian rights.
Justice can never be absolute: The clock cannot be turned back to 1948. But a just way must be found to implement the right of return, Nabulsi echoes the view of most Palestinians when she says, "Until the refugees are put at the centre of a real, substantive peace process, there will be no peace."
The whirlwind of summiteering on climate change, non-proliferation, the economy, and Iran swept the Arab-Israeli conflict off the news -- but not before Barack Obama had spoken of a "just, lasting and comprehensive peace in the Middle East." That startling turn of phrase -- used just before his trilateral with Mahmoud Abbas and Benjamin Netanyahu - is a throwback to a much earlier era of American peacemaking.
A focus on justice would be a welcome break with the sterile Oslo attempts to strike a deal on land percentages and refugee numbers.
The question is: Who defines what constitutes justice today? In his speech at the United Nations the next day, Obama sounded more like Bush junior, who is not often associated with the rule of law. Obama spoke of "a Jewish State of Israel, with true security for all Israelis; and a viable, independent Palestinian state with contiguous territory that ends the occupation that began in 1967." Instead of achieving justice, this outcome would actually undermine it.
Take the terms "viable" and "contiguous." For some years, these uninspiring words have been appended to "Palestinian state." Imagine a Palestinian declaring "I have a dream: contiguity!" or "I have struggled for 100 years to achieve viability." The Israelis, who've achieved sovereignty, yearn for security and recognition. The Palestinians strive for self-determination, freedom, justice, and equality.
Terms like contiguous and viable hint at an unpleasant truth: that the 42-year occupation may have made free and sovereign statehood impossible. Palestinians could well end up with a state that is viable (economic activity), contiguous (tunnels under illegal settlements and Jewish-only roads), and "independent" (a seat at the U.N.) while Israel maintains ultimate control over policy and resources.
Obama further undermines justice by speaking of Israel as a "Jewish State" as Netanyahu wants. A Jewish state would continue to privilege Jews over non-Jews and would exclude Palestinian refugees and exiles. And here we come to the crux of the matter. The rights of Palestinian refugees have been at the heart of the conflict since 1948. In fact, this is what justice means to a Palestinian. Can the Arab-Israeli conflict be solved without implementing the right of return? It might have been, in the early, heady Oslo days given Yasser Arafat's stature and the desire by some of the younger generation to build a sovereign state in the occupied territories. But Israel missed that opportunity and Arafat died in 2004, imprisoned in his presidential compound by Ariel Sharon.
Since Oslo, the right of return movement has grown considerably stronger. Karma Nabulsi, Professor of International Relations at Oxford University and an expert on Palestinian refugee communities, says the right of return is now a point of unity among Palestinians living under occupation, in exile or in Israel, whether they are refugees or non-refugees and it is upheld by all political parties and civil society.
Nabulsi recalls that the Oslo years raised the hopes of Israelis across the political spectrum "that the refugees would disappear off the map when they disappeared off the negotiating table." They were shocked to find, for example at Camp David in 2000, that what had been shelved as a final status issue still needed to be substantively addressed.
Nabulsi insists it is crucial to engage the refugees and exiles -- who constitute the majority of Palestinians -- in the discussion about implementing their rights. It is also important to educate both sides about what this would mean for them.
I reflected on the challenges of educating around the right of return. Israelis would need to see how this would work in practice and that it would entail neither the destruction of Israel nor its Jewish ties. Palestinian refugees need information on how Israel looks and functions to make informed choices on whether to return or to opt for another country.
Palestinians have begun to openly challenge their leadership on the issue. For example, in a recent piece the respected Palestinian author and journalist Fouzi El-Asmar politely but firmly reminded Abbas that he does not speak for all Palestinians. El-Asmar says Abbas was right to step in after Arafat's death. Yet, while he was elected president of the Palestinian Authority in his own right, he is just the interim chair of the Palestine Liberation Organization, the only body authorized to negotiate with Israel. Until the Palestinian National Council is reconstituted to elect a PLO chairman, El-Asmar underscores, no one has the authority to compromise on Palestinian rights.
Justice can never be absolute: The clock cannot be turned back to 1948. But a just way must be found to implement the right of return, Nabulsi echoes the view of most Palestinians when she says, "Until the refugees are put at the centre of a real, substantive peace process, there will be no peace."
Wednesday, October 14, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Know Your Dictator
By Nadia Hijab
As the United Nations General Assembly convenes this week, a high-level parade of actual and aspiring dictators arrives in New York City. This is a good time for people of conscience to reflect on how to deal with dictators.
The U.S. government appears to have found a way that works for it: Libya is a case in point. Having long treated it as a pariah high on the terrorist list, the United States began to rehabilitate Colonel Muammar Qaddafi after 2003, when Libya agreed not to seek nuclear weapons and to pay compensation for its implication in such crimes as Lockerbie.
The world will be seeing a lot of Libya this week. It was elected to hold the presidency of this year's General Assembly and will preside over the high-level meetings. Qaddafi will participate in the historic Security Council summit chaired by Barack Obama. Yet there are few perceptible reforms within Libya itself as he celebrates his 40th year in power.
Many of us may find it difficult to know what's right and what's wrong in such situations. How far should human rights advocates push their governments? Who decides when to protect a population, how, and at what cost? In the month leading up to the U.S. invasion of Iraq, many well-intentioned people, even those who expressed doubts about the Bush war objectives, said, "Saddam Hussein is a terrible dictator; we owe it to the Iraqis to do something."
Those who still think so should probably take a moment to read the eloquent statement by Muntadhar al-Zaidi, the Iraqi journalist who threw a shoe at Bush and who was just released from prison. Iraqis were well aware of the oppression they lived under, he said, but the invasion and occupation has "divided one brother from another .... It turned our homes into never-ending funeral tents. And our graveyards spread into parks and roadsides. It is a plague."
Clearly, invasion and occupation are not the way to deal with dictatorship. So what can ordinary citizens do?
Well, first, define your dictator. Respectable human rights organizations -- ones that are not seen as Western-funded or guided -- should come together to compile a citizen's Good Government Index and rank governments accordingly. There are, of course, "freedom indices" that rank states based on some civil and political rights. The GGI would be broader and cover issues like corruption as well as progress in achieving development goals.
No country would score full marks. For example, accusations of fraud in elections would apply not just to Iran and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad but also to the United States and George W. Bush. Similarly, the Arab world is not the only region where leaders pass power on to sons while people remain fairly powerless.
A state would not be allowed to claim the mantle of democracy if it privileges some ethnic or religious groups or is responsible for prolonged violations of human rights through occupation, as is the case of Israel. Acts of rendition and torture would count for something too.
Second, narrow the dictator's reach. States that do not score above 60 per cent on the GGI should not be considered for election to the Human Rights Council or to lead other world bodies. Concerned citizens would need to lobby to ensure that their countries vote only for states that rank higher on the index.
States really value international recognition. For example, in the heated race to head UNESCO, the U.N.'s educational, scientific, and cultural organization, Egypt is bringing its full weight to bear behind its former minister of culture. Arab press reports even claim that Egypt is promising to be "neutral" on settlements just to get Israel to withdraw its reservations.
Third, do business, but not as usual. No amount of internal repression will stop governments and corporations from doing business with non-democratic regimes. What concerned citizens should do is limit normal business dealings partly through citizen boycotts and partly by lobbying and media outreach. At a minimum, there should be a push for an arms boycott against repressive states.
For the GGI to work, citizens need to be better informed about foreign policy on an ongoing basis, not just when their country launches an invasion in their name. While there is more information available than ever, the realities of daily life intrude. That's where a well-designed index produced by respected organizations would help. There have been some attempts to produce such an index. Since the number of dictators is growing, these attempts are worth pursuing.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
As the United Nations General Assembly convenes this week, a high-level parade of actual and aspiring dictators arrives in New York City. This is a good time for people of conscience to reflect on how to deal with dictators.
The U.S. government appears to have found a way that works for it: Libya is a case in point. Having long treated it as a pariah high on the terrorist list, the United States began to rehabilitate Colonel Muammar Qaddafi after 2003, when Libya agreed not to seek nuclear weapons and to pay compensation for its implication in such crimes as Lockerbie.
The world will be seeing a lot of Libya this week. It was elected to hold the presidency of this year's General Assembly and will preside over the high-level meetings. Qaddafi will participate in the historic Security Council summit chaired by Barack Obama. Yet there are few perceptible reforms within Libya itself as he celebrates his 40th year in power.
Many of us may find it difficult to know what's right and what's wrong in such situations. How far should human rights advocates push their governments? Who decides when to protect a population, how, and at what cost? In the month leading up to the U.S. invasion of Iraq, many well-intentioned people, even those who expressed doubts about the Bush war objectives, said, "Saddam Hussein is a terrible dictator; we owe it to the Iraqis to do something."
Those who still think so should probably take a moment to read the eloquent statement by Muntadhar al-Zaidi, the Iraqi journalist who threw a shoe at Bush and who was just released from prison. Iraqis were well aware of the oppression they lived under, he said, but the invasion and occupation has "divided one brother from another .... It turned our homes into never-ending funeral tents. And our graveyards spread into parks and roadsides. It is a plague."
Clearly, invasion and occupation are not the way to deal with dictatorship. So what can ordinary citizens do?
Well, first, define your dictator. Respectable human rights organizations -- ones that are not seen as Western-funded or guided -- should come together to compile a citizen's Good Government Index and rank governments accordingly. There are, of course, "freedom indices" that rank states based on some civil and political rights. The GGI would be broader and cover issues like corruption as well as progress in achieving development goals.
No country would score full marks. For example, accusations of fraud in elections would apply not just to Iran and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad but also to the United States and George W. Bush. Similarly, the Arab world is not the only region where leaders pass power on to sons while people remain fairly powerless.
A state would not be allowed to claim the mantle of democracy if it privileges some ethnic or religious groups or is responsible for prolonged violations of human rights through occupation, as is the case of Israel. Acts of rendition and torture would count for something too.
Second, narrow the dictator's reach. States that do not score above 60 per cent on the GGI should not be considered for election to the Human Rights Council or to lead other world bodies. Concerned citizens would need to lobby to ensure that their countries vote only for states that rank higher on the index.
States really value international recognition. For example, in the heated race to head UNESCO, the U.N.'s educational, scientific, and cultural organization, Egypt is bringing its full weight to bear behind its former minister of culture. Arab press reports even claim that Egypt is promising to be "neutral" on settlements just to get Israel to withdraw its reservations.
Third, do business, but not as usual. No amount of internal repression will stop governments and corporations from doing business with non-democratic regimes. What concerned citizens should do is limit normal business dealings partly through citizen boycotts and partly by lobbying and media outreach. At a minimum, there should be a push for an arms boycott against repressive states.
For the GGI to work, citizens need to be better informed about foreign policy on an ongoing basis, not just when their country launches an invasion in their name. While there is more information available than ever, the realities of daily life intrude. That's where a well-designed index produced by respected organizations would help. There have been some attempts to produce such an index. Since the number of dictators is growing, these attempts are worth pursuing.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Friday, September 25, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Sinking the Goldstone Report
By Nadia Hijab
Timing is everything.
On Monday, the United States assumed its seat on the United Nations Human Rights Council -- the one the Bush administration had cold-shouldered, then boycotted. The U.S. representative declared in Obamaesque tones, "Make no mistake: The United States will not look the other way in the face of serious human rights abuses."
And on Tuesday, Justice Richard Goldstone and his team submitted the report of their fact-finding mission into violations of international human rights and humanitarian law during Israel's December-January offensive against Gaza -- a report requested by the Council itself.
The Goldstone Report could derail the Obama administration's hopes of a two-state solution. Unless, that is, someone can sink it. An unlikely set of allies may come together to do so: Israel, given the findings against it of war crimes and possible crimes against humanity; the United States, to defend Israel as well as its own plans for the Middle East; Egypt; and the Palestinian Authority.
It would be quite hard to sink the Goldstone Report. One reason is the team's impeccable credentials. Goldstone, a South African Jew with close ties to Israel, served as Prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. Another member, Hina Jilani, participated in the commission of inquiry on Darfur. Israel and its supporters always complain that no one looks at other countries' abuses. Well, this team has.
Moreover, the Goldstone Report is painstakingly even-handed. It finds evidence of war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity not just against Israel but also against Palestinian armed groups. And it criticizes both Hamas and the Palestinian Authority for human rights violations in their crackdowns on each other's members.
In addition, the Goldstone team provides almost no room for anyone to wriggle out of its recommendations. It requests the Human Rights Council to submit its report to the Security Council, where the United States has a veto, as well as to the U.N. General Assembly, where it does not.
It calls on Israel as well as the authorities in Gaza to launch independent and credible investigations into the violations. And to make sure they do, it asks that an independent team of experts be established to review progress. If the process is not credible -- as measured against international law standards -- then the Gaza situation should be referred to the International Criminal Court at the end of six months. It also upholds universal jurisdiction, calling on other states to undertake criminal investigations in their national courts so as to prevent impunity.
The Report politely expresses doubt that Israel will make reparations to the Palestinians of Gaza for the extensive damage inflicted on them and their infrastructure -- so it recommends that the General Assembly establish an escrow account into which Israel would pay.
The Obama administration could send a strong signal by voting to submit the report to the Security Council and the General Assembly, or even by abstaining. But, despite its fine words on Monday, it is more likely to want to bury it. Otherwise, attention will focus on prosecuting an Israel it's trying to nudge to the negotiating table. The problem it will face is that Third World countries dominate both the Human Rights Council and General Assembly and they traditionally support Palestinian rights. So it will seek an alliance with Egypt and the Palestinian Authority. If they indicate they do not want the report to go forward, the rest of the Third World would find it hard to go over their heads.
But could Egypt and the Palestinian Authority possibly want to stop accountability for war crimes in Gaza? Hard to believe, but they may have already done so earlier this year when Father Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, the General Assembly's Nicaraguan president, tried to get the international community to stop the slaughter.
Father Miguel has named no names, but in his speech at the end of his one-year term this week, he left little doubt about what happened. He said he had tried to persuade "those who should have been most closely involved" to convene the General Assembly to help the Palestinians under fire. But "all I received was advice to give the process more time... we should do nothing that could endanger the success that was always just beyond our reach."
And he went on to make a very serious accusation against "those who should supposedly have been most interested" yet "denied their support." He said he hoped "that they were right and that I was wrong. Otherwise, we face an ugly situation of constant complicity with the aggression against the rights of the noble and long-suffering Palestinian people."
If this complicity repeats itself at the Human Rights Council, the Goldstone Report will be sunk. The power of the state system (and a putative statelet) will have trumped the principles of international law and human rights -- unless human rights advocates act to make sure the right thing gets done.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Timing is everything.
On Monday, the United States assumed its seat on the United Nations Human Rights Council -- the one the Bush administration had cold-shouldered, then boycotted. The U.S. representative declared in Obamaesque tones, "Make no mistake: The United States will not look the other way in the face of serious human rights abuses."
And on Tuesday, Justice Richard Goldstone and his team submitted the report of their fact-finding mission into violations of international human rights and humanitarian law during Israel's December-January offensive against Gaza -- a report requested by the Council itself.
The Goldstone Report could derail the Obama administration's hopes of a two-state solution. Unless, that is, someone can sink it. An unlikely set of allies may come together to do so: Israel, given the findings against it of war crimes and possible crimes against humanity; the United States, to defend Israel as well as its own plans for the Middle East; Egypt; and the Palestinian Authority.
It would be quite hard to sink the Goldstone Report. One reason is the team's impeccable credentials. Goldstone, a South African Jew with close ties to Israel, served as Prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. Another member, Hina Jilani, participated in the commission of inquiry on Darfur. Israel and its supporters always complain that no one looks at other countries' abuses. Well, this team has.
Moreover, the Goldstone Report is painstakingly even-handed. It finds evidence of war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity not just against Israel but also against Palestinian armed groups. And it criticizes both Hamas and the Palestinian Authority for human rights violations in their crackdowns on each other's members.
In addition, the Goldstone team provides almost no room for anyone to wriggle out of its recommendations. It requests the Human Rights Council to submit its report to the Security Council, where the United States has a veto, as well as to the U.N. General Assembly, where it does not.
It calls on Israel as well as the authorities in Gaza to launch independent and credible investigations into the violations. And to make sure they do, it asks that an independent team of experts be established to review progress. If the process is not credible -- as measured against international law standards -- then the Gaza situation should be referred to the International Criminal Court at the end of six months. It also upholds universal jurisdiction, calling on other states to undertake criminal investigations in their national courts so as to prevent impunity.
The Report politely expresses doubt that Israel will make reparations to the Palestinians of Gaza for the extensive damage inflicted on them and their infrastructure -- so it recommends that the General Assembly establish an escrow account into which Israel would pay.
The Obama administration could send a strong signal by voting to submit the report to the Security Council and the General Assembly, or even by abstaining. But, despite its fine words on Monday, it is more likely to want to bury it. Otherwise, attention will focus on prosecuting an Israel it's trying to nudge to the negotiating table. The problem it will face is that Third World countries dominate both the Human Rights Council and General Assembly and they traditionally support Palestinian rights. So it will seek an alliance with Egypt and the Palestinian Authority. If they indicate they do not want the report to go forward, the rest of the Third World would find it hard to go over their heads.
But could Egypt and the Palestinian Authority possibly want to stop accountability for war crimes in Gaza? Hard to believe, but they may have already done so earlier this year when Father Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, the General Assembly's Nicaraguan president, tried to get the international community to stop the slaughter.
Father Miguel has named no names, but in his speech at the end of his one-year term this week, he left little doubt about what happened. He said he had tried to persuade "those who should have been most closely involved" to convene the General Assembly to help the Palestinians under fire. But "all I received was advice to give the process more time... we should do nothing that could endanger the success that was always just beyond our reach."
And he went on to make a very serious accusation against "those who should supposedly have been most interested" yet "denied their support." He said he hoped "that they were right and that I was wrong. Otherwise, we face an ugly situation of constant complicity with the aggression against the rights of the noble and long-suffering Palestinian people."
If this complicity repeats itself at the Human Rights Council, the Goldstone Report will be sunk. The power of the state system (and a putative statelet) will have trumped the principles of international law and human rights -- unless human rights advocates act to make sure the right thing gets done.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Friday, September 18, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Settling for ... Israeli Settlements?
By Nadia Hijab
The Arabs have a saying for someone who's not getting anywhere: "He's managed to explain, after considerable strain, that water is water." And so it is with US envoy George Mitchell: After considerable effort he's apparently settled for a settlement freeze that involves more settlements.
A freeze turns out to have been a bad idea from the start, and no one understood just how bad it was better than Israeli attorney Michael Sfard, who has been suing the Israeli state over settlements for months. "The idea of a settlement freeze was created by people who don't understand settlements," Sfard says because the very raison d'être of settlements is "growth and enlarging the scope of territorial domination."
Anyone who knows the history understands that "redeeming" the land has been at the heart of the Israeli enterprise from Day One. Just ask any Palestinian.
Sfard foresaw the mess the Obama Administration finds itself in today as it seeks to bring about a two-state solution. Speaking at an event at the Washington DC-based New America Foundation back in mid-July, he explained that any "freeze" would be undermined in two ways: through planning of settlement construction, and through settler violence.
In fulfilment of Sfard's prediction, Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu has just had his construction plans approved by the Israeli cabinet in advance of any announcement of a settlement freeze he may make with US envoy George Mitchell later this week, or at the United Nations General Assembly later this month. This 'freeze' would exclude 2,500 units under construction in East Jerusalem -- and it will be temporary, if press reports are to be believed.
Who would have thought that we might one day regret the passing of Condi & Co.? After all, no one had great expectations of the Bush Administration to begin with, and certainly not after the serial devastation of Afghanistan, Iraq, Lebanon, and Gaza. Hardly anyone took Condoleezza Rice's multiple trips to the region seriously, and the Annapolis process was seen as no more than the froth on a badly brewed cappuccino.
But the people of the region have had expectations of Obama and Mitchell, whose credibility has been dented by the months Mitchell has spent patting the Israelis into a comfortable settlement posture and squeezing the Arabs for gestures of normalization.
About the only thing that can still be said for the two-state solution is that it might save a little bit of the land of Palestine for the Palestinians. If the Obama Administration can't convince its closest ally and largest aid recipient to freeze, let alone dismantle, its settlements then what's the point?
Even former president Jimmy Carter has written in an Op Ed in The Washington Post that a one state solution now seems a more "likely alternative to the present debacle."
Nonetheless, there are a few rays of hope in an otherwise gloomy landscape. One is the work of Michael Sfard himself and of Yesh Din, the group he serves as legal counsel. Yesh Din is using hitherto untapped information sources to sue the state over Israel's illegal settlement activity. It also monitors settler violence as part of a project to protect the Palestinians living under occupation.
Sfard's visit to Washington DC -- during which he visited the Obama administration and Congressional offices -- is part of a new trend of Israeli human rights organizations speaking directly to the American policy community. Sfard's trip was sponsored by the Carter Center, whose staff realized that Israeli human rights groups were focusing their outreach on Europe because they lacked the resources to visit America.
The other hopeful trend remains the work of the Palestinian civil society, whose boycott call against Israel's violations of Palestinian rights bears new fruit almost every day. Most recently Jane Fonda, Naomi Klein, Alice Walker, and Danny Glover joined over 50 artists to protest the Toronto International Film Festival spotlight on the city of Tel Aviv. They are not against showing Israeli films but rather are against the staging of "a propaganda campaign on behalf of ... an apartheid regime."
And then there is the Norwegian pension fund decision to divest from the Israeli company Elbit Systems for its involvement in construction on occupied Palestinian land. "We do not wish to fund companies that so directly contribute to violations of international humanitarian law," explained Finance Minister Kristin Halvorsen.
If only Obama would hearken to those Nordic words. But perhaps it is premature to mourn his administration's foray into the peace process. The tight-lipped Mitchell may yet have something up his sleeve. Otherwise, come back, Condi, at least we knew where we were.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
The Arabs have a saying for someone who's not getting anywhere: "He's managed to explain, after considerable strain, that water is water." And so it is with US envoy George Mitchell: After considerable effort he's apparently settled for a settlement freeze that involves more settlements.
A freeze turns out to have been a bad idea from the start, and no one understood just how bad it was better than Israeli attorney Michael Sfard, who has been suing the Israeli state over settlements for months. "The idea of a settlement freeze was created by people who don't understand settlements," Sfard says because the very raison d'être of settlements is "growth and enlarging the scope of territorial domination."
Anyone who knows the history understands that "redeeming" the land has been at the heart of the Israeli enterprise from Day One. Just ask any Palestinian.
Sfard foresaw the mess the Obama Administration finds itself in today as it seeks to bring about a two-state solution. Speaking at an event at the Washington DC-based New America Foundation back in mid-July, he explained that any "freeze" would be undermined in two ways: through planning of settlement construction, and through settler violence.
In fulfilment of Sfard's prediction, Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu has just had his construction plans approved by the Israeli cabinet in advance of any announcement of a settlement freeze he may make with US envoy George Mitchell later this week, or at the United Nations General Assembly later this month. This 'freeze' would exclude 2,500 units under construction in East Jerusalem -- and it will be temporary, if press reports are to be believed.
Who would have thought that we might one day regret the passing of Condi & Co.? After all, no one had great expectations of the Bush Administration to begin with, and certainly not after the serial devastation of Afghanistan, Iraq, Lebanon, and Gaza. Hardly anyone took Condoleezza Rice's multiple trips to the region seriously, and the Annapolis process was seen as no more than the froth on a badly brewed cappuccino.
But the people of the region have had expectations of Obama and Mitchell, whose credibility has been dented by the months Mitchell has spent patting the Israelis into a comfortable settlement posture and squeezing the Arabs for gestures of normalization.
About the only thing that can still be said for the two-state solution is that it might save a little bit of the land of Palestine for the Palestinians. If the Obama Administration can't convince its closest ally and largest aid recipient to freeze, let alone dismantle, its settlements then what's the point?
Even former president Jimmy Carter has written in an Op Ed in The Washington Post that a one state solution now seems a more "likely alternative to the present debacle."
Nonetheless, there are a few rays of hope in an otherwise gloomy landscape. One is the work of Michael Sfard himself and of Yesh Din, the group he serves as legal counsel. Yesh Din is using hitherto untapped information sources to sue the state over Israel's illegal settlement activity. It also monitors settler violence as part of a project to protect the Palestinians living under occupation.
Sfard's visit to Washington DC -- during which he visited the Obama administration and Congressional offices -- is part of a new trend of Israeli human rights organizations speaking directly to the American policy community. Sfard's trip was sponsored by the Carter Center, whose staff realized that Israeli human rights groups were focusing their outreach on Europe because they lacked the resources to visit America.
The other hopeful trend remains the work of the Palestinian civil society, whose boycott call against Israel's violations of Palestinian rights bears new fruit almost every day. Most recently Jane Fonda, Naomi Klein, Alice Walker, and Danny Glover joined over 50 artists to protest the Toronto International Film Festival spotlight on the city of Tel Aviv. They are not against showing Israeli films but rather are against the staging of "a propaganda campaign on behalf of ... an apartheid regime."
And then there is the Norwegian pension fund decision to divest from the Israeli company Elbit Systems for its involvement in construction on occupied Palestinian land. "We do not wish to fund companies that so directly contribute to violations of international humanitarian law," explained Finance Minister Kristin Halvorsen.
If only Obama would hearken to those Nordic words. But perhaps it is premature to mourn his administration's foray into the peace process. The tight-lipped Mitchell may yet have something up his sleeve. Otherwise, come back, Condi, at least we knew where we were.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Saturday, September 12, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Playing From Strength In The Middle East
By Nadia Hijab
The peace plans proliferated shortly after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. In these "land for peace" deals, Israel would evacuate the territory it had occupied in exchange for peace with the Arabs and in line with the United Nations Security Council resolution 242.
Israel concluded such deals with both Egypt and Jordan. But as it continued to colonize the occupied Palestinian territories and the Golan Heights, Arabs began to worry about a "peace for peace" scenario: Israel keeps the land while Arabs get the peace.
Today the Obama Administration appears stuck in a "freeze for peace" moment: an Israeli freeze on settlements in exchange for further Arab normalization. This might have been a good idea when first mooted. Not any more. It has been undermined by reports of an American-Israeli thaw to continue construction of some 2,500 housing units in the illegal settlements.
And it has hit up against an Arab position. As Saudi Arabia's foreign minister put it starkly this week, unless Israel is clearly committed to withdrawing from Arab lands, there is no interest in incremental "confidence-building measures." This is hardly surprising -- given that Israel has expanded settlements for 42 years.
The problem with "freeze for peace" is that the Obama administration is playing from weakness. It is like a poker player with a large pile of chips facing a belligerent player with only a few chips left -- most of which the administration has given or lent him -- just shelling out hard-earned cash to keep the old game going.
America, instead, should play from strength. Here are five suggestions, none too politically costly to Obama:
First, up the ante. The administration can neatly step out of the trap it has unwittingly set for itself by shifting the discourse from a settlement freeze to an evacuation.
Here's what Obama could say: "Let me be clear. I have already stated that my administration does not accept the legitimacy of continued Israeli settlements. There is no point having 'natural growth' in structures which must be evacuated, as required by international law. Peace with the Palestinians -- based on two sovereign states along the 1967 borders with minor, mutually agreed modifications -- is the best guarantee of Israel's survival and security. We call on the world to act: Not against Israel, but against Israel's occupation."
Second, the administration should heed the growing mainstream demands to stop those American Jewish organizations that are funding the illegal settlements. The Washington Post has carried two solidly researched pieces questioning these organizations' tax-free status -- one by David Ignatius in March, and one by Ronit Avni in June. You don't get more mainstream than the Post, and these columns reflect a fast-growing shift in American public opinion, including among American Jews, in support of tougher action for peace.
Third, just as Israel is stalling on what America has described as one of its national security interests -- peace in the Middle East -- the administration should similarly stall on issues important to Israel. For instance, sharing military technology, providing military aid or loan guarantees, and conducting joint military exercises. Bureaucracies can find ways to slow things down without a policy shift, and the administration should use them all.
Indeed, Obama should recall that the Bush administration slapped tough sanctions against Israel in 2005, when it violated restrictions on sharing American technology by selling Harpy killer drones to China. Israel got the message and toed the line.
Fourth, engage Hamas so as to rescue Gaza and enable reunification of Palestinian ranks. This is easily done. Hamas has upheld a ceasefire with Israel. Its leader, Khaled Meshal, supported a two-state solution in a May interview with The New York Times. The Quartet (Russia, America, European Union, and United Nations) could interpret this as constituting acceptance of its conditions that Hamas renounce violence, recognize Israel's existence, and accept past agreements
Fifth, encourage Europe to deflect some of the heat from the United States. The European Union has shelved an upgrade of relations with Israel. Some member states are taking action against Israeli imports made in the illegal settlements. But Europe could do much more, given that it is Israel's largest trading partner.
European leaders are ready for such measures. For example, in late July several British members of parliament forcefully challenged a government minister for not doing more to end Israel's occupation. As one parliamentarian put it, "Our Government's response has been to protest to the Israeli ambassador, but [this] is like shouting at a fish. All the evidence is that, when we protest, the Israelis build the settlements even faster."
There is much more the Obama administration can do. The five steps outlined above are just a few of the chips it has to hand -- powerful diplomatic ways to bring about peace.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
The peace plans proliferated shortly after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. In these "land for peace" deals, Israel would evacuate the territory it had occupied in exchange for peace with the Arabs and in line with the United Nations Security Council resolution 242.
Israel concluded such deals with both Egypt and Jordan. But as it continued to colonize the occupied Palestinian territories and the Golan Heights, Arabs began to worry about a "peace for peace" scenario: Israel keeps the land while Arabs get the peace.
Today the Obama Administration appears stuck in a "freeze for peace" moment: an Israeli freeze on settlements in exchange for further Arab normalization. This might have been a good idea when first mooted. Not any more. It has been undermined by reports of an American-Israeli thaw to continue construction of some 2,500 housing units in the illegal settlements.
And it has hit up against an Arab position. As Saudi Arabia's foreign minister put it starkly this week, unless Israel is clearly committed to withdrawing from Arab lands, there is no interest in incremental "confidence-building measures." This is hardly surprising -- given that Israel has expanded settlements for 42 years.
The problem with "freeze for peace" is that the Obama administration is playing from weakness. It is like a poker player with a large pile of chips facing a belligerent player with only a few chips left -- most of which the administration has given or lent him -- just shelling out hard-earned cash to keep the old game going.
America, instead, should play from strength. Here are five suggestions, none too politically costly to Obama:
First, up the ante. The administration can neatly step out of the trap it has unwittingly set for itself by shifting the discourse from a settlement freeze to an evacuation.
Here's what Obama could say: "Let me be clear. I have already stated that my administration does not accept the legitimacy of continued Israeli settlements. There is no point having 'natural growth' in structures which must be evacuated, as required by international law. Peace with the Palestinians -- based on two sovereign states along the 1967 borders with minor, mutually agreed modifications -- is the best guarantee of Israel's survival and security. We call on the world to act: Not against Israel, but against Israel's occupation."
Second, the administration should heed the growing mainstream demands to stop those American Jewish organizations that are funding the illegal settlements. The Washington Post has carried two solidly researched pieces questioning these organizations' tax-free status -- one by David Ignatius in March, and one by Ronit Avni in June. You don't get more mainstream than the Post, and these columns reflect a fast-growing shift in American public opinion, including among American Jews, in support of tougher action for peace.
Third, just as Israel is stalling on what America has described as one of its national security interests -- peace in the Middle East -- the administration should similarly stall on issues important to Israel. For instance, sharing military technology, providing military aid or loan guarantees, and conducting joint military exercises. Bureaucracies can find ways to slow things down without a policy shift, and the administration should use them all.
Indeed, Obama should recall that the Bush administration slapped tough sanctions against Israel in 2005, when it violated restrictions on sharing American technology by selling Harpy killer drones to China. Israel got the message and toed the line.
Fourth, engage Hamas so as to rescue Gaza and enable reunification of Palestinian ranks. This is easily done. Hamas has upheld a ceasefire with Israel. Its leader, Khaled Meshal, supported a two-state solution in a May interview with The New York Times. The Quartet (Russia, America, European Union, and United Nations) could interpret this as constituting acceptance of its conditions that Hamas renounce violence, recognize Israel's existence, and accept past agreements
Fifth, encourage Europe to deflect some of the heat from the United States. The European Union has shelved an upgrade of relations with Israel. Some member states are taking action against Israeli imports made in the illegal settlements. But Europe could do much more, given that it is Israel's largest trading partner.
European leaders are ready for such measures. For example, in late July several British members of parliament forcefully challenged a government minister for not doing more to end Israel's occupation. As one parliamentarian put it, "Our Government's response has been to protest to the Israeli ambassador, but [this] is like shouting at a fish. All the evidence is that, when we protest, the Israelis build the settlements even faster."
There is much more the Obama administration can do. The five steps outlined above are just a few of the chips it has to hand -- powerful diplomatic ways to bring about peace.
Nadia Hijab is an independent analyst and a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Friday, August 07, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Memoirs Of A Lost Arab World
By Nadia Hijab
"It was a trying time for dreamers," Wadad Makdisi Cortas wrote of the year 1935. She was 26 and "yearned to speak my language, to read Arabic books, and to foster Arab independence and solidarity." But she had just become the headmistress of a girls' school in Lebanon that was a particular thorn in the side of the French colonial rulers.
As in their other colonies, the French imposed their language, insisting that the students at the Ahliah National School for Girls not only be taught in French but also use it at recess. "Students who insisted on speaking Arabic were to be singled out, and those who persisted were to be given detention," Cortas recalled. (Of course, as history marched on, English won the battle to become the global lingua franca.)
Cortas' memoirs span the 20th Century: She was born in 1909 and died in 1979. She writes beautifully, with dry humor and with sadness, of living and travelling in a Middle East without borders and of the agony inflicted as frontiers were carved into a soil alive with friendships and family ties -- agonies that continue to this day.
She evokes a time when Jews and Arabs mingled freely, then stopped due to the growing conflict as Palestine was forcibly transformed into Israel. And she describes from personal knowledge -- she was one of 12 women amidst 1,000 men at the American University of Beirut -- women's struggle for a place in the public sphere.
Cortas was still the headmistress when my mother taught at Ahliah years later and when I went to school there decades later. So I turned to the just-published English translation of her memoirs, A World I Loved: The Story of an Arab Woman (Nation Books) with anticipation mixed with apprehension. She was a formidable woman and I had left a lot of homework undone: I was sure she would reach across the pages of time to hold me to account.
To my mind, perhaps the book's most astonishing revelation was that she was only five feet tall. She so towered over everyone, her back straighter than the wall in the assembly hall where we were gathered for pep talks and music. But of course she spoke from the stage and we were much smaller then.
When she was growing up, in the early days of the 20th Century, Arabs were not yet worried about Zionism. Cortas describes a mixed Middle East that included White Russians, Armenians, Turks, Jews and many others among the Arabs. In her youth, this woman from what had just become Lebanon even visited a Jewish kibbutz in the Galilee. She describes it as efficiently run by recently arrived Polish Jews but "completely detached from the life of the area." Arabs only later discovered that many kibbutz dwellers were being trained in modern warfare at the same time as the British empire was disarming the Palestinians.
Cortas' writing is often lyrical. She depicts a Beirut where mulberry trees and orchards stretched out in place of today's chic restaurants and cafes. "We learned to love the sea in all of its moods," she writes, and tells of the old fisherman Khalil who remained by the sea when the Italians bombarded the Lebanese coast on the eve of World War I. His philosophy: "Conquerors come and go. Only the sea is eternally with us."
She was bred on politics, which were then as they are now a matter of life and death. She listened as her father and his friends argued long into the night whether Arab aspirations for independence would fare better under a weak Ottoman Empire or by supporting the British and French. Arab nationalists chose the latter and paid a price still exacted today.
Cortas came from a family of redoubtable women, and her father supported the equality of the sexes. She and her sister were the first girls from their school -- they also studied at Ahliah -- to go to university. At the American University of Beirut, they were able to get an education but had no social life. In a puzzling insight into social mores, roller-skating was the only sport considered proper for young women.
The female students were not allowed to attend historical plays, but could take up public speaking, and they happily debated the emancipation of women and political freedoms. The student body went on strike to protest British and French imperialism, but America was looked upon with favor as "a great center of liberal ideas." That was then.
Cortas visited America many times in later years, admiring its "organization and discipline" but finding that "grace had vanished. Life was a swift race, and no one could afford to loiter." She noted that black students at the University of Michigan, where she worked for a post-graduate degree, were a small minority and were "quite aloof. When it was my privilege to have contact with some of them, they unloaded their painful recollections." In perhaps the understatement of the century, she thought it would "take a long time to change the situation."
This globe-trotting woman also taught in Iraq back in 1930. Her daily commute in Baghdad involved a boat ride across the Tigris, past riverbanks adorned with tall palms dangling red dates, gardens, and palaces. "I did not have eyes enough to see all the haunting sights of this magical city."
But Cortas soon got into trouble. Chosen to speak to a cohort of graduating pilots, she "prepared a fiery speech expressing pride at seeing the first Arab aviators fly in Arab skies. I must have been strongly moved, for the speech disturbed the British authorities." For the rest of her stay, she concentrated on her teaching.
Palestine, Lebanon, Iraq, and the whole Arab world were intertwined then, and, in spite of the borders, still are. Cortas' daughter Mariam married the late Palestinian intellectual Edward Said. Cortas helped to found and served on the board of many organizations, including the Institute for Palestine Studies, to which I am affiliated.
This intertwining is why to be an Arab is to sometimes live in a well of sorrow. My mother, who also taught in Baghdad in her youth, before her exile from Palestine, spent her last years in Jordan. The advent of satellite TV into many homes since 2000 meant that she was daily buffeted by graphic images of terrifying death in Iraq to the east and in Palestine to the west. Perhaps many Arabs found some meagre comfort, as I did, that their parents were no longer alive for the Israeli assault on Gaza this winter.
Cortas wrote before she died in 1979: "War has crowded the memories of my youth and old age and every stage in between." She witnessed the early flowering and brutal crushing of Arab nationalism; the catastrophic loss of Palestine in 1948, which has defined the region since; national liberation movements; the growing rapaciousness of oil wealth, local and foreign; and the succession of home grown dictators and their freedoms denied.
Her last years were marked by the horrors of the Lebanese civil war, described in staccato sentences in between sheltering from the fighting. Yet her legacy lives on and the school she served for so long has remained a byword for Arab nationalism. But her nationalism was never of an ugly, exclusivist kind. Rather it was about people attached to their land being able to express their identity amidst diversity.
She wondered whether succeeding generations would "prove wiser" than her own. As if to answer that question, the introduction was written by her daughter Mariam, who worked tirelessly to get the English edition published in time for the 100th anniversary of her mother's birth. Mariam has loving, and unflinchingly honest, memories of her mother.
And the afterword is written by Cortas' granddaughter Najla, an accomplished actress, who discovered during a visit to Lebanon in 2006, when war raged once more, that she was the veteran now, comforting children and "somehow responsible for future generations." She and her peers fought down their fear and went on to protest in old ways and new, blogging and creating art, music and theatre, with "no sense of resignation."
Had Cortas lived through the horrors of the wars of the present day, she would also have seen much determination and sensed many changes, small but tangible, giving hope that a world loved is not yet lost. It is still a trying time for dreamers. Yet there are dreamers still, of all races and creeds, striving for a different reality.
"It was a trying time for dreamers," Wadad Makdisi Cortas wrote of the year 1935. She was 26 and "yearned to speak my language, to read Arabic books, and to foster Arab independence and solidarity." But she had just become the headmistress of a girls' school in Lebanon that was a particular thorn in the side of the French colonial rulers.
As in their other colonies, the French imposed their language, insisting that the students at the Ahliah National School for Girls not only be taught in French but also use it at recess. "Students who insisted on speaking Arabic were to be singled out, and those who persisted were to be given detention," Cortas recalled. (Of course, as history marched on, English won the battle to become the global lingua franca.)
Cortas' memoirs span the 20th Century: She was born in 1909 and died in 1979. She writes beautifully, with dry humor and with sadness, of living and travelling in a Middle East without borders and of the agony inflicted as frontiers were carved into a soil alive with friendships and family ties -- agonies that continue to this day.
She evokes a time when Jews and Arabs mingled freely, then stopped due to the growing conflict as Palestine was forcibly transformed into Israel. And she describes from personal knowledge -- she was one of 12 women amidst 1,000 men at the American University of Beirut -- women's struggle for a place in the public sphere.
Cortas was still the headmistress when my mother taught at Ahliah years later and when I went to school there decades later. So I turned to the just-published English translation of her memoirs, A World I Loved: The Story of an Arab Woman (Nation Books) with anticipation mixed with apprehension. She was a formidable woman and I had left a lot of homework undone: I was sure she would reach across the pages of time to hold me to account.
To my mind, perhaps the book's most astonishing revelation was that she was only five feet tall. She so towered over everyone, her back straighter than the wall in the assembly hall where we were gathered for pep talks and music. But of course she spoke from the stage and we were much smaller then.
When she was growing up, in the early days of the 20th Century, Arabs were not yet worried about Zionism. Cortas describes a mixed Middle East that included White Russians, Armenians, Turks, Jews and many others among the Arabs. In her youth, this woman from what had just become Lebanon even visited a Jewish kibbutz in the Galilee. She describes it as efficiently run by recently arrived Polish Jews but "completely detached from the life of the area." Arabs only later discovered that many kibbutz dwellers were being trained in modern warfare at the same time as the British empire was disarming the Palestinians.
Cortas' writing is often lyrical. She depicts a Beirut where mulberry trees and orchards stretched out in place of today's chic restaurants and cafes. "We learned to love the sea in all of its moods," she writes, and tells of the old fisherman Khalil who remained by the sea when the Italians bombarded the Lebanese coast on the eve of World War I. His philosophy: "Conquerors come and go. Only the sea is eternally with us."
She was bred on politics, which were then as they are now a matter of life and death. She listened as her father and his friends argued long into the night whether Arab aspirations for independence would fare better under a weak Ottoman Empire or by supporting the British and French. Arab nationalists chose the latter and paid a price still exacted today.
Cortas came from a family of redoubtable women, and her father supported the equality of the sexes. She and her sister were the first girls from their school -- they also studied at Ahliah -- to go to university. At the American University of Beirut, they were able to get an education but had no social life. In a puzzling insight into social mores, roller-skating was the only sport considered proper for young women.
The female students were not allowed to attend historical plays, but could take up public speaking, and they happily debated the emancipation of women and political freedoms. The student body went on strike to protest British and French imperialism, but America was looked upon with favor as "a great center of liberal ideas." That was then.
Cortas visited America many times in later years, admiring its "organization and discipline" but finding that "grace had vanished. Life was a swift race, and no one could afford to loiter." She noted that black students at the University of Michigan, where she worked for a post-graduate degree, were a small minority and were "quite aloof. When it was my privilege to have contact with some of them, they unloaded their painful recollections." In perhaps the understatement of the century, she thought it would "take a long time to change the situation."
This globe-trotting woman also taught in Iraq back in 1930. Her daily commute in Baghdad involved a boat ride across the Tigris, past riverbanks adorned with tall palms dangling red dates, gardens, and palaces. "I did not have eyes enough to see all the haunting sights of this magical city."
But Cortas soon got into trouble. Chosen to speak to a cohort of graduating pilots, she "prepared a fiery speech expressing pride at seeing the first Arab aviators fly in Arab skies. I must have been strongly moved, for the speech disturbed the British authorities." For the rest of her stay, she concentrated on her teaching.
Palestine, Lebanon, Iraq, and the whole Arab world were intertwined then, and, in spite of the borders, still are. Cortas' daughter Mariam married the late Palestinian intellectual Edward Said. Cortas helped to found and served on the board of many organizations, including the Institute for Palestine Studies, to which I am affiliated.
This intertwining is why to be an Arab is to sometimes live in a well of sorrow. My mother, who also taught in Baghdad in her youth, before her exile from Palestine, spent her last years in Jordan. The advent of satellite TV into many homes since 2000 meant that she was daily buffeted by graphic images of terrifying death in Iraq to the east and in Palestine to the west. Perhaps many Arabs found some meagre comfort, as I did, that their parents were no longer alive for the Israeli assault on Gaza this winter.
Cortas wrote before she died in 1979: "War has crowded the memories of my youth and old age and every stage in between." She witnessed the early flowering and brutal crushing of Arab nationalism; the catastrophic loss of Palestine in 1948, which has defined the region since; national liberation movements; the growing rapaciousness of oil wealth, local and foreign; and the succession of home grown dictators and their freedoms denied.
Her last years were marked by the horrors of the Lebanese civil war, described in staccato sentences in between sheltering from the fighting. Yet her legacy lives on and the school she served for so long has remained a byword for Arab nationalism. But her nationalism was never of an ugly, exclusivist kind. Rather it was about people attached to their land being able to express their identity amidst diversity.
She wondered whether succeeding generations would "prove wiser" than her own. As if to answer that question, the introduction was written by her daughter Mariam, who worked tirelessly to get the English edition published in time for the 100th anniversary of her mother's birth. Mariam has loving, and unflinchingly honest, memories of her mother.
And the afterword is written by Cortas' granddaughter Najla, an accomplished actress, who discovered during a visit to Lebanon in 2006, when war raged once more, that she was the veteran now, comforting children and "somehow responsible for future generations." She and her peers fought down their fear and went on to protest in old ways and new, blogging and creating art, music and theatre, with "no sense of resignation."
Had Cortas lived through the horrors of the wars of the present day, she would also have seen much determination and sensed many changes, small but tangible, giving hope that a world loved is not yet lost. It is still a trying time for dreamers. Yet there are dreamers still, of all races and creeds, striving for a different reality.
Wednesday, July 22, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Palestinian Titanic
By Nadia Hijab
Dialogue. Confidence-building measures. Joint committees. Prisoner exchanges. These are all terms we have grown used to hearing during the endless Israeli-Palestinian negotiations. Now we're hearing them about negotiations between the Palestinians themselves -- or rather among the political forces that claim leadership of the Palestinians, with the Fatah and Hamas movements at their head.
Egyptian mediators billed the latest round of negotiations in early July -- the sixth such "national dialogue" -- as the make-or-break round for reconciliation. However, those talks only resulted in plans for another round on July 25, which is supposed to conclude with a reconciliation agreement on July 28.
Each side appears willing to wait the other out. Fatah believes that Hamas, weakened by years of siege, will be further crippled by changes in the status of its allies: the weak showing by the Hizbullah-led alliance in Lebanon's parliamentary elections, the turmoil in the wake of Iran's elections, and Syria's growing rapprochement with the United States. Hamas is hoping that the international community's stance towards it will continue to soften.
Rarely have leaders appeared so disconnected from the needs and rights of the people they claim to represent. The conditions in Gaza are so dire that Americans, Europeans and other civilians undertake quixotic attempts to break Israel's blockade, most recently through a humanitarian boat that was seized by the Israeli navy.
The Israeli blockade has prevented reconstruction after its year-end assault, and Gazans have been reduced to building homes from mud. Without reconciliation among Palestinian factions, the massive investment necessary to rebuild Gaza will not be forthcoming and Egypt will not reopen its own crossing.
As for the rest of the Israeli-occupied territories, here is a snapshot from the last week of June according to United Nations reports: Israeli forces injured 12 Palestinians in the West Bank, where the number of Israeli search operations exceeded the average for the first quarter of 2009, and there were three home demolitions, including two "forced self-demolitions" in East Jerusalem. Meanwhile Palestinian refugees and exiles languish in their 60-year limbo.
The dismemberment of the Palestinian national movement is one of Israel's biggest successes. Yet, while Israel -- and the Bush administration -- provoked the rift, Palestinian leaders are sustaining it, becoming passive onlookers who appear powerless to shape their future, as though only Israel and the United States have agency.
Unless they want to become even more irrelevant to their people's fate, Palestinian political parties might want to consider three things.
First, Hamas is not the enemy. Neither is Fatah. Israel is -- until an Israeli-Arab peace agreement brings freedom, justice, equality, and security. At present, it is pointless for Palestinian leaders to argue about elections and government posts; there is little to govern under Israel's occupation and in exile. Rather, they should step away from the lure of government and form a salvation front to rescue the national movement and lead the struggle for rights.
Second, the Palestinian national movement should work for peace with Israel from a position of strength. Unity is one element of such a position, intensive diplomatic outreach another. Yet, in the Palestinian context, strength does not necessarily mean military force. Armed resistance against occupation is sanctioned under international law -- if it does not violate the law by, for example, targeting civilians. But using weapons against Israel puts Palestinians on a battlefield where they are weakest and Israel is strongest and makes it appear that there are two equal adversaries with equal claims.
Third, Palestinians are not powerless. The international movement of solidarity is not only growing, it is growing increasingly powerful with the effective use of the non-violent tools of boycott and divestment.
Recently, the French corporation Veolia decided to pull out of the light rail project that connects Jerusalem to the illegal Israeli settlements -- a major victory for the Europe-wide boycott effort that was estimated to have cost the company $7 billion. Over in Australia, Melbourne decided not to renew the metro management contract of Veolia's company Connex, the target of a sister boycott campaign.
Jews continue to be among the most active boycotters. For example, the Yes Men, who use humor and subterfuge to spotlight corporate excesses, just withdrew from the Jerusalem Film Festival. In a powerful open letter, they said their decision was not easy given their Jewish roots. Then they cited the many human rights violations of Israel's occupation and declared, "Our film mustn't help lend an aura of normalcy to a state that makes these decisions. For us, that's the bottom line."
Fatah and Hamas should rejoin ranks on the basis of a different political program and skillfully use the many sources of strength available to the Palestinians. Otherwise they will be reduced to rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic while their ship of state rapidly sinks.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Dialogue. Confidence-building measures. Joint committees. Prisoner exchanges. These are all terms we have grown used to hearing during the endless Israeli-Palestinian negotiations. Now we're hearing them about negotiations between the Palestinians themselves -- or rather among the political forces that claim leadership of the Palestinians, with the Fatah and Hamas movements at their head.
Egyptian mediators billed the latest round of negotiations in early July -- the sixth such "national dialogue" -- as the make-or-break round for reconciliation. However, those talks only resulted in plans for another round on July 25, which is supposed to conclude with a reconciliation agreement on July 28.
Each side appears willing to wait the other out. Fatah believes that Hamas, weakened by years of siege, will be further crippled by changes in the status of its allies: the weak showing by the Hizbullah-led alliance in Lebanon's parliamentary elections, the turmoil in the wake of Iran's elections, and Syria's growing rapprochement with the United States. Hamas is hoping that the international community's stance towards it will continue to soften.
Rarely have leaders appeared so disconnected from the needs and rights of the people they claim to represent. The conditions in Gaza are so dire that Americans, Europeans and other civilians undertake quixotic attempts to break Israel's blockade, most recently through a humanitarian boat that was seized by the Israeli navy.
The Israeli blockade has prevented reconstruction after its year-end assault, and Gazans have been reduced to building homes from mud. Without reconciliation among Palestinian factions, the massive investment necessary to rebuild Gaza will not be forthcoming and Egypt will not reopen its own crossing.
As for the rest of the Israeli-occupied territories, here is a snapshot from the last week of June according to United Nations reports: Israeli forces injured 12 Palestinians in the West Bank, where the number of Israeli search operations exceeded the average for the first quarter of 2009, and there were three home demolitions, including two "forced self-demolitions" in East Jerusalem. Meanwhile Palestinian refugees and exiles languish in their 60-year limbo.
The dismemberment of the Palestinian national movement is one of Israel's biggest successes. Yet, while Israel -- and the Bush administration -- provoked the rift, Palestinian leaders are sustaining it, becoming passive onlookers who appear powerless to shape their future, as though only Israel and the United States have agency.
Unless they want to become even more irrelevant to their people's fate, Palestinian political parties might want to consider three things.
First, Hamas is not the enemy. Neither is Fatah. Israel is -- until an Israeli-Arab peace agreement brings freedom, justice, equality, and security. At present, it is pointless for Palestinian leaders to argue about elections and government posts; there is little to govern under Israel's occupation and in exile. Rather, they should step away from the lure of government and form a salvation front to rescue the national movement and lead the struggle for rights.
Second, the Palestinian national movement should work for peace with Israel from a position of strength. Unity is one element of such a position, intensive diplomatic outreach another. Yet, in the Palestinian context, strength does not necessarily mean military force. Armed resistance against occupation is sanctioned under international law -- if it does not violate the law by, for example, targeting civilians. But using weapons against Israel puts Palestinians on a battlefield where they are weakest and Israel is strongest and makes it appear that there are two equal adversaries with equal claims.
Third, Palestinians are not powerless. The international movement of solidarity is not only growing, it is growing increasingly powerful with the effective use of the non-violent tools of boycott and divestment.
Recently, the French corporation Veolia decided to pull out of the light rail project that connects Jerusalem to the illegal Israeli settlements -- a major victory for the Europe-wide boycott effort that was estimated to have cost the company $7 billion. Over in Australia, Melbourne decided not to renew the metro management contract of Veolia's company Connex, the target of a sister boycott campaign.
Jews continue to be among the most active boycotters. For example, the Yes Men, who use humor and subterfuge to spotlight corporate excesses, just withdrew from the Jerusalem Film Festival. In a powerful open letter, they said their decision was not easy given their Jewish roots. Then they cited the many human rights violations of Israel's occupation and declared, "Our film mustn't help lend an aura of normalcy to a state that makes these decisions. For us, that's the bottom line."
Fatah and Hamas should rejoin ranks on the basis of a different political program and skillfully use the many sources of strength available to the Palestinians. Otherwise they will be reduced to rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic while their ship of state rapidly sinks.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Thursday, July 09, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
The Obama Difference
By Nadia Hijab
In the days since Barack Obama's speech in Cairo last week there has been a desperate search for substance in between the lines of a great performance. Where are the policies that can change the lives of people in the Middle East hit by the wars and occupations initiated or supported by the United States?
Many have read much into Obama's speech - that was part of its genius - but it contained no policy announcements. That does not mean there are no policies. The Obama administration works differently from its predecessors in at least three ways.
First, it doesn't do business on the basis of public pronouncements. There will, for example, be no reprise of Bush senior's public appeal to the American people that he was "one little lonely guy" facing up to a thousand lobbyists from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee.
At that time, the Bush administration wanted Israel to attend the Madrid peace conference in the wake of the 1990-91 Gulf war. The White House also announced its intention to tie loan guarantees to Israel to ending settlement activity. In contrast, the Obama administration looks unlikely to make any public threats.
Second, the Obama administration speaks with one voice. The same tough line - settlements must stop, peace must start - is delivered by Mr. Obama; Vice President Joe Biden, who used to call himself a Zionist; Hillary Clinton, the former stridently pro-Israel junior senator from New York; Rahm Emanuel, who twice volunteered for the Israeli Army; the national security adviser, General James Jones; and the special envoy, George Mitchell.
This seamless act makes it hard for right-wing pro-Israel forces to drive in a policy wedge. This is a far cry from Bush junior's administration, when Vice President Dick Cheney and the deputy national security advisor Elliot Abrams actively undermined Condoleezza Rice's efforts.
Third, this is an administration that does its homework. It has studied the rise and fall of previous peace efforts, including Bill Clinton's hasty and ill-prepared convening of the Camp David summit in 2000. By contrast, weeks before Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visited Washington in May, the Obama team reportedly briefed key Democrats in Congress about possible disagreements with Israel.
When Mr. Netanyahu visited Capitol Hill, expecting to be shielded from the administration, Haaretz reported that he was "stunned" by a coordinated attack against his stand on settlements. Several leading lawmakers, including Jewish ones, said they thought Mr. Netanyahu should be "very, very aware of the concerns of the administration and Congress."
True, AIPAC secured 329 Congressional signatures on a letter urging Mr. Obama to pursue peace as "a devoted friend to Israel." But the warnings of senior lawmakers still carry weight.
Meanwhile, it is worth noting some of the policy shifts, however small. For instance, Israelis maintain that they had an understanding with the Bush administration supporting "natural growth" in the settlements. Hillary Clinton shot this down in no uncertain terms. The Obama administration, she pointed out, had been given the official records by the outgoing Bush administration, and there "is no memorialization of any informal and oral agreements. If they did occur, which, of course, people say they did, they did not become part of the official position of the United States Government."
As for the 2004 Bush exchange of letters with former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon that promised Israel it could have the major settlement blocs plus Jerusalem and minus the Palestinian refugees, the State Department spokesman steadfastly side-stepped a journalist's questions as to whether or not the letters were binding.
So, yes, nothing has changed on the ground yet. But because of the way it works, the Obama administration has a much better chance of bringing peace to the Middle East than its predecessors. Still, before breaking out the champagne, remember that Mr. Obama works within the boundaries of the American establishment.
Within those narrow confines and given the present Israeli-Palestinian power imbalance, the Palestinians are likely to secure a bare minimum of rights while Israel walks off with the rest. Unless, that is, the Palestinians can rapidly tilt the balance in their favor - or unless Israel's intransigence does it for them.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
In the days since Barack Obama's speech in Cairo last week there has been a desperate search for substance in between the lines of a great performance. Where are the policies that can change the lives of people in the Middle East hit by the wars and occupations initiated or supported by the United States?
Many have read much into Obama's speech - that was part of its genius - but it contained no policy announcements. That does not mean there are no policies. The Obama administration works differently from its predecessors in at least three ways.
First, it doesn't do business on the basis of public pronouncements. There will, for example, be no reprise of Bush senior's public appeal to the American people that he was "one little lonely guy" facing up to a thousand lobbyists from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee.
At that time, the Bush administration wanted Israel to attend the Madrid peace conference in the wake of the 1990-91 Gulf war. The White House also announced its intention to tie loan guarantees to Israel to ending settlement activity. In contrast, the Obama administration looks unlikely to make any public threats.
Second, the Obama administration speaks with one voice. The same tough line - settlements must stop, peace must start - is delivered by Mr. Obama; Vice President Joe Biden, who used to call himself a Zionist; Hillary Clinton, the former stridently pro-Israel junior senator from New York; Rahm Emanuel, who twice volunteered for the Israeli Army; the national security adviser, General James Jones; and the special envoy, George Mitchell.
This seamless act makes it hard for right-wing pro-Israel forces to drive in a policy wedge. This is a far cry from Bush junior's administration, when Vice President Dick Cheney and the deputy national security advisor Elliot Abrams actively undermined Condoleezza Rice's efforts.
Third, this is an administration that does its homework. It has studied the rise and fall of previous peace efforts, including Bill Clinton's hasty and ill-prepared convening of the Camp David summit in 2000. By contrast, weeks before Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visited Washington in May, the Obama team reportedly briefed key Democrats in Congress about possible disagreements with Israel.
When Mr. Netanyahu visited Capitol Hill, expecting to be shielded from the administration, Haaretz reported that he was "stunned" by a coordinated attack against his stand on settlements. Several leading lawmakers, including Jewish ones, said they thought Mr. Netanyahu should be "very, very aware of the concerns of the administration and Congress."
True, AIPAC secured 329 Congressional signatures on a letter urging Mr. Obama to pursue peace as "a devoted friend to Israel." But the warnings of senior lawmakers still carry weight.
Meanwhile, it is worth noting some of the policy shifts, however small. For instance, Israelis maintain that they had an understanding with the Bush administration supporting "natural growth" in the settlements. Hillary Clinton shot this down in no uncertain terms. The Obama administration, she pointed out, had been given the official records by the outgoing Bush administration, and there "is no memorialization of any informal and oral agreements. If they did occur, which, of course, people say they did, they did not become part of the official position of the United States Government."
As for the 2004 Bush exchange of letters with former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon that promised Israel it could have the major settlement blocs plus Jerusalem and minus the Palestinian refugees, the State Department spokesman steadfastly side-stepped a journalist's questions as to whether or not the letters were binding.
So, yes, nothing has changed on the ground yet. But because of the way it works, the Obama administration has a much better chance of bringing peace to the Middle East than its predecessors. Still, before breaking out the champagne, remember that Mr. Obama works within the boundaries of the American establishment.
Within those narrow confines and given the present Israeli-Palestinian power imbalance, the Palestinians are likely to secure a bare minimum of rights while Israel walks off with the rest. Unless, that is, the Palestinians can rapidly tilt the balance in their favor - or unless Israel's intransigence does it for them.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Tuesday, June 09, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...
The Real Heroes Of Durban
By Nadia Hijab
Barack Obama feels able to counsel others -- most recently Armenians and Turks -- to work through their pasts "in a way that is honest, open and constructive." Otherwise, he cautions, unresolved history "can be a heavy weight." And yet Obama decided to leave his own country's past unresolved by boycotting this week's international conference in Geneva convened to review progress (or otherwise) since the World Conference Against Racism held in Durban, South Africa in 2001.
This is a big step back from engagement with the international community, which the Obama administration had seemed to be promoting quite vigorously. And the U.S. move has encouraged other Western nations to boycott, further weakening what should have been an important forum.
All peoples of all colors have practiced slavery, race, oppression, and/or discrimination with varying ferocity. These are uncomfortable subjects at the best of times, but that's no reason not to talk about them. Otherwise, they are indeed a heavy weight.
Besides, by boycotting the conference, the United States is unlikely to stop the international movement for justice for the Palestinian people or end African American demands for reparations for slavery -- two of the main reasons why the administration is said to have decided not to go.
Even though the U.S. administration is not participating in the Durban Review Conference in Geneva, Americans and others can still take a moment for some personal reflection.
Why does racism still lurk within so many of them? Or, rather, within so many of us -- few members of the human race are immune. And what actions can people take when governments don't act?
A first step in dealing with the racist within is to become more conscious of the use of language.
Among Arab Americans, for example, it is common to hear the expression "She's pretty, even though she's dark." Or "Whiten our face," meaning, "Do us proud." When the implications are pointed out to them, some resist the accusation; others do change their speech and behavior.
At the same time, Black Americans account for the largest ethnic group among Muslims in America, some 30% of the total. The religion's openness to embrace races and ethnicities is an aspect of Islam that is not sufficiently acknowledged in the U.S. public sphere.
Among Black Americans, a shared experience of oppression does not necessarily translate into race-free relations. There are tensions between diverse ethnicities; different values are attached to skin shades and hair types. As her husband's race for the presidency grew more serious, Michelle Obama's hair grew straighter, part of a makeover grounded in a belief that Americans still ascribe a lower value to "kinky" hair.
The truth is, even as people struggle valiantly against slavery, racism, and colonialism, the features of the oppressor can insidiously come to be seen as superior. Conscious effort is needed not just to promote emancipation and end Jim Crow laws but also to change social mores.
For many peoples, the struggle against colonialism has created a strong sense of solidarity. In a recent example powerful for its symbolism, South African dockworkers in Durban, outraged by the attack on Gaza, refused to offload goods on a ship from Israel.
Many Black Americans have also supported the Palestinian struggle, some putting their careers at risk to do so. Although Arab American organizations reach out to Black, Latino and other communities, the Arab American community itself does not yet express sufficient understanding of and support for Black, Latino or other minority causes.
Prison would be a good place to start working on shared solidarity. The United States has the world's largest prison population -- over 2.3 million people are in jail. Black Americans account for a disproportionate number of prisoners: one of every 15 Black adults is in jail.
Palestinians could certainly resonate to these data. Some 11,000 Palestinian prisoners are in Israeli jails. It is said that nearly a quarter of the population has been jailed by Israel during its 42-year occupation.
As both communities know to their cost, the larger the number of the people oppressed, the more invisible they are. Many people know the name of Israel's sole prisoner in Palestinian hands; hardly anyone outside of their families can name one of the 11,000 Palestinian prisoners.
And people find it far easier to blame the victim than the perpetrators or the conditions that create victim hood. Racist explanations abound as to why so many Black Americans are in jail.
Discussions of race and oppression are often divisive and disruptive, but the road to freedom and real equality begins there. The Obama administration, which speaks so often of seeking justice at home and abroad, has set us all back with the roadblock it erected on the road to the Durban review conference. The real heroes of Durban are the South African dockworkers.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Barack Obama feels able to counsel others -- most recently Armenians and Turks -- to work through their pasts "in a way that is honest, open and constructive." Otherwise, he cautions, unresolved history "can be a heavy weight." And yet Obama decided to leave his own country's past unresolved by boycotting this week's international conference in Geneva convened to review progress (or otherwise) since the World Conference Against Racism held in Durban, South Africa in 2001.
This is a big step back from engagement with the international community, which the Obama administration had seemed to be promoting quite vigorously. And the U.S. move has encouraged other Western nations to boycott, further weakening what should have been an important forum.
All peoples of all colors have practiced slavery, race, oppression, and/or discrimination with varying ferocity. These are uncomfortable subjects at the best of times, but that's no reason not to talk about them. Otherwise, they are indeed a heavy weight.
Besides, by boycotting the conference, the United States is unlikely to stop the international movement for justice for the Palestinian people or end African American demands for reparations for slavery -- two of the main reasons why the administration is said to have decided not to go.
Even though the U.S. administration is not participating in the Durban Review Conference in Geneva, Americans and others can still take a moment for some personal reflection.
Why does racism still lurk within so many of them? Or, rather, within so many of us -- few members of the human race are immune. And what actions can people take when governments don't act?
A first step in dealing with the racist within is to become more conscious of the use of language.
Among Arab Americans, for example, it is common to hear the expression "She's pretty, even though she's dark." Or "Whiten our face," meaning, "Do us proud." When the implications are pointed out to them, some resist the accusation; others do change their speech and behavior.
At the same time, Black Americans account for the largest ethnic group among Muslims in America, some 30% of the total. The religion's openness to embrace races and ethnicities is an aspect of Islam that is not sufficiently acknowledged in the U.S. public sphere.
Among Black Americans, a shared experience of oppression does not necessarily translate into race-free relations. There are tensions between diverse ethnicities; different values are attached to skin shades and hair types. As her husband's race for the presidency grew more serious, Michelle Obama's hair grew straighter, part of a makeover grounded in a belief that Americans still ascribe a lower value to "kinky" hair.
The truth is, even as people struggle valiantly against slavery, racism, and colonialism, the features of the oppressor can insidiously come to be seen as superior. Conscious effort is needed not just to promote emancipation and end Jim Crow laws but also to change social mores.
For many peoples, the struggle against colonialism has created a strong sense of solidarity. In a recent example powerful for its symbolism, South African dockworkers in Durban, outraged by the attack on Gaza, refused to offload goods on a ship from Israel.
Many Black Americans have also supported the Palestinian struggle, some putting their careers at risk to do so. Although Arab American organizations reach out to Black, Latino and other communities, the Arab American community itself does not yet express sufficient understanding of and support for Black, Latino or other minority causes.
Prison would be a good place to start working on shared solidarity. The United States has the world's largest prison population -- over 2.3 million people are in jail. Black Americans account for a disproportionate number of prisoners: one of every 15 Black adults is in jail.
Palestinians could certainly resonate to these data. Some 11,000 Palestinian prisoners are in Israeli jails. It is said that nearly a quarter of the population has been jailed by Israel during its 42-year occupation.
As both communities know to their cost, the larger the number of the people oppressed, the more invisible they are. Many people know the name of Israel's sole prisoner in Palestinian hands; hardly anyone outside of their families can name one of the 11,000 Palestinian prisoners.
And people find it far easier to blame the victim than the perpetrators or the conditions that create victim hood. Racist explanations abound as to why so many Black Americans are in jail.
Discussions of race and oppression are often divisive and disruptive, but the road to freedom and real equality begins there. The Obama administration, which speaks so often of seeking justice at home and abroad, has set us all back with the roadblock it erected on the road to the Durban review conference. The real heroes of Durban are the South African dockworkers.
Nadia Hijab is a senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies.
Thursday, April 23, 2009 |
0
comments |
Read more...











