Israeli National Security Analyst Warns of Hezbollah-Al Qaeda Nukes, Advocates Attacking Population Centers, Holy Sites
By Richard Silverstein
Some political wonks and academic analysts have a tendency to create problems where none exist in order to justify the Wonk Full-Employment Opportunity Act. It’s sort of like the bankruptcy lawyer who rubs his hands with glee when the economy goes in the tank. But in this case, the consequences are far more weighty than mere financial ruin.
Chuck Freilich, a former Israeli national security advisor and academic analyst wrote a recent report aptly titled, The Armageddon Scenario: Israel and the Threat of Nuclear Terrorism, for the Begin-Sadat Center which advocates bombing back to the Stone Age any Muslim group or nation which announces the intention of acquiring a nuclear weapon and which Israel views as a threat. He views usual suspects like Iran as such a threat. In fact, if Freilich’s advice were adopted by the current government, Teheran would now be a smoking ruin.
But he widens the scope to include Al Qaeda and even Hezbollah as potential culprits. Freilich advocates full force not just against the group or nation that threatens Israel, but against any other party or nation which offers nuclear technology or assistance in the pursuit of WMD capacity.
The rhetoric of this report must be read to be believed. It’s pure Gothic horror show:
Note well too that Freilich is not talking about retaliation AFTER an attack against Israel, he’s talking about a pre-emptive attack BEFORE a Muslim nation even gets a nuclear capability. He’s also talking about Israeli willingness to use every weapon in its arsenal, including nuclear weapons one must presume. And he’s talking about Israel bombing not just major populations centers like Teheran, but religious shrines. He acknowledges faintly that this might “exacerbate the religious dimension” without coming face to face with the fact that he’s advocated provoking a religious holy war against Islam.
Talk about thinking the unthinkable. There are reasons why some thoughts and ideas are taboo. There are reasons why humanity clings desperately to a few basic values and rules of civilization. It’s so that lunacy like this does not take hold and drive us like lemmings over the cliff and to oblivion. If Prof. Freilich wants to jump by all means let him. But don’t take the rest of us with you on the way down, thank you.
Let’s also remember that Al Qaeda has shown no ability to carry out a nuclear attack on anyone. Hezbollah hasn’t even said it would be interested in such a heinous act. So to anticipate the likelihood of this happening is again to create a problem where none exists. And this is the modus operandi for the Israeli nationalist right and U.S. neocons. It was what got us into the Iraq war via Saddam’s supposed WMD. It’s what could lure Israel into its next military misadventure.
When I first read about this report I was hoping that it was authored by a typical right-wing nut job whose ranting could be safely ignored. But Freilich’s report was prepared for the widely respected Begin-Sadat Center. He’s been a fellow at Belfer Center of the JFK School of Government at Harvard. He’s served in senior positions in the Israeli defense ministry, the UN mission, and been deputy national security advisor. He writes regularly for the centrist Bitterlemons website. He seems to have gravitas. And that’s what scares me.
If this is what serious Israeli analysts are thinking Israel’s in a whole heap of trouble. And not just Israel. The fallout of such Israeli bellicosity will surely suck the U.S. into the maelstrƶm. Do we want that?
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Some political wonks and academic analysts have a tendency to create problems where none exist in order to justify the Wonk Full-Employment Opportunity Act. It’s sort of like the bankruptcy lawyer who rubs his hands with glee when the economy goes in the tank. But in this case, the consequences are far more weighty than mere financial ruin.
Chuck Freilich, a former Israeli national security advisor and academic analyst wrote a recent report aptly titled, The Armageddon Scenario: Israel and the Threat of Nuclear Terrorism, for the Begin-Sadat Center which advocates bombing back to the Stone Age any Muslim group or nation which announces the intention of acquiring a nuclear weapon and which Israel views as a threat. He views usual suspects like Iran as such a threat. In fact, if Freilich’s advice were adopted by the current government, Teheran would now be a smoking ruin.
But he widens the scope to include Al Qaeda and even Hezbollah as potential culprits. Freilich advocates full force not just against the group or nation that threatens Israel, but against any other party or nation which offers nuclear technology or assistance in the pursuit of WMD capacity.
The rhetoric of this report must be read to be believed. It’s pure Gothic horror show:
Potential perpetrators of nuclear terrorism must be convinced that the US and Israel will retaliate devastatingly. For Israel, this means a “shoot first, no questions asked” policy. Both those clearly responsible for an attack (if any) and those reasonably suspected of involvement must be held accountable. There will be no room for diplomacy, and Israel must respond with all capabilities at its disposal, without waiting for the results of nuclear forensics.
In the event of a declared nuclear terrorist capability, a stated intention to acquire one, or an advanced suspected one, the known or suspected perpetrator and host country should be attacked with overwhelming and if necessary devastating force, in the attempt to prevent the threat’s materialization. As things stand today, and unless virtually irrefutable and immediate evidence exists to the contrary, Israel should adopt a declared retaliatory policy which holds Iran and/or al-Qaeda responsible for any nuclear attack, regardless of who may or may not have carried it out.
If the source of a terrorist nuclear attack against Israel is unknown, or if it is known to originate with al-Qaeda or Iran, Israel should make it clear that its response will be unlimited and include not just major population centers, but all sites of value, including those of major symbolic importance for the Muslim world. A declaratory policy such as this might be highly inflammatory and further exacerbate the religious dimension of the US and Israeli confrontations with the Muslim world. This policy should therefore not be announced officially, as part of Israel’s declared retaliatory posture, but should be made “known,” much as the international community “knows” that Israel has nuclear weapons, whether they do or do not in fact exist. The policy can be “leaked” in a variety of manners.It feels here as if Freilich is channeling Curtis LeMay and Dr. Strangelove. The real danger here is that if Israel were to adopt even 1/10 of the analyst’s recommendations it would take the Middle East that much closer to nuclear conflagration.
Note well too that Freilich is not talking about retaliation AFTER an attack against Israel, he’s talking about a pre-emptive attack BEFORE a Muslim nation even gets a nuclear capability. He’s also talking about Israeli willingness to use every weapon in its arsenal, including nuclear weapons one must presume. And he’s talking about Israel bombing not just major populations centers like Teheran, but religious shrines. He acknowledges faintly that this might “exacerbate the religious dimension” without coming face to face with the fact that he’s advocated provoking a religious holy war against Islam.
Talk about thinking the unthinkable. There are reasons why some thoughts and ideas are taboo. There are reasons why humanity clings desperately to a few basic values and rules of civilization. It’s so that lunacy like this does not take hold and drive us like lemmings over the cliff and to oblivion. If Prof. Freilich wants to jump by all means let him. But don’t take the rest of us with you on the way down, thank you.
Let’s also remember that Al Qaeda has shown no ability to carry out a nuclear attack on anyone. Hezbollah hasn’t even said it would be interested in such a heinous act. So to anticipate the likelihood of this happening is again to create a problem where none exists. And this is the modus operandi for the Israeli nationalist right and U.S. neocons. It was what got us into the Iraq war via Saddam’s supposed WMD. It’s what could lure Israel into its next military misadventure.
When I first read about this report I was hoping that it was authored by a typical right-wing nut job whose ranting could be safely ignored. But Freilich’s report was prepared for the widely respected Begin-Sadat Center. He’s been a fellow at Belfer Center of the JFK School of Government at Harvard. He’s served in senior positions in the Israeli defense ministry, the UN mission, and been deputy national security advisor. He writes regularly for the centrist Bitterlemons website. He seems to have gravitas. And that’s what scares me.
If this is what serious Israeli analysts are thinking Israel’s in a whole heap of trouble. And not just Israel. The fallout of such Israeli bellicosity will surely suck the U.S. into the maelstrƶm. Do we want that?
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Wednesday, May 26, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
My Quarrel With Sam Norich
By Richard Silvestein
Sam Norich, the publisher of the Jewish Forward, disappointed me. After e mailing him twice and leaving an office voice mail message asking him to answer questions I had about Ari Morgenstern’s threats against the Forward and Zeek and related matters, all he could muster was the feeble virtual non sequitur below published as a comment at my blog.
A little background for those new to the story. The Forward’s right-wing op-ed editor Daniel Treiman published a mendacious op ed by John Hagee which I critiqued (with the assistance of Rachel Tabachnick) here on Sunday. In the course of that post, I was critical of Treiman’s editorial judgement and some other related matters. But the vast majority of my post was a point by point rebuttal of Hagee’s miasma of lies and deceit.
Note that there is not a single word defending what Hagee peddled to Forward readers. Not a single substantive rejoinder to my post. Here is Norich’s response:
We Jews would never accept such a figure (though we did in earlier times in the form of Shabbtai Tzvi and Jacob Frank and look how well that ended). It pains me to think that The Forward has aided and abetted Christian fundamentalism’s answer to Shabbtai Tzvi.
Norich calls my treatment of The Forward “smashmouth” which is patently untrue. The vast majority of the post dealt with the content of Hagee’s op ed which I treated with the derision it deserved. In one paragraph, I criticized the editorial judgement of Dan Treiman and called him right wing (which he is). That is the sole basis of Norich’s claim that I smashmouthed The Forward. Gee, it makes you wonder how they would react if someone really took ‘em to the woodshed.
A few comments on Norich’s statement. Normally, it’s a good thing for a publisher to stand by an editor. As long as the editor has performed his job properly. But when an editor has not done so, for a publisher to defend him may appear honorable and proper, but it does a disservice to the newspaper they both serve. I can only hope that Sam Norich has the qualities of a politician who is able to speak to a public audience differently than an internal one. I can only hope that Norich understands how deficient and damaging the Forward piece was and will deal with it in ways he would prefer not to reveal publicly.
Norich’s claim that the Forward and Zeek are independent entities and that he does not get involved in the latter’s business is not entirely true. In fact, Ari Morgenstern, when he wished to complain about Rachel Tabachnick’s in Zeek which criticized Hagee did so to Sam Norich. There is a danger in making claims that shade the truth as Norich has done. In fact, Ari Morgenstern threatened Zeek with a lawsuit via Norich. What I wanted to ask Norich, and which he refused, was what was said in that conversation. Perhaps the reason he won’t talk to me directly is that the contents of that conversation might not be flattering.
I do know that the conversation Norich had with Morgenstern concerned Kaiser enough that she said she fully expected a lawsuit. I also know that she found herself a pro bono attorney to represent the publication in the event of such a lawsuit, which she fully anticipated. And Norich would’ve been derelict in his duties had he not consulted The Forward’s own attorney to determine whether the Forward had any liability in this matter. Undoubtedly, the attorney would’ve responded, No. But The Forward, in the person of Norich, was very much involved in this matter.
Might John Hagee’s piece have become part of this entire conversation between Hagee’s side and The Forward? This again is a question Norich could’ve answered if he’d had the guts to talk to me.
And here’s another derelection of editorial duty on the part of Treiman in vetting this piece before publication. I know Hagee’s rhetorical style. I’ve also consulted others who’ve followed Hagee’s career, preaching and writing for years. We both agree that the Forward piece contained nothing of Hagee’s normally flamboyant, dramatic style. It contained nothing of the vividness or imagery of his standard theological rhetoric. So in fact, I suspect (without having a smoking gun to prove it) that Hagee did not write this piece. I strongly suspect that he trusted his Jewish advisors to do so for him and it was submitted in his name. But Dan Treiman doesn’t know enough about Hagee’s MO nor his writing style to have sussed this out. So here’s a question for you, Sam. Did you or Dan at any time ask whoever submitted this piece whether Hagee wrote it himself? And who sent you the piece? Was it Morgenstern or did it come from Hagee? Did you ever see any notations, edits or even a signature from Hagee on the piece he allegedly submitted?
I know that normally a newspaper can accept on faith that a writer who submits a piece has written it himself. But this case is different. Here we’re dealing with an author who has lied about his views in the piece he is attempting to publish. An author attempting through artifice and deceit to inveigle himself into the good graces of The Forward’s largely suspicious readership. Did Dan Treiman know this? If not, why not? And how does Sam Norich with a straight face defend The Forward’s accepting a piece for publication such as this? And has he gone back to Morgenstern and Hagee to demand an explanation of the multiple deviations from his previous theological record that are evident in what he wrote for the Forward?
Finally, Norich’s claim that I made an error in saying that Tabachnick’s comments in the Hagee article thread were deleted is only partially true. As a webmaster, I have never faced the type of technical glitch he describes in which the Hagee article was “disappeared” from the Forward site and the comments lost. But I do know that any decent webmaster retains copies of his website for just such an eventuality. It is not very hard to go back to the last iteration of the site and find the lost post and restore it with its comments. And if somehow the comments became separated from the article itself there is a site online which retains all the comments for this article and if Norich really wishes to restore them I can get him the URL. Finally, why does the current iteration of the Hagee article online not offer any opportunity to post comments? In essence, they’ve closed comments for the article.
I’m sorry to be so harsh, but I think Hagee has performed a type of malpractice on The Forward and the publication has been taken. And I say this as someone who has admired The Forward over the years and written very strong positive statements about it in this blog. I do not say this as an enemy. I say this as someone who is deeply disappointed when a friend has let them down very badly.
One final note: John Hagee and Avi Morgenstern are very litigious fellows. So I make crystal clear that everything stated above about John Hagee’s authorship of this article is my considered opinion and not a statement of fact.
The title of this post is a reference to the seminal Chaim Grade story, My Quarrel With Hersh Rasseyner, about a quarrel between two Jews, one who has lost his faith and another who has retained his, despite being a Holocaust survivor.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003. The opinions of this article are the author's own.
Sam Norich, the publisher of the Jewish Forward, disappointed me. After e mailing him twice and leaving an office voice mail message asking him to answer questions I had about Ari Morgenstern’s threats against the Forward and Zeek and related matters, all he could muster was the feeble virtual non sequitur below published as a comment at my blog.
A little background for those new to the story. The Forward’s right-wing op-ed editor Daniel Treiman published a mendacious op ed by John Hagee which I critiqued (with the assistance of Rachel Tabachnick) here on Sunday. In the course of that post, I was critical of Treiman’s editorial judgement and some other related matters. But the vast majority of my post was a point by point rebuttal of Hagee’s miasma of lies and deceit.
Note that there is not a single word defending what Hagee peddled to Forward readers. Not a single substantive rejoinder to my post. Here is Norich’s response:
To Richard Silverstein,
I received your email early Saturday morning asking to speak with me, and intended to contact you on Sunday, until I read your post of Saturday night titled “Jewish Forward helps Hagee wash away his sins.” Having read your smashmouth treatment of the Forward I saw no point in responding to your request, not even after your second email, on Sunday evening, asking for “an opportunity to hear your side of the matter before I publish.” A peculiar sequence.
But your readers deserve better. I would guess that many of them would welcome a clear expression of John Hagee’s views on issues of concern to Jews in particular, though not only to us. It’s precisely because the op-ed in question is so markedly different in tone and emphasis compared to some of Pastor Hagee’s previous statements that it bears serious consideration by the audience it was addressed to. To be sure, the piece should raise questions in the minds of knowledgeable readers, about the evolution of the author’s own thinking about these issues, about the differences between his views and those of some other spokesmen for Christian Zionists and evangelicals, and indeed about how those views will inform the positions that Pastor Hagee and Christians United for Israel will be taking in the months ahead. I’m proud of our editors’ decision to run the op-ed and eager to see where it takes us. Your readers and ours can be sure that the Forward will continue to report on this subject, and that we’ll continue to do so independent of the forces and agendas arrayed on these issues inside and outside the Jewish community.
I cannot speak for Zeek. We have a co-marketing agreement with Zeek and as part of that arrangement we host that publication on our web site, TheJewishDailyForward.com. That brings the editorial offerings of each publication to the attention of the other’s online readership, but they have no say about our editorial judgments and we have no say about theirs.
Finally, I want to correct just one error of fact in your post, for the record. Neither Daniel Treiman nor anyone else at the Forward removed the comments that had been posted to the Hagee op-ed. We’re still trying to understand how that happened, and how a second, identical version of the op-ed was posted for several days, before we removed it. Our tech team have reason to doubt that it was the result of foul play; they are looking into whether an improper character in one of the tags or in the text of a comment could have taken down the connection between this piece and our commenting system. We’re working to restore that connection.Apparently, the publisher and managing editor (after writing this critical post I was blacklisted by her) of The Forward are so thin-skinned that they cannot accept serious criticism of their editorial judgment. Norich’s response is sophistry. Instead of dealing with the fact that Hagee lied through his teeth and sold The Forward readers a bill of goods, Norich says that the piece reveals the “evolution of Hagee’s thinking.” I’ve got news for Norich. Megalomaniacs’ thinking doesn’t “evolve” except in ways that allow them to aggrandize themselves further. And I call Hagee a megalomaniac because he sees himself as God’s agent in the world whose job is to midwife the End Times.
Samuel Norich, Publisher, The Forward
We Jews would never accept such a figure (though we did in earlier times in the form of Shabbtai Tzvi and Jacob Frank and look how well that ended). It pains me to think that The Forward has aided and abetted Christian fundamentalism’s answer to Shabbtai Tzvi.
Norich calls my treatment of The Forward “smashmouth” which is patently untrue. The vast majority of the post dealt with the content of Hagee’s op ed which I treated with the derision it deserved. In one paragraph, I criticized the editorial judgement of Dan Treiman and called him right wing (which he is). That is the sole basis of Norich’s claim that I smashmouthed The Forward. Gee, it makes you wonder how they would react if someone really took ‘em to the woodshed.
A few comments on Norich’s statement. Normally, it’s a good thing for a publisher to stand by an editor. As long as the editor has performed his job properly. But when an editor has not done so, for a publisher to defend him may appear honorable and proper, but it does a disservice to the newspaper they both serve. I can only hope that Sam Norich has the qualities of a politician who is able to speak to a public audience differently than an internal one. I can only hope that Norich understands how deficient and damaging the Forward piece was and will deal with it in ways he would prefer not to reveal publicly.
Norich’s claim that the Forward and Zeek are independent entities and that he does not get involved in the latter’s business is not entirely true. In fact, Ari Morgenstern, when he wished to complain about Rachel Tabachnick’s in Zeek which criticized Hagee did so to Sam Norich. There is a danger in making claims that shade the truth as Norich has done. In fact, Ari Morgenstern threatened Zeek with a lawsuit via Norich. What I wanted to ask Norich, and which he refused, was what was said in that conversation. Perhaps the reason he won’t talk to me directly is that the contents of that conversation might not be flattering.
I do know that the conversation Norich had with Morgenstern concerned Kaiser enough that she said she fully expected a lawsuit. I also know that she found herself a pro bono attorney to represent the publication in the event of such a lawsuit, which she fully anticipated. And Norich would’ve been derelict in his duties had he not consulted The Forward’s own attorney to determine whether the Forward had any liability in this matter. Undoubtedly, the attorney would’ve responded, No. But The Forward, in the person of Norich, was very much involved in this matter.
Might John Hagee’s piece have become part of this entire conversation between Hagee’s side and The Forward? This again is a question Norich could’ve answered if he’d had the guts to talk to me.
And here’s another derelection of editorial duty on the part of Treiman in vetting this piece before publication. I know Hagee’s rhetorical style. I’ve also consulted others who’ve followed Hagee’s career, preaching and writing for years. We both agree that the Forward piece contained nothing of Hagee’s normally flamboyant, dramatic style. It contained nothing of the vividness or imagery of his standard theological rhetoric. So in fact, I suspect (without having a smoking gun to prove it) that Hagee did not write this piece. I strongly suspect that he trusted his Jewish advisors to do so for him and it was submitted in his name. But Dan Treiman doesn’t know enough about Hagee’s MO nor his writing style to have sussed this out. So here’s a question for you, Sam. Did you or Dan at any time ask whoever submitted this piece whether Hagee wrote it himself? And who sent you the piece? Was it Morgenstern or did it come from Hagee? Did you ever see any notations, edits or even a signature from Hagee on the piece he allegedly submitted?
I know that normally a newspaper can accept on faith that a writer who submits a piece has written it himself. But this case is different. Here we’re dealing with an author who has lied about his views in the piece he is attempting to publish. An author attempting through artifice and deceit to inveigle himself into the good graces of The Forward’s largely suspicious readership. Did Dan Treiman know this? If not, why not? And how does Sam Norich with a straight face defend The Forward’s accepting a piece for publication such as this? And has he gone back to Morgenstern and Hagee to demand an explanation of the multiple deviations from his previous theological record that are evident in what he wrote for the Forward?
Finally, Norich’s claim that I made an error in saying that Tabachnick’s comments in the Hagee article thread were deleted is only partially true. As a webmaster, I have never faced the type of technical glitch he describes in which the Hagee article was “disappeared” from the Forward site and the comments lost. But I do know that any decent webmaster retains copies of his website for just such an eventuality. It is not very hard to go back to the last iteration of the site and find the lost post and restore it with its comments. And if somehow the comments became separated from the article itself there is a site online which retains all the comments for this article and if Norich really wishes to restore them I can get him the URL. Finally, why does the current iteration of the Hagee article online not offer any opportunity to post comments? In essence, they’ve closed comments for the article.
I’m sorry to be so harsh, but I think Hagee has performed a type of malpractice on The Forward and the publication has been taken. And I say this as someone who has admired The Forward over the years and written very strong positive statements about it in this blog. I do not say this as an enemy. I say this as someone who is deeply disappointed when a friend has let them down very badly.
One final note: John Hagee and Avi Morgenstern are very litigious fellows. So I make crystal clear that everything stated above about John Hagee’s authorship of this article is my considered opinion and not a statement of fact.
The title of this post is a reference to the seminal Chaim Grade story, My Quarrel With Hersh Rasseyner, about a quarrel between two Jews, one who has lost his faith and another who has retained his, despite being a Holocaust survivor.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003. The opinions of this article are the author's own.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Zeek Suspends Hagee Coverage Under Political, Legal Assault
By Richard Silverstein
Rachel Tabachnick, until last month, reported on Christian Zionism twice a month as a contributor to Zeek, the Forward’s companion site. This week, she brought me the troubling news that Zeek’s editor, Jo Ellen Kaiser had forbidden her from writing on this subject or on John Hagee. This happened in the aftermath of legal threats made by Ari Morgenstern, Hagee’s chief Jewish PR flack to Sam Norich, the Forward’s publisher.
I discovered that other writers have received either resigned or faced similar cease and desist orders from Kaiser. Joel Schalit, Zeek’s online editor, who engaged many of these writers originally to write for the publication, announced his resignation due to editorial and philosophical disagreements with its direction. Originally, he was supposed to have left in July (and part, though not all of his reason for leaving involved editorial disagreement). But due to the fracas involving Tabachnick, he resigned on May 22nd.
Originally, Schalit and Kaiser came to Zeek from Tikkun Magazine. They left their jobs as editors there after a similar argument with Michael Lerner. He didn’t want Tikkun to turn into a publication that over-emphasized coverage of the Israel. He wanted to publish on subjects less confrontational, less divisive. He wanted more Diaspora, less Israel. Kaiser and Schalit left over precisely this argument. Yet here Kaiser makes almost the same choice herself, instead of Lerner. She mistakenly sees Christian Zionism and Hagee as essentially an Israel related story and not a Diaspora story. That’s what to her makes it tangential, rather than essential.
I disagree. John Hagee is one of the big stories not just for Jews concerned about Israel, but for all Jews. His manipulations and fraudulent representations of Christian Zionist theology, his support for a radical right wing agenda not just in Israel but in the U.S. should make every Jew sit up and take notice.
Returning to Tabachnick’s work, Zeek double and triple-checked the material Tabachnick had written over the past year and couldn’t find a single error. Despite this, Kaiser determined that discretion was the better part of valor and decided that protecting Zeek from legal jeopardy was more important than standing by her writer.
The Forward’s publisher, Sam Norich, fielded complaints he received about Tabachnick’s writing from Ari Morgenstern. I do not know what role, if any, Norich played in decisions made about Tabachnick. I should add that I made repeated attempts to interview both Norich and Kaiser for this story. I even e-mailed Kaiser a series of questions which she said she would answer. Later, she said she was having second thoughts. I sent e-mails and left a voice mail message for Norich and his sole response was to publish a comment, about which I wrote this post.
I do not know whether Kaiser put Tabachnick on hiatus solely to protect Zeek from the threat of a lawsuit from Hagee’s goons; or she was concerned about jeopardizing Zeek’s relationship with The Forward as well (Zeek shares The Forward’s web server); or this was part of her editorial pruning of Israel-related material and authors from the publication. Most importantly, I do not know whether threat of lawsuits had anything to do with The Forward’s agreeing to publish Hagee’s piece. At the very least, even if the timing of these matters is purely coincidence it does not look good.
While Alan Dershowitz boasts that he invented the term lawfare to describe the use of legal fora by Israel’s enemies to battle against it (this Wikipedia article disputes his claim and notes it originated seven years before he says he coined it), he makes no mention of a similar strategy among the pro-Israel right. Besides the Hagee-Morgenstern threats, the Israeli rightist Im Tirtzu, recipient of $200,000 in CUFI funding, regularly threatens legal action against those who criticize it. In fact, when Didi Remez created the mock Facebook group, Im Tirztu–Fascist Movement (what else is new?), Ronen Shoval immediately threatened Didi, who responded with a three page letter from his attorney, Michael Sfard, explaining why Shoval had not a snowball’s chance in hell of an apology. That’s the posture Jo Ellen Kaiser should adopt: “Serve a paper and sue me, sue me, what can you do me?”
Further troubling, is that Rachel Tabachnick and her partner in Talk2Action, Bruce Wilson, published several comments in the Hagee online thread which consisted of quotations from the pastor which rebutted the claims in his article. Those comments disappeared from the site (those quotations can now be read here along with amplified archival material attesting to Hagee’s views) . Now, when you visit the Hagee article you cannot publish any comments. This makes it appear to be an editorial retreat not just by Zeek, but by the Forward itself.
So why would Ari Morgenstern and John Hagee be burned up by Rachel Tabachnick’s attacks in the pages of Zeek? Clearly, even if there was no specific quid pro quo between Hagee and the Forward that resulted in his work being printed there, Hagee’s in the middle of a charm offensive in the Jewish community. He’s seeking to purify his soul of past sins against Jews unfortunately by lying his way out of them.
Many Jewish journalists (Sarah Posner, Max Blumenthal, etc.) are writing about Hagee and attacking his views, but few, if any are published in Jewish publications. Zeek is the exception. Until now, with the megaphone offered by The Forward’s website, Zeek offered some of the most damaging material exposing the seamy underbelly of Hagee’s anti-Jewish theology. This proved especially nettlesome to Hagee and his court Jews, Morgenstern and CUFI director David Brog. That’s why they undertook to silence her.
I note too that both Andrew Sullivan and the Washington Post Faith blog published letters from Morgenstern rebutting attacks on Hagee. I wonder if Morgenstern took them to the woodshed as he did Sam Norich? What, if anything, were the nature of those conversations? Did they too involve legal threats? I do know for a fact that Hagee’s lawyers wrote threatening letters to Rabbi Haim Dov Beliak’s Jews on First, a group that combats Christian fundamentalism.
Unfortunately, Zeek’s editor Kaiser determined that fighting a war against CUFI would deter Zeek from issues more central to its mission. She determined that exposing Christian Zionism was tangential and not worth the fight. To this I say, if you want to have a relevant progressive Jewish publication how can you NOT take up this cause? If you want to brand yourself as a crusading enterprise with a distinct message, what better way to do this than by saying to Ari Morgenstern in the words of his beloved president: “bring it on?”
Personally, I think that Zeek has missed a sterling opportunity. It would’ve found allies in this fight it didn’t know it had. It would’ve gain readers, gained traction, gained credibility. Not that it doesn’t have those things now. But it would’ve had them in spades if it had addressed these issues differently. Now, all it has is a reputation for flinching in the face of the assault by right-wing Christian Zionist bullies and their Jewish enablers.
Apparently, Hagee isn’t the only force in the right-wing community from whom Zeek is flinching. After being told to stop writing about Christian Zionism, Tabachnick wrote a story criticizing Phyllis Chesler for the role she played in supporting an effort by evangelicals to kidnap a Muslim child who came under sway of Christian missionaries. After reading the story, Kaiser was none too happy with her author and approached Chesler for a rebuttal. The rebuttal strangely did not rebut any factual statement in the original story. It did not find any errors, in fact it wasn’t substantive at all.
As a result of Kaiser’s flight toward the bunker (Phil Weiss’ description of The Forward’s behavior) Chesler’s allies in the far right Jewish world smelled blood in the water. Hit pieces on Tabachnick were published by Frontpagemagazine and American Spectator. Which goes to show that when you retreat in the face of such an onslaught it only emboldens the political bullies.
Another word on Hagee’s alternate charm-threat offensive in the Jewish community. Besides legal threats, he uses honey (or cash as the case may be) with those in the community prone to accept such blandishments. I’ve already covered the $500,000 gift from Hagee to Elie Wiesel’s foundation (the latter wiped out by an overly trusting reliance on Bernie Madoff’s financial acumen), which likely played some role in Wiesel accepting an invitation to keynote CUFI’s national convention this year.
The organization hosts Nights to Honor Israel along with co-sponsoring local Jewish federations, which receive individual gifts generally in the $100,000 range for their troubles. In an age when Jewish philanthropy toward Israel is receding, federation campaigns are looking everywhere they can for replacement funding. CUFI presents an exceptionally attractive alternative. But it should be noted that these gifts do not support local federation philanthropy. Instead, they go into the coffers of the Jewish Agency or individual CUFI donees (often settlement-oriented), which is the midst of a shakeup that involves absorbing evangelical forces into leadership roles (essentially a slow motion takeover). In this project, the evangelicals work hand in glove with handsomely compensated Jewish leaders like Rabbi Yechiel Eckstein. The $58-million CUFI has given to Israel projects (many of them far-right settler oriented as I’ve documented here) over the past few years is another bone thrown to Israel and Diaspora Jewry to lull it into complacency.
But as Rabbi Eric Yoffie wrote so presciently in The Forward last year, American Jews and their federations should not be tricked by such tempting offers. Do not think there is no price to paid, no quid pro quo. Hagee is not doing this out of the goodness of his heart. He’s not even doing out of the goodness of his heart toward Israel, as he claims. He, like every other powerful figure, has his own agenda. That agenda includes conversion of the Jews in order to bring the End Times and Jesus’ return. Missionaries like Hagee are no longer the hit ‘em on the head types who use heavy-handed tactics that are transparent to the naked eye. They’ve become far more sophisticated in their methods. They do outreach. They seek allies. They work their way into communities and even nations, like Israel. They do good. They keep the more objectionable aspects of their agenda under wraps. They wait patiently for their opportunity.
Now, Hagee-allied groups are ensconced in Israel and doing missionary work to Jews and Muslims. They don’t do this under Hagee’s official banner. He’s a bit too sophisticated for that. They work under Maoz Israel Ministries, which Hagee and two of his fellow CUFI ministers have publicly endorsed.
That’s why I simply don’t understand why Zeek has allowed itself to be cowed by Hagee. Nor do I understand why The Forward has given its heksher in the form of coveted space on its op-ed page to Hagee’s smooth talk about Jews. This is definitely not their finest hour.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Rachel Tabachnick, until last month, reported on Christian Zionism twice a month as a contributor to Zeek, the Forward’s companion site. This week, she brought me the troubling news that Zeek’s editor, Jo Ellen Kaiser had forbidden her from writing on this subject or on John Hagee. This happened in the aftermath of legal threats made by Ari Morgenstern, Hagee’s chief Jewish PR flack to Sam Norich, the Forward’s publisher.
I discovered that other writers have received either resigned or faced similar cease and desist orders from Kaiser. Joel Schalit, Zeek’s online editor, who engaged many of these writers originally to write for the publication, announced his resignation due to editorial and philosophical disagreements with its direction. Originally, he was supposed to have left in July (and part, though not all of his reason for leaving involved editorial disagreement). But due to the fracas involving Tabachnick, he resigned on May 22nd.
Originally, Schalit and Kaiser came to Zeek from Tikkun Magazine. They left their jobs as editors there after a similar argument with Michael Lerner. He didn’t want Tikkun to turn into a publication that over-emphasized coverage of the Israel. He wanted to publish on subjects less confrontational, less divisive. He wanted more Diaspora, less Israel. Kaiser and Schalit left over precisely this argument. Yet here Kaiser makes almost the same choice herself, instead of Lerner. She mistakenly sees Christian Zionism and Hagee as essentially an Israel related story and not a Diaspora story. That’s what to her makes it tangential, rather than essential.
I disagree. John Hagee is one of the big stories not just for Jews concerned about Israel, but for all Jews. His manipulations and fraudulent representations of Christian Zionist theology, his support for a radical right wing agenda not just in Israel but in the U.S. should make every Jew sit up and take notice.
Returning to Tabachnick’s work, Zeek double and triple-checked the material Tabachnick had written over the past year and couldn’t find a single error. Despite this, Kaiser determined that discretion was the better part of valor and decided that protecting Zeek from legal jeopardy was more important than standing by her writer.
I do not know whether Kaiser put Tabachnick on hiatus solely to protect Zeek from the threat of a lawsuit from Hagee’s goons; or she was concerned about jeopardizing Zeek’s relationship with The Forward as well (Zeek shares The Forward’s web server); or this was part of her editorial pruning of Israel-related material and authors from the publication. Most importantly, I do not know whether threat of lawsuits had anything to do with The Forward’s agreeing to publish Hagee’s piece. At the very least, even if the timing of these matters is purely coincidence it does not look good.
While Alan Dershowitz boasts that he invented the term lawfare to describe the use of legal fora by Israel’s enemies to battle against it (this Wikipedia article disputes his claim and notes it originated seven years before he says he coined it), he makes no mention of a similar strategy among the pro-Israel right. Besides the Hagee-Morgenstern threats, the Israeli rightist Im Tirtzu, recipient of $200,000 in CUFI funding, regularly threatens legal action against those who criticize it. In fact, when Didi Remez created the mock Facebook group, Im Tirztu–Fascist Movement (what else is new?), Ronen Shoval immediately threatened Didi, who responded with a three page letter from his attorney, Michael Sfard, explaining why Shoval had not a snowball’s chance in hell of an apology. That’s the posture Jo Ellen Kaiser should adopt: “Serve a paper and sue me, sue me, what can you do me?”
Further troubling, is that Rachel Tabachnick and her partner in Talk2Action, Bruce Wilson, published several comments in the Hagee online thread which consisted of quotations from the pastor which rebutted the claims in his article. Those comments disappeared from the site (those quotations can now be read here along with amplified archival material attesting to Hagee’s views) . Now, when you visit the Hagee article you cannot publish any comments. This makes it appear to be an editorial retreat not just by Zeek, but by the Forward itself.
So why would Ari Morgenstern and John Hagee be burned up by Rachel Tabachnick’s attacks in the pages of Zeek? Clearly, even if there was no specific quid pro quo between Hagee and the Forward that resulted in his work being printed there, Hagee’s in the middle of a charm offensive in the Jewish community. He’s seeking to purify his soul of past sins against Jews unfortunately by lying his way out of them.
Many Jewish journalists (Sarah Posner, Max Blumenthal, etc.) are writing about Hagee and attacking his views, but few, if any are published in Jewish publications. Zeek is the exception. Until now, with the megaphone offered by The Forward’s website, Zeek offered some of the most damaging material exposing the seamy underbelly of Hagee’s anti-Jewish theology. This proved especially nettlesome to Hagee and his court Jews, Morgenstern and CUFI director David Brog. That’s why they undertook to silence her.
I note too that both Andrew Sullivan and the Washington Post Faith blog published letters from Morgenstern rebutting attacks on Hagee. I wonder if Morgenstern took them to the woodshed as he did Sam Norich? What, if anything, were the nature of those conversations? Did they too involve legal threats? I do know for a fact that Hagee’s lawyers wrote threatening letters to Rabbi Haim Dov Beliak’s Jews on First, a group that combats Christian fundamentalism.
Unfortunately, Zeek’s editor Kaiser determined that fighting a war against CUFI would deter Zeek from issues more central to its mission. She determined that exposing Christian Zionism was tangential and not worth the fight. To this I say, if you want to have a relevant progressive Jewish publication how can you NOT take up this cause? If you want to brand yourself as a crusading enterprise with a distinct message, what better way to do this than by saying to Ari Morgenstern in the words of his beloved president: “bring it on?”
Personally, I think that Zeek has missed a sterling opportunity. It would’ve found allies in this fight it didn’t know it had. It would’ve gain readers, gained traction, gained credibility. Not that it doesn’t have those things now. But it would’ve had them in spades if it had addressed these issues differently. Now, all it has is a reputation for flinching in the face of the assault by right-wing Christian Zionist bullies and their Jewish enablers.
Apparently, Hagee isn’t the only force in the right-wing community from whom Zeek is flinching. After being told to stop writing about Christian Zionism, Tabachnick wrote a story criticizing Phyllis Chesler for the role she played in supporting an effort by evangelicals to kidnap a Muslim child who came under sway of Christian missionaries. After reading the story, Kaiser was none too happy with her author and approached Chesler for a rebuttal. The rebuttal strangely did not rebut any factual statement in the original story. It did not find any errors, in fact it wasn’t substantive at all.
As a result of Kaiser’s flight toward the bunker (Phil Weiss’ description of The Forward’s behavior) Chesler’s allies in the far right Jewish world smelled blood in the water. Hit pieces on Tabachnick were published by Frontpagemagazine and American Spectator. Which goes to show that when you retreat in the face of such an onslaught it only emboldens the political bullies.
Another word on Hagee’s alternate charm-threat offensive in the Jewish community. Besides legal threats, he uses honey (or cash as the case may be) with those in the community prone to accept such blandishments. I’ve already covered the $500,000 gift from Hagee to Elie Wiesel’s foundation (the latter wiped out by an overly trusting reliance on Bernie Madoff’s financial acumen), which likely played some role in Wiesel accepting an invitation to keynote CUFI’s national convention this year.
The organization hosts Nights to Honor Israel along with co-sponsoring local Jewish federations, which receive individual gifts generally in the $100,000 range for their troubles. In an age when Jewish philanthropy toward Israel is receding, federation campaigns are looking everywhere they can for replacement funding. CUFI presents an exceptionally attractive alternative. But it should be noted that these gifts do not support local federation philanthropy. Instead, they go into the coffers of the Jewish Agency or individual CUFI donees (often settlement-oriented), which is the midst of a shakeup that involves absorbing evangelical forces into leadership roles (essentially a slow motion takeover). In this project, the evangelicals work hand in glove with handsomely compensated Jewish leaders like Rabbi Yechiel Eckstein. The $58-million CUFI has given to Israel projects (many of them far-right settler oriented as I’ve documented here) over the past few years is another bone thrown to Israel and Diaspora Jewry to lull it into complacency.
But as Rabbi Eric Yoffie wrote so presciently in The Forward last year, American Jews and their federations should not be tricked by such tempting offers. Do not think there is no price to paid, no quid pro quo. Hagee is not doing this out of the goodness of his heart. He’s not even doing out of the goodness of his heart toward Israel, as he claims. He, like every other powerful figure, has his own agenda. That agenda includes conversion of the Jews in order to bring the End Times and Jesus’ return. Missionaries like Hagee are no longer the hit ‘em on the head types who use heavy-handed tactics that are transparent to the naked eye. They’ve become far more sophisticated in their methods. They do outreach. They seek allies. They work their way into communities and even nations, like Israel. They do good. They keep the more objectionable aspects of their agenda under wraps. They wait patiently for their opportunity.
Now, Hagee-allied groups are ensconced in Israel and doing missionary work to Jews and Muslims. They don’t do this under Hagee’s official banner. He’s a bit too sophisticated for that. They work under Maoz Israel Ministries, which Hagee and two of his fellow CUFI ministers have publicly endorsed.
That’s why I simply don’t understand why Zeek has allowed itself to be cowed by Hagee. Nor do I understand why The Forward has given its heksher in the form of coveted space on its op-ed page to Hagee’s smooth talk about Jews. This is definitely not their finest hour.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Australia Expels Israeli Diplomat Over Forged Passports In Dubai Assassination
By Richard Silverstein
Australia today informed Israel that it was expelling a diplomat as a penalty for Israel’s role in forging Australian passports used in the Dubai assassination of Mahmoud al-Mabouh. Though the government would not say who was expelled, Britain expelled Israel’s local Mossad station chief and one would assume Australia did the same.
The fact that Australia took months after the infraction to act indicates it wanted to do little more than slap Israel on the wrist. The statement by the foreign minister confirms this:
Israel is like a substance abuser who requires intervention to prevent self-destructive behavior. The nations of the world have basically washed their hands of Israel in this matter. The only silver lining is that Australia promised that if such acts happen again it will take stronger action:
And Israel of course has learned no lesson from all of this:
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Australia today informed Israel that it was expelling a diplomat as a penalty for Israel’s role in forging Australian passports used in the Dubai assassination of Mahmoud al-Mabouh. Though the government would not say who was expelled, Britain expelled Israel’s local Mossad station chief and one would assume Australia did the same.
The fact that Australia took months after the infraction to act indicates it wanted to do little more than slap Israel on the wrist. The statement by the foreign minister confirms this:
“The Government takes this step much more in sorrow than anger or retaliation,” Mr Smith said.The problem with Australia’s wrist slap is that all of those nations whose passports were forged or whose sovereignty was violated have essentially given Israel a green light to do something like this again in future. U.S. credit cards were abused by the Israelis and two of the assassins traveled to this country after the murder, yet not a peep has come out of the Obama administration. Contrast this with the whirlwind of U.S. intelligence activity and press briefings that accompany word of Islamic terrorism on these shores. Why do we give Mossad a pass?
Israel is like a substance abuser who requires intervention to prevent self-destructive behavior. The nations of the world have basically washed their hands of Israel in this matter. The only silver lining is that Australia promised that if such acts happen again it will take stronger action:
He also said Israel should realise it is on notice that if it again fabricates Australian passports similar or stronger action would be taken.But one has to wonder what the value of these nice sounding words is. When push comes to shove will Australia do anything different next time?
And Israel of course has learned no lesson from all of this:
When asked if Israel had acknowledged its part in the affair or had apologised, Mr Smith replied: “In terms of the substance of these matters Israel has not been drawn in those conversations or drawn on those matters.”
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Monday, May 24, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Jewish Forward Helps Hagee Wash Away His Sins
By Richard Silverstein
Many Jews know John Hagee, founder of Christians United for Israel and leading Christian Zionist zealot, as an anti-Semite who believes Hitler was sent by God to help create the State of Israel. They may also know he supports an Israeli attack on Iran and that he likens Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to Hitler. They may also know that he is a pro-settler, not-one-incher, who believes every bit of Biblical Israel was given to the Jewish people by God. Hagee condemns any peace settlement or Israeli leader who considers withdrawing from a single settlement and labels withdrawal or territorial compromise a betrayal of God’s covenant with Israel.
Perhaps he is most notoriously known for embracing an End Times narrative that calls for two-thirds of the Jewish people to be killed and the remaining one-third to come to Jesus to be reborn in the blood of the Christian lamb. Less well-known is his classical anti-Semitic view that the world economic order is controlled by a group like the Illuminati, one of whose primary members are the Rothschild family:
So imagine my surprise when I read John Hagee’s name plastered on The Forward’s website this week. Astonishingly, the liberal Jewish publication had given the uber-Zionist. anti-Semite a platform for his noxious views. The piece the Forward published is extraordinary in so many ways. I have read many speeches and sermons by John Hagee. While they are always deeply disturbing, the Forward op ed is startingly different because it advances a revisionist version of Hagee as philo-Semite, two-stater, land-for peacer that is entirely at variance with his preceding career. It’s as if a plastic surgeon took a flabby, balding, flat-footed, nondescript man and turned him into George Clooney (or to be more political accurate, Charlton Heston–when he was alive at least).
In fact, the Forward column is so poles apart from the Hagee that anyone who’s read him knows that I half-believe it wasn’t written by him; but rather by a Jewish ghost-writer (possibly like his PR flack Ari Morgenstern or political lobbyist, David Brog).
In short, the Forward piece is a tissue of lies easily disproved by the most basic Google searches of his previous writings. The main howlers are his claim that he is willing to accept a two-state solution (although he doesn’t endorse this path himself even in this column) if Israel itself does:
In the following passage from Hagee’s Forward article, he addresses the End Times scenario of which so many Jews are leery:
In fact, this view of Hagee and CUFI flies in the face of everything we know about them. The truth is they are an activist group and the purpose of their activism is to hasten the Second Coming.
Hagee in The Forward is only too happy to play the religious hate card by making Israel’s and America’s chief enemy, Islam:
Finally, the idea that American and Israeli soldiers defend the same values is ludicrous, unless you want to argue somehow that U.S. occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan are parallel to Israel’s Occupation of Palestinian lands. This, of course is Al Qaeda’s argument and it wouldn’t surprise me at all to find the latter in agreement with John Hagee, as they are both religious extremists.
Finally, I take strong exception to The Forward’s decision to publish this execrable nonsense. The paper’s op-ed editor, the right-leaning Daniel Treiman commissioned this piece and he should have his license to practice journalism suspended. Did he do any fact-checking before publishing this? Or did he feel his author was of such impeccable reputation that such rudimentary editorial review was unnecessary?
Furthermore, the Forward deleted comments posted by Rachel Tabachnick and Bruce Wilson of Talk2Action, Jewish opponents of Hagee, in the thread for this article. Their contributions offered Hagee quotations like the ones above to rebut the claims he made. I’m assuming that Treiman as op-ed editor made the decision to excise these perfectly reasonable comments. Did he or did someone higher in the food chain?
If so, why?
Until recently, Rachel Tabachnick contributed articles twice a month to Zeek, a progressive Jewish publication which shares a website with The Forward, about Hagee and Christian Zionism. Her work on this subject has been suspended by Zeek’s editor, Jo Ellen Kaiser. No one can now write for Zeek about either matter.
This is the first in a series of posts I’ll be writing about Hagee’s relationship with The Forward and Zeek, threats levelled against them by Hagee, and questions raised about the suspension of Tabachnick’s work. Stay tuned…
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Many Jews know John Hagee, founder of Christians United for Israel and leading Christian Zionist zealot, as an anti-Semite who believes Hitler was sent by God to help create the State of Israel. They may also know he supports an Israeli attack on Iran and that he likens Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to Hitler. They may also know that he is a pro-settler, not-one-incher, who believes every bit of Biblical Israel was given to the Jewish people by God. Hagee condemns any peace settlement or Israeli leader who considers withdrawing from a single settlement and labels withdrawal or territorial compromise a betrayal of God’s covenant with Israel.
Perhaps he is most notoriously known for embracing an End Times narrative that calls for two-thirds of the Jewish people to be killed and the remaining one-third to come to Jesus to be reborn in the blood of the Christian lamb. Less well-known is his classical anti-Semitic view that the world economic order is controlled by a group like the Illuminati, one of whose primary members are the Rothschild family:
Our economic destiny is controlled by the Federal Reserve system that is now headed by Alan Greenspan. Think about this. It is not a government institution. It is controlled by a group of Class A stockholders including the Rothschilds of Europe…So get this one thought : The value of your dollar is controlled by an organization that is not controlled by America.Jewish leaders like Rabbi Eric Yoffie have railed against Hagee in the pages of the Jewish Forward, urging their members not to collaborate with or participate in events sponsored by CUFI.
So imagine my surprise when I read John Hagee’s name plastered on The Forward’s website this week. Astonishingly, the liberal Jewish publication had given the uber-Zionist. anti-Semite a platform for his noxious views. The piece the Forward published is extraordinary in so many ways. I have read many speeches and sermons by John Hagee. While they are always deeply disturbing, the Forward op ed is startingly different because it advances a revisionist version of Hagee as philo-Semite, two-stater, land-for peacer that is entirely at variance with his preceding career. It’s as if a plastic surgeon took a flabby, balding, flat-footed, nondescript man and turned him into George Clooney (or to be more political accurate, Charlton Heston–when he was alive at least).
In fact, the Forward column is so poles apart from the Hagee that anyone who’s read him knows that I half-believe it wasn’t written by him; but rather by a Jewish ghost-writer (possibly like his PR flack Ari Morgenstern or political lobbyist, David Brog).
In short, the Forward piece is a tissue of lies easily disproved by the most basic Google searches of his previous writings. The main howlers are his claim that he is willing to accept a two-state solution (although he doesn’t endorse this path himself even in this column) if Israel itself does:
Another concern that some individuals have expressed is that Christian Zionists will use our influence to stand in the way of efforts to advance a two-state solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict. Such a claim shows a complete disregard for our record.What is Hagee’s record? Just after 30 evangelical leaders wrote a letter to Pres. Bush endorsing a two-state solution, the good Pastor penned his own letter which laid out his negative views of a two-state solution. It read in part:
Mr. President, we write this letter to state we are opposed to America pressuring Israel to give up more land for any reason.
…Simply stated, land for peace is a policy is a failed policy of the past that has produced nothing but more war.So, if you read Hagee’s Forward screed carefully you will see what he is really saying is I detest a two state solution and land for peace. But if Israel embraces it, I won’t stand in the way. But even that is undermined by his seeming endorsement of the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin as detailed by Max Blumenthal in The Nation:
…In his 1996 book The Beginning of the End, Hagee described the murder of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin as fulfillment of prophecy and suggested admiration for Rabin’s assassin, Yigal Amir.
Imagining Amir’s mindset as he prepared himself to kill Rabin, Hagee wrote, “Tonight, if God was good, an opportunity would show itself. No longer would Rabin be able to transfer Israeli lands to Palestinians. The damage he’d done in the West Bank and Gaza was enough. Israel had a divine right to the land, and to give it away was an act of treason against Israel and an abomination against God.”Does this suggest to you someone who’s prepared to accept an Israeli peace plan that betrays such principles?
In the following passage from Hagee’s Forward article, he addresses the End Times scenario of which so many Jews are leery:
Other [Jews suspicious of us] posit that our Zionism is tied to an effort to speed the second coming of Jesus. [This] allegation is flat wrong…
…The fact is that the vast majority of Christian Zionists and Evangelicals do not believe there is anything we can do to hasten the second coming of Jesus. Our theology is clear that we humans are utterly powerless to change God’s timetable. Yes, like many Jews we do believe that the creation of Israel was the fulfillment of biblical prophecy. And like our Jewish friends we also search the Scriptures to understand what may come next in God’s plans for His creation. But since we are powerless to change these plans, our motives for standing with Israel come from elsewhere.In other words, Hagee’s belief in an apocalyptic future in which Jews are fated to die (curiously any discussion of this theological belief of his is missing from the Forward) is nothing personal. Rather it is a divine plan over which Hagee has no control. So if Jews have any problem with it don’t take it up with Hagee, take it up with the Guy Upstairs. Further, he would have us believe that he and his followers are quiescent folks who sit back and wait for the Lord’s will to be done. That they do nothing in order to hasten God’s plan. And whatever they do do, they do for the purest of motives having nothing to do with End Times theology.
In fact, this view of Hagee and CUFI flies in the face of everything we know about them. The truth is they are an activist group and the purpose of their activism is to hasten the Second Coming.
Hagee in The Forward is only too happy to play the religious hate card by making Israel’s and America’s chief enemy, Islam:
Christian Zionists also recognize that Israel is not the cause of militant Islam’s hatred of America, but an ally in the fight against militant Islam. Until 9/11 and the ensuing events, Israel largely confronted this threat alone. And to this day the frontline of this conflict remains Israel’s backyard. But Christian Zionists understand that Israel is merely militant Islam’s first target. While American and Israeli soldiers do not fight on the same battlefield, they defend the same values.In penning this bilge, Hagee is oblivious to the fact that Israel’s chief opponent is not “militant Islam,” but the Palestinian people, who are not motivated primarily by religious hatred, but rather by a political grievance, that is 42 years of Occupation. Even if you argue falsely that Hamas is no different from Al Qaeda and it is motivated by religious hatred of Israel, how do you explain the equally implacable resistance of Fatah and West Bank Palestinians to Occupation? Such nuance is lost on Hagee.
Finally, the idea that American and Israeli soldiers defend the same values is ludicrous, unless you want to argue somehow that U.S. occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan are parallel to Israel’s Occupation of Palestinian lands. This, of course is Al Qaeda’s argument and it wouldn’t surprise me at all to find the latter in agreement with John Hagee, as they are both religious extremists.
Finally, I take strong exception to The Forward’s decision to publish this execrable nonsense. The paper’s op-ed editor, the right-leaning Daniel Treiman commissioned this piece and he should have his license to practice journalism suspended. Did he do any fact-checking before publishing this? Or did he feel his author was of such impeccable reputation that such rudimentary editorial review was unnecessary?
Furthermore, the Forward deleted comments posted by Rachel Tabachnick and Bruce Wilson of Talk2Action, Jewish opponents of Hagee, in the thread for this article. Their contributions offered Hagee quotations like the ones above to rebut the claims he made. I’m assuming that Treiman as op-ed editor made the decision to excise these perfectly reasonable comments. Did he or did someone higher in the food chain?
If so, why?
Until recently, Rachel Tabachnick contributed articles twice a month to Zeek, a progressive Jewish publication which shares a website with The Forward, about Hagee and Christian Zionism. Her work on this subject has been suspended by Zeek’s editor, Jo Ellen Kaiser. No one can now write for Zeek about either matter.
This is the first in a series of posts I’ll be writing about Hagee’s relationship with The Forward and Zeek, threats levelled against them by Hagee, and questions raised about the suspension of Tabachnick’s work. Stay tuned…
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Sunday, May 23, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Makhoul’s Lawyers Accuse Shin Bet Of Possible Torture
By Richard Silverstein
The Israeli court and Shin Bet acquiesced to a demand by Ameer Makhoul’s lawyers to consult with him after they’d been denied access to him for 12 days after his arrest. They’d threatened to refuse to continue cooperating with the legal process in protest. It appears that Israeli authorities only understand such threats and that is all that makes them do anything in conformance with standard due process procedures observed by most democracies.
Makhoul’s lawyers also added that they suspected that his treatment in detention violated the Geneva Convention governing treatment of prisoners. Adalah, who is representing him, published a press release Serious Suspicion of Shabak (GSS) Use of Illegal Methods of Interrogation Against…Ameer Makhoul. The Israeli reports don’t details their reasons for suspecting this. The director of Adalah said they expected to publish an affidavit from their client tomorrow which should shed more light on the subject. In addition, the Shin Bet has refused to divulge Makhoul’s medical records while under detention, which raises further suspicions of what, if anything, they may be hiding.
Hassan Jaja, who is the mystery-man accused falsely of recruiting Makhoul, Omar Said and Jamal Juma’a to spy against Israel on behalf of Hezbollah, has released the transcript of his remarks at the opening of the 2007 conference his NGO sponsored in Amman on traditional Arab medicine. Omar Said also spoke at this conference about his own experience in the field of pharmacology and traditional herbal medicine. It was here, apparently, that the alleged fatal plot was hatched between Said and Jaja to betray the State of Israel. After reading Jaja’s talk (translation Rechavia Berman), you’ll have to explain to me how likely it is that this environmental and peace activist is engaged in anything like what he’s accused of:
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
The Israeli court and Shin Bet acquiesced to a demand by Ameer Makhoul’s lawyers to consult with him after they’d been denied access to him for 12 days after his arrest. They’d threatened to refuse to continue cooperating with the legal process in protest. It appears that Israeli authorities only understand such threats and that is all that makes them do anything in conformance with standard due process procedures observed by most democracies.
Makhoul’s lawyers also added that they suspected that his treatment in detention violated the Geneva Convention governing treatment of prisoners. Adalah, who is representing him, published a press release Serious Suspicion of Shabak (GSS) Use of Illegal Methods of Interrogation Against…Ameer Makhoul. The Israeli reports don’t details their reasons for suspecting this. The director of Adalah said they expected to publish an affidavit from their client tomorrow which should shed more light on the subject. In addition, the Shin Bet has refused to divulge Makhoul’s medical records while under detention, which raises further suspicions of what, if anything, they may be hiding.
Hassan Jaja, who is the mystery-man accused falsely of recruiting Makhoul, Omar Said and Jamal Juma’a to spy against Israel on behalf of Hezbollah, has released the transcript of his remarks at the opening of the 2007 conference his NGO sponsored in Amman on traditional Arab medicine. Omar Said also spoke at this conference about his own experience in the field of pharmacology and traditional herbal medicine. It was here, apparently, that the alleged fatal plot was hatched between Said and Jaja to betray the State of Israel. After reading Jaja’s talk (translation Rechavia Berman), you’ll have to explain to me how likely it is that this environmental and peace activist is engaged in anything like what he’s accused of:
We greet you all in joy and warmth upon your arrival to the abode of Jordan, twin of Palestine.
Welcome to the first regional conference on Arab and Islamic Medicine, taking place under the auspices of the Master of the Land who is ever striving – and with God’s aid, successfully so – at instilling dynamism, momentum and development for the benefit of this good people, the noble nation and future generations.
The holding of this conference withing the domain of the Jordanian Hashemite Kingdom lends it special flavor and deep significance, under a stable, secure and balanced Arab and Islamic canopy.
We hold this conference today under…circumstances which bring to the forefront a poignant, primal and continuing conflict between a vivacious inclination…committed to the good in human nature, respectful of common sense, of mankind’s nature, its innate decency, its freedom and benefit – a direction which views man created in the image of the creator as the main part of creation due to his tendency towards reciprocal relationships, harmony and integration with all other creatures…rather than at their expense – and another inclination predicated on control, racism, seizure, exploitation and maximization of profits by any and all means, an inclination which serves neither man nor nature but fails them both, and heeds not the words of the sublime creator “Walk not complacent upon the earth so that thou shalt not destroy it, and thou shalt not exceed the mountain tops”.
Believe the sublime God who also said, in his dear book, “And we have created thee male and female and made you into nations and tribes so that thou shalt know that God has blessed thee”.
Believe the sublime God when not to Muslims or to Arabs alone He speaks. Therein lies a universal, human, open, healthy and just message.
…We see the Islamic culture as but an inseparable part of global culture, with which it once had expansive relations of mutual and fertile influence.This is our version of globalization which is consistent with the wisdom of the Creator, who laid the foundation for human knowledge and achievement…
This blessed conference we hold here today wishes to modestly direct efforts towards the revival and the imparting of learning of truth and justice, of equality and decency, and the freedom of nations and of man, learning of which the essence is to serve people, through an continuing aspiration to detect the true and practical needs and problems of man, and thus bring about serious, effective, proper and healthy scientific study, in search of proper solutions.
This is what we believe and according to this we act. And some may ask, is their any other approach in this world? Are there those who do not see man – whatever his color, whatever his religion, his language and nationality, his sex and appearance – as God’s creation? As one’s brother of equal value?
…Yes. There are forces, institutions, commercial corporations and groups whose concepts, aims, plans and modes of operation are based on exploitation, aggression and usurpation of the other, of people, of human societies, of countries and cultures, nations and religions.
Organizations which thrive on the creation of problems, which convince people of a myriad of imaginary needs and trumped-up ailments in order to sell their products and reap profits. Forces who bring about the destruction of the environment, the environmental balance and the health of mankind in order to foist their interests and designs upon others.
Our guiding principle and concept regarding professional and human interactions between people and institutions is “do no harm and you will suffer none.”
We at the Arab Group for the Protection of Nature have close ties and full cooperation with our brethren at the Galilee Society and its special center for scientific studies (“al-Maisam”), and with the ground-breaking al-Antaki firm, whose motto “When the Wisdom of the East Meets Modern Knowledge” I took a great liking to, and who I felt immensely proud upon learning that it exports its products to European markets at world-class standards.
…This scientific conference marks an important achievement. We express the humble hope that our efforts here shall lay the foundations…to revive the Arab-Islamic scientific heritage, which is engaged in harmonious dialogue with the cultures of other nations, and we begin this effort with the field of folk medicine.We extend our hand to our co-nationals in Jordan and our brethren in Palestine and throughout the Arab homeland, across the spectrum of occupations and professions, vocational organizations and trade unions and to artisans among the people, to create contacts and fruitful cooperation across borders – despite…hardships and…obstacles.
We may act together with determination, patience and faith that our variety is a building block of our unity and one of the sources of our strength.
May God be with us and grant us pure faith materialized in action beneficial to man, granting him satisfaction, peace of mind, calm and joy.
Peace be upon you, the mercy of God and His blessing.Supporters of Dr. Omar Said have released this statement in support of a petition campaign on his behalf. It is an excellent portrait of the man and his work on behalf of traditional Arab medicine:
Dr. Omar Said, pharmacologist…academic, peace and ecological activist, was arrested and accused of spying for Hizbollah…[He] is an important international intellectual figure, a scientist…and one of the world’s top experts on traditional Arabic medicine, Arabic medical history and medicinal plants. He has written many scientific papers, and the author of a forthcoming academic text which will be the most authoritative text on Arabic medicine in the world. He is the founder and director of the largest botanical garden of medicinal plants in the Middle East, run by an Israeli NGO. It is used both for research, preservation, and also education, ecology and co-existence…He has invited and given classes to many thousands of Arab and Jewish children at the botanical garden, bringing them together to study something of interest to all communities.
He is close to both Jews and Arabs in daily life, in work and in the intellectual community. He has been politically active, and was the deputy mayor of Kfar Kanna, in the Galilee. Much of this work has been to bring healing to his community and to the relationships between Jews and Arabs. All those who have worked with him on a daily basis, including many Jewish colleagues, know him to be a friend, a warm partner, a lover of peace and a great man with a big heart.
Dr. Said is constantly travelling throughout the world, in particular Jordan, where he buys herbs, carries out research, and meets experts from Arab countries. It is shameful that this activity is the reason for the suspicion of the Israeli security apparatus. It is likely that a great mistake and a serious injustice is happening right now.
Omar was arrested…under a very vague law that criminalises contact with anyone that the security authorities define as suspect. We call for the immediate release of Dr. Omar Said, and the end of the use of this law to harass individuals who are no actual risk or threat to security.To sign this statement on behalf of Dr. Said, send an e mail with your name and any other identifying information to amar at al-antaki dot com.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Thursday, May 20, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Israel’s Attack On Goldstone Belies Its Own Support Of Apartheid
By Richard Silverstein
Sasha Polakow-Suransky writes tellingly in Foreign Policy and Huffington Post about the current smear campaign against Judge Goldstone mounted by the Israeli government with the help of willing collaborating journalists like Tehiya Barak, Jeffrey Goldberg and Jonathan Chait. It was Barak who opened the floodgates with his Yediot Achronot hit-piece, undoubtedly inspired by material developed by the Lieberman-Ayalon foreign ministry. Don’t ya just love the incestuous relationship the hacks in government ministries have with the hacks in the newsroom?
Since Barak claims that his story is a “special Yediot investigation,” let’s do the same thing it claimed to do to Goldstone’s record and shine a light on its journalistic claims. Well, it falls short right from the beginning when it claims that Goldstone “asserted that Israel committed war crimes.” He did nothing of the sort. What he DID assert was that his commission had amassed enough evidence that there MAY have been war crimes committed by BOTH sides that the charges should be investigated formally by both sides themselves. Goldstone said many times that he was not a finder of fact as a judge would be in a formal legal proceeding.
The Yediot hit-piece continues with this breathless commentary:
Not to mention that Goldstone only actually sentenced two individuals to death. The other 26 cases were appeals in which he upheld a lower court ruling.
The Goldstone smearmeisters have it all figured out with their 20-20 hindsight view of history. Goldstone’s responsibility was either to overturn capital punishment or resign his judgeship and emigrate from South Africa. Don’t you just love it when 20 years after the fact the smug hypocritical moralists come along and give advice about how others should behave in order to retain their moral purity?
Here Barak accuses Goldstone of committing the heresy of writing in favor of capital punishment, a crime committed–surprise, surprise–by most judges in this country who’ve ever affirmed such a sentence:
And keep in mind that Barak is in high moral dudgeon about South Africa’s policy of capital punishment when his own army regularly executes Palestinian militants without any trial. Is that the pot calling the kettle or what?
Here is another claim about which the only proper response is–not so fast, Barak:
U.S. Federal Judge Thelton Henderson went to South Africa in the 1980s and according to a close friend of his who wrote me, discovered this about Judge Richard Goldstone:
And then you have the outright lies of Alan Dershowitz which Yediot quotes as if they were halacha l’Moshe mi’Sinai:
Dersh then goes on to quote his infamous comparison of Goldstone to Mengele, which I’ve eviscerated in a previous post:
Here Dershowitz also uses a rhetorical smearing technique he accuses the far left of using against Israel: the Nazi charge. When you want to pull out all the stops and prove you have absolutely no sense of historical proportion liken your opponent or the regime your opponent supports to Nazis.
Was apartheid evil? Certainly. Was it worthy of comparison to Nazis? I don’t know. Perhaps as worthy as comparing Israel to Nazis. If you’re uncomfortable with the abuse of one historical analogy you should be uncomfortable with the other. Did South Africa commit genocide against Blacks? I don’t think so. Crimes yes. Injustice yes. But genocide?
Personally, I think someone ought to give Alan Dershowitz a Valium and get him to calm down a bit. He really does a grave disservice to his side every time he opens his mouth.
Both Barak and the Israel foreign ministry make a telling admission in this quotation from a ministry statement about the Yediot report (and this is why I believe this is an orchestrated government sponsored campaign):
The Yediot story quotes Knesset speaker Reuven Rivlin making this specious claim against the South African jurist:
The enormous contribution that Polakow-Surasky makes to this debate is his revelation of the deep ties between Israel and apartheid era South Africa. I’m just beginning to read his new book, The Unspoken Alliance. It uncovers the hitherto secret dealings between the two nations which brought much-needed cash to Israel in return for nuclear weapons technology and advanced weapons systems which South Africa used in its wars in Namibia and Angola. In fact, Israel was the apartheid nation’s primary arms supplier ($1.5 billion worth in 1988 alone) and violated international sanctions to do so. South Africa was Israel’s single largest customer for military exports. Overall, the former country was Israel’s second or third largest trading partner after the U.S. And this during a period when there were strict international sanctions in place to prevent precisely such trade.
In 1980, the UN voted for an oil embargo against South Africa much as Israel is urging the world body to do against Iran. Where was the Israeli representative at the time? Absent. Is that how Israel showed its opposition to apartheid? By failing to cast its vote when it had a chance?
So what you have is a current Israeli government hypocritically complaining about the alleged collaboration of one South African Jewish judge with a system which the entire Israeli military establishment at the same time was propping up with all the might at its disposal. Who committed the worse sin? Richard Goldstone or the State of Israel? Was it worse for Goldstone to allow blacks to be sent to their execution or that Israel expedited South Africa’s development of a nuclear weapon?
We complain about the threat of nuclear proliferation if Iran gets a nuclear bomb. We complain about Pakistani scientists giving WMD secrets to North Korea? What about Israeli’s role in exporting such nuclear technology to South Africa? We complain that Russia and China aren’t willing to coƶperate with punishing sanctions against the Iranian regime to prevent it from getting nuclear weapons. What about Israel’s own surreptitious violation of similar sanctions?
And what is Israel’s defense for its actions then? We had few friends. It was a relationship of convenience. We had something they needed and vice versa. We did what we had to do. And is Israel’s excuse much different or superior to Goldstone’s own defense of his actions?
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Sasha Polakow-Suransky writes tellingly in Foreign Policy and Huffington Post about the current smear campaign against Judge Goldstone mounted by the Israeli government with the help of willing collaborating journalists like Tehiya Barak, Jeffrey Goldberg and Jonathan Chait. It was Barak who opened the floodgates with his Yediot Achronot hit-piece, undoubtedly inspired by material developed by the Lieberman-Ayalon foreign ministry. Don’t ya just love the incestuous relationship the hacks in government ministries have with the hacks in the newsroom?
Since Barak claims that his story is a “special Yediot investigation,” let’s do the same thing it claimed to do to Goldstone’s record and shine a light on its journalistic claims. Well, it falls short right from the beginning when it claims that Goldstone “asserted that Israel committed war crimes.” He did nothing of the sort. What he DID assert was that his commission had amassed enough evidence that there MAY have been war crimes committed by BOTH sides that the charges should be investigated formally by both sides themselves. Goldstone said many times that he was not a finder of fact as a judge would be in a formal legal proceeding.
The Yediot hit-piece continues with this breathless commentary:
The man who authored the Goldstone Report criticizing the IDF’s actions during Operation Cast Lead took an active part in the racist policies of one of the cruelest regimes of the 20th century.This claim too falls by the wayside. Goldstone, as an appellate judge, reviewed sentences handed down by lower courts. And as such courts function everywhere, he could only overturn a verdict if he found a flaw in procedure or the earlier ruling. Appellate judges don’t make law. They apply existing law. And in the rare instances in which they do innovate and plow new ground, they must do so in the context of the legal and legislative system in which function.
During his tenure as sitting as judge in the appellant court during the 1980s and 1990s sentenced dozens of blacks mercilessly to their death.
Not to mention that Goldstone only actually sentenced two individuals to death. The other 26 cases were appeals in which he upheld a lower court ruling.
The Goldstone smearmeisters have it all figured out with their 20-20 hindsight view of history. Goldstone’s responsibility was either to overturn capital punishment or resign his judgeship and emigrate from South Africa. Don’t you just love it when 20 years after the fact the smug hypocritical moralists come along and give advice about how others should behave in order to retain their moral purity?
Here Barak accuses Goldstone of committing the heresy of writing in favor of capital punishment, a crime committed–surprise, surprise–by most judges in this country who’ve ever affirmed such a sentence:
Goldstone sentenced at least 28 black defendants to death. Most of them were found guilty of murder and sought to appeal the verdict. In those days, he actually made sure he showed his support for the execution policy, writing in one verdict that it reflects society’s demands that a price be paid for crimes it rightfully views as frightening.We’re going to have Supreme Court confirmation hearings soon for Elena Kagan. Would these same hypo-moralists demand that Kagan renounce capital punishment in her hearings? And if she couldn’t get four of her colleagues to agree that capital punishment should be overturned should she resign her seat and leave the country in disgust?
And keep in mind that Barak is in high moral dudgeon about South Africa’s policy of capital punishment when his own army regularly executes Palestinian militants without any trial. Is that the pot calling the kettle or what?
Here is another claim about which the only proper response is–not so fast, Barak:
Even when it came to far less serious offenses, Goldstone sided through and through with the racist policies of the Apartheid regime.Actually, Barak is abysmally ignorant of the real history of the era as corrected by Polakow-Suraksy, who argues that the critics:
…Fail to acknowledge Goldstone’s crucial role in facilitating South Africa’s transition to democracy by chairing the investigative Commission on Public Violence and Intimidation from 1991-1994. Among other things, this commission exposed the apartheid government’s links to a so-called Third Force–made up of government security and ex-security operatives seeking to derail peaceful democratic elections.
The Goldstone Commission’s revelations outraged Nelson Mandela, leading him to conclude that F.W. de Klerk’s government had organized covert death squads…Goldstone’s work earned him Mandela’s respect and, in 1994, South Africa’s first black president appointed Goldstone to the Constitutional Court…Further, it was Goldstone’s landmark ruling that overturned the Homelands policy that was a bulwark of the apartheid system. Amazing how an ignorant journalist with an axe to grind can reduce history to a steaming heap of rubble.
U.S. Federal Judge Thelton Henderson went to South Africa in the 1980s and according to a close friend of his who wrote me, discovered this about Judge Richard Goldstone:
Thelton first went to South Africa in the 1980s. In fact, being African-American, he was detained there and endured a very unpleasant experience. He will tell you about black leaders repeatedly telling him there were three good judges in the country, and the best of the three was a remarkable man, Richard Goldstone. In addition to being regarded for his fairness and justice in the courtroom, he was known by prisoners for his regular visits to the prisons. He went regularly because he was concerned about their being tortured and about their not getting medical care. (Another friend has told me about this aspect of Richard and that some black prisoners felt he literally saved their lives as a result of his visits to prisons.)This is the very same judge who “sided through and through” with the apartheid regime. Shameful.
And then you have the outright lies of Alan Dershowitz which Yediot quotes as if they were halacha l’Moshe mi’Sinai:
“Goldstone took a job as an apartheid judge. He allowed dozens of black people who were unfairly tried to be executed,”How does Dersh know they were “unfairly tried?” Did he do any research into the cases? Or does he argue that anyone sentenced to death under apartheid was tried “unfairly.” And would Dersh concede the same about Palestinian civilians killed by the IDF during the Gaza war? No, of course he wouldn’t. That’s his double-standard. He can denounce the sins of apartheid with clean hands and a clear conscience. But he refuses to acknowledge any sins of Occupation.
Dersh then goes on to quote his infamous comparison of Goldstone to Mengele, which I’ve eviscerated in a previous post:
“You know, a lot of people say we just followed the law, German judges… That’s what Mengele said too. That was Mengele’s defense and that was what everybody said in Nazi Germany. ‘We just followed the law.’ When you are in an apartheid country like South Africa, you don’t follow the law,” Dershowitz added.I pointed out in that post that Mengele never mounted such a defense because he was never prosecuted for his crimes.
Here Dershowitz also uses a rhetorical smearing technique he accuses the far left of using against Israel: the Nazi charge. When you want to pull out all the stops and prove you have absolutely no sense of historical proportion liken your opponent or the regime your opponent supports to Nazis.
Was apartheid evil? Certainly. Was it worthy of comparison to Nazis? I don’t know. Perhaps as worthy as comparing Israel to Nazis. If you’re uncomfortable with the abuse of one historical analogy you should be uncomfortable with the other. Did South Africa commit genocide against Blacks? I don’t think so. Crimes yes. Injustice yes. But genocide?
Personally, I think someone ought to give Alan Dershowitz a Valium and get him to calm down a bit. He really does a grave disservice to his side every time he opens his mouth.
Both Barak and the Israel foreign ministry make a telling admission in this quotation from a ministry statement about the Yediot report (and this is why I believe this is an orchestrated government sponsored campaign):
A Foreign Ministry official referred to the investigation as “explosive PR material”“PR material?” Really. Is that what working in the Israeli foreign ministry has become? PR flackery? Hasbara? Is that what this campaign against Goldstone is all about? Two-bit fakery?
The Yediot story quotes Knesset speaker Reuven Rivlin making this specious claim against the South African jurist:
“Such a person should not be allowed to lecture a democratic state defending itself against terrorists, who are not subject to the criteria of international moral norms…”The actual truth of the matter is that Goldstone did not quarrel with Israel’s right to defend itself or respond to the rocket attacks by Palestinian “terrorists,” which he conceded might be war crimes. What he DID concern himself with was the Israeli attacks which killed 1,100 civilians, 300 of them children.
In 1980, the UN voted for an oil embargo against South Africa much as Israel is urging the world body to do against Iran. Where was the Israeli representative at the time? Absent. Is that how Israel showed its opposition to apartheid? By failing to cast its vote when it had a chance?
So what you have is a current Israeli government hypocritically complaining about the alleged collaboration of one South African Jewish judge with a system which the entire Israeli military establishment at the same time was propping up with all the might at its disposal. Who committed the worse sin? Richard Goldstone or the State of Israel? Was it worse for Goldstone to allow blacks to be sent to their execution or that Israel expedited South Africa’s development of a nuclear weapon?
We complain about the threat of nuclear proliferation if Iran gets a nuclear bomb. We complain about Pakistani scientists giving WMD secrets to North Korea? What about Israeli’s role in exporting such nuclear technology to South Africa? We complain that Russia and China aren’t willing to coƶperate with punishing sanctions against the Iranian regime to prevent it from getting nuclear weapons. What about Israel’s own surreptitious violation of similar sanctions?
And what is Israel’s defense for its actions then? We had few friends. It was a relationship of convenience. We had something they needed and vice versa. We did what we had to do. And is Israel’s excuse much different or superior to Goldstone’s own defense of his actions?
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Chomsky To Deliver Bir Zeit Lecture On Al Jazeera
By Richard Silverstein
Well, maybe this will teach the petty bureaucrats at the Israeli Interior Ministry a lesson. After lecturing him for four hours on the errors of his ways in criticizing Israel and telling him what he could or should do to be allowed admittance, they sent Prof. Noam Chomsky packing back to Amman. Later, Israeli PR flacks attempted to backtrack by lying and claiming it was all a clerical error by a desk jockey the Allenby Bridge.
Still later, they offered to allow him back into the West Bank (which isn’t Israel last I checked, even by Israel’s standards, so why should they even be determining who enters Palestinian territory?). When Chomsky inquired about whether this was a bona fide official guarantee of entry he discovered it wasn’t. Israel is just playing games.
But Chomsky, not to be played the fool, has delightfully one-upped them all. He’s going to deliver his Bir Zeit lecture via video conference from Amman and it will be telecast live on Al Jazeera. That way it will reach an audience thousands of times larger than the original lecture would have. Since Al Jazeera is available in Israel, perhaps even Israeli citizens will be able to watch him take apart the hypocrisy and brustishness of Israeli policy and Occupation.
This is the problem with Israeli policy and with all authoritarian regimes (which the Occupation certainly is). It thinks of the short term benefit, not the long term. It thinks of tactics instead of strategies. It puts a finger in the dyke but does nothing to preserve the ecosystem itself.
On a related note, Haaretz columnist Brad Burston has written a typically eloquent, soul-searching cri de coeur about the ugly rise of fascism inside Israel. Lest my right-wing readers jump on Burston as a typically left-wing commentator, this is simply untrue. Burston made aliyah decades ago and joined Kibbutz Gezer, where I myself visited when I studied in Israel. He has impeccable credentials as a liberal Zionist. So for him to be writing so openly using such strong language should tell us that the canary is singing in the coal mine that is Israeli “democracy.” Israel is a nation under threat. Even perhaps a nation beginning to implode under our very eyes from the heap of self-contradictions under which it labors.
I was delighted to read that Elvis Costello, a performer I admire greatly, has cancelled his Israel performances on his upcoming tour. He wrote a remarkably sensitive, balanced account of his decision which acknowledges that the decision is morally conflicted but had to be made nevertheless:
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Well, maybe this will teach the petty bureaucrats at the Israeli Interior Ministry a lesson. After lecturing him for four hours on the errors of his ways in criticizing Israel and telling him what he could or should do to be allowed admittance, they sent Prof. Noam Chomsky packing back to Amman. Later, Israeli PR flacks attempted to backtrack by lying and claiming it was all a clerical error by a desk jockey the Allenby Bridge.
Still later, they offered to allow him back into the West Bank (which isn’t Israel last I checked, even by Israel’s standards, so why should they even be determining who enters Palestinian territory?). When Chomsky inquired about whether this was a bona fide official guarantee of entry he discovered it wasn’t. Israel is just playing games.
But Chomsky, not to be played the fool, has delightfully one-upped them all. He’s going to deliver his Bir Zeit lecture via video conference from Amman and it will be telecast live on Al Jazeera. That way it will reach an audience thousands of times larger than the original lecture would have. Since Al Jazeera is available in Israel, perhaps even Israeli citizens will be able to watch him take apart the hypocrisy and brustishness of Israeli policy and Occupation.
This is the problem with Israeli policy and with all authoritarian regimes (which the Occupation certainly is). It thinks of the short term benefit, not the long term. It thinks of tactics instead of strategies. It puts a finger in the dyke but does nothing to preserve the ecosystem itself.
On a related note, Haaretz columnist Brad Burston has written a typically eloquent, soul-searching cri de coeur about the ugly rise of fascism inside Israel. Lest my right-wing readers jump on Burston as a typically left-wing commentator, this is simply untrue. Burston made aliyah decades ago and joined Kibbutz Gezer, where I myself visited when I studied in Israel. He has impeccable credentials as a liberal Zionist. So for him to be writing so openly using such strong language should tell us that the canary is singing in the coal mine that is Israeli “democracy.” Israel is a nation under threat. Even perhaps a nation beginning to implode under our very eyes from the heap of self-contradictions under which it labors.
I was delighted to read that Elvis Costello, a performer I admire greatly, has cancelled his Israel performances on his upcoming tour. He wrote a remarkably sensitive, balanced account of his decision which acknowledges that the decision is morally conflicted but had to be made nevertheless:
It is after considerable contemplation that I have lately arrived at the decision that I must withdraw from the two performances scheduled in Israel on the 30th of June and the 1st of July.
One lives in hope that music is more than mere noise, filling up idle time, whether intending to elate or lament.
Then there are occasions when merely having your name added to a concert schedule may be interpreted as a political act that resonates more than anything that might be sung and it may be assumed that one has no mind for the suffering of the innocent.
…If these subjects are actually too grave and complex to be addressed in a concert, then it is also quite impossible to simply look the other way.
…I am not taking this decision lightly or so I may stand beneath any banner, nor is it one in which I imagine myself to possess any unique or eternal truth.
It is a matter of instinct and conscience.
…Sometimes a silence in music is better than adding to the static and so an end to it.
I cannot imagine receiving another invitation to perform in Israel, which is a matter of regret but I can imagine a better time when I would not be writing this.
With the hope for peace and understanding. Elvis CostelloHaaretz notes that Santana and Gil Scott Heron have also joined in the protest by cancelling their own performances. I hope other performers will read Costello’s nuanced, humble and carefully articulated statement in full. It gives them much to ponder. I too want to make clear that I do not support such a decision as a means of harming Israelis, especially those who share a critique of Occupation. This is a political act, not one of petty vindictiveness. Of course, many Israelis will mistakenly take it as the latter. This is not an act that ultimately seeks harm to Israel or God forbid, it’s destruction. It is a moral statement that tells Israel that the rest of the world will no longer sit idly by. That if Israel wishes to continue down this road, a price will be paid in isolation. And that when Israel ends Occupation, then that price will be redeemed and Israel’s status will be restored.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Bibi On Barring Chomsky: ‘I Read It In The News Today, Oh Boy’
By Richard Silverstein
Well, one thing we know…Bibi reads the papers (Bibiton-Yisrael HaYom at least): that’s apparently how he learns of major decisions made by his own Interior Ministry to bar one of the most distinguished linguists in the world from entering the West Bank to lecture at Bir Zeit University. You wouldn’t think he’d hear it from his own minister, would you?
People who are writing about this incident are getting it wrong when they say Chomsky was denied entry to Israel. He was denied entry to the West Bank, which is not Israel. Israel should have no right to determine who enters Palestinian territory via the Allenby Bridge. This should be controlled by the PA.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Well, one thing we know…Bibi reads the papers (Bibiton-Yisrael HaYom at least): that’s apparently how he learns of major decisions made by his own Interior Ministry to bar one of the most distinguished linguists in the world from entering the West Bank to lecture at Bir Zeit University. You wouldn’t think he’d hear it from his own minister, would you?
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Monday that he had learned of the decision not to allow Noam Chomsky to enter Israel from the press…
“We read about it in the paper,” Netanyahu said during a Knesset session…This is a classic case of passing the buck as far down the line as you can go. Was the decision to bar the enimnent Dr. Chomsky made my a senior official? Hell no, Israel always allows junior officers manning a desk at the Allenby Bridge to make such judgments independently:
Mark Regev, a spokesman for Prime Minister Netanyahu said, “There is no change in our policy. The idea that Israel is preventing people from entering whose opinions are critical of the state is ludicrous; it is not happening. This was a mishap. A guy at the border overstepped his authority.”
Regev suggested that if Chomsky tried to enter Israel again, he would succeed.I think Israel punished the 81 year old Chomsky enough interrogating him for 4 hours after he’d made the trek from Boston to Amman and thence to the Allenby Bridge. Why would he want to be put through this nonsense again just to enable Israel to say it did the right thing (finally) by admitting him?
People who are writing about this incident are getting it wrong when they say Chomsky was denied entry to Israel. He was denied entry to the West Bank, which is not Israel. Israel should have no right to determine who enters Palestinian territory via the Allenby Bridge. This should be controlled by the PA.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Israeli Interior Ministry Denies Chomsky West Bank Entry
By Richard Silverstein
Oops, it was all a big misunderstanding claims Eli Yishai’s Interior Ministry. That’s what Al Jazeera claims the goons who denied Prof. Noam Chomsky entry into the West Bank at the Allenby crossing are now saying. As Chomsky says in this interview, what could they have misunderstood? Who he was? Where he was going (to speak at Bir Zeit University)?
Here’s the government’s statement which should be read to see how bureaucracy functions so well in service of Occupation and its associated evils:
Israel Radio quotes an apparently conflicting statement from the Interior Ministry specifying that Chomsky must access the West Bank through Ben Gurion Airport. Reading between the lines, aside from petty harrassment, this seems to be another attempt by Israel to compel Chomsky to concede that Israel controls the West Bank. Undoubtedly, they viewed his attempt at entering via Jordan as a way to deny Israeli sovereignty over the territory.
Given the alternate statements it makes you wonder who’s running the show, or whether anyone’s running the show at the Ministry. Joe Biden probably wondered the same thing the day he was buffaloed by the Ramat Shlomo announcement.
On days like today when Omar Said’s detention has been extended along with a prohibition against consulting his attorney, I tear my hair because there is too much about which to write. Too much injustice. Too much repression. Too much fear. Too much stupidity.
When Professor Chomsky, one of the world’s most distinguished linguists and a fierce critic of Israeli Occupation and policy, presented himself at the Allenby Bridge, he was grilled for hours about his intentions. The official interrogating him made clear that they were refusing him entry because of his hostile views and because he was only speaking at Bir Zeit, but not in Israel (which he has often done). The latter is a laughable criticism. If Chomsky had been on his way to lecture at Bir Zeit and an Israeli university then they would have had grounds to claim that his views couldn’t be espoused within Israel without harming the security interests of the State. Damned if you do and damned if you don’t.
His interrogator consulted closely with his superiors in the Ministry. So for Yishai’s minions to claim it was all a big misunderstanding is ludicrous. They knew exactly what they were doing and did it. It was about as much of a misunderstanding as Joe Biden’s snub at the hands of the same Ministry which had approved 1,600 new housing units in occupied East Jerusalem the day before he arrived in Israel. All an accident, a big misunderstanding. It’s almost like they’d put a shiv in between your ribs and watch you bleed to death all the while telling you it was all just a big misunderstanding.
Noam Sheizaf had one of the best summaries of the significance of this incident:
Neither Makhoul nor Said have seen any evidence against them. They don’t know what they did that constituted espionage. They haven’t seen the most elemental rights accorded to suspects in any case in a western democracy (unless you want to compare their treatment to enemy combatants at Guantanamo, but they aren’t even U.S. citizens and Makhoul and Said are).
As the headline of the Moderate Voice’s story (see link below) on this incident says, “Democracies do not fear ideas.” I guess this one does, unless you want to argue that it isn’t a democracy, which Israel makes is easier and easier for its enemies to do. Is this any way to run a democracy? You bet it isn’t.
On dark days like today I can even laugh at the black humor in the title of a new Facebook group founded by one of the members of the Free Ameer Makhoul group I created: Together Toward Collective Suicide.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Oops, it was all a big misunderstanding claims Eli Yishai’s Interior Ministry. That’s what Al Jazeera claims the goons who denied Prof. Noam Chomsky entry into the West Bank at the Allenby crossing are now saying. As Chomsky says in this interview, what could they have misunderstood? Who he was? Where he was going (to speak at Bir Zeit University)?
Here’s the government’s statement which should be read to see how bureaucracy functions so well in service of Occupation and its associated evils:
Sabine Haddad, a spokesperson for the Interior Ministry, confirmed to Haaretz that the officials at the border were from the ministry.
“Because he entered the Palestinian Authority territory only, his entry is the responsibility of the Office of the Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories at the Defense Ministry. There was a misunderstanding on our side, and the matter was not brought to the attention of the COGAT.”
Haddad told Haaretz that “the minute the COGAT says that they do not object, Chomsky’s entry would have been permitted.”So what she’s saying is that her own ministry official made a mistake in not passing off Chomsky’s entry to the Defense Ministry. If entry via the Allenby Bridge is supposed to be handled by the Defense Ministry, why was it handled by the wrong Ministry? Are there two types of entries there that are handled differently depending on the individual? It simply doesn’t pass the smell test.
Israel Radio quotes an apparently conflicting statement from the Interior Ministry specifying that Chomsky must access the West Bank through Ben Gurion Airport. Reading between the lines, aside from petty harrassment, this seems to be another attempt by Israel to compel Chomsky to concede that Israel controls the West Bank. Undoubtedly, they viewed his attempt at entering via Jordan as a way to deny Israeli sovereignty over the territory.
Given the alternate statements it makes you wonder who’s running the show, or whether anyone’s running the show at the Ministry. Joe Biden probably wondered the same thing the day he was buffaloed by the Ramat Shlomo announcement.
On days like today when Omar Said’s detention has been extended along with a prohibition against consulting his attorney, I tear my hair because there is too much about which to write. Too much injustice. Too much repression. Too much fear. Too much stupidity.
When Professor Chomsky, one of the world’s most distinguished linguists and a fierce critic of Israeli Occupation and policy, presented himself at the Allenby Bridge, he was grilled for hours about his intentions. The official interrogating him made clear that they were refusing him entry because of his hostile views and because he was only speaking at Bir Zeit, but not in Israel (which he has often done). The latter is a laughable criticism. If Chomsky had been on his way to lecture at Bir Zeit and an Israeli university then they would have had grounds to claim that his views couldn’t be espoused within Israel without harming the security interests of the State. Damned if you do and damned if you don’t.
His interrogator consulted closely with his superiors in the Ministry. So for Yishai’s minions to claim it was all a big misunderstanding is ludicrous. They knew exactly what they were doing and did it. It was about as much of a misunderstanding as Joe Biden’s snub at the hands of the same Ministry which had approved 1,600 new housing units in occupied East Jerusalem the day before he arrived in Israel. All an accident, a big misunderstanding. It’s almost like they’d put a shiv in between your ribs and watch you bleed to death all the while telling you it was all just a big misunderstanding.
Noam Sheizaf had one of the best summaries of the significance of this incident:
There is no arguing that Israel is now viewing certain ideas, not just actions, as existential threat, and is willing to make use of its powers in order to suppress them. It is important to understand this point: Some people think that the state made a stupid mistake today, when it chose to refuse Chomsky a visa. But that’s only true if you judge the affair in terms of actual security – then you conclude that making such a fuss over a speech in Ramallah by an aging linguistic that no one would even notice is pure madness. But if you are obsessed with the persecution of “dangerous ideas” and constantly searching for ideological menaces, then Chomsky is a threat. In this context, not allowing him to enter your country might be logical…but it is also scary is hell.This comes on top of other nasty developments in the case of Omar Said and Ameer Makhoul. Today, the Petah Tikvah kangaroo court extended Said’s remand for another six days, while Makhoul’s counsel announced that they would hereby cease participating in the legal charade that was his case since they had not been able to consult with him since his detention over two weeks ago. Adalah, the Israeli Palestinian NGO providing his legal representation said:
“Due to the utter lack of respect for due process, the representation of Ameer Makhoul in the detention hearings has become meaningless.”What this proves is that there are at least two tiers of justice (possibly more). One for Israelis involved in conventional legal cases and another for those involved in security cases. Those caught up in the latter can expect minimal rights if any (cf. Anat Kamm). And if you are a Palestinian Israeli citizen you can even those minimal rights to be truncated almost at will.
Neither Makhoul nor Said have seen any evidence against them. They don’t know what they did that constituted espionage. They haven’t seen the most elemental rights accorded to suspects in any case in a western democracy (unless you want to compare their treatment to enemy combatants at Guantanamo, but they aren’t even U.S. citizens and Makhoul and Said are).
As the headline of the Moderate Voice’s story (see link below) on this incident says, “Democracies do not fear ideas.” I guess this one does, unless you want to argue that it isn’t a democracy, which Israel makes is easier and easier for its enemies to do. Is this any way to run a democracy? You bet it isn’t.
On dark days like today I can even laugh at the black humor in the title of a new Facebook group founded by one of the members of the Free Ameer Makhoul group I created: Together Toward Collective Suicide.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Monday, May 17, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Jaja’s Wife Denies Hezbollah Connection
By Richard Silverstein
There is some question about whether Hassan Geagea’s name should be spelled ‘Jaja.’ Since it appears that there is a Hassan Jaja on Facebook (as well as Hassan ‘Geagea’) who lists as a Friend Rayan Zuayter, who is the actual wife of Geagea/Jaja, I’ve decided to change the spelling of his name to Jaja.
Thanks to some intrepid sources, who’ve done some great research for this post on the ties between Hassan Jaja and Omar Said, which the Shin Bet lamely claims dealt with recruiting the latter to spy for Hezbollah against Israel.
Jaja founded the Arab Group for the Protection of Nature, whose mission is to the repair environmental damage caused by Israel’s wars in Lebanon and Gaza. He also maintains a professional interest in farming and Arab traditional medicine and owns Sanabel, a Jordanian nursery and landscape design business. As part of his engagement with herbal medicine, he spoke at First Regional Scientific Conference on Traditional Arab and Islamic Medicine (Amman, Jordan August 8-10, 2007). Said Omar also presented a talk at the same meeting. This could be the contact the Shin Bet is lamely calling Said’s recruitment into the dastardly clutches of Hezbollah.
It just occurred to me that Israel’s spookerati would have us believe that Hassan Jaja is recruiting Hezbollah spies in Jordan under the noses of the Jordanian security services. Why, in heaven’s name would King Abdullah let that happen? Why would Jordan have any interest in allowing anything to happen on its soil that would assist Hezbollah? Is Hassan Nasrallah opening a new Jordanian beachhead in his campaign to obliterate the Jewish entity? The very notion is preposterous.
Another point of interest is that the meeting between Jamal Juma’a and Jaja which led to the former’s arrest by the S.B. took place shortly after this in October, 2007.
Hassan Jaja’s wife is Razan Zuayter. She is also the daughter of distinguished Palestinian historian Akram Zaitar. Zuayter published a letter in the Arab newspaper, Al Ghad, in which she categorically denies any connection between her husband and Hezbollah. She says that Makhoul and Said’s links with him are “professional links with the Arab Group for the Protection of Nature”.
So, one of the potential goals of this harrassment is to break any sense of solidarity between Palestinians living within Israel and those in the Diaspora.
Once again, this appears of a piece with Yuval Diskin’s long-term goal, publicly announced in 2007 of breaking the back of the Israeli Palestinian nationalist movement. I’d like my American readers to imagine a scenario in which the FBI investigated and criminalized American Jewish contacts with Israeli NGOs. We simply wouldn’t stand for it. Why should Israeli Palestinians? Of course, the difference between here and there is that our system has checks and balances and we have a Congress (or at least some members of that body) who would frown on such spook activism. In Israel, no Knesset member would criticize such persecution. Have you heard of any Jewish Knesset member who has expressed a shred of concern for the welfare of these two Israeli citizens?
A number of readers and observers of this case have remarked about their fear that the S.B. has another more damaging rabbit up its sleeve than Hassan Geagea (my apologies to Mr. Jaja for using such a metaphor but it is intended as a comment on the S.B.’s attitudes and not on him). Rechavia Berman has joked about Nasrallah’s cousin being their ace in the hole, which they’ll trot out with a huge puff of smoke. Personally, I haven’t been that impressed with the manner of S.B. investigations. They don’t seem to have that level of sophistication. Their M.O. seems to throw everything at the victim and hope something sticks. Then when it doesn’t they go after the next hapless victim.
Haaretz’s excised passage did note that the security agency did have a series of forbidden contacts with which it might charge Makhoul. I’d dearly like to know who those might be if there are indeed any others (there may not be).
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
There is some question about whether Hassan Geagea’s name should be spelled ‘Jaja.’ Since it appears that there is a Hassan Jaja on Facebook (as well as Hassan ‘Geagea’) who lists as a Friend Rayan Zuayter, who is the actual wife of Geagea/Jaja, I’ve decided to change the spelling of his name to Jaja.
Thanks to some intrepid sources, who’ve done some great research for this post on the ties between Hassan Jaja and Omar Said, which the Shin Bet lamely claims dealt with recruiting the latter to spy for Hezbollah against Israel.
Jaja founded the Arab Group for the Protection of Nature, whose mission is to the repair environmental damage caused by Israel’s wars in Lebanon and Gaza. He also maintains a professional interest in farming and Arab traditional medicine and owns Sanabel, a Jordanian nursery and landscape design business. As part of his engagement with herbal medicine, he spoke at First Regional Scientific Conference on Traditional Arab and Islamic Medicine (Amman, Jordan August 8-10, 2007). Said Omar also presented a talk at the same meeting. This could be the contact the Shin Bet is lamely calling Said’s recruitment into the dastardly clutches of Hezbollah.
It just occurred to me that Israel’s spookerati would have us believe that Hassan Jaja is recruiting Hezbollah spies in Jordan under the noses of the Jordanian security services. Why, in heaven’s name would King Abdullah let that happen? Why would Jordan have any interest in allowing anything to happen on its soil that would assist Hezbollah? Is Hassan Nasrallah opening a new Jordanian beachhead in his campaign to obliterate the Jewish entity? The very notion is preposterous.
Another point of interest is that the meeting between Jamal Juma’a and Jaja which led to the former’s arrest by the S.B. took place shortly after this in October, 2007.
Hassan Jaja’s wife is Razan Zuayter. She is also the daughter of distinguished Palestinian historian Akram Zaitar. Zuayter published a letter in the Arab newspaper, Al Ghad, in which she categorically denies any connection between her husband and Hezbollah. She says that Makhoul and Said’s links with him are “professional links with the Arab Group for the Protection of Nature”.
So, one of the potential goals of this harrassment is to break any sense of solidarity between Palestinians living within Israel and those in the Diaspora.
Once again, this appears of a piece with Yuval Diskin’s long-term goal, publicly announced in 2007 of breaking the back of the Israeli Palestinian nationalist movement. I’d like my American readers to imagine a scenario in which the FBI investigated and criminalized American Jewish contacts with Israeli NGOs. We simply wouldn’t stand for it. Why should Israeli Palestinians? Of course, the difference between here and there is that our system has checks and balances and we have a Congress (or at least some members of that body) who would frown on such spook activism. In Israel, no Knesset member would criticize such persecution. Have you heard of any Jewish Knesset member who has expressed a shred of concern for the welfare of these two Israeli citizens?
A number of readers and observers of this case have remarked about their fear that the S.B. has another more damaging rabbit up its sleeve than Hassan Geagea (my apologies to Mr. Jaja for using such a metaphor but it is intended as a comment on the S.B.’s attitudes and not on him). Rechavia Berman has joked about Nasrallah’s cousin being their ace in the hole, which they’ll trot out with a huge puff of smoke. Personally, I haven’t been that impressed with the manner of S.B. investigations. They don’t seem to have that level of sophistication. Their M.O. seems to throw everything at the victim and hope something sticks. Then when it doesn’t they go after the next hapless victim.
Haaretz’s excised passage did note that the security agency did have a series of forbidden contacts with which it might charge Makhoul. I’d dearly like to know who those might be if there are indeed any others (there may not be).
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Saturday, May 15, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Hassan Jaja, Shin Bet’s All-Purpose ‘Hezbollah Spy’
By Richard Silverstein
A member of the Free Ameer Makhoul Facebook group, Disk Missing, did a cracker-jack piece of research and noted that Israeli Palestinian anti-Wall activist, Jamal Juma’a, was arrested last December and imprisoned for several weeks. Machsom Watch observed his legal hearings and characterized the evidence (such as it was) thus:
Hassan Jaja founded a Jordanian NGO whose mission is to repair environmental damage from Israel’s invasions of Lebanon and Gaza. According to a political statement he signed sponsored by the Lebanese civil society movement, he supports non-interference in the affairs of Lebanon, where he now lives. Doesn’t sound like a position supported by Hezbollah, which is heavily supported by Syria. Rechavia Berman has done further online research and discovers some of Jaja’s other interests are gardening, food independence, and Arab traditional medicine. For God’s sake, the guy likes growing food and collecting herbs. All I can say to the S.B. is: is that all you’ve got?
I note that Juma’a was released from detention after several weeks under arrest. No charges were ever filed. What do you think the odds will be of a similar outcome in this case?
Another interesting piece of evidence in the Machsom Watch report is that the S.B. apparently has an informant who it claims is cooperating with it in implicating Juma’a. It could be true or it could be a ploy to sow mistrust among the Israeli Palestinian activist community.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
A member of the Free Ameer Makhoul Facebook group, Disk Missing, did a cracker-jack piece of research and noted that Israeli Palestinian anti-Wall activist, Jamal Juma’a, was arrested last December and imprisoned for several weeks. Machsom Watch observed his legal hearings and characterized the evidence (such as it was) thus:
The defendant is charged with links to a hostile organization and with providing services, allegedly in October 2007. The incident in question took place in Jordan and involved a third person who implicated Jumaa. The claim is that the defendant met with a certain Hassan Jaja who tried to recruit him to the Hizbullah. Since the defendant’s computer contains a correspondence with Hassan Jaja, lasting until 2009, he is charged with links to the organization.Given that Machsom Watch was transcribing oral arguments and may’ve written the name ‘Jaja’ as the transcriber heard it, Disk Missing thinks it’s very likely that this could be the same Hassan Jaja whom the security services have dusted off as a “Hezbollah agent” in an attempt to implicate Makhoul and Said. Well, well, well. All I can say if this is true is that it proves even more convincingly that the Shin Bet has nothing on the current victims. And it all gets so old, so fast. The agency recycles the same ploys, the same charges, the same scenarios over and over again never achieving the effect they desire of criminalizing Palestinian nationalism and breaking the movement.
Hassan Jaja founded a Jordanian NGO whose mission is to repair environmental damage from Israel’s invasions of Lebanon and Gaza. According to a political statement he signed sponsored by the Lebanese civil society movement, he supports non-interference in the affairs of Lebanon, where he now lives. Doesn’t sound like a position supported by Hezbollah, which is heavily supported by Syria. Rechavia Berman has done further online research and discovers some of Jaja’s other interests are gardening, food independence, and Arab traditional medicine. For God’s sake, the guy likes growing food and collecting herbs. All I can say to the S.B. is: is that all you’ve got?
I note that Juma’a was released from detention after several weeks under arrest. No charges were ever filed. What do you think the odds will be of a similar outcome in this case?
Another interesting piece of evidence in the Machsom Watch report is that the S.B. apparently has an informant who it claims is cooperating with it in implicating Juma’a. It could be true or it could be a ploy to sow mistrust among the Israeli Palestinian activist community.
Richard Silverstein is an author, journalist and blogger, with articles appearing in Haaretz, the Jewish Forward, Los Angeles Times, the Guardian’s Comment Is Free, Al Jazeera English, and Alternet. His work has also been in the Seattle Times, American Conservative Magazine, Beliefnet and Tikkun Magazine, where he is on the advisory board. Check out Silverstein's blog at Tikun Olam, one of the earliest liberal Jewish blogs, which he has maintained since February, 2003.
Saturday, May 15, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...









