Medvedev And Yanukovich Planning ‘Secret Protocol’ On Transdniestria?
By Paul Goble
Although aides to Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovich are denying it, many commentators and politicians in Ukraine, Moldova and Romania are convinced that he and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev have secretly agreed to a course of action that would have Transdniestria attached to Ukraine and Moldova brought under tight Russian control.
When they met last week, Medvedev and Yanukovich issued a joint declaration about the resolution of the Transdniestria dispute. It contained only general expressions of good will, but a week ago, an official in the Ukrainian president’s protocol service leaked information about the talks of the two presidents that suggested they had agreed on rather more.
Indeed, what some have compared to “the secret protocols” of the 1939 Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, the supposed accord calls for a referendum in Transdniestria by the end of the year on its becoming an autonomous republic within Ukraine and pressure on Chisinau to elect a president and form a government more to Moscow’s liking.
In the current issue of “Versiya,” Georgy Filin discusses this case, not only detailing the statements of the various sides but also suggesting some of the consequences for Moldova, Ukraine, and their neighbors if reports about a secret agreement between Medvedev and Yanukovich are even partially true (versia.ru/articles/2010/may/24/pridnestrovje).
The leak of information about the supposed accord, Filin says, were “well paid for by functionaries of the Block of Yulia Timoshenko,” and the associates of this anti-Yanukovich party immediately handed copies of the document to Oleh Bilorus, a member of that party who heads the Foreign Relations Committee of the Verkhovna Rada.
Immediately copies were handed over to Chisinau officials where, in Filin’s words, they had “the effect of a bomb going off.” Sergey Mokan, the head of the Moldovan “People’s Action” Movement, said the Medvedev-Yanukovich accord “represents an ultimatum to Moldova and is the beginning of a new military-political expansion in the post-Soviet space.”
“Kyiv and Moscow have decided to act according to the principle of ‘divide and rule.’” Mokan’s comment was expanded upon by Moldovan Prime Minister Vladimir Filat, who said what Medvedev and Yanukovich had agreed to was like “the swallowing up” businessmen talk about when they takeover companies. And neither asked the Moldovans what they “think.”
“What in fact have Russia and Ukraine prepared for Moldova and Transdniestria?” Filin asks rhetorically. The first thing that has to be said, he points out, is that “the protocols which have fallen into the hands of Ukrainian journalists were prepared by the Ukrainian side” rather than being a joint statement or agreement.
They are thus, the “Versiya” journalist says, “exclusively ‘the Ukrainian vision’ of the resolution of the Transdniestria question and at the same time of the Moldovan one.” That “vision” calls for a referendum in November or December in Transdniestria concerning that breakaway territory’s inclusion into Ukraine as an autonomous republic.
Why, Filin asks, did the accord not call for uniting Transdniestria to the Russian Federation, as many in Transdniestria have proposed? The answer to that question, he continues, is “very simple.” Uniting Transdniestria to Ukraine makes greater sense economically, and doing so will allow Russia to “begin in Moldova a program of ‘an orange counterrevolution.’”
That will allow the Russian powers that be to orchestrate the election by the Moldovan parliament of a pro-Moscow president sometime next year. “Of course,” Filin continues, “one cannot talk about any Anschluss of Moldova by Russia.” In this case, “the technology is different,” one that counts on Moldovan wine producers wanting to sell their output in Russia.
According to Ukrainian parliamentarian Bilorus, “the new leadership of Ukraine has taken a new position concerning Transdniestria, one that in essence is the copy of Russia’s position.” Two years ago, he continued, Moscow offered Kyiv the same deal: ‘You gather in Transdniestria and give us Moldova,” an exchange then-President Viktor Yushchenko rejected.
Romania’s President Traian Basescu has reacted just as harshly as the Moldovans. “If Kyiv has pretensions concerning the return of Transdniestria to Ukraine, then officials there should not forget about the return to Chisinau of Southern Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina, territories which the former Ukrainian SSR received after the Second World War.”
And Basescu suggested that “Moscow and now Kyiv are trying to create on the territory which at the end of World War II should have been returned to Romania a pseudo-federation of three political-legal pseudo-subjects. But we will do everything to oppose the Russian-Ukrainian plan for the amputation of Bessarabia.”
Although Filin does not mention it, the possibility that Moldova could become part of Romania if Transdniestria were to become an autonomy within Ukraine is not the only way in which such a Russian-Ukrainian plan would send shockwaves through the international system far beyond Transdniestria.
If Transdniestria were transferred, that would trigger a provision in the 1994 accord between Chisinau and the Gagauz, an Orthodox Christian Turkic-speaking community in southern Moldova. That agreement allows the Gagauz to withdraw from Moldova if the status of Transdniestria were ever to change.
Perhaps because of these reactions or perhaps because the supposed agreement between Medvedev and Yanukovich never took place, Yanukovich’s office has been at pains to deny that there is or was any such accord. Anna German, a representative of the Ukrainian Presidential Administration made a public declaration to that effect.
“Transdniestria will remain independent and not become part of Ukraine,” she said. Suggestions to the contrary are “provocations” by Yuliya Timoshenko in order to cast doubt on “the political and diplomatic successes of Viktor Yanukovich in order to destabilize the situation in the country.”
But Filin concludes, her words are less than fully convincing, all the more because the Verkhovna Rada has already discussed the procedure that would have to be followed for places like Transdniestria to join Ukraine. Indeed, he says, the Ukrainian deputies have come up with a slogan: ‘Transdniestria – the First Stage of a New Pereyaslavska Rada’ – neither more nor less!”
Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .
Although aides to Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovich are denying it, many commentators and politicians in Ukraine, Moldova and Romania are convinced that he and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev have secretly agreed to a course of action that would have Transdniestria attached to Ukraine and Moldova brought under tight Russian control.
When they met last week, Medvedev and Yanukovich issued a joint declaration about the resolution of the Transdniestria dispute. It contained only general expressions of good will, but a week ago, an official in the Ukrainian president’s protocol service leaked information about the talks of the two presidents that suggested they had agreed on rather more.
Indeed, what some have compared to “the secret protocols” of the 1939 Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, the supposed accord calls for a referendum in Transdniestria by the end of the year on its becoming an autonomous republic within Ukraine and pressure on Chisinau to elect a president and form a government more to Moscow’s liking.
In the current issue of “Versiya,” Georgy Filin discusses this case, not only detailing the statements of the various sides but also suggesting some of the consequences for Moldova, Ukraine, and their neighbors if reports about a secret agreement between Medvedev and Yanukovich are even partially true (versia.ru/articles/2010/may/24/pridnestrovje).
The leak of information about the supposed accord, Filin says, were “well paid for by functionaries of the Block of Yulia Timoshenko,” and the associates of this anti-Yanukovich party immediately handed copies of the document to Oleh Bilorus, a member of that party who heads the Foreign Relations Committee of the Verkhovna Rada.
Immediately copies were handed over to Chisinau officials where, in Filin’s words, they had “the effect of a bomb going off.” Sergey Mokan, the head of the Moldovan “People’s Action” Movement, said the Medvedev-Yanukovich accord “represents an ultimatum to Moldova and is the beginning of a new military-political expansion in the post-Soviet space.”
“Kyiv and Moscow have decided to act according to the principle of ‘divide and rule.’” Mokan’s comment was expanded upon by Moldovan Prime Minister Vladimir Filat, who said what Medvedev and Yanukovich had agreed to was like “the swallowing up” businessmen talk about when they takeover companies. And neither asked the Moldovans what they “think.”
“What in fact have Russia and Ukraine prepared for Moldova and Transdniestria?” Filin asks rhetorically. The first thing that has to be said, he points out, is that “the protocols which have fallen into the hands of Ukrainian journalists were prepared by the Ukrainian side” rather than being a joint statement or agreement.
They are thus, the “Versiya” journalist says, “exclusively ‘the Ukrainian vision’ of the resolution of the Transdniestria question and at the same time of the Moldovan one.” That “vision” calls for a referendum in November or December in Transdniestria concerning that breakaway territory’s inclusion into Ukraine as an autonomous republic.
Why, Filin asks, did the accord not call for uniting Transdniestria to the Russian Federation, as many in Transdniestria have proposed? The answer to that question, he continues, is “very simple.” Uniting Transdniestria to Ukraine makes greater sense economically, and doing so will allow Russia to “begin in Moldova a program of ‘an orange counterrevolution.’”
That will allow the Russian powers that be to orchestrate the election by the Moldovan parliament of a pro-Moscow president sometime next year. “Of course,” Filin continues, “one cannot talk about any Anschluss of Moldova by Russia.” In this case, “the technology is different,” one that counts on Moldovan wine producers wanting to sell their output in Russia.
According to Ukrainian parliamentarian Bilorus, “the new leadership of Ukraine has taken a new position concerning Transdniestria, one that in essence is the copy of Russia’s position.” Two years ago, he continued, Moscow offered Kyiv the same deal: ‘You gather in Transdniestria and give us Moldova,” an exchange then-President Viktor Yushchenko rejected.
Romania’s President Traian Basescu has reacted just as harshly as the Moldovans. “If Kyiv has pretensions concerning the return of Transdniestria to Ukraine, then officials there should not forget about the return to Chisinau of Southern Bessarabia and Northern Bukovina, territories which the former Ukrainian SSR received after the Second World War.”
And Basescu suggested that “Moscow and now Kyiv are trying to create on the territory which at the end of World War II should have been returned to Romania a pseudo-federation of three political-legal pseudo-subjects. But we will do everything to oppose the Russian-Ukrainian plan for the amputation of Bessarabia.”
Although Filin does not mention it, the possibility that Moldova could become part of Romania if Transdniestria were to become an autonomy within Ukraine is not the only way in which such a Russian-Ukrainian plan would send shockwaves through the international system far beyond Transdniestria.
If Transdniestria were transferred, that would trigger a provision in the 1994 accord between Chisinau and the Gagauz, an Orthodox Christian Turkic-speaking community in southern Moldova. That agreement allows the Gagauz to withdraw from Moldova if the status of Transdniestria were ever to change.
Perhaps because of these reactions or perhaps because the supposed agreement between Medvedev and Yanukovich never took place, Yanukovich’s office has been at pains to deny that there is or was any such accord. Anna German, a representative of the Ukrainian Presidential Administration made a public declaration to that effect.
“Transdniestria will remain independent and not become part of Ukraine,” she said. Suggestions to the contrary are “provocations” by Yuliya Timoshenko in order to cast doubt on “the political and diplomatic successes of Viktor Yanukovich in order to destabilize the situation in the country.”
But Filin concludes, her words are less than fully convincing, all the more because the Verkhovna Rada has already discussed the procedure that would have to be followed for places like Transdniestria to join Ukraine. Indeed, he says, the Ukrainian deputies have come up with a slogan: ‘Transdniestria – the First Stage of a New Pereyaslavska Rada’ – neither more nor less!”
Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
World Biodiversity Day: Thousands Connect With Nature Through EU Campaign
Saturday is World Biodiversity Day and despite efforts around the globe, studies show that biodiversity – the rich variety of life on this planet – is diminishing at a startling rate.
An innovative EU campaign to highlight this message is engaging thousands of people across the European Union and beyond. The campaign website has already received more than half a million visits, while over 56,000 people have shown their support for the campaign on Facebook. The Commission is marking World Biodiversity Day with a series of events in six focus countries: Spain, the Netherlands, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland and Italy.
Environment Commissioner Janez Potočnik said, "It is good to see how this campaign is capturing people's imagination. We must keep up the momentum and translate this interest into real action and real policies. to safeguard the rich variety of life on Earth."
Campaign captures public attention
People of all ages are connecting with nature through the biodiversity campaign's interactive website and social media. In the first six weeks of the campaign the website, which is available in all EU languages, registered more than 550,000 page views with the number growing daily. Some 56,000 people from more than 120 countries have declared their support on the biodiversity Facebook pages.
Built around the slogan, ‘Biodiversity – we are all in this together’, the campaign aims to raise awareness of the problem of biodiversity loss and show the implications of these losses in our daily lives.
The campaign has an educational component that reveals the benefits biodiversity brings, and stresses in particular the idea of ecosystem services and the dangers of their disappearance. The theme that returns repeatedly is the idea of connectivity and interdependence.
The latest element to be added is a powerful video clip which sends a stark message about the urgent need for action. The clip aims to highlight how the loss of any link in the chain of life, however insignificant it may appear, can upset the whole balance of nature.
The campaign has a special focus on countries where action is considered especially useful. Successful launches have taken place in Spain, the Netherlands, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland and Italy with PR actions and street art. Family activity events will also take place in all six focus countries as part of World Biodiversity Day celebrations.
From awareness to action
As well as raising awareness, the campaign is also focusing on making citizens more aware of the role they can play in slowing and preventing biodiversity loss. This aims to get people doing something – on their own or in projects – to protect and care for nature.
The website is already actively engaging the public in learning about how we are interconnected with nature. As well as making friends with living organisms and species, members of the public can also create a biodiversified image of themselves on Facebook.
The hope is that by discovering more about the natural world which we so often take for granted, we will learn to take greater care of it.
A new viewer for Natura 2000
The European Commission, with the support of the European Environment Agency (EEA), has launched a new IT tool to bring the public closer to Natura 2000, its flagship network of protected areas.
Natura 2000 is the key instrument to protect biodiversity in the European Union. It is the largest ecological network of protected areas in the world, consisting of more than 25, 000 sites and covering 17% of the EU's land territory. Natura 2000 aims to ensure the survival of Europe's most valuable species and habitats, and safeguards numerous ecosystem services.
Using GIS (Geographical Information System) technology, the interactive viewer allows users to locate sites and related information on species and habitats of interest, using street maps, photographs, satellite imagery and background documents about the regions in question. The tool should raise awareness among the general public, and provides a useful instrument for developers, land use planners, landowners, government authorities, NGOs and researchers.
An innovative EU campaign to highlight this message is engaging thousands of people across the European Union and beyond. The campaign website has already received more than half a million visits, while over 56,000 people have shown their support for the campaign on Facebook. The Commission is marking World Biodiversity Day with a series of events in six focus countries: Spain, the Netherlands, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland and Italy.
Environment Commissioner Janez Potočnik said, "It is good to see how this campaign is capturing people's imagination. We must keep up the momentum and translate this interest into real action and real policies. to safeguard the rich variety of life on Earth."
Campaign captures public attention
People of all ages are connecting with nature through the biodiversity campaign's interactive website and social media. In the first six weeks of the campaign the website, which is available in all EU languages, registered more than 550,000 page views with the number growing daily. Some 56,000 people from more than 120 countries have declared their support on the biodiversity Facebook pages.
Built around the slogan, ‘Biodiversity – we are all in this together’, the campaign aims to raise awareness of the problem of biodiversity loss and show the implications of these losses in our daily lives.
The campaign has an educational component that reveals the benefits biodiversity brings, and stresses in particular the idea of ecosystem services and the dangers of their disappearance. The theme that returns repeatedly is the idea of connectivity and interdependence.
The latest element to be added is a powerful video clip which sends a stark message about the urgent need for action. The clip aims to highlight how the loss of any link in the chain of life, however insignificant it may appear, can upset the whole balance of nature.
The campaign has a special focus on countries where action is considered especially useful. Successful launches have taken place in Spain, the Netherlands, Bulgaria, Romania, Poland and Italy with PR actions and street art. Family activity events will also take place in all six focus countries as part of World Biodiversity Day celebrations.
From awareness to action
As well as raising awareness, the campaign is also focusing on making citizens more aware of the role they can play in slowing and preventing biodiversity loss. This aims to get people doing something – on their own or in projects – to protect and care for nature.
The website is already actively engaging the public in learning about how we are interconnected with nature. As well as making friends with living organisms and species, members of the public can also create a biodiversified image of themselves on Facebook.
The hope is that by discovering more about the natural world which we so often take for granted, we will learn to take greater care of it.
A new viewer for Natura 2000
The European Commission, with the support of the European Environment Agency (EEA), has launched a new IT tool to bring the public closer to Natura 2000, its flagship network of protected areas.
Natura 2000 is the key instrument to protect biodiversity in the European Union. It is the largest ecological network of protected areas in the world, consisting of more than 25, 000 sites and covering 17% of the EU's land territory. Natura 2000 aims to ensure the survival of Europe's most valuable species and habitats, and safeguards numerous ecosystem services.
Using GIS (Geographical Information System) technology, the interactive viewer allows users to locate sites and related information on species and habitats of interest, using street maps, photographs, satellite imagery and background documents about the regions in question. The tool should raise awareness among the general public, and provides a useful instrument for developers, land use planners, landowners, government authorities, NGOs and researchers.
Friday, May 21, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
U.S. And NATO Accelerate Military Build-Up In Black Sea Region
By Rick Rozoff
In the post-Cold War era and especially since 2001 the Pentagon has been steadily shifting emphasis, and moving troops and equipment, from bases in Germany and Italy to Eastern Europe in its drive to the east and the south.
That process was preceded and augmented by the absorption of former Eastern Bloc nations into the North Atlantic Treaty Organization beginning in 1999. In one of the first nations in that category, Poland, the initial contingent of what will be over 100 U.S. troops arrived in the town of Morag this week, as near as 35 miles from Russian territory, as part of a Status of Forces Agreement between Washington and the host country ratified this February.
Also in February, the governments of the Black Sea nations of Romania and Bulgaria confirmed plans for the U.S. to deploy a land-based version of Standard Missile-3 anti-ballistic interceptors on their territory.
The U.S. Sixth Fleet, headquartered in Italy, has deployed warships to the Black Sea with an increased frequency over the past few years, visiting and conducting joint drills with the navies of Bulgaria, Romania and Georgia.
Last autumn it was revealed that the Pentagon planned to spend $110 million dollars to upgrade and modernize a base in Bulgaria and another in Romania, two of seven such newly-acquired installations in the two nations.
The air, naval and infantry bases in Bulgaria and Romania have been employed for the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and, although not publicly acknowledged, doubtlessly for arming Georgia before, during and since its five-day war with Russia in August of 2008.
The Pentagon's Joint Task Force-East has all but officially been assigned to the Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield in Romania and also makes regular use of the Romanian Army's Babadag Training Area and the Novo Selo Training Range in Bulgaria, the latter near the strategic Bezmer Air Base and the Black Sea port city of Burgas (Bourgas).
Last year Joint Task Force-East conducted a series of military trainings with Bulgarian and Romanian counterparts from August 7 to October 24. The immediate purpose of the combat drills was for "downrange" operations in Afghanistan, but the lengthy and extensive nature of the maneuvers demonstrated the longer-term and longer-range intents of the U.S. and its NATO allies. The latter also have free use of the Bulgarian and Romanian military bases.
Two squadrons from the 2nd Stryker Cavalry Regiment were among the 2,000 American troops who participated in last year's war games in the two nations.
American Admiral James Stavridis, commander of U.S. European Command and NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Europe, visited Romania on April 27 and 28, meeting with the country's president and defense minister. The main topics of discussion were NATO's new Strategic Concept and its war in Afghanistan, but the issue of stationing U.S. interceptor missiles was surely touched upon as well.
NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen was in Romania on May 6 and 7 to meet with the president, defense minister, foreign minister and top military commander. The U.S.-NATO missile shield project and the war in Afghanistan were major subjects on the agenda.
Five days after Rasmussen left the capital the Romanian Foreign Ministry announced that "A round of technical US-Romanian talks on Romania's inclusion in the Phased Adaptive Approach of the European missile defense system took place in Bucharest" a day earlier, May 11. [1]
The NATO chief arrived in neighboring Bulgaria on May 20 for similar discussions. The local press announced in advance that "The construction of a common missile defense system and Bulgaria’s accession into it, along with reforms in the Bulgarian army and NATO’s new strategic concept – these will be some of the issues that NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen is going to discuss with his Bulgarian partners during his two-day visit to Sofia beginning on Thursday, May 20." [2]
In fact, while in the Bulgarian capital Rasmussen met with the nation's prime minister, president and defense minister and, according to a Bulgarian news source, the top issue discussed was "the planned installation of an anti-missile defence system in the region, as Brussels plans to deploy anti-missile units in Bulgaria and negotiations are set to be launched following the Portugal Nato summit" in November. [3]
Rasmussen reiterated the demand that all Balkans nations be incorporated into NATO, which would dictate the inclusion of Bosnia, Serbia, Macedonia, Montenegro and Kosovo. (As NATO recognizes the last-named as an independent state.)
The host nation's foreign minister, Nikolay Mladenov, spoke after the meeting with NATO's secretary general and linked the North Atlantic bloc's collective military assistance article with U.S.-led missile deployments and anti-Russian energy transit projects. He specifically highlighted "setting up the anti-missile defence shield as a part of Article 5 against new threats" and "the inclusion of energy security to key security issues." [4]
On May 14 Chairman of the NATO Military Committee Admiral Giampaolo Di Paola was in Romania to meet with Defense Minister Gabriel Oprea, and the "current stage of NATO-led military actions in Afghanistan and Romania’s participation in Alliance missions were the main subjects" of deliberation. Romania's defense minister said, "Romania’s prompt response to the proposal to install missile shield elements on its soil is a confirmation of the responsibility whereby Romania approaches national, South-East European and Alliance security issues." [5]
The nation, which lost another soldier to fighting in Afghanistan this week, has recently confirmed plans to deploy 600 more troops for the South Asian war, bringing the aggregate number to 1,800.
On May 17 the U.S.'s Black Sea Rotational Force 2010 three-month series of military exercises was launched at Romania's Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield.
Several days before "more than 100 Marines from across the United States put boots on the ground in Romania and stepped into history as the first Security Cooperation Marine Air-Ground Task Force in the Black Sea region.
"The Marines were deployed to build partnerships with nations in the Black Sea, Balkan and Caucasus regions...." [6]
The Black Sea Rotational Force 2010 drills are being conducted in eastern Romania in Constanta on the Black Sea and Tulcea, also on the Black Sea and close to the border with Moldova, and include over 300 troops from the U.S., the host country, Ukraine and Macedonia.
The U.S. Marine Corps deployment is "the first of its kind for United States Marines to the Black Sea region." [7]
The commander of the Black Sea Rotational Force Security Cooperation Marine Air-Ground Task Force (MAGTF), Lieutenant Colonel Tom Gordon, spoke at the opening ceremony at the Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield. His comments included the following: "Our mission over the next three months will be to conduct multilateral security cooperation activities with partner nations in the Black Sea, Balkan, and Caucasus regions in order to enhance our collective professional military capacity, promote regional stability, and build enduring relationships with our partner nations. As a MAGTF we will simultaneously engage with Romanian Land, Naval, Air, and Special Forces throughout our deployment."
A Romanian officer present said, "This is a great opportunity for us to know the Marines. I expect my men to show they are prepared to fight with America in Afghanistan." [8]
In advance of the maneuvers, the U.S. Marine Corps moved military vehicles from a base in Norway, part of Marine Corps Prepositioning Program Norway.
"The Marine Corps and Norway have developed a unique relationship for the storage and care of prepositioned equipment and supplies. The method of storage to support the prepositioned assets for a MAGTF is a series of six caves in the Trondheim region of central Norway."
To illustrate both the range of military networks stretching from old to new NATO states and where their ultimate downrange destinations are located, a Marine website supplied additional details:
"Norway relies on the Marine’s prepositioning program as a major cornerstone of the nation’s internal defense plan. With deep-water ports in close proximity to the storage caves, equipment can quickly be loaded aboard available shipping for operations in threatened parts of Europe, Africa or the Middle East. This capability was demonstrated by the supplying of equipment and ammunition in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom." [9]
U.S. Marines will be occupied "working in the Black Sea, Balkan and Caucasus regions" to "build enduring partnerships and build the capacity of partner nation’s military forces" until the end of July, by which time NATO's largest military offensive of the nearly nine-year-old Afghan war - the assault on Kandahar province - will be underway.
Shortly before the above-described war games began, U.S. Air Force personnel were deployed from the Ramstein Air Base in Germany to Romania for Operation Carpathian Summer 2010, an air force medical evacuation exercise. "Held at Otopeni Airfield, near Bucharest, Operation Carpathian Summer 2010 was designed to strengthen the partnership between the U.S. and Romanian air forces, while elevating their capability to work together.
"Though this is not the first time American airmen have worked with the Romanian air force, the 86th AES [Aeromedical Evacuation Squadron] has never before joined in the training with their Romanian colleagues." [10]
At the same time Romanian troops joined colleagues from the U.S., Britain, Belgium, Croatia, France, Germany, Hungary, Norway, Poland and Slovakia at the Joint Multinational Readiness Center in Hohenfels, Germany to engage in joint military training with soldiers from the Afghan National Army.
On May 19 the Stars and Stripes armed forces publication reported that "Rapid expansion of the Army's unmanned aircraft fleet has prompted the service to begin offering initial training in Europe, instead of sending troops to the U.S. to learn...." Among the drones that will be used for the training are the Extended-Range Multi-Purpose MQ-1C Warrior, "which can fly for more than 20 hours and launch air-to-ground missiles," and the RQ-11 Raven small class unmanned aerial vehicle used by the U.S. and NATO allies.
The news source added that "a course next month at Grafenwohr Training Area, will, for the first time, offer initial operator training on the Raven UAS [Unmanned Aircraft System] in Europe.
"The Army is looking at flying the Raven in Romania and possibly Bulgaria, and attempting to open a range in Italy for the 173rd Airborne Brigade's unmanned aircraft." [11]
From April 12-16 a U.S. Air Force team at the Aviano Air Base in Italy, "in an effort to improve an already established military relationship," provided aircraft maintenance training to the Bulgarian and Romanian air forces. [12]
On May 18 200 U.S. airmen and ten F-15 multi-role strike fighters spearheaded the launching of Operation Sentry Gold at the Graf Ignatievo Air Base in Bulgaria. "The exercise is designed to provide the U.S. Air Force and Bulgarian air force the opportunity to learn from each other and increase their respective NATO interoperability."
The American commander involved in the maneuvers emphasized that the Bulgarian air force still uses Russian MiG-21s and MiG-29s, saying: "We simulate fighting MiGs all the time. Being here allows us to really see them in action."
A Bulgarian officer said of the drills, "Sentry Gold increases the realism of our combat training. We get to see how a unit with a tested and proven combat history does things," and added, "Training together with [U.S. Air Forces in Europe] and the U.S. pilots moves us closer to NATO standards." [13]
As noted earlier, NATO chief Rasmussen arrived in the Bulgarian capital on May 20. Five days earlier the nation's defense minister, Anyu Angelov, affirmed that "We will file a request to join the common European missile shield during NATO Secretary-General Anders Fogh Rasmussen's visit to Sofia...." [14]
The Bulgarian defense chief also said that his ministry will allot funds to upgrade the nation's air defense system and that "Brussels has promised to co-finance the initiative, while NATO will allocate US $7.5 million to complete the construction of the Graf Ignatievo airbase." [15]
On the eastern shore of the Black Sea, senior Georgian military officials met with the permanent representatives of all 28 NATO member states at a sitting of the NATO-Georgia Commission (created the month after Georgia's war with Russia in 2008) on May 5. A week later NATO's South Caucasus liaison officer Zbigniew Ribatski announced that the military bloc will open a representative's office in Georgia this summer.
On May 14 the Georgian press reported the launching of a U.S.-funded military training simulation facility in the country: "The Simulation Training Center has been formed through the framework of US-Georgia cooperation. The United States, under the ongoing collaboration, donated the Center with the cutting-edge technical equipment and developed special training programs for it." [16] The inauguration was attended by new U.S. ambassador John Bass and NATO nations' military attaches.
Even Ukraine under its new president Viktor Yanukovich remains within NATO's Black Sea plans. The prohibition against the presence of foreign military forces for exercises in the nation, effected by the former opposition against Yanukovich's pro-U.S. predecessor Viktor Yushchenko, has been reversed, and U.S. and fellow NATO states' troops may resume Sea Breeze exercises on Ukraine's Black Sea coast.
The establishment of U.S. and NATO naval, air and infantry bases and interceptor missile installations in Black Sea nations is the prototype for expansive and permanent military build-ups in Eastern Europe and into former Soviet space, which is being replicated in the Baltic Sea region. An imaginary Iranian threat is the subterfuge employed to justify the presence of U.S. and NATO warplanes, warships, troops, mechanized and airborne units, missile batteries, training centers and radar facilities in the Black Sea and Baltic Sea regions.
Iran does not border either of the two seas and has neither the ability nor any reason to threaten nations that do.
Recent news reports from both sides of the Atlantic speak of a warming of relations between Russia and the United States, between Russia and NATO. If so, Russian political leaders won't have to extend their hands far to clasp those of their alleged Western friends and allies. They need merely reach across their southwestern and northwestern borders on the Black and Baltic Seas.
Rick Rozoff is a journalist and blogger and many of his articles may be found at the Stop NATO blog.
Notes:
1) HotNews.ro, May 12, 2010
2) Standart News, May 16, 2010
3) Sofia Echo, May 20, 2010
4) Focus News Agency, May 20, 2010
5) The Financiarul, May 14, 2010
6) Xinhua News Agency, May 13, 2010
7) United States European Command, May 17, 2010
8) Ibid
9) Marines.mil, May 12, 2010
10) U.S. European Command, May 14, 2010
11) Stars and Stripes, May 19, 2010
12) U.S. Air Forces in Europe, April 20, 2010
13) U.S. Air Forces in Europe, May 18, 2010
14) Standart News, May 15, 2010
15) Ibid
16) Georgia Ministry of Defence, May 14, 2010
In the post-Cold War era and especially since 2001 the Pentagon has been steadily shifting emphasis, and moving troops and equipment, from bases in Germany and Italy to Eastern Europe in its drive to the east and the south.
That process was preceded and augmented by the absorption of former Eastern Bloc nations into the North Atlantic Treaty Organization beginning in 1999. In one of the first nations in that category, Poland, the initial contingent of what will be over 100 U.S. troops arrived in the town of Morag this week, as near as 35 miles from Russian territory, as part of a Status of Forces Agreement between Washington and the host country ratified this February.
Also in February, the governments of the Black Sea nations of Romania and Bulgaria confirmed plans for the U.S. to deploy a land-based version of Standard Missile-3 anti-ballistic interceptors on their territory.
The U.S. Sixth Fleet, headquartered in Italy, has deployed warships to the Black Sea with an increased frequency over the past few years, visiting and conducting joint drills with the navies of Bulgaria, Romania and Georgia.
Last autumn it was revealed that the Pentagon planned to spend $110 million dollars to upgrade and modernize a base in Bulgaria and another in Romania, two of seven such newly-acquired installations in the two nations.
The air, naval and infantry bases in Bulgaria and Romania have been employed for the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and, although not publicly acknowledged, doubtlessly for arming Georgia before, during and since its five-day war with Russia in August of 2008.
The Pentagon's Joint Task Force-East has all but officially been assigned to the Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield in Romania and also makes regular use of the Romanian Army's Babadag Training Area and the Novo Selo Training Range in Bulgaria, the latter near the strategic Bezmer Air Base and the Black Sea port city of Burgas (Bourgas).
Last year Joint Task Force-East conducted a series of military trainings with Bulgarian and Romanian counterparts from August 7 to October 24. The immediate purpose of the combat drills was for "downrange" operations in Afghanistan, but the lengthy and extensive nature of the maneuvers demonstrated the longer-term and longer-range intents of the U.S. and its NATO allies. The latter also have free use of the Bulgarian and Romanian military bases.
Two squadrons from the 2nd Stryker Cavalry Regiment were among the 2,000 American troops who participated in last year's war games in the two nations.
American Admiral James Stavridis, commander of U.S. European Command and NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Europe, visited Romania on April 27 and 28, meeting with the country's president and defense minister. The main topics of discussion were NATO's new Strategic Concept and its war in Afghanistan, but the issue of stationing U.S. interceptor missiles was surely touched upon as well.
NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen was in Romania on May 6 and 7 to meet with the president, defense minister, foreign minister and top military commander. The U.S.-NATO missile shield project and the war in Afghanistan were major subjects on the agenda.
Five days after Rasmussen left the capital the Romanian Foreign Ministry announced that "A round of technical US-Romanian talks on Romania's inclusion in the Phased Adaptive Approach of the European missile defense system took place in Bucharest" a day earlier, May 11. [1]
The NATO chief arrived in neighboring Bulgaria on May 20 for similar discussions. The local press announced in advance that "The construction of a common missile defense system and Bulgaria’s accession into it, along with reforms in the Bulgarian army and NATO’s new strategic concept – these will be some of the issues that NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen is going to discuss with his Bulgarian partners during his two-day visit to Sofia beginning on Thursday, May 20." [2]
In fact, while in the Bulgarian capital Rasmussen met with the nation's prime minister, president and defense minister and, according to a Bulgarian news source, the top issue discussed was "the planned installation of an anti-missile defence system in the region, as Brussels plans to deploy anti-missile units in Bulgaria and negotiations are set to be launched following the Portugal Nato summit" in November. [3]
Rasmussen reiterated the demand that all Balkans nations be incorporated into NATO, which would dictate the inclusion of Bosnia, Serbia, Macedonia, Montenegro and Kosovo. (As NATO recognizes the last-named as an independent state.)
The host nation's foreign minister, Nikolay Mladenov, spoke after the meeting with NATO's secretary general and linked the North Atlantic bloc's collective military assistance article with U.S.-led missile deployments and anti-Russian energy transit projects. He specifically highlighted "setting up the anti-missile defence shield as a part of Article 5 against new threats" and "the inclusion of energy security to key security issues." [4]
On May 14 Chairman of the NATO Military Committee Admiral Giampaolo Di Paola was in Romania to meet with Defense Minister Gabriel Oprea, and the "current stage of NATO-led military actions in Afghanistan and Romania’s participation in Alliance missions were the main subjects" of deliberation. Romania's defense minister said, "Romania’s prompt response to the proposal to install missile shield elements on its soil is a confirmation of the responsibility whereby Romania approaches national, South-East European and Alliance security issues." [5]
The nation, which lost another soldier to fighting in Afghanistan this week, has recently confirmed plans to deploy 600 more troops for the South Asian war, bringing the aggregate number to 1,800.
On May 17 the U.S.'s Black Sea Rotational Force 2010 three-month series of military exercises was launched at Romania's Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield.
Several days before "more than 100 Marines from across the United States put boots on the ground in Romania and stepped into history as the first Security Cooperation Marine Air-Ground Task Force in the Black Sea region.
"The Marines were deployed to build partnerships with nations in the Black Sea, Balkan and Caucasus regions...." [6]
The Black Sea Rotational Force 2010 drills are being conducted in eastern Romania in Constanta on the Black Sea and Tulcea, also on the Black Sea and close to the border with Moldova, and include over 300 troops from the U.S., the host country, Ukraine and Macedonia.
The U.S. Marine Corps deployment is "the first of its kind for United States Marines to the Black Sea region." [7]
The commander of the Black Sea Rotational Force Security Cooperation Marine Air-Ground Task Force (MAGTF), Lieutenant Colonel Tom Gordon, spoke at the opening ceremony at the Mihail Kogalniceanu Airfield. His comments included the following: "Our mission over the next three months will be to conduct multilateral security cooperation activities with partner nations in the Black Sea, Balkan, and Caucasus regions in order to enhance our collective professional military capacity, promote regional stability, and build enduring relationships with our partner nations. As a MAGTF we will simultaneously engage with Romanian Land, Naval, Air, and Special Forces throughout our deployment."
A Romanian officer present said, "This is a great opportunity for us to know the Marines. I expect my men to show they are prepared to fight with America in Afghanistan." [8]
In advance of the maneuvers, the U.S. Marine Corps moved military vehicles from a base in Norway, part of Marine Corps Prepositioning Program Norway.
"The Marine Corps and Norway have developed a unique relationship for the storage and care of prepositioned equipment and supplies. The method of storage to support the prepositioned assets for a MAGTF is a series of six caves in the Trondheim region of central Norway."
To illustrate both the range of military networks stretching from old to new NATO states and where their ultimate downrange destinations are located, a Marine website supplied additional details:
"Norway relies on the Marine’s prepositioning program as a major cornerstone of the nation’s internal defense plan. With deep-water ports in close proximity to the storage caves, equipment can quickly be loaded aboard available shipping for operations in threatened parts of Europe, Africa or the Middle East. This capability was demonstrated by the supplying of equipment and ammunition in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom." [9]
U.S. Marines will be occupied "working in the Black Sea, Balkan and Caucasus regions" to "build enduring partnerships and build the capacity of partner nation’s military forces" until the end of July, by which time NATO's largest military offensive of the nearly nine-year-old Afghan war - the assault on Kandahar province - will be underway.
Shortly before the above-described war games began, U.S. Air Force personnel were deployed from the Ramstein Air Base in Germany to Romania for Operation Carpathian Summer 2010, an air force medical evacuation exercise. "Held at Otopeni Airfield, near Bucharest, Operation Carpathian Summer 2010 was designed to strengthen the partnership between the U.S. and Romanian air forces, while elevating their capability to work together.
"Though this is not the first time American airmen have worked with the Romanian air force, the 86th AES [Aeromedical Evacuation Squadron] has never before joined in the training with their Romanian colleagues." [10]
At the same time Romanian troops joined colleagues from the U.S., Britain, Belgium, Croatia, France, Germany, Hungary, Norway, Poland and Slovakia at the Joint Multinational Readiness Center in Hohenfels, Germany to engage in joint military training with soldiers from the Afghan National Army.
On May 19 the Stars and Stripes armed forces publication reported that "Rapid expansion of the Army's unmanned aircraft fleet has prompted the service to begin offering initial training in Europe, instead of sending troops to the U.S. to learn...." Among the drones that will be used for the training are the Extended-Range Multi-Purpose MQ-1C Warrior, "which can fly for more than 20 hours and launch air-to-ground missiles," and the RQ-11 Raven small class unmanned aerial vehicle used by the U.S. and NATO allies.
The news source added that "a course next month at Grafenwohr Training Area, will, for the first time, offer initial operator training on the Raven UAS [Unmanned Aircraft System] in Europe.
"The Army is looking at flying the Raven in Romania and possibly Bulgaria, and attempting to open a range in Italy for the 173rd Airborne Brigade's unmanned aircraft." [11]
From April 12-16 a U.S. Air Force team at the Aviano Air Base in Italy, "in an effort to improve an already established military relationship," provided aircraft maintenance training to the Bulgarian and Romanian air forces. [12]
On May 18 200 U.S. airmen and ten F-15 multi-role strike fighters spearheaded the launching of Operation Sentry Gold at the Graf Ignatievo Air Base in Bulgaria. "The exercise is designed to provide the U.S. Air Force and Bulgarian air force the opportunity to learn from each other and increase their respective NATO interoperability."
The American commander involved in the maneuvers emphasized that the Bulgarian air force still uses Russian MiG-21s and MiG-29s, saying: "We simulate fighting MiGs all the time. Being here allows us to really see them in action."
A Bulgarian officer said of the drills, "Sentry Gold increases the realism of our combat training. We get to see how a unit with a tested and proven combat history does things," and added, "Training together with [U.S. Air Forces in Europe] and the U.S. pilots moves us closer to NATO standards." [13]
As noted earlier, NATO chief Rasmussen arrived in the Bulgarian capital on May 20. Five days earlier the nation's defense minister, Anyu Angelov, affirmed that "We will file a request to join the common European missile shield during NATO Secretary-General Anders Fogh Rasmussen's visit to Sofia...." [14]
The Bulgarian defense chief also said that his ministry will allot funds to upgrade the nation's air defense system and that "Brussels has promised to co-finance the initiative, while NATO will allocate US $7.5 million to complete the construction of the Graf Ignatievo airbase." [15]
On the eastern shore of the Black Sea, senior Georgian military officials met with the permanent representatives of all 28 NATO member states at a sitting of the NATO-Georgia Commission (created the month after Georgia's war with Russia in 2008) on May 5. A week later NATO's South Caucasus liaison officer Zbigniew Ribatski announced that the military bloc will open a representative's office in Georgia this summer.
On May 14 the Georgian press reported the launching of a U.S.-funded military training simulation facility in the country: "The Simulation Training Center has been formed through the framework of US-Georgia cooperation. The United States, under the ongoing collaboration, donated the Center with the cutting-edge technical equipment and developed special training programs for it." [16] The inauguration was attended by new U.S. ambassador John Bass and NATO nations' military attaches.
Even Ukraine under its new president Viktor Yanukovich remains within NATO's Black Sea plans. The prohibition against the presence of foreign military forces for exercises in the nation, effected by the former opposition against Yanukovich's pro-U.S. predecessor Viktor Yushchenko, has been reversed, and U.S. and fellow NATO states' troops may resume Sea Breeze exercises on Ukraine's Black Sea coast.
The establishment of U.S. and NATO naval, air and infantry bases and interceptor missile installations in Black Sea nations is the prototype for expansive and permanent military build-ups in Eastern Europe and into former Soviet space, which is being replicated in the Baltic Sea region. An imaginary Iranian threat is the subterfuge employed to justify the presence of U.S. and NATO warplanes, warships, troops, mechanized and airborne units, missile batteries, training centers and radar facilities in the Black Sea and Baltic Sea regions.
Iran does not border either of the two seas and has neither the ability nor any reason to threaten nations that do.
Recent news reports from both sides of the Atlantic speak of a warming of relations between Russia and the United States, between Russia and NATO. If so, Russian political leaders won't have to extend their hands far to clasp those of their alleged Western friends and allies. They need merely reach across their southwestern and northwestern borders on the Black and Baltic Seas.
Rick Rozoff is a journalist and blogger and many of his articles may be found at the Stop NATO blog.
Notes:
1) HotNews.ro, May 12, 2010
2) Standart News, May 16, 2010
3) Sofia Echo, May 20, 2010
4) Focus News Agency, May 20, 2010
5) The Financiarul, May 14, 2010
6) Xinhua News Agency, May 13, 2010
7) United States European Command, May 17, 2010
8) Ibid
9) Marines.mil, May 12, 2010
10) U.S. European Command, May 14, 2010
11) Stars and Stripes, May 19, 2010
12) U.S. Air Forces in Europe, April 20, 2010
13) U.S. Air Forces in Europe, May 18, 2010
14) Standart News, May 15, 2010
15) Ibid
16) Georgia Ministry of Defence, May 14, 2010
Friday, May 21, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Austerity Measures Spark Mass Protests In Romania
One of the largest mass protests since the fall of Communism in 1989 hit Bucharest yesterday (19 May) after the government announced deep spending cuts, casting doubt over Romania's ability to meet its IMF loan commitments.
According to EurActiv Romania, between 30,000 and 50,000 protesters took to the centre of Bucharest, while the trade unions said a general strike would be called on 31 May.
Protesters called on the government to apply austerity measures in a differentiated manner, rather than spreading the burden across the entire population - including retired people - without taking account of low incomes.
Under pressure from the IMF, the government promised to slash state wages by 25% and pensions by 15% as part of efforts to secure the release of the next tranche of loans.
The leaders of the protests demanded the resignations of President Traian Basescu and Prime Minister Emil Boc.
In the meantime, Boc called on the country's administrative officials to donate remuneration gained from their membership boards of companies in which the state is a minority stakeholder. The money would go into a solidarity fund, he said, and those who refuse to donate would be dismissed.
Similarity with Greece?
Romanian daily Adevarul writes that the obvious question – is Romania following in the footsteps of bankrupt Greece? – is not easy to answer. Unlike Greece, whose main problem is public debt, Romania has one of the lowest public debts at only 24% of GDP and ranks 24th in the 27-member EU bloc.
Romania's problem, Adevarul continues, is its budget deficit, implying that the country's authorities had overspent.
"As an absolute figure, the public debt is not so worrying, but it should be seen in the context of its prospects of increasing and the macroeconomic situation," financial analyst Laurian Lungu of Macroanalitica is quoted as saying.
By 2012, public debt will have increased to 31-32% of GDP, presuming that the budget deficit evolves as expected. If not, public debt may increase much more dramatically, he warned.
Daniel Daianu, a centre-right EU lawmaker and former finance minister, said that Romania could not be compared to Greece, because the country did not rely as heavily on tourism revenue.
"We have a bigger and more diversified economic potential than Greece. We may have no islands, but we have a chemical industry, we have an automotive sector and an aeronautic one. We don't lack infrastructure and capacity to organise," he said.
Analysts quoted by Reuters say the government may end up bowing to public pressure and softening the planned cuts in a bid to preserve popularity for its shaky parliamentary majority, even though elections are not scheduled until late 2012.
"The ability of the government to deliver substantial cuts by July to meet the IMF's demands is low," BNP Paribas analysts said in a note.
"A failure to meet the performance criteria then and a second postponement of the IMF disbursement could be a significant blow."
Neighbouring Bulgaria, the EU's poorest member, is also trying to impose public spending cuts of about 20% to fill a revenue gap and keep its budget deficit under control.
Source: EurActiv
According to EurActiv Romania, between 30,000 and 50,000 protesters took to the centre of Bucharest, while the trade unions said a general strike would be called on 31 May.
Protesters called on the government to apply austerity measures in a differentiated manner, rather than spreading the burden across the entire population - including retired people - without taking account of low incomes.
Under pressure from the IMF, the government promised to slash state wages by 25% and pensions by 15% as part of efforts to secure the release of the next tranche of loans.
The leaders of the protests demanded the resignations of President Traian Basescu and Prime Minister Emil Boc.
In the meantime, Boc called on the country's administrative officials to donate remuneration gained from their membership boards of companies in which the state is a minority stakeholder. The money would go into a solidarity fund, he said, and those who refuse to donate would be dismissed.
Similarity with Greece?
Romanian daily Adevarul writes that the obvious question – is Romania following in the footsteps of bankrupt Greece? – is not easy to answer. Unlike Greece, whose main problem is public debt, Romania has one of the lowest public debts at only 24% of GDP and ranks 24th in the 27-member EU bloc.
Romania's problem, Adevarul continues, is its budget deficit, implying that the country's authorities had overspent.
"As an absolute figure, the public debt is not so worrying, but it should be seen in the context of its prospects of increasing and the macroeconomic situation," financial analyst Laurian Lungu of Macroanalitica is quoted as saying.
By 2012, public debt will have increased to 31-32% of GDP, presuming that the budget deficit evolves as expected. If not, public debt may increase much more dramatically, he warned.
Daniel Daianu, a centre-right EU lawmaker and former finance minister, said that Romania could not be compared to Greece, because the country did not rely as heavily on tourism revenue.
"We have a bigger and more diversified economic potential than Greece. We may have no islands, but we have a chemical industry, we have an automotive sector and an aeronautic one. We don't lack infrastructure and capacity to organise," he said.
Analysts quoted by Reuters say the government may end up bowing to public pressure and softening the planned cuts in a bid to preserve popularity for its shaky parliamentary majority, even though elections are not scheduled until late 2012.
"The ability of the government to deliver substantial cuts by July to meet the IMF's demands is low," BNP Paribas analysts said in a note.
"A failure to meet the performance criteria then and a second postponement of the IMF disbursement could be a significant blow."
Neighbouring Bulgaria, the EU's poorest member, is also trying to impose public spending cuts of about 20% to fill a revenue gap and keep its budget deficit under control.
Source: EurActiv
Thursday, May 20, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
EU Commission Gives Estonia Euro Green Light For 2011
Estonia was given the green light on Wednesday (12 May) to join the euro zone in 2011 and become its 17th member in what is likely to be the crisis-hit currency area's last enlargement for at least four years.
Despite the European Central Bank's doubts about how long Estonia can hold down inflation, the European Union's executive arm said the former Soviet republic of 1.4 million people was ready to adopt the euro, unlike other, bigger hopefuls such as the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland.
"Estonia has achieved a high degree of sustainable economic convergence and is ready to adopt the euro on 1 January 2011," EU Economic and Monetary Affairs Commissioner Olli Rehn said in a statement.
If, as expected, it is given the final go-ahead by EU finance ministers, the Baltic country will become the fifth state that joined the Union in 2004 to adopt the currency. Slovenia entered the euro zone in 2007, Cyprus and Malta did so in 2008, and Slovakia followed in 2009.
The Commission's decision could reassure other candidates that the euro zone remains open for expansion despite Greece's debt crisis, which has fuelled tension in the currency area and forced it to create a $1-trillion emergency aid mechanism for members facing solvency problems.
Indeed, the turmoil within the single currency area has dampened enthusiasm towards the euro among candidate members. Polish Finance Minister Jacek Rostowski said on Wednesday that Warsaw was in no hurry to join the single currency area, which he said needed time to "refurbish" itself after the Greek crisis.
A European Central Bank report said there were mixed signals on Estonia's readiness to adopt the euro due to question marks regarding the future sustainability of the country's convergence, notably concerning inflation.
Very low inflation in Estonia - which averaged -0.7% over the last 12 months, compared to the 1% benchmark -- was due to mainly temporary factors, it said.
"In sum, there are concerns regarding the sustainability of inflation convergence in Estonia," the ECB said.
Under EU law, the Commission's recommendations are binding. The ECB's are not.
Tough reforms rewarded
The Commission said that other euro candidates - Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Sweden - were not ready.
Either their inflation rates are too high, budget deficits too wide or most have not yet joined the ERM II currency system, a stability test for eurozone membership, it said.
"The nine member states with a so-called 'derogation' [to the euro] have made uneven progress on the road to the single currency," the Commission said.
A recent Reuters poll among economists, mirrored by a report by credit rating agency Fitch, said those countries were forecast to adopt the euro in 2014-2016 at the earliest.
The Commission's recommendation crowns reforms that have turned Estonia into one of the most open and liberal economies in the 27-nation EU and a darling of investors.
It rewards Estonia's austerity programme, which was implemented despite deep recession last year and has ensured the country's budget deficit is below 3% of gross domestic product - one criterion for joining the euro zone.
The country cut its deficit to 1.7% of GDP last year despite an economic contraction of nearly 15%. Estonia also has one of the smaller national debts in the EU - 7.2% of GDP.
The adoption of the euro is not expected to change much for Estonia's investors and its citizens, since the country has long kept its kroon currency fixed against the euro in a currency board. The exchange rate is expected to be kept during the currency changeover.
The Commission said Estonia, which accounts for a tiny fraction of the euro zone's 10-trillion-euro ($12,700-billion) economy, met all the entry criteria on inflation, interest rates, its budget deficit, public debt and currency stability.
Source: EurActiv
Despite the European Central Bank's doubts about how long Estonia can hold down inflation, the European Union's executive arm said the former Soviet republic of 1.4 million people was ready to adopt the euro, unlike other, bigger hopefuls such as the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland.
"Estonia has achieved a high degree of sustainable economic convergence and is ready to adopt the euro on 1 January 2011," EU Economic and Monetary Affairs Commissioner Olli Rehn said in a statement.
If, as expected, it is given the final go-ahead by EU finance ministers, the Baltic country will become the fifth state that joined the Union in 2004 to adopt the currency. Slovenia entered the euro zone in 2007, Cyprus and Malta did so in 2008, and Slovakia followed in 2009.
The Commission's decision could reassure other candidates that the euro zone remains open for expansion despite Greece's debt crisis, which has fuelled tension in the currency area and forced it to create a $1-trillion emergency aid mechanism for members facing solvency problems.
Indeed, the turmoil within the single currency area has dampened enthusiasm towards the euro among candidate members. Polish Finance Minister Jacek Rostowski said on Wednesday that Warsaw was in no hurry to join the single currency area, which he said needed time to "refurbish" itself after the Greek crisis.
A European Central Bank report said there were mixed signals on Estonia's readiness to adopt the euro due to question marks regarding the future sustainability of the country's convergence, notably concerning inflation.
Very low inflation in Estonia - which averaged -0.7% over the last 12 months, compared to the 1% benchmark -- was due to mainly temporary factors, it said.
"In sum, there are concerns regarding the sustainability of inflation convergence in Estonia," the ECB said.
Under EU law, the Commission's recommendations are binding. The ECB's are not.
Tough reforms rewarded
The Commission said that other euro candidates - Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Sweden - were not ready.
Either their inflation rates are too high, budget deficits too wide or most have not yet joined the ERM II currency system, a stability test for eurozone membership, it said.
"The nine member states with a so-called 'derogation' [to the euro] have made uneven progress on the road to the single currency," the Commission said.
A recent Reuters poll among economists, mirrored by a report by credit rating agency Fitch, said those countries were forecast to adopt the euro in 2014-2016 at the earliest.
The Commission's recommendation crowns reforms that have turned Estonia into one of the most open and liberal economies in the 27-nation EU and a darling of investors.
It rewards Estonia's austerity programme, which was implemented despite deep recession last year and has ensured the country's budget deficit is below 3% of gross domestic product - one criterion for joining the euro zone.
The country cut its deficit to 1.7% of GDP last year despite an economic contraction of nearly 15%. Estonia also has one of the smaller national debts in the EU - 7.2% of GDP.
The adoption of the euro is not expected to change much for Estonia's investors and its citizens, since the country has long kept its kroon currency fixed against the euro in a currency board. The exchange rate is expected to be kept during the currency changeover.
The Commission said Estonia, which accounts for a tiny fraction of the euro zone's 10-trillion-euro ($12,700-billion) economy, met all the entry criteria on inflation, interest rates, its budget deficit, public debt and currency stability.
Source: EurActiv
Thursday, May 13, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Pirate Threat Persists After Hijacked Tanker's Release
By Ilya Kramnik
On the night of May 6, 2010, commandos from the Marshal Shaposhnikov anti-submarine warfare (ASW) ship of the Russian Navy's Pacific Fleet, on an anti-piracy mission in the Gulf of Aden, stormed the Moscow University oil tanker that was seized yesterday by Somali pirates and released her 23 crewmembers.
The Russian tanker, owned by the Novorossiisk Shipping Company (Novoship), carrying 86,000 metric tons of crude oil, was hijacked by Somalian pirates in the morning of May 5, while sailing from the Red Sea to China.
The crew signaled that speedboats full of armed men were approaching their vessel. After that, communications with the tanker were lost. The crew, however, managed to barricade themselves inside one of the ship's below-deck sections, and switch off her propulsion unit and rudder control system.
The pirates declared they had captured the ship and warned that crewmembers' lives would be in danger if any attempt to board her were made. However, they were unable to reach the crew or reactivate the tanker's engines.
The Marshal Shaposhnikov covered over 300 nautical miles and was approaching the Moscow University. After assessing the situation, the officers learned that the tanker's crew was in a safe place, hiding, and that the pirates were unable to control the ship. They prepared to storm the tanker.
The ASW ship's marine unit has been specially trained and had conducted several hostage-release exercises in preparation for its current tour of duty. Consequently, the ship was seized quickly and without a hitch. The marines approached the tanker in speedboats and quickly disarmed the pirates, killing one of them. No soldiers or sailors were injured.
The Russian Prosecutor-General's Office has opened a criminal case under article 227 of the Criminal Code, which deals with piracy. The hapless "gentlemen of fortune" will be put on trial in Moscow.
This incident highlights the problem of legal support for anti-piracy operations and makes it possible to assess the effectiveness of the fight against pirates.
Under article 227 of the Russian Criminal Code, pirates may face up to 15 years in prison. The life of an inmate in a Russian prison camp is more comfortable than life in Somalia, in addition to which they are eligible for parole. There are also many pirates who want to serve their prison terms in EU countries, hoping that they will be allowed to stay there upon release.
Most curiously, the pirates would have faced tougher punishment if they were captured before the criminal case in Russia had been opened. In that case, they would likely have been extradited to Yemen, which summarily hangs all pirates caught prowling the sea, weapons in hand.
As a rule, Russian and foreign navies aim to prevent ships from being hijacked and their actions are seldom crowned with such an outstanding success involving the arrest of hijackers aboard the seized vessel as that of May 6. However, this remains a struggle against the symptoms of the disease, rather than the disease itself. Piracy is a very profitable business. These "gentlemen of fortune" continue to seize new ships and their crews, releasing them for ransom.
This situation stands in stark contrast to the global repercussions of the major volcanic events in April 2010 at the Eyjafjallajokull ice cap in southern Iceland. Air travel across western and northern Europe was disrputed for an initial period of six days. Although ash clouds did not pose an immediate danger, as many had feared, it caused all-out panic, with many European countries promptly banning all air traffic.
The reason for this ban is obvious: 90% of airline passengers flying over Europe are EU citizens, and their mass death in case of such evident force majeure circumstances is fraught with serious political consequences. Against this backdrop, European politicians care little about the threat of pirate attacks on the crews of merchant-marine ships, who are usually recruited from developing countries, the least prosperous European states, such as Greece or Romania, or even from major powers that are outside the EU including Ukraine, Russia and India.
At the same time, the scale of piracy has not yet reached frightening dimensions and business community remains unconcerned about it. As a result, the crews of civilian ships are escorted by relatively few warships, which are unable to effectively protect all shipping in the region. All they can do is use the theory of probability to try to predict possible attacks on specific freighters, container carriers or tankers.
This situation once again highlights the importance of cooperation between countries combating piracy on a tactical level off the Somali coast and at the level of official agencies. There has to be a standard set of regulations making it possible to fight piracy. The pirates' future should not depend on the national affiliation of warships seizing them.
One possible solution would be to pass an international code stipulating the punishment for the various crimes, the court proceedings and execution of verdicts. Once again, EU prisons are unlikely to scare Somalian pirates who will not face famine or possible death there, as they do in their home country torn apart by civil war.
But tougher penalties are not enough to achieve results. As has often been said, any successful anti-piracy struggle should be based on the normalization of the situation in war-torn Somalia, military operations against pirates in coastal areas and a strict crackdown on the financial infrastructure of crime rings profiting from piracy. Just as was the case centuries ago, piracy and aiding pirates must once again become a capital offense.
Unfortunately, Europe's modern mindset prevents EU countries from recalling their own anti-piracy efforts in the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries when captured pirates were either thrown overboard or tried by national courts and inevitably executed. Quite possibly, this situation could be rectified through cooperation between Russia, the United States, China and the Arab world, none of whom worship human life to the absurd extent of dismissing a justified penalty for grave crimes.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article was first published.
On the night of May 6, 2010, commandos from the Marshal Shaposhnikov anti-submarine warfare (ASW) ship of the Russian Navy's Pacific Fleet, on an anti-piracy mission in the Gulf of Aden, stormed the Moscow University oil tanker that was seized yesterday by Somali pirates and released her 23 crewmembers.
The Russian tanker, owned by the Novorossiisk Shipping Company (Novoship), carrying 86,000 metric tons of crude oil, was hijacked by Somalian pirates in the morning of May 5, while sailing from the Red Sea to China.
The crew signaled that speedboats full of armed men were approaching their vessel. After that, communications with the tanker were lost. The crew, however, managed to barricade themselves inside one of the ship's below-deck sections, and switch off her propulsion unit and rudder control system.
The pirates declared they had captured the ship and warned that crewmembers' lives would be in danger if any attempt to board her were made. However, they were unable to reach the crew or reactivate the tanker's engines.
The Marshal Shaposhnikov covered over 300 nautical miles and was approaching the Moscow University. After assessing the situation, the officers learned that the tanker's crew was in a safe place, hiding, and that the pirates were unable to control the ship. They prepared to storm the tanker.
The ASW ship's marine unit has been specially trained and had conducted several hostage-release exercises in preparation for its current tour of duty. Consequently, the ship was seized quickly and without a hitch. The marines approached the tanker in speedboats and quickly disarmed the pirates, killing one of them. No soldiers or sailors were injured.
The Russian Prosecutor-General's Office has opened a criminal case under article 227 of the Criminal Code, which deals with piracy. The hapless "gentlemen of fortune" will be put on trial in Moscow.
This incident highlights the problem of legal support for anti-piracy operations and makes it possible to assess the effectiveness of the fight against pirates.
Under article 227 of the Russian Criminal Code, pirates may face up to 15 years in prison. The life of an inmate in a Russian prison camp is more comfortable than life in Somalia, in addition to which they are eligible for parole. There are also many pirates who want to serve their prison terms in EU countries, hoping that they will be allowed to stay there upon release.
Most curiously, the pirates would have faced tougher punishment if they were captured before the criminal case in Russia had been opened. In that case, they would likely have been extradited to Yemen, which summarily hangs all pirates caught prowling the sea, weapons in hand.
As a rule, Russian and foreign navies aim to prevent ships from being hijacked and their actions are seldom crowned with such an outstanding success involving the arrest of hijackers aboard the seized vessel as that of May 6. However, this remains a struggle against the symptoms of the disease, rather than the disease itself. Piracy is a very profitable business. These "gentlemen of fortune" continue to seize new ships and their crews, releasing them for ransom.
This situation stands in stark contrast to the global repercussions of the major volcanic events in April 2010 at the Eyjafjallajokull ice cap in southern Iceland. Air travel across western and northern Europe was disrputed for an initial period of six days. Although ash clouds did not pose an immediate danger, as many had feared, it caused all-out panic, with many European countries promptly banning all air traffic.
The reason for this ban is obvious: 90% of airline passengers flying over Europe are EU citizens, and their mass death in case of such evident force majeure circumstances is fraught with serious political consequences. Against this backdrop, European politicians care little about the threat of pirate attacks on the crews of merchant-marine ships, who are usually recruited from developing countries, the least prosperous European states, such as Greece or Romania, or even from major powers that are outside the EU including Ukraine, Russia and India.
At the same time, the scale of piracy has not yet reached frightening dimensions and business community remains unconcerned about it. As a result, the crews of civilian ships are escorted by relatively few warships, which are unable to effectively protect all shipping in the region. All they can do is use the theory of probability to try to predict possible attacks on specific freighters, container carriers or tankers.
This situation once again highlights the importance of cooperation between countries combating piracy on a tactical level off the Somali coast and at the level of official agencies. There has to be a standard set of regulations making it possible to fight piracy. The pirates' future should not depend on the national affiliation of warships seizing them.
One possible solution would be to pass an international code stipulating the punishment for the various crimes, the court proceedings and execution of verdicts. Once again, EU prisons are unlikely to scare Somalian pirates who will not face famine or possible death there, as they do in their home country torn apart by civil war.
But tougher penalties are not enough to achieve results. As has often been said, any successful anti-piracy struggle should be based on the normalization of the situation in war-torn Somalia, military operations against pirates in coastal areas and a strict crackdown on the financial infrastructure of crime rings profiting from piracy. Just as was the case centuries ago, piracy and aiding pirates must once again become a capital offense.
Unfortunately, Europe's modern mindset prevents EU countries from recalling their own anti-piracy efforts in the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries when captured pirates were either thrown overboard or tried by national courts and inevitably executed. Quite possibly, this situation could be rectified through cooperation between Russia, the United States, China and the Arab world, none of whom worship human life to the absurd extent of dismissing a justified penalty for grave crimes.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author's and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article was first published.
Friday, May 07, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
NATO Secretary General Discusses NATO’s Future In Romania
NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen visited Romania on 6 and 7 May, where he met with President Traian Basescu, Foreign Minister Teodor Baconschi and other high-level Romanian officials, and gave a public address at the University of Bucharest.
At a joint press conference with President Basescu on 6 May, the Secretary General thanked Romania for its contribution to the NATO-led operation in Afghanistan, saying that it is “substantial, without caveats and with a growing focus on training”.
The two also discussed NATO’s new Strategic Concept, which will be agreed by Allies at the Lisbon Summit in November, and missile defence, which will figure prominently in discussions among Allies in the coming months. “I hope that in Lisbon we will decide that missile defence is an Alliance’s mission, by combining the US and the NATO systems. That will provide an efffective coverage to our populations,” Rasmussen said.
Speaking to the press on 7 of May with Foreign Minister Baconschi, the Secretary General mentioned their discussion on NATO's open door policy and the Balkans. "We share the view that the best recipe for lasting security and stability in the Balkans is integration of all countries of the region in the euroatlantic structures, into the EU and NATO", he said.
Later in the day, Mr Rasmussen gave a public speech at the University of Bucharest, School of Law, underlining the importance of NATO’s efforts in Afghanistan, and of addressing nuclear proliferation, energy security and cyber defence.
He spoke about the “unique solidarity between North American and European democracies” that has already proved its worth, for example, during the Cold War and the Balkan conflicts. Now, he said, Alliance solidarity is helping to bring stability to Afghanistan: “Together, we will protect the population and pull the rug from under the insurgency. We will then start to transfer additional security responsabilities to the Afghan forces themselves, district by district, province by province.”
On nuclear proliferation, the Secretary General stressed that the threat of proliferation is “real and growing” with more than 30 countries having or developing missile capabilities. “In many cases, these missiles could eventually threaten our populations and territories. And several countries are seeking nuclear weapons” – a deadly combination, he said. To address this threat, he said that Allies need to maintain an appropiate nuclear deterrent.
“Furthermore, we must take a fresh look at missile defence – not as a substitute for nuclear detterence, but as a complement to it”, the Secretary General said.
Mr Rasmussen also stressed the need for a better understanding of the implications of energy security. “NATO is a unique mechanism for collecting information from different sources… We have the means to protect critical energy infrastructure. We have experience in consequence management, for example when it comes to mitigating the effects of accidents,” he noted.
On cyber defence, the Secretary General said: “Nowhere is the need to act today rather than tomorrow more evident than in this area… In short, a cyber attack can bring a country down without a single soldier having to cross its borders.”
In closing, Mr Rasmussen spoke about the new Strategic Concept. In his view, the new Strategic Concept will reaffirm that “NATO’s core task was, continues to be and will remain territorial collective defence of our territories and populations”.
At the same time, he argued, NATO will also have to adapt to tackle the threats of the 21 century. “I am not going to prejudge the new Strategic Concept,” he said. “But I’ll make one point very clear: We cannot afford to put missile defence, energy security or cyber defence on the back burner. Because new challenges don’t wait until we feel ready to meet them.”
At a joint press conference with President Basescu on 6 May, the Secretary General thanked Romania for its contribution to the NATO-led operation in Afghanistan, saying that it is “substantial, without caveats and with a growing focus on training”.
The two also discussed NATO’s new Strategic Concept, which will be agreed by Allies at the Lisbon Summit in November, and missile defence, which will figure prominently in discussions among Allies in the coming months. “I hope that in Lisbon we will decide that missile defence is an Alliance’s mission, by combining the US and the NATO systems. That will provide an efffective coverage to our populations,” Rasmussen said.
Speaking to the press on 7 of May with Foreign Minister Baconschi, the Secretary General mentioned their discussion on NATO's open door policy and the Balkans. "We share the view that the best recipe for lasting security and stability in the Balkans is integration of all countries of the region in the euroatlantic structures, into the EU and NATO", he said.
Later in the day, Mr Rasmussen gave a public speech at the University of Bucharest, School of Law, underlining the importance of NATO’s efforts in Afghanistan, and of addressing nuclear proliferation, energy security and cyber defence.
He spoke about the “unique solidarity between North American and European democracies” that has already proved its worth, for example, during the Cold War and the Balkan conflicts. Now, he said, Alliance solidarity is helping to bring stability to Afghanistan: “Together, we will protect the population and pull the rug from under the insurgency. We will then start to transfer additional security responsabilities to the Afghan forces themselves, district by district, province by province.”
On nuclear proliferation, the Secretary General stressed that the threat of proliferation is “real and growing” with more than 30 countries having or developing missile capabilities. “In many cases, these missiles could eventually threaten our populations and territories. And several countries are seeking nuclear weapons” – a deadly combination, he said. To address this threat, he said that Allies need to maintain an appropiate nuclear deterrent.
“Furthermore, we must take a fresh look at missile defence – not as a substitute for nuclear detterence, but as a complement to it”, the Secretary General said.
Mr Rasmussen also stressed the need for a better understanding of the implications of energy security. “NATO is a unique mechanism for collecting information from different sources… We have the means to protect critical energy infrastructure. We have experience in consequence management, for example when it comes to mitigating the effects of accidents,” he noted.
On cyber defence, the Secretary General said: “Nowhere is the need to act today rather than tomorrow more evident than in this area… In short, a cyber attack can bring a country down without a single soldier having to cross its borders.”
In closing, Mr Rasmussen spoke about the new Strategic Concept. In his view, the new Strategic Concept will reaffirm that “NATO’s core task was, continues to be and will remain territorial collective defence of our territories and populations”.
At the same time, he argued, NATO will also have to adapt to tackle the threats of the 21 century. “I am not going to prejudge the new Strategic Concept,” he said. “But I’ll make one point very clear: We cannot afford to put missile defence, energy security or cyber defence on the back burner. Because new challenges don’t wait until we feel ready to meet them.”
Friday, May 07, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Georgia Pumped Up About LNG Project with Azerbaijan, Romania
By Nino Pasturia
It is being touted as a project that could beat the long-delayed Nabucco pipeline to the finish line. Even so, the recently unveiled Azerbaijan-Georgia-Romania Black Sea liquefied natural gas export route appears to be long on promises and short on financing.
Known as the Azerbaijan-Georgia-Romania Interconnection Project (AGRI), the project plans to supply roughly 6- to 8-billion cubic meters of liquefied Azerbaijani natural gas per year to Europe via Black Sea tankers. The project would circumvent both Russia and Turkey, two of the South Caucasus’ main energy transit corridors.
The gas would run via pipelines from Baku to the Georgian Black Sea port of Poti, where it would be liquefied. Tankers would then transport the gas to the Romanian Black Sea port of Constanta, where the LNG would be converted back into gas and shipped onward to Western Europe. Romania contains underground gas storage facilities and a network of pipelines to Bulgaria and Hungary.
A joint Georgian-Azerbaijani-Romanian company headquartered in Bucharest is expected to be set up within the next few months to complete a feasibility study for the project, Georgian Minister of Energy Aleksandr Khetaguri told EurasiaNet.org. If financing comes through, the project is scheduled to be gas-ready by 2013 or 2014, he said. An agreement on the project was inked by the three partners in Bucharest on April 13.
“AGRI may come true sooner than Nabucco if everything goes smoothly,” Khetaguri forecast optimistically. “It is a supplementary project to Nabucco to insure a diversified gas supply to the EU [European Union].”
Nabucco, which has an official launch date of 2014, has been plagued by a variety of unanswered questions, including an ongoing dispute between Azerbaijan and Turkey over transit fees for Azerbaijani gas. On April 27, Turkish Energy Minister Taner Yildiz was quoted as saying that the two sides had reached a tentative agreement about a transit fee. No details have been made public yet.
Other Nabucco partners, however, have expressed reservations. In a recent interview with the German newspaper Sueddeutsche Zeitung, European Energy Commissioner Guenther Oettinger projected that Nabucco may not come online until 2018 at the earliest. Oettinger later issued a statement expressing confidence that Nabucco will start work in 2014, and be at “full capacity” by 2018, various media outlets reported.
Nabucco is projected to carry about 30 billion cubic meters (bcm) of gas per year to Europe. But Khetaguri argues that more will be needed to meet European demand. “Any volume of gas that can be provided to Europe via alternative routes bypassing Russia is attractive to Europe,” Khetaguri said.
Plans for financing the project, and what amount of gas Georgia would take as a transit fee, remain unknown. Khetaguri estimated the project’s total cost at 4 billion - 6 billion euros, or about $5.3 billion - $8 billion.
“Nobody can say today who will be financing and constructing the terminals,” Khetaguri said. “This feasibility study will make clear how profitable the AGRI project is for investments and only then will the financing issue be settled. … It’s too early to talk of this today.”
Tbilisi-based independent energy analyst Liana Jervalidze characterized AGRI as a “win-win” proposition. It includes gas producer Azerbaijan, a country vitally interested in the EU market; the gas consumer itself, the EU, interested in diversifying its gas supplies; and a small transit country Georgia, that has no incentive to cause difficulties.
“Azerbaijan does not have a more stable partner than Georgia at the moment. It is too little, gas-deficient, depends on Azerbaijan and is interested in transiting as much gas as possible to enjoy additional volumes of gas as a transit fee,” said Jervalidze. That situation is the opposite for “Turkey, which ranks among the G-20, is a very powerful player with influence over Middle Eastern countries, and can dictate its rules of the game in transit policy.”
Khetaguri asserted that Romania would be a “guaranteed purchaser” for 8 bcm of AGRI gas. Romania’s energy-sector National Regulatory Authority reported natural gas consumption for 2009 stood at 13.2 bcm. Other Central European countries – Serbia, Greece, Bulgaria and Hungary – are expected to tap into the project, too, he said.
Poland and Croatia both have LNG terminal projects underway that Jervalidze predicted could spark additional interest in AGRI gas supplies.
While enthusiasm for AGRI is high in Georgia, some experts in Azerbaijan are more restrained in their analysis. Those outside of Georgia see geopolitics as a potential obstacle. “Nobody forgot the consequences of the Russian aggression in Georgia when the export of Azerbaijani oil and oil products across Georgia was paralyzed for approximately a month,” commented Ilham Shaban, head of the Center for Oil Research in Baku. “Therefore, top Azerbaijani officials are making very cautious statements about this project at the moment.”
The costs involved pose another potential problem, he said. Construction of the Poti terminal for liquefying Azerbaijani gas could cost at least 5 billion euros, or about $6.7 billion, Shaban estimated. Georgian Energy Minister Khetaguri did not dispute that estimate, but noted that construction of the Constanta terminal, which would convert the fluid back into gas, is expected to be much cheaper – roughly 1 billion euros (about $1.3 billion).
If the feasibility study shows that the project would “be commercially reasonable only if its productive capacity is based on at least 5 billion cubic meters [per year],” then questions will arise about finding sufficient consumers for the LNG and how much gas they would want to receive for covering any part of the Romanian terminal’s construction expenses, Shaban predicted.
“The Azerbaijani government is not going to subsidize this project. Commercial expenses must be met by companies,” Shaban said.
Nino Patsuria is a freelance reporter based in Tbilisi. Copyright (c) 2003 Open Society Institute. Reprinted with the permission of the Open Society Institute, 400 West 59th Street, New York, NY 10019 USA, www.EurasiaNet.org or www.soros.org.
It is being touted as a project that could beat the long-delayed Nabucco pipeline to the finish line. Even so, the recently unveiled Azerbaijan-Georgia-Romania Black Sea liquefied natural gas export route appears to be long on promises and short on financing.
Known as the Azerbaijan-Georgia-Romania Interconnection Project (AGRI), the project plans to supply roughly 6- to 8-billion cubic meters of liquefied Azerbaijani natural gas per year to Europe via Black Sea tankers. The project would circumvent both Russia and Turkey, two of the South Caucasus’ main energy transit corridors.
The gas would run via pipelines from Baku to the Georgian Black Sea port of Poti, where it would be liquefied. Tankers would then transport the gas to the Romanian Black Sea port of Constanta, where the LNG would be converted back into gas and shipped onward to Western Europe. Romania contains underground gas storage facilities and a network of pipelines to Bulgaria and Hungary.
A joint Georgian-Azerbaijani-Romanian company headquartered in Bucharest is expected to be set up within the next few months to complete a feasibility study for the project, Georgian Minister of Energy Aleksandr Khetaguri told EurasiaNet.org. If financing comes through, the project is scheduled to be gas-ready by 2013 or 2014, he said. An agreement on the project was inked by the three partners in Bucharest on April 13.
“AGRI may come true sooner than Nabucco if everything goes smoothly,” Khetaguri forecast optimistically. “It is a supplementary project to Nabucco to insure a diversified gas supply to the EU [European Union].”
Nabucco, which has an official launch date of 2014, has been plagued by a variety of unanswered questions, including an ongoing dispute between Azerbaijan and Turkey over transit fees for Azerbaijani gas. On April 27, Turkish Energy Minister Taner Yildiz was quoted as saying that the two sides had reached a tentative agreement about a transit fee. No details have been made public yet.
Other Nabucco partners, however, have expressed reservations. In a recent interview with the German newspaper Sueddeutsche Zeitung, European Energy Commissioner Guenther Oettinger projected that Nabucco may not come online until 2018 at the earliest. Oettinger later issued a statement expressing confidence that Nabucco will start work in 2014, and be at “full capacity” by 2018, various media outlets reported.
Nabucco is projected to carry about 30 billion cubic meters (bcm) of gas per year to Europe. But Khetaguri argues that more will be needed to meet European demand. “Any volume of gas that can be provided to Europe via alternative routes bypassing Russia is attractive to Europe,” Khetaguri said.
Plans for financing the project, and what amount of gas Georgia would take as a transit fee, remain unknown. Khetaguri estimated the project’s total cost at 4 billion - 6 billion euros, or about $5.3 billion - $8 billion.
“Nobody can say today who will be financing and constructing the terminals,” Khetaguri said. “This feasibility study will make clear how profitable the AGRI project is for investments and only then will the financing issue be settled. … It’s too early to talk of this today.”
Tbilisi-based independent energy analyst Liana Jervalidze characterized AGRI as a “win-win” proposition. It includes gas producer Azerbaijan, a country vitally interested in the EU market; the gas consumer itself, the EU, interested in diversifying its gas supplies; and a small transit country Georgia, that has no incentive to cause difficulties.
“Azerbaijan does not have a more stable partner than Georgia at the moment. It is too little, gas-deficient, depends on Azerbaijan and is interested in transiting as much gas as possible to enjoy additional volumes of gas as a transit fee,” said Jervalidze. That situation is the opposite for “Turkey, which ranks among the G-20, is a very powerful player with influence over Middle Eastern countries, and can dictate its rules of the game in transit policy.”
Khetaguri asserted that Romania would be a “guaranteed purchaser” for 8 bcm of AGRI gas. Romania’s energy-sector National Regulatory Authority reported natural gas consumption for 2009 stood at 13.2 bcm. Other Central European countries – Serbia, Greece, Bulgaria and Hungary – are expected to tap into the project, too, he said.
Poland and Croatia both have LNG terminal projects underway that Jervalidze predicted could spark additional interest in AGRI gas supplies.
While enthusiasm for AGRI is high in Georgia, some experts in Azerbaijan are more restrained in their analysis. Those outside of Georgia see geopolitics as a potential obstacle. “Nobody forgot the consequences of the Russian aggression in Georgia when the export of Azerbaijani oil and oil products across Georgia was paralyzed for approximately a month,” commented Ilham Shaban, head of the Center for Oil Research in Baku. “Therefore, top Azerbaijani officials are making very cautious statements about this project at the moment.”
The costs involved pose another potential problem, he said. Construction of the Poti terminal for liquefying Azerbaijani gas could cost at least 5 billion euros, or about $6.7 billion, Shaban estimated. Georgian Energy Minister Khetaguri did not dispute that estimate, but noted that construction of the Constanta terminal, which would convert the fluid back into gas, is expected to be much cheaper – roughly 1 billion euros (about $1.3 billion).
If the feasibility study shows that the project would “be commercially reasonable only if its productive capacity is based on at least 5 billion cubic meters [per year],” then questions will arise about finding sufficient consumers for the LNG and how much gas they would want to receive for covering any part of the Romanian terminal’s construction expenses, Shaban predicted.
“The Azerbaijani government is not going to subsidize this project. Commercial expenses must be met by companies,” Shaban said.
Nino Patsuria is a freelance reporter based in Tbilisi. Copyright (c) 2003 Open Society Institute. Reprinted with the permission of the Open Society Institute, 400 West 59th Street, New York, NY 10019 USA, www.EurasiaNet.org or www.soros.org.
Wednesday, May 05, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
South Stream Pipeline Will Pass Through Romania
By Marian Chirac
(BIRN) -- After years of opposing the project, Romania is now ready to join the Russian-backed South Stream gas transit pipeline, officials in Bucharest said.
"We have been able to start a dialogue, including with Russia. South Stream will pass through Romania," the country's Economy Minister Adriean Videanu said during an on-line interview Thursday with local media.
He didn't want to further elaborate.
Early this year, Russian gas giant Gazprom invited Romanian state-run gas pipeline operator Transgaz to join the South Stream.
Romanian authorities, who in recent years have expressed their reluctance to take part in the project, have not commented further on the proposal, but local analysts said that Romania is interested in participating in the
pipeline.
The South Stream pipeline is mainly backed by Russia, which will supply gas from Russia’s Black Sea coast through Bulgaria and Serbia to Hungary, Italy and Greece.
Romania has been a strong supporter of Gazprom's direct competitor, the Nabucco project, which aims to reduce European reliance on Russian gas by providing access to supplies from Azerbaijan and other central Asian countries.
The projected Nabucco route runs through Turkey, Bulgaria, Romania and Hungary to its final destination in Austria.
(BIRN) -- After years of opposing the project, Romania is now ready to join the Russian-backed South Stream gas transit pipeline, officials in Bucharest said.
"We have been able to start a dialogue, including with Russia. South Stream will pass through Romania," the country's Economy Minister Adriean Videanu said during an on-line interview Thursday with local media.
He didn't want to further elaborate.
Early this year, Russian gas giant Gazprom invited Romanian state-run gas pipeline operator Transgaz to join the South Stream.
Romanian authorities, who in recent years have expressed their reluctance to take part in the project, have not commented further on the proposal, but local analysts said that Romania is interested in participating in the
pipeline.
The South Stream pipeline is mainly backed by Russia, which will supply gas from Russia’s Black Sea coast through Bulgaria and Serbia to Hungary, Italy and Greece.
Romania has been a strong supporter of Gazprom's direct competitor, the Nabucco project, which aims to reduce European reliance on Russian gas by providing access to supplies from Azerbaijan and other central Asian countries.
The projected Nabucco route runs through Turkey, Bulgaria, Romania and Hungary to its final destination in Austria.
Saturday, April 24, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
EU Growth Returns, But Credit Crunch Lingers
Europe may be slowly emerging from the deepest recession in decades but businesses continue to struggle to access finance. EurActiv's network asks whether the credit crunch is ending and what governments across the EU are doing to help.
While GDP is back in positive territory and industrial production is up, according to Eurostat, small firms complain that banks remain over cautious.
The issue has crept steadily up the political agenda, not least because bank bailouts mean governments have nationalised, or taken a stake in, several financial institutions. Banks, keen to restore order to their balance sheets, have been resisting pressure to lend for political rather than commercial reasons.
Governments have appointed "public interest" directors to the boards of state-supported banks and appointed appeals bodies to referee disputes between lenders and companies who believe they have been unfairly refused access to finance.
UK
In the UK, where economic issues have dominated the election debate, getting credit to small businesses has been a feature of party manifestos.
Gordon Brown's incumbent Labour Party is promising a £4 billion Growth Capital Fund, which will provide capital injections of between £2 million and £10 million for small firms. Labour also promises to create a new Small Business Credit Adjudicator with statutory powers, ensuring that SMEs are not turned down unfairly when applying to banks for finance.
The Conservative Party, led by David Cameron, makes the availability of credit one of its "benchmarks for Britain". They want more diverse sources of affordable credit for small buisneses, and are proposing a loan guarantee scheme.
Nick Clegg's Liberal Democrats promise to break up banks and build up diverse local and regional sources of business finance, as part of a plan to ensure the economy is "never again destabilised by high-risk financial industries".
The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) has launched its own election policy wish-list, urging politicians to prioritise access to finance in order to sustain the recovery. The cost of loans and overdrafts remains too high, says the FSB, and it wants more competition in the marketplace through the establishment of a Post Bank and better use of state-owned banks.
"The future health of our economy depends on restoring the trust of small businesses in the banks. Promoting and emboldening the Financial Intermediary Service would help," says the business organisation.
Germany
In Germany, the government has appointed an SME credit mediator, Hans-Joachim Metternich, to help small firms get credit during the economic crisis. He says that although figures from the German government show there is no nationwide credit crunch, firms could still be facing liquidity problems in the near future.
The overall volume loans granted has been shrinking in recent months, according to Metternich.
"It's too soon to say whether this is mainly due to the economic crisis and postponed investment activities or signals that companies are increasingly having problems getting money despite an increase in orders received. However, SMEs in particular are already suffering from tougher credit criteria put in place by financial institutions," he said.
He said the role of the credit mediator will pool expert knowledge to ensure that all public support schemes are adequately considered.
The KfW Banking Group, a public bank which grants credit to SMEs, said the credit problems have not yet passed.
"In our view, such a danger is not averted. Due to the crisis the internal financing abilities of companies are limited. When the economy revives, as expected, increasingly more capital is needed," the bank said.
When the crisis first broke, large German companies were feeling the pinch, but now it is mainly small businesses that have difficulty getting credit. KfW says export industries have been hit by worsening conditions.
France
In France, small companies struggled to access credit in the months after the crisis hit Europe, but the situation has slowly improved (EurActiv 22/07/09).
The results of a bank lending survey in relation to credit data, published in January 2010 by the Banque de France, revealed that banks' conditions for credit in France were slightly more flexible in the last quarter of 2009, particularly for SMEs.
The current slowdown in lending in France seems to be due to a combination of a tightening of credit supply and a fall in demand. The European Investment Bank (EIB) has earmarked €30 billion for SMEs between 2008 and 2011 and last year already granted €13 billion.
Of this, €950 million was distributed to French companies through commercial banks. Crédit Coopératif lent €150 million for SME projects. Banque Fédérale des Banques Populaires provided loans of €100 million. BNP Paribas provided credit worth €400 million, while Crédit Agricole gave loans of €300 million for small businesses.
Slovakia
While the Slovak banking system was relatively healthy when the credit crunch struck, the Slovak government decided to strengthen access to finance for entrepreneurs as a part of its anti-crisis measures.
Almost €33 million has been provided to increase the capital base of the Slovak Guarantee and Development Bank (Slovenská Záručná a Rozvojová banka; SZRB), which provides specialist support for SMEs.
In addition, the EIB approved a credit line of €50 million to the SZRB, which will be used to support SMEs investing in several sectors, especially industry and services. A further €11.5 million has been made available to Eximbank, to strengthen loans to exporting SMEs, and €5 million has been earmarked to support between 500 and 750 entrepreneurs through a 'micro loan' programme.
The National Bank of Slovakia (Národná banka Slovenska; NBS) in its response to the financial crisis decided to tighten liquidity requirements for banks. During the last quarter of 2008 and at the beginning of 2009, a decrease in lending, especially of working capital, was recorded.
In January 2009 the stagnation of new operating loans and a decrease in new investment loans were recorded due to low demand, resulting from unpredictable economic developments and stricter credit conditions faced by banks.
"The behaviour of the banks was and still is very cautious. When they expect a possible worsening of the economic and financial situation for Slovak firms, they tighten credit standards to avoid credit defaults," Jozef Hudák, director of the Business Environment Department at the Ministry of the Economy says.
He also stressed that negative market conditions have arisen due to economic development and entrepreneurs' reluctance to run up debts during a time of uncertainty.
In Slovakia, the volume of enterprise and household loans began to rise in the second half of last year, but fell again in the final quarter of 2009.
Similar trends were recorded in January 2010, when lending fell compared to a month-on-month and year-on-year basis. The volume of operating loans was still declining, but the volume of investing loans and property loans was increasing.
"In 2009 the overall loan volume of lending for SMEs decreased, because firms were cancelling or postponing their investment plans due to recession and that led to lower investment loan demand. On the other hand we recorded an increase in the field of operating financing, especially in overdrafts. Enterprises used these loans to compensate for late payments from their customers and business partners," Alena Walterová, spokesperson for VÚB bank, a member of Intesa Sanpaolo Group, told EurActiv.sk.
Czech Republic
Almost half of Czech companies (46%) claim that their access to finance has worsened since six months ago, the latest survey from the Czech Chamber of Commerce (CCC) revealed.
"In June 2009 it was 55% of companies, which means that the situation is still deteriorating although not as quickly as six months ago," CCC President Petr Kužel states. "Therefore we started talks with domestic banks again," he adds.
On the contrary, 27% of survey participants reported better access to bank loans, while 16% have not observed any changes (the rest answered 'I don't know'). According to 62% of companies, banks are more demanding when discussing loan terms.
"The CCC survey has shown nothing new. This topic is debated all the time. Companies complain about access to credit even in an economic boom," said Karel Havlíček, vice-chairman of the Czech Association of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises. "Of course, the banks are more vigilant in times of crisis," he added.
Havlíček complained that nowadays banks usually demand as much as 40% participation by firms in an investment (banks are not willing to cover more than 60% of the investment costs with loans).
Havlíček doubts that talks with the banks (led by the CCC) will yield any results. "Banks manage their risks on the base of internal guidelines usually set by their foreign owners," he explains.
Ireland
The Irish government has nationalised the troubled Anglo Irish Bank and recapitalised Bank of Ireland and Allied Irish Bank, but SMEs continue to complain about access to credit. A Credit Review Office has also been established and can intervene where viable businesses are denied access to credit.
A survey by accounting firm Mazars shows one in five small businesses are not getting enough credit, despite a commitment by the country's two biggest banks – BOI and AIB – to make €3 billion available in loans.
The Small Firms Association wants to see direct government intervention to force banks to lend. SFA Director Patricia Callan said the Mazars survey echoes the Association's own research, which shows a decrease in the availability of working capital. The cost of finance is also increasing, according to a sizeable proportion of SMEs.
"The recently established Credit Review Office is critical to establishing whether the bank refusal rate is reasonable or otherwise, and should make the next Mazars report more useful in its commentary," Callan said.
She said small businesses are failing not because they have run out of customers, ideas or products, but because they have run out of money.
Romania
Access to finance has not improved in recent months in Romania, entrepreneurs say. The situation is similar both for bank loans and for EU funding opportunities.
Several businesspeople from the National Council for SMEs in Romania, a professional association, told EurActiv.ro that there is no change in the banks' attitude. "The banks are not open to providing loans for SMEs," they said. The entrepreneurs think that the government should help companies to get loans and find a solution together with the banks.
"Even if the situation on the market has calmed down and the Central Bank offered a strong signal by reducing the interest rate from 10.25% to 6.5% in only a few months, the banks are moving slowly and are still not rushing to provide facilities for SMEs' financing," said Alexandra Popa of financial news portal Conso.ro.
"Besides a small decrease in interest rates and two new loan products, the SMEs affected by the economic crisis have little chance of finding finance opportunities. The commercial banks that provide some loans use mostly EBRD [European Bank for Reconstruction and Development] and EIB financing targeting priority economic areas. Still, the state-owned banks claim to be focusing on companies in 2010," said the Conso.ro expert.
Popa noted that banks prefer to attract clients by offering promotions and reducing fees for current accounts. "Smaller fees, free management, cheaper transactions: all of these are part of the banks' strategy to attract companies' savings," she said.
The situation is bleak for SMEs that wish to access EU funds. Those who submit projects to the authorities must wait for 6-7 months, in some cases, to find out if they were selected for finance. Then, if they manage to find the financial resources to start their projects, they wait a further one or two months for payment.
The Ministry of Finance and the Managing Authorities for structural funds have started to meet regularly to find solutions for giving loans to entrepreneurs that were selected in European programmes. But it seems that no solution will be found for a few months at least.
Another communication initiative is expected from the banks and targets entrepreneurs: the president of the national bankers' association, Radu Ghetea, promised recently at a public conference to publish a list of principles and conditions that banks must follow when analysing a loan request.
Source: EurActiv
While GDP is back in positive territory and industrial production is up, according to Eurostat, small firms complain that banks remain over cautious.
The issue has crept steadily up the political agenda, not least because bank bailouts mean governments have nationalised, or taken a stake in, several financial institutions. Banks, keen to restore order to their balance sheets, have been resisting pressure to lend for political rather than commercial reasons.
Governments have appointed "public interest" directors to the boards of state-supported banks and appointed appeals bodies to referee disputes between lenders and companies who believe they have been unfairly refused access to finance.
UK
In the UK, where economic issues have dominated the election debate, getting credit to small businesses has been a feature of party manifestos.
Gordon Brown's incumbent Labour Party is promising a £4 billion Growth Capital Fund, which will provide capital injections of between £2 million and £10 million for small firms. Labour also promises to create a new Small Business Credit Adjudicator with statutory powers, ensuring that SMEs are not turned down unfairly when applying to banks for finance.
The Conservative Party, led by David Cameron, makes the availability of credit one of its "benchmarks for Britain". They want more diverse sources of affordable credit for small buisneses, and are proposing a loan guarantee scheme.
Nick Clegg's Liberal Democrats promise to break up banks and build up diverse local and regional sources of business finance, as part of a plan to ensure the economy is "never again destabilised by high-risk financial industries".
The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) has launched its own election policy wish-list, urging politicians to prioritise access to finance in order to sustain the recovery. The cost of loans and overdrafts remains too high, says the FSB, and it wants more competition in the marketplace through the establishment of a Post Bank and better use of state-owned banks.
"The future health of our economy depends on restoring the trust of small businesses in the banks. Promoting and emboldening the Financial Intermediary Service would help," says the business organisation.
Germany
In Germany, the government has appointed an SME credit mediator, Hans-Joachim Metternich, to help small firms get credit during the economic crisis. He says that although figures from the German government show there is no nationwide credit crunch, firms could still be facing liquidity problems in the near future.
The overall volume loans granted has been shrinking in recent months, according to Metternich.
"It's too soon to say whether this is mainly due to the economic crisis and postponed investment activities or signals that companies are increasingly having problems getting money despite an increase in orders received. However, SMEs in particular are already suffering from tougher credit criteria put in place by financial institutions," he said.
He said the role of the credit mediator will pool expert knowledge to ensure that all public support schemes are adequately considered.
The KfW Banking Group, a public bank which grants credit to SMEs, said the credit problems have not yet passed.
"In our view, such a danger is not averted. Due to the crisis the internal financing abilities of companies are limited. When the economy revives, as expected, increasingly more capital is needed," the bank said.
When the crisis first broke, large German companies were feeling the pinch, but now it is mainly small businesses that have difficulty getting credit. KfW says export industries have been hit by worsening conditions.
France
In France, small companies struggled to access credit in the months after the crisis hit Europe, but the situation has slowly improved (EurActiv 22/07/09).
The results of a bank lending survey in relation to credit data, published in January 2010 by the Banque de France, revealed that banks' conditions for credit in France were slightly more flexible in the last quarter of 2009, particularly for SMEs.
The current slowdown in lending in France seems to be due to a combination of a tightening of credit supply and a fall in demand. The European Investment Bank (EIB) has earmarked €30 billion for SMEs between 2008 and 2011 and last year already granted €13 billion.
Of this, €950 million was distributed to French companies through commercial banks. Crédit Coopératif lent €150 million for SME projects. Banque Fédérale des Banques Populaires provided loans of €100 million. BNP Paribas provided credit worth €400 million, while Crédit Agricole gave loans of €300 million for small businesses.
Slovakia
While the Slovak banking system was relatively healthy when the credit crunch struck, the Slovak government decided to strengthen access to finance for entrepreneurs as a part of its anti-crisis measures.
Almost €33 million has been provided to increase the capital base of the Slovak Guarantee and Development Bank (Slovenská Záručná a Rozvojová banka; SZRB), which provides specialist support for SMEs.
In addition, the EIB approved a credit line of €50 million to the SZRB, which will be used to support SMEs investing in several sectors, especially industry and services. A further €11.5 million has been made available to Eximbank, to strengthen loans to exporting SMEs, and €5 million has been earmarked to support between 500 and 750 entrepreneurs through a 'micro loan' programme.
The National Bank of Slovakia (Národná banka Slovenska; NBS) in its response to the financial crisis decided to tighten liquidity requirements for banks. During the last quarter of 2008 and at the beginning of 2009, a decrease in lending, especially of working capital, was recorded.
In January 2009 the stagnation of new operating loans and a decrease in new investment loans were recorded due to low demand, resulting from unpredictable economic developments and stricter credit conditions faced by banks.
"The behaviour of the banks was and still is very cautious. When they expect a possible worsening of the economic and financial situation for Slovak firms, they tighten credit standards to avoid credit defaults," Jozef Hudák, director of the Business Environment Department at the Ministry of the Economy says.
He also stressed that negative market conditions have arisen due to economic development and entrepreneurs' reluctance to run up debts during a time of uncertainty.
In Slovakia, the volume of enterprise and household loans began to rise in the second half of last year, but fell again in the final quarter of 2009.
Similar trends were recorded in January 2010, when lending fell compared to a month-on-month and year-on-year basis. The volume of operating loans was still declining, but the volume of investing loans and property loans was increasing.
"In 2009 the overall loan volume of lending for SMEs decreased, because firms were cancelling or postponing their investment plans due to recession and that led to lower investment loan demand. On the other hand we recorded an increase in the field of operating financing, especially in overdrafts. Enterprises used these loans to compensate for late payments from their customers and business partners," Alena Walterová, spokesperson for VÚB bank, a member of Intesa Sanpaolo Group, told EurActiv.sk.
Czech Republic
Almost half of Czech companies (46%) claim that their access to finance has worsened since six months ago, the latest survey from the Czech Chamber of Commerce (CCC) revealed.
"In June 2009 it was 55% of companies, which means that the situation is still deteriorating although not as quickly as six months ago," CCC President Petr Kužel states. "Therefore we started talks with domestic banks again," he adds.
On the contrary, 27% of survey participants reported better access to bank loans, while 16% have not observed any changes (the rest answered 'I don't know'). According to 62% of companies, banks are more demanding when discussing loan terms.
"The CCC survey has shown nothing new. This topic is debated all the time. Companies complain about access to credit even in an economic boom," said Karel Havlíček, vice-chairman of the Czech Association of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises. "Of course, the banks are more vigilant in times of crisis," he added.
Havlíček complained that nowadays banks usually demand as much as 40% participation by firms in an investment (banks are not willing to cover more than 60% of the investment costs with loans).
Havlíček doubts that talks with the banks (led by the CCC) will yield any results. "Banks manage their risks on the base of internal guidelines usually set by their foreign owners," he explains.
Ireland
The Irish government has nationalised the troubled Anglo Irish Bank and recapitalised Bank of Ireland and Allied Irish Bank, but SMEs continue to complain about access to credit. A Credit Review Office has also been established and can intervene where viable businesses are denied access to credit.
A survey by accounting firm Mazars shows one in five small businesses are not getting enough credit, despite a commitment by the country's two biggest banks – BOI and AIB – to make €3 billion available in loans.
The Small Firms Association wants to see direct government intervention to force banks to lend. SFA Director Patricia Callan said the Mazars survey echoes the Association's own research, which shows a decrease in the availability of working capital. The cost of finance is also increasing, according to a sizeable proportion of SMEs.
"The recently established Credit Review Office is critical to establishing whether the bank refusal rate is reasonable or otherwise, and should make the next Mazars report more useful in its commentary," Callan said.
She said small businesses are failing not because they have run out of customers, ideas or products, but because they have run out of money.
Romania
Access to finance has not improved in recent months in Romania, entrepreneurs say. The situation is similar both for bank loans and for EU funding opportunities.
Several businesspeople from the National Council for SMEs in Romania, a professional association, told EurActiv.ro that there is no change in the banks' attitude. "The banks are not open to providing loans for SMEs," they said. The entrepreneurs think that the government should help companies to get loans and find a solution together with the banks.
"Even if the situation on the market has calmed down and the Central Bank offered a strong signal by reducing the interest rate from 10.25% to 6.5% in only a few months, the banks are moving slowly and are still not rushing to provide facilities for SMEs' financing," said Alexandra Popa of financial news portal Conso.ro.
"Besides a small decrease in interest rates and two new loan products, the SMEs affected by the economic crisis have little chance of finding finance opportunities. The commercial banks that provide some loans use mostly EBRD [European Bank for Reconstruction and Development] and EIB financing targeting priority economic areas. Still, the state-owned banks claim to be focusing on companies in 2010," said the Conso.ro expert.
Popa noted that banks prefer to attract clients by offering promotions and reducing fees for current accounts. "Smaller fees, free management, cheaper transactions: all of these are part of the banks' strategy to attract companies' savings," she said.
The situation is bleak for SMEs that wish to access EU funds. Those who submit projects to the authorities must wait for 6-7 months, in some cases, to find out if they were selected for finance. Then, if they manage to find the financial resources to start their projects, they wait a further one or two months for payment.
The Ministry of Finance and the Managing Authorities for structural funds have started to meet regularly to find solutions for giving loans to entrepreneurs that were selected in European programmes. But it seems that no solution will be found for a few months at least.
Another communication initiative is expected from the banks and targets entrepreneurs: the president of the national bankers' association, Radu Ghetea, promised recently at a public conference to publish a list of principles and conditions that banks must follow when analysing a loan request.
Source: EurActiv
Friday, April 23, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Balkan Airports Reopen After Volcanic Ash Disruption
(BIRN) -- Most airports in the Western Balkans reopened on Sunday and Monday as the cloud of ash from a volcano in Iceland caused major disruption throughout European airspace, while some travelers from the region faced serious difficulties as they tried to make their way home.
Dozens of flights scheduled through the weekend were cancelled at airports in the region, but airspace throughout Southeast Europe began to open again on Sunday afternoon. Flights to Western Europe, however, continue to be affected by the cloud of volcanic ash.
The ash has been present in European airspace ever since the Eyjafjallajoekull volcano in Iceland began erupting last Wednesday. Flights have been banned over fear that the fine dust particles could cause aircraft engines to seize or stall.
In a statement on Monday the authorities at Tirana’s Mother Theresa International Airport announced that they were operating flight only for Athens, Istanbul, Rome and Bari, while all other destinations in Western Europe were cancelled.
An Albanian state delegation led by the country's Prime Minister, Sali Berisha, which had been left stranded in Belgium since Thursday after the country closed its airspace, arrived on Sunday evening following a trip by rail and car throughout Europe.
Berisha’s motorcade arrived at 9 pm at Murriqan border crossing with Montenegro, after first having stopped in Germany and Austria.
In Bosnia and Herzegovina, Sarajevo International Airport opened this morning for flights to and from the region, and during the day for flights to and from Istanbul, Budapest and Vienna.
Sarajevo-x web portal published a story about Aida Sosic and Amel Ugarak from Bugojno, who left for Iceland before the volcano erupted for a theatre festival in Rejkjavik. Since all flights from Iceland to western Europe have been canceled, they have had to prolong their stay in Iceland's capital.
"We managed to find some people from Bosnia and they helped us. But, there is no Bosnian embassy here and the nearest ones are in Norway, Sweden and Denmark. The problem for us is that our visa will expire soon, and we cannot reach anybody in any of our embassies," Aida said in an email to Sarajevo-x.
All Croatian airports, with the exception of the airport in Osijek, were re-opened by 3pm Sunday.
The Croatian national aviation authority said in a statement that following the latest weather reports it decided to re-open Croatia's airspace, except for the northern and eastern areas.
The Croatian national aviation authority will continue following weather reports and developments in European airspace before making any new decisions, daily T portal reported.
Serbian airspace was also reopened on Sunday, and departures and arrivals were restarting after the closure of the airspace and the country's main airport in Belgrade, according to broadcaster B92.
Macedonia was one of the few countries in Europe that was not forced to close its airspace because of the volcanic ash, but most airports remained inactive as flights to and from the country were canceled due to the closure of airspace in other parts of Europe.
Bulgaria, which reopened most of its airports on Monday, faced a similar situation, with most flights to and from Western Europe being canceled. Neighbouring Romania began to reopen its airspace on Monday to transiting flights, hotnews.ro reported.
Source: BalkanInsight.com (BIRN)
Dozens of flights scheduled through the weekend were cancelled at airports in the region, but airspace throughout Southeast Europe began to open again on Sunday afternoon. Flights to Western Europe, however, continue to be affected by the cloud of volcanic ash.
The ash has been present in European airspace ever since the Eyjafjallajoekull volcano in Iceland began erupting last Wednesday. Flights have been banned over fear that the fine dust particles could cause aircraft engines to seize or stall.
In a statement on Monday the authorities at Tirana’s Mother Theresa International Airport announced that they were operating flight only for Athens, Istanbul, Rome and Bari, while all other destinations in Western Europe were cancelled.
An Albanian state delegation led by the country's Prime Minister, Sali Berisha, which had been left stranded in Belgium since Thursday after the country closed its airspace, arrived on Sunday evening following a trip by rail and car throughout Europe.
Berisha’s motorcade arrived at 9 pm at Murriqan border crossing with Montenegro, after first having stopped in Germany and Austria.
In Bosnia and Herzegovina, Sarajevo International Airport opened this morning for flights to and from the region, and during the day for flights to and from Istanbul, Budapest and Vienna.
Sarajevo-x web portal published a story about Aida Sosic and Amel Ugarak from Bugojno, who left for Iceland before the volcano erupted for a theatre festival in Rejkjavik. Since all flights from Iceland to western Europe have been canceled, they have had to prolong their stay in Iceland's capital.
"We managed to find some people from Bosnia and they helped us. But, there is no Bosnian embassy here and the nearest ones are in Norway, Sweden and Denmark. The problem for us is that our visa will expire soon, and we cannot reach anybody in any of our embassies," Aida said in an email to Sarajevo-x.
All Croatian airports, with the exception of the airport in Osijek, were re-opened by 3pm Sunday.
The Croatian national aviation authority said in a statement that following the latest weather reports it decided to re-open Croatia's airspace, except for the northern and eastern areas.
The Croatian national aviation authority will continue following weather reports and developments in European airspace before making any new decisions, daily T portal reported.
Serbian airspace was also reopened on Sunday, and departures and arrivals were restarting after the closure of the airspace and the country's main airport in Belgrade, according to broadcaster B92.
Macedonia was one of the few countries in Europe that was not forced to close its airspace because of the volcanic ash, but most airports remained inactive as flights to and from the country were canceled due to the closure of airspace in other parts of Europe.
Bulgaria, which reopened most of its airports on Monday, faced a similar situation, with most flights to and from Western Europe being canceled. Neighbouring Romania began to reopen its airspace on Monday to transiting flights, hotnews.ro reported.
Source: BalkanInsight.com (BIRN)
Monday, April 19, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
NATO: Pentagon’s Gateway Into Former Warsaw Pact, Soviet Nations
By Rick Rozoff
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization was founded in April of 1949 by a country not on the European continent, the United States, and eleven subordinates which had fought on both sides of the World War that had ended four years earlier: Belgium, Britain, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway and Portugal. Greece and Turkey were added in 1952 after their service in the Korean War and West Germany joined in 1955.
Five days after the inclusion of the Federal Republic of Germany on May 9, in contravention of the 1945 Potsdam Agreement between Britain, the U.S. and the Soviet Union which explicitly demanded and meticulously detailed plans for the demilitarization of Germany, the Soviet Union established the Warsaw Treaty Organization (Warsaw Pact) in response. Fellow members were Albania, Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, the German Democratic Republic (East Germany), Hungary, Poland and Romania. Albania formally withdrew in 1968, though it had not been a participating member since the early 1960s, and Romania had been a member in name only for at least twenty years before the pact’s formal disbandment.
With the accession of Spain into the “military alliance of democratic states in Europe and North America” in 1982 the U.S.-led military bloc grew from its original 12 to 16 members. By that time the Warsaw Pact had shrunk from eight to seven members and some of the remaining ones were only selectively involved.
NATO regularly held large-scale military exercises in alleged defense of Norway, Denmark and other members, but never deployed forces or conducted operations outside member states’ territories, counting on the thousands of American nuclear warheads in European NATO states to respond to the Warsaw Pact’s conventional military superiority in the event of armed confrontation. [1]
Military forces from the Warsaw Pact intervened in Czechoslovakia in 1968 and in the early 1980s it appeared they might do so again in Poland, and the Soviet Union sent troops to Hungary in 1956 after Prime Minister Imre Nagy withdrew his nation from the Warsaw Pact.
The Soviet Union’s justification for those actions was that nations in Eastern Europe gravitating toward the West could be transformed into sites from which NATO, and especially its dominant member the U.S., would present a military threat on or near its borders.
In 1999, eight years after the formal dissolution of the Warsaw Pact and the fragmentation of the Soviet Union itself, the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland were brought into NATO as full members during the bloc’s fiftieth anniversary summit in Washington, DC, while NATO was conducting its first large-scale military operation outside the territory of its member states and its first major armed conflict: The almost three-month Operation Allied Force air war against Yugoslavia, which had not been a member of either Cold War military alliance.
The accession of three former Warsaw Pact nations in 1999 was the largest one-time expansion in NATO’s history. Five years later at the Istanbul summit seven new members were inducted, six former Warsaw Pact countries, including three ex-Soviet republics, and a former federal republic of Yugoslavia: Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia.
With the earlier absorption of East Germany into NATO with German reunification in 1990, by 2004 every member of the erstwhile Warsaw Pact outside the Soviet Union except short-term member Albania had been brought into the Western military alliance. Albania was incorporated into NATO at the Strasbourg-Kehl summit last year.
The worst suspicions harbored east of the Cold War divide had been confirmed. Not only have all of the Soviet Union’s previous allies in Eastern Europe been recruited into a Washington-dominated military bloc that for eleven years has been actively waging wars in Europe and beyond Europe in Asia, but territory of what had been the Soviet Union itself now contains a NATO air base (Lithuania) and a cyber warfare center (Estonia).
Once Soviet Republics like Ukraine, Georgia, Azerbaijan and Armenia are being actively pursued by NATO, which has held military exercises in those countries.
In 2007 NATO selected the Papa Air Base in Hungary for its first Strategic Airlift Capability (SAC) operation in support of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq (for the present). In the same year the Alliance announced it would open its first training center in a former Warsaw Pact country, in the Polish city of Bydgoszcz.
Starting the year after they were admitted as full NATO members, Bulgaria and Romania were approached by the U.S. to offer the Pentagon access to several major military bases. [2] Both countries had turned their air bases over to Washington in late 2002 and early 2003 for the invasion of Iraq, but in 2005 and 2006 Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice signed formal agreements for the acquisition of military bases with Romania and Bulgaria, respectively. The Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base and training and firing grounds in Babadag, Cincu and Smardan in Romania, and the Bezmer Air Base, the Graf Ignatievo Air Base and the Novo Selo Training Range in Bulgaria were locked into initial ten-year agreements. The Pentagon is not planning to leave, surely not after spending billions of dollars to modernize the facilities.
The deployment of between 5,000-10,000 U.S. troops to the bases at any one time is the first Pentagon presence in former Warsaw Pact nations. And the seven Bulgarian and Romanian installations are the first American military bases in any of those countries. Neither the troops nor the bases were the last.
The U.S. has moved its Joint Task Force-East, whose name alone indicates its purpose, to the Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base in Romania, and in the words of the unit’s deputy commander in 2008, “We are building a permanent forward operating station here….” [3]
The worst fear of the Soviet Union during the Cold War years was not just of NATO in general but of the U.S. in particular moving its military personnel and hardware toward its borders. Anyone who experienced a nightmare of that occurring twenty years ago and only woke up decades later would have difficulty realizing it was no longer just a dream.
NATO is, simply put, the major mechanism for moving the U.S. military into the territory of what had been the Warsaw Pact. And the Soviet Union. Permanently and aggressively.
By 2006 the advance of the Pentagon into Eastern Europe under the banner of NATO had become apparent enough – inescapably so – that quite far from the continent a Chinese military analyst, Lin Zhiyuan, deputy office director of the World Military Affairs Research Department of the Chinese Academy of Military Sciences, wrote that “new military bases, airports and training bases will be built in Hungary, Romania, Poland, Bulgaria and other nations to ensure ‘gangways’ to some areas in the Middle East, Africa and Asia [for] possible military actions in the years ahead.” [4]
As a major American news agency described the plans in 2007, “The bases are part of an ambitious plan to shift EUCOM’s [European Command's] fighting brigades from western Europe – mostly Germany – to forward bases closer to the Caucasus, the Balkans, the Middle East and Africa, for a quicker strike capability.” [5] [6]
The Bezmer, Graf Ignatievo and Mihail Kogalniceanu air bases in Bulgaria and Romania are being upgraded to serve as part of a series of new American strategic air bases outside the U.S. Aimed toward the east and the south.
In Poland, the activation of an Advanced Patriot Capability-3 interceptor missile battery manned by at least 100 U.S. military personnel has been scheduled for later this month. The troops will be deployed only 35 miles from Russia’s isolated enclave of Kaliningrad and will be the first foreign forces stationed in that nation since the end of the Warsaw Pact.
They will not be the last. After U.S. President Barack Obama met with the leaders of eleven new Eastern European NATO states – Bulgaria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, and Slovenia – in Prague on April 8 following the signing of a Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (START) II agreement with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, Polish President Donald Tusk told reporters “From the perspective of [President Obama] and the U.S. the signing of the START 2 treaty has no influence on the work on the SM3 anti-missile shield.” [7]
Tusk was not speaking of the short- to medium-range Patriots missiles that may arrive in his country any day, but of Standard Missile-3 longer-range anti-missile and anti-satellite interceptors that will be adapted from sea-based to land-based use. In Pentagonese, the Aegis Ashore component of the Phased Adaptive Approach for progressively longer-range missiles in Eastern Europe, ones which in the third phase could cripple Russia’s ability to launch a retaliatory response to a first strike.
This February 27 the now late Polish President Lech Kaczynski ratified a Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) with the U.S. for the stationing of the latter’s troops on his nation’s soil.
On March 5 the Polish armed forces launched combat training exercises with the participation of “scores of U.S. Army soldiers.” [8]
Going backward in time, in August of 2008 the U.S. signed an agreement with Poland which includes a “commitment for both states to come to each other’s assistance in case of military threats.” [9] What certainly appears to be a mutual defense pact.
In 2002 Poland signed the largest military purchase agreement in its history: 48 F-16 multirole jet fighters, the first of which were delivered in 2006. They were the first U.S. fighters provided to a former Eastern Bloc nation.
In 2005 Poland became the first former Warsaw Pact state to assume control of the NATO Baltic air patrol established immediately after Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania joined the bloc in 2004. Polish warplanes took over from U.S. F-16 Fighting Falcons. Poland will again take control of the mission next month with four warplanes operating out of and 100 troops stationed at the Lithuanian Air Force base at Siauliai.
In 2007 the Pentagon announced plans to sell Romania 48 F-16s as well, 24 new and 24 refurbished older jet fighters, for $4.5 billion, without doubt the most expensive military purchase in that nation’s history also. Late last month the Romanian government confirmed its decision to buy the 24 second-hand F-16s, beating out competition from France’s Dassault (Rafale), Sweden’s SAAB (Grippen) and the European Aeronautic Defence and Space Company (Eurofighter).
Early this month U.S. arms manufacturer Textron disclosed it would jointly produce armored vehicles with a Romanian counterpart, as “Romania is planning to buy about 800 armored vehicles.” [10] Romania’s NATO accession has proven invaluable for the Pentagon’s plans to expand deployments and operations from Europe to the east and the south and has been correspondingly lucrative for U.S. arms firms.
In March the Czech press revealed that “the Czech Republic is in discussions with the Obama administration to host a command center for the United States’ altered missile-defense plan.” [11]
During the recently-concluded Nuclear Security Summit in Washington, DC where a number of decidedly unrelated agreements were reached including one with which the U.S. secured the right for military overflights from Kazakhstan [12], Czech Defense Minister Martin Bartak disclosed that his meetings in the American capital included one with Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Michele Flournoy and Under Secretary of State for Arms Control Ellen Tauscher, the latter a long-time advocate for and organizer of U.S. missile shield projects in Eastern Europe.
In addition to being pressured by his American interlocutors to provide more troops for the Afghan war, Bartak said the three talked about Washington’s interceptor missile system, specifically that “The Czech Republic may be a part of a new warning system against possible enemy missile attacks,” personally adding that “the Czech Republic is prepared to participate in the system.” To demonstrate that the deliberations were not of an abstract nature, the Czech defense chief also mentioned the “sharing of data from commanding and observing elements placed in two locations in the Czech Republic.” [13]
Both the missile shield command center and the surveillance sites would include, in fact would be run by, American military personnel.
As will the (presumably) Standard Missile-3 interceptor missile sites offered to the U.S. in February by the Romanian and Bulgarian governments.
In Hungary, the world’s first multi-national strategic airlift operation was activated last July at the Papa Air Base. Although established under the auspices of NATO and jointly operated by twelve NATO and all-but-acknowledged NATO members – the U.S., Bulgaria, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Romania and Slovenia and Finland and Sweden – it is not under NATO command. It is an American project for the expanding war in Afghanistan with, as one U.S. officer assigned to the command put it, a “24-hours-a-day, seven-days-a-week” operation which “recently moved 2.1 million pounds of equipment essential to surge operations supporting the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan.” [14]
U.S. Air Force personnel are deployed there for the indefinite future, as their fellow service members are in Bulgaria and Romania and soon will be in Poland.
In former Soviet space, in addition to the participation of American warplanes over the Baltic nations of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and the regular participation of troops in NATO Partnership for Peace and other war games in Ukraine, Azerbaijan and Armenia, the Pentagon has established a permanent presence in Georgia since 2002, first with a Train and Equip Program and since then with U.S. Marines there on an ongoing basis and a steady parade of Marine commanders in and out of the capital of Tbilisi. Most recently Lieutenant General Richard F. Natonski, Commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Command, and Brigadier General Paul W. Brier, Commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Europe (and of U.S. Marine Forces Africa) earlier this month. [14]
U.S. troops and equipment were in that nation during the five-day war with Russia in August of 2008 and are there now.
The U.S. guided missile frigate USS John L. Hall arrived at the Georgian Black Sea port of Poti on April 14 for a week of joint exercises.
In turbulent Kyrgyzstan the U.S. runs one of the largest transit operations for the war in Afghanistan. In March U.S. Special Representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan Richard Holbrooke stated that 35,000 American troops pass through the air base at Manas each month on their way to and from Afghanistan, and U.S. Central Command has acknowledged that the number reached 50,000 last month.
In neighboring Kazakhstan, the U.S. gained military flyover rights with the government on April 11 which include for the first time the transit of combat troops and lethal military equipment.
A Kyrgyz news source revealed that in discussions between Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev, U.S. President Obama and his main Russian and Eurasian hand Michael McFaul, the last-named proposed the establishment of an American military base in Kazakhstan to either supplement or replace if need be the Transit Center at Manas in Kyrgyzstan. [15]
Retired Russian general Leonid Ivashov has stated that new U.S.-Kazakh military cooperation plans “threaten the interests of Russia and other countries, notably China and especially Iran against which the United States is preparing a military operation,” particularly if as seems increasingly likely the U.S. opens “a military base in Kazakhstan similar in size to the Kyrgyz facility.” [16]
In the post-Cold War period the Pentagon through bilateral agreements, but even more so through NATO partnerships, has ensconced itself in former Warsaw Pact and Soviet nations from the Baltic Sea to the Black Sea to Central Asia. From the Balkans to the Chinese border.
Rick Rozoff is a journalist and blogger and many of his articles may be found at the Stop NATO blog.
NOTES:
1) NATO’s Sixty Year Legacy: Threat Of Nuclear War In Europe Stop Nato, March 31, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/08/27/natos-sixty-year-legacy-threat-of-nuclear-war-in-europe
Bulgaria, Romania: U.S., NATO Bases For War In The East Stop NATO, October 24, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/bulgaria-romania-u-s-nato-bases-for-war-in-the-east
2) Black Sea: Pentagon’s Gateway To Three Continents And The Middle East
Stop NATO, February 21, 2009 http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/08/27/79
3) United States Army, July 24, 2008
4) People’s Daily, December 5, 2006
5) United Press International, May 18, 2007
6) Bulgaria, Romania: U.S., NATO Bases For War In The East Stop NATO, October 24, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/bulgaria-romania-u-s-nato-bases-for-war-in-the-east
7) Polish Radio, April 9, 2010
8) U.S., NATO Intensify War Games Around Russia’s Perimeter Stop NATO, March 6, 2010
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2010/03/06/u-s-nato-intensify-war-games-around-russias-perimeter
9) Bloomberg News, August 15, 2008
10) Agence France-Presse, April 9, 2010
11) Prague Post, February 10, 2010
12) Kazakhstan: U.S., NATO Seek Military Outpost Between Russia And China
Stop NATO, April 13, 2010 http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2010/04/15/kazakhstan-u-s-nato-seek-military-outpost-between-russia-and-china
13) Czech News Agency, April 14, 2010
14) United States Air Forces in Europe, April 2, 2010
15) U.S. Marines In The Caucasus As West Widens Afghan War Stop NATO, September 3, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/09/04/u-s-marines-in-the-caucasus-as-west-widens-afghan-war
16) 24.kg, April 12, 2010
17) Nezavisimaya Gazeta, April 14, 2010
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization was founded in April of 1949 by a country not on the European continent, the United States, and eleven subordinates which had fought on both sides of the World War that had ended four years earlier: Belgium, Britain, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway and Portugal. Greece and Turkey were added in 1952 after their service in the Korean War and West Germany joined in 1955.
Five days after the inclusion of the Federal Republic of Germany on May 9, in contravention of the 1945 Potsdam Agreement between Britain, the U.S. and the Soviet Union which explicitly demanded and meticulously detailed plans for the demilitarization of Germany, the Soviet Union established the Warsaw Treaty Organization (Warsaw Pact) in response. Fellow members were Albania, Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, the German Democratic Republic (East Germany), Hungary, Poland and Romania. Albania formally withdrew in 1968, though it had not been a participating member since the early 1960s, and Romania had been a member in name only for at least twenty years before the pact’s formal disbandment.
With the accession of Spain into the “military alliance of democratic states in Europe and North America” in 1982 the U.S.-led military bloc grew from its original 12 to 16 members. By that time the Warsaw Pact had shrunk from eight to seven members and some of the remaining ones were only selectively involved.
NATO regularly held large-scale military exercises in alleged defense of Norway, Denmark and other members, but never deployed forces or conducted operations outside member states’ territories, counting on the thousands of American nuclear warheads in European NATO states to respond to the Warsaw Pact’s conventional military superiority in the event of armed confrontation. [1]
Military forces from the Warsaw Pact intervened in Czechoslovakia in 1968 and in the early 1980s it appeared they might do so again in Poland, and the Soviet Union sent troops to Hungary in 1956 after Prime Minister Imre Nagy withdrew his nation from the Warsaw Pact.
The Soviet Union’s justification for those actions was that nations in Eastern Europe gravitating toward the West could be transformed into sites from which NATO, and especially its dominant member the U.S., would present a military threat on or near its borders.
In 1999, eight years after the formal dissolution of the Warsaw Pact and the fragmentation of the Soviet Union itself, the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland were brought into NATO as full members during the bloc’s fiftieth anniversary summit in Washington, DC, while NATO was conducting its first large-scale military operation outside the territory of its member states and its first major armed conflict: The almost three-month Operation Allied Force air war against Yugoslavia, which had not been a member of either Cold War military alliance.
The accession of three former Warsaw Pact nations in 1999 was the largest one-time expansion in NATO’s history. Five years later at the Istanbul summit seven new members were inducted, six former Warsaw Pact countries, including three ex-Soviet republics, and a former federal republic of Yugoslavia: Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia.
With the earlier absorption of East Germany into NATO with German reunification in 1990, by 2004 every member of the erstwhile Warsaw Pact outside the Soviet Union except short-term member Albania had been brought into the Western military alliance. Albania was incorporated into NATO at the Strasbourg-Kehl summit last year.
The worst suspicions harbored east of the Cold War divide had been confirmed. Not only have all of the Soviet Union’s previous allies in Eastern Europe been recruited into a Washington-dominated military bloc that for eleven years has been actively waging wars in Europe and beyond Europe in Asia, but territory of what had been the Soviet Union itself now contains a NATO air base (Lithuania) and a cyber warfare center (Estonia).
Once Soviet Republics like Ukraine, Georgia, Azerbaijan and Armenia are being actively pursued by NATO, which has held military exercises in those countries.
In 2007 NATO selected the Papa Air Base in Hungary for its first Strategic Airlift Capability (SAC) operation in support of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq (for the present). In the same year the Alliance announced it would open its first training center in a former Warsaw Pact country, in the Polish city of Bydgoszcz.
Starting the year after they were admitted as full NATO members, Bulgaria and Romania were approached by the U.S. to offer the Pentagon access to several major military bases. [2] Both countries had turned their air bases over to Washington in late 2002 and early 2003 for the invasion of Iraq, but in 2005 and 2006 Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice signed formal agreements for the acquisition of military bases with Romania and Bulgaria, respectively. The Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base and training and firing grounds in Babadag, Cincu and Smardan in Romania, and the Bezmer Air Base, the Graf Ignatievo Air Base and the Novo Selo Training Range in Bulgaria were locked into initial ten-year agreements. The Pentagon is not planning to leave, surely not after spending billions of dollars to modernize the facilities.
The deployment of between 5,000-10,000 U.S. troops to the bases at any one time is the first Pentagon presence in former Warsaw Pact nations. And the seven Bulgarian and Romanian installations are the first American military bases in any of those countries. Neither the troops nor the bases were the last.
The U.S. has moved its Joint Task Force-East, whose name alone indicates its purpose, to the Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base in Romania, and in the words of the unit’s deputy commander in 2008, “We are building a permanent forward operating station here….” [3]
The worst fear of the Soviet Union during the Cold War years was not just of NATO in general but of the U.S. in particular moving its military personnel and hardware toward its borders. Anyone who experienced a nightmare of that occurring twenty years ago and only woke up decades later would have difficulty realizing it was no longer just a dream.
NATO is, simply put, the major mechanism for moving the U.S. military into the territory of what had been the Warsaw Pact. And the Soviet Union. Permanently and aggressively.
By 2006 the advance of the Pentagon into Eastern Europe under the banner of NATO had become apparent enough – inescapably so – that quite far from the continent a Chinese military analyst, Lin Zhiyuan, deputy office director of the World Military Affairs Research Department of the Chinese Academy of Military Sciences, wrote that “new military bases, airports and training bases will be built in Hungary, Romania, Poland, Bulgaria and other nations to ensure ‘gangways’ to some areas in the Middle East, Africa and Asia [for] possible military actions in the years ahead.” [4]
As a major American news agency described the plans in 2007, “The bases are part of an ambitious plan to shift EUCOM’s [European Command's] fighting brigades from western Europe – mostly Germany – to forward bases closer to the Caucasus, the Balkans, the Middle East and Africa, for a quicker strike capability.” [5] [6]
The Bezmer, Graf Ignatievo and Mihail Kogalniceanu air bases in Bulgaria and Romania are being upgraded to serve as part of a series of new American strategic air bases outside the U.S. Aimed toward the east and the south.
In Poland, the activation of an Advanced Patriot Capability-3 interceptor missile battery manned by at least 100 U.S. military personnel has been scheduled for later this month. The troops will be deployed only 35 miles from Russia’s isolated enclave of Kaliningrad and will be the first foreign forces stationed in that nation since the end of the Warsaw Pact.
They will not be the last. After U.S. President Barack Obama met with the leaders of eleven new Eastern European NATO states – Bulgaria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, and Slovenia – in Prague on April 8 following the signing of a Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (START) II agreement with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, Polish President Donald Tusk told reporters “From the perspective of [President Obama] and the U.S. the signing of the START 2 treaty has no influence on the work on the SM3 anti-missile shield.” [7]
Tusk was not speaking of the short- to medium-range Patriots missiles that may arrive in his country any day, but of Standard Missile-3 longer-range anti-missile and anti-satellite interceptors that will be adapted from sea-based to land-based use. In Pentagonese, the Aegis Ashore component of the Phased Adaptive Approach for progressively longer-range missiles in Eastern Europe, ones which in the third phase could cripple Russia’s ability to launch a retaliatory response to a first strike.
This February 27 the now late Polish President Lech Kaczynski ratified a Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) with the U.S. for the stationing of the latter’s troops on his nation’s soil.
On March 5 the Polish armed forces launched combat training exercises with the participation of “scores of U.S. Army soldiers.” [8]
Going backward in time, in August of 2008 the U.S. signed an agreement with Poland which includes a “commitment for both states to come to each other’s assistance in case of military threats.” [9] What certainly appears to be a mutual defense pact.
In 2002 Poland signed the largest military purchase agreement in its history: 48 F-16 multirole jet fighters, the first of which were delivered in 2006. They were the first U.S. fighters provided to a former Eastern Bloc nation.
In 2005 Poland became the first former Warsaw Pact state to assume control of the NATO Baltic air patrol established immediately after Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania joined the bloc in 2004. Polish warplanes took over from U.S. F-16 Fighting Falcons. Poland will again take control of the mission next month with four warplanes operating out of and 100 troops stationed at the Lithuanian Air Force base at Siauliai.
In 2007 the Pentagon announced plans to sell Romania 48 F-16s as well, 24 new and 24 refurbished older jet fighters, for $4.5 billion, without doubt the most expensive military purchase in that nation’s history also. Late last month the Romanian government confirmed its decision to buy the 24 second-hand F-16s, beating out competition from France’s Dassault (Rafale), Sweden’s SAAB (Grippen) and the European Aeronautic Defence and Space Company (Eurofighter).
Early this month U.S. arms manufacturer Textron disclosed it would jointly produce armored vehicles with a Romanian counterpart, as “Romania is planning to buy about 800 armored vehicles.” [10] Romania’s NATO accession has proven invaluable for the Pentagon’s plans to expand deployments and operations from Europe to the east and the south and has been correspondingly lucrative for U.S. arms firms.
In March the Czech press revealed that “the Czech Republic is in discussions with the Obama administration to host a command center for the United States’ altered missile-defense plan.” [11]
During the recently-concluded Nuclear Security Summit in Washington, DC where a number of decidedly unrelated agreements were reached including one with which the U.S. secured the right for military overflights from Kazakhstan [12], Czech Defense Minister Martin Bartak disclosed that his meetings in the American capital included one with Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Michele Flournoy and Under Secretary of State for Arms Control Ellen Tauscher, the latter a long-time advocate for and organizer of U.S. missile shield projects in Eastern Europe.
In addition to being pressured by his American interlocutors to provide more troops for the Afghan war, Bartak said the three talked about Washington’s interceptor missile system, specifically that “The Czech Republic may be a part of a new warning system against possible enemy missile attacks,” personally adding that “the Czech Republic is prepared to participate in the system.” To demonstrate that the deliberations were not of an abstract nature, the Czech defense chief also mentioned the “sharing of data from commanding and observing elements placed in two locations in the Czech Republic.” [13]
Both the missile shield command center and the surveillance sites would include, in fact would be run by, American military personnel.
As will the (presumably) Standard Missile-3 interceptor missile sites offered to the U.S. in February by the Romanian and Bulgarian governments.
In Hungary, the world’s first multi-national strategic airlift operation was activated last July at the Papa Air Base. Although established under the auspices of NATO and jointly operated by twelve NATO and all-but-acknowledged NATO members – the U.S., Bulgaria, Estonia, Hungary, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Romania and Slovenia and Finland and Sweden – it is not under NATO command. It is an American project for the expanding war in Afghanistan with, as one U.S. officer assigned to the command put it, a “24-hours-a-day, seven-days-a-week” operation which “recently moved 2.1 million pounds of equipment essential to surge operations supporting the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan.” [14]
U.S. Air Force personnel are deployed there for the indefinite future, as their fellow service members are in Bulgaria and Romania and soon will be in Poland.
In former Soviet space, in addition to the participation of American warplanes over the Baltic nations of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and the regular participation of troops in NATO Partnership for Peace and other war games in Ukraine, Azerbaijan and Armenia, the Pentagon has established a permanent presence in Georgia since 2002, first with a Train and Equip Program and since then with U.S. Marines there on an ongoing basis and a steady parade of Marine commanders in and out of the capital of Tbilisi. Most recently Lieutenant General Richard F. Natonski, Commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Command, and Brigadier General Paul W. Brier, Commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Europe (and of U.S. Marine Forces Africa) earlier this month. [14]
U.S. troops and equipment were in that nation during the five-day war with Russia in August of 2008 and are there now.
The U.S. guided missile frigate USS John L. Hall arrived at the Georgian Black Sea port of Poti on April 14 for a week of joint exercises.
In turbulent Kyrgyzstan the U.S. runs one of the largest transit operations for the war in Afghanistan. In March U.S. Special Representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan Richard Holbrooke stated that 35,000 American troops pass through the air base at Manas each month on their way to and from Afghanistan, and U.S. Central Command has acknowledged that the number reached 50,000 last month.
In neighboring Kazakhstan, the U.S. gained military flyover rights with the government on April 11 which include for the first time the transit of combat troops and lethal military equipment.
A Kyrgyz news source revealed that in discussions between Kazakh President Nursultan Nazarbayev, U.S. President Obama and his main Russian and Eurasian hand Michael McFaul, the last-named proposed the establishment of an American military base in Kazakhstan to either supplement or replace if need be the Transit Center at Manas in Kyrgyzstan. [15]
Retired Russian general Leonid Ivashov has stated that new U.S.-Kazakh military cooperation plans “threaten the interests of Russia and other countries, notably China and especially Iran against which the United States is preparing a military operation,” particularly if as seems increasingly likely the U.S. opens “a military base in Kazakhstan similar in size to the Kyrgyz facility.” [16]
In the post-Cold War period the Pentagon through bilateral agreements, but even more so through NATO partnerships, has ensconced itself in former Warsaw Pact and Soviet nations from the Baltic Sea to the Black Sea to Central Asia. From the Balkans to the Chinese border.
Rick Rozoff is a journalist and blogger and many of his articles may be found at the Stop NATO blog.
NOTES:
1) NATO’s Sixty Year Legacy: Threat Of Nuclear War In Europe Stop Nato, March 31, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/08/27/natos-sixty-year-legacy-threat-of-nuclear-war-in-europe
Bulgaria, Romania: U.S., NATO Bases For War In The East Stop NATO, October 24, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/bulgaria-romania-u-s-nato-bases-for-war-in-the-east
2) Black Sea: Pentagon’s Gateway To Three Continents And The Middle East
Stop NATO, February 21, 2009 http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/08/27/79
3) United States Army, July 24, 2008
4) People’s Daily, December 5, 2006
5) United Press International, May 18, 2007
6) Bulgaria, Romania: U.S., NATO Bases For War In The East Stop NATO, October 24, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/bulgaria-romania-u-s-nato-bases-for-war-in-the-east
7) Polish Radio, April 9, 2010
8) U.S., NATO Intensify War Games Around Russia’s Perimeter Stop NATO, March 6, 2010
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2010/03/06/u-s-nato-intensify-war-games-around-russias-perimeter
9) Bloomberg News, August 15, 2008
10) Agence France-Presse, April 9, 2010
11) Prague Post, February 10, 2010
12) Kazakhstan: U.S., NATO Seek Military Outpost Between Russia And China
Stop NATO, April 13, 2010 http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2010/04/15/kazakhstan-u-s-nato-seek-military-outpost-between-russia-and-china
13) Czech News Agency, April 14, 2010
14) United States Air Forces in Europe, April 2, 2010
15) U.S. Marines In The Caucasus As West Widens Afghan War Stop NATO, September 3, 2009
http://rickrozoff.wordpress.com/2009/09/04/u-s-marines-in-the-caucasus-as-west-widens-afghan-war
16) 24.kg, April 12, 2010
17) Nezavisimaya Gazeta, April 14, 2010
Friday, April 16, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
After Bulgaria, Romania Delays Euro Adoption
Romanian Central Bank governor Mugur Isarescu suggested his country would delay its 2015 target for adopting the euro, saying "more preparation" was needed, the Romanian press wrote yesterday (15 April).
"A delay of one or two years is less significant than the need to accede to the euro zone well prepared," Isarescu said.
Last week, Bulgaria's centre-right government abandoned plans to join ERM II, the euro zone's waiting room, after the country recorded a larger-than-expected deficit in 2009.
The Romanian National Bank will continue to mention 2015 as a target date, Isarescu said, because the ambitious objective would act as a catalyst role in preparing for the single currency.
Isarescu said the Romanian economy was stalled due to high inflation. According to official statistics, inflation in Romania will reach about 3.5% by the end of the year.
A relatively poor Balkan state of 22 million people, Romania has experienced a sharp economic reversal in the last year as a result of the global financial crisis and poor economic policies.
"For 15 years, I haven't been going to restaurants," Isarescu is quoted as saying. The central bank governor explained his personal austerity by saying that each time he went to a restaurant, people would come to his table to ask him what the exchange rate for Romanian currency would be.
Lucian Croitoru, an advisor to the government, was quoted by AFP as saying that Romania's planned 2012 entry into ERM II, seen as the euro zone waiting room, would now be a difficult goal.
He said the difficulties were stemming from the population's reluctance to accept austerity measures designed to keep the budget deficit below 3% of GDP.
In 2009, Romania had a deficit of 7.2%. Since then it has committed to reforming its pension and public sector wage systems in a bid to bring this figure down to 5.9% during 2010.
During the global recession, Romania has been transformed from the European Union's fastest-growing economy and an attractive destination for foreign investors to a problem zone in dire need of aid.
In March 2009, the country secured a 20-billion euro bailout package. Of that sum, the International Monetary Fund will provide 12.9 billion, the European Commission five billion and the World Bank 1.5 billion. About one billion will be raised by other financial institutions.
Source: EurActiv
"A delay of one or two years is less significant than the need to accede to the euro zone well prepared," Isarescu said.
Last week, Bulgaria's centre-right government abandoned plans to join ERM II, the euro zone's waiting room, after the country recorded a larger-than-expected deficit in 2009.
The Romanian National Bank will continue to mention 2015 as a target date, Isarescu said, because the ambitious objective would act as a catalyst role in preparing for the single currency.
Isarescu said the Romanian economy was stalled due to high inflation. According to official statistics, inflation in Romania will reach about 3.5% by the end of the year.
A relatively poor Balkan state of 22 million people, Romania has experienced a sharp economic reversal in the last year as a result of the global financial crisis and poor economic policies.
"For 15 years, I haven't been going to restaurants," Isarescu is quoted as saying. The central bank governor explained his personal austerity by saying that each time he went to a restaurant, people would come to his table to ask him what the exchange rate for Romanian currency would be.
Lucian Croitoru, an advisor to the government, was quoted by AFP as saying that Romania's planned 2012 entry into ERM II, seen as the euro zone waiting room, would now be a difficult goal.
He said the difficulties were stemming from the population's reluctance to accept austerity measures designed to keep the budget deficit below 3% of GDP.
In 2009, Romania had a deficit of 7.2%. Since then it has committed to reforming its pension and public sector wage systems in a bid to bring this figure down to 5.9% during 2010.
During the global recession, Romania has been transformed from the European Union's fastest-growing economy and an attractive destination for foreign investors to a problem zone in dire need of aid.
In March 2009, the country secured a 20-billion euro bailout package. Of that sum, the International Monetary Fund will provide 12.9 billion, the European Commission five billion and the World Bank 1.5 billion. About one billion will be raised by other financial institutions.
Source: EurActiv
Friday, April 16, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
The Coming European Debt Wars
By Michael Hudson
Government debt in Greece is just the first in a series of European debt bombs that are set to explode.
The mortgage debts in post-Soviet economies and Iceland are more explosive. Although these countries are not in the Eurozone, most of their debts are denominated in euros. Some 87% of Latvia’s debts are in euros or other foreign currencies, and are owed mainly to Swedish banks, while Hungary and Romania owe euro-debts mainly to Austrian banks. So their government borrowing by non-euro members has been to support exchange rates to pay these private-sector debts to foreign banks, not to finance a domestic budget deficit as in Greece.
All these debts are unpayably high because most of these countries are running deepening trade deficits and are sinking into depression. Now that real estate prices are plunging, trade deficits are no longer financed by an inflow of foreign-currency mortgage lending and property buyouts. There is no visible means of support to stabilize currencies (e.g., healthy economies). For the past year these countries have supported their exchange rates by borrowing from the EU and IMF. The terms of this borrowing are politically unsustainable: sharp public sector budget cuts, higher tax rates on already over-taxed labor, and austerity plans that shrink economies and drive more labor to emigrate.
Bankers in Sweden and Austria, Germany and Britain are about to discover that extending credit to nations that can’t (or won’t) pay may be their problem, not that of their debtors. No one wants to accept the fact that debts that can’t be paid, won’t be. Someone must bear the cost as debts go into default or are written down, to be paid in sharply depreciated currencies, but many legal experts find debt agreements calling for repayment in euros unenforceable.
Every sovereign nation has the right to legislate its own debt terms, and the coming currency re-alignments and debt write-downs will be much more than mere “haircuts.”
There is no point in devaluing, unless “to excess” – that is, by enough to actually change trade and production patterns. That is why Franklin Roosevelt devalued the US dollar by 41% against gold in 1933, raising its official price from $20 to $35 an ounce. And to avoid raising the U.S. debt burden proportionally, he annulled the “gold clause” indexing payment of bank loans to the price of gold. This is where the political fight will occur today – over the payment of debt in currencies that are devalued. Another byproduct of the Great Depression in the United States and Canada was to free mortgage debtors from personal liability, making it possible to recover from bankruptcy.
Foreclosing banks can take possession of collateral real estate, but do not have any further claim on the mortgagees. This practice – grounded in common law – shows how North America has freed itself from the legacy of feudal-style creditor power and the debtors’ prisons that made earlier European debt laws so harsh.
The question is, who will bear the loss? Keeping debts denominated in euros would bankrupt much local business and real estate. Conversely, re-denominating these debts in local depreciated currency will wipe out the capital of many euro-based banks. But these banks are foreigners, after all – and in the end, governments must represent their own home electorates. Foreign banks do not vote.
Foreign dollar holders have lost 29/30th of the gold value of their holdings since the United States stopped settling its balance-of-payments deficits in gold in 1971. They now receive less than a thirtieth of this, as the price has risen to $1,100 an ounce. If the world can take that, why shouldn’t it take the coming European debt write-downs in stride?
There is growing recognition that the post-Soviet economies were structured from the start to benefit foreign interests, not local economies. For example, Latvian labor is taxed at over 50% (labor, employer, and social tax) – so high as to make it noncompetitive, while property taxes are less than 1%, providing an incentive toward rampant speculation. This skewed tax philosophy made the “Baltic Tigers” and central Europe prime loan markets for Swedish and Austrian banks, but their labor could not find well-paying work at home. Nothing like this (or their abysmal workplace protection laws) is found in the Western European, North American or Asian economies.
It seems unreasonable and unrealistic to expect that large sectors of the New European population can be made subject to salary garnishment throughout their lives, reducing them to a lifetime of debt peonage. Future relations between Old and New Europe will depend on the Eurozone’s willingness to re-design the post-Soviet economies on more solvent lines – with more productive credit and a less rentier-biased tax system that promotes employment rather than asset-price inflation that drives labor to emigrate. In addition to currency realignments to deal with unaffordable debt, the indicated line of solution for these countries is a major shift of taxes off labor onto land, making them more like Western Europe. There is no just alternative. Otherwise, the age-old conflict-of-interest between creditors and debtors threatens to split Europe into opposing political camps, with Iceland the dress rehearsal.
Until this debt problem is resolved – and the only way to resolve it is to negotiate a debt write-off – European expansion (the absorption of New Europe into Old Europe) seems over. But the transition to this future solution will not be easy. Financial interests still wield dominant power over the EU, and will resist the inevitable. Gordon Brown already has shown his colors in his threats against Iceland to illegally and improperly use the IMF as a collection agent for debts that Iceland doesn’t legally owe, and to blackball Icelandic membership in the EU.
Confronted with Mr. Brown’s bullying – and that of Britain’s Dutch poodles – 97% of Icelandic voters opposed the debt settlement that Britain and the Netherlands sought to force down the throat of Allthing members last month. This high a vote has not been seen in the world since the old Stalinist era.
It is only a foretaste. The choice that Europe ends up making will likely drive millions into the streets. Political and economic alliances will shift, currencies will crumble and governments will fall. The European Union and indeed, the international financial system will change in ways yet to be seen. This will be especially the case if nations adopt the Argentina model and refuse to make payment until steep discounts are made.
Paying in euros – for real estate and personal income streams in negative equity, where the debts exceed the current value of income flows available to pay mortgages or for that matter, personal debts – is impossible for nations that hope to maintain a modicum of civil society.
“Austerity plans” IMF and EU style is an antiseptic, technocratic jargon for life-shortening and killing impact of gutting income, social services, spending on health on hospitals, education and other basic needs, and selling off public infrastructure for buyers to turn nations into “tollbooth economies” where everyone is obliged to pay access prices for roads, education, medical care and other costs of living and doing business that have long been subsidized by progressive taxation in North America and Western Europe.
The battle lines are being drawn regarding how private and public debts are to be repaid. For nations that balk at repayment in euros, the creditor nations have their “muscle” waiting in the wings: the credit rating agencies. At the first sign a nation is balking in paying in hard currency, or even at the first hint of it questioning a foreign debt as improper, the agencies will move in to reduce a nation’s credit rating. This will increase the cost of borrowing and threaten to paralyze the economy by starving it for credit.
The most recent shot was fired n April 6 when Moody’s downgraded Iceland’s debt from stable to negative. “Moody’s acknowledged that Iceland might still achieve a better deal in renewed negotiations, but said the current uncertainty was hurting the country’s short-term economic and financial prospects.”
The fight is on. It should be an interesting decade.
Prof. Hudson is Chief Economic Advisor to the Reform Task Force Latvia (RTFL). Michael Hudson is President of The Institute for the Study of Long-Term Economic Trends (ISLET), a Wall Street Financial Analyst, Distinguished Research Professor of Economics at the University of Missouri, Kansas City and author of Super-Imperialism: The Economic Strategy of American Empire (1968 & 2003), Trade, Development and Foreign Debt (1992 & 2009) and of The Myth of Aid (1971). For more of his writing check out his website: http://michael-hudson.com
Government debt in Greece is just the first in a series of European debt bombs that are set to explode.
The mortgage debts in post-Soviet economies and Iceland are more explosive. Although these countries are not in the Eurozone, most of their debts are denominated in euros. Some 87% of Latvia’s debts are in euros or other foreign currencies, and are owed mainly to Swedish banks, while Hungary and Romania owe euro-debts mainly to Austrian banks. So their government borrowing by non-euro members has been to support exchange rates to pay these private-sector debts to foreign banks, not to finance a domestic budget deficit as in Greece.
All these debts are unpayably high because most of these countries are running deepening trade deficits and are sinking into depression. Now that real estate prices are plunging, trade deficits are no longer financed by an inflow of foreign-currency mortgage lending and property buyouts. There is no visible means of support to stabilize currencies (e.g., healthy economies). For the past year these countries have supported their exchange rates by borrowing from the EU and IMF. The terms of this borrowing are politically unsustainable: sharp public sector budget cuts, higher tax rates on already over-taxed labor, and austerity plans that shrink economies and drive more labor to emigrate.
Bankers in Sweden and Austria, Germany and Britain are about to discover that extending credit to nations that can’t (or won’t) pay may be their problem, not that of their debtors. No one wants to accept the fact that debts that can’t be paid, won’t be. Someone must bear the cost as debts go into default or are written down, to be paid in sharply depreciated currencies, but many legal experts find debt agreements calling for repayment in euros unenforceable.
Every sovereign nation has the right to legislate its own debt terms, and the coming currency re-alignments and debt write-downs will be much more than mere “haircuts.”
There is no point in devaluing, unless “to excess” – that is, by enough to actually change trade and production patterns. That is why Franklin Roosevelt devalued the US dollar by 41% against gold in 1933, raising its official price from $20 to $35 an ounce. And to avoid raising the U.S. debt burden proportionally, he annulled the “gold clause” indexing payment of bank loans to the price of gold. This is where the political fight will occur today – over the payment of debt in currencies that are devalued. Another byproduct of the Great Depression in the United States and Canada was to free mortgage debtors from personal liability, making it possible to recover from bankruptcy.
Foreclosing banks can take possession of collateral real estate, but do not have any further claim on the mortgagees. This practice – grounded in common law – shows how North America has freed itself from the legacy of feudal-style creditor power and the debtors’ prisons that made earlier European debt laws so harsh.
The question is, who will bear the loss? Keeping debts denominated in euros would bankrupt much local business and real estate. Conversely, re-denominating these debts in local depreciated currency will wipe out the capital of many euro-based banks. But these banks are foreigners, after all – and in the end, governments must represent their own home electorates. Foreign banks do not vote.
Foreign dollar holders have lost 29/30th of the gold value of their holdings since the United States stopped settling its balance-of-payments deficits in gold in 1971. They now receive less than a thirtieth of this, as the price has risen to $1,100 an ounce. If the world can take that, why shouldn’t it take the coming European debt write-downs in stride?
There is growing recognition that the post-Soviet economies were structured from the start to benefit foreign interests, not local economies. For example, Latvian labor is taxed at over 50% (labor, employer, and social tax) – so high as to make it noncompetitive, while property taxes are less than 1%, providing an incentive toward rampant speculation. This skewed tax philosophy made the “Baltic Tigers” and central Europe prime loan markets for Swedish and Austrian banks, but their labor could not find well-paying work at home. Nothing like this (or their abysmal workplace protection laws) is found in the Western European, North American or Asian economies.
It seems unreasonable and unrealistic to expect that large sectors of the New European population can be made subject to salary garnishment throughout their lives, reducing them to a lifetime of debt peonage. Future relations between Old and New Europe will depend on the Eurozone’s willingness to re-design the post-Soviet economies on more solvent lines – with more productive credit and a less rentier-biased tax system that promotes employment rather than asset-price inflation that drives labor to emigrate. In addition to currency realignments to deal with unaffordable debt, the indicated line of solution for these countries is a major shift of taxes off labor onto land, making them more like Western Europe. There is no just alternative. Otherwise, the age-old conflict-of-interest between creditors and debtors threatens to split Europe into opposing political camps, with Iceland the dress rehearsal.
Until this debt problem is resolved – and the only way to resolve it is to negotiate a debt write-off – European expansion (the absorption of New Europe into Old Europe) seems over. But the transition to this future solution will not be easy. Financial interests still wield dominant power over the EU, and will resist the inevitable. Gordon Brown already has shown his colors in his threats against Iceland to illegally and improperly use the IMF as a collection agent for debts that Iceland doesn’t legally owe, and to blackball Icelandic membership in the EU.
Confronted with Mr. Brown’s bullying – and that of Britain’s Dutch poodles – 97% of Icelandic voters opposed the debt settlement that Britain and the Netherlands sought to force down the throat of Allthing members last month. This high a vote has not been seen in the world since the old Stalinist era.
It is only a foretaste. The choice that Europe ends up making will likely drive millions into the streets. Political and economic alliances will shift, currencies will crumble and governments will fall. The European Union and indeed, the international financial system will change in ways yet to be seen. This will be especially the case if nations adopt the Argentina model and refuse to make payment until steep discounts are made.
Paying in euros – for real estate and personal income streams in negative equity, where the debts exceed the current value of income flows available to pay mortgages or for that matter, personal debts – is impossible for nations that hope to maintain a modicum of civil society.
“Austerity plans” IMF and EU style is an antiseptic, technocratic jargon for life-shortening and killing impact of gutting income, social services, spending on health on hospitals, education and other basic needs, and selling off public infrastructure for buyers to turn nations into “tollbooth economies” where everyone is obliged to pay access prices for roads, education, medical care and other costs of living and doing business that have long been subsidized by progressive taxation in North America and Western Europe.
The battle lines are being drawn regarding how private and public debts are to be repaid. For nations that balk at repayment in euros, the creditor nations have their “muscle” waiting in the wings: the credit rating agencies. At the first sign a nation is balking in paying in hard currency, or even at the first hint of it questioning a foreign debt as improper, the agencies will move in to reduce a nation’s credit rating. This will increase the cost of borrowing and threaten to paralyze the economy by starving it for credit.
The most recent shot was fired n April 6 when Moody’s downgraded Iceland’s debt from stable to negative. “Moody’s acknowledged that Iceland might still achieve a better deal in renewed negotiations, but said the current uncertainty was hurting the country’s short-term economic and financial prospects.”
The fight is on. It should be an interesting decade.
Prof. Hudson is Chief Economic Advisor to the Reform Task Force Latvia (RTFL). Michael Hudson is President of The Institute for the Study of Long-Term Economic Trends (ISLET), a Wall Street Financial Analyst, Distinguished Research Professor of Economics at the University of Missouri, Kansas City and author of Super-Imperialism: The Economic Strategy of American Empire (1968 & 2003), Trade, Development and Foreign Debt (1992 & 2009) and of The Myth of Aid (1971). For more of his writing check out his website: http://michael-hudson.com
Saturday, April 10, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...









