Nile Waters: Only A Partial Agreement
Only four countries – Ethiopia, Uganda, Rwanda and Tanzania – have signed, in Entebbe, Uganda, an agreement to share the management of the waters of the Nile, reports MISNA.
Egypt and Sudan have long opposed the project, of which little is known, seeing as both countries have benefited from the previous water sharing treaty going back to 1959.
Both countries have boycotted Friday’s meeting.
Other notable absentees at the meeting were representatives from the government of Burundi, of the DR Congo and Kenya, which could sign the agreement at a later date.
In recent years the countries of the Nile Basin have been discussing to review the water sharing arrangements and rights over the waters of the river, but Friday’s agreement marks a clear break.
According to Mufid Shehab, Egyptian minister of parliamentary and juridical affairs, without Sudan and Egypt’s signature, the Entebbe document cannot be adopted and enforced.
Source: Original reporting by MISNA
Egypt and Sudan have long opposed the project, of which little is known, seeing as both countries have benefited from the previous water sharing treaty going back to 1959.
Both countries have boycotted Friday’s meeting.
Other notable absentees at the meeting were representatives from the government of Burundi, of the DR Congo and Kenya, which could sign the agreement at a later date.
In recent years the countries of the Nile Basin have been discussing to review the water sharing arrangements and rights over the waters of the river, but Friday’s agreement marks a clear break.
According to Mufid Shehab, Egyptian minister of parliamentary and juridical affairs, without Sudan and Egypt’s signature, the Entebbe document cannot be adopted and enforced.
Source: Original reporting by MISNA
Saturday, May 15, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Community Service “Inadequate Punishment”, Say Rwanda Survivors
Sixteen years after the Rwandan genocide, thousands of perpetrators who confessed their roles before the traditional Gacaca Courts have been released and sentenced to community service, but survivors say this is an inadequate punishment.
"The punishment should be [close] to the pain those inmates inflicted," Theodore Simburudali, the chairman of the genocide survivor organization, Ibuka, told IRIN.
He urged the government to do more to stop the killing of genocide survivors in parts of the country.
Ibuka has frequently decried the killing of survivors, most often after testifying against suspects in the courts. Some genocide suspects and convicts, according to the organization, single out the survivors for revenge.
"We need to [implore] Rwandan officials to [see] the seriousness of the issue because genocide survivors are still the targets of those who slaughtered their families, rather than expecting [them] to live in the same community with murderers," Simburudali added.
At least 106,918 convicts have gone through the programme, referred to as TIG (Travaux d'Intérêt Général), since its inception in 2005, according to the government.
Under Rwandan law certain categories of genocide perpetrators serve part of their prison term in jail with the remainder as community service, in a bid to decongest the prisons and foster reconciliation, say government officials.
"This punishment allows the [perpetrators] to acquire new professional skills that will help facilitate their reintegration into society, as well as to turn them into good citizens," Evariste Bizimana, TIG executive coordinator, told IRIN. "They [the TIG inmates] have been able to learn vocational skills, while building several houses for vulnerable people, many of whom are genocide survivors."
Under TIG, inmates build houses for vulnerable groups, and community infrastructure such as roads, and are also involved in agricultural activities.
"This programme is part of a reconciliation process as we need to educate those killers who confess their crimes [in order] to live side-by-side with genocide survivors," Bizimana added. "[They] must understand that this is a punishment, not merely a transit camp to be reintegrated into society."
Those sentenced to community service are housed in camps around the country and are not remunerated. Many now show remorse.
Thaddeo Munyansanga, a Hutu who was working in a Tutsi household before 1994 said: "When the killing started, I was told by the [Interahamwe] militia that I would end up owning all my former boss's belongings."
Munyansanga's house was located a short distance from his former boss's widow, Philomène Uwinyange, in Kibirizi village in the south.
"I regret all that I did, I now hope that Uwinyange will accept my apologies," Munyansanga told IRIN. "I don't want to push her any further to forgive me. It is a matter of time, considering the seriousness of our [actions]."
Uwinyange, 56, takes care of three adopted children – her children were killed in the genocide. "We have no choice [but to] reconcile with those who killed our relatives. What [else] can we do?" she said.
According to Justice Minister Tharcisse Karugarama, community service is not intended to trivialize the seriousness of the crimes.
"We are trying to foster reconciliation among killers and victims," Karugarama told IRIN. "What is most important is to ensure a follow-up as some of these people still harbour genocide ideology upon returning back to their villages."
Michael Kanimba, a 21-year-old student in Kigali, whose father was recently sentenced to two years of community service, supported the idea of community service. "Those convicts are slowly turned into responsible citizens to [enable them to] live side by side with genocide survivors," he said.
Source: IRIN
"The punishment should be [close] to the pain those inmates inflicted," Theodore Simburudali, the chairman of the genocide survivor organization, Ibuka, told IRIN.
He urged the government to do more to stop the killing of genocide survivors in parts of the country.
Ibuka has frequently decried the killing of survivors, most often after testifying against suspects in the courts. Some genocide suspects and convicts, according to the organization, single out the survivors for revenge.
"We need to [implore] Rwandan officials to [see] the seriousness of the issue because genocide survivors are still the targets of those who slaughtered their families, rather than expecting [them] to live in the same community with murderers," Simburudali added.
At least 106,918 convicts have gone through the programme, referred to as TIG (Travaux d'Intérêt Général), since its inception in 2005, according to the government.
Under Rwandan law certain categories of genocide perpetrators serve part of their prison term in jail with the remainder as community service, in a bid to decongest the prisons and foster reconciliation, say government officials.
"This punishment allows the [perpetrators] to acquire new professional skills that will help facilitate their reintegration into society, as well as to turn them into good citizens," Evariste Bizimana, TIG executive coordinator, told IRIN. "They [the TIG inmates] have been able to learn vocational skills, while building several houses for vulnerable people, many of whom are genocide survivors."
Under TIG, inmates build houses for vulnerable groups, and community infrastructure such as roads, and are also involved in agricultural activities.
"This programme is part of a reconciliation process as we need to educate those killers who confess their crimes [in order] to live side-by-side with genocide survivors," Bizimana added. "[They] must understand that this is a punishment, not merely a transit camp to be reintegrated into society."
Those sentenced to community service are housed in camps around the country and are not remunerated. Many now show remorse.
Thaddeo Munyansanga, a Hutu who was working in a Tutsi household before 1994 said: "When the killing started, I was told by the [Interahamwe] militia that I would end up owning all my former boss's belongings."
Munyansanga's house was located a short distance from his former boss's widow, Philomène Uwinyange, in Kibirizi village in the south.
"I regret all that I did, I now hope that Uwinyange will accept my apologies," Munyansanga told IRIN. "I don't want to push her any further to forgive me. It is a matter of time, considering the seriousness of our [actions]."
Uwinyange, 56, takes care of three adopted children – her children were killed in the genocide. "We have no choice [but to] reconcile with those who killed our relatives. What [else] can we do?" she said.
According to Justice Minister Tharcisse Karugarama, community service is not intended to trivialize the seriousness of the crimes.
"We are trying to foster reconciliation among killers and victims," Karugarama told IRIN. "What is most important is to ensure a follow-up as some of these people still harbour genocide ideology upon returning back to their villages."
Michael Kanimba, a 21-year-old student in Kigali, whose father was recently sentenced to two years of community service, supported the idea of community service. "Those convicts are slowly turned into responsible citizens to [enable them to] live side by side with genocide survivors," he said.
Source: IRIN
Sunday, May 02, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
France Resumes Investigation Into Death Of Rwanda President 16 Years Ago
A commission of five experts entrusted with ascertaining the circumstances, mandates and authors of the downing of the aircraft that 16 years ago caused the death of Rwandan president Juvenal Habyarimana (and his Burundian counterpart Cyprien Ntaryamira), which many consider to be the spark that prompted the Rwandan genocide.
The commission was instituted by French judge Marc Trevidic.
The judge has thus revived the investigation into the responsibilities of the crash of the presidential Falcon 50 jet, at the origin of the break in Franco-Rwnadan diplomatic relations three years ago, and which have only managed to be re-established recently.
In November 2006, the judge who was managing the investigation, Jean-Louis Brugière, had issued arrest warrants against some members of the entourage of current president Paul Kagame, suspected of having had a responsibility in the episode.
According to the version of Kagame’s Rwandan Patriotic Front, which took power after the end of the genocide, the responsibilities in the crash of Habyarimana’s plane are attributable to the Hutu extremists who committed the massacres of 1994.
The daily ‘Le Parisien’, says that judge Trevidic intends to go to Rwanda along with experts that he has nominated and get conclusions within a year. This year is especially significant for Rwanda, as it is getting ready for the presidential elections of next August 25.
Source: Original reporting by MISNA
The commission was instituted by French judge Marc Trevidic.
The judge has thus revived the investigation into the responsibilities of the crash of the presidential Falcon 50 jet, at the origin of the break in Franco-Rwnadan diplomatic relations three years ago, and which have only managed to be re-established recently.
In November 2006, the judge who was managing the investigation, Jean-Louis Brugière, had issued arrest warrants against some members of the entourage of current president Paul Kagame, suspected of having had a responsibility in the episode.
According to the version of Kagame’s Rwandan Patriotic Front, which took power after the end of the genocide, the responsibilities in the crash of Habyarimana’s plane are attributable to the Hutu extremists who committed the massacres of 1994.
The daily ‘Le Parisien’, says that judge Trevidic intends to go to Rwanda along with experts that he has nominated and get conclusions within a year. This year is especially significant for Rwanda, as it is getting ready for the presidential elections of next August 25.
Source: Original reporting by MISNA
Wednesday, April 28, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
DR Congo: Protecting Peace Accords Amid Hopes And Fears
“Civil society hopes that the signatories of the Goma peace accords will find the way to resolve today’s problems. After all the efforts made to achieve these accords, it would be inconceivable to question once again the arduous pacification process”,Solange Lwashiga, leading representative of women’s peace groups in South Kivu, told MISNA.
Lwashiga was commenting on the announcement of a formation of an alliance between different rebel groups accusing the government of DR Congo of failing to apply the pace accords.
“We have heard rumors concernin g this so called alliance, but so far nothing specific and pragmatic. However, in our efforts to sensitize the armed groups, we have effectively found malcontent by those feeling that they have been sidelined or whose who felt they did not get the office they deserved," Lwashiga said,
The former rebels, who have fomented tensions, fears and fighting for years in the regions near the borders with Rwanda and Uganda, and it has been difficult to integrate them in the military and political life of the country.
“Among the representatives of power, there are certainly those who do not wish to leave their place, especially to former combatants,” said Gogo Kazira, a representative of the Collective of Women’s Associations for Development (Cafede), speaking to MISNA from Goma, capital of North Kivu.
“The armed groups’ announcement is discomforting for the populations of our areas,” said Ms. Kazira, who noted that in the past a few sparks were able to set off violence in the region.
The Kinshasa daily ‘Le Potentiel’ observes that the new alliance of groups that were enemies in the past was announced while insurgents were attacking the airport in Mbandaka, thousands of kilometers away, but at a delicate period for the region’s future, characterized by elections in Sudan, in Burundi, in Rwanda and in 2011 in the DR Congo itself.
Source: Original reporting MISNA
Lwashiga was commenting on the announcement of a formation of an alliance between different rebel groups accusing the government of DR Congo of failing to apply the pace accords.
“We have heard rumors concernin g this so called alliance, but so far nothing specific and pragmatic. However, in our efforts to sensitize the armed groups, we have effectively found malcontent by those feeling that they have been sidelined or whose who felt they did not get the office they deserved," Lwashiga said,
The former rebels, who have fomented tensions, fears and fighting for years in the regions near the borders with Rwanda and Uganda, and it has been difficult to integrate them in the military and political life of the country.
“Among the representatives of power, there are certainly those who do not wish to leave their place, especially to former combatants,” said Gogo Kazira, a representative of the Collective of Women’s Associations for Development (Cafede), speaking to MISNA from Goma, capital of North Kivu.
“The armed groups’ announcement is discomforting for the populations of our areas,” said Ms. Kazira, who noted that in the past a few sparks were able to set off violence in the region.
The Kinshasa daily ‘Le Potentiel’ observes that the new alliance of groups that were enemies in the past was announced while insurgents were attacking the airport in Mbandaka, thousands of kilometers away, but at a delicate period for the region’s future, characterized by elections in Sudan, in Burundi, in Rwanda and in 2011 in the DR Congo itself.
Source: Original reporting MISNA
Wednesday, April 14, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Rwanda Cleric Says Approval Of Second Gay US Bishop Is Divisive
By Fredrick Nzwili
Anglican Archbishop Emmanuel Kolini of Rwanda has warned that the approval of a second openly homosexual bishop in the U.S. Episcopal Church will further tear apart the 77-million-member worldwide Anglican Communion.
In an interview with Ecumenical News International in Kigali, Kolini said the ratification will make it harder for the grouping to heal the rift created by the debate on homosexuality over the years.
"It is clear that those on both sides of the issue are not of the same mind and are not going to work together," he told ENI in an interview on 24 March during which he accused Western churches of imposing homosexuality onto the South.
The Rev. Mary Glasspool, who has lived with a female partner for 22 years, on 17 March, received the required number of votes from bishops and standing committees to be elected as the bishop of Los Angeles, making her the Episcopal Church's second openly homosexual bishop.
In 2003, Bishop V. Gene Robinson was elected the bishop of New Hampshire. After Robinson's election, a number of Anglican bishops, mainly in the South, broke ties with Episcopalians. Four U.S. dioceses and dozens of parishes have also left the Episcopal Church since then.
Kolini in the past has used the terms "moral genocide" in referring to homosexuality among Christians in his country, which suffered genocide in 1994. He said in the interview he believes that the churches in the South have a responsibility to show the way to their people over the matter.
The Rwandan church leader said differences over homosexuality in the Anglican Communion are cultural, although some provinces, or church regions, want them to be seen as biblical. Kolini believes that homosexuality is being forced on the developing world. He described this as a new form of "cultural imperialism".
"They ask us to read the Bible with them [on the issue], but the difference is culture; it is not the understanding of the Bible," said Kolini. "If they interpret it in their own cultural contexts, let them keep it that way with themselves. It is not supposed to be imposed upon us."
African Anglican dioceses have been consecrating bishops to serve in a splinter U.S. church formed as a result of the split over homosexuality and Rwanda has 10 bishops serving under the Anglican Mission in the Americas, a group launched in 2000.
Source: ENI
Anglican Archbishop Emmanuel Kolini of Rwanda has warned that the approval of a second openly homosexual bishop in the U.S. Episcopal Church will further tear apart the 77-million-member worldwide Anglican Communion.
In an interview with Ecumenical News International in Kigali, Kolini said the ratification will make it harder for the grouping to heal the rift created by the debate on homosexuality over the years.
"It is clear that those on both sides of the issue are not of the same mind and are not going to work together," he told ENI in an interview on 24 March during which he accused Western churches of imposing homosexuality onto the South.
The Rev. Mary Glasspool, who has lived with a female partner for 22 years, on 17 March, received the required number of votes from bishops and standing committees to be elected as the bishop of Los Angeles, making her the Episcopal Church's second openly homosexual bishop.
In 2003, Bishop V. Gene Robinson was elected the bishop of New Hampshire. After Robinson's election, a number of Anglican bishops, mainly in the South, broke ties with Episcopalians. Four U.S. dioceses and dozens of parishes have also left the Episcopal Church since then.
Kolini in the past has used the terms "moral genocide" in referring to homosexuality among Christians in his country, which suffered genocide in 1994. He said in the interview he believes that the churches in the South have a responsibility to show the way to their people over the matter.
The Rwandan church leader said differences over homosexuality in the Anglican Communion are cultural, although some provinces, or church regions, want them to be seen as biblical. Kolini believes that homosexuality is being forced on the developing world. He described this as a new form of "cultural imperialism".
"They ask us to read the Bible with them [on the issue], but the difference is culture; it is not the understanding of the Bible," said Kolini. "If they interpret it in their own cultural contexts, let them keep it that way with themselves. It is not supposed to be imposed upon us."
African Anglican dioceses have been consecrating bishops to serve in a splinter U.S. church formed as a result of the split over homosexuality and Rwanda has 10 bishops serving under the Anglican Mission in the Americas, a group launched in 2000.
Source: ENI
Friday, April 02, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Presidential Elections Puts Rwanda Under Scrutiny
Rwanda's upcoming presidential elections has cast a spotlight on its democratic credentials, with observers warning that allegations of intimidation of opposition leaders could mar the process.
"It is a very important event for our country because it is the second time we are electing a head of state," Chrysologue Karangwa, President of the Electoral Commission, told IRIN. "The people are preparing themselves for it."
Observers say the prevailing political environment restricts opponents of the ruling Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF).
“Rwanda needs to allow the democratic process, to create political space for everybody,” a Nairobi-based regional analyst, who requested anonymity, said. “Otherwise the elections will be a fait accompli. That will undermine Rwanda's democratic growth.”
Paul Kagame has been president since March 2000, after leading the RPF to power in July 1994 and ending the Rwandan genocide. The slaughter of more than 800,000 Tutsis and moderate Hutus was by far the bloodiest chapter in a long power struggle between the minority Tutsis and majority Hutus.
In August 2003, Kagame won 95 percent of the votes in the first national elections since 1994. His main competitor, Faustin Twagiramungu, won 3.5 percent.
Kagame is widely expected to be nominated again as the RPF flag-bearer in the 9 August election, but recent incidents involving other potential candidates have fuelled concerns that the poll will not be fair.
Election questions
"It is very difficult to imagine any opposition candidates who can get a significant share of the votes," Thomas Cargill, assistant head of the Africa Programme at Chatham House, said. "The RPF dominates political life in Rwanda, but it is good for Rwanda to start going through the motions."
He warned, however, that elections sometimes delivered only a semblance of democracy. "Like Ethiopia and Uganda, the governments of the day need to maintain the strings of power in some kind of democratic process. So you need an opposition.
"These governments tread a fine line - allow the opposition to operate and field candidates, but in a way that does not readily give them any chance," he added.
Aid workers in the capital, Kigali, and in Goma, in neighbouring Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), are concerned about the potential fallout.
"A political crisis in Rwanda could trigger a humanitarian problem, including displacement across borders," an international security observer at an aid mission in Goma told IRIN. "There is also the unresolved question of armed Rwandan militias in DRC."
The alleged “lack of political space” in Rwanda is frequently cited by the Hutu diaspora, refugees and such DRC-based militias to justify their refusal to return home.
Karangwa insisted nothing would disrupt the polls. "I can assure you the forthcoming elections are going to be free and fair," he told IRIN on 10 March. "We are working towards that objective and are totally open."
Jean Paul Kimonyo, a policy adviser to Kagame, writing in The New Times newspaper of 9 March, said the country was on the right political track. "The issue here is how do you ensure political cooperation when confrontational politics will almost certainly lead to renewed violence?
"Under President Kagame’s leadership, Rwanda has persistently ensured ownership of its nation building process by its citizens. It is much more challenging but certainly more promising."
Impressive gains
Rwanda has, since 1994, recorded impressive gains towards the Millennium Development Goals, according to the UN Development Programme. Primary school enrolment, for example, is now 97 percent of all school-going age children.
Family planning, according to the World Bank, has tripled in the last three years, while assisted deliveries have increased from 39 to 52 percent. The use of insecticide-treated nets is up by 70 percent, and under-five mortality has fallen by 30 percent.
Policies and laws that guarantee equal opportunities for men and women, according to the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, have resulted in Rwanda holding a world record of women parliamentarians: 56.3 percent, just ahead of Sweden at 46.4 percent.
This year, according to Finance and Economic Planning Minister John Rwangombwa, the economy should grow by 7-8 percent, up from 5.5 percent in 2009.
Nevertheless, Rwanda “needs to open up and encourage past wounds to heal positively”, a diplomat in the capital, Kigali, told IRIN. Advocacy groups claim a lack of respect for basic political and human rights, and harassment of perceived political opponents.
According to the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI), an Indian NGO, article 13 of Rwanda’s constitution, which makes it an offence to engage in “revisionism” or “negationism” [denial of genocide], has been “broadly defined to include anyone who disagrees with the ruling RPF’s account of the genocide”.
"CHRI is deeply concerned at the continued restrictions and threats to opposition parties in the run-up to Rwanda’s Presidential elections,” it said in 6 March statement.
Referring to a 25 February warning by the security ministry that politicians who “slander the country” or are “against public unity” would be punished, it called for “immediate steps to ensure respect for the basic, universal rights to freedom of expression, freedom of association and peaceful assembly of opposition parties”.
Attacks on opponents
The 3 February attack on Victoire Ingabire, president of the United Democratic Forces party, and her aide Joseph Ntawangundi, by a mob in Kigali was the most visible example of opposition harassment so far, the Nairobi analyst said. Attacked while reportedly collecting party registration documents, she reportedly lost her passport, while Ntawangundi was severely beaten.
Ingabire returned to Rwanda in January, after living in Europe for 16 years. During a visit to the Gisozi Genocide memorial site, she upset survivor groups by alluding to the killing of Hutus, 85 percent of the population.
The day after the attack on Ingabire, Frank Habineza, president of the Green Party, reported being threatened. Earlier, the leader of the Ideal Social Party, Bernard Ntaganda, was called before the senate to answer accusations relating to propagation of genocide ideology.
Soon after, local government minister James Musoni warned politicians "who violate the constitution and the rule of law by politicking along ethnic lines. Whatever they do should not be a stumbling block to people's peace, unity and security," he said in a press statement.
“Politicians and all those who wish to practise politics are not allowed to do anything that undermines the sovereignty of Rwanda and its citizens."
The attack on Ingabire, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said, “appeared to have been well coordinated, suggesting it had been planned in advance”.
"The Rwandan government already tightly controls political space," said Georgette Gagnon, HRW’s Africa director. "These incidents will further undermine democracy by discouraging any meaningful opposition in the elections. On several occasions, the government has used accusations of participation in the genocide or ‘genocide ideology’, as a way of targeting and discrediting its critics.”
Karangwa denounced HRW. "That woman has not been beaten, not at all," he told IRIN. "I do not believe the entire Human Rights Watch report. In our country there is no intimidation or harassment of opposition leaders."
Kigali resident Joseph Barigye said Ingabire had "provoked" people. "The memories [of the genocide] are still fresh, so one needs to talk to people carefully," he told IRIN. "And that is the reason Kagame will win again."
Silencing critics
Ingabire, in an interview with The EastAfrican newspaper on 15 February, said: “Kagame's government is not ready to accept opposition. This is why they sent young men to beat me and my aide two weeks ago - which was a true reflection of the lack of democracy and freedom of expression in Rwanda.
“This treatment extends to all opposition politicians,” she added. “We are not enemies. Instead, he uses the genocide ideology against us. The genocide took place 16 years ago and now is the time for democracy.”
Kagame told a recent news conference that Ingabire had "gone too far in abusing the country’s goodwill in attempting to destroy [Rwanda’s] positive steps", but "whoever tries to act in contradiction to what the laws say will not be given room".
Meanwhile, there are concerns about Kagame’s relations with the media after he publicly accused unnamed journalists of conspiring with two former military officers he accused of carrying out two recent grenade attacks in the capital.
“Kagame’s televised warnings will help silence critics prior to the August presidential election," wrote Tom Rhodes, Africa programme coordinator of the Committee to Protect Journalists, on the organization’s website.
“With pro-government media outlets outweighing the country’s beleaguered private press, the chances of balanced election coverage are now slimmer than ever,” he added.
Chatham House’s Cargill said Rwanda's past had to be put in context. "There are clearly some authoritarian tendencies within the Rwandan state, but Rwanda is coming from a place few countries have to been in recent years," he told IRIN. "Still, there is a need for balance because the government is using all the advantages of incumbency."
Source: IRIN
"It is a very important event for our country because it is the second time we are electing a head of state," Chrysologue Karangwa, President of the Electoral Commission, told IRIN. "The people are preparing themselves for it."
Observers say the prevailing political environment restricts opponents of the ruling Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF).
“Rwanda needs to allow the democratic process, to create political space for everybody,” a Nairobi-based regional analyst, who requested anonymity, said. “Otherwise the elections will be a fait accompli. That will undermine Rwanda's democratic growth.”
Paul Kagame has been president since March 2000, after leading the RPF to power in July 1994 and ending the Rwandan genocide. The slaughter of more than 800,000 Tutsis and moderate Hutus was by far the bloodiest chapter in a long power struggle between the minority Tutsis and majority Hutus.
In August 2003, Kagame won 95 percent of the votes in the first national elections since 1994. His main competitor, Faustin Twagiramungu, won 3.5 percent.
Kagame is widely expected to be nominated again as the RPF flag-bearer in the 9 August election, but recent incidents involving other potential candidates have fuelled concerns that the poll will not be fair.
Election questions
"It is very difficult to imagine any opposition candidates who can get a significant share of the votes," Thomas Cargill, assistant head of the Africa Programme at Chatham House, said. "The RPF dominates political life in Rwanda, but it is good for Rwanda to start going through the motions."
He warned, however, that elections sometimes delivered only a semblance of democracy. "Like Ethiopia and Uganda, the governments of the day need to maintain the strings of power in some kind of democratic process. So you need an opposition.
"These governments tread a fine line - allow the opposition to operate and field candidates, but in a way that does not readily give them any chance," he added.
Aid workers in the capital, Kigali, and in Goma, in neighbouring Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), are concerned about the potential fallout.
"A political crisis in Rwanda could trigger a humanitarian problem, including displacement across borders," an international security observer at an aid mission in Goma told IRIN. "There is also the unresolved question of armed Rwandan militias in DRC."
The alleged “lack of political space” in Rwanda is frequently cited by the Hutu diaspora, refugees and such DRC-based militias to justify their refusal to return home.
Karangwa insisted nothing would disrupt the polls. "I can assure you the forthcoming elections are going to be free and fair," he told IRIN on 10 March. "We are working towards that objective and are totally open."
Jean Paul Kimonyo, a policy adviser to Kagame, writing in The New Times newspaper of 9 March, said the country was on the right political track. "The issue here is how do you ensure political cooperation when confrontational politics will almost certainly lead to renewed violence?
"Under President Kagame’s leadership, Rwanda has persistently ensured ownership of its nation building process by its citizens. It is much more challenging but certainly more promising."
Impressive gains
Rwanda has, since 1994, recorded impressive gains towards the Millennium Development Goals, according to the UN Development Programme. Primary school enrolment, for example, is now 97 percent of all school-going age children.
Family planning, according to the World Bank, has tripled in the last three years, while assisted deliveries have increased from 39 to 52 percent. The use of insecticide-treated nets is up by 70 percent, and under-five mortality has fallen by 30 percent.
Policies and laws that guarantee equal opportunities for men and women, according to the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, have resulted in Rwanda holding a world record of women parliamentarians: 56.3 percent, just ahead of Sweden at 46.4 percent.
This year, according to Finance and Economic Planning Minister John Rwangombwa, the economy should grow by 7-8 percent, up from 5.5 percent in 2009.
Nevertheless, Rwanda “needs to open up and encourage past wounds to heal positively”, a diplomat in the capital, Kigali, told IRIN. Advocacy groups claim a lack of respect for basic political and human rights, and harassment of perceived political opponents.
According to the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI), an Indian NGO, article 13 of Rwanda’s constitution, which makes it an offence to engage in “revisionism” or “negationism” [denial of genocide], has been “broadly defined to include anyone who disagrees with the ruling RPF’s account of the genocide”.
"CHRI is deeply concerned at the continued restrictions and threats to opposition parties in the run-up to Rwanda’s Presidential elections,” it said in 6 March statement.
Referring to a 25 February warning by the security ministry that politicians who “slander the country” or are “against public unity” would be punished, it called for “immediate steps to ensure respect for the basic, universal rights to freedom of expression, freedom of association and peaceful assembly of opposition parties”.
Attacks on opponents
The 3 February attack on Victoire Ingabire, president of the United Democratic Forces party, and her aide Joseph Ntawangundi, by a mob in Kigali was the most visible example of opposition harassment so far, the Nairobi analyst said. Attacked while reportedly collecting party registration documents, she reportedly lost her passport, while Ntawangundi was severely beaten.
Ingabire returned to Rwanda in January, after living in Europe for 16 years. During a visit to the Gisozi Genocide memorial site, she upset survivor groups by alluding to the killing of Hutus, 85 percent of the population.
The day after the attack on Ingabire, Frank Habineza, president of the Green Party, reported being threatened. Earlier, the leader of the Ideal Social Party, Bernard Ntaganda, was called before the senate to answer accusations relating to propagation of genocide ideology.
Soon after, local government minister James Musoni warned politicians "who violate the constitution and the rule of law by politicking along ethnic lines. Whatever they do should not be a stumbling block to people's peace, unity and security," he said in a press statement.
“Politicians and all those who wish to practise politics are not allowed to do anything that undermines the sovereignty of Rwanda and its citizens."
The attack on Ingabire, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said, “appeared to have been well coordinated, suggesting it had been planned in advance”.
"The Rwandan government already tightly controls political space," said Georgette Gagnon, HRW’s Africa director. "These incidents will further undermine democracy by discouraging any meaningful opposition in the elections. On several occasions, the government has used accusations of participation in the genocide or ‘genocide ideology’, as a way of targeting and discrediting its critics.”
Karangwa denounced HRW. "That woman has not been beaten, not at all," he told IRIN. "I do not believe the entire Human Rights Watch report. In our country there is no intimidation or harassment of opposition leaders."
Kigali resident Joseph Barigye said Ingabire had "provoked" people. "The memories [of the genocide] are still fresh, so one needs to talk to people carefully," he told IRIN. "And that is the reason Kagame will win again."
Silencing critics
Ingabire, in an interview with The EastAfrican newspaper on 15 February, said: “Kagame's government is not ready to accept opposition. This is why they sent young men to beat me and my aide two weeks ago - which was a true reflection of the lack of democracy and freedom of expression in Rwanda.
“This treatment extends to all opposition politicians,” she added. “We are not enemies. Instead, he uses the genocide ideology against us. The genocide took place 16 years ago and now is the time for democracy.”
Kagame told a recent news conference that Ingabire had "gone too far in abusing the country’s goodwill in attempting to destroy [Rwanda’s] positive steps", but "whoever tries to act in contradiction to what the laws say will not be given room".
Meanwhile, there are concerns about Kagame’s relations with the media after he publicly accused unnamed journalists of conspiring with two former military officers he accused of carrying out two recent grenade attacks in the capital.
“Kagame’s televised warnings will help silence critics prior to the August presidential election," wrote Tom Rhodes, Africa programme coordinator of the Committee to Protect Journalists, on the organization’s website.
“With pro-government media outlets outweighing the country’s beleaguered private press, the chances of balanced election coverage are now slimmer than ever,” he added.
Chatham House’s Cargill said Rwanda's past had to be put in context. "There are clearly some authoritarian tendencies within the Rwandan state, but Rwanda is coming from a place few countries have to been in recent years," he told IRIN. "Still, there is a need for balance because the government is using all the advantages of incumbency."
Source: IRIN
Thursday, March 11, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Barcelona Football Club President Opens Hall In Rwandan Refugee Camp
By Line Pedersen in Kibiza, Rwanda for UNHCR
Joan Laporta, president of Spanish football giant FC Barcelona, opened a special community hall for Congolese refugees during a visit earlier this month to Kiziba camp in Rwanda.
Laporta and Barcelona executives, guided by staff from the UN refugee agency, visited the hilltop camp in the north-west corner of the country last Thursday. Kiziba, home to some 19,000 refuges from Democratic Republic of the Congo's eastern provinces, is one of three camps to have benefitted from the special partnership between UNHCR, Nike and the FC Barcelona Foundation.
The youthful Barcelona chief received a warm welcome from the camp residents, many of whom knew about his team and were keen to meet him. "Barcelona has done a lot to enable us to play sports in the camp," said 17-year-old Arsene, whose family fled from the Democratic Republic of the Congo when he was only two years old.
The highlight of the visit was the opening of the multi-purpose hall, where refugees will be able to hold cultural events and community meetings as well as play indoor sports and watch television. The hall will also be used for educational purposes and workshops. It was built with funding from the FC Barcelona Foundation.
"It will become the central place for strengthening community life," predicted Manuel Dos Santos, head of the UNHCR field office at Kiziba, adding that it was popularly known as Barça Hall.
This was the first time that Laporta had visited a UNHCR field operation or a refugee camp, but Barcelona has been providing support to the refugees in Kizimba, Nyabiheke and Gihembe camps since he signed a three-year partnership agreement with High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres in 2008.
"Thanks to everybody for putting their hearts into this," Laporta said in an address to the refugees. "The best sporting decision I ever made was to develop the Foundation to help people like you."
Many of the younger refugees, such as Arsene, play football in the camp and follow Barcelona and other big European teams on TV. "I can't believe the president of Barça has come here. We are very happy. It means a lot to us," Arsene said.
Laporta also visited the Kigali Memorial Centre, which was opened in 2004 to remember the estimated 800,000 people who lost their lives during the ethnic bloodletting of 1994.
On his return to Spain, Laporta attended activities in the southern port of Almeria linked to the departure on Sunday of a Play4Africa convoy, an initiative supported by both Barcelona and UNHCR. The Play4Africa vehicles will travel through 14 countries on their way to Cape Town in time for the World Cup football finals.
They will be stopping at dozens of towns en route, handing out footballs, boots and humanitarian aid to needy people. The beneficiaries will also include thousands of young refugee sport lovers in countries such as Sudan, Rwanda and Kenya. UNHCR is providing some logistical support.
Joan Laporta, president of Spanish football giant FC Barcelona, opened a special community hall for Congolese refugees during a visit earlier this month to Kiziba camp in Rwanda.
Laporta and Barcelona executives, guided by staff from the UN refugee agency, visited the hilltop camp in the north-west corner of the country last Thursday. Kiziba, home to some 19,000 refuges from Democratic Republic of the Congo's eastern provinces, is one of three camps to have benefitted from the special partnership between UNHCR, Nike and the FC Barcelona Foundation.
The youthful Barcelona chief received a warm welcome from the camp residents, many of whom knew about his team and were keen to meet him. "Barcelona has done a lot to enable us to play sports in the camp," said 17-year-old Arsene, whose family fled from the Democratic Republic of the Congo when he was only two years old.
The highlight of the visit was the opening of the multi-purpose hall, where refugees will be able to hold cultural events and community meetings as well as play indoor sports and watch television. The hall will also be used for educational purposes and workshops. It was built with funding from the FC Barcelona Foundation.
"It will become the central place for strengthening community life," predicted Manuel Dos Santos, head of the UNHCR field office at Kiziba, adding that it was popularly known as Barça Hall.
This was the first time that Laporta had visited a UNHCR field operation or a refugee camp, but Barcelona has been providing support to the refugees in Kizimba, Nyabiheke and Gihembe camps since he signed a three-year partnership agreement with High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres in 2008.
"Thanks to everybody for putting their hearts into this," Laporta said in an address to the refugees. "The best sporting decision I ever made was to develop the Foundation to help people like you."
Many of the younger refugees, such as Arsene, play football in the camp and follow Barcelona and other big European teams on TV. "I can't believe the president of Barça has come here. We are very happy. It means a lot to us," Arsene said.
Laporta also visited the Kigali Memorial Centre, which was opened in 2004 to remember the estimated 800,000 people who lost their lives during the ethnic bloodletting of 1994.
On his return to Spain, Laporta attended activities in the southern port of Almeria linked to the departure on Sunday of a Play4Africa convoy, an initiative supported by both Barcelona and UNHCR. The Play4Africa vehicles will travel through 14 countries on their way to Cape Town in time for the World Cup football finals.
They will be stopping at dozens of towns en route, handing out footballs, boots and humanitarian aid to needy people. The beneficiaries will also include thousands of young refugee sport lovers in countries such as Sudan, Rwanda and Kenya. UNHCR is providing some logistical support.
Wednesday, March 10, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Tracking Male Circumcision Rollout In Africa
Medical male circumcision is now widely recognized as an important HIV prevention tool, and several African countries have included it in their national HIV strategies.
IRIN/PlusNews lists the progress of 13 nations in eastern and southern Africa identified as priority countries for male circumcision scale-up by the UN World Health Organization.
Kenya: An estimated 85 percent of men are circumcised, but just 40 percent of those in Nyanza province, which has the country's highest prevalence, have had the procedure. In 2008 the government launched a national campaign and by the end of 2009 more than 90,000 men had been circumcised, 40,000 of them during a two-month "rapid results" initiative in Nyanza.
The government aims to have all uncircumcised men - an estimated 1.1 million - undergo the procedure by 2013. Kenya is the only African country to have successfully rolled out male circumcision on such a large scale.
Zambia: Male circumcision prevalence is 13 percent, and Zambia aims to circumcise about 250,000 men every year. More than 16,000 men were circumcised at 11 sites in 2009, and the goal is to have 300 sites offering the services by 2014.
Swaziland: The Ministry of Health and Human Services plans to provide circumcision to 80 percent of men aged 15 to 24 by the end of 2014. Just eight percent of Swazi men are circumcised. The country - which has the world's highest HIV prevalence - developed a male circumcision strategy in 2008; by the end of 2009 more than 5,000 men had undergone the surgery.
Botswana: Five centres of excellence have been identified to scale-up circumcision services, and Botswana's Ministry of Health aims to reach at least 460,000 HIV negative men and boys below the age of 49 by 2012. More than 4,300 men have been circumcised since April 2009.
Zimbabwe: In April 2009 the pilot phase of service delivery began, during which 1,818 men were circumcised at four sites. A national male circumcision policy was launched in November 2009.
Rwanda: Since 2008 the government has been rolling out male circumcision in the army, where prevalence is 4.5 percent compared to a national rate of three percent. A recent study suggested that Rwanda should also be scaling up circumcision across a broad range of age groups, especially the very young, where the procedure was found to be highly cost-effective.
South Africa: The government has been criticized for moving too slowly in developing a national circumcision strategy. By December 2009 the country had a draft policy but no mechanisms for training, quality assurance, or monitoring and evaluation. South Africa has the world's largest HIV-positive population.
About 35 percent of men are circumcised. Data from the only site currently providing free circumcision - Orange Farm, near Johannesburg - reveals that 14,253 men were circumcised in 2009.
Namibia: A draft policy was submitted to parliament and training of surgical health professionals is underway. Five circumcision pilot sites have been identified, two of which are in operation. A 2009 field analysis showed that the unit cost per procedure was very high: US$88 for adults and $72 for newborns.
Lesotho: About 4,000 men are circumcised annually at government and private clinics. A policy has been approved but is yet to be launched, and formal scale-up has not yet started. The Puisano Outreach Organization, a local NGO, is engaged in male circumcision campaigns throughout the country.
Tanzania: A 2009 situation analysis found male circumcision was accepted, even among traditionally non-circumcising communities, and 70 percent of Tanzanian men were circumcised. A national policy is being developed and three demonstration sites have been set up.
Mozambique: No formal policy for male circumcision has been developed, but an existing operational plan for HIV prevention includes circumcision. Five pilot sites have been selected for scale-up in 2010.
Malawi: The country is conducting data analysis to inform its male circumcision strategy. A local NGO, Banja la Mtsogolo, is providing male circumcision services in its clinics, where it has 19 trained clinicians performing the procedure.
Uganda: This is one of the three countries where studies showed the link between male circumcision and HIV, but only 25 percent of men are circumcised and HIV prevalence is rising. There has been some criticism for failing to start male circumcision quickly enough - the country still has no policy, nor has it started service delivery.
Source: IRIN
IRIN/PlusNews lists the progress of 13 nations in eastern and southern Africa identified as priority countries for male circumcision scale-up by the UN World Health Organization.
Kenya: An estimated 85 percent of men are circumcised, but just 40 percent of those in Nyanza province, which has the country's highest prevalence, have had the procedure. In 2008 the government launched a national campaign and by the end of 2009 more than 90,000 men had been circumcised, 40,000 of them during a two-month "rapid results" initiative in Nyanza.
The government aims to have all uncircumcised men - an estimated 1.1 million - undergo the procedure by 2013. Kenya is the only African country to have successfully rolled out male circumcision on such a large scale.
Zambia: Male circumcision prevalence is 13 percent, and Zambia aims to circumcise about 250,000 men every year. More than 16,000 men were circumcised at 11 sites in 2009, and the goal is to have 300 sites offering the services by 2014.
Swaziland: The Ministry of Health and Human Services plans to provide circumcision to 80 percent of men aged 15 to 24 by the end of 2014. Just eight percent of Swazi men are circumcised. The country - which has the world's highest HIV prevalence - developed a male circumcision strategy in 2008; by the end of 2009 more than 5,000 men had undergone the surgery.
Botswana: Five centres of excellence have been identified to scale-up circumcision services, and Botswana's Ministry of Health aims to reach at least 460,000 HIV negative men and boys below the age of 49 by 2012. More than 4,300 men have been circumcised since April 2009.
Zimbabwe: In April 2009 the pilot phase of service delivery began, during which 1,818 men were circumcised at four sites. A national male circumcision policy was launched in November 2009.
Rwanda: Since 2008 the government has been rolling out male circumcision in the army, where prevalence is 4.5 percent compared to a national rate of three percent. A recent study suggested that Rwanda should also be scaling up circumcision across a broad range of age groups, especially the very young, where the procedure was found to be highly cost-effective.
South Africa: The government has been criticized for moving too slowly in developing a national circumcision strategy. By December 2009 the country had a draft policy but no mechanisms for training, quality assurance, or monitoring and evaluation. South Africa has the world's largest HIV-positive population.
About 35 percent of men are circumcised. Data from the only site currently providing free circumcision - Orange Farm, near Johannesburg - reveals that 14,253 men were circumcised in 2009.
Namibia: A draft policy was submitted to parliament and training of surgical health professionals is underway. Five circumcision pilot sites have been identified, two of which are in operation. A 2009 field analysis showed that the unit cost per procedure was very high: US$88 for adults and $72 for newborns.
Lesotho: About 4,000 men are circumcised annually at government and private clinics. A policy has been approved but is yet to be launched, and formal scale-up has not yet started. The Puisano Outreach Organization, a local NGO, is engaged in male circumcision campaigns throughout the country.
Tanzania: A 2009 situation analysis found male circumcision was accepted, even among traditionally non-circumcising communities, and 70 percent of Tanzanian men were circumcised. A national policy is being developed and three demonstration sites have been set up.
Mozambique: No formal policy for male circumcision has been developed, but an existing operational plan for HIV prevention includes circumcision. Five pilot sites have been selected for scale-up in 2010.
Malawi: The country is conducting data analysis to inform its male circumcision strategy. A local NGO, Banja la Mtsogolo, is providing male circumcision services in its clinics, where it has 19 trained clinicians performing the procedure.
Uganda: This is one of the three countries where studies showed the link between male circumcision and HIV, but only 25 percent of men are circumcised and HIV prevalence is rising. There has been some criticism for failing to start male circumcision quickly enough - the country still has no policy, nor has it started service delivery.
Source: IRIN
Saturday, March 06, 2010 |
2
comments |
Read more...
New Genocide Cases Often Denied After Holocaust
Experiences from the Holocaust led to the international community coming together and agreeing on the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Despite this, more cases of genocide occurred during the 20th century than during any other century.
Research at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden, shows that it is precisely these comparisons with the Holocaust that have often hindered intervention on the part of the international community.
"The Holocaust is sometimes used by the international community as an excuse for not intervening in new cases of genocide," said Malin Isaksson, researcher at the University of Gothenburg, who has studied the way in which the Holocaust has been used in interpreting other cases of genocide during the post-war era.
The Holocaust is regarded as having given rise to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide; the legal document that aims to prevent and punish future cases of genocide. But since the Holocaust holds the exceptional position of being one of the biggest crimes against humanity, comparing it with other incidents resembling genocide has at times been controversial.
"This has meant that the Holocaust has become an important rhetorical tool for international figures in achieving various political aims in relation to other cases of genocide," said Malin Isaksson, who is defending a thesis in peace and development research.
Isaksson has also examined the impact of the Holocaust being used as a frame of reference on the introduction of the Genocide Convention, mainly considering the way in which the international community has acted.
"The Genocide Convention only comes into force if the case in question is defined as genocide, according to the criteria detailed under the convention. Comparisons are often made with the Holocaust, which means that few cases are recognised as genocide by the international community, Isaksson said, adding that, "This does not necessarily mean that the case doesn't meet the criteria. It is often a matter of the international community attempting to circumvent the obligation to intervene that is set out in the convention. This in turn is down to a lack of political will to intervene. So you could maintain that the Holocaust is sometimes held up not to prevent the reoccurrence of such events but with the very opposite aim."
Cases of genocide in Cambodia and Rwanda
As examples, Malin Isaksson has looked at how the international community acted during the cases of genocide in Cambodia and Rwanda.
"Comparisons were made with the Holocaust when the genocide in Cambodia was taking place. But at the beginning of the 1990s this comparison was no longer evident. By that time people had begun to regard the Holocaust as a unique event. This in turn meant that during the Rwandan genocide, almost no comparisons at all were made with the Holocaust. In official statements, the word 'genocide' was steered well clear of because the international community wanted to avoid intervention in what really they knew to be a case of genocide, in accordance with the convention," said Isaksson.
The various interpretations of the Holocaust have also not only affected the way in which the international community perceived different cases of genocide, but in actual fact enable various rhetorical justifications for the actions of the international community.
The conclusion is that the international community uses the Holocaust to uphold the norm of non-intervention, which in practice means that there is no intervention in cases of genocide.
"Perhaps it's not so difficult to understand that states act based on their own interests and volition, but it is harder to understand why that doesn't extend to preventing cases of genocide," Isaksson said.
Research at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden, shows that it is precisely these comparisons with the Holocaust that have often hindered intervention on the part of the international community.
"The Holocaust is sometimes used by the international community as an excuse for not intervening in new cases of genocide," said Malin Isaksson, researcher at the University of Gothenburg, who has studied the way in which the Holocaust has been used in interpreting other cases of genocide during the post-war era.
The Holocaust is regarded as having given rise to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide; the legal document that aims to prevent and punish future cases of genocide. But since the Holocaust holds the exceptional position of being one of the biggest crimes against humanity, comparing it with other incidents resembling genocide has at times been controversial.
"This has meant that the Holocaust has become an important rhetorical tool for international figures in achieving various political aims in relation to other cases of genocide," said Malin Isaksson, who is defending a thesis in peace and development research.
Isaksson has also examined the impact of the Holocaust being used as a frame of reference on the introduction of the Genocide Convention, mainly considering the way in which the international community has acted.
"The Genocide Convention only comes into force if the case in question is defined as genocide, according to the criteria detailed under the convention. Comparisons are often made with the Holocaust, which means that few cases are recognised as genocide by the international community, Isaksson said, adding that, "This does not necessarily mean that the case doesn't meet the criteria. It is often a matter of the international community attempting to circumvent the obligation to intervene that is set out in the convention. This in turn is down to a lack of political will to intervene. So you could maintain that the Holocaust is sometimes held up not to prevent the reoccurrence of such events but with the very opposite aim."
Cases of genocide in Cambodia and Rwanda
As examples, Malin Isaksson has looked at how the international community acted during the cases of genocide in Cambodia and Rwanda.
"Comparisons were made with the Holocaust when the genocide in Cambodia was taking place. But at the beginning of the 1990s this comparison was no longer evident. By that time people had begun to regard the Holocaust as a unique event. This in turn meant that during the Rwandan genocide, almost no comparisons at all were made with the Holocaust. In official statements, the word 'genocide' was steered well clear of because the international community wanted to avoid intervention in what really they knew to be a case of genocide, in accordance with the convention," said Isaksson.
The various interpretations of the Holocaust have also not only affected the way in which the international community perceived different cases of genocide, but in actual fact enable various rhetorical justifications for the actions of the international community.
The conclusion is that the international community uses the Holocaust to uphold the norm of non-intervention, which in practice means that there is no intervention in cases of genocide.
"Perhaps it's not so difficult to understand that states act based on their own interests and volition, but it is harder to understand why that doesn't extend to preventing cases of genocide," Isaksson said.
Monday, March 01, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...









