Why Arizona Should “Racially Profile”

By Selwyn Duke

When the Times Square bombing suspect was first reported to be a “white male,” I shook my head. I knew that, despite Mayor Bloomberg’s asinine musings about how the perpetrator was probably “homegrown” and perhaps someone upset about the healthcare bill, this was nonsense. “It’s about as likely as a story about Bill Clinton becoming a monk,” I thought.

Of course, this was no great insight. Given that 99 percent of the terrorists bedeviling us today are non-white Muslims, it was just common sense — otherwise known as profiling.

The critics of Arizona’s new immigration law complain that it will lead to “racial profiling.” In response, the law’s defenders point out that the legislation specifically forbids the practice.

Both groups are wrong.

They accept two false suppositions. The first is that the practice in question is immoral.

The second is that “racial profiling” actually exists.

Generally speaking, it does not — that is, not in the sense of a phenomenon widespread enough to warrant continual media attention. In reality, there are only two kinds of profiling: good profiling and bad profiling.

Let’s discuss the difference.

Profiling is simply a method by which law enforcement can determine the probability that an individual has committed a crime or has criminal intent. Now, when making this assessment, many different factors are considered. Some have to do with age, sex, dress, behavior, the car being driven, whether or not a person is “out of place” (e.g., a well-dressed fellow in a BMW cruising a drug-plagued neighborhood), and, yes, some have to do with race. But whatever the criteria, good profiling chooses them in accordance with sound criminological science. And as soon as we subordinate that standard to anything, such as political or social concerns, we have rendered it bad profiling.

We also render it unfair. That is, contrary to the notion that using racial factors in profiling is discriminatory, in the negative sense of the word, it is actually the refusal to consider them that is so.

I’ll explain. I’m a member of one of the most profiled groups in the country: males. Law enforcement views us much more suspiciously than females because we commit an inordinate amount of crime. And we aren’t the only ones, as youths also attract a jaundiced eye for the same reason. Now, if considering race when profiling is “racism,” isn’t considering sex and age “sexism” and “ageism”?

The truth is that none of these things are any kind of ism. And is it just to discriminate among higher-crime-incidence groups — scrutinizing some more closely but not others — based on whether they are in or out of favor politically and socially?

This is where the capital-D discrimination lies. If you’re male or a teen, you’re fair game. But, for instance, when the matter is Muslims, the double standards fly. When seeking to identify terrorists, the people who have no problem placing the probing eye on males warn that Muslims mustn’t receive extra scrutiny. But why? As far as the terrorist threat facing the West goes, “Muslim” is a more consistent part of the terrorist profile than is “male,” as there have been more female suicide bombers than non-Muslim ones.

Some may say we must be especially sensitive with regard to race (yes, I realize “Islamic” isn’t a race), but this is silly for two reasons. First, it is a hang-up; it is suicidal to sacrifice blood on the altar of political correctness. Second, there is no blanket refusal to consider racial factors when profiling. For example, part of the profile for serial killers and methamphetamine dealers is “Caucasian.”

Likewise, given that more than 90 percent of the illegals in Arizona hail from Mexico and Latin America, isn’t “Hispanic” part of the relevant profile here? Mind you, the operative word is “part.” To say “This person appears to be of Mexican descent, so he must be illegal” is no different than assuming that every white person deals meth — it would be bad profiling. But just as a meth dealer will usually exhibit characteristics that distinguish him from Morris the accountant, an illegal alien is usually distinguishable from an acculturated Hispanic American.

And what if you’re a citizen who doesn’t exhibit the differences or one who can’t distinguish them? If the former, now you know why assimilation matters. And what of the latter? Then you aren’t qualified to profile professionally.

Nevertheless, society needs those who are. As Dr. Walter Williams once wrote:

What about using race or ethnicity as proxies for some unobserved characteristic? Some racial and ethnic groups have a higher incidence of mortality from various diseases than the national average. In 1998, mortality rates for cardiovascular diseases were approximately 30 percent higher among black adults than among white adults. Cervical cancer rates were almost five times higher among Vietnamese women in the United States than among white women. The Pima Indians of Arizona have the highest known diabetes rates in the world. Prostate cancer is nearly twice as common among black men as white men.

My, those “racist” diseases. Of course, race’s and ethnicity’s value as proxies isn’t limited to physical disease but extends to so many things. Just ask Jesse Jackson. In 1993 he said, “There is nothing more painful to me . . . than to walk down the street and hear footsteps and start thinking about robbery, then look around and see somebody white and feel relieved.”

The reality is that we all profile. For example, everyone (not just ol’ Jena Jesse) has heard about something called a “suspicious-looking character.” Also, having been raised in New York City, I’ve often heard people be identified as “looking like tourists.” Now, what do you think these things mean? We are able to thus categorize people only because we’re all natural-born sociologists and psychologists; we all possess some understanding of man’s behavior, of what is normal in a given situation, and can use this knowledge to help assess others’ status and intent. Who wouldn’t be wary of someone with a buzz cut who sports a Swastika tattoo on his forehead? Who can’t identify an angry countenance as just that?

Of course, these are obvious examples, and the more subtle the behavior and signs, the more discerning the observer must be to note and draw correct conclusions from them. Regardless, this ability is good — and wholly necessary for survival. It is no different from how we profile animals and would pet the sheep but not the wolf; it allows us to avoid danger, both to our person and the kind that could result in being wronged. And when it’s applied by the police, we call it “profiling.” Yet it is nothing but the application of common sense within the sphere of law enforcement. Nevertheless, Jena Jesse and others would disallow good profiling and insist that the police check their common sense at the station-house door.

After Dr. Williams discusses how the prevalence of certain diseases correlates with race, he asks, “Would one condemn a medical practitioner for advising greater screening and monitoring of black males for cardiovascular disease and prostate cancer, or greater screening and monitoring for cervical cancer among Vietnamese American females, and the same for diabetes among Pima Indians?”

Unfortunately, when the matter is the social disease of crime, we not only condemn such a practice, we fire the good diagnosticians. For example, in an older article about former attorney general John Ashcroft’s investigation of 13 cities for “racial profiling” (thank you, George Bush), ABC reports on efforts to eradicate the practice and writes, “police officials who defended profiling have been removed from their posts.”

Translation: Our security has been placed in the hands of PC lackeys.

Lest I be misunderstood, I don’t say good profiling is the magic bullet for Arizona’s illegal alien problem. In point of fact, I presented more effective solutions in my piece “Immigration: Solutions, Not Excuses.” My point is a larger one: Whether the crime is violating borders, bodies or buildings, whether it’s committed in Arizona or Anytown USA, good profiling is not just part of law enforcement.

It’s the heart law enforcement.

What do you think the legal standard of “reasonable suspicion” is? What should the police be suspicious of? Only males, teens, and whites in certain situations?

The bigots are not those who support good profiling, which scrutinizes all groups in accordance with sound criminological science. It is the Times Square bombing-analyst hopers (such as Contessa Brewer) who play pin the tale on the honkey, doing their best imitation of the three blind, deaf and mute monkeys.

America, we need to end our hang-up with race — before it ends us.

Contact Selwyn Duke
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

The States Must Rise Again: The Only Way To Combat Obama’s Socialist Agenda

By Selwyn Duke

With the passage of ObamaCare coming on the heels of government takeover of industries and taxpayer-funded bailouts of the irresponsible, many are wondering how we can turn the socialist tide. They see Uncle Sam expanding, their rights and economic prospects shrinking and their voices ignored. For these people, November cannot come soon enough.

But November is not the ultimate solution. In the political universe, seven months is an eternity, and we cannot know precisely how public sentiment will evolve. Besides, the chances of Republicans retaking both Houses are slim and, even if they do, there’s no guarantee they’ll rise to the occasion. Some will be Scott Brown types — not the sort to give us tradition we can believe in.

A better solution lies on the local and state levels. Fifteen states are currently suing the federal government over ObamaCare, and then there is the Tenth Amendment Movement, involving at least 35 states that are asserting their sovereignty over powers granted them by that amendment. These are good starts, but . . . .

Question: What if the Supreme Court, in obvious violation of the Constitution, upholds ObamaCare? Do we simply obey unflinchingly and wait for the next federal usurpation?

Certainly, there is every reason to believe the Black Robes will thus rule, as enabling the Leviathan’s tyranny has become their practice. Of course, many legal “scholars” will provide oh-so intellectual justifications for the incessant expansion of federal power as they lawyer away our rights. But let’s look at what James Madison, considered the father of the Constitution, wrote in The Federalist, No. 45: 
The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite. The former will be exercised principally on external objects, as war, peace, negotiation, and foreign commerce . . . . 

When was the last time we had a government reflecting these limits? The truth is that Uncle Sam violates the Constitution ever more brazenly with the passage of time, adding to its power and subtracting from our rights. And it won’t stop unless someone stops it.

And it is time we stopped it. The states should send a message: Black Robes, if you won’t do your job, we will do it for you. No state resident shall be compelled to buy health insurance, and we will not cooperate in the enforcement of such a mandate. Furthermore, no federal agents may enter our territories for the purposes of such enforcement. And if they do, they will be arrested.

On top of this immediate concern, states should resolve that the same will apply to all other unconstitutional mandates — regardless of how established and longstanding they may be.

Period.

Now, many people — good people — will object to this prescription. “How can you defy the courts?” they will ask. “We must respect the rule of law.” But what is the law? The Constitution is the supreme law of the land. And when a government violates it, it loses its legitimacy, right to exist and legal authority.

Will we just accept an oligarchic judiciary and abide by its dictates no matter how onerous? Will we accept social engineers-cum-lawyers’ “interpretations” of plain language regardless of how contrary to the text they may be? What will we believe, them or our own eyes? If the former, we are not governed by the rule of law. We are governed by the rule of lawyers.

And let us understand fully the moral and legal validity of my counsel. The Constitution is the contract the American people have with one another, and enumerated in it are the rights and responsibilities of all those party to it. But it has one serious flaw.


It only works if you actually abide by it.

Now, what if one of the parties, being more powerful, continually violates the contract for the purposes of advantaging itself? Do you seek redress through the courts? Sure. What if, however, this party has the power to appoint judges sympathetic to its tyrannical aims? What if these judges, with a wink and a nod and legalistic mumbo-jumbo, aid and abet the party in its breach of contract? Do you just say, “Oh, well, that’s what the contract means now because they said so”? Or do you recognize a simple fact?

To wit: Through its habitual violation of the terms of the contract, the federal government has rendered it null and void.

Null and void. It is silly to think that states have an obligation to follow the law when the Leviathan violates it at will. It is to fight abiding by Queensberry rules while your opponent makes up his own rules. That is, if you can even characterize it as fighting and not genuflection.

I know my prescription is bold enough to scare many into believing all the more in November, but be under no illusions. The idea that we’re going to put the Leviathan in its proper place at the national ballot box is a pipe dream. The problem of extra-constitutional federal governance is not a new phenomenon; it is approximately 100 years old and so deeply ingrained that the central government views many violations of the Constitution as federal rights. Besides, the Founding Fathers gave us a balance of power between Washington and the states for a reason: Governments don’t willingly relinquish or limit their own power. Thus, it is naïve to think that “asking” the Leviathan to recede into its cage will bring anything but contemptuous laughter. For how long will we say “pretty please”? For how long will we play by the rules while the Leviathan plays with the rules? It’s time to stop asking and start telling.

Moreover, those of us who care about resurrecting tradition are in the minority. The 11 most populous states boast more than half our population and enough electoral votes to elect the president, and they are a decidedly liberal bunch. Obama won nine of them — most by wide margins — losing only Texas and Georgia. Four of them, California, New York, Illinois and New Jersey — which alone have a quarter of the U.S.’ population — are firmly entrenched in the statist camp; three of them, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Michigan, have one foot in that grave; and two of them, Florida and North Carolina, are teetering on the edge. And all of them, along with the rest of the West, are trending left.

It is time for the few remaining pockets of traditionalism to take control of their culture and destiny. If not now, when? Will the resurrection of manly virtue ever wait for the next usurpation? Will we wait until the Black Robes find a justification for hate-speech laws? Do we sit idly by while cultural traitors manufacture socialist votes by granting amnesty to 13-20 million illegals, people with no allegiance to our nation? Will we just watch them build a statist electoral phalanx that will support the redistribution of wealth and further constitutional trespass? I say no. States should send a message to the Leviathan: If you don’t do your job, we’ll do it for you. They should make clear that they will not recognize the citizenship of any individual who broke into our nation and was then given a get-out-of-jail-free-if-you-vote-for-me card.

Period.

What’s that you say? Immigration is a federal role?

Null and void.

And if asked about the constitutionality of the matter, I would just quote a very powerful woman second in line to the presidency: “Are you serious?! Are you serious?!

Yes, I am serious. It’s time to stop acting like an abused wife who’d rather take beating after beating after beating than leave the tyrant.

The sun will not come out in November. It rises with the vigilant, shines on the stout-hearted, and sets only when a nation’s courage sleeps.

Contact Selwyn Duke
Wednesday, April 07, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

And That’s All He Has To Say About That: Tom Hanks And Twisted History

By Selwyn Duke

Stupid is as Hollywood does . . . and does and does and does.  And the latest example is Forrest Hanks, who has just managed to graduate — in the Tinseltown U. way of thinking — from moron to imbecile. 


During a recent interview with Time magazine, Forrest (a.k.a. Tom Hanks) was discussing his new HBO WWII series The Pacific and, boy, did he ever deliver some gems.  What was the gist of it?

We Americans were out to kill the Japanese because, well, you know, we’re just so irredeemably “racist.”

Written by a Dan Winters, the Time piece opens with this line, “To the young Tom Hanks, history was as dull as an algebra equation.”  I’m sure.  After all, in his day, school curricula wanted for the kind of intellectual stimulation provided by things such as the demonization of Christianity, the West and America.  But never fear, Forrest is here, the man Winters calls “American history’s highest-profile professor,” who brings a “nuanced view of the past into the homes and lives of countless millions.”  

What might this nuance be?  Well, among other things, Forrest told Winters, “Back in World War II, we viewed the Japanese as ‘yellow, slant-eyed dogs’ that believed in different gods. They were out to kill us because our way of living was different. We, in turn, wanted to annihilate them because they were different. Does that sound familiar, by any chance, to what's going on today?”

Uh, no, Forrest, actually, it doesn’t.  In fact, it doesn’t even sound like what went on back then.

The fact is that both the Japanese and the Islamists have been different from us since before they were Japanese and Islamists and we were “us.” Yet this never inspired us to try to annihilate them.  And, as to why we did involve ourselves in the relevant conflicts, while I’m certainly not America’s highest-profile history professor, I seem to remember the dates of December 7, 1941 and September 11, 2001 as being somewhat significant.  I’ll also note that WWII saw us allied with the very different Chinese and Filipinos and fighting against the more consanguineous Germans (the German bloodline is the most common in the U.S.).   

This isn’t to say that one can’t question the wisdom of conflicts such as our Mideast campaigns.  I myself have pointed out the folly of trying to democratize cultures that are so — Forrest will love this — different from ours.  But to claim that we’re locking horns with Muslims because we consider them alien is stupid beyond words.  

But stupid is as Hanks does.  Something else he pulled out of his box of chocolates — the idea that we tried to “annihilate” the Japanese or that we are attempting the same with Muslims — is also profoundly silly.  When the Land of the Rising Sun finally fell in 1945, we were, in fact, remarkably merciful.  We didn’t sack and raze Tokyo or extract steep reparations.  On the contrary, we respected Japanese culture, allowing its people to retain their beloved emperor.  We also helped the nation get back on its feet and helped pave the way for the economic powerhouse status it would enjoy in the 1980s.  As for Iraq and Afghanistan, surgical strikes and lawyer-disgorged rules of engagement hardly constitute an attempt at annihilation.     
    
In fact, forget about Forrest being a professor, he fails even as a student.  Case in point: His lamenting the characterization of the Japanese as “yellow, slant-eyed dogs.”  Does anyone really think the use of such epithets makes us unique?  If so, know that the Japanese referred to us as “hairy white apes.” It’s part of the common wartime propaganda technique of demonizing and dehumanizing the enemy for the purposes of galvanizing public support for a total war effort.  

It is also true that prejudice is the rule for man, not the exception.  For instance, read the Bible, and it’s plain that the different peoples — Jews, Samaritans, etc. — harbored some very unflattering ideas about one another.  The Muslims are well-known for characterizing Jews as pigs and apes.  During the Ruandan genocide of 1994, the Hutus would refer to the Tutsis as “cockroaches.”  And then there are the Hollywood types such as Forrest.  They’re so prejudiced against America that they think America is uniquely prejudiced.
And theirs is a true prejudice.  Understand that the word doesn’t refer to holding negative opinions about other individuals or groups; it refers to holding such opinions when they have no basis in reality, when you cling to them in the face of all evidence to the contrary. 

This brings us to what really is a “nuanced” view.  In reality, the United States is the most tolerant nation on Earth.  We’re so darn tolerant, in fact, that we even countenance evil, such as the noxious cultural effluent that continually flows from Hollywood movies and mouths.  

We’re also more likely to find exotic cultures intriguing than detestable.  As to this, I think of the stereotypical portrayals of other peoples found in older cartoons, such as an Arabian in traditional garb wielding a scimitar.  While today CDs of such cartoons include disclaimers about the insensitivity and stereotypes found within, none of us children viewed such things with contempt.  On the contrary, we would have much rather met the Arabian than the policeman portrayed or visited his land than Chicago.  Of course, we would have been sorely disappointed if we had.  But this was only because the reality could never have measured up to a neat, fascinating portrayal that could make a nine-year-old mind fill with wonder.       


Having said this, we certainly can carry on a debate about wartime propaganda and ask if G.K. Chesterton was right when he said, “The true soldier fights not because he hates what is in front of him, but because he loves what is behind him.”  We also can and should bemoan prejudice.  But we should understand that we’re not bemoaning American nature.  We’re bemoaning man’s nature. 

Returning to Forrest’s conception of nuance, he also told Winters, “Certainly, we wanted to honor U.S. bravery in The Pacific.  But we also wanted to have people say, ‘We didn't know our troops did that to Japanese people.’”  Ah, Hollywood wrapping itself in the flag again — which flag I have no idea.

Let’s talk a bit about who did what to whom.  Unlike us, Japan’s treatment of prisoners more reflected pagan convention than Geneva Convention. In fact, a staggering 40 percent of American POWs in Japanese hands died (versus 37 percent in Korea and 15 percent in Vietnam).  

The most infamous example of such brutality was The Bataan Death March in the Philippines, where 75,000 Allied soldiers were taken prisoner.  Despite the fact that the captured forces were willing to provide trucks and fuel for their own transport, the Japanese military insisted on forcing the men — who were already sick and starving — to march for a week in tropical heat to faraway prison camps. And the savagery they were subject to is staggering.  Writes Wikipedia:
    Beheadings, cutting of throats and casual shootings were the more common actions—compared to instances of bayonet stabbing, rape, disembowelment, rifle butt beating and a deliberate refusal to allow the prisoners food or water while keeping them continually marching . . . . Falling down or inability to continue moving was tantamount to a death sentence, as was any degree of protest or expression of displeasure. 
At least a quarter of them died.

Yet the US did not respond in kind.  Our brutality was reserved for the battlefield and only exercised because we faced the Samurai creed incarnate, an enemy that was intent on fighting to the death.  And death is what they got.

As for Forrest, some may wonder how a man’s thinking can become so twisted.  Well, the Time interview may provide some insight in this regard.  It seems that Daddy Hanks served in WWII and left his boy with a very definite impression of his time in uniform.  Said Forrest, “He had nothing nice to say about the Navy. He hated the Navy. He hated everybody in the Navy. He had no glorious stories about it.”

Wow, everybody?  You mean, he didn’t encounter one nice person during all his time in the service?  There was no nobility, no virtue whatsoever?  Well, I guess Forrest’s particular talents don’t skip a generation.
Now, I should mention that my father not only served in WWII, he was a POW in Germany.  And while he also had no glorious tales, with the exception of a rather odious sergeant, he didn’t hate his comrades in arms.  In fact, he didn’t even dislike all his German captors (one of whom promised to protect him after the SS visited his camp and said that all the prisoners should be killed).  And should it be otherwise?  If you hate the whole world, it’s a good bet the world isn’t the problem.

As for my attitude, have I been too tough on Forrest?  Have I been a bully?  If so, I’ll be the first to say, run, Forrest!  Run!

Just not for political office.
                                                          Contact Selwyn Duke
Thursday, March 18, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Understanding the Global-warming Jihadists

By Selwyn Duke

"I was born with a chronic anxiety about the weather," said John Burroughs in 1877. Today, anxiety about the weather is more common than ever, although it’s not inborn but cultivated in schoolrooms, through television sets and by lying, rapacious ex-vice presidents. And I have anxiety about the weather, too — especially when it’s being used to promote a destructive agenda.

This brings us to Climategate, the scandal everyone is talking about and that inspired British journalist James Delingpole to write “it's [the climate con is] all unravelling now.” I only wish I could be so optimistic. Sure, we have the smoking gun of the hacked emails from the University of East Anglia, which provide evidence that we “deniers” were only denying a lie. And the erstwhile head of its Climatic Research Unit, Phil Jones — a con man with a science degree if ever there were one — had to resign in disgrace. But don’t for a moment confuse a smoking gun with a coup de grace, or being sacrificed for the team with waving the white flag. I say this because I long ago realized something about man’s nature, something that may sound like a gross exaggeration: If a person has a strong enough vested interest in believing 2+2=5, he will surely insist it is so — in the face of all evidence to the contrary. But before I talk about who the real deniers are and what is being denied, let’s discuss the ugly reality reaffirmed by Climategate.

Here is the lowdown in a nutshell: Governments have used billions of dollars of our money to fund fraudulent science, which, in turn, is used to justify policy that would steal untold billions more from us through taxation and the handicapping of the private sector. This will, of course, stifle the creation of wealth, but it will also be a transfer of it. But this would not be so much from the rich to the poor; it would be from the poor and middle class to the rich and well-connected. Carbon-credit con men such as Al Gore will add to their many millions, while subtracting from the many millions some of the latter’s few dollars. It would move us toward a situation in which we’d have two Americas, as John Edwards might say. One would be a lying, covetous ruling class of John Edwardses. The other would be the masses, who would be perpetually mired in serfdom.

Yet defeating the climate con won’t be easy, because it isn’t just money that drives the con men. In fact, many of them are so married the climate con that they have become one with their misguided notions. Call it the Zen of Being Wrong.

One reason not to do wrong is that an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Obviously, Bill Clinton, John Edwards and Tiger Woods would never have felt the urge to lie about their affairs if they had never had affairs. Of course, the lying was immoral, but this is how one sin leads to another. A transgression leads to a lie, which leads to a full-blown cover-up, etc. And the deeper you dig that hole, the harder and more painful it is to climb out of it.

In the case of the climate con artists, the pain would be great and the price steep. Their creed has been likened to a religion, and in many ways it is. They aren’t global-warming theorists.

They are global-warming fundamentalists.

They have invested so much of their time, energy, emotion, ego and reputations in the climate con that to relinquish it would be to relinquish themselves; to call it a lie is to call their lives a lie. It’s just a bit like asking a Jihadist to give up Islam. These are not people who subscribe to AGW theory; they have submitted to it.

Then you have those who are using this religion to make money — and they and the true believers are often one and the same. These are the carbon-credit capitalists, the green-technology givers and greenback grabbers.

And we have to add to this the fact that all these people had become science’s Torquemadas, inquisitors bent on stifling inquisitiveness. Al Gore told us “The debate is over” as he and his co-religionists strove to root out heresy and sought to destroy the “deniers.” Thus, they have no reason to expect mercy. Surrender is simply not an option.

So forget about icebergs; the meltdown the climate con artists fear is that of their reputations, egos, finances and faith. Scientists or not, to admit error is not merely the alteration of a hypothesis to them; it is the loss of religion and meaning, the end of empire, the fall of Rome. It is complete and utter personal destruction.

Yet destruction is precisely what the climate-change con men would visit on the economies of nations in their delusional grip. Other lands, such as China and India, will never yield to such insanity. They may pay lip service to it, though, especially if doing so will encourage us to more thoroughly handicap ourselves. Then they can laugh and rise to prominence while we become the most recent great civilization to descend into backwater status.

As I write this, the climate-change con artists are meeting in Copenhagen, where useful-idiot communists are protesting in the streets while their standard bearers, Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez, Zimbabwean strongman Robert Mugabe and Bolivian President Evo Morales are railing against free markets and beating the red drum. Do you really think these folks care about the environment? The green that really concerns them is your money — and I do mean your money. Because if there is an “international” agreement to fight the phantom of climate change, you can bet your depreciating bottom dollar that we Americans will pay the freight. We are, after all, the world’s biggest energy suckers.

The question is, are we just the world’s biggest suckers?

Chavez, Mugabe and China are betting yes. And if we want to make fools out of them, we’ll cause radical climate change — to the political climate in Washington in 2010. It’s probably our last chance to prove who the fools really are.
Sunday, December 20, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...

Death of the West: Our Sexual Identity Crisis

By Selwyn Duke

Perhaps you’ve heard the tragic story of David Reimer. Born in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada in 1966, David was the victim of a botched circumcision that left his penis charred beyond surgical repair. His parents Ron and Janet, no doubt beside themselves, were confused about the best way to proceed. Then, one day, they saw a man named Dr. John Money on television.

Money was talking about his theory of “gender neutrality,” which states that “gender identity” is learned rather than innate. The idea was that the sexes were the same except for the superficial physical differences; this implies that if a child were altered so as to superficially resemble the opposite sex and was raised as one of its members, he would be happy with that sexual identity. Hearing this, the Reimers hoped they had found their salvation.

They took their boy to Money, who told them that their son’s penis could not be restored and that he stood a much better chance of living a happy life if “sex-reassignment surgery” (in reality, reassigning sex is about as possible as reassigning species) were performed and he was raised as a girl. The Reimers agreed, and the surgery was performed when the boy, who would be named “Brenda,” was 22 months old.

In reality, the kindest way to describe Money’s theory is fanciful. His idea of “gender neutrality” was still in vogue when I was a youth, and “vogue,” in the most frivolous sense, is the correct term. It was always more style than science; it was something that I, even as a teen, knew was bunk. Yet who would listen to people such as me? We were old-fashioned, behind the times. And it didn’t matter that Money was Alfred Kinsey redux and believed pedophilia was lovely if it was for “love.” It didn’t matter that David and his twin brother, Brian, said that Money sexually abused them during photo shoots. He was a “doctor,” a Ph.D. on the cutting edge of a brave new world.

Only, David (“Brenda” at the time) wanted nothing to do with that world. Although he was never told he was a boy, had been surgically altered, was dressed and raised as a girl and was regularly seeing Money for therapy, he resisted his “gender assignment” from the outset. He acted like a boy, played with boys’ toys and objected to seeing Money from the age of seven. It wasn’t going well — and it wouldn’t end well.

At the age of 14, in a rare commendable act of teen rebellion, David threatened suicide if he were forced to continue with Money’s prescriptions. This prompted his parents to finally tell him the truth about his condition. With his eyes opened, he then replaced his estrogen treatments with male hormone therapy, took the name “David,” started living as a boy, underwent reconstructive genital surgery and later married a woman who already had children. Yet the damage had been done. His tormented life which began in such a tragic way came to a tragic end: he did commit suicide, at the age of 38.

Dr. Money, too, is now dead. Yet he died with his ideological boots on; not only did he fail to repent, he fraudulently portrayed David’s case — the one for which he was most famous — as a success for years after its failure was obvious. This, and his refusal to ever own up to the failure, only increased the chances that other children would be thus scarred.

As a testimonial to how quickly fashions pass away, Money’s theory has joined him in the grave. The stake through its heart came in the 1990s, with brain research and an improved understanding of intrauterine development proving conclusively that the sexes are different even within the womb and the skull. These new findings expressing old wisdom were related as revelation, reflecting the idea that nothing is truly valid until vindicated by “science.” So there was no collective mea culpa from the psychological establishment for clouding reality and misleading generations of naïve parents. They just continued without missing a beat, as if it were a matter no more significant than recommending the wrong size shoes for the kids. Worse still, they have now moved on to their next mistake.

We have heard about the curious case of Caster Semenya, the 18-year-old South African runner who has been competing as a woman. Semenya has become the focus of suspicion (I’ll use masculine pronouns, as I’m convinced this individual is a boy who experienced abnormal intrauterine development) because of his masculine physique, deep voice, development of facial hair, male mannerisms and the fact that he has been winning races by wide margins. As a result, a battery of medical exams to determine his true sex has been conducted, although the results have not been officially released. Yet the real story here is not what investigation may tell us about Semenya. It is what our reaction to Semenya tells us about ourselves.

This is reflected in comments found throughout the Internet. For instance, consider “JimBob” posting under this Daily Mail piece, who said,

“Why is everyone talking about genetics? What about Caster's own mind - if she believes within herself that she's female, then she is.”

Echoing this sentiment here, “Green Is Good” wrote,

“SHE identifies HERself as a female. Done.”

Then, back to the Mail, “Livio” opined,

“This is a clear case of gender identity discrimination. What if she is a man who identifies himself as a woman?”

That’s interesting. What if you’re a lunkhead who identifies himself as intelligent?

Yet it isn’t sufficient to just dismiss this with sarcasm, as this isn’t the rambling of only a few twisted minds.

What these posters are expressing is the handiwork of today’s Dr. Moneys, “transgender” theory. This is the idea that your “gender” can be whatever you want it to be — male, female, both male and female or neither, etc. — that it isn’t limited by biology. If you have a problem with this, bravo, but then you should have a problem with the word “gender” itself. Why? Because its current usage (it used to apply only to words) was originated by people such as Money for the purposes of facilitating the relation of their theories. Understand that while many people use “gender” as a synonym for “sex,” that is not its social sciences definition, which dictates that it refers to social rather than biological differences. Yet people love to use this and other elements of the lexicon of the left. It’s a fascinating phenomenon. If you replace a simple, one-syllable word such as “poor” or “sex” with impressive sounding terms such as “underprivileged” or “gender” for ideological reasons, people, oblivious to the underlying agenda and wishing to sound sophisticated, will glom onto them. You see, simpletons, who are relatively rare, prefer simple words. And the only other group that does is rarer still: true intellectuals. But I digress.

So, returning to Semenya, many people express the shocking idea that his actual sex should have no bearing on whether he should be allowed to compete with women. It’s that modern phenomenon — image is everything, reality is negotiable.

This notion has so taken hold that we’ve recently heard of two stories out of Britain wherein young boys, ages 12 and 9, showed up in school earlier this month as “girls,” sporting girls’ clothing and ponytails and bearing feminine names. And the schools are kowtowing to them, telling other pupils that they’ll be punished if they don’t handle the “sex change” “sensitively.” Yet sensitivity is not for the other children, who are upset and confused. In just the way that David Reimer’s body was mutilated in deference to yesterday’s latest theory, their minds must be mutilated in deference to today’s.

Now, even if someone subscribes to “transgender” theory, it is striking that he would allow a child who is too young to decide to have sex decide what sex he should be. How did we get to this point?

These parents, like Ron and Janet Reimer before them, are listening to the respected social scientists of their day. These “experts” tell them that there is something called “gender dysphoria,” which is the persistent feeling that one is a member of one sex trapped in the body of the other. It’s enough to convince many parents, such as those of German Tim Petras, who received female hormone “treatments” at age 12 and now goes by the name of Kim. Yet on what basis is this diagnosis really made?

Feelings.

It is truly reflective of this age, where relativism has obviated reason. That is to say, if there are no absolutes, no Truth to use as a yardstick for judging among feelings, the feelings themselves become the ultimate arbiter. Then, of course, if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it’s a Fig Newton if it feels like one.

But one of the problems with emotion is that it is by its very nature irrational. And if anyone would defend an emotion-based diagnosis such as “gender dysphoria,” note that it’s brought to us by the same psycho-babblers who have given us something dubbed “body dysmorphia.” This is this persistent feeling that a certain body part, such as an arm or leg (or multiple body parts), doesn’t belong on one’s body. And if you think it isn’t taken seriously, know that doctors have amputated healthy limbs on this basis.

Be shocked — that is, unless you accept “gender dysphoria” as legitimate. Then you’d better be introspective. For what is the difference? Why would you accept the emotion-based diagnosis of gender dysphoria but not the emotion-based one of body dysmorphia? Why are the feelings of those who suffer from the latter invalid but the feelings of those who suffer from the former a credible arbiter? Both groups have persistent feelings that their bodies aren’t as they should be. Both groups cannot bear to live in their bodies as they are. Both groups want to have their bodies altered. And both groups have found “experts” willing to put them under the knife. Sure, it strikes us as the most horrid malpractice when a doctor amputates healthy body parts, such as a pair of legs. But, then, should we view it any less dimly simply because those healthy body parts are between the legs?

Lamentably, today the answer is often yes, and this speaks volumes about our society. That is, we’ve all heard that old stereotype of a lunatic, the guy in an asylum who thinks he is Napoleon. Now the asylums have largely been emptied, and I think I know why: we’ve turned the outside world into an asylum. What was once only acceptable to a small group within the scariest of walls — detachment from reality — has now been mainstreamed. You can be a man who thinks he is a woman, yet no straitjacket is slapped on you. It is slapped on the mouths of those who dare say self-image isn’t reality.

And that is the point: there is something called reality. When feelings tell one he is, or should be, something he is not or shouldn’t be — a girl, a legless man or Napoleon — the sane conclusion is that you’re confronted with a psychological problem, not a physical one. It may be intractable, and it is certainly easier to mutilate the body than cure the mind. But you cannot mutilate reality, only obscure it. If a man loses his genitalia in an accident, does he cease to be male? Or, if “gender” is a continuum as today’s Moneys say, is he less male? Did David Reimer cease to be a boy because he was mutilated and given estrogen against his will? Of course, the “experts” would say the answer is no, since he never saw himself as a girl. Again, though, feelings cannot be the arbiters of reality. After all, I may have hypertrichosis like Jo-Jo the Dog-Faced Boy, undergo operations to create a snout, paws and a tail, howl under the moonlight and change my name to Spot. Yet am I sane if I call myself a different species?

So what are we to conclude about “gender” science? Decades ago its “experts” said society could turn your boy into a girl if it felt like it; now they say he can turn himself into a girl if he feels like it. Is it just a coincidence that Dr. Money’s “gender neutrality” theory accorded with his day’s feminist claim that sex roles should be discarded because the sexes are essentially the same? Is it just a coincidence that the current “transgender” theory accords with our day’s homosexual claim that sex roles should be discarded because everyone and his values are essentially different? It is at all possible that these theories have less to do with sound science than the spirit of the age?

We have gone from the proposition that “gender” can be whatever society says it is to the proposition that it can be whatever the individual says it is without ever stopping to wonder if the second idea is just a crank like the first. But most won’t wonder because today we place more faith in doctors than doctrine, and today’s doctors say that eternal common sense and yesterday’s doctors’ nonsense are wrong. Yet the most significant thing that distinguishes them from Dr. John Money is that they are still alive — and their theory is not yet dead.
Tuesday, September 29, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...

Talk Show Host Michael Savage’s Website Attacked by Hackers

By Selwyn Duke

A little while back, talk show host Michael Savage had to endure an attack on his character when the British government associated him with terrorists and other criminals and banned him from traveling to the U.K. But on Saturday, August 22 the attack — or at least an attack — was brought to his own shores when a computer hacker damaged his website by sneaking into its server through a feedback portal, forcing technicians to shut it down for nearly an hour.

The attack came on the heels of sharp criticism leveled at the U.K. by Savage over its release of Lockerbie bomber Abdel Baset al-Megrahi, prompting the host to speculate that the British government might have ordered the hacking effort in retaliation. Drew Zahn writes of Savage’s suspicions at WorldNetDaily.com:

"Why on the day of the worldwide furor over the release of the Lockerbie Bomber by [British Prime Minister] Gordon Brown would Michael Savage's website be hacked?" the radio host posited. "We cannot say who did this, but would it not be a possibility that the Brits themselves ordered this hack-attack?

"Why?" Savage asked WND. "Because the evidence that they placed me on this list with real murderers and terrorists was a political favor to some Islamic nation can be found in the recently discovered e-mails, hidden until now by the Gordon Brown government. Their own e-mail chain on banning Savage states, 'There is no evidence of Savage advocating or inciting violence,' yet, by including Savage on this banned list it would 'help provide a balance of types of exclusion cases,' in other words, the list would not only contain radical Muslims but also a white male conservative."

Whoever orchestrated the attack, it makes MichaelSavage.com the latest in a long line of traditionalist websites victimized by hacker intrusion. The Daily Telegraph, Glenn Reynold’s site Instapundit.com, HughHewitt.com, PowerLine.com, JihadWatch.com and Bill O’Reilly’s website were all victims, just to name a handful (Michelle Malkin discussed how 27 traditionalist Hosting Matters blogs were simultaneously taken down here). Additionally, NewsWithViews.com, which publishes my work, seems to have been attacked more than once. In fact, just earlier this year I received a phone call from its publisher informing me that the site’s email account was being targeted and that I’d have to contact them via a different address.

And it seems as if cyber attacks are right out of the left’s playbook. In fact, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (USDHS) issued a report in January of this year stating that left-wing extremists were likely to increase the use of such attacks during the next decade. Moreover, the left’s strange Islamist bedfellows use this tactic quite liberally as well, as evidenced by a 2008 attack on a Dutch hosting company that affected more than 200 websites; it followed in the wake of anti-Islamist commentary such as that in Dutch politician Geert Wilder’s movie Fitna. I should also mention that the attack on JihadWatch.com was traced back to Turkey, and one of the intrusions Malkin cited originated with computers in Saudi Arabia.

In light of this history, it wouldn’t surprise me if the attack on Savage’s site was the handiwork of Islamists, perhaps in a Muslim country, perhaps in Britain. And what we can know for sure is that if Islamists are not the culprit, their leftist facilitators likely are.

Whatever the case, cyber attacks are far from harmless. They are a type of virtual vandalism that causes the target to incur reparative costs. Moreover, there is also the possibility that if such costs become too high for a hosting company, it might refuse to host the targeted site, which would cause the webpage to disappear from the Internet until it was able to find hosting services elsewhere.

Now, harking back the USDHS report, it isn’t surprising that the left would have no compunction about using cyber attacks. And we cannot truly appreciate the threat posed by the left unless we understand why.

The left is morally relativistic at its core, meaning, its members generally don’t believe in Absolute Moral Truth. Because of this, there is nothing to govern their agenda except for their own desires, their own feelings. That is to say, a person who understands that we are meant to govern ourselves with that eternal, unchanging moral yardstick called Truth realizes that the end does not justify the means. Sure, he isn’t perfect, but he understands that he cannot just “follow his heart,” that his emotions aren’t the arbiters of reality. This is why Saul “the Red” Alinsky instructed his followers to force their adversaries (that means traditionalists) to live up to their own principles. You see, he understood that we actually have some.

But the left proceeds largely unencumbered by morality. Whatever helps them achieve their immediate goal — instituting faux marriage, inuring people to abortion, stifling anti-Islamist dissent or whatever it may be — is justifiable in their universe. Their “values” originate from within and change with the winds of convenience. Thus, while traditionalists fight abiding by Queensbury Rules, their enemies proceed no holds barred.

Of course, we can never take this leaf out of the left’s book, as it would require a complete abandonment of morality. But we also have to be careful that we don’t bring a knife to a gunfight.

Know thy enemy.
Saturday, September 12, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...

The Race Idiots

By Selwyn Duke

With relativistic people, there is no such thing as a true axiom, yet you’d never know it listening to our modern mantras. We hear things such as “Our strength lies in our diversity,” “Religion has caused all the wars in history,” and “Everything is a matter of perspective” proclaimed with theological assurance. Of course, the last supposition is contradictory, and embracing it renders moral supposition itself meaningless. Regardless, it’s natural for man to make sense of the world by “profiling” elements of reality.

Many of our assumptions pertain to race, and one is always uttered in the wake of stories such as the recent Henry Louis Gates affair. What happens is that, referring to race, people will reflexively say something akin to the following, “Well, we still have a long way to go.” Even conservatives pay homage to this self-evident provisional “truth,” only, they add a qualifier so it goes something like, “We still have a long way to go, but . . .,” with the caboose being “we’ve made great strides,” “we’ve come a long way” or some variation thereof. It’s obligatory, after all. It’s how you polish up you credentials as a person who “understands the problem.”

It’s also reflective of a hang-up. Oh, this isn’t to say I believe we’ve achieved perfection in racial attitudes, perish the thought. It is to say, however, that seeing a failure to achieve perfection in an area as a characteristic problem is far more of a problem than what ostensibly needs invasive and aggressive remedy. It usually yields a cure worse than the disease.

Understand that bigotry is simply a manifestation of one of the Seven Deadly Sins: wrath. It is not the end-all and be-all, the source of all our woes. It is not, relatively speaking, even a major problem (although, it waxes when we let the Sharptons, Jacksons and Obamas of the world stir the pot).

If this statement raises eyebrows, perspective is needed. If we were otherwise perfect and called the ether home, any extant bigotry would rightly stick out like white sheets at a Black Panther meeting. Yet we are far from perfect. We exhibit not just one element of wrath but also its other manifestations and the rest of the deadly sins — greed, lust, sloth, pride, envy and gluttony — to varying degrees. So the question is not whether bigotry exists and is a problem, as this is true of every sin. It concerns whether it is a characteristic problem.
In other words, if we were to constantly lament our lacking math ability, it would imply one of two things. It either stands out in reality, making us pay it some mind, or it stands out only in our minds, in which case we are detached from reality. If the former, it would have to pale in comparison to the mathematical achievement of other nations or to our ability in other areas, such as English and history. So the question is, does our obsession with bigotry meet one of the last criterion’s two elements?

No rational person can make the case that we rank high on the world’s bigotry scale, not on a planet in which racial and ethnic patriotism reign supreme. Many don’t realize that this is in fact man’s default state, but the irony is that it’s because they’ve fallen victim to something they might be wont to preach against: “ethnocentrism.” The fact is that man is tribal by fallen nature, and there is little in the way of political correctness outside the Western world. In fact, far from being taught that it’s wrong to discriminate, many groups are taught that it’s wrong to not place your “people” first. Such a thing can make you a pariah.
The reality is that we kill ourselves talking about bigotry, but much of the world kills others because of it. We’ve all heard about this, from the Balkan ethnic cleansing in the 1990s to the Ruandan genocide in which hundreds of thousands of Tutsis were murdered by Hutu tribesman, who happened to refer to them as “cockroaches.” Oh, I should mention that no hate-speech charges are in the offing.
But, okay, we’re better than the monster in another country, but maybe bigotry is the worst monster roaming our countryside. Except that, well, believing this requires the most incomplete of moral compasses. Let’s now contrast this manifestation of wrath with the rest of our national sins.

It’s obvious where we should start. Given that we have sexual imagery and innuendo everywhere, classes in pornography and “sexology” in colleges, and stories of children re-enacting Caligula’s court in schools, can we really make the case that bigotry is a greater problem than lust? What about greed? Well, given the Bernie Madoffs of the world, the recent Wall Street woes, rapacious government officials and the long-accepted maxim about the lust for money being the root of all evil, it just may rank a bit higher as well. Sloth? Our welfare state and handout-and-entitlement mentality. Envy? Class warfare. Gluttony? We have more obese people than the rest of the world combined. Pride? Given how people are loath to admit error — think Obama and his refusal to apologize to the Cambridge police — and the super-size egos that abound, this trumps bigotry also.

This lack of perspective is no small matter, as it leads to much destructive social engineering. Just think about race-based quotas, affirmative action and set asides. Consider the assumption that relative racial homogeneity within a business or organization equates to racial animosity in its leaders’ hearts, or how largely white neighborhoods are targeted with “low income” housing because, well, we all know there just must be unjust discrimination. And think about how Obama, Gates and so many others will just assume that white police are bigoted because “We still have a long way to go.” All the while we have schools teaching perversion, profligate government spending, illegal aliens “undocumented” into legitimacy, criminals who go unpunished, slackers who are rewarded, heroes who are derided and traitors who are exalted. We have caricatured virtue and vice, exaggerating some parts to grotesque proportions while ignoring others. The result is that we misdirect our scalpel during “corrective” surgery, slicing off healthy tissue while allowing cancerous tumors in our midst to grow unfettered.

Not only does this selective moral blindness numb us to our real national sins, it also allows the reprobate the illusion of righteousness. In fact, while the stereotype of the self-righteous oaf is of a rightist religious zealot, a far more fitting candidate is the loopy leftist lunkhead. He is the one who will parade about defining favored vices as virtue, worshipping sex and mammon, secure in his own saintliness because he utters nary a racial joke and bears nobly that newly-minted white man’s burden. The modern leftist is like a Nazi who thinks he is good because he is hygienic and punctual.

Yet this leftist conception of virtue is as shallow as it is narrow; its definition of goodness doesn’t seem to involve love for what one defends as much as equal-opportunity hatred. As to this, I have long observed something: liberals treat blacks like people; the problem is that they don’t treat people like people. That is to say, they treat blacks like everyone else, but they treat everyone pretty shabbily. With Torquemada-like zeal they advance the dogma that we must treat all people equally, but much is missing from that prescription. Equally at what moral level? You can treat people equally by killing them all with the same expedition and ferocity.

So here is the left’s implied standard: you may curse people out generically for five minutes with seething hatred, just don’t utter one racial epithet. You may let everyone starve, just don’t give one race a morsel of food another cannot digest. You may corrupt all races with vile hip-hop anti-culture, just don’t imply that it is more corruptive than anything else. This is our national hang-up, our racial Puritanism.

Leftists don’t realize it, but with their obsession, they are reminiscent of a group from the past which they view with utter contempt and mockery. And while it’s generally not true that authentic Christians were hung-up on sex, the people in question could be thus described. These were individuals who would, and I’ll be delicate, affix mechanical devices to boys to prevent a certain normal physiological reaction. (No, this was not medieval times but those of the “Enlightenment,” and the instigators were at least as likely to be physicians and scientists as churchmen.) I guess they figured that they “still had a long way to go.”
Now, people weren’t wrong to preach chastity just as we aren’t wrong to preach charity. But among the legitimate moralists of the day were those who caricatured the virtue, thereby perverting it, just as we do today with racial brotherhood. The question is, will you and I be voices of reason or, in obeisance to the age, insist that all racial talk is “dirty”? If the latter, then we will be deserving of the mockery when people two centuries hence laugh at how “repressed” we were.
Contact Selwyn Duke
Tuesday, August 25, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...

Why I Must Defend Barbara Boxer

By Selwyn Duke

We’ve all heard about the little dust-up between Black Chamber of Commerce president and CEO Harry Alford and Democrat senator Barbara Boxer during an Environment & Public Works (EPW) hearing on “green” jobs. Boxer, the chairman of the EPW committee, was trying to refute a report commissioned by Alford’s organization stating that the Waxman-Markey American Clean Energy and Security Act — which I’ll call “cap-and-sap” — would actually cause a net reduction in jobs. So, marshalling her arguments, she cited many sources that support cap-and-sap — among them the NAACP and the leader of 100 Black Men of America.

This didn’t sit too well with Mr. Alford. He responded, “Madam Chair, that is condescending to me. I’m the National Black Chamber of Commerce, and you’re trying to put up some other black group to pit against me . . . . All that’s condescending, and I don’t like it. It’s racial.”

In a later interview, Alford was even more pointed in his criticism, saying that his Boxer match was “like being in Mississippi in 1945” and “vile Jim Crow.” He described the essence of the senator’s comments thus, “Colored boy, what are you doing with this sophisticated report?”

Well, Mr. Alford, tell us how you really feel.

Now, although I had never heard of Alford before this brouhaha, I like what I see; he seems a stand-up fellow, down-to-earth, commonsensical, sincere and spirited. In other words, the antithesis of a liberal. I also could not agree with him more on cap-and-sap. I go even further in fact: it is part of a destructive agenda often animated by diabolical motivations. Nevertheless, I must do something that is a first for this scribe: defend Barbara Boxer.

At least, that is, a little bit.

Lest I be misunderstood, I think Boxer is the worst politics has to offer — this makes her the worst of the worst. And I can certainly see why she would have irked Alford, as she was not only condescending, she was her usual imperious, supercilious, paternalistic self. And this is par for the course. Remember when Boxer chided Brigadier General Michael Walsh simply because he abided by military protocol concerning the addressing of those of higher rank and called her “ma’am”? It was a pathetic display. But, then again, the general did err. It takes a bit of detachment from reality to view Boxer as any kind of superior. There are better things to call her.

Yet, having said all this, a good man can be wrong and, well, you know what they say about a broken clock. So, I ask, was her approach during the hearing truly reflective of bigotry?

It was certainly racial. Boxer never would have cited the NAACP had a white man been locking horns with her. But everyone seems to be missing the pink elephant in the middle of the room: Alford isn’t the president of the Chamber of Commerce.
He is the president of the Black Chamber of Commerce.

I’ll illustrate this fairly obvious point further. Let’s say I’m head of an organization called the Catholic Chamber of Commerce and I appear before the right honourable Senator Boxer. Now, would it be surprising if, in an effort to sway me, she cited opinion rendered by the Catholic League and Opus Dei? Or should I accuse Boxer, a Jewish woman, of anti-Catholic bias? Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure the woman is anti-lots of things; regardless, it wouldn’t be just to accuse her of bigotry simply because she inferred my passions from my associations and built her argument around them. After all, if you’re going to define your organization based on a characteristic, you cannot blame people for viewing you through its prism.

I’ll also point out that during Alford’s opening statement he said the following, “that [the projected disparate impact of cap-and-sap] worries me and my members because the black community suffers mightily when the economy goes south.” Of course, Alford’s emphasis on the black community reflects a special concern for it; given this, however, is it surprising that Boxer would counter by citing entities that lay claim to having the same special concern?

The answer is obvious. Despite this, however, many of my ideological brethren are now using the EPW incident to paint Boxer as a bigot. And, insofar as this goes, I regret to say that they're guilty of intellectual dishonesty. Oh, I do understand the overwhelming temptation. The senator and her leftist ilk wrote the book on playing the race card and using Stalinist tactics to destroy opponents — and they do it for the most specious of reasons. There are the examples of Bill O’Reilly and golf commentator Kelly Tilghman, who innocently used a variation on the word “lynch” during commentary about blacks; there was university student Keith John Sampson, who was persecuted simply for reading an anti-Ku Klux Klan book; and then there was the pillorying of Rush Limbaugh over his analysis of black quarterback Donovan McNabb’s boosters. These are just a sampling of numerous instances where the left sent lynching parties after those they hated for only one reason: because they could.
Thus, just as when Hillary and Bill Clinton were accused of bigotry while campaigning against Barack Obama, the Boxer controversy is an example of liberals being mauled by a hoary and horrible monster of their own design. And many conservatives relish the chance to give the left a taste of its own medicine because, well, now they can.

Yet it takes a good dose of rationalization to convince oneself that something only racial is “racist.” This may be easy for the left, but for those on the right it probably takes a bit more effort. After all, many liberals are so detached from reality, so solipsistic and relativistic, that they mistake their feelings for Truth. They have the lie on retainer. Conservatives, on the other hand, embrace it only occasionally, as a consultant.

Another difference between the right and left is that we traditionalists know we’re called to be better than that. We know that the Truth will not only set us free and carry the day when the last chapter is written, but that it’s all we have. The lie will never serve us like it does the liars. That is, unless, as they have done, we make it our master.

And the Truth is the point. Whenever we peddle that lie called the race card, we contribute to the mass delusion and lessen the chances that the Truth will be known, all for some momentary political gain. We trade something beautiful for thirty pieces of silver. Liberals make this a practice, and it’s why they’re contemptible. But, remember, silver is all they have.

As for my friends on the right, for the moment, I could be even madder at you. After all, your trespass is the greater. You forced me to defend Barbara Boxer.
Tuesday, July 28, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...

Can Obama Spell 'Failure'?

By Selwyn Duke

There actually was a time when an “e” ended a political career. Or, at least, the misuse of an “e.” I refer to that fateful day in 1992 when Vice President Dan Quayle told a 12-year-old schoolboy that “potato” was spelled with an “e” at its end. While the reality is that a flash card Quayle had been given bore the misspelling, the mistake was seized upon by the media and used to cement the eye-candy-and-air image of the boyishly good-looking vice president. It was a silly way to measure a man, but image is everything in politics.

So now it’s time for the gander’s sauce. If it was justifiable to write off Quayle as a dolt for stumbling over the spud, how should we react to frequent misspellings in press releases issued by the White House? Michael O’Brien at The Hill’s Blog Briefing Room reports on this story, writing, “Misspellings continued to plague the Obama administration on Thursday [9/9], after two more releases containing errors were sent to reporters in the last 24 hours.”

First the White House staff misspelled Obama’s first name, writing it as “Barak.” Then, O’Brien reports, there were two more examples. They are, “Recvoery.gov Version 2.0 $18 Million Contract Awarded” and, referring to U.K. leader Gordon Brown, “The Prime Minister wlecomed the President's plans for a nuclear security conference in 2010.”

Now, while sweating the small stuff can get you branded as punctilious today, a person’s failure to attend to detail tells you much about him. And this is not at all like the Quayle potato blunder. Not only had the former vice president been given that flash card bearing the misspelling, it’s also understandable that he wouldn’t have spotted the error, since the plural form of the word does end in “oes.” Second, unless you’re an Idaho farmer, you probably haven’t written the word “potato” in a very long time. Lastly, it’s simply impossible for an individual to make continual public appearances without making some mistakes. Hey, just ask Al Gore about how “a leopard can’t change his stripes.”

But what the Obama administration exhibits is quite different: Institutional sloppiness. It’s one thing for an individual to sometimes make mistakes; it’s quite another when a large organization repeatedly churns them out. And let’s place this in perspective.

Some may note that Internet news and commentary websites are rife with mistakes as well, and this is true. However, this is often a function of manpower. Most e-zines simply do not have the staff necessary to achieve near perfect presentation, as they usually operate on a shoestring budget. In contrast, if you write for even a small magazine, their superior finances allow for tremendous oversight. A piece will be filtered through a number of different editors. It then may be returned to the writer for review, allowing him to assess the editorial changes and make a few more alterations before the work ever makes it into print. The result of this collaborative process is that you really can cross all your t’s and dot all your i’s.

Now, the fact that the Obama administration isn’t achieving quality even approaching that of a small magazine is striking. This is the White House, remember, with the endless resources government provides. Hasn’t the person or people writing Obama’s press releases ever heard of a spell-check program? Wouldn’t it be reasonable to have at least two different individuals proofread the material before disseminating it to the whole world? Such institutional sloppiness is inexcusable.

Some may say I’m being picayune, that this is much ado about nothing. But if you think this sloppiness somehow magically limits itself to the issuance of press releases, then you’d probably believe that Michelle Obama buys her sneakers at Wal-Mart. In point of fact, it tells us something about those at the helm of our listing nation.

It’s not that they’re stupid. A genius, even a responsible one, can transpose letters while typing just as he can fail to spot the misspelling of a type of starchy tuber. But when such errors are consistently made by large groups of people working together — that institutional sloppiness — it bespeaks of a lack of conscientiousness and attention to detail, to an absence of the desire to uphold standards.

This is characteristic of liberals; it is part of their world view. These are the people who don’t trouble over standards in morality because, their relativism informs, Truth doesn’t exist anyway. They don’t worry about the standards prescribed by the Constitution or, for that matter, any inconvenient law of man because, without Truth, laws can be based on nothing transcendent. And, of course, if these greater matters can be ignored, why worry about language? (I’d bet that the too-cool-to-care leftists in the White House are the type of people who, in personal emails, replace “you” with “u” and don’t capitalize the first letter in a sentence. I bet they can spell “socialism” and “social decay” just fine, though.)

This is the modus operandi of the situational values set, of those who have contempt for standards. After all, if standards are ever and always negotiable, why worry much about them? Without Truth to use as a yardstick for determining them and making moral decisions, you might as well just use the only guide you have left: emotion. This is why liberals are so feelings-oriented.

So, in the case of the press releases, spelling errors are minor problems but a major indicator. With such institutional sloppiness, why should we think that the Obama administration is meticulous about anything? Why would we think that they’d pay attention to the details of where stimulus money is going? How could we expect them to iron out all the details of managing national health care? Why should anyone trust that these liberals could, as they purport to be able to, regulate an economy involving millions of minor details? We have a bull in the china shop of policy.

Yet, what is worse is liberals’ failure to attend to detail in their own minds. I often quote G.K. Chesterton, and one reason I like him so much is that he was a “complete thinker.” That is, he would analyze a matter from every angle, thereby peeling away the layers of illusion and uncovering Truth. But this is uncommon among normal people — and unheard of among the left. This is one reason why they can embrace nonsensical, illogical ideas. Some of them may entertain communism, completely ignoring the simple fact that if people were good enough to make a communist government work, we wouldn’t need government. They embrace multiculturalism, oblivious to the plain fact that nations without a unifying culture descend into disunity. They will say that man is just a highly evolved animal, but then insist that, in the violent animal kingdom, this animal’s children must be “taught” to be violent (when arguing against spanking). They will aver that homosexuality is inborn while just as passionately averring that sex roles must be taught. They will insist that relative are right and wrong while also insisting that the right is absolutely wrong. And just recently, Obama cited California as an example of a state that is energy efficient yet economically healthy. He ignored two minor details, however: bankruptcy and rolling blackouts.

Barack Obama is an urban rube. And he surrounds himself with likeminded — or, I should say, like-impassioned — urban rubes. Some fancy these people sophisticated, but while they give the illusion of sophistication, they possess none of its substance. They were simply raised wrong and rendered bereft of logic, as they never learned to subordinate emotion to reason so that the former wouldn’t cloud the latter. They are people who don’t cross their t’s and dot their i’s in anything, be it philosophy, personal life or policy. They are ruined souls. And they are bringing us to ruin.

As for Dan Quayle’s potato problem, if an onus belonged anywhere, it was on the institution that printed an incorrect flash card. And we should note that this institution was a school, one of those great bastions of liberal unthought.
Wednesday, July 15, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...

Mark Sanford And The Left's Romper Room

By Selwyn Duke

There is probably nothing that pleases our libertine left more than a social conservative’s fall from grace. Just witness the predictable feeding frenzy that ensued when South Carolina governor Mark Sanford confessed to marital infidelity. Why, so voracious are his critics that a Google search for Sanford’s name in parentheses and the word “hypocrite” yields 20,600 of their pages.

For many reasons, not the least of which was the governor’s condemnation of Bill Clinton’s serial adultery in the 1990s, the left has put him in a glass house the size of the Crystal Cathedral. And, in all fairness, Sanford should be taken to task. We all have a duty to hold our leaders to the highest standards, and I’ll be the first to say that if a politician — regardless of party or passions — cannot uphold sterling moral and ethical standards, he needs to go. Yet would the left join me in this? Would they say, “You know what, you’re right; we can’t subordinate virtue to political expediency”? Not going to happen, not with this childish bunch.

On the contrary, whether it’s Clinton, Barney Frank, Mel Reynolds, John Edwards, Gerry Studds or someone else, liberals tend to circle the wagons around transgressing brothers regardless of the offense. Reynolds, convicted of 12 counts of sexual assault on a 16-year-old, was pardoned by Clinton; Studds, who had an affair with a teenage boy, was re-elected six times by Massachusetts voters. Hey, people in glass houses protect other people in glass houses.

Of course, it’s no secret that leftists couldn’t care a whit about sexual impropriety. How could they? Once you’ve rubber-stamped homosexual behavior, it follows that everything below it in the hierarchy of sin —which is most things — is also just a “lifestyle choice.”

In fairness again, however, not too many leftists try very hard to feign outrage at the violation of marriage vows, which, if they had their way, would be an event in the 2012 Olympics. Rather, the stones they hurl with shot-put gusto pertain to hypocrisy, although it’s never explained how such a thing is reckoned wrong in the universe of moral relativism. But how could we expect such philosophical depth, anyway, when leftists can’t even understand far simpler things, such as the meaning of hypocrisy?

Sanford could well be a hypocrite, but I doubt it. As I wrote in my piece, “Sanford’s and Ensign’s Fall from Grace Fuels the Immorality Police”:

I've observed that a great many people who fail to uphold their own ideals, wholeheartedly believe in them at the moment they espouse them; it is that perilous transition between talking and walking where problems occur. To paraphrase Confucius, "It is not that I do not know what to do; it is that I do not do what I know." Was the ancient sage a hypocrite? No, a mortal is more like it.

Hypocrisy isn't saying one thing while doing another; it's saying one thing while intending to do another. To think otherwise is intellectually sloppy at best, as we are then lumping mortals' weakness and their self-serving deception into the same category. For example, two men tell their children not to drink to excess but then get drunk. However, while one of them planned to hit the bottle all along, the other's counsel was sincere. The problem is that he went to a gathering, had drinks waved under his nose and was seduced by the bottle. Now, call him pathetic if you must. Call him weak. Call him a sorry excuse for a father. But a hypocrite he is not.

Now, I have no stake in Sanford’s political fortunes. But I do care about ideas, and I see no evidence of hypocrisy. In fact, I’m not even so sure how much of a hypocrite Clinton is — at least regarding his extra-marital dalliances. I’m content to call him a cad.

Yet there are profound differences between the two men. Note that Sanford offered an unequivocal and apparently heartfelt apology at his teary-eyed press conference. There was no legalistic sleight-of-tongue about what the definition of “is” is, no feigned ingenuousness about what constitutes sex. And these differences are reflected in the behavior of their wives, too.

Sanford’s wife, Jenny, asked him to leave their home and wasn’t by his side during the news conference. In contrast, that Hillary . . . well, she just takes a lickin’ and keeps on tickin’. But why?

My analysis of the difference is this: While it probably was far from perfect, the Sanfords actually had (and let’s hope will have) a real marriage. Jenny Sanford reacted normally, the way many hurt wives would. And it’s entirely possible, as M. Sanford has said, that his Argentine escapade was his first full-blown affair. It’s even more likely that it was the first time his wife had learned he had “crossed lines.”

As for the Clintons, they don’t have a marriage.

They have a business arrangement.

In the 1990s, Hillary didn’t stand by her man — she stood by her plan. She had hitched her wagon to Bill’s star and endured the bumps, jolts and rollovers. Did you really think she was going to cash out after giving Bill her best years and suffering the worst humiliations right when Clinton, Inc. was hitting paydirt? No, sir, not Nicola Machiavelli.

But, since I’m starting to feel like a gossip columnist, I’ll move on to deeper issues. That is where the truly childish leftist commentary can be found, anyway.

A good example of such a bad example is a CNN.com writer named Robert Zimmerman. Billed as a “political analyst,” he recently wrote the piece, “Let’s leave Mark Sanford’s family alone … as long as he leaves our families alone,” and its content is as snide as the title suggests. After opening with an obligatory sentence about how everyone “had to feel extraordinary sympathy for the Governor’s wife and family,” he immediately transitioned into the irrational, talking about how “family values” politicians’ sexual impropriety is dwarfed only by an even greater moral defect. This, supposedly, is traditionalists’ divisiveness, fear-mongering, prejudice and, vice of vices, their imposition of values. He writes:

Throughout their political careers, they have tried to dictate the definition of a moral American and a proper family. They have tried to create laws that restrict a woman’s decision about her health and body and have denied personal rights and human dignity to gay and lesbian Americans. These are reflections of the immorality of their movement.

. . . Now I know that many will bring up the scandals regarding the personal behavior of former President Bill Clinton, former Governor Eliot Spitzer, former Governor Jim McGreevey and former Senator John Edwards. As wrong and destructive as their behaviors were, these men did not try to dictate to us how we should live our lives . . . .

I’m not precisely sure how to rate this commentary, but it hovers somewhere between idiocy and imbecility. First, Zimmerman contradicts himself within the space of two sentences. He scores traditionalists for trying to “dictate the definition of a moral American” but then labels their movement immoral. But how can you make that judgment without deciding upon a definition for a “moral American”? Some may say the difference is that he won’t try to “dictate” that definition, but what does this mean? If he insists his conception of morality is correct, how is he different from the absolutists he bemoans? And if he is unsure, that throws his assessment of the traditionalist movement into question, doesn’t it?

OK, I get it. The fellow travelers in government he mentions (Edwards, McGreevey, etc.) don’t try to legislate their values. Except, if this is true, it’s only because those particular gentlemen are no longer in government. Correct me if I’m wrong, but being in government involves the act of governing; this involves controlling, and this is synonymous with telling us “how we should live our lives.” Let’s define this more precisely.

There is no such thing as a lawmaker who doesn’t try to legislate a conception of morality; this is because a law by definition is the imposition of a value. After all, a law states there is something you must or mustn’t do, ostensibly because it is, respectively, a moral imperative or morally wrong — or a corollary thereof. If this isn’t the case, why prescribe or proscribe it? What would be the point?

Of course, from the relativistic left’s perspective, morality doesn’t exist and “values” are merely an expression of consensus opinion, which, of course, is synonymous with how most people happen to feel about something at a given time. Thus, implicit in the left’s philosophy is the idea that they make laws in order to enforce their preferences. This robs them of all legitimacy.

After all, if I can make the case that I’m legislating elements of Truth, I at least have a claim to moral authority. For then the claim is not that I’m imposing my values but, rather, morals originating outside myself — outside man, in fact — and authored by something superior to him. Yet leftists’ implicit claim is that they are merely imposing feelings gussied up as “values”; thus, what they impose certainly is theirs. On what basis, then, should we take their pronouncements seriously? They may scoff at those who would point to God’s law when shaping man’s, but what alternative do they offer? Should we instead defer to their egos, their base instincts, their illusions? “If it feels good, legislate it” isn’t much of a rationale.

Some may say the Zimmermans of the world are being Machiavellian, that their accusations amount to a ploy designed to discredit their opponents’ conception of morality. But while this may be true in a few cases, the bulk of them can’t be accused of possessing that kind of sophistication. In most cases it’s simply that they notice, as anyone would, the imposition of morals alien to them. On the other hand, they swim in their own values as a frog raised in a polluted pond swims in its dirty water: The values are simply the stuff of their natural environment, so leftists feel that nothing is amiss. As C.S. Lewis said about such people, “their scepticism about values is on the surface: it is for use on other people’s values; about the values current in their own set they are not nearly sceptical enough.”

But whether they peddle this fallacy driven by phoniness or foolishness, the result is identical: it serves to stifle substantive debate. And traditionalists could do this, too. We could cite legislation we despise and complain of how the left dictates, controls, and imposes values. We could mention how the left won’t let us run our own businesses as we see fit, with their anti-discrimination and anti-smoking laws and other limitations on freedom; or how they won’t let us raise children as we desire, with anti-spanking laws and intrusive CPS agencies. “Ah,” retorts the left, “But those things are necessary; they stop people from hurting others; they are right!” But that’s the rub, isn’t it? Traditionalists don’t agree, and just as you leftists are sure of your dogmas, they are sure of theirs. If we weren’t sure of them, they wouldn’t be called dogmas.

So let’s now discuss the difference between a child’s literary tantrums and an adult’s incisive commentary. The child falls down and pounds the earth, disgorging visceral nonsense about how the other side is a meany who wants to control people’s lives. The child then wants to take his ball and go home — or take his opponents’ ball away (e.g., Fairness Doctrine). But an adult understands that governing involves imposing, dictating and controlling; it involves legislating a conception of morality. It’s simply a matter of what we will impose, dictate and control, of what that conception of morality will be.

This won’t be discovered if we entertain childish avoidance maneuvers that stifle the only debate that can determine this, the most important debate there ever could be: What is good? What is Truth? Unless a person is willing to discuss this — maturely, as an adult, without relativistic dodges — he has no more business rendering commentary or writing laws than the boys in Lord of the Flies.
Tuesday, July 07, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...

Which Side Really Inspires Violence, The Right Or Left?

By Selwyn Duke

Is the right responsible for inspiring murder, such as that of late-term abortionist George Tiller by Kansas native Scott Roeder? Some certainly seem to think so. For instance, the Friday before last Bill O’Reilly had as a guest on his show Joan Walsh, the editor of leftist news site Salon.com. She appeared because she had criticized O’Reilly for engaging in what she called a “jihad” against Tiller. Her thesis is that O’Reilly and, presumably, the rest of us who are passionately pro-life are culpable Tiller’s death.

Of course, this isn’t a novel idea among the left. If there is any kind of violent incident perpetrated by someone ostensibly a rightist, they blame their political opponents for stoking the fires of hatred. You can just count on it every time, be it an attack on an abortion center, a Timothy McVeigh, or . . . or . . . well, actually, there aren’t really all that many, are there? But don’t bother ideologues with the facts.

Now, Walsh, a woman of mediocre intellect and lacking moral fiber — she has lauded Tiller “the baby killer” as a hero — has been beating this drum hard. In fact, on June 10 she published a piece titled “Can right-wing hate talk lead to murder?” In it, she seems to draw a connection between James von Brunn, the 88-year-old white supremacist who murdered security guard Stephen Tyrone Johns at the Holocaust Museum, and fairly benign commentary about the effects of political correctness. She wrote:

In a debate with Buchanan [Pat Buchanan] a couple of weeks ago, he told me that what was happening to white men was exactly what happened to black men — he didn't give me any examples of lynching — and that it was open season on white men. Wealthy Sen. Lindsay Graham suggested an average white guy like himself wouldn't get a fair shake from Sotomayor, and now even the new face of the GOP, Michael Steele, has said the same thing. If I were a marginal, unemployed, angry, racist white man right now, I'd be hearing a lot of mainstream conservative support for my point of view. Can that help create a climate for more violence? I don't know. I hope not, but I don't know.

No, Walsh doesn’t know much. First, von Brunn isn’t a rightist — he is a “whitist.” In fact, he is quite the opposite of a rightist many ways, as Bob Unruh reports at WorldNetDaily:

The Moonbattery blog revealed von Brunn advocated the socialist policies espoused by Adolf Hitler and used Darwinian theory to support his anti-Semitism.

And in statements that later were stripped from an anti-religion website, he wrote, "The Big Lie technique, employed by Paul to create the CHRISTIAN RELIGION, also was used to create the HOLOCAUST RELIGION … CHRISTIANITY AND THE HOLOCAUST are HOAXES."

This probably would come as such a shock to someone as ill-informed as Walsh that she’d scarcely believe it; it’s just too contrary to her dogma. Yet I could have guessed it. Those who have actually studied the history of Nazism and the white supremacist movement know that, from Adolf Hitler in the 1930s to his fellow travelers today, its ranks have always harbored hostility toward Christianity. The reasons are simple: Whether you view Christianity as merely an outgrowth of Judaism or the fulfillment of it, it is the second part of Judeo-Christian. Second, like the ancient Romans, the Nazis viewed the faith of “turn the other cheek” (counsel which, mind you, is misunderstood) as an influence that militates against manly virtue. Lastly, a lie doesn’t find much acquaintance with the Truth.

Instead, white supremacists much prefer ancient Germanic pagan religions and even Islam. Just consider Hitler, for instance, and his dislike for the heroic Frankish (Germanic) warrior Charles Martel. What was Martel’s sin? He halted the Moslem advance into Europe at the Battle of Tours in 732 A.D. Paul Belien addressed this misguided passion of Hitler’s in the Brussels Journal, writing,

“‘Had Charles Martel not been victorious,’ Hitler told his inner crowd in August 1942, ‘then we should in all probability have been converted to Mohammedanism, that cult which glorifies the heroism and which opens up the seventh Heaven to the bold warrior alone. Then the Germanic races would have conquered the world.’”

The Nazis’ dislike for Christianity was so great that, not surprisingly, they sought to destroy it. Leftists may scoff at a notion so contrary to their prejudices, but the evidence of this fact is now overwhelming. And of this evidence, perhaps the most compelling was uncovered by a Jewish attorney named Julie Seltzer Mandel, a woman whose grandmother was a survivor of the Auschwitz concentration camp. I addressed her discovery in my piece “Hitler and Christianity,” writing:

While a law student and editor of the Nuremberg Project for the Rutgers Journal of Law and Religion, Mandel gained access to 148 bound volumes of rare documents — some marked “Top Secret” — compiled by the Office of Strategic Services (or O.S.S., the WWII forerunner to the CIA).

After scouring the papers, she published the first installment of them in 2002, a 120-page O.S.S. report entitled “The Nazi Master Plan: The Persecution of the Christian Churches.” Reporting on these O.S.S. findings in the Philadelphia Inquirer, Edward Colimore wrote: “The fragile, typewritten documents from the 1940s lay out the Nazi plan in grim detail: Take over the churches from within, using party sympathizers. Discredit, jail or kill Christian leaders. And re-indoctrinate the congregants. Give them a new faith — in Germany’s Third Reich.” He then quotes Mandel: “A lot of people will say, ‘I didn’t realize that they were trying to convert Christians to a Nazi philosophy.’... They wanted to eliminate the Jews altogether, but they were also looking to eliminate Christianity.”

To this day nothing has changed. If you examine the writings of contemporary white supremacists, you will find much hatred for Christianity, affection for paganism and sympathy for Islam.

Now, I ask you: Which is better characterized by this description, the right or left? When answering, remember that those euphemistically-named censorship bureaucracies of the left, “human rights commissions,” consistently silence those who dare criticize Islam, most notably Christians.

Getting back to von Brunn, we can ask a similar question: Given that he hated not only Jews but also George Bush and neocons in general, of whom is he more reminiscent, Newt Gingrich or, maybe, um, Barack Obama’s buddy Reverend Wright? Bear in mind that Wright’s serpentine tongue won him the spotlight again with that recent explanation we’ve all heard for why he is persona non grata in the White House. To wit: “Them Jews ain’t going to let him [Obama] talk to me.”

Now let’s return to the matter of the impact of words. The Walshes of the world say that many of us rightists are responsible for inciting violence. In response, many on our side will say that there is only one person responsible for an act of violence, the perpetrator, be he Scott Roeder, von Dunn, Timothy McVeigh or someone else. As to these theses, the Walsh position is childish and contradictory; the rightist defense is incorrect and contradictory. Let’s discuss the Truth.

In reality, virtually all of us understand that words can seduce, be they a lover’s syrupy overtures or a hater’s cynical appeals. This is why Edward Bulwer-Lytton said that “The pen is mightier than the sword.” We treasure freedom of speech not because words are meaningless, but precisely because they’re powerful. And we allow it despite and because of words’ potential to inspire, for the pen of virtue remains eternally sharp, while the sword of vice’s edge is always dulled by time.

So while we’re right to deny responsibility for Roeder, it’s not because, as many imply, that such a thing is impossible in principle; it’s just that, in this case, we aren’t responsible in the particular (I’ll address the reason for this in a moment). And Walsh is right to imply that such things are possible in principle; her childishness lies in her silly implication that only the right is responsible for them in the particular.

Of course, it’s quite reflexive for a person — even a good one — being tarnished by guilt by association to deny the reality of indirect culpability, but the reflexive is seldom beholden to reason It’s also reflexive for dishonorable people such as Walsh to very cynically seize upon a violent event and use it to tarnish opponents, and, more ominously, to provide a specious justification for Fairness Doctrine-like legislation in the near future and hate-speech laws a bit further down the road. But whether or not the Walsh set actually believes their rhetoric depends upon the completeness of their detachment from reality.

To understand more deeply the fallacies here, consider the innumerable instances of leftist violence we’ve seen over the years. Would Moslem convert Carlos Bledsoe have murdered the army recruiter in Arkansas had he not been exposed to the anti-white, anti-Western and anti-Christian rhetoric that prevails in modern America? Would Ted Kaczynski, the Unabomber, have perpetrated his acts had he not been weaned on the environmentalist radicalism so prevalent today? Would all the domestic terrorists who firebombed fur stores and vandalized SUVs and research facilities have done so were it not for this ideological force? Would Colin Ferguson have targeted whites in the 1993 Long Island Railroad massacre had he not been assailed with anti-white rhetoric from the Reverend Wrights, Jacksons and Sharptons of the world?

Now, you can take issue with my examples; you can quibble about the particulars. But many other incidents could be cited, and the details aren’t really the issue. The point is, would we really deny that the indoctrination people are subjected to influences their thinking? Are Palestinians born hating Jews? Do madrassah schoolboys have a gene dictating hatred for the West? As for Walsh, she may turn a blind eye to the violence authored by her ilk, but an affinity for relativism doesn’t change reality.

Now we come to the crux of the matter: If rightist rhetoric can inspire others to violence just like the leftist variety, what determines culpability? Well, we must ask the only relevant question about that rhetoric:

Is it the Truth?

Sure, you may warn that a new resident in the neighborhood did time in prison for child molestation, and an angry mob may kill him. But did you do wrong? On the other hand, it’s a different matter entirely if harm befalls someone after you wrongly and maliciously label him a child molester.

Thus, anytime you sound an alarm — whether it contains the ring of Truth or that of lies — it can serve as a call to violent action for some. But what should we do? Create a Fahrenheit 451 situation in which ideas are roundly suppressed and people are kept comfortably numb? No one wants that, and it wouldn’t work anyway.

At the end of the day, one who speaks the Truth may inspire violence against livers of lies just as one who speaks lies may inspire violence against the tellers of Truth. But this isn’t the fault of the Truth; it simply means that society needs more of it.

So the moral of this story is that we all can inspire violence with words, but not all of us speak inspired words. Evil may be done in the name of good or evil, but it is only those who speak the latter who have blood on their hands. Paging Joan Walsh.
Monday, June 22, 2009 | 0 comments | Read more...



Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search