Massive Measles Vaccination Campaign Under Way In Zimbabwe
By Tapuwa Mutseyekwa
In Zimbabwe this week, a huge programme to vaccinate 5 million children against measles, dubbed the national Child Health Days initiative, is kicking off.
A growing outbreak of measles in this southern African nation has claimed nearly 400 lives, and 7,000 cases of the dangerous disease have been recorded recently. Zimbabwe and the world are banking on the immunization campaign to reverse that disturbing trend.
Speaking at the launch of the campaign, UNICEF Representative in Zimbabwe Dr. Peter Salama said this year's Child Health Days come as the country grapples with many social challenges, especially in health. Immunization coverage has plummeted in Zimbabwe, and now only about 60 per cent of all children receive the life-saving measles vaccine.
Limited central funds to support immunization have led to "a marked deterioration in service delivery across the country," said Dr. Salama. "This state of affairs, we are aware, has dramatically reduced access to services for those who need them the most."
Reaching remote areas
The 10-day national Child Health Days initiative, now in its sixth year, targets children under the age of 15. In addition to measles vaccinations, the intensive campaign will also provide children with vital immunization against polio, diphtheria, pertussis and tetanus.
The effort is being led by Zimbabwe's Ministry of Health and Child Welfare, and is supported by UNICEF, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the non-governmental organization Helen Keller International.
The government is providing vaccines, logistics and a mobile, nationwide staff capable of reaching the most remote populations in Zimbabwe. The international donor community has contributed significant resources to this campaign, as well as ongoing routine immunization in the country. Donors include the Consolidated Emergency Relief Fund, the European Commission and the Governments of Japan, the United Kingdom, Canada and the Netherlands.
Social mobilization
Also speaking during the Child Health Days launch, WHO Representative Dr. Custodia Mandlhate called on all stakeholders to work together to rid Zimbabwe of preventable diseases.
"We are calling for strong engagement and deep involvement," said Dr. Mandlhate. "Let us all join hands and renew our commitments as a caring society, caring nation."
Throughout Zimbabwe, social mobilization and community outreach activities are being ramped up, and parents are being told to bring their children to designated vaccination points at hospitals, clinics, community centres, churches and schools. Meanwhile, mobile outreach teams have been established to bring immunizations door-to-door in remote areas.
Back to a 'golden era'
UNICEF's Dr. Salama said he has high hopes that the massive push will help re-establish Zimbabwe as a leader in public health in southern Africa. There was a time when more than 80 per cent of children were vaccinated here, and Dr. Salama believes Child Health Days can help bring back that era of good health.
"There are huge opportunities for us to build back better the golden era of Zimbabwe, where public health reached every mother and child with vital services for free," he said. "But this process of building back better is not for one agency, department, ministry, sector or even a single community. It requires a collective effort and responsibility."
Source: United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF)
In Zimbabwe this week, a huge programme to vaccinate 5 million children against measles, dubbed the national Child Health Days initiative, is kicking off.
A growing outbreak of measles in this southern African nation has claimed nearly 400 lives, and 7,000 cases of the dangerous disease have been recorded recently. Zimbabwe and the world are banking on the immunization campaign to reverse that disturbing trend.
Speaking at the launch of the campaign, UNICEF Representative in Zimbabwe Dr. Peter Salama said this year's Child Health Days come as the country grapples with many social challenges, especially in health. Immunization coverage has plummeted in Zimbabwe, and now only about 60 per cent of all children receive the life-saving measles vaccine.
Limited central funds to support immunization have led to "a marked deterioration in service delivery across the country," said Dr. Salama. "This state of affairs, we are aware, has dramatically reduced access to services for those who need them the most."
Reaching remote areas
The 10-day national Child Health Days initiative, now in its sixth year, targets children under the age of 15. In addition to measles vaccinations, the intensive campaign will also provide children with vital immunization against polio, diphtheria, pertussis and tetanus.
The effort is being led by Zimbabwe's Ministry of Health and Child Welfare, and is supported by UNICEF, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the non-governmental organization Helen Keller International.
The government is providing vaccines, logistics and a mobile, nationwide staff capable of reaching the most remote populations in Zimbabwe. The international donor community has contributed significant resources to this campaign, as well as ongoing routine immunization in the country. Donors include the Consolidated Emergency Relief Fund, the European Commission and the Governments of Japan, the United Kingdom, Canada and the Netherlands.
Social mobilization
Also speaking during the Child Health Days launch, WHO Representative Dr. Custodia Mandlhate called on all stakeholders to work together to rid Zimbabwe of preventable diseases.
"We are calling for strong engagement and deep involvement," said Dr. Mandlhate. "Let us all join hands and renew our commitments as a caring society, caring nation."
Throughout Zimbabwe, social mobilization and community outreach activities are being ramped up, and parents are being told to bring their children to designated vaccination points at hospitals, clinics, community centres, churches and schools. Meanwhile, mobile outreach teams have been established to bring immunizations door-to-door in remote areas.
Back to a 'golden era'
UNICEF's Dr. Salama said he has high hopes that the massive push will help re-establish Zimbabwe as a leader in public health in southern Africa. There was a time when more than 80 per cent of children were vaccinated here, and Dr. Salama believes Child Health Days can help bring back that era of good health.
"There are huge opportunities for us to build back better the golden era of Zimbabwe, where public health reached every mother and child with vital services for free," he said. "But this process of building back better is not for one agency, department, ministry, sector or even a single community. It requires a collective effort and responsibility."
Source: United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF)
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Zimbabwe Murambatsvina Victims Still Homeless
(IRIN) - In the winter of 2005 the government uprooted some 700,000 Zimbabweans across the country in Operation Murambatsvina, officially described as a "slum clearance programme", but promises to re-house those who lost their homes and livelihoods five years ago have practically been abandoned, human rights groups say.
Amnesty International (AI), a global rights watchdog, and the Coalition Against Forced Evictions, a local group representing the dispossessed people, said the government's re-housing scheme, Operation Garikai/Hlalani Kuhle (For a better life), has failed to deliver.
"Those affected by Operation Murambatsvina rapidly became invisible; forced to relocate to rural areas, absorbed into existing overcrowded urban housing, or pushed into government designated settlements," the groups said in a joint statement.
"It is a scandal that five years on, victims are left to survive in plastic shacks without basic essential services. The needs of these victims are at risk of being forgotten because their voices are consistently ignored," said Cousin Zilala, Zimbabwe director of AI.
"The few houses that were built under the Garikai/Hlalani Kuhle scheme are completely uninhabitable - they have no floors, windows, water or toilets. Communities living in designated resettlement areas are dependent on humanitarian assistance and self-help initiatives for their survival," he commented.
In Operation Murambatsvina (drive out the filth) the Zimbabwe African National Union-Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF) government bulldozed houses, demolished informal traders' stalls and confiscated their goods, leaving them without a livelihood. United Nations Special Envoy Anna Tibaijuka visited Zimbabwe in the wake of Murambatsvina said the operation had breached both national and international human rights law.
Five weeks later the government launched the re-housing scheme, but the few houses that were built were reportedly given to civil servants, police and soldiers, and there have been no other significant government programmes to assist the hundreds of thousands of victims of Murambatsvina.
The groups condemned Zimbabwe's unity government, formed in February 2009 by the long-ruling ZANU-PF and two factions of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), for their inaction: "The unity government has done nothing to improve the plight of survivors of the forced evictions and their children who have been born in informal settlements."
Fidelis Mhashu, Minister of National Housing and Social Amenities, acknowledged that there was "a huge problem in terms of trying to provide accommodation to the population of Zimbabwe; indeed, there is a housing backlog that we ought to deal with," he noted.
"Currently, there are no substantive figures of how many people are on the housing waiting list. For Harare, [the capital] the estimates range from 500,000, while the national backlog is estimated at between 1.2 million and 1.5 million for urban areas," he told IRIN.
"The government is working flat out to ensure that the backlog is reduced, and land has been earmarked in urban areas for acquisition," he said, but progress was being hampered "because those who own the land have to be compensated [and] we don't have enough money."
Amnesty International (AI), a global rights watchdog, and the Coalition Against Forced Evictions, a local group representing the dispossessed people, said the government's re-housing scheme, Operation Garikai/Hlalani Kuhle (For a better life), has failed to deliver.
"Those affected by Operation Murambatsvina rapidly became invisible; forced to relocate to rural areas, absorbed into existing overcrowded urban housing, or pushed into government designated settlements," the groups said in a joint statement.
"It is a scandal that five years on, victims are left to survive in plastic shacks without basic essential services. The needs of these victims are at risk of being forgotten because their voices are consistently ignored," said Cousin Zilala, Zimbabwe director of AI.
"The few houses that were built under the Garikai/Hlalani Kuhle scheme are completely uninhabitable - they have no floors, windows, water or toilets. Communities living in designated resettlement areas are dependent on humanitarian assistance and self-help initiatives for their survival," he commented.
In Operation Murambatsvina (drive out the filth) the Zimbabwe African National Union-Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF) government bulldozed houses, demolished informal traders' stalls and confiscated their goods, leaving them without a livelihood. United Nations Special Envoy Anna Tibaijuka visited Zimbabwe in the wake of Murambatsvina said the operation had breached both national and international human rights law.
Five weeks later the government launched the re-housing scheme, but the few houses that were built were reportedly given to civil servants, police and soldiers, and there have been no other significant government programmes to assist the hundreds of thousands of victims of Murambatsvina.
The groups condemned Zimbabwe's unity government, formed in February 2009 by the long-ruling ZANU-PF and two factions of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), for their inaction: "The unity government has done nothing to improve the plight of survivors of the forced evictions and their children who have been born in informal settlements."
Fidelis Mhashu, Minister of National Housing and Social Amenities, acknowledged that there was "a huge problem in terms of trying to provide accommodation to the population of Zimbabwe; indeed, there is a housing backlog that we ought to deal with," he noted.
"Currently, there are no substantive figures of how many people are on the housing waiting list. For Harare, [the capital] the estimates range from 500,000, while the national backlog is estimated at between 1.2 million and 1.5 million for urban areas," he told IRIN.
"The government is working flat out to ensure that the backlog is reduced, and land has been earmarked in urban areas for acquisition," he said, but progress was being hampered "because those who own the land have to be compensated [and] we don't have enough money."
Saturday, May 22, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Ban Ki-Moon Must Stand Tall
By Bo Kyi
(DVB) -- At a recent press conference, the spokesperson for UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon asserted that “the United Nations has strongly encouraged the Myanmar [Burmese] authorities to invite regional and international monitors because we believe that that will inspire confidence in the elections”.
It is hard to imagine anything inspiring confidence in the elections. To speak of election monitors in Burma misses the point entirely. An election is more than just what happens on the day: to be effective, election observation must look at the entire electoral process over a long period of time, rather than at election-day proceedings only. For this to occur, there needs to be genuine support from the state, as occurred in Cambodia in 1993, where over 50,000 Cambodians were trained as election officials by the UN Transitional. Elections are a process and it is the process itself that is fundamental to democracy.
The legitimacy of the election in Burma will not rest on the whether international observers are allowed to monitor the election – the legitimacy of the election rests on the regime’s response to dissent.
In Burma, some 2,200 people remain in prison, where they live in dire conditions and endure appalling abuses at the hands of the military junta for their simple desire for a more peaceful and democratic Burma. If it is democracy that this election is meant to serve, then why does the junta keep locking up the very people who seek this aim?
A normal part of a democratic electoral process is debate; criticism of the incumbent government. Where the ruling party has not lived up to expectations, the election campaign is an opportunity for those contesting the election to show voters where the incumbent fell short and why they, as candidates, are a better option. In countries like the US, this is taken to the extreme, with candidates and parties publicly ridiculing each other; nothing is sacred in their efforts to expose the competition.
But in Burma, this is not the case. The Burmese junta has made clear its thoughts on “the process of fostering democracy,” when they said that “improper and inappropriate campaigns” would not be allowed. It is not hard to imagine what is meant by “improper and inappropriate,” and it is evident what the consequences for those found engaging in such campaigning would be. History shows us that desperate despots stop at nothing to perpetuate their rule. The past twenty years in Burma have shown us this much, too.
Most recently, the regime, threatened by the power of the people, enforced legislation to ensure the opposition is divided and weakened, which forced the National League for Democracy (NLD) party to disband. But this only indicates where the weakness of this regime lies. A military regime will never capture the hearts and minds of its people, not in the way that Daw Aung San Suu Kyi can, not in the way Min Ko Naing inspires generations of activists the world over. That is the power of democracy; it lies in the power of the people.
As if harassment, intimidation and imprisonment of the opposition were not enough, the ruling State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) has gone one step further to seal the fate of the election outcome: they have violated their own election laws. Burmese prime minister Thein Sein and his cronies have formed their own political party, the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP). In doing so, they violate Chapter 2, Article 4(d) of the Political Parties Registration Law, which prohibits civil servants from forming a political party.
With the 2008 constitution already ensuring the military 25 percent of the seats in parliament, the fact that the military-led USDP is now going to contest the election should dispel any doubts as to the SPDC’s true intention for any power sharing arrangement.
Regardless of whether international observers monitor the election, the elections will not be credible if they are held without the release of all political prisoners and without the criminal records of current political prisoners being wiped, therefore guaranteeing their right to participation, once released. For the secretary general of the UN to suggest otherwise is naïve, if not neglectful. What can we learn from other dictators and their sham electoral processes?
During the 2008 election in Zimbabwe, opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai withdrew from the contest because of violence against his supporters. In the run up to the election, Mugabe set paramilitary thugs on his opponents, intimidating many potential voters. At one point, Mugabe’s men even attempted to throw Tsvangirai out of an eight-story building. The state-run media spewed out propaganda; intense and abusive vitriol against the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party and Tsvangirai. The independent press was attacked, and its editors and writers frequently brought in for police “questioning.” Following the 2008 election of Mugabe, some African leaders refused to recognize Mugabe as president of Zimbabwe. Given a similar pattern of willful perversion of the electoral process in Burma, will the Southeast Asian leaders do the same?
What can we expect from Burma’s neighbours? China’s ambassador recently told reporters: “A general election being held in any country is a matter of a sovereign state, so that should be respected.” But as the British ambassador, Mark Lyall Grant, aptly noted, “The instability that could be caused by a flawed electoral process is a threat to international peace and security.”
The UN Secretary General does not provide much inspiration for those looking for a bold approach to Burma. “It’s frustrating and … disappointing that we have not seen much progress” toward democracy, said Ban Ki-moon. “Much progress” – in April alone, at least 12 political activists were arrested, bringing the number of political activists in prison to 2199. Leaping from 1185 in 2006, now, as the election looms ever closer, the figure is set to increase.
Elections are important for the democratization of Burma, but, with almost 2,200 political prisoners excluded, the election will not be democratic, or free, or fair. Democracy and human rights are interdependent. You cannot have one without the other. Political prisoners embody the denial of the most basic freedoms essential to humankind: freedom of thought, association and assembly. The treatment of these prisoners also violates fundamental rights: the right to be free from torture, the right to health and the right to an adequate standard of living. The judicial system, in Burma, far from affording individuals basic standards of justice, is employed by the regime as an instrument of repression to silence dissent. And, at every level, impunity reigns.
In 2009 Ban Ki-moon stated: “It is high time to turn the promise of the responsibility to protect into practice”. It is high time he gave meaning to these words; it is high time he stood up for the people of Burma. Without the support of the UN and the countries which make up its mandate, then all you are left with is bravery of the Burmese people to fight alone; with their words and with their hearts. It is time Ban Ki-moon stood on the side of the Burmese people. He has the freedom to speak out and those who have the freedom to speak out should do so for those who cannot. The risk for him is far less than the risk my courageous brothers and sisters take, for they will continue to risk torture and even death before renouncing their non-violent struggle.
Bo Kyi is joint secretary of the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners-Burma (AAPP)
(DVB) -- At a recent press conference, the spokesperson for UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon asserted that “the United Nations has strongly encouraged the Myanmar [Burmese] authorities to invite regional and international monitors because we believe that that will inspire confidence in the elections”.
It is hard to imagine anything inspiring confidence in the elections. To speak of election monitors in Burma misses the point entirely. An election is more than just what happens on the day: to be effective, election observation must look at the entire electoral process over a long period of time, rather than at election-day proceedings only. For this to occur, there needs to be genuine support from the state, as occurred in Cambodia in 1993, where over 50,000 Cambodians were trained as election officials by the UN Transitional. Elections are a process and it is the process itself that is fundamental to democracy.
The legitimacy of the election in Burma will not rest on the whether international observers are allowed to monitor the election – the legitimacy of the election rests on the regime’s response to dissent.
In Burma, some 2,200 people remain in prison, where they live in dire conditions and endure appalling abuses at the hands of the military junta for their simple desire for a more peaceful and democratic Burma. If it is democracy that this election is meant to serve, then why does the junta keep locking up the very people who seek this aim?
A normal part of a democratic electoral process is debate; criticism of the incumbent government. Where the ruling party has not lived up to expectations, the election campaign is an opportunity for those contesting the election to show voters where the incumbent fell short and why they, as candidates, are a better option. In countries like the US, this is taken to the extreme, with candidates and parties publicly ridiculing each other; nothing is sacred in their efforts to expose the competition.
But in Burma, this is not the case. The Burmese junta has made clear its thoughts on “the process of fostering democracy,” when they said that “improper and inappropriate campaigns” would not be allowed. It is not hard to imagine what is meant by “improper and inappropriate,” and it is evident what the consequences for those found engaging in such campaigning would be. History shows us that desperate despots stop at nothing to perpetuate their rule. The past twenty years in Burma have shown us this much, too.
Most recently, the regime, threatened by the power of the people, enforced legislation to ensure the opposition is divided and weakened, which forced the National League for Democracy (NLD) party to disband. But this only indicates where the weakness of this regime lies. A military regime will never capture the hearts and minds of its people, not in the way that Daw Aung San Suu Kyi can, not in the way Min Ko Naing inspires generations of activists the world over. That is the power of democracy; it lies in the power of the people.
As if harassment, intimidation and imprisonment of the opposition were not enough, the ruling State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) has gone one step further to seal the fate of the election outcome: they have violated their own election laws. Burmese prime minister Thein Sein and his cronies have formed their own political party, the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP). In doing so, they violate Chapter 2, Article 4(d) of the Political Parties Registration Law, which prohibits civil servants from forming a political party.
With the 2008 constitution already ensuring the military 25 percent of the seats in parliament, the fact that the military-led USDP is now going to contest the election should dispel any doubts as to the SPDC’s true intention for any power sharing arrangement.
Regardless of whether international observers monitor the election, the elections will not be credible if they are held without the release of all political prisoners and without the criminal records of current political prisoners being wiped, therefore guaranteeing their right to participation, once released. For the secretary general of the UN to suggest otherwise is naïve, if not neglectful. What can we learn from other dictators and their sham electoral processes?
During the 2008 election in Zimbabwe, opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai withdrew from the contest because of violence against his supporters. In the run up to the election, Mugabe set paramilitary thugs on his opponents, intimidating many potential voters. At one point, Mugabe’s men even attempted to throw Tsvangirai out of an eight-story building. The state-run media spewed out propaganda; intense and abusive vitriol against the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party and Tsvangirai. The independent press was attacked, and its editors and writers frequently brought in for police “questioning.” Following the 2008 election of Mugabe, some African leaders refused to recognize Mugabe as president of Zimbabwe. Given a similar pattern of willful perversion of the electoral process in Burma, will the Southeast Asian leaders do the same?
What can we expect from Burma’s neighbours? China’s ambassador recently told reporters: “A general election being held in any country is a matter of a sovereign state, so that should be respected.” But as the British ambassador, Mark Lyall Grant, aptly noted, “The instability that could be caused by a flawed electoral process is a threat to international peace and security.”
The UN Secretary General does not provide much inspiration for those looking for a bold approach to Burma. “It’s frustrating and … disappointing that we have not seen much progress” toward democracy, said Ban Ki-moon. “Much progress” – in April alone, at least 12 political activists were arrested, bringing the number of political activists in prison to 2199. Leaping from 1185 in 2006, now, as the election looms ever closer, the figure is set to increase.
Elections are important for the democratization of Burma, but, with almost 2,200 political prisoners excluded, the election will not be democratic, or free, or fair. Democracy and human rights are interdependent. You cannot have one without the other. Political prisoners embody the denial of the most basic freedoms essential to humankind: freedom of thought, association and assembly. The treatment of these prisoners also violates fundamental rights: the right to be free from torture, the right to health and the right to an adequate standard of living. The judicial system, in Burma, far from affording individuals basic standards of justice, is employed by the regime as an instrument of repression to silence dissent. And, at every level, impunity reigns.
In 2009 Ban Ki-moon stated: “It is high time to turn the promise of the responsibility to protect into practice”. It is high time he gave meaning to these words; it is high time he stood up for the people of Burma. Without the support of the UN and the countries which make up its mandate, then all you are left with is bravery of the Burmese people to fight alone; with their words and with their hearts. It is time Ban Ki-moon stood on the side of the Burmese people. He has the freedom to speak out and those who have the freedom to speak out should do so for those who cannot. The risk for him is far less than the risk my courageous brothers and sisters take, for they will continue to risk torture and even death before renouncing their non-violent struggle.
Bo Kyi is joint secretary of the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners-Burma (AAPP)
Monday, May 17, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Calls For Zimbabwe Govt To Stop Harassing Former Govt Members
The Zimbabwe authorities must stop harassing political opponents and government critics, Amnesty International said today, following the acquittal of a critic of President Robert Mugabe accused of plotting to overthrow him.
Roy Bennett, a Movement for Democratic Change official, had been charged with "conspiring to acquire arms with a view to disrupting essential services" following his arrest in February 2008. He was acquitted by a Harare court on Monday.
"While welcoming the acquittal of Roy Bennett, we remain concerned about persistent abuse of the law against perceived opponents of the former ZANU-PF government," said Michelle Kagari Amnesty International's Deputy Director for Africa.
"We urge the unity government to immediately end all malicious prosecutions of people exercising their rights to freedom of expression, association and peaceful assembly."
Roy Bennett was previously adopted as a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International in 2004 after he was sentenced to a 15-month jail term by a parliamentary committee.
Despite the creation of the unity government in February 2009, police continue to arbitrarily arrest and detain human rights activists, journalists and political activists aligned to the former opposition parties now sharing power in the inclusive government.
In the last three months human rights activists attempting to facilitate public debate on past human rights violations have been specifically targeted and their activities barred by police.
Between 26 and 28 April, police in Masvingo, Gweru and Chinhoyi stopped exhibitions of photographs depicting organised violence and torture that followed the March 2008 elections. The exhibitions were organised by the Zimbabwe Human Rights Association (ZimRights) to facilitate public debate as part of the national healing process.
In Masvingo, ZimRights' regional chairperson Mr Joel Hita was arrested and detained overnight. He is still facing unspecified charges.
Roy Bennett, a Movement for Democratic Change official, had been charged with "conspiring to acquire arms with a view to disrupting essential services" following his arrest in February 2008. He was acquitted by a Harare court on Monday.
"While welcoming the acquittal of Roy Bennett, we remain concerned about persistent abuse of the law against perceived opponents of the former ZANU-PF government," said Michelle Kagari Amnesty International's Deputy Director for Africa.
"We urge the unity government to immediately end all malicious prosecutions of people exercising their rights to freedom of expression, association and peaceful assembly."
Roy Bennett was previously adopted as a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International in 2004 after he was sentenced to a 15-month jail term by a parliamentary committee.
Despite the creation of the unity government in February 2009, police continue to arbitrarily arrest and detain human rights activists, journalists and political activists aligned to the former opposition parties now sharing power in the inclusive government.
In the last three months human rights activists attempting to facilitate public debate on past human rights violations have been specifically targeted and their activities barred by police.
Between 26 and 28 April, police in Masvingo, Gweru and Chinhoyi stopped exhibitions of photographs depicting organised violence and torture that followed the March 2008 elections. The exhibitions were organised by the Zimbabwe Human Rights Association (ZimRights) to facilitate public debate as part of the national healing process.
In Masvingo, ZimRights' regional chairperson Mr Joel Hita was arrested and detained overnight. He is still facing unspecified charges.
Monday, May 10, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Zimbabwe Opposition Infighting Faises Spectre Of Violence
A public disagreement between Zimbabwe's Prime Minister, Morgan Tsvangirai, and Finance Minister Tendai Biti over pay increases in public servants' salaries is being seen as evidence of greater divisions between two of the most senior leaders of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC).
Biti said salaries had been frozen, while Tsvangirai, leader of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), told a May Day rally that public servants, including medical staff and teachers, would be in line for salary adjustments that currently range from US$165 to US$250 a month.
Although the salaries are low by international standards, they were used to entice public servants back to the workplace when hyperinflation had reduced their pay to less than a dollar a month.
Replacing the Zimbabwe dollar with a basket of foreign currencies - including the US dollar, the South African rand and the Botswana pula - eliminated hyperinflation, but fuel and electricity remain scarce, and although food is available, many cannot afford it.
The MDC became the first party to seriously challenge Mugabe's rule since he came to power after independence from Britain in 1980 by winning a parliamentary majority during the violence-plagued 2008 elections.
The Global Political Agreement - brokered by the Southern African Development Community, a regional body - was signed in September 2008, paving the way for the formation of the unity government in February 2009 - a fragile coalition between President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's MDC, and an MDC splinter party led by Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara.
However, the performance of the unity government has not greatly altered the living conditions of most Zimbabweans. Political violence has picked up in recent months and has been largely attributed to President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF party attempting to reclaim political support and punish those seen as supporting the MDC, particularly in rural areas.
However, Tsvangirai supporters were recently held responsible for an attack on the MDC's national director, Toendepi Shone, who is seen to be aligned with Zimbabwe's finance minister, Tendai Biti, who is also secretary general of the MDC.
Shone's car was "impounded" at Tsvangirai residence and he was accused of touring the provinces to campaign for Biti in a bid to challenge Tsvangirai's position at the party's 2011 elective congress.
Tsvangirai supporters have also barred the MDC's director for security, Chris Dlamini, from the party headquarters as he was also seen as a Biti supporter. Biti still has access to the party's headquarters, but his security detail has been increased.
"We have always said that Tsvangirai has some violent bodyguards and young followers around him, but nobody has believed us," a former senior MDC official who declined to be identified, told IRIN.
The politics of division
"It would be in the interests of ZANU-PF to have a weaker MDC in the next elections in order to avoid the defeat that it experienced in 2008. ZANU-PF would want an MDC candidate who does not have national appeal, such as Morgan Tsvangirai, and they would happily fund destabilization processes within the MDC," political analyst and academic Eldred Masunungure told IRIN.
"Tsvangirai is the face of opposition politics ... and has national appeal; anybody coming out to oppose or disturb his programmes would be shunned by the people, who are thirsty for change in the country."
Another election is expected in 2011 or 2012, ratcheting up the political temperature and raising the spectre of violence between competing parties and factions that often lies just beneath the surface.
Tsvangirai has admitted to tension within the MDC but downplayed it. "The secretary general [Biti] and myself have been comrades in this struggle for many years and have stood together throughout this time, and we will not allow the enemies of real change to succeed in derailing the people's cause," he said.
"The attempt to divide us has been expressed through violence and disturbances, dubious teams sent to provinces, preaching gospels of division, and baseless and defamatory documents being manufactured and distributed to the press."
Source: IRIN
Biti said salaries had been frozen, while Tsvangirai, leader of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), told a May Day rally that public servants, including medical staff and teachers, would be in line for salary adjustments that currently range from US$165 to US$250 a month.
Although the salaries are low by international standards, they were used to entice public servants back to the workplace when hyperinflation had reduced their pay to less than a dollar a month.
Replacing the Zimbabwe dollar with a basket of foreign currencies - including the US dollar, the South African rand and the Botswana pula - eliminated hyperinflation, but fuel and electricity remain scarce, and although food is available, many cannot afford it.
The MDC became the first party to seriously challenge Mugabe's rule since he came to power after independence from Britain in 1980 by winning a parliamentary majority during the violence-plagued 2008 elections.
The Global Political Agreement - brokered by the Southern African Development Community, a regional body - was signed in September 2008, paving the way for the formation of the unity government in February 2009 - a fragile coalition between President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's MDC, and an MDC splinter party led by Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara.
However, the performance of the unity government has not greatly altered the living conditions of most Zimbabweans. Political violence has picked up in recent months and has been largely attributed to President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF party attempting to reclaim political support and punish those seen as supporting the MDC, particularly in rural areas.
However, Tsvangirai supporters were recently held responsible for an attack on the MDC's national director, Toendepi Shone, who is seen to be aligned with Zimbabwe's finance minister, Tendai Biti, who is also secretary general of the MDC.
Shone's car was "impounded" at Tsvangirai residence and he was accused of touring the provinces to campaign for Biti in a bid to challenge Tsvangirai's position at the party's 2011 elective congress.
Tsvangirai supporters have also barred the MDC's director for security, Chris Dlamini, from the party headquarters as he was also seen as a Biti supporter. Biti still has access to the party's headquarters, but his security detail has been increased.
"We have always said that Tsvangirai has some violent bodyguards and young followers around him, but nobody has believed us," a former senior MDC official who declined to be identified, told IRIN.
The politics of division
"It would be in the interests of ZANU-PF to have a weaker MDC in the next elections in order to avoid the defeat that it experienced in 2008. ZANU-PF would want an MDC candidate who does not have national appeal, such as Morgan Tsvangirai, and they would happily fund destabilization processes within the MDC," political analyst and academic Eldred Masunungure told IRIN.
"Tsvangirai is the face of opposition politics ... and has national appeal; anybody coming out to oppose or disturb his programmes would be shunned by the people, who are thirsty for change in the country."
Another election is expected in 2011 or 2012, ratcheting up the political temperature and raising the spectre of violence between competing parties and factions that often lies just beneath the surface.
Tsvangirai has admitted to tension within the MDC but downplayed it. "The secretary general [Biti] and myself have been comrades in this struggle for many years and have stood together throughout this time, and we will not allow the enemies of real change to succeed in derailing the people's cause," he said.
"The attempt to divide us has been expressed through violence and disturbances, dubious teams sent to provinces, preaching gospels of division, and baseless and defamatory documents being manufactured and distributed to the press."
Source: IRIN
Saturday, May 08, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Ahmadinejad Trip Tempts African Trade Hopes
By Howard Lesser
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s two-day visit to Zimbabwe last week has stirred up dissension within Zimbabwe’s unity government. Members of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), including Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, stayed away from official welcoming ceremonies, as they assailed the Iranian leader’s stand on human rights and other issues. The MDC argued that Mr. Ahmadinejad’s visit would send a wrong message about Zimbabwe, which is trying to restore democracy and revive a shattered economy with western aid.
Journalist Sanday Chongo Kabange covered the Ahmadinejad visit for the online media outlet Africa News. He says that in contrast, Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe has offered support for Iran’s nuclear program and generally has been trying to strengthen ties among countries at odds with the west.
“Mugabe has gone to his so-called ‘look East policy,’ where he’s seeking a lot of support from Asian countries after the United States and Great Britain, and especially the European Union, imposed travel restrictions on his government. So he’s looking out to Asia for support, especially when it comes to finance and technical support to develop his country,” he said.
Iran has been actively seeking suppliers for the development of its nuclear program. After refusing to share data with international inspectors of its uranium enrichment program and making threats against the state of Israel, Tehran has drawn several rounds of sanctions from the United Nations.
As a resource-rich southern African country, Zimbabwe is believed to have available uranium deposits to sell. On Monday, Zimbabwe Industry and Commerce Minister Welshman Ncube denied reports that Iran had won permission to extract uranium with Zimbabwe receiving oil from Iran in exchange. Journalist Kabange says that despite no mention of nuclear issues on the public agenda during last week’s talks, the subject may very likely have been raised, not only because of Iran’s needs, but also due to Harare’s interests.
“Africa is at the moment certainly experiencing a critical shortage of energy, and maybe nuclear energy will be one area that Robert Mugabe and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad might have discussed,” said Kabange.
He said Zimbabwe’s motivation for selling may also stem from both dire economic need and eager advances from rapidly expanding countries in Asia.
“When somebody’s desperate and has a lot of resources, they can do anything. Uranium is actually being explored in most African countries, and Zimbabwe has quite sufficient deposits of uranium. Probably, that is one thing that might have triggered Ahmadinejad’s visit. While trading with countries like China, for example, that are heading towards Africa to get a lot of raw materials to use it in their industries, probably the visit by Mr. Ahmadinejad would be one that’s trying to look for resources and then penetrate Africa for more uranium,” he noted.
On Friday, Mr. Ahmadinejad headed from Zimbabwe to Uganda, where he signed several cooperation agreements and sought support against a fourth round of U.N. sanctions against his nuclear expansion. Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni did not indicate whether Kampala will back new sanctions. But with leverage as a rotating member of the U.N. Security Council, Kabange says that Presidents Museveni and Ahmadinejad had a lot to talk about over the weekend.
“Iran has seen that there are a lot of raw materials in Africa. I’m sure it is trying to get as much as it can, win the support of African countries, get the raw materials, and take it back, probably to its nuclear program. It might have these enormous nuclear plans within its country and is trying to enrich itself with a lot of nuclear energy, so it wants to get as many resources from different sources in Africa,” he suggested.
President Museveni has not yet disclosed whether Uganda will back sanctions against Iran. Uganda is reportedly also interested in acquiring, perhaps from Iran, the capability to develop and refine its own oil resources in northwestern Uganda around Lake Albert, which is believed to hold approximately 2 billion barrels worth of oil.
Source: VOA
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s two-day visit to Zimbabwe last week has stirred up dissension within Zimbabwe’s unity government. Members of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), including Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, stayed away from official welcoming ceremonies, as they assailed the Iranian leader’s stand on human rights and other issues. The MDC argued that Mr. Ahmadinejad’s visit would send a wrong message about Zimbabwe, which is trying to restore democracy and revive a shattered economy with western aid.
Journalist Sanday Chongo Kabange covered the Ahmadinejad visit for the online media outlet Africa News. He says that in contrast, Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe has offered support for Iran’s nuclear program and generally has been trying to strengthen ties among countries at odds with the west.
“Mugabe has gone to his so-called ‘look East policy,’ where he’s seeking a lot of support from Asian countries after the United States and Great Britain, and especially the European Union, imposed travel restrictions on his government. So he’s looking out to Asia for support, especially when it comes to finance and technical support to develop his country,” he said.
Iran has been actively seeking suppliers for the development of its nuclear program. After refusing to share data with international inspectors of its uranium enrichment program and making threats against the state of Israel, Tehran has drawn several rounds of sanctions from the United Nations.
As a resource-rich southern African country, Zimbabwe is believed to have available uranium deposits to sell. On Monday, Zimbabwe Industry and Commerce Minister Welshman Ncube denied reports that Iran had won permission to extract uranium with Zimbabwe receiving oil from Iran in exchange. Journalist Kabange says that despite no mention of nuclear issues on the public agenda during last week’s talks, the subject may very likely have been raised, not only because of Iran’s needs, but also due to Harare’s interests.
“Africa is at the moment certainly experiencing a critical shortage of energy, and maybe nuclear energy will be one area that Robert Mugabe and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad might have discussed,” said Kabange.
He said Zimbabwe’s motivation for selling may also stem from both dire economic need and eager advances from rapidly expanding countries in Asia.
“When somebody’s desperate and has a lot of resources, they can do anything. Uranium is actually being explored in most African countries, and Zimbabwe has quite sufficient deposits of uranium. Probably, that is one thing that might have triggered Ahmadinejad’s visit. While trading with countries like China, for example, that are heading towards Africa to get a lot of raw materials to use it in their industries, probably the visit by Mr. Ahmadinejad would be one that’s trying to look for resources and then penetrate Africa for more uranium,” he noted.
On Friday, Mr. Ahmadinejad headed from Zimbabwe to Uganda, where he signed several cooperation agreements and sought support against a fourth round of U.N. sanctions against his nuclear expansion. Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni did not indicate whether Kampala will back new sanctions. But with leverage as a rotating member of the U.N. Security Council, Kabange says that Presidents Museveni and Ahmadinejad had a lot to talk about over the weekend.
“Iran has seen that there are a lot of raw materials in Africa. I’m sure it is trying to get as much as it can, win the support of African countries, get the raw materials, and take it back, probably to its nuclear program. It might have these enormous nuclear plans within its country and is trying to enrich itself with a lot of nuclear energy, so it wants to get as many resources from different sources in Africa,” he suggested.
President Museveni has not yet disclosed whether Uganda will back sanctions against Iran. Uganda is reportedly also interested in acquiring, perhaps from Iran, the capability to develop and refine its own oil resources in northwestern Uganda around Lake Albert, which is believed to hold approximately 2 billion barrels worth of oil.
Source: VOA
Tuesday, April 27, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Uganda President To Seek Clarification From US On Sanctions Against Iran
Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni will not make a decision on sanctions against Iran until he gets better explanation from the U.S. government on the sanctions to better understand the dispute over Iranian controversial nuclear program, CNN said.
"We are just students on this matter," the president said. "It is a debate I have not been following," Museveni continued.
Uganda is a non-permanent member of the U.N. Security Council. Museveni said that the country is a representative of Africa and would follow what Africa decides.
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad arrived in Uganda Friday seeking support from the country for Iranian nuclear program. Ahmadinejad described the sanctions as a "joke."
He said Iran wanted Uganda to understand that its nuclear program was for peaceful purposes adding that Western suspicions were "baseless." Earlier he accused the West of trying to deny countries' rights for nuclear energy.
However, Museveni called for a "nuclear weapons-free world." Ugandan president backed nations' rights for an access to nuclear technology, as long as they are for "peaceful purposes."
"Nuclear weapons are dangerous for humanity, even more dangerous than all the other previous weapon systems," he said. "We should, therefore, work for a nuclear weapons-free world," Museveni continued. "This means that those who have these weapons should work to get rid of them under an internationally agreed and verifiable treaty."
Iran has economic agreements with more than a dozen African nations. Iranian president had also visited Zimbabwe this week.
The United States and other Western countries suspect Iran of developing nuclear weapons under the guise of a civilian nuclear energy program and are seeking new sanctions following Iran's move to enrich uranium to 20%.
The UN-sponsored deal to supply nuclear fuel for a research reactor in Tehran proposes Iran ship out low-enriched uranium to be processed into higher-grade nuclear fuel and then returned to Iran.
Source: RIA Novosti
"We are just students on this matter," the president said. "It is a debate I have not been following," Museveni continued.
Uganda is a non-permanent member of the U.N. Security Council. Museveni said that the country is a representative of Africa and would follow what Africa decides.
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad arrived in Uganda Friday seeking support from the country for Iranian nuclear program. Ahmadinejad described the sanctions as a "joke."
He said Iran wanted Uganda to understand that its nuclear program was for peaceful purposes adding that Western suspicions were "baseless." Earlier he accused the West of trying to deny countries' rights for nuclear energy.
However, Museveni called for a "nuclear weapons-free world." Ugandan president backed nations' rights for an access to nuclear technology, as long as they are for "peaceful purposes."
"Nuclear weapons are dangerous for humanity, even more dangerous than all the other previous weapon systems," he said. "We should, therefore, work for a nuclear weapons-free world," Museveni continued. "This means that those who have these weapons should work to get rid of them under an internationally agreed and verifiable treaty."
Iran has economic agreements with more than a dozen African nations. Iranian president had also visited Zimbabwe this week.
The United States and other Western countries suspect Iran of developing nuclear weapons under the guise of a civilian nuclear energy program and are seeking new sanctions following Iran's move to enrich uranium to 20%.
The UN-sponsored deal to supply nuclear fuel for a research reactor in Tehran proposes Iran ship out low-enriched uranium to be processed into higher-grade nuclear fuel and then returned to Iran.
Source: RIA Novosti
Sunday, April 25, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Zimbabwe: Sanctions And Solidarity
By Briggs Bomba and William Minter for FPIF
Zimbabwe is currently the subject of sanctions designed to pressure Robert Mugabe and his colleagues to cease human rights abuses and remove other barriers to democratization in the country. Yet despite some recent positive developments — such as the appointment of independent commissions on human rights, elections, and the media — the future of democracy in Zimbabwe remains highly uncertain.
Hardliners in Mugabe’s party, the Zimbabwe African National Union Patriotic Front (ZANU–PF) are still resisting sharing authority with Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) officials in the government. The Southern African Development Community (SADC) continues its mediation efforts, but the parties remain stalemated on "outstanding issues." Most significantly, while day-to-day political violence has dramatically decreased, the government hasn't systematically dealt with the culture of impunity, and the potential for more violence remains. There has been no progress at all on security reform. With new elections predicted for next year, most likely without completion of a new constitution, Mugabe and his partisans retain the capacity to ramp up repression — and the will to do so.
In this context, the debate on sanctions has been highly contentious, full of strong language for and against but not much clarity on the specific measures in place and their impact, intended or otherwise.
The violations of democratic rights used to justify the sanctions have been well-documented. However, the fact that they’ve been imposed only by Western powers has undermined the international legitimacy of these measures. Even those who support sanctions have pointed out that Western countries have not imposed similar sanctions on other regimes guilty of similar offenses. President Mugabe and his defenders have even contended that sanctions are illegal as well as illegitimate. Zimbabwe's civil society has been divided on whether sanctions are appropriate or not.
Sanctions can refer to a wide variety of international measures penalizing certain actions in order to alter behavior. Any country has the sovereign right to determine its foreign policy toward another country, according to its own laws, with sanctions option occupying the middle ground between diplomacy and war. To determine whether such measures are legitimate or effective, it’s essential to look at their content, implementation, and impact.
Sanctions are only one of several policy tools. Both supporters and opponents of sanctions in Zimbabwe exaggerate their importance. The international community, at both the global and regional levels, has other means at its disposal. The key issue is not only when to lift or relax sanctions, but also how much support Western countries will provide for economic recovery, and what role Zimbabwe's African neighbors will play in this process.
Sanctions in Practice
The current sanctions differ in several respects from previous sanctions against the white-minority regimes in Rhodesia and South Africa. They are aimed at abuses by a specific political faction rather than at a system entrenched for generations. And they are explicitly defined as limited and "targeted" rather than as comprehensive.
Even so, today's debate features the same wide gap between rhetoric and reality that characterized previous debates. Thus Great Britain and the entire United Nations imposed presumably comprehensive sanctions on white-minority Rhodesia after its unilateral declaration of independence in 1965. But British and other world leaders clearly understood that South Africa, the Portuguese colonial regime in Mozambique, and even British oil companies undermined strategic components of sanctions, such as the ban on oil imports. Sanctions against Rhodesia became a decisive factor only after 1975, when Mozambique became independent and closed its transit routes to Rhodesia. And it was in part the tacit threat of sanctions from South Africa that finally induced Ian Smith to enter into negotiations for transition to majority rule.
Though labeled comprehensive, those sanctions were actually not. Similarly, today's sanctions are labeled as targeted, but no one, not even the governments that adopted sanctions, investigated to what extent they are actually affecting the intended targets.
No government has imposed comprehensive trade or investment sanctions on Zimbabwe comparable to those that anti-apartheid activists demanded, and partially achieved, against the South African apartheid regime, or to those that the United States still imposes on Cuba. Yet hard-line Mugabe supporters try to give the impression that the existing measures have massive negative effects on the Zimbabwean economy. In fact, the European Union and the United States are still among Zimbabwe's largest trading partners. EU-Zimbabwe trade totaled $561 million in 2008, the last year for which full statistics are available, second only to the dominant role of South Africa with $2.6 billion in trade with Zimbabwe. China followed with $267 million and the United States with $197 million.
In addition to prohibitions on arms sales, the limited measures in place include asset freezes and travel bans targeted at specific individuals and companies owned by them. The EU, for example, cites "persons who bear a wide responsibility for serious violations of human rights and of the freedom of opinion, of association, and of peaceful assembly." The U.S. Zimbabwe Democracy and Economic Recovery Act of 2001 (ZDERA), calling for measures later implemented by President George W. Bush, specified "individuals responsible for the deliberate breakdown of the rule of law, politically motivated violence, and intimidation in Zimbabwe."
Implementation of these measures, however, has been neither transparent nor precisely targeted. As of March 2010, the list of persons targeted by EU sanctions includes 197 individuals and 31 companies. The U.S. list, last updated in November 2008, includes 132 individuals and 54 companies. Although these lists exist on the web, no documentation explains the process for deciding which individuals or companies are candidates for inclusion. Moreover, lists from Canada, Australia, New Zealand, the United States, and the EU do not match up.
Some of those on the lists are appropriate targets of sanctions, such as Mugabe himself and officials directly responsible for violence such as war veteran leader Joseph Chinotimba, Police Commissioner Augustine Chihuri, and Zimbabwe Defense Forces Commander Constantine Chiwenga. But others clearly should not be there, such as former Minister of Health Timothy Stamps, who is on the EU list even though he retired in 2002. Stamps was responsible for the innovative and successful Zimbabwean health policies of the 1980s and early 1990s before the Mugabe government imposed cuts that devastated the system, at the insistence of international financial institutions. Other questionable additions to the EU list are people like Peter Chigoka, whose management of Zimbabwe cricket may be dubious on multiple grounds, but who can hardly be considered responsible for politically motivated violence. And including journalists, such as Judith Makwanya of Zimbabwe Broadcasting and Caesar Zvayi, of The Herald, however sycophantic their support of the regime, hardly seems consistent with advocacy of freedom of the press.
The lists seem to include all prominent government and party officials, without documenting their involvement in human rights abuses or opposition to democracy. Even if such a broad targeting mechanism were appropriate at one time, which is doubtful, it became clearly inappropriate with the establishment of the government of national unity over a year ago, in February 2009. The implementation of the agreement forming that government contains many flaws, and some ZANU (PF) hardliners are determined to sabotage it. But it's counterproductive to indiscriminately identify all ZANU (PF) officials as complicit in those actions.
A 2008 executive order by President George W. Bush, renewed in March 2009 and 2010 by President Obama, made sanctions more inflexible. The new sanctions refer not only to persons meeting the original criteria but to "senior officials of the Government of Zimbabwe," as well as to state-owned companies. One result has been the blockage of assistance to companies such as Agribank and ZB Bank, which supply financing for Zimbabwe's small-scale farmers. And even though many officials of the current unity government have not been added to the U.S. list, the wording of the executive order still reflects a counterproductive rigidity in Washington policy circles. When Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangarai's delegation met with Obama in June 2009, for example, Zimbabwe Minister of Tourism Walter Mzembi, an advocate for reform within ZANU (PF), was barred from the meeting, even though he is not on the U.S. sanctions list.
This less-than-discriminate "targeting" undermines the credibility of the sanctions within Zimbabwe and the southern African region, and casts doubt on the motives of the countries implementing the sanctions. In practical terms, the targets can easily evade serious consequences by doing their business in South Africa or Asia. The failure to win over regional public opinion through an open process significantly weakens the impact of the measures and allows defenders of ZANU (PF) to dominate the debate. Instead of changing behavior, poorly implemented and explained sanctions provide ZANU (PF) with a convenient scapegoat to divert attention from their failure to implement agreements.
International Financial Institutions
Current sanctions include a U.S. congressional mandate that the United States vote against loans or debt cancellation for Zimbabwe by international financial institutions (IFI) such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank, and the African Development Bank, unless the president determines that Zimbabwe has met certain conditions or waives this provision.
Since the formation of the unity government, relations between Zimbabwe and the IFIs have thawed. Significantly, the IMF has restored Zimbabwe’s voting rights and granted a $510 million support facility for the economic crisis, while the World Bank is managing a multi-donor fund to support recovery. But economic support for Zimbabwe is still far from adequate.
In this new era of the unity government, despite its faults, continued political restrictions on IFI dealings with Zimbabwe, such as those stated in U.S. legislation, make no sense. These institutions instead need to work constructively with the energetic efforts led by Zimbabwe's Finance Minister Tendai Biti, to turn around the economy and bring relief to long-suffering Zimbabweans. Fundamental to this effort would be relief of the nearly $6 billion in international debt that has depressed economic growth rates by two-thirds. An official debt audit and a new framework for debt contraction and management — all based on transparency and accountability — are essential.
Zimbabwe’s structural adjustment program in 1990, supposedly homegrown but crafted along standard World Bank lines, negatively affected social services and the economy more generally, sparking social struggles and eroding Mugabe's legitimacy in the eyes of Zimbabweans. While ZANU (PF) must take responsibility for the economic mismanagement, corruption, and political repression that followed, the IFIs share the blame for launching Zimbabwe's spiral of decline from its status as a model for the region. They should also take responsibility for supporting rather than hindering recovery.
From Sanctions to Recovery
Lifting sanctions on hardliners who continue to impede Zimbabwe’s democratization would be a mistake. It would be seen as a signal of impunity for future as well as past abuses. But keeping the current list as is would also be a mistake, reinforcing the incorrect premise that ZANU (PF) is homogeneous. Current sanctions, which do not take into account diverse views within Mugabe’s party, should be reviewed with more precise targeting and consistent implementation.
Such a review, including all the countries that adopted sanctions, should include a detailed evaluation of the criteria for inclusion on an agreed list of targets, investigation of the reasons for including specific persons and companies, and transparent and wide disclosure of the process and the results. The intended effect should be not only more credible implementation. It should also be aimed at gaining more support from Zimbabwean and international public opinion, with convincing documentation for every name included on the list. The list should also be updated regularly. For instance, the current list does not reflect the rapid growth and strategic importance of the diamond industry in eastern Zimbabwe, the well-documented human rights abuses by the Zimbabwean military, or corruption and illegality in assignment of contracts. The government awarded new mining rights in 2009 to two South African companies, Mbada Diamonds and Canadile Mining, which were established in collaboration with former Zimbabwean military officers and are embroiled in controversy both in Zimbabwe and South Africa. Yet there is apparently no process for investigating whether or not they should be added to the sanctions lists.
Those sanctions that remain after the review should be matched by equally prominent policy measures to support economic and social recovery in Zimbabwe, as well as continuing support for civil society. They should also urge southern African governments to consider parallel if not identical measures for effective pressure to remove obstacles to democratization.
There must also be strong and well-publicized positive measures to meet humanitarian needs and to support economic and social recovery. In fact, this is now the official policy of Zimbabwe's donors, including those countries imposing sanctions. But the consolidated UN appeal for 2009, which included $722 million for critical needs, raised only 65 percent of the total required. The 2010 appeal, released in November 2009 and calling for $378 million, had raised only $12 million by late March 2010, despite positive reports from the previous year on collaboration among donors, private agencies, and working-level Zimbabwean government officials.
While this gap can partly be explained by slow budget and disbursement processes, it also contradicts the donors' own judgment that support is "time critical." Donor countries should give much greater priority to substantive action to support both humanitarian and development needs in Zimbabwe.
Southern African Responsibility
Actions by Western countries may have some influence. Southern Africa, however, is the most decisive component of the international community for the future of Zimbabwe. Zimbabwe's neighbors, particularly South Africa and Botswana, are the most severely affected by its ongoing crisis. South Africa hosts the largest number of Zimbabwean refugees, estimated at over one million. The political and economic crisis in Zimbabwe, accompanied by xenophobic violence against refugees in South Africa, is the major threat to peace in the southern African region.
To their credit, SADC countries are engaged in ongoing diplomatic efforts to resolve the crisis. SADC helped negotiate the Global Political Agreement (GPA) that led to the formation of the unity government last year. With South Africa in the lead, SADC is also the guarantor of this agreement. South Africa is Zimbabwe's leading trading partner and has greater economic leverage than any other country. Yet while Western countries have overemphasized largely ineffective sanctions, South Africa and its SADC partners have also faltered, failing to ensure full implementation of the GPA. The impact of diplomacy has repeatedly been undermined by a stance of "see no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil," carried over from the period of President Thabo Mbeki's "quiet diplomacy."
Almost one year into the presidency of Jacob Zuma in South Africa, policy remains hobbled by the lack of a plan B to deal with ZANU (PF) intransigence. Hopes aroused by the latest round of mediation have been dashed. SADC leaders are well aware that Mugabe and his colleagues are holding up progress, just as they were well aware of the waves of state-sponsored violence that reached their height during the 2008 election crisis. In private, SADC officials often criticize ZANU (PF). Before he was president, Zuma himself publicly rebuked Mugabe for failing to step down. But in public, with the exception of Botswana's President Ian Khama, SADC leaders have failed to bring public pressure to bear on Zimbabwe's leaders to implement their commitments. Strikingly, Zuma has even undermined his own diplomacy by echoing Mugabe's talking points.
As mediators in Zimbabwe, SADC leaders have to avoid unproductive rhetoric, and South Africa has to avoid the image of a regional bully. But diplomacy without real pressure loses credibility. When diplomacy is thwarted, failure to strengthen it with other options not only evades the region's responsibility to Zimbabwe. It also endangers the stability and damages the reputation of the entire region.
The unity government has resulted in real progress in Zimbabwe, mitigating the decade-long political and economic crisis. Political violence has declined, and the economy has improved. But these changes will not be sustainable unless constitutional reform is completed and unless fundamental political change is protected from the threat of violence from an unreformed security sector. Just as Western governments need to think beyond relying primarily on sanctions, so SADC governments need to think creatively beyond exclusive reliance on "quiet diplomacy."
This does not imply, as defenders of "quiet diplomacy" often argue, a shift to the opposite extreme of "megaphone diplomacy" or intrusive mediator intervention. But the mediation process could be strengthened if SADC governments were also willing to proactively build public support for respecting human rights, the rule of law, and the illegitimacy of political violence. In particular, it is important to provide encouragement to the new human rights, electoral, and media commissions.
South African and other SADC leaders can also help focus the spotlight on abuses. In effect, although new elections may come next year or later, Zimbabwe is already in a "pre-election" period. SADC preparation should begin now. It should make use of existing SADC standards rather than waiting until increased violence is imminent. More broadly, the tone of debates in South Africa in particular can influence parallel debates in Zimbabwe. A case in point is the current debate on indigenization, where a new proposal to require 51 percent Zimbabwean ownership of companies raises real issues of economic inequality but also provides ample opportunity for elite corruption, demagogic rhetoric, and extra-legal actions.
There are also other formal mechanisms, such as the Kimberley Process (KP) for diamond certification, which may significantly affect the resources available to securocrat hardliners. SADC governments, which have leading roles in this internationally mandated process, should insist that this process go beyond technical details to fundamental issues of human rights and corruption. Abbey Chikane, the former chairman of South Africa's Diamond Board, is currently investigating Zimbabwe diamonds as the KP monitor. Whether or not he certifies the diamonds from Marange, and on what grounds, will be a key indicator of whether SADC is willing to use the leverage it has to promote accountability in Zimbabwe.
Solidarity activists should not expect anything more than incremental changes from their governments. Activist groups both in Southern Africa and around the world, including Zimbabwean diaspora groups, should also take their own initiatives.
In 2008, dockworkers around the region set a precedent for vigorous action when they refused to unload an arms shipment from China to Zimbabwe in 2008, sparking support from broader civil society. Given how the public debate on Zimbabwe is still dominated by outdated and simplistic stereotypes, international groups should prioritize highlighting the achievements of the unity government as well as exposing continuing obstacles to democracy and economic recovery. Only a visible boost in people-to-people solidarity is likely to lead governments, from Pretoria to London and Washington, to adopt more effective policies.
The primary responsibility lies with the internal efforts of Zimbabwean democratic forces. But their chances of success will depend on whether those outside, both Zimbabwean and others, also take their responsibilities seriously.
Briggs Bomba, a Zimbabwean civil society activist, is director of campaigns for Africa Action. William Minter is the editor of AfricaFocus Bulletin. Both are FPIF contributors and have recently returned from visits to Zimbabwe. This article was published by FPIF and is reprinted with permission.
Zimbabwe is currently the subject of sanctions designed to pressure Robert Mugabe and his colleagues to cease human rights abuses and remove other barriers to democratization in the country. Yet despite some recent positive developments — such as the appointment of independent commissions on human rights, elections, and the media — the future of democracy in Zimbabwe remains highly uncertain.
Hardliners in Mugabe’s party, the Zimbabwe African National Union Patriotic Front (ZANU–PF) are still resisting sharing authority with Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) officials in the government. The Southern African Development Community (SADC) continues its mediation efforts, but the parties remain stalemated on "outstanding issues." Most significantly, while day-to-day political violence has dramatically decreased, the government hasn't systematically dealt with the culture of impunity, and the potential for more violence remains. There has been no progress at all on security reform. With new elections predicted for next year, most likely without completion of a new constitution, Mugabe and his partisans retain the capacity to ramp up repression — and the will to do so.
In this context, the debate on sanctions has been highly contentious, full of strong language for and against but not much clarity on the specific measures in place and their impact, intended or otherwise.
The violations of democratic rights used to justify the sanctions have been well-documented. However, the fact that they’ve been imposed only by Western powers has undermined the international legitimacy of these measures. Even those who support sanctions have pointed out that Western countries have not imposed similar sanctions on other regimes guilty of similar offenses. President Mugabe and his defenders have even contended that sanctions are illegal as well as illegitimate. Zimbabwe's civil society has been divided on whether sanctions are appropriate or not.
Sanctions can refer to a wide variety of international measures penalizing certain actions in order to alter behavior. Any country has the sovereign right to determine its foreign policy toward another country, according to its own laws, with sanctions option occupying the middle ground between diplomacy and war. To determine whether such measures are legitimate or effective, it’s essential to look at their content, implementation, and impact.
Sanctions are only one of several policy tools. Both supporters and opponents of sanctions in Zimbabwe exaggerate their importance. The international community, at both the global and regional levels, has other means at its disposal. The key issue is not only when to lift or relax sanctions, but also how much support Western countries will provide for economic recovery, and what role Zimbabwe's African neighbors will play in this process.
Sanctions in Practice
The current sanctions differ in several respects from previous sanctions against the white-minority regimes in Rhodesia and South Africa. They are aimed at abuses by a specific political faction rather than at a system entrenched for generations. And they are explicitly defined as limited and "targeted" rather than as comprehensive.
Even so, today's debate features the same wide gap between rhetoric and reality that characterized previous debates. Thus Great Britain and the entire United Nations imposed presumably comprehensive sanctions on white-minority Rhodesia after its unilateral declaration of independence in 1965. But British and other world leaders clearly understood that South Africa, the Portuguese colonial regime in Mozambique, and even British oil companies undermined strategic components of sanctions, such as the ban on oil imports. Sanctions against Rhodesia became a decisive factor only after 1975, when Mozambique became independent and closed its transit routes to Rhodesia. And it was in part the tacit threat of sanctions from South Africa that finally induced Ian Smith to enter into negotiations for transition to majority rule.
Though labeled comprehensive, those sanctions were actually not. Similarly, today's sanctions are labeled as targeted, but no one, not even the governments that adopted sanctions, investigated to what extent they are actually affecting the intended targets.
No government has imposed comprehensive trade or investment sanctions on Zimbabwe comparable to those that anti-apartheid activists demanded, and partially achieved, against the South African apartheid regime, or to those that the United States still imposes on Cuba. Yet hard-line Mugabe supporters try to give the impression that the existing measures have massive negative effects on the Zimbabwean economy. In fact, the European Union and the United States are still among Zimbabwe's largest trading partners. EU-Zimbabwe trade totaled $561 million in 2008, the last year for which full statistics are available, second only to the dominant role of South Africa with $2.6 billion in trade with Zimbabwe. China followed with $267 million and the United States with $197 million.
In addition to prohibitions on arms sales, the limited measures in place include asset freezes and travel bans targeted at specific individuals and companies owned by them. The EU, for example, cites "persons who bear a wide responsibility for serious violations of human rights and of the freedom of opinion, of association, and of peaceful assembly." The U.S. Zimbabwe Democracy and Economic Recovery Act of 2001 (ZDERA), calling for measures later implemented by President George W. Bush, specified "individuals responsible for the deliberate breakdown of the rule of law, politically motivated violence, and intimidation in Zimbabwe."
Implementation of these measures, however, has been neither transparent nor precisely targeted. As of March 2010, the list of persons targeted by EU sanctions includes 197 individuals and 31 companies. The U.S. list, last updated in November 2008, includes 132 individuals and 54 companies. Although these lists exist on the web, no documentation explains the process for deciding which individuals or companies are candidates for inclusion. Moreover, lists from Canada, Australia, New Zealand, the United States, and the EU do not match up.
Some of those on the lists are appropriate targets of sanctions, such as Mugabe himself and officials directly responsible for violence such as war veteran leader Joseph Chinotimba, Police Commissioner Augustine Chihuri, and Zimbabwe Defense Forces Commander Constantine Chiwenga. But others clearly should not be there, such as former Minister of Health Timothy Stamps, who is on the EU list even though he retired in 2002. Stamps was responsible for the innovative and successful Zimbabwean health policies of the 1980s and early 1990s before the Mugabe government imposed cuts that devastated the system, at the insistence of international financial institutions. Other questionable additions to the EU list are people like Peter Chigoka, whose management of Zimbabwe cricket may be dubious on multiple grounds, but who can hardly be considered responsible for politically motivated violence. And including journalists, such as Judith Makwanya of Zimbabwe Broadcasting and Caesar Zvayi, of The Herald, however sycophantic their support of the regime, hardly seems consistent with advocacy of freedom of the press.
The lists seem to include all prominent government and party officials, without documenting their involvement in human rights abuses or opposition to democracy. Even if such a broad targeting mechanism were appropriate at one time, which is doubtful, it became clearly inappropriate with the establishment of the government of national unity over a year ago, in February 2009. The implementation of the agreement forming that government contains many flaws, and some ZANU (PF) hardliners are determined to sabotage it. But it's counterproductive to indiscriminately identify all ZANU (PF) officials as complicit in those actions.
A 2008 executive order by President George W. Bush, renewed in March 2009 and 2010 by President Obama, made sanctions more inflexible. The new sanctions refer not only to persons meeting the original criteria but to "senior officials of the Government of Zimbabwe," as well as to state-owned companies. One result has been the blockage of assistance to companies such as Agribank and ZB Bank, which supply financing for Zimbabwe's small-scale farmers. And even though many officials of the current unity government have not been added to the U.S. list, the wording of the executive order still reflects a counterproductive rigidity in Washington policy circles. When Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangarai's delegation met with Obama in June 2009, for example, Zimbabwe Minister of Tourism Walter Mzembi, an advocate for reform within ZANU (PF), was barred from the meeting, even though he is not on the U.S. sanctions list.
This less-than-discriminate "targeting" undermines the credibility of the sanctions within Zimbabwe and the southern African region, and casts doubt on the motives of the countries implementing the sanctions. In practical terms, the targets can easily evade serious consequences by doing their business in South Africa or Asia. The failure to win over regional public opinion through an open process significantly weakens the impact of the measures and allows defenders of ZANU (PF) to dominate the debate. Instead of changing behavior, poorly implemented and explained sanctions provide ZANU (PF) with a convenient scapegoat to divert attention from their failure to implement agreements.
International Financial Institutions
Current sanctions include a U.S. congressional mandate that the United States vote against loans or debt cancellation for Zimbabwe by international financial institutions (IFI) such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank, and the African Development Bank, unless the president determines that Zimbabwe has met certain conditions or waives this provision.
Since the formation of the unity government, relations between Zimbabwe and the IFIs have thawed. Significantly, the IMF has restored Zimbabwe’s voting rights and granted a $510 million support facility for the economic crisis, while the World Bank is managing a multi-donor fund to support recovery. But economic support for Zimbabwe is still far from adequate.
In this new era of the unity government, despite its faults, continued political restrictions on IFI dealings with Zimbabwe, such as those stated in U.S. legislation, make no sense. These institutions instead need to work constructively with the energetic efforts led by Zimbabwe's Finance Minister Tendai Biti, to turn around the economy and bring relief to long-suffering Zimbabweans. Fundamental to this effort would be relief of the nearly $6 billion in international debt that has depressed economic growth rates by two-thirds. An official debt audit and a new framework for debt contraction and management — all based on transparency and accountability — are essential.
Zimbabwe’s structural adjustment program in 1990, supposedly homegrown but crafted along standard World Bank lines, negatively affected social services and the economy more generally, sparking social struggles and eroding Mugabe's legitimacy in the eyes of Zimbabweans. While ZANU (PF) must take responsibility for the economic mismanagement, corruption, and political repression that followed, the IFIs share the blame for launching Zimbabwe's spiral of decline from its status as a model for the region. They should also take responsibility for supporting rather than hindering recovery.
From Sanctions to Recovery
Lifting sanctions on hardliners who continue to impede Zimbabwe’s democratization would be a mistake. It would be seen as a signal of impunity for future as well as past abuses. But keeping the current list as is would also be a mistake, reinforcing the incorrect premise that ZANU (PF) is homogeneous. Current sanctions, which do not take into account diverse views within Mugabe’s party, should be reviewed with more precise targeting and consistent implementation.
Such a review, including all the countries that adopted sanctions, should include a detailed evaluation of the criteria for inclusion on an agreed list of targets, investigation of the reasons for including specific persons and companies, and transparent and wide disclosure of the process and the results. The intended effect should be not only more credible implementation. It should also be aimed at gaining more support from Zimbabwean and international public opinion, with convincing documentation for every name included on the list. The list should also be updated regularly. For instance, the current list does not reflect the rapid growth and strategic importance of the diamond industry in eastern Zimbabwe, the well-documented human rights abuses by the Zimbabwean military, or corruption and illegality in assignment of contracts. The government awarded new mining rights in 2009 to two South African companies, Mbada Diamonds and Canadile Mining, which were established in collaboration with former Zimbabwean military officers and are embroiled in controversy both in Zimbabwe and South Africa. Yet there is apparently no process for investigating whether or not they should be added to the sanctions lists.
Those sanctions that remain after the review should be matched by equally prominent policy measures to support economic and social recovery in Zimbabwe, as well as continuing support for civil society. They should also urge southern African governments to consider parallel if not identical measures for effective pressure to remove obstacles to democratization.
There must also be strong and well-publicized positive measures to meet humanitarian needs and to support economic and social recovery. In fact, this is now the official policy of Zimbabwe's donors, including those countries imposing sanctions. But the consolidated UN appeal for 2009, which included $722 million for critical needs, raised only 65 percent of the total required. The 2010 appeal, released in November 2009 and calling for $378 million, had raised only $12 million by late March 2010, despite positive reports from the previous year on collaboration among donors, private agencies, and working-level Zimbabwean government officials.
While this gap can partly be explained by slow budget and disbursement processes, it also contradicts the donors' own judgment that support is "time critical." Donor countries should give much greater priority to substantive action to support both humanitarian and development needs in Zimbabwe.
Southern African Responsibility
Actions by Western countries may have some influence. Southern Africa, however, is the most decisive component of the international community for the future of Zimbabwe. Zimbabwe's neighbors, particularly South Africa and Botswana, are the most severely affected by its ongoing crisis. South Africa hosts the largest number of Zimbabwean refugees, estimated at over one million. The political and economic crisis in Zimbabwe, accompanied by xenophobic violence against refugees in South Africa, is the major threat to peace in the southern African region.
To their credit, SADC countries are engaged in ongoing diplomatic efforts to resolve the crisis. SADC helped negotiate the Global Political Agreement (GPA) that led to the formation of the unity government last year. With South Africa in the lead, SADC is also the guarantor of this agreement. South Africa is Zimbabwe's leading trading partner and has greater economic leverage than any other country. Yet while Western countries have overemphasized largely ineffective sanctions, South Africa and its SADC partners have also faltered, failing to ensure full implementation of the GPA. The impact of diplomacy has repeatedly been undermined by a stance of "see no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil," carried over from the period of President Thabo Mbeki's "quiet diplomacy."
Almost one year into the presidency of Jacob Zuma in South Africa, policy remains hobbled by the lack of a plan B to deal with ZANU (PF) intransigence. Hopes aroused by the latest round of mediation have been dashed. SADC leaders are well aware that Mugabe and his colleagues are holding up progress, just as they were well aware of the waves of state-sponsored violence that reached their height during the 2008 election crisis. In private, SADC officials often criticize ZANU (PF). Before he was president, Zuma himself publicly rebuked Mugabe for failing to step down. But in public, with the exception of Botswana's President Ian Khama, SADC leaders have failed to bring public pressure to bear on Zimbabwe's leaders to implement their commitments. Strikingly, Zuma has even undermined his own diplomacy by echoing Mugabe's talking points.
As mediators in Zimbabwe, SADC leaders have to avoid unproductive rhetoric, and South Africa has to avoid the image of a regional bully. But diplomacy without real pressure loses credibility. When diplomacy is thwarted, failure to strengthen it with other options not only evades the region's responsibility to Zimbabwe. It also endangers the stability and damages the reputation of the entire region.
The unity government has resulted in real progress in Zimbabwe, mitigating the decade-long political and economic crisis. Political violence has declined, and the economy has improved. But these changes will not be sustainable unless constitutional reform is completed and unless fundamental political change is protected from the threat of violence from an unreformed security sector. Just as Western governments need to think beyond relying primarily on sanctions, so SADC governments need to think creatively beyond exclusive reliance on "quiet diplomacy."
This does not imply, as defenders of "quiet diplomacy" often argue, a shift to the opposite extreme of "megaphone diplomacy" or intrusive mediator intervention. But the mediation process could be strengthened if SADC governments were also willing to proactively build public support for respecting human rights, the rule of law, and the illegitimacy of political violence. In particular, it is important to provide encouragement to the new human rights, electoral, and media commissions.
South African and other SADC leaders can also help focus the spotlight on abuses. In effect, although new elections may come next year or later, Zimbabwe is already in a "pre-election" period. SADC preparation should begin now. It should make use of existing SADC standards rather than waiting until increased violence is imminent. More broadly, the tone of debates in South Africa in particular can influence parallel debates in Zimbabwe. A case in point is the current debate on indigenization, where a new proposal to require 51 percent Zimbabwean ownership of companies raises real issues of economic inequality but also provides ample opportunity for elite corruption, demagogic rhetoric, and extra-legal actions.
There are also other formal mechanisms, such as the Kimberley Process (KP) for diamond certification, which may significantly affect the resources available to securocrat hardliners. SADC governments, which have leading roles in this internationally mandated process, should insist that this process go beyond technical details to fundamental issues of human rights and corruption. Abbey Chikane, the former chairman of South Africa's Diamond Board, is currently investigating Zimbabwe diamonds as the KP monitor. Whether or not he certifies the diamonds from Marange, and on what grounds, will be a key indicator of whether SADC is willing to use the leverage it has to promote accountability in Zimbabwe.
Solidarity activists should not expect anything more than incremental changes from their governments. Activist groups both in Southern Africa and around the world, including Zimbabwean diaspora groups, should also take their own initiatives.
In 2008, dockworkers around the region set a precedent for vigorous action when they refused to unload an arms shipment from China to Zimbabwe in 2008, sparking support from broader civil society. Given how the public debate on Zimbabwe is still dominated by outdated and simplistic stereotypes, international groups should prioritize highlighting the achievements of the unity government as well as exposing continuing obstacles to democracy and economic recovery. Only a visible boost in people-to-people solidarity is likely to lead governments, from Pretoria to London and Washington, to adopt more effective policies.
The primary responsibility lies with the internal efforts of Zimbabwean democratic forces. But their chances of success will depend on whether those outside, both Zimbabwean and others, also take their responsibilities seriously.
Briggs Bomba, a Zimbabwean civil society activist, is director of campaigns for Africa Action. William Minter is the editor of AfricaFocus Bulletin. Both are FPIF contributors and have recently returned from visits to Zimbabwe. This article was published by FPIF and is reprinted with permission.
Friday, April 23, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Zimbabwe: Empty Promises For Free Expression
Zimbabwe's power-sharing government has not carried out critical media reforms as promised under the country's September 2008 Global Political Agreement, Human Rights Watch said in a report released today.
The 26-page report, "Sleight of Hand: Repression of the Media and the Illusion of Reform in Zimbabwe," says that the Zimbabwe Africa National Union-Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF), the former sole ruling party, still holds the balance of power in the coalition government forged with the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), the former opposition movement, in February 2009. ZANU-PF promotes political propaganda and restricts independent reporting through repressive laws that remain unchanged, and it retains its control of security forces and key resources, Human Rights Watch said.
"The Global Political Agreement promised reforms that would guarantee transparency and promote free, fair, and credible elections," said Georgette Gagnon, Africa director at Human Rights Watch. "But these have turned out to be empty promises. The power-sharing government is taking no serious steps toward reform."
The new government has not reformed media-related laws, as promised, and blocks free expression through senior officials aligned to ZANU-PF and partisan state security agents. In the past year, not one independent television or radio station has received a license to operate.
As a result, journalists are effectively unable to report on significant political and economic developments, depriving Zimbabweans of independent sources of information. State-controlled print and electronic media only dispense ZANU-PF-approved messages.
Under the new government, at least 15 journalists have been harassed, arbitrarily arrested, or assaulted by Zimbabwe's state security forces. For instance, Anderson Manyere, a freelance photojournalist, has been arbitrarily detained three times since early 2010. On January 18, police arrested and detained him for two hours for filming a protest march in Harare by Women of Zimbabwe Arise (WOZA). He was released without charge. On another occasion, ZANU-PF youths unlawfully detained Manyere for filming their protest against international sanctions on the ZANU-PF leadership; the youths handed Manyere over to state security agents, who forced him to delete all footage in his camera before they released him.
Human Rights Watch also documented the case of Stanley Kwenda, a journalist who was forced to flee the country on January 16 following alleged death threats from a senior police officer. Kwenda had reported in The Zimbabwean newspaper that the officer had barred Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai of the MDC from visiting police stations across the country.
Kwenda said:
The police officer hurled insults and threats at me over the phone, saying, ‘Kwenda, you are to die, you will not last the weekend.' He said I would be dead before my fellow congregants at my church had said their prayers the following Sunday. I was so afraid that I was left trembling. I realized I had no protection in Zimbabwe and my only option was to flee the country.
President Robert Mugabe of ZANU-PF has begun to speak publicly about new elections in 2011. Without structural and institutional reforms, Zimbabweans risk a repeat of the horrific, state-sponsored violence of 2008, when more than 160 people were killed after ZANU-PF mobilized to prevent an MDC victory.
The new government has made a few superficial reforms, but these have resulted in little meaningful improvement for those who wish to express independent political views or to criticize official policy, Human Rights Watch said. At least five major pieces of legislation remain on the books that are used to target and silence journalists.
For instance, the Broadcasting Services Act allows for private broadcasting and provides for the issuance of licenses, but the application procedures are so complex and stringent that no licenses have been issued other than to the government-controlled Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation (ZBC).
The Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act prohibits the full-time employment of unaccredited journalists by news agencies and the mass media. The Public Order and Security Act criminalizes "publishing or communicating statements prejudicial to the State" and prohibits "undermining authority of, or insulting the President." The phrase has been interpreted broadly to prosecute critics of the president, his government, and his policies.
Human Rights Watch urged President Jacob Zuma of South Africa and his team tasked with facilitating Zimbabwe's political process to call on parties to the Global Political Agreement, particularly ZANU-PF, to carry out the promised reforms, including constitutional, electoral, and security improvements, within a specific time frame. The transitional government should guarantee, protect, and promote fundamental rights, including freedom of expression, in accordance with its domestic and international legal obligations, Human Rights Watch said.
"The power-sharing government needs to do just that - share power," Gagnon said. "Any assessment of the power-sharing government that does not address its record on human rights reforms is at best shoddy, and at worst complicit, in the government's failed promises."
The 26-page report, "Sleight of Hand: Repression of the Media and the Illusion of Reform in Zimbabwe," says that the Zimbabwe Africa National Union-Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF), the former sole ruling party, still holds the balance of power in the coalition government forged with the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), the former opposition movement, in February 2009. ZANU-PF promotes political propaganda and restricts independent reporting through repressive laws that remain unchanged, and it retains its control of security forces and key resources, Human Rights Watch said.
"The Global Political Agreement promised reforms that would guarantee transparency and promote free, fair, and credible elections," said Georgette Gagnon, Africa director at Human Rights Watch. "But these have turned out to be empty promises. The power-sharing government is taking no serious steps toward reform."
The new government has not reformed media-related laws, as promised, and blocks free expression through senior officials aligned to ZANU-PF and partisan state security agents. In the past year, not one independent television or radio station has received a license to operate.
As a result, journalists are effectively unable to report on significant political and economic developments, depriving Zimbabweans of independent sources of information. State-controlled print and electronic media only dispense ZANU-PF-approved messages.
Under the new government, at least 15 journalists have been harassed, arbitrarily arrested, or assaulted by Zimbabwe's state security forces. For instance, Anderson Manyere, a freelance photojournalist, has been arbitrarily detained three times since early 2010. On January 18, police arrested and detained him for two hours for filming a protest march in Harare by Women of Zimbabwe Arise (WOZA). He was released without charge. On another occasion, ZANU-PF youths unlawfully detained Manyere for filming their protest against international sanctions on the ZANU-PF leadership; the youths handed Manyere over to state security agents, who forced him to delete all footage in his camera before they released him.
Human Rights Watch also documented the case of Stanley Kwenda, a journalist who was forced to flee the country on January 16 following alleged death threats from a senior police officer. Kwenda had reported in The Zimbabwean newspaper that the officer had barred Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai of the MDC from visiting police stations across the country.
Kwenda said:
The police officer hurled insults and threats at me over the phone, saying, ‘Kwenda, you are to die, you will not last the weekend.' He said I would be dead before my fellow congregants at my church had said their prayers the following Sunday. I was so afraid that I was left trembling. I realized I had no protection in Zimbabwe and my only option was to flee the country.
President Robert Mugabe of ZANU-PF has begun to speak publicly about new elections in 2011. Without structural and institutional reforms, Zimbabweans risk a repeat of the horrific, state-sponsored violence of 2008, when more than 160 people were killed after ZANU-PF mobilized to prevent an MDC victory.
The new government has made a few superficial reforms, but these have resulted in little meaningful improvement for those who wish to express independent political views or to criticize official policy, Human Rights Watch said. At least five major pieces of legislation remain on the books that are used to target and silence journalists.
For instance, the Broadcasting Services Act allows for private broadcasting and provides for the issuance of licenses, but the application procedures are so complex and stringent that no licenses have been issued other than to the government-controlled Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation (ZBC).
The Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act prohibits the full-time employment of unaccredited journalists by news agencies and the mass media. The Public Order and Security Act criminalizes "publishing or communicating statements prejudicial to the State" and prohibits "undermining authority of, or insulting the President." The phrase has been interpreted broadly to prosecute critics of the president, his government, and his policies.
Human Rights Watch urged President Jacob Zuma of South Africa and his team tasked with facilitating Zimbabwe's political process to call on parties to the Global Political Agreement, particularly ZANU-PF, to carry out the promised reforms, including constitutional, electoral, and security improvements, within a specific time frame. The transitional government should guarantee, protect, and promote fundamental rights, including freedom of expression, in accordance with its domestic and international legal obligations, Human Rights Watch said.
"The power-sharing government needs to do just that - share power," Gagnon said. "Any assessment of the power-sharing government that does not address its record on human rights reforms is at best shoddy, and at worst complicit, in the government's failed promises."
Tuesday, April 20, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Clinton Statement On Zimbabwe National Day
Hillary Rodham Clinton
Secretary of State, Washington, DC
On behalf of President Obama and the American people, I congratulate the people of Zimbabwe as you celebrate 30 years of independence on April 18.
The United States believes in Zimbabwe’s promise and we support your aspirations to build an open and participatory democracy with respect for rule of law and fundamental freedoms.
The United States provides more than $300 million per year to support Zimbabwe’s economic reforms and a democratic transition, as well as for humanitarian, food, and health assistance.
We also continue to challenge Zimbabwe’s leaders to act in good faith to fully implement the Global Political Agreement and share power in an inclusive and transparent fashion for the benefit of all Zimbabweans. I urge Zimbabwe’s leaders to continue to move toward democratic reform and to open political space.
The people of Zimbabwe have persevered through considerable adversity in recent years. The United States will continue to stand with you and work with you on the road to a more peaceful and prosperous future for Zimbabwe.
Secretary of State, Washington, DC
On behalf of President Obama and the American people, I congratulate the people of Zimbabwe as you celebrate 30 years of independence on April 18.
The United States believes in Zimbabwe’s promise and we support your aspirations to build an open and participatory democracy with respect for rule of law and fundamental freedoms.
The United States provides more than $300 million per year to support Zimbabwe’s economic reforms and a democratic transition, as well as for humanitarian, food, and health assistance.
We also continue to challenge Zimbabwe’s leaders to act in good faith to fully implement the Global Political Agreement and share power in an inclusive and transparent fashion for the benefit of all Zimbabweans. I urge Zimbabwe’s leaders to continue to move toward democratic reform and to open political space.
The people of Zimbabwe have persevered through considerable adversity in recent years. The United States will continue to stand with you and work with you on the road to a more peaceful and prosperous future for Zimbabwe.
Saturday, April 17, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
In Zimbabwe North Korea's Soccer Team Brings Bad Memories
Zimbabwe's plan to host a North Korean soccer side for the June 2010 FIFA World Cup in neighbouring South Africa is rekindling memories of the Matabeleland massacres in the 1980s, amid a current climate of political intolerance.
Soon after independence from Britain in 1980, President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF launched Operation Gukhurundi - a Shona phrase for "the early rain which washes away the chaff before the spring rains" - on the pretext of tackling insurgents and counter-revolutionaries sponsored by apartheid South Africa.
He unleashed the Zimbabwean army's North Korean-trained 5th Brigade in the provinces of Matabeleland North and South, and Midlands in southwestern Zimbabwe, strongholds of the rival ZAPU party, led by Joshua Nkomo. More than 20,000 people were killed in Operation Gukhurundi.
Now, the planned visit by the soccer side is leading to a resurfacing of emotions and vows of protests against the "unwanted visitors".
Political temperatures have also been ratcheted up recently by disagreement within the unity government - a fragile coalition between Mugabe's ZANU-PF, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) and an MDC splinter party led by Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambura - over a new constitution.
ZANU-PF favours the adoption of a constitution drafted ahead of the violent March 2008 elections - known as the Kariba Draft - which concentrates power on an incumbent president, while the MDC favours a people-driven constitution, and argues that such a provision was made in the September 2008 Global Political Agreement, which paved the way for the unity government formed in February 2009.
Outreach teams have been trained to gather and compile information from Zimbabweans about what they expect in a new constitution, and will be deployed once funding is available.
Tariro Makumbe, a member of the MDC youth wing in the ZANU-PF rural stronghold of Muzarabani, in Mashonaland Central Province, in the north, fled to the capital, Harare, after her home was razed. She had objected to a ZANU-PF aligned chief's decree that not everybody would be permitted to contribute their views when the constitutional outreach team visited the area.
Censoring the constitution
"We were told that only selected ZANU-PF officials, youth and war veterans would be allowed to speak - anybody who spoke without authority would be beaten up after the constitutional outreach teams had left," she told IRIN.
Those selected to speak at the consultative meetings would favour the Kariba Draft, which includes the position that the fast-track land reform process launched in 2000 is irreversible, and that Zimbabwe will never again be a colony.
In recent weeks ZANU-PF and its youth wing has apparently launched Operation Hapana Anotaura (Nobody Speaks) to allow only the views of Mugabe's ZANU-PF party to be expressed to the constitution evaluation teams during meetings in rural areas.
"We have it on good authority that ZANU-PF has launched Operation Hapana Anotaura to stop grassroots people from freely airing their views during the constitutional outreach programme to be done by the Parliamentary Select Committee," the Centre for Community Development in Zimbabwe (CCDZ), an NGO working with traumatised communities, said in a statement.
"CCDZ is working in deeply polarised communities where Zimbabweans live in fear, and violence and intimidation is a living reality that haunts them on a daily basis," the statement said.
Elias Mudzuri, energy minister in the unity government and organising secretary of Tsvangirai's MDC, said he encountered increasing levels of political intolerance while travelling recently to the opening of a clinic in the Mashonaland Central Province.
"ZANU-PF youth militia set up roadblocks and threatened villagers from attending the function. We should not be allowing such acts of brutality to be taking place in modern Zimbabwe. I shudder to imagine what villagers in the remote parts of the country, who support the MDC, have to go through at the hands of marauding ZANU-PF militia who take the law into their hands at will."
Secretary-general of the MDC's youth wing, Solomon Madzore, told IRIN his organization was planning to visit rural areas to "conscientise" people, so that they should actively and openly participate in the constitution-making process.
"We want to remove the element of fear by talking to our parents and the general populace in the countryside," he said. "There is nothing illegal about the constitution-making process, which is a product of the inclusive [unity] government."
Source: IRIN
Soon after independence from Britain in 1980, President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF launched Operation Gukhurundi - a Shona phrase for "the early rain which washes away the chaff before the spring rains" - on the pretext of tackling insurgents and counter-revolutionaries sponsored by apartheid South Africa.
He unleashed the Zimbabwean army's North Korean-trained 5th Brigade in the provinces of Matabeleland North and South, and Midlands in southwestern Zimbabwe, strongholds of the rival ZAPU party, led by Joshua Nkomo. More than 20,000 people were killed in Operation Gukhurundi.
Now, the planned visit by the soccer side is leading to a resurfacing of emotions and vows of protests against the "unwanted visitors".
Political temperatures have also been ratcheted up recently by disagreement within the unity government - a fragile coalition between Mugabe's ZANU-PF, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) and an MDC splinter party led by Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambura - over a new constitution.
ZANU-PF favours the adoption of a constitution drafted ahead of the violent March 2008 elections - known as the Kariba Draft - which concentrates power on an incumbent president, while the MDC favours a people-driven constitution, and argues that such a provision was made in the September 2008 Global Political Agreement, which paved the way for the unity government formed in February 2009.
Outreach teams have been trained to gather and compile information from Zimbabweans about what they expect in a new constitution, and will be deployed once funding is available.
Tariro Makumbe, a member of the MDC youth wing in the ZANU-PF rural stronghold of Muzarabani, in Mashonaland Central Province, in the north, fled to the capital, Harare, after her home was razed. She had objected to a ZANU-PF aligned chief's decree that not everybody would be permitted to contribute their views when the constitutional outreach team visited the area.
Censoring the constitution
"We were told that only selected ZANU-PF officials, youth and war veterans would be allowed to speak - anybody who spoke without authority would be beaten up after the constitutional outreach teams had left," she told IRIN.
Those selected to speak at the consultative meetings would favour the Kariba Draft, which includes the position that the fast-track land reform process launched in 2000 is irreversible, and that Zimbabwe will never again be a colony.
In recent weeks ZANU-PF and its youth wing has apparently launched Operation Hapana Anotaura (Nobody Speaks) to allow only the views of Mugabe's ZANU-PF party to be expressed to the constitution evaluation teams during meetings in rural areas.
"We have it on good authority that ZANU-PF has launched Operation Hapana Anotaura to stop grassroots people from freely airing their views during the constitutional outreach programme to be done by the Parliamentary Select Committee," the Centre for Community Development in Zimbabwe (CCDZ), an NGO working with traumatised communities, said in a statement.
"CCDZ is working in deeply polarised communities where Zimbabweans live in fear, and violence and intimidation is a living reality that haunts them on a daily basis," the statement said.
Elias Mudzuri, energy minister in the unity government and organising secretary of Tsvangirai's MDC, said he encountered increasing levels of political intolerance while travelling recently to the opening of a clinic in the Mashonaland Central Province.
"ZANU-PF youth militia set up roadblocks and threatened villagers from attending the function. We should not be allowing such acts of brutality to be taking place in modern Zimbabwe. I shudder to imagine what villagers in the remote parts of the country, who support the MDC, have to go through at the hands of marauding ZANU-PF militia who take the law into their hands at will."
Secretary-general of the MDC's youth wing, Solomon Madzore, told IRIN his organization was planning to visit rural areas to "conscientise" people, so that they should actively and openly participate in the constitution-making process.
"We want to remove the element of fear by talking to our parents and the general populace in the countryside," he said. "There is nothing illegal about the constitution-making process, which is a product of the inclusive [unity] government."
Source: IRIN
Tuesday, April 13, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Food Insecurity Threatens Rural Zimbabwe Villages
The villagers of Nkalanje, in Zimbabwe's arid Matabeleland South Province, use bells tied around the necks of their livestock to track animals that roam ever greater distances in search of sparse tufts of grass as a dry spell tightens its grip in the already food insecure country.
Nicholas Ntepe, 40, told IRIN he often spent days away from home to find his livestock and bring them closer to home. "It is a tough life, because I have to divide my time between looking for my livestock and looking for food to feed my family."
An assessment by at the beginning of April indicated that crops had failed in all seven districts of Matabeleland South, and an estimated 9,000 tons of maize would be required each month to mitigate the effects of the expected food shortages.
The governor of the province, Angeline Masuku, told IRIN: "We have not yet had distress calls, possibly because some people are still surviving on produce such as pumpkins, but we expect to stock up maize so that we are found ready when the food shortages become more pronounced."
Masuku said although the province had received occasional drizzle, which had improved pastures, most of the crops were a write-off and sparse pastures posed a serious threat to villagers' livestock.
The province plans to introduce a scheme in which villagers undertake community improvement tasks, such as assisting clinics, schools and other public institutions, in return for food.
A similar situation is unfolding in Midlands Province, where the harvest is projected to fail in most parts, with the districts of Mberengwa, Zvishavane, Shurugwi, Gweru and Mvuma hardest hit.
About 2.4 million people received food assistance in the first quarter of 2010 and a recent UNICEF report noted that "approximately 78 percent of the population of Zimbabwe is absolutely poor, and 55 percent live below the food poverty line".
People living below the food poverty line cannot meet any of their basic needs and suffer chronic hunger. The report said an estimated 6.6 million people, including 3.5 million children, were suffering this extreme form of deprivation.
'We need food aid as of yesterday'
A report by the Famine Early Warning System Network (FEWSNET) said although most households in rural areas had come through the peak hunger season, adverse agricultural conditions were affecting Masvingo, Matabeleland South and Manicaland provinces, among other areas.
''It's another bad year for the province, as only three out of eight districts are likely to record meaningful harvests this year''
"It's another bad year for the province, as only three out of eight districts are likely to record meaningful harvests this year," Jason Machaya, governor of Midlands, told IRIN. "The tonnage is far less than what we require to feed all the families that have run out of food, and there is urgent need to source more maize."
Chief Ngungumbane, in Mberengwa district, Midlands, told IRIN: "People here have not harvested anything for the past two years. At the moment only one NGO [which he did not name] is assisting people under the food-for-work programme, but this is not enough because most families ran out of food last year."
The people who were most vulnerable would slip through the net if they could not work. "Those living with HIV and AIDS, the aged and the disabled cannot benefit, yet they are the worst affected," Ngungumbane said.
Nyasha Zindove, the administrator of Zaka district in Masvingo Province, said there was urgent need for food relief. "We need food aid as of yesterday - at least 100,000 villagers are vulnerable."
Source: IRIN
Nicholas Ntepe, 40, told IRIN he often spent days away from home to find his livestock and bring them closer to home. "It is a tough life, because I have to divide my time between looking for my livestock and looking for food to feed my family."
An assessment by at the beginning of April indicated that crops had failed in all seven districts of Matabeleland South, and an estimated 9,000 tons of maize would be required each month to mitigate the effects of the expected food shortages.
The governor of the province, Angeline Masuku, told IRIN: "We have not yet had distress calls, possibly because some people are still surviving on produce such as pumpkins, but we expect to stock up maize so that we are found ready when the food shortages become more pronounced."
Masuku said although the province had received occasional drizzle, which had improved pastures, most of the crops were a write-off and sparse pastures posed a serious threat to villagers' livestock.
The province plans to introduce a scheme in which villagers undertake community improvement tasks, such as assisting clinics, schools and other public institutions, in return for food.
A similar situation is unfolding in Midlands Province, where the harvest is projected to fail in most parts, with the districts of Mberengwa, Zvishavane, Shurugwi, Gweru and Mvuma hardest hit.
About 2.4 million people received food assistance in the first quarter of 2010 and a recent UNICEF report noted that "approximately 78 percent of the population of Zimbabwe is absolutely poor, and 55 percent live below the food poverty line".
People living below the food poverty line cannot meet any of their basic needs and suffer chronic hunger. The report said an estimated 6.6 million people, including 3.5 million children, were suffering this extreme form of deprivation.
'We need food aid as of yesterday'
A report by the Famine Early Warning System Network (FEWSNET) said although most households in rural areas had come through the peak hunger season, adverse agricultural conditions were affecting Masvingo, Matabeleland South and Manicaland provinces, among other areas.
''It's another bad year for the province, as only three out of eight districts are likely to record meaningful harvests this year''
"It's another bad year for the province, as only three out of eight districts are likely to record meaningful harvests this year," Jason Machaya, governor of Midlands, told IRIN. "The tonnage is far less than what we require to feed all the families that have run out of food, and there is urgent need to source more maize."
Chief Ngungumbane, in Mberengwa district, Midlands, told IRIN: "People here have not harvested anything for the past two years. At the moment only one NGO [which he did not name] is assisting people under the food-for-work programme, but this is not enough because most families ran out of food last year."
The people who were most vulnerable would slip through the net if they could not work. "Those living with HIV and AIDS, the aged and the disabled cannot benefit, yet they are the worst affected," Ngungumbane said.
Nyasha Zindove, the administrator of Zaka district in Masvingo Province, said there was urgent need for food relief. "We need food aid as of yesterday - at least 100,000 villagers are vulnerable."
Source: IRIN
Saturday, April 10, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Zimbabwe Electoral And Human Rights Commissions Launched
Zimbabwe's members of the electoral commission and the human rights commission were sworn-in Thursday before President Mugabe.
The two organisms, along with a media commission – serving since December – will enable Zimbabwe to take a significant step in advancing the normalization process in the country.
Borne out of the agreement between Mugabe’s Zanu–Pf , Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC-T and deputy PM Arthur Mutambara’s MDC-M, the two commissions, still vacant, were considered to be essential to face a series of political questions and, according to various observers, they are politically balanced with technical people and officials that refer to the various components making up the national unity government.
The electoral commission will be presided by Justice Simpson Mutambanengwe, former judge of the Supreme Court. Reginald Austin will head the Human Rights commission, whose task will be to investigate violations perpetrated in the past and to monitor respect for fundamental rights.
The nominations have come just weeks after South African President Jacob Zuma’s visit to Harare, according to whom, the parties had committed to resolve the internal tensions of the coalition, tensions largely tied to the appointment of high officials and the issue of EU and US imposed sanctions against 200 officials with close ties to Mugabe and the Zanu-PF.
Source: Original reporting MISNA
The two organisms, along with a media commission – serving since December – will enable Zimbabwe to take a significant step in advancing the normalization process in the country.
Borne out of the agreement between Mugabe’s Zanu–Pf , Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC-T and deputy PM Arthur Mutambara’s MDC-M, the two commissions, still vacant, were considered to be essential to face a series of political questions and, according to various observers, they are politically balanced with technical people and officials that refer to the various components making up the national unity government.
The electoral commission will be presided by Justice Simpson Mutambanengwe, former judge of the Supreme Court. Reginald Austin will head the Human Rights commission, whose task will be to investigate violations perpetrated in the past and to monitor respect for fundamental rights.
The nominations have come just weeks after South African President Jacob Zuma’s visit to Harare, according to whom, the parties had committed to resolve the internal tensions of the coalition, tensions largely tied to the appointment of high officials and the issue of EU and US imposed sanctions against 200 officials with close ties to Mugabe and the Zanu-PF.
Source: Original reporting MISNA
Thursday, April 01, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...
Tracking Male Circumcision Rollout In Africa
Medical male circumcision is now widely recognized as an important HIV prevention tool, and several African countries have included it in their national HIV strategies.
IRIN/PlusNews lists the progress of 13 nations in eastern and southern Africa identified as priority countries for male circumcision scale-up by the UN World Health Organization.
Kenya: An estimated 85 percent of men are circumcised, but just 40 percent of those in Nyanza province, which has the country's highest prevalence, have had the procedure. In 2008 the government launched a national campaign and by the end of 2009 more than 90,000 men had been circumcised, 40,000 of them during a two-month "rapid results" initiative in Nyanza.
The government aims to have all uncircumcised men - an estimated 1.1 million - undergo the procedure by 2013. Kenya is the only African country to have successfully rolled out male circumcision on such a large scale.
Zambia: Male circumcision prevalence is 13 percent, and Zambia aims to circumcise about 250,000 men every year. More than 16,000 men were circumcised at 11 sites in 2009, and the goal is to have 300 sites offering the services by 2014.
Swaziland: The Ministry of Health and Human Services plans to provide circumcision to 80 percent of men aged 15 to 24 by the end of 2014. Just eight percent of Swazi men are circumcised. The country - which has the world's highest HIV prevalence - developed a male circumcision strategy in 2008; by the end of 2009 more than 5,000 men had undergone the surgery.
Botswana: Five centres of excellence have been identified to scale-up circumcision services, and Botswana's Ministry of Health aims to reach at least 460,000 HIV negative men and boys below the age of 49 by 2012. More than 4,300 men have been circumcised since April 2009.
Zimbabwe: In April 2009 the pilot phase of service delivery began, during which 1,818 men were circumcised at four sites. A national male circumcision policy was launched in November 2009.
Rwanda: Since 2008 the government has been rolling out male circumcision in the army, where prevalence is 4.5 percent compared to a national rate of three percent. A recent study suggested that Rwanda should also be scaling up circumcision across a broad range of age groups, especially the very young, where the procedure was found to be highly cost-effective.
South Africa: The government has been criticized for moving too slowly in developing a national circumcision strategy. By December 2009 the country had a draft policy but no mechanisms for training, quality assurance, or monitoring and evaluation. South Africa has the world's largest HIV-positive population.
About 35 percent of men are circumcised. Data from the only site currently providing free circumcision - Orange Farm, near Johannesburg - reveals that 14,253 men were circumcised in 2009.
Namibia: A draft policy was submitted to parliament and training of surgical health professionals is underway. Five circumcision pilot sites have been identified, two of which are in operation. A 2009 field analysis showed that the unit cost per procedure was very high: US$88 for adults and $72 for newborns.
Lesotho: About 4,000 men are circumcised annually at government and private clinics. A policy has been approved but is yet to be launched, and formal scale-up has not yet started. The Puisano Outreach Organization, a local NGO, is engaged in male circumcision campaigns throughout the country.
Tanzania: A 2009 situation analysis found male circumcision was accepted, even among traditionally non-circumcising communities, and 70 percent of Tanzanian men were circumcised. A national policy is being developed and three demonstration sites have been set up.
Mozambique: No formal policy for male circumcision has been developed, but an existing operational plan for HIV prevention includes circumcision. Five pilot sites have been selected for scale-up in 2010.
Malawi: The country is conducting data analysis to inform its male circumcision strategy. A local NGO, Banja la Mtsogolo, is providing male circumcision services in its clinics, where it has 19 trained clinicians performing the procedure.
Uganda: This is one of the three countries where studies showed the link between male circumcision and HIV, but only 25 percent of men are circumcised and HIV prevalence is rising. There has been some criticism for failing to start male circumcision quickly enough - the country still has no policy, nor has it started service delivery.
Source: IRIN
IRIN/PlusNews lists the progress of 13 nations in eastern and southern Africa identified as priority countries for male circumcision scale-up by the UN World Health Organization.
Kenya: An estimated 85 percent of men are circumcised, but just 40 percent of those in Nyanza province, which has the country's highest prevalence, have had the procedure. In 2008 the government launched a national campaign and by the end of 2009 more than 90,000 men had been circumcised, 40,000 of them during a two-month "rapid results" initiative in Nyanza.
The government aims to have all uncircumcised men - an estimated 1.1 million - undergo the procedure by 2013. Kenya is the only African country to have successfully rolled out male circumcision on such a large scale.
Zambia: Male circumcision prevalence is 13 percent, and Zambia aims to circumcise about 250,000 men every year. More than 16,000 men were circumcised at 11 sites in 2009, and the goal is to have 300 sites offering the services by 2014.
Swaziland: The Ministry of Health and Human Services plans to provide circumcision to 80 percent of men aged 15 to 24 by the end of 2014. Just eight percent of Swazi men are circumcised. The country - which has the world's highest HIV prevalence - developed a male circumcision strategy in 2008; by the end of 2009 more than 5,000 men had undergone the surgery.
Botswana: Five centres of excellence have been identified to scale-up circumcision services, and Botswana's Ministry of Health aims to reach at least 460,000 HIV negative men and boys below the age of 49 by 2012. More than 4,300 men have been circumcised since April 2009.
Zimbabwe: In April 2009 the pilot phase of service delivery began, during which 1,818 men were circumcised at four sites. A national male circumcision policy was launched in November 2009.
Rwanda: Since 2008 the government has been rolling out male circumcision in the army, where prevalence is 4.5 percent compared to a national rate of three percent. A recent study suggested that Rwanda should also be scaling up circumcision across a broad range of age groups, especially the very young, where the procedure was found to be highly cost-effective.
South Africa: The government has been criticized for moving too slowly in developing a national circumcision strategy. By December 2009 the country had a draft policy but no mechanisms for training, quality assurance, or monitoring and evaluation. South Africa has the world's largest HIV-positive population.
About 35 percent of men are circumcised. Data from the only site currently providing free circumcision - Orange Farm, near Johannesburg - reveals that 14,253 men were circumcised in 2009.
Namibia: A draft policy was submitted to parliament and training of surgical health professionals is underway. Five circumcision pilot sites have been identified, two of which are in operation. A 2009 field analysis showed that the unit cost per procedure was very high: US$88 for adults and $72 for newborns.
Lesotho: About 4,000 men are circumcised annually at government and private clinics. A policy has been approved but is yet to be launched, and formal scale-up has not yet started. The Puisano Outreach Organization, a local NGO, is engaged in male circumcision campaigns throughout the country.
Tanzania: A 2009 situation analysis found male circumcision was accepted, even among traditionally non-circumcising communities, and 70 percent of Tanzanian men were circumcised. A national policy is being developed and three demonstration sites have been set up.
Mozambique: No formal policy for male circumcision has been developed, but an existing operational plan for HIV prevention includes circumcision. Five pilot sites have been selected for scale-up in 2010.
Malawi: The country is conducting data analysis to inform its male circumcision strategy. A local NGO, Banja la Mtsogolo, is providing male circumcision services in its clinics, where it has 19 trained clinicians performing the procedure.
Uganda: This is one of the three countries where studies showed the link between male circumcision and HIV, but only 25 percent of men are circumcised and HIV prevalence is rising. There has been some criticism for failing to start male circumcision quickly enough - the country still has no policy, nor has it started service delivery.
Source: IRIN
Saturday, March 06, 2010 |
2
comments |
Read more...
Political And Security Challenges For Zimbabwe Transition
Despite initial scepticism, Zimbabwe’s year-old unity government has achievements to its credit, but the democratic transition remains at risk, especially from hard-line security officials – President Robert Mugabe’s last reliable supporters.
A wide range of problems could return Zimbabwe to where it was a year ago – on the edge of collapse – if the long-ruling Zimbabwe African National Union (ZANU-PF) party and the military leadership maintain an intransigent stance on the reforms for economic and political stability.
The International Crisis Group report "Zimbabwe: Political and Security Challenges to the Transition," analyses the situation resulting from the Global Political Agreement (GPA) that broke the stalemate following failed 2008 presidential elections and led to formation of the unity government in February 2009. According to the report all domestic signatories of the GPA, as well as the South African mediation, must embrace democratic transformation as the vital objective of the transition.
"As Zimbabwe enters its second year under a unity government, the challenges to democratic transformation are in sharp focus," said Africa Program Director François Grignon. "The military leadership and other Mugabe loyalists in ZANU-PF are using their symbiotic relationship with the state apparatus to exercise veto power over the transition. A mature political system must develop, so ZANU-PF and the MDC engage as both competitors in politics and partners in government."
Against the odds, the government that brought together President Mugabe and the leaders of the divided wings of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara, started well. Schools and hospitals re-opened; civil servants were paid and returned to work; Hyperinflation was halted; goods returned to store shelves; a cholera epidemic was controlled; human rights activists reported a significant drop in abuses.
Nevertheless, the International Crisis Group warns that major threats can still derail the reform process.
In particular, the resistance of powerful security sector leaders and fractious in-fighting between and within ZANU-PF and the MDC must be addressed now. South African President Jacob Zuma and the Southern African Development Community (SADC) need to press the parties, and especially Mugabe, to see the transition to a successful conclusion. Western donors should back their efforts, including by expanding assistance, keeping targeted sanctions on spoilers but also by ending sanctions on firms important for economic growth.
A relatively small number of “securocrats” oppose reforms, motivated by the fear of losing power, wealth and impunity. Zimbabweans across the political spectrum are quietly considering how to ease them into retirement, while simultaneously professionalising security forces respectful of human rights and a democratically elected government.
"Inter-party cooperation and the full engagement of civil society are essential for a successful democratic transition," said Donald Steinberg, Crisis Group’s Deputy President for Policy. "Above all, Zimbabweans themselves must put the legacy of ‘divide-and-rule’ politics behind them."
A wide range of problems could return Zimbabwe to where it was a year ago – on the edge of collapse – if the long-ruling Zimbabwe African National Union (ZANU-PF) party and the military leadership maintain an intransigent stance on the reforms for economic and political stability.
The International Crisis Group report "Zimbabwe: Political and Security Challenges to the Transition," analyses the situation resulting from the Global Political Agreement (GPA) that broke the stalemate following failed 2008 presidential elections and led to formation of the unity government in February 2009. According to the report all domestic signatories of the GPA, as well as the South African mediation, must embrace democratic transformation as the vital objective of the transition.
"As Zimbabwe enters its second year under a unity government, the challenges to democratic transformation are in sharp focus," said Africa Program Director François Grignon. "The military leadership and other Mugabe loyalists in ZANU-PF are using their symbiotic relationship with the state apparatus to exercise veto power over the transition. A mature political system must develop, so ZANU-PF and the MDC engage as both competitors in politics and partners in government."
Against the odds, the government that brought together President Mugabe and the leaders of the divided wings of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara, started well. Schools and hospitals re-opened; civil servants were paid and returned to work; Hyperinflation was halted; goods returned to store shelves; a cholera epidemic was controlled; human rights activists reported a significant drop in abuses.
Nevertheless, the International Crisis Group warns that major threats can still derail the reform process.
In particular, the resistance of powerful security sector leaders and fractious in-fighting between and within ZANU-PF and the MDC must be addressed now. South African President Jacob Zuma and the Southern African Development Community (SADC) need to press the parties, and especially Mugabe, to see the transition to a successful conclusion. Western donors should back their efforts, including by expanding assistance, keeping targeted sanctions on spoilers but also by ending sanctions on firms important for economic growth.
A relatively small number of “securocrats” oppose reforms, motivated by the fear of losing power, wealth and impunity. Zimbabweans across the political spectrum are quietly considering how to ease them into retirement, while simultaneously professionalising security forces respectful of human rights and a democratically elected government.
"Inter-party cooperation and the full engagement of civil society are essential for a successful democratic transition," said Donald Steinberg, Crisis Group’s Deputy President for Policy. "Above all, Zimbabweans themselves must put the legacy of ‘divide-and-rule’ politics behind them."
Thursday, March 04, 2010 |
0
comments |
Read more...









