Dispatch From A Show Trial

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

By Grigory Pasko

March 31 will mark the one year anniversary of the start of the second trial of Mikhail Khodorkovsky. When a court trial drags on for more than a year, I need not listen to the hearsay, but rather I have had the "pleasure" of observing one from the inside.

Если Вы хотите прочитать оригинал данной статьи на русском языке, нажмите сюда.

This was not my first visit to the latest session of the Khamovnichesky Court in the case of the former YUKOS managers. I was amazed that, like a year ago, like half a year ago, like a month ago - there was a multitude of spectators. It is already obvious: interest in the trial, at the very least, has not weakened. And from the discussions in the net one can even say that it has grown: people understand ever more - the trial has obviously been ordered from above, is political, clearly unfair, and the power that has started it up in the first place clearly does not know what to do next.

That is, the repressive convoy-justice «machine» was put in motion long ago. Who will stop it and how - is something probably nobody understands or knows.

The «machine» does some very strange things at every step. First they declared the trial to be open, so much so that they even put television panels up in a separate hall - for direct broadcast of the trial. Soon they rejected this idea: it's just uncustomary that everybody's laughing at the prejudice, powerlessness and shabbiness of the thinking of the procurators, while they - are people of a delicate spiritual constitution.

In the courtroom it is cramped and stuffy. To record the trial on video and to photograph is also not allowed, although the trial is open. They say that this - is also at the demand of the spiritually woundable procurators.

A part of the «machine» are - the convoyers [Russian for the guards responsible for transporting prisoners--Trans.]. The young lads-robots, overdosed on bad action movies, with a delirious look and machine-guns atilt, appear ludicrous and laughable. But nobody's told them about this. And they guard Khodorkovsky and Lebedev with such fury that one is even scared - for them themselves first and foremost: after all, you could get a heart attack from overdoing it like that.

The procurators carry their concerned look with a sense of procuratorial dignity. For some reason they're dressed differently [Russian prosecutors generally wear matching light-blue military-style uniforms to work--Trans.] "Straight as a shot from a gun", Lakhtin - in a suit and tie; the half-asleep Shokhin - in a shirt with a short sleeve and without a tie; Ibragimova, smiling at something - in a shirt with a long sleeve, but without a tie.... In a word, to use the terminology of Go'lchehra Ibragimova, one's like Stenka, in a hat; another, like Juan, in a sombrero. They are sometimes cheerful, sometimes don't even pose questions to the witnesses. But with great pleasure, as it appeared to me, they attempt to object against the defendants, when these pose their own questions to the witnesses.

Judge Danilkin is practically not even visible because of the table. He's got a labored look and a dreary gaze. Both the look and the gaze literally say: I'm here by accident and not by my will; I don't know what to do next and how to do next; we're all in one boat, which is floating who knows where and is being led by who knows who.

He even pronounced a phrase that was pure genius for a judge:

- I'm covering for myself, so there wouldn't be a situation...

A situation, moreover foul-smelling, nevertheless exists.

And it is this: the witnesses are stubbornly not testifying in favor of the prosecution.

If they (and after all, the procurators had presented them as prosecution witnesses!) had come to court and said: yes, we saw (heard, know, have proof in the form of documents, etc.) that Messrs. Khodorkovsky and Lebedev were pilfering oil and were getting for this unaccounted-for incomes, going away from the payment of taxes, having unlawfully in such a manner enriched themselves, then this whole trial would have ended a long time ago.

And there wouldn't be any perpetually irritated procurators; lawyers and defendants worn out by the pointless stupidity of what is taking place; a judge cornered by boredom...

One of the permanent observers at the trial shared impressions with me: "Shokhin ought to be writing textbooks on demagogy - the person says remarkably much and not on topic."

Unfortunately, that day Shokhin either kept his mouth shut, or slept.

Among the visitors in the hall - journalists, representatives of international organizations, former employees of the YUKOS company.. .I met my acquaintances and colleagues from Reporters without Borders and International French radio.

The defendants, despite all this, look and hold themselves well and participate actively in the trial. Possibly more actively than anybody else. I understand them: I've been in such a situation myself. And here the matter is not that the lawyers have pulled back, no. It's just that the trial is at such a stage that the prosecution witnesses have clearly fizzled out, but the trial itself does not promise anything out of the ordinary at this stage.

The dismay in the heads of the organizers of the trial has led to a situation where telejournalists from REN-TV have all of a sudden wandered into the trial. Lakhtin nearly had a heart attack: he jumped up, got all bent out of shape... But a court representative explained to him that there is permission. (Later there was a story a whole two minutes long on the news).

The witness Kudasov was treasurer. Standing behind the lectern [as witnesses do in Russian courts--Trans.] is uncomfortable for him, he needs to bend down to the microphone all the time, but his voice doesn't get any louder for this.

The conversation is taking place between him and the defendants. They are talking about things that are little-comprehensible or completely incomprehensible to the majority of those present, including the judge and the procurators. Drawing up contracts, financial accounting consolidated reporting, capital investments, affiliated companies... Businessmen prattling away in their own language, and one thing never does jump out from their dialogues: the guilt of the defendants.

- Did you transfer money to the personal accounts of citizens?, -- asks Khodorkovsky.

-- Money, transferred from such companies as «Fargoil», «Energotrade», per agreements for the purchase-sale of oil, which passed through the treasury, was put on the accounts of «Tomskneft», «Yuganskneftegas», «Samaraneftegas», -- replies the witness Kudasov.
Lebedev first asked if they are acquainted. «I personally am not acquainted with Platon Leonidovich, a couple of times I saw him at corporate holidays», -- clarified the witness to the court. «What is known to you about my activity in the YUKOS oil company?» -- «Nothing is known to me». -- «I gave you assignments with respect to payments?» -- «Did not give».

There were, noted Kudasov, no «global problems» on the part of the organs of currency-and-export control. Nor were there delays in or non-receipt of foreign-exchange proceeds...
And so on, and so forth...

So where, exactly, is the evidence with respect to the indictment? Where are all these articles enumerated on the courtroom doors: «Items «a», «b» pt.3, art.160, pt 3 art. 174, pt.4 art. 160, pt. 3 art. 174,pt.4 art. 174-1 CC RF [Criminal Code of the Russian Federation--Trans.]?


... For a while, the trial moves completely to a stage of torpidity. The journalists stopped clicking on the keyboards of their notebooks. The bailiff at the cage is playing games on his telephone. Shokhin is obviously sleeping. Danilkin is yawning. The lawyers are bored. The witness is drinking a second glass of water. Khodorkovsky moved aside the thick stack of papers which he had been reading until then, and is sitting in the aquarium [in the current trial, the prisoners are not in a cage, but in a bulletproof glass box--Trans.], head bent down - he's resting. Lebedev is leafing through the volumes of the case and without any hurry posing questions.

With the volumes there's a problem in general. In order to pose a question, Lebedev first needs to speak about how the sheets of the case file had already been read out. To ask for the volume from the judge, the judge serves it to a lawyer, the lawyer transfers to the witness, that one reads and only then responds to the question that had been posed. Then the used volume floats slowly in the opposite direction - to the judge's table.

There are more than a hundred and thirty volumes, I will remind!

(From personal observations: the more volumes, the less the likelihood of an acquittal. Otherwise you'd have to admit the impenetrable moronity of those who carved out these 130 volumes).

For an instant the trial was jolted awake from the universal stupor and boredom.

Judge: - Lebedev, you have the 64th volume?

Lebedev: - I don't have it!

Judge: - So where is it?

Lebedev: - I returned it to you.

Judge: - When? Where can it be? Searches on the table). Ah! Found it! (with a sense of empowerment).

I'm thinking: if in 15 minutes he's forgotten about where he'd stashed a volume and whether the volume ever existed in the first place, then how does he remember everything that they've already examined over a year?

After this the trial once again falls into a semi-sleeping state.
After lunch an enliveliage is sensed. Skirmishes arise between the procurator Lakhtin and Platon Lebedev. The procurator is attempting, posing a question to the witness, to implant in him his incriminatory interpretation of the proffered document. Lebedev, having studied these tricks well, objects against this. A lawyer and the judge join the fray. There are objections and objections to objections. Then they remember about the witness, who, shifting from foot to foot (he - the only one who is standing the entire trial) asks to be reminded what the question was about, because he's already managed to completely forget it.

Observers of the court trial, which has lasted a year already, have long ago become convinced that Khodorkovsky and Lebedev are asserting their rightness solidly. Which you can't say about the representatives of the state prosecution.

This is not the first time I have been present at a court trial in the «YUKOS case» and I have long ago observed: the level of preparedness of the procurators for the court sessions is very low. It goes without saying that nobody has the right to demand of Shokhin or Lakhtin the presence of a candidate's [Ph.D.--Trans.] degree in the realm of economics. From them - by law - is required merely the scrupulous observance of criminal-procedure legislation and the provision of all the evidence according to the charge. Both with the former and with the latter the procurators have obvious problems. These gaps both in the former and in the latter, as it appeared to me, judge Viktor Danilkin often forgives the procurators.

And how not to forgive, if he himself, as it appeared to me, does not completely understand the essence of many of the economic intricacies of this case. Or does not want to understand? BUT such a thing is possible only in the event that the text of the verdict is known in advance.

...The trial continues. Four procurators, seven lawyers, two defendants, a judge and a secretary, over a dozen convoyers-bailiffs... A whole bunch of people engaged daily and not for the first year already in something little-comprehensible.

Observers from Mars in an hour would say: forget about you all, it's not interesting, because it's unlawful. It's better to look at the stars and listen to the rustle of eternity on the wings of the cosmos.

Instead of this we are listening to the rustle of the volumes of the criminal case and through it - the phrase of judge Danilkin:

- I'm covering for myself, so there wouldn't be a situation...

* * *
In an interview Mikhail Khodorkovsky says: "I understand perfectly well that there are several bureaucrats who initiated the second trial and who want me behind bars forever. But whatever happens, I am going to defend my position and my innocence. Firstly, I don't think the outcome of the case is preordained. And secondly, I don't want to allow anyone the possibility to think that I am guilty of something. So I'm going to prove that I am in the right so comprehensively that nobody will have any room left for doubt."

...I personally have not had any doubts in his rightness for a long time already. If someone of the readers does have some - go down to the court session. There is much you will understand.


Grigory Pasko is a Russian journalist and publisher of an environmental magazine. In November 1997 Pasko was arrested by FSB agents in Vladivostok and accused of espionage for publications on the environmental problems in the Japanese sea but found not guilty due to lack of evidence. He was found guilty of “abuse of his official position,” but released immediately under a general amnesty. He was recognized as a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International. This article originally (here)  appeared at the Robert Amsterdam: Perspectives on Global Politics and Business website.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • MySpace
  • LinkedIn
  • Live
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • Sphinn
  • Propeller
  • Slashdot
  • Netvibes

0 comments:

Post a Comment




Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search