Malaysian Muslim Convert Fails To Get Custody Of Toddler
The High Court in Ipoh ordered Mohd. Ridzuan Abdullah to immediately surrender his third and youngest child to the custody of Indira Gandhi. The couple have been separated for a year, ever since the former Hindu man converted to Islam.
On March 11, 2010, the High Court gave Indira custody of the 23-month-old child, effectively overturning an earlier order by the Syariah Court.
Indira’s lead lawyer M. Kulasegaran told UCA News that enforcing the court order is “very slow and painful.” The lawyer, who is also a Member of Parliament, said he will raise this matter in Parliament on April 1 evening.
According to the news portal Malaysian Insider, Gandhi recalled she married Pathmanathan, Mohd. Ridzuan’s original name, according to Hindu rites 14 years ago, but the marriage turned sour afterward. However, Gandhi stuck by him and bore three children now aged 13, 12 and two.
In March last year, Pathmanathan suggested that the family embrace Islam for economic advantage. “I refused and so did my two older children,” Gandhi said. Patmanathan left home soon after, taking with him their then 11-month-old daughter.
Gandhi lodged a police report and it was only then that she was told that Pathmanathan had embraced Islam in early March 2009 and that he had converted their three children a month later on April 12 without her consent or knowledge.
The Syariah Court had also granted Pathmanathan custody of the children.
Fight taken to civil courts
Gandhi took her fight to the civil courts to nullify her children’s conversion and to get custody. On March 11 this year, the Perak state High Court judge gave her custody of the youngest child, overturning the Syariah Court order.
The judge also overruled objections from the lawyers for the state Religious Department who argued that the matter should have been handled by the Syariah Court.
Lawyer Kulasegaran told media after the hearing that “the judge said Gandhi, being a non-Muslim, had no rights in the Syariah Court.” Mohd. Ridzuan then applied for a stay of execution of the high court order.
That the civil court decided to hear the case was seen as a “breakthrough” as the Federal Constitution states that matters pertaining to Shari’a law cannot be heard in the civil court.
Kulasegaran told the press he plans to file contempt proceedings should the child not be handed over to Gandhi.
Indira’s case, which is only the latest of several similar cases, prompted the Malaysian cabinet to make a landmark decision in April last year to end the problem faced by non-Muslims when one spouse converts to Islam and also converts the children to Islam without the knowledge or approval of the other spouse.
The cabinet decided that the children from such a marriage will continue with the common religion of the parents at the time of marriage. Moreover, in the event one spouse converts to Islam, the civil courts will be the place to dissolve the marriage.
The policy has not been translated into law as it has yet to be brought to Parliament, prompting many to declare that it was merely a political decision. Many believe any attempts to do so will face fierce resistance from Islamic groups.
Meanwhile in a separate court, the decision on Gandhi’s application for leave for a judicial review to quash the conversion of her three children to Islam has been set for April 3.


























0 comments:
Post a Comment