Cyprus Misses The Peace Boat - Again
Elections in the Turkish controlled north of Cyprus have resulted in defeat for Mehmet Ali Talat, the moderate Turkish Cypriot leader who for the last five years had tried to steer the territory out of its isolation, and pave the way for its return within the framework of a unified Cypriot state.
In 2004 on the eve of Cyprus accession to the European Union a referendum in the north surprisingly approved a UN sponsored deal that would have seen the island reunified prior to the accession. The deal was however rejected by the mainly Greek populated south. Since the government in the south is the one that is legally recognised by the international community it now represents the whole of the island in the European corridors of power.
The Greek Cypriot rejection of a peace deal in 2004, and subsequent intransigence ever since, has scuppered the possibility of a political solution to the Cyprus problem, which since 1974 has seen the island, and its Capital Nicosia, partitioned into ethnically cleansed zones. The new President of north Cyprus, Dervis Eroglu, is a hard line nationalist who insists that the future of north Cyprus should be as an independent state. He has promised to continue negotiating with the south, but observers feel that this process will now drag out, and could easily become meaningless.
This development is a bad news for all. Greek Cypriot hopes for reunification are now further away than they have been for a decade. It is true that under President Christofias, over the last year, the Greek Cypriot side had shown more flexibility than it had shown in recent years in its negotiations with the north, but some say that the Greek Cypriots still did not do enough and missed the best opportunity they had of reunifying their country.
For the European Union this development means that its hopes that EU membership could be a stimulus for peace on the island has failed and the Union will now have to deal with the fall out in its relations with Turkey, as well as with the continued intransigence of the Greek Cypriot government.
Many criticise the EU for allowing a divided Island to join in 2004 in the first place. The Turkish Cypriot community feels that it has been penalised by the EU despite the fact that it was the one that had accepted the peace deal, whilst the south, after rejecting the peace deal than went on to reap the benefits of EU membership.
Now a Greek Cypriot government, with a veto right in the EU councils is able to hold the whole Union to ransom, not only on Cypriot issues, but also on the whole relationship between the Union and Turkey.
For Turkey too, the result is uncomfortable for the current government of Prime Minister Erdogan who had been hoping for a solution for the Cyprus problem, clearing one of the major obstacles on its tortuous journey to EU membership. Mr Eroglu has made the strengthening g of relations with “motherland” Turkey as a cornerstone of his policy. Indeed given its current isolation north Cyprus is dependent on Turkey in political, military and economic spheres.
Turkey is likely to push Eroglu to remain engaged in the peace negotiations and many hope that once faced with the responsibilities of office Eroglu may look again at the options in front of him. However even the most optimistic observer cannot but accept that the peace process is at best delayed, at worst derailed. Many consider that a solution to the Cyprus problem is still possible if the European Union adopts a different approach to its relationship with the island. This approach will need to be much more even handed with the two communities.
The EU must also not allow its negotiations with Turkey on accession to be held hostage to the Cyprus problem. Indeed Turkey’s EU membership may be the ultimate stimulus that is going to be necessary to clinch a Cypriot peace deal. It cannot be business as usual in Brussels. Many feel that Cyprus has once again missed the peace boat, but that from every crisis, an opportunity arises, and the new crisis in the Cyprus peace process should serve to re-assess tactics and revive efforts to close a sad chapter in Europe’s history.
LINKS is a British non governmental organisation working for the peaceful resolution of conflicts and in support of democracy and sustainable development in societies in transition, through dialogue and innovative initiatives.


























April 28, 2010 at 3:41 PM
"Some say that the Greek Cypriots still did not do enough". I'd like to know who these 'some' are. Presumably Turks. As for Links, the idea it is an independent observer (particularly after such a blatent anti-Greek Cypriot article as this) is laughable.