The Provocations Of Prosecutors - More On Khodorkovsky Trial

Thursday, April 15, 2010

By Grigory Pasko

During my last visit to the Khodorkovsky trial courtroom, I had the opportunity to stop the procurators Kovalikhina and Shokhin outside on the staircase with a question: "Do the procurators give interviews?" Shokhin stopped short in surprise. Kovalikhina, continuing to move, replied: "They do. After the verdict."

Well, at least that. Before the verdict, they, apparently, have nothing to say. So much nothing that, besides the open loutishness of the procurator Lakhtin, nobody, it would seem, is expecting anything from them in the trial any more.

Если Вы хотите прочитать оригинал данной статьи на русском языке, нажмите сюда.

On 7 April, the court day began, as usual. True, there were more visitors than usual, but fewer than on the 6th - the first day of the reading out of testimony by Mikhail Khodorkovsky.

Bearing witness on numerous occasions about how a cohesive public goes to the trial in the capacity of observers was the behavior of one of the bailiffs: he was knitting his brows every possible way, admonishing, threatening... He didn't like it that the public was reacting in a lively way to the loutishness of the procurator Lakhtin.

On the whole, though, the customary situation ruled at the session: Khodorkovsky was speaking: the judge Danilkin was obviously not listening to him and was busy with something of his own; the procurators Shokhin, Lakhtin, Kovalikhina and Ibragimova were demonstratively not listening to Khodorkovsky, occasionally exchanging a laugh with one another.

In the meantime, Khodorkovsky was speaking about how the investigation had acted in bad faith. In the capacity of evidence he cited as an example the fact that the investigative group had refused to attach to the case file a series of documents, including inventory-taking reports and inventory lists.

A ruckus broke out when Mikhail Borisovich started to cite the decree on the refusal to satisfy Lebedev's complaint against the actions of the investigator Alyshev, which was issued by the deputy head of the department for the investigation of particularly important cases -- the head of the first section of the Investigative Administration under the procuracy of the RF, S. Kovrayev.

All of a sudden, Lakhtin started, jumped up and began to shout: «Khodorkovsky is taking a volume of the case and is showing us this document. Is it or is it not contained there?...Is this document being reproduced through the equipment in this form? I consider that it is not contained there!»

The lawyer Schmidt reacted with the words: «Being demonstrated is a true excerpt from the case file materials... -- find it on your computer, stand up, make a statement that you are asking the court to check! And don't interrupt, please! You do not have any right to interfere with the defendant giving free testimony! Obey the law!».

«The defendant is defending himself in all ways not prohibited by law!» -- reported the judge to Lakhtin. «Well he's disoriented! - commented Lebedev on the prosecutor's perplexity and added: -- The given document during the time of the preliminary hearing I was producing to you personally and was reading this idiotic phrase of general Kovrayev's into the record!»

«I ask to admonish Lebedev! And as for Kovrayev, I'll personally ring him by telephone and report that they have offended him in this trial! With all the circumstances deriving therefrom!» -- the procurator Lakhtin began to threaten the defendants. The courtroom was laughing.

«Just don't shoot yourself, Lakhtin!» -- retorted Platon Lebedev from the aquarium.

Judge Danilkin threatened Lebedev with removal from the courtroom and announced a five-minute recess.

Goodness! How this all looked like what I saw and experienced in «my» trials! In exactly the same way the procurators ignored the code of criminal procedure; in exactly the same way the judge pretended that he doesn't notice this; in exactly the same way I and my lawyers had to appeal to both the judge and the procurators to obey the law. Sometimes the procurators would switch to yelling. I recall how one of them, shrieking, either filed a motion or simply voiced his thoughts. «I ask, - said he, - to enter Pasko's smiles into the record!»

And how many times they promised to remove me from the cage!

It was all like being swept right back to the past.

The tragedy is only in that this - is reality. This time - for Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Platon Lebedev and their lawyers. A tragedy - because the outcome of the trial is evident. Otherwise the judge would behave himself differently: he'd be admonishing the procurators, giving the defendant time to say what he has to say, would ask for details, and lastly would be looking at the screen, where the evidence of the innocence of the defendants was being demonstrated... Alas, alas...

And still, Mikhail Khodorkovsky is right a thousand times over that he's setting forth his arguments in detail, precisely and clearly, smashing the «bad-faith» charge. He is also right in that time and again he's got to teach an Economics 101 course for the procurators and the judge, that he doesn't lose his composure and begin yelling himself (although I'm amazed how he manages to: I couldn't; I, like Platon, would burst out and advise Lakhtin to go shoot himself)... At the end of the day, he's doing this not just for the court. He's doing this for us too, those who wish him to get out and be free as quickly as possible; and for those who for whatever reason are still captive to the false representations about the decency of the charge.

Grigory Pasko is a Russian journalist and publisher of an environmental magazine. In November 1997 Pasko was arrested by FSB agents in Vladivostok and accused of espionage for publications on the environmental problems in the Japanese sea but found not guilty due to lack of evidence. He was found guilty of “abuse of his official position,” but released immediately under a general amnesty. He was recognized as a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International. This article originally (here)  appeared at the Robert Amsterdam: Perspectives on Global Politics and Business website.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • MySpace
  • LinkedIn
  • Live
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • Sphinn
  • Propeller
  • Slashdot
  • Netvibes

0 comments:

Post a Comment




Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search