Elections To Show What Is Right And Wrong With Geogia's Democracy
The people of Georgia will go to the polls again on Sunday, 30 May. They will not be choosing their President, or their parliament. These elections are simply to elect local authorities. They are however important because they will give an indication of what is right and what is wrong with Georgian democracy at a time when the democratic credentials of the Georgian government are increasingly challenged.
Even before a single vote has been cast it is already possible to say that a lot is right, but a lot remains wrong.
Georgia has vibrant politics, sometimes much too vibrant for the feint hearted. There is an abundance of political parties and nobody who ever wanted to do politics in Georgia has ever been stopped. The election legislation has been the subject of much scrutiny, both internally and by international experts. Although not perfect the legislative framework is more than adequate and if administered properly can serve the Georgian people well. The administrative capacity of the central Election Commission and the regional and local commissions is much improved.
The decision of the government of President Saakashvili to turn the post of Mayor of Tbilisi into an elected post for the first time is to be commended. This is an important post that deserves to be filled through popular vote. Nearly a third of the Georgian population lives in Tbilisi and the vote of the capital determines national politics. The campaign for the local elections has been largely calm and focused on economic issues. This is a sign of an increased maturity amongst the Georgian body politic. Both government and opposition have had some access to the media, but more on this later.
A lot remains wrong however with Georgian democracy, and whilst the government can be blamed for most of the shortcomings, the opposition also shares some responsibility.
The media remains a major problem. Much was wrong with Georgia before President Saakashvili took power in November 2003. One thing was however right. Georgia had a very diverse and exciting free press that was ready to hold government to account. Not anymore. Most Georgian media is now government controlled. The free press that remains is embattled. Many journalists are either disillusioned or afraid.
Whilst opposition politicians are given air time to air their opinions, including on the national public broadcasting channel, their views are generally neutralised by editorial programming that is blatantly biased.
The situation gets worse the further one goes from Tbilisi.
The elections to be held on Sunday have also been marred by the abuse of administrative resources, especially in the context of the Tbilisi Mayorship and Council elections. Patronage in politics is not a unique Georgian characteristic. However the scale on which it has been conducted is worrisome.
The biggest question-marks remain with the actual conduct of the election process. The government has been at pains to emphasise that it wants a fair election. There will be many local and international observers on hand on Sunday to see if this is going to be the case.
Already however one major problem that has traditionally existed in the Georgian election process remains – an inaccurate voters list. For example there are reliable reports of names of people long deceased, mysteriously reappearing on the electoral roll – some after having been removed from previous list. There were some attempts to scrutinise the lists in the run up to the elections and the Central Electoral Commission even gave some resources to the political parties to encourage them to do this, but major problems remain.
The opposition parties are here at fault since they have not taken the task to properly scrutinise the voters list seriously enough. No election can be fair if the voters list is inaccurate and the prime responsibility for ensuring an accurate voters list remains with the election authorities
The opposition is also at fault for not being able to agree either on a common strategy or a common list of candidates. In some cases opposition parties have decided to boycott the elections outright. Election boycotts never work. It is the duty of opposition parties to use every opportunity that the democratic process gives them, even if this process is flawed. Those opposition parties that are contesting the elections have failed to unite their efforts. Splintered, the Georgian opposition is easily seen off by what remains an impressively well organised and well resourced ruling party.
On the eve of the Georgia Municipal elections it is therefore already possible to draw some positive and some negative conclusions. Much more may be deduced from what actually happens on polling day, and at the ever problematic counting process.
Georgians will wake up on Monday with the same President and Parliament, but with a new understanding of the state of their democracy. If the Georgian government cannot get these Municipal elections right, it is very unlikely that it will ever get any election right.
Dennis Sammut is the Executive Director of LINKS and long time commentator on the Caucasus Region. This article was published by LINKS.


























May 28, 2010 at 9:33 PM
Cannot agree with the following statement: "Whilst opposition politicians are given air time to air their opinions, including on the national public broadcasting channel, their views are generally neutralised by editorial programming that is blatantly biased."
I watched those editorials, and I can hardly call them biased, let alone "blatantly biased". Pinpointing the flaws of the opposition (as well as the government) cannot in all fairness be called a bias, but rather a journalistic duty of any objective reporter. In fact, current Georgian "opposition" has so many flaws (as the author points out himself) and produces such an impressive flow of completely irresponsible statements and blatant lies, that NOT pointing them out should be considered a bias.
Moreover, the author completely forgets to mention opposition TV channels where opposition reigns totally unchecked (talk about bias). These are freely accessible (and remain quite popular) to Tbilisi population as well as through internet - live and recorded.
So, while some problems certainly exist in Georgian media, I wouldn't call it a "major problem". In fact I see a good democratic dynamics under unique Georgian circumstances.
A major problem in Georgia, in my opinion, is the visible absence of sane and constructive opposition. What is currently called an "opposition" is a marginalized mix of former power-privileged, corrupt, and mostly incompetent officials who lost their access to the "feed trough" and blatant Russian agents, openly sponsored from Kremlin (almost a cliché but, sadly, still true). The emergence of a strong, transparent, and truly national opposition party is of vital importance to Georgian democracy.
May 30, 2010 at 12:00 PM
The article is surprisingly well written. Usually I see all kinds of rediculus articles from Europe about Georgian inside politics.
I only strongly disagree about media freedom. georgia has a LOT of free media just look.
Majority of paper media is pro-opposition. Up to 90%.
TV - "Maestro" (which has gone on the satellite), "KavkasiaTV"... are VERY VERY pro-opposition and anti governmental I hardly can call them balanced, they are usually very biased.
"Rustavi2, PGB, Imedi, Mze" - on the other hand are quite well balanced. the majority of time in talk shows is still devoted tio opposition but in general both sides get enougth of airt time. Up to 30-35% of all the news(that are aired every 1-3 hours) are devoted to the view of opposition.
In general while Georgian government is far from perfect I would blame the opposition much harder for it's failures. Because saying that "President is idiot!" is not good enougth, if you are ONLY saying this and he is actually DOING things that change country for better. Could they maybe... I'dunno suggest something at least? I would vote for opposition if they made any sense to me. but no, sorry Saakashvili is at least doing things and saying things about economy and other things I agree with. the opposition on the other hand has only one plan - "Get rid of Saakashvili" - NOT good enough for me! Sorry.