Elections To Show What Is Right And Wrong With Geogia's Democracy

By Dennis Sammut for LINKS

The people of Georgia will go to the polls again on Sunday, 30 May. They will not be choosing their President, or their parliament. These elections are simply to elect local authorities. They are however important because they will give an indication of what is right and what is wrong with Georgian democracy at a time when the democratic credentials of the Georgian government are increasingly challenged.

Even before a single vote has been cast it is already possible to say that a lot is right, but a lot remains wrong.
Georgia has vibrant politics, sometimes much too vibrant for the feint hearted. There is an abundance of political parties and nobody who ever wanted to do politics in Georgia has ever been stopped. The election legislation has been the subject of much scrutiny, both internally and by international experts. Although not perfect the legislative framework is more than adequate and if administered properly can serve the Georgian people well. The administrative capacity of the central Election Commission and the regional and local commissions is much improved.

The decision of the government of President Saakashvili to turn the post of Mayor of Tbilisi into an elected post for the first time is to be commended. This is an important post that deserves to be filled through popular vote. Nearly a third of the Georgian population lives in Tbilisi and the vote of the capital determines national politics. The campaign for the local elections has been largely calm and focused on economic issues. This is a sign of an increased maturity amongst the Georgian body politic. Both government and opposition have had some access to the media, but more on this later.

A lot remains wrong however with Georgian democracy, and whilst the government can be blamed for most of the shortcomings, the opposition also shares some responsibility.

The media remains a major problem. Much was wrong with Georgia before President Saakashvili took power in November 2003. One thing was however right. Georgia had a very diverse and exciting free press that was ready to hold government to account. Not anymore. Most Georgian media is now government controlled. The free press that remains is embattled. Many journalists are either disillusioned or afraid.

Whilst opposition politicians are given air time to air their opinions, including on the national public broadcasting channel, their views are generally neutralised by editorial programming that is blatantly biased.

The situation gets worse the further one goes from Tbilisi.

The elections to be held on Sunday have also been marred by the abuse of administrative resources, especially in the context of the Tbilisi Mayorship and Council elections. Patronage in politics is not a unique Georgian characteristic. However the scale on which it has been conducted is worrisome.

The biggest question-marks remain with the actual conduct of the election process. The government has been at pains to emphasise that it wants a fair election. There will be many local and international observers on hand on Sunday to see if this is going to be the case.

Already however one major problem that has traditionally existed in the Georgian election process remains – an inaccurate voters list. For example there are reliable reports of names of people long deceased, mysteriously reappearing on the electoral roll – some after having been removed from previous list. There were some attempts to scrutinise the lists in the run up to the elections and the Central Electoral Commission even gave some resources to the political parties to encourage them to do this, but major problems remain.

The opposition parties are here at fault since they have not taken the task to properly scrutinise the voters list seriously enough. No election can be fair if the voters list is inaccurate and the prime responsibility for ensuring an accurate voters list remains with the election authorities

The opposition is also at fault for not being able to agree either on a common strategy or a common list of candidates. In some cases opposition parties have decided to boycott the elections outright. Election boycotts never work. It is the duty of opposition parties to use every opportunity that the democratic process gives them, even if this process is flawed. Those opposition parties that are contesting the elections have failed to unite their efforts. Splintered, the Georgian opposition is easily seen off by what remains an impressively well organised and well resourced ruling party.

On the eve of the Georgia Municipal elections it is therefore already possible to draw some positive and some negative conclusions. Much more may be deduced from what actually happens on polling day, and at the ever problematic counting process.

Georgians will wake up on Monday with the same President and Parliament, but with a new understanding of the state of their democracy. If the Georgian government cannot get these Municipal elections right, it is very unlikely that it will ever get any election right.


Dennis Sammut is the Executive Director of LINKS and long time commentator on the Caucasus Region. This article was published by LINKS.
Friday, May 28, 2010 | 2 comments | Read more...

EU To Monitor Local Elections In Georgia

Members of the Committee of the Regions will join their counterparts in the Council of Europe's Congress of Local and Regional Authorities to monitor local elections in Georgia on 30 May 2010. Voters there will elect mayors and councillors in 64 municipalities, including five self-governing cities. For the first time, the mayor of Tbilisi will be directly elected.

On 27 and 28 May, the joint delegation will meet representatives of government and electoral bodies, including the speaker of the parliament, Davit Bakradze and the Minister for Regional Development and Infrastructure, Davit Tkeshelalvili. Meetings are also scheduled with media and local NGO representatives. Discussions will be held with members of the OSCE/ODIHR delegation.

Four CoR members are among the delegation of locally-elected representatives – Teet Kallasvee, member of Haapsalu Town Council (EE/EPP), Sharon Taylor, member of Stevenage Borough Council (UK/PES), Jasmina Vidmar, member of Maribor City Council (SI/ALDE) and Uno Silberg, member of Kose Municipality Council (EE/EA) – joining ten members of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe. Congress vice-president Günther Krug (DE, SOC) will head the delegation.

As part of its cooperation with the Congress, the CoR regularly participates in election monitoring at local and regional levels. Past joint missions have included elections in Serbia (2008) and in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (2009), the aim being to bolster the integrity of the democratic process by bringing to light any irregularities and issuing recommendations to enable improvements. This work is aimed at fostering confidence in local and regional elected representatives and increases voter turnout.

This mission further cements the cooperation agreement signed by the CoR and the Council of Europe's Congress of Local and Regional Authorities. Renewed in 2009, the agreement enables the two bodies to deepen European cooperation on local and regional democracy, devolution and self-governance in Europe.

Please click the following link for more information on the elections in Georgia.

Note to editors
A pre-election mission was carried out by the Congress at the beginning of May in Tbilisi and Rustavi to assess the situation in the country prior to the elections. Congress members met representatives of electoral commissions, government and parliament, as well as candidates from the ruling party and the opposition standing for the post of mayor of Tbilisi.

The delegation will present its findings at a press conference in Tbilisi scheduled for 11 a.m. on Monday 31 May (Hotel Ambasadori, 13 Shavteli St., Tbilisi).

The post-mission report will be the subject of a consultation process between the Congress and the CoR, following which the presidents of the two bodies will work together on the follow-up and implementation of its recommendations.

The mission's findings will feed into the own-initiative opinion on "Localand regional government in Georgia and the development of cooperation between Georgia and the EU" being drafted for the CoR by Jacek Protas, marshall of the Warmińsko-Mazurskie region (PL/EPP). The draft opinion is due to be discussed at the meeting of the CIVEX commission on 2 July, and adopted at the CoR's autumn plenary session.
Friday, May 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

U.S. Security Doctrine: U.S. To Support Sovereignty Of Russia's Neighbors

(Civil.Ge) -- While seeking engagement with Moscow, the U.S. will continue supporting territorial integrity of Russia's neighbors, the national security strategy unveiled by the Obama administration on May 27 says.

On Russia the document says that the U.S. has an interest in "a strong, peaceful, and prosperous Russia that respects international norms." Nonproliferation and "confronting violent extremism, especially in Afghanistan" are named among areas in which the U.S. will seek "greater partnership" with Russia.

"While actively seeking Russia’s cooperation to act as a responsible partner in Europe and Asia, we will support the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Russia’s neighbors," the document reads.

While addressing the European allies, the strategy says that the U.S. is committed to cooperate with EU "in promoting democracy and prosperity in Eastern European countries."

"We will remain dedicated to advancing stability and democracy in the Balkans and to resolving conflicts in the Caucasus and in Cyprus," the document reads.
Friday, May 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Moscow Wants To Replace Saakashvili And Lukashenka

By Paul Goble

That Moscow would like to see Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili replaced isn’t news to anyone but that it would like to have someone else in the place of his Belarusian counterpart Alyaksandr Lukashenka may come as a surprise, although Russian analysts say it is far from clear who that might be or how Moscow could arrange it.

Last week, “Newsweek” reported that having claimed “two political scalps” in the last few months with the replacement of Ukrainian President Viktor Yushchenko and Kyrgyz President Kurmanbek Bakiyev with more malleable leaders, Moscow was now looking to replace others in the former Soviet space with which it is unhappy.

Not surprisingly, the weekly suggested that Saakashvili was “target number one,” but more interestingly, it indicated that Lukashenka ranked just behind him in the Kremlin’s wish list. Now this week, in “Novaya politika,” Lidiya Adrusenko considers what may happen in Georgia and Belarus and concludes that Moscow faces enormous obstacles in both.

Some of the Moscow officials and analysts with whom “Newsweek” spoke suggested that a move against Saakashvili might begin as early as May 30th when elections are held for the mayor of Tbilisi and for the leaders of other local government bodies across Georgia (www.novopol.ru/-vremya-novyih-liderov-esche-ne-prishlo-text85198.html).

The possibility of using elections in Georgia as the occasion for a kind of “reverse orange-style revolution” was first put forward, Adrusenko points out, not by Duma deputy Sergey Markov as “Newsweek” reported but rather by Zurab Nogaideli, the former Georgian premier who “more often than his other colleagues visits Moscow.”

Nogaideli suggested that “if Saakashvili tries to falsify the vote, then an uprising will begin in Tbilisi similar to ‘the Bishkek revolution.’” But later, the Moscow commentator notes, Nogaideli reversed himself, saying that there would not be a Kyrgyz variant in Georgia, and that “scenarios” of this type were being dreamed up by Saakashvili but not in Moscow.

“Serious analysts,” Andrusenko continues, conclude that “the upcoming elections may turn out to be a complete defeat of the opposition figures, because they cannot unite and are competing among themselves.” Moreover, polls show that 51 percent of Georgians “positively assess” Saakashvili, while “12 percent support the opposition.”

Saakashvili’s ruling party should win without difficulty, these analysts say, “not because the population of Georgia is satisfied with him but because it is disappointed in other political forces” and is not prepared, as the failed counter-demonstration of May 6 showed, ready to follow its lead.

Thus, Andrusenko sums up for Georgia, “Saakashvili’s time has still not come to an end, and Moscow must carry out a lengthy search for an alternative leader on whom it might rely.” But Russia does have one advantage now: It won’t be acting alone because both the EU and the US are increasingly cool toward someone they had earlier enthusiastically backed.

The situation for Moscow in Belarus is more complicated for three reasons: First, although Russian leaders are “terribly tired” of Lukashenka, he is “formally” Russia’s ally, so moving against him is hard. Second, Lukashenka exercises much greater control in his country that Saakashvili does in his.

And third, the opposition in Belarus is far weaker than is its counterpart in Georgia. Those factors combine to mean that Moscow has had far fewer contacts with the Belarusian opposition than it has had with the Georgian one and that the Russian leadership thus has fewer choices about how to proceed to have any chance of success.

Later this year or the beginning of next, Belarus is scheduled to have presidential elections, an event that Moscow might seek to make use of. Lukashenka has indicated that he is ready to serve a fourth term, and all indications are that despite his international isolation he almost certainly could guarantee his “re-election.”

Despite that, Andrusenko continues, Russian officials are beginning to say “and quite openly at that” that they would like to be able “to deal in Belarus with another leader.” For them, the analyst says, the question isn’t so much about whether he would be “pro-Russian” or “pro-European” but rather more pragmatic and predictable.

Alyaksandr Milinkevich, the leader of the pro-Western united Belarusian opposition, is unlikely to get Moscow’s backing, but other leaders who have been discussed include Andrey Sannikov, the former foreign minister, who Andrusenko suggests views the relations Ukraine is now establishing with Moscow as “an example” for Belarus.

But some commentators in Moscow suggest that mentions of Sannikov are “only for cover,” while Moscow finds someone else. And they suggest that the Russiana powers that be might push current head of the Belarusian cabinet Sergey Sidorsky, even though he has expressed no interest in the race.

Consequently and despite Moscow’s desires, Andrusenko concludes, “the epoch of Lukashenka” in Belarus is not likely to come to an end as a result of the elections because the current Belarusian leader has created a political system in which “no one except for himself has a chance to become president” – at least by electoral means.


Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .   
Thursday, May 27, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Georgia Candidate Taken To Court For Homophobic Remarks On Facebook

(Civil.Ge) -- A Georgia court refused on May 25 an appeal by election watchdog group to suspend a majoritarian candidate for Tbilisi City Council membership from opposition Freedom Party to stand in the May 30 local elections.

The case, what appeared to be the first of this type, involved homophobic remarks made by the candidate on his Facebook page.

Tbilisi-based legal advocacy group, Georgian Young Lawyers Association (GYLA), which is monitoring elections, filed against Lado Sadgobelashvili, running in Tbilisi’s Mtatsminda single-mandate constituency, who posted last week on his Facebook wall messages like “Georgia without sexual minorities” and “days of homosexuals in Georgia is counted”.

GYLA claimed that Sadgobelashvili violated paragraph 2 of article 75 of the election code, which reads: “The election program must not contain propaganda of war and violence, of overthrowing the existing state and social system or replacing it through violence, of violating the territorial integrity of Georgia, of calling to foster hatred and enmity, religious and ethnic confrontation.”

GYLA deemed that the candidate’s Facebook messages contained propaganda of violence and hatred, which should have been resulted in suspension of the candidate. The Tbilisi City Court rejected GYLA’s arguments.

“It does not matter what the court ruling will be,” candidate Lado Sadgobelashvili, 24, told journalists before the court hearing on May 25. “The most important for me is protection of Orthodox Christian values.”
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Egyptian FM To Visit Georgia

(Civil.Ge) -- Egypt's Foreign Minister, Ahmed Aboul Gheit, will visit Georgia on May 25 after traveling to Azerbaijan, according to the Georgian and Egyptian foreign ministries.

The visit, which will be Egyptian Foreign Minister's first ever trip to Georgia, aims at fostering bilateral relations and at holding "consultations over all the regional and international political issues of mutual interest," the Egyptian Foreign Ministry said.

In Tbilisi Foreign Minister, Ahmed Aboul Gheit plans to meet with President Saakashvili, Parliamentary Chairman Davit Bakradze and Georgian Foreign Minister Grigol Vashadze.

According to the Georgian Foreign Ministry signing of an agreement on cooperation in the field of economy and science.

Georgian PM Nika Gilauri paid a two day visit to Egypt in January, 2010.

According to the Georgian state statistics office, the largest amount of foreign direct investment after United Arab Emirates came in Georgia from Egypt - USD 167.5 million - in 2009.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Georgia's Saakashvili Accused Of Plotting To Retain Power

By Natia Kuprashvili

(IWPR) -- A commission set up last year to appease opposition protesters has backed changes to the constitution stripping power from the presidency and awarding it to parliament - though opposition leaders see a plot by the president to hang on to power.

President Mikhail Saakashvili created the commission, which includes some opposition figures, to attempt to defuse opponents’ anger over his leadership record. The proposed amendments would seem to satisfy some of their demands, however serious reservations are now being expressed.

Saakashvili is legally obliged to relinquish the presidency in 2013, but some of his critics fear the changes could see him follow the example of Russian ex-president Vladimir Putin, who retained power when obliged to step down by becoming prime minister.

“Mikhail Saakashvili will remain before us in the role of prime minister or chairman of parliament. In one form or another, he will try to remain at the roots of power,” Jondi Bagaturia, a member of parliament from the opposition Kartuli Dasi party, said.

The Constitutional Commission considered two other potential constitutional amendments – one creating a vice-president, and the other making the country into a federation with wider powers for the president – but rejected them.

Instead, it favoured a plan to increase the powers of the parliament and prime minister at the expense of the president.

Georgia’s constitution, which was adopted on August 25, 1995, has already been changed several times, with all the amendments strengthening the president. The most significant reforms came after the Rose Revolution of 2003, which brought Saakashvili to power.

Davit Usufashvili, leader of the Republican Party, was an ally of the president during the bloodless revolution that overthrew Eduard Shevardnadze, but moved into opposition specifically because of Saakashvili’s changes to the constitution.

“Under Shevardnadze Georgia had a strong and irresponsible president. But then the head of the state did not have constitutional levers to influence parliament. But within a few months of the revolution, after serious changes of the constitution, parliament practically lost its functions and became an organ approving the instructions of the president,” he said.

“Then, with those changes, Saakashvili created a constitution for himself, and now he once again is preparing amendments for himself.”

Saakashvili’s allies angrily denied any suggestion that the president was modelling his departure on Putin, who is a fierce opponent of the Georgian government.

“Such statements are a slander on Georgian society, which would never allow the establishment of a Putin-type regime in this country,” Pavle Kublashvili, head of parliament’s legal affairs committee, said.

“As for the constitutional changes, for me the priority is a constitution that balances the powers of the executive and legislative branches and gives an effective mechanism for the creation of a strong and democratic state.”

The constitutional commission denied that it had been set up to serve any individual’s interests, saying it was following advice already offered by international bodies such as the Council of Europe’s Venice Commission.

“Why was constitutional reform put on the agenda? It was specifically done so as to create balance in the governance of the country. In fact, this is specifically what the Venice Commission demanded when it criticised the changes to the constitution aimed at increasing the president’s powers,” Sulkhan Meladze, spokesman for the commission, said.

He did not deny, however, that the proposed changes could provide a mechanism for Saakashvili to remain in power.

“But that must not be an obstacle to reform. We do not know what will happen tomorrow, but we definitely know what is necessary to improve democracy in the country. And specifically, it is necessary that the powers of parliament and the executive branch are put into balance.”

Bakar Berekashvili, who is a lecturer at the University of Tbilisi and chairman of the Institute for Democratic Reforms think tank, said the commission had studied all the options and concluded there was a definite need for changes to the constitution.

“A high level of democracy can be attained in both a parliamentary and a presidential model of government. But in a country like Georgia, I think a mixed model is more pragmatic and acceptable; a constitution that as little as possible allows someone to usurp power,” he said.

“Suspicions that the current president is using the amendments to the constitution so as to remain in power are legitimate. But I think that, if the amendments are adopted in the form that they were worked out by the constitutional commission, then it is unlikely that the country could expect one man to hold all the power.”

The president must now send the draft law to parliament, and before he does so, the Venice Commission is expected to examine it and make its observations.

“Maybe a few points will be changed, but the main principles -- greater independence for local authorities and courts, a reduction in power for the president and a strengthening of parliament and the government - will remain unchanged,” Meladze said.

“We cannot write into the constitution that Saakashvili must not come to power.”


Natia Kuprashvili is a freelance journalist in Tbilisi. This article originally appeared in CRS, produced by the Institute for War and Peace Reporting, www.iwpr.net
Monday, May 24, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Efforts Underway For Georgia-Iran Visa Free Travel

(Civil.Ge) -- Political declaration on willingness to lift visa requirements between Iran and Georgia has been made and now “technical, inter-agency” works are underway on the document, Nino Kalandadze, the Georgian deputy foreign minister, said on May 24.

She said that negotiating process on the matter would start after the document underwent internal procedures in various state agencies.

Ramin Mehmanparast, a spokesman for the Iranian Foreign Ministry, announced about the intention of the two countries to cancel visa requirements during his visit in Tbilisi last week.

“We welcome this decision, as it is very important from the economic point of view for our country,” Kalandadze told journalists on May 24. “It might be an interesting for individual citizens in terms of trade opportunities.”

“Of course it in no way means shift in Georgia’s foreign policy and it does not come in conflict with [Georgia’s] foreign policy priorities, involving integration with the European Union, visa facilitation with EU and membership into NATO. Based on our country’s national interests and based on our citizens’ economic interests, we want to open all the ways,” she said.

She also said that planned visa free agreement with Iran “will not have a negative effect on Georgia-U.S. relations.”

“We have friendly relations with all the states, which protect our country’s independence, interests, sovereignty and recognizes territorial integrity of our country. We want to have good neighborly relations with all the states in the region.”

“Iran is one of the strongest states in the region. At the same time, we have our strategic partners, like the United States and we are in constant dialogue with [our partners] and we do not deem that this decision [on visa free travel with Iran] will create problems,” Kalandadze added.

She also said that not only exact date was yet set for the possible visit of Iranian President, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, to Georgia. “Talks on how this visit may take place are premature yet,” Kalandadze said.
Monday, May 24, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Georgian Deputy FM: ‘New Stage In Georgia-Iran Relations’

(Civil.Ge) -- Bilateral relations between Iran and Georgia are entering “new stage” and Tbilisi hopes ties will further deepen, Nino Kalandadze, the Georgian deputy foreign minister, said on May 22.

She was speaking after signing of a memorandum of understanding between the Georgian and Iranian Foreign Ministries “on cooperation in the media sphere.” A spokesman for the Iranian Foreign Ministry, Ramin Mehmanparast, who visited Tbilisi with a group of Iranian journalists, signed the memorandum.

“Georgia is highly grateful to the Iranian authorities’ policy towards Georgia, which we deem as very reasonable and which involves unconditional support to Georgia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity,” the Georgian Deputy Foreign Minister said.

“A new stage has begun in our bilateral relations and we welcome it and we hope that we will deepen [relations] in all the fields. Signing of this first memorandum is a clear example of that,” Nino Kalandadze added.

Before signing the memorandum, the Iranian Foreign Ministry’s spokesman met with Georgian Foreign Minister Grigol Vashadze and discussed “broad range of bilateral issues”, including Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki’s planned official visit to Georgia, the Georgian foreign ministry said.

The Iranian Foreign Ministry’s spokesman said on May 21, that the visit would likely to take place in June, followed by a visit of Georgian PM Nika Gilauri to Tehran. Ramin Mehmanparast also said that details of possible visit of Iranian, President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, would also be discussed during those high level contacts.

“Relations between Iran and Georgia are excellent,” Mehmanparast said. “In political affairs we have very good relationship, but we think that we should increase our cooperation in economic affairs... especially in energy sector, agriculture.”

Speaking at a conference of Iranian and Georgian journalists in Tbilisi on May 21, Iran’s new ambassador to Georgia, Majid Saber, said there was a great potential in boosting bilateral cooperation in energy sector. He said that Iran planned to invest in construction of hydro power plant in Georgia and the Georgian side had requested Iran to share its experience in wind energy development.
Sunday, May 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Are More Border Changes Ahead In Eurasia?

By Paul Goble

Since 1991, the post-Soviet governments and the international community have been adamant against any change in the borders in Eurasia, and many expressed concerns that one of the results of Moscow’s decision to recognize Abkhazia and South Ossetia would be to spark demands for border changes or even the formation of new independent states.

There have been demands by various groups across the post-Soviet space since that time, but this week featured three such calls, an indication ever more people may think they now have a chance to achieve such outcomes and thus a challenge to the supporters of current arrangements even if nothing comes of their appeals.

The first of these calls came from the Mezhdurechensk miners, at least some of whom are calling for the creation of a West Siberian Republic as a way of forcing out the current powers that be at a minimum and possibly leading to the creation of their own independent state, something that would cut the Russian Federation in half (imc-siberia.org/ru/node/4676).

The second comes from a group calling itself “Vally Karjala” or “Free Karelia, which is using both print media and the Internet to push the idea that Karelia should be allowed to become a free and independent state, the successor to the Ukhta Republic of 1920 whose 90th anniversary the group is celebrating (mariuver.wordpress.com/2010/05/19/kareliju-svobodnoi/#more-17289).

And the third involves speculation that, in the words of the New Region agency, “as a result of secret agreements of Dmitry Medvedev and Viktor Yanukovich, the unrecognized Transdniestr Republic can be folded into Ukraine, and Moldova can thereby return to the zone of Russian influence (www.nr2.ru/283874.html).

(Indeed, according to Oleh Bilorus, Ukraine’s first ambassador to the US and currently chairman of the Ukrainian parliament’s foreign relations committee, this is the direction the Kyiv appears to be moving in even though the consequences of such an action would be enormous not only in Moldova, which might disappear, but throughout the Balkans.)

None of these calls or speculations is likely to have a result, just as none of the efforts of various ethnic communities in the North Caucasus to redraw the map there is. But what is striking is that more and more groups are prepared to identify such changes as part of their agenda, an indication the taboo that Vladimir Putin worked so hard to impose is decaying.

And that in turn means that more groups, both those like the Ingermanlanders in the Northwest and ethnic communities across the Russian Federation and predominantly ethnic Russian regions are now going to be discussing such possibilities, discussions that by their very nature will force Moscow and other capitals to take a position.

Again, the chances that any or even a few of these changes will occur are not great, but public discussions about them at the very least will highlight the problems underlying many of the borders imposed by Stalin and make in more likely that those who feel new borders or even new states are the only way to proceed will be less likely to back down.

That could have its most immediate consequences on some of the “frozen” conflicts, making their resolution more rather than less difficult and highlighting the way in which Moscow’s incautious approach to Georgia in 2008 is going to continue to have consequences far beyond the borders of the Caucasus.


Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com . 
Sunday, May 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Clarifying Fate Of Missing Georgians, Ossetians And Russians In 2008 Hostilities

Djordje Drndarski, the ICRC's deputy head of operations for Eastern Europe, explains how coordination mechanisms can help families find out what happened to their missing loved ones.

What exactly is the role of the ICRC in the search for missing persons?

The first and most important thing to point out is that the families of missing persons have the right to know what happened to their loved ones. So the ICRC reminds the parties to the conflict of the provisions in international humanitarian law setting out this right and of their obligation to search actively for persons reported missing. The families need to end the uncertainty, close the grieving process and go on with their lives. Allow me to take this occasion to commend the Georgian, South Ossetian and Russian parties on their commitment to participating in this important process.

The ICRC plays two main roles: it serves as a neutral intermediary between the parties and it provides support for the families of missing persons.

In its role as a neutral intermediary, the ICRC obtained the agreement of the parties to set up a mechanism within which it coordinates in a confidential manner the exchange of information between the parties and stands ready to provide any necessary technical support required for the recovery and identification of mortal remains.

In parallel, the ICRC provides support for the families, who face legal, financial, social and psychological problems. (See also Missing loved ones: helping families cope with the uncertainty).

I would like to emphasize that the mechanism is strictly humanitarian in purpose and does not involve any political aspects. The ICRC is committed to serving as a neutral intermediary on these issues on the basis of the applicable provisions of international humanitarian law.

How does the ICRC obtain information about people who went missing?

One of the ICRC's most important activities in conflict situations consists in restoring contact between family members who have been separated from one another. During and after the August 2008 conflict, the ICRC received tracing requests from families of missing persons which it took up with the authorities. In total, 1234 tracing requests were received, but luckily most cases were quickly resolved and family links restored.

The ICRC searches for people in towns and villages, visits places of detention, checks out allegations of arrest and makes every possible effort to find those who have gone missing. Participants in the coordination mechanism will convey any further information they obtain. The cases of 47 persons remain unresolved.

What kind of technical support can the ICRC give the parties?

One type of support consists in drawing up and constantly updating the list of missing persons. Another concerns forensic issues.

The type of forensic support provided by the ICRC depends on what is specifically required in a given context. In all cases, however, the ICRC becomes involved only with the consent of the parties and at their request. The ICRC helps build the capacity of local staff to carry out forensic activities through training programmes, seminars and workshops. It also provides support for ante-mortem data collection, exhumations and other activities, tools for use in laboratory analysis, and other kinds of technical support useful in identifying mortal remains in a manner consistent with international standards. (See also Missing persons: providing support to the grieving.) In addition, the ICRC can – if requested by the parties – serve as a neutral intermediary in transfers of mortal remains.

What was the aim of the two meetings linked to the 2008 hostilities and what will happen next?

The issue of missing persons is highly charged throughout the entire Caucasus region owing to the armed conflicts that have taken place there since the 1990s. After the most recent conflict, once most families had succeeded in restoring contact with their relatives, the ICRC quickly set up a special humanitarian mechanism to determine what happened to those who had gone missing, as it is important not to waste any time.

The first formal meeting of the mechanism was held in Switzerland on 23 February. Representatives from Tbilisi, Tskhinvali/Tskhinval and Moscow took part. A second meeting took place on 29 April, during which terms of reference were discussed and information on missing persons and gravesites was exchanged. A presentation on exhuming and identifying remains was made by an ICRC forensic adviser, and the participants considered the concrete action that needed to be taken.

The list of missing persons is currently being discussed, and another meeting should take place in June. On the basis of comments received from the participants, the ICRC will assess the level of additional technical support that each party requires to be able to carry out recovery and identification work in accordance with international standards.

Are there other places where the ICRC plays a similar role in coordination mechanisms and forensic activities?

The ICRC provides support for coordination mechanisms seeking to determine what happened to people missing in connection with the events in Kosovo from 1998 to 2000, the 1990-1991 Gulf War and other events. It serves in different capacities depending on the needs and requests of the authorities concerned. In Cyprus, the ICRC offered advice and support in establishing and training a forensic team, comprising both Greek and Turkish Cypriot forensic scientists, which is seeking to resolve cases of missing persons. Within the Caucasus region, the ICRC has been actively involved in collecting data on people still missing in connection with the Nagorny-Karabakh conflict and in providing training for local forensics experts in the northern Caucasus. Our organization also carries out forensic activities in the Middle East and throughout Latin America.


Source: International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)
Saturday, May 22, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Russian Intelligence Services’ Return to Crimea Seen Having Far-Reaching Consequences

By Paul Goble

Aleksandr Bortnikov, the head of Russia’s FSB, and Valery Khoroshkovsky, head of Ukraine’s SBU, have signed a five-year agreement that will allow Moscow again to put intelligence agents in Crimea, from which 19 such Russian officers were expelled at the end of last year for attempting to recruit Ukrainians as spies.
While the new accord reportedly allows Ukraine the right to approve or disapprove Russian officers to be sent there, something the 2000 accord Kyiv denounced in December 2009 did not, many Ukrainian analysts have expressed doubts that this provision will protect Kyiv’s interests and fears that the accord will have serious and far-reaching consequences for Ukraine.

Nadezhda Maynaya of “Glavred” interviewed two Ukrainian analysts to get their reactions to this latest development in the ongoing warming of Russian-Ukrainian relations. Their responses should set off alarm bells not only in Ukraine but also in regional and Western capitals (glavred.info/archive/2010/05/19/170153-4.html).

The behavior of Russian agents last year, Rostislav Pavlenko, the director of the School of Political Analysis of the Kyiv-Mohylev Academy, said, raises doubts as to whether any document Moscow officials sign or any statements they make can be trusted. After all, what the Russians did last year was prohibited by bilateral agreements.

“Today,” the Ukrainian analyst continued, “we observe in fact an invitation to the Russian special services to return to the territory of Ukraine,” a development that he said has at least three serious consequences. First, the presence of Russian special service officers in Ukraine has been legalized,” opening the way to more abuse.

Second, the accords create problems by setting up “a collision of legislation,” with Russian law calling for one thing and Ukrainian another. And third, Pavlenko said, “there can arise definite geopolitical and geo-strategic problems,” such as occurred in August 2008 when Ukraine took Georgia’s side following Moscow’s invasion of the Caucasus country.

Given that Ukraine has agreed to extend the presence of the Black Sea Fleet in Sevastopol for another 25 years, there is certainly time for the appearance of a situation “when the Black Sea Fleet and the special services based within it can be used in actions that are counter to the interests of Ukraine.”

But the impact of this FSB-SBU accord is likely to be even larger, Ukrainian political scientist Yevgeny Zherebetsky argued. That is because the commanders of the Black Sea Fleet, immediately after the extension of the basing accord, began a “massive” downsizing, retiring some 7500 staffers, “of whom 6500 are civilians and citizens of Ukraine.”

In addition, the fleet plans to retire 550 officers, many of whom will like the civilians have relatively low pensions and thus be open as are the civilians for recruitment by the Russian special services for work against Ukraine as a way to supplement their relatively small benefit checks.

According to Zherebetsky, it is “very important for Russians to obtain control over Crimea” because it lacks warm water ports. But “if everything will develop so ‘well’ [for Moscow] as it is now, then the Russians will try to extend their influence to Odessa, Kherson, and Nikolayev,” in an arc extending from Transdniestria to Abkhazia.

For that purpose, he continued, “Russia needs a broad network of agents of the special services,” but its prospects for success if these agents are active are very good because “over the course of the period of independence, the Ukrainian leadership has done nothing so that Ukraine could obtain complete power over the territory of Crimea.”

Pavlenko agreed, and he added that “the official strengthening of the return of FSB agents to Ukraine are steps toward the development, legalization and creation of opportunities which are in no way connected only with the defense of the Black Sea Fleet” but rather are intended to create “a mechanism of influence on Ukraine.”

And this problem is going to arise very quickly, Zherebetsky added. One issue that seems certain to break into the open is the question of whether the Russian ships carry nuclear weapons. As a declared non-nuclear state, Ukraine cannot have military units on its territory that have such weapons, but the new accord makes it impossible for Kyiv to know whether they are there.

Moreover, even as this agreement was being signed, Russian officials were signaling that they want even more. One Russian leader suggested that the sailors in the Black Sea Fleet should have dual Russian-Ukrainian citizenship (news.liga.net/news/N1014381.html), and another said Moscow wants all of Sevastopol back (news.km.ru/rossiya_mozhet_potrebovat_sevast).



Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com .   
Saturday, May 22, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Parliament Lays Markers For Future EU Relations With The South Caucasus

By LINKS

The resolution on a future EU strategy towards the South Caucasus adopted yesterday by the European Parliament lays down a number of important markers that those in the region, and in the European Union and beyond working with the South Caucasus, should note and heed.

The resolution is a reflection of a realisation that has finally taken hold in Brussels that the South Caucasus is the next area that the European Union will have to engage with in a significant way over the coming decade and beyond. This engagement had felt for most of the past decade more as mission creep rather than a strategic choice. That is past. The strategy may not yet be fully mature, but the understanding that one is needed is now well and truly embedded. The reflexes of the European Commission have traditionally been to approach the region with caution. This could also be seen from the intervention of Commissioner Stefan Fule immediately prior to the vote, where he tried to argue that no new strategy was necessary because the EU Eastern Partnership and neighbourhood Policies already lay down strategies for engagement with the South Caucasus.

In a sense he is right. There is no need for another exercise that takes years in planning and creates a new bureaucratic layer at the end to implement its recommendations. What is required now is that what is already envisaged and decided in the Eastern Partnership and Neighbourhood Policy instruments be implemented strategically rather than as bureaucratic chore.

The Parliament’s resolution was diligently drafted by the rapporteur, Bulgarian MEP Evgeni Kirilov. It went through a rigorous process of debate in the Foreign Affairs Committee where a number of amendments were considered and adopted and where the text was tightened. The European Parliament is sometimes considered an ineffective talking shop. However this resolution has been able to capture the broad consensus of the European political leadership towards the South Caucasus, despite all the diversity, differences and nuanced approaches that exist in the 27 member states. Even for this alone it needs to be applauded.

The resolution contains a number of innovative ideas for strengthening peace and democracy in the region and about the facilitation of interaction between the EU and the three South Caucasus Republics

Some ideas included in the resolution may take time to implement. The proposal to establish a Conference for Security and Co-operation for the South Caucasus where the countries of the region, their neighbours and other interested party can start addressing some of the security concerns that have overshadowed regional relations over the last decade, is one that as yet has to find favour in many of the chancelleries of Europe. Its endorsement by the European Parliament however, takes it for the first time out of the realm of discussion of the think tanks and puts it for discussion in the political arena. Other recommendations should however be easier to implement. Extending an EU mandate to the French co-Chair of the OSCE Minsk Group that is empowered to facilitate negotiations over the resolution of the Karabakh conflict is something that is now widely considered expedient, and the fact that French MEPs have not opposed it indicates that there may be a certain amount of French convergence on this issue.

The EP resolution talks at length about the importance of the process of democracy, human rights and particularly media freedom in Armenia , Azerbaijan and Georgia. The message to the three countries is clear, you cannot avoid these issues if you want to do business with Europe. The Parliament has a duty to ensure that European institutions continue to put the human dimension agenda at the heart of the relations between the EU and the South Caucasus.

The resolution does not quite spell out what the EU’s end game in the region is. It states that “the EU’s main objective in the region is to encourage the development of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia towards open, peaceful, stable and democratic countries, ready to establish good neighbourly relations and able to transform the South Caucasus into a region of sustainable peace, stability and prosperity, with a view to enhancing the integration of these countries in European policies; considers that the EU needs to play an increasingly active political role to achieve this objective, by developing a strategy that would combine its soft power with a firm approach, in agreement with the countries of the region and complemented by bilateral policies”. Not quite membership perspective, but in fact to have tried to do so at this stage would have been counter-productive.

None of the three South Caucasus countries is ready for EU membership, politically, economically or socially. It is not clear if the leaderships of the three countries are even ready to embark on the long and difficult journey towards membership. What the EP resolution does however is it proposes a range of measures, that if properly implemented would in the end make EU membership for Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia, not only possible, but also desirable for both sides.

The European Parliament should continue to monitor the situation in the South Caucasus, and particularly its relations with the EU, holding the institutions to account but also ensuring that the message sent to the three governments remains clear and unambiguous.


LINKS is a British non governmental organisation working for the peaceful resolution of conflicts and in support of democracy and sustainable development in societies in transition, through dialogue and innovative initiatives.   
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Iranian FM Expected To Visit Georgia In June

(Civil.Ge) -- Foreign Minister of Iran, Manouchehr Mottaki, is expected to visit Georgia tentatively in June, Ramin Mehmanparast, a spokesman for the Iranian Foreign Ministry, said on May 21.

The Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman is visiting Tbilisi, accompanying a group of Iranian journalists.

He also said that a visit of Iranian President, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, was also possible. According to the Iranian sources, President Saakashvili extended invitation to Iranian President to visit Georgia on May 14 when Iran's new ambassador in Tbilisi, Majid Saber, submitted his credentials to the Georgian President.

After the planned Iranian Foreign Minister’s visit to Georgia, Mehmanparast said, holding of a joint Georgian-Iranian governmental commission meeting was expected in Iran.

“We are waiting for the Georgian Prime Minister [Nika Gilauri] to visit Iran and accompanying the delegation for the joint commission,” he said.

“Relations between Iran and Georgia are excellent,” Mehmanparast said. “In political affairs we have very good relationship, but we think that we should increase our cooperation in economic affairs... especially in energy sector, agriculture.”

Speaking at a conference of Iranian and Georgian journalists in Tbilisi on May 21, Iran’s new ambassador to Georgia, Majid Saber, said there was a great potential in boosting bilateral cooperation in energy sector. He said that Iran planned to invest in construction of hydro power plant in Georgia and the Georgian side had requested Iran to share its experience in wind energy development.

Responding to a question about Georgia-U.S. relations, the Iranian ambassador recalled Georgia’s energy crisis in January, 2006 caused by explosion of two gas pipelines in Russia’s North Caucasus and said Iran at the time showed its readiness to provide assistance through supply of gas.

“No U.S. help was there when you needed it most. Real friendship is demonstrated in hard times,” the Iranian ambassador said without further elaboration on the matter.
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

European Parliament Adopts Resolution On South Caucasus

(Civil.Ge) -- European Parliament adopted a non-binding resolution on May 20 calling for greater EU involvement in the South Caucasus and for the EU to became "a significant security actor in the region".

The key amendment, which draft of the resolution underwent before being adopted, in respect of Georgia is that the final text no longer includes term "occupied territories" in reference to Georgia's two breakaway regions. (Summary of the draft available here)

The draft resolution said that "Russia and the de facto authorities of the occupied territories, which are under Russian effective control, are blocking" full implementation of a mandate by EU Monitoring Mission in Georgia, which is not able to access the breakaway regions.

Wording of the adopted text in this respect is as follows: the European Parliament "calls on Russia and the de facto authorities of the breakaway regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia to stop blocking" full implementation of EUMM mandate.

Other key points of the text in respect of Georgia, including calls for Russia to fully ceasefire accords, as well as on democratic reforms and on media ownership, remained unchanged.
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

South Caucasus: EU Must Help Stabilise Region, Say MEPs

The EU must pursue a strategy to promote stability, prosperity and conflict resolution in the South Caucasus, argues a resolution adopted by Parliament on Thursday.

The region is central to the EU's energy interests as it hosts the South Caucasus Pipeline, which transports gas from the Caspian to the Black Sea.

Although Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia have been partners of the EU's Neighbourhood Policy since 2004, a comprehensive regional strategy is still lacking for the region, says the resolution, which was drafted by Evgeni Kirilov (S&D, BG). MEPs want the EU strategy for the South Caucasus to concentrate on three areas: conflict resolution; promotion of democracy, human rights and the rule of law; economic cooperation and social development.

Europe faces a complex geopolitical situation in its dealings with this region, with conflicts in the Nagorno Karabakh area and Georgia as well as tensions between Armenia and Turkey.

The situation of conflict in the region is neither acceptable nor viable, say MEPs, who express concern at the recent increases in military spending and call for the withdrawal of Armenian forces from all occupied territories of Azebaïdjan. Another obstacle to economic and social development is the persistence of "frozen conflicts".

Energy security

Lastly, MEPs highlight the importance of the region for the EU's energy security and supply. They express support for the strengthening of EU-South Caucasus cooperation in energy projects and urge the EU to work firmly towards completion of the Nabucco pipeline.

Ahead of local elections in Georgia to be held on 30 May, MEPs insist that measures be taken to ensure that international electoral standards are respected. The EP's Foreign Affairs Committee will send an ad-hoc delegation of seven MEPs to observe these elections.
Thursday, May 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Top Executive Of Russian-Georgian Company Arrested

(Civil.Ge) -- General director of a Russian-Georgian company Energy Invest, Geno Malazonia, was arrested on the suspicions of tax evasion, the chief prosecutor’s office said on May 20.

Malazonia, who was arrested on May 19, is also suspected of fraud, illegal entrepreneurship and misuse of office, “through which the state sustained significant financial damage,” the chief prosecutor’s office said.

Energy Invest, one of the largest investment companies in Georgia owns fertilizer producing plant, Azot, in Rustavi and 110 MW gas turbine generator in Gardabani, which is a joint venture with Russia’s VTB Bank. Majority stakes in Energy Invest is reportedly owned by Russian companies Intergasinvest and Interinvest.

Before joining Energy Invest in 2004, Malazonia served in various position in the state structures since 1999, including as deputy head of customs service; chief of anti-monopoly agency; deputy minister for finance and education.

According to Energy Invest employees, the tax service has been auditing the company since April 12.
Thursday, May 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

NATO's New Strategic Concept

By Andrei Fedyashin

NATO comes out with a new strategic concept once every ten years, like a child that outgrows its old clothes and needs new ones. The great paradox of these regular changes is that NATO's original "zone of hostility" has been shrinking geographically over the past 20 years while its zone of activity has continued to expand. In fact, all of NATO's past concepts simply provided a formal rationale for what it had been doing for a few years anyway, even if this extended beyond NATO's official competence.

But that is beside the point, really. Sometimes military alliances do have to adapt to volatile times in ways their founders could not have envisioned. However, one needs to distinguish between a single deviation from the mission and a consistent policy of expanding one's authority.

NATO is certainly the latter case. The "wise men" led by former U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright have recently released their recommendations for NATO's strategic goals for the next decade. The report will have to be considered by the 28 member governments and approved at the Lisbon summit in November. The 2010 Strategic Concept will replace the 1999 concept.

The report, titled "NATO 2020: Assured Security: Dynamic Engagement", recommends that NATO engage dynamically with countries and organizations that are outside the Euro-Atlantic region, which it has been doing de facto for the past 20 years. There is also a proposal to incorporate NATO forces into the larger UN military structure, allowing NATO to conduct operations all over the world, possibly in partnership with other countries (Russia, China). But any potential partnership will clearly be tilted toward NATO leadership.

There has been speculation that Albright's recommendations would move NATO in that very direction ever since her team of a dozen military and civilian experts from the private and public sectors began its work last summer. The only question was to what extent NATO's transformation into a global military and political organization (in spite of its Charter) would be institutionalized. The answer, we now know, is: to a large extent.

Over the past decade, Europeans have come to view NATO as an anachronism badly in need of modernization. Yet no one seriously proposed disbanding the alliance, with the exception, perhaps, of some lefty revolutionary hotheads. NATO is so deeply entrenched in Europe's economy that uprooting it would inevitably come with social and economic consequences, such as increased unemployment. Not even Russia would make such an absurd (for the time being) demand. But there is a big difference between not actively opposing NATO and supporting its globalization.

Documents like Albright's usually do not recommend fundamental changes, as they are authored by seasoned diplomats, military experts, politicians, academics, advisors and other brains.

Ever since 1951, the alliance has always looked to its best and brightest to resolve problems that conventional diplomacy could not.

NATO has been trying to justify its existence in a world that has changed dramatically over the past 20 years. With the disintegration of the Warsaw Pact, NATO's opponent and reason for existing, most Warsaw Pact members became NATO members. Now, without its communist counterpart, NATO is finding it difficult to come up with a political rationale for the existence of its colossal war machine. Russia certainly remained a threat to Europe during the turmoil of the 1990s, but a threat that required an international police force, at most. NATO could not accept such a downgraded status.

Therefore, Albright's group was given the difficult task of creating a new political and ideological rationale for NATO's existence. NATO's new concept must be a kind of seal of approval for the 21st century, proving that the alliance is essential for the global security framework.

That is why the document contains provisions on the expansion of NATO's political and military roles, the boundaries of its activity, its methods and means and completely new functions. Under the new concept, NATO's primary objectives would be to improve the global non-proliferation regime, cut nuclear arsenals, fight terrorism, build a missile-defense shield in Europe, and combat maritime piracy and cyber-attacks. Other objectives include ensuring energy security, preventing global warming and protecting water sources and other natural resources. These do not sound like the objectives of a military alliance.

The concept also proposes creating a NATO liaison department at the UN. In addition, NATO would assume responsibility for providing military support for the UN's civilian operations.

The concept includes an entire paragraph on Russia. It does not include much in the way of new ideas, except for a call to strengthen cooperation within the NATO-Russia Council, which has been inadequate to date. Russia is no longer seen as an enemy, but at the same time NATO does not want partnership with Russia to limit its ability to protect its members.

The only truly new idea is bad news for Ukraine and Georgia - or perhaps just Georgia, as Ukraine's new government is unlikely to seek NATO membership. One of the clauses contains a curious phrase, which could be interpreted in a variety of ways, none of which can be very good for prospective members. "In addition, NATO's diplomatic efforts with Russia, Ukraine, Georgia and the other countries of the Caucasus, and other nonmember states, show that nations do not have to be part of the Alliance to join with NATO on projects that benefit all."

Officially, the concept reiterates that NATO is a voluntary alliance with an open-door policy.

It is extremely tempting to venture into that "open door" to challenge NATO's new concept. If global security is NATO's primary concern, then all the problems besetting NATO-Russia relations could be solved in an instant. All Moscow needs to do is file for membership. Our individual problems and concerns would be transformed into shared problems and concerns. Nikita Khrushchev suggested this as a joke in 1954. He nearly filed an application. Why not try again?

The opinions expressed in this article are the author's alone and do not necessarily represent those of RIA Novosti, where this article was published.
Thursday, May 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Moscow Not Ready To Risk Absorbing South Ossetia, Markedonov Says

By Paul Goble

Despite calls by the president of North Ossetia for uniting his republic with South Ossetia within in the Russian Federation, Moscow is not yet ready to take that step lest it trigger a new round of instability in the North Caucasus and further complicate relations with Moscow’s various foreign partners, according to a leading Russian analyst.

In an article posted online, Sergey Markedonov, one of Russia’s most thoughtful commentators on the Caucasus, says that North Ossetian President Taymuras Mamsurov’s May 12th call is hardly surprising given that the idea of uniting the two Ossetias has a history going back to the end of the Soviet period (www.politcom.ru/10121.html).

In the late 1980s and early 1990s, he writes, the idea of uniting the two Ossetias, one inside the Russian Federation and the other in Georgia was “intensively discussed on both sides of the Caucasus mountains,” in the South in response to the rising tide of Georgian ethno-nationalism and in the North for that reason and because of the North’s clash with Ingushetia.

Some in Moscow were prepared to back such a combination, seeing it “as an alternative to the parade of sovereignties that was then gathering strength.” Later, in March 1993, the North Ossetian parliament took the further step of recognizing South Ossetia as an independent republic, doing so 15 years “earlier than Russia,” Markedonov notes.

But from 1993 to 2004, Markedonov writes, the idea of combining the two republics was put on hold, as the result of Moscow’s policies and the approach of North Ossetia’s second president Aleksandr Dzasokhov, even though many Ossetians in both continued to be interested in linking their two republics more closely.
The Russian-Georgian war of August 2008 and Moscow’s diplomatic recognition of South Ossetia changed all this. But Mamsurov’s declaration earlier this month raises the question as to “the readiness of the Russian leadership to yet again revise the status quo in the Caucasus region.”

According to Markedonov, “the existence of South Ossetia creates more than a few political-level paradoxes. On the one hand, it enjoys some of the attributes of an independent state. But on the other, it is far smaller than North Ossetia which “is not an independent formation.”

North Ossetia is more than twice as large and its population may be as much as 15 times as great as South Ossetia, and North Ossetians have typically viewed themselves as fulfilling the function of “the elder brother,” not the junior partner. Moreover, all Ossetians know that “the South Ossetian project initially was defined not as a separatist but as an irredentist effort.”

Even after August 2008, the independence of South Ossetia, “in contrast to that of Abkhazia,” was viewed by most people in the region as “an intermediate result,” that would ultimately result in the absorption of South Ossetia into North Ossetia and the Russian Federation.

But there are compelling reasons, Markedonov argues, to think that Moscow is not prepared to take this step just yet and that Mamsurov’s comments have more to do with internal North Ossetian politics than they do with Moscow’s policies.

On the one hand, any decision to unite South Ossetia with the Russian Federation is “not a narrow regional question” but rather one that involves a range of domestic and foreign policies. Taking this step would not only exacerbate the Ossetian-Ingush conflict but energize the increasingly active Circassian movement, one of several seeking to overcome ethnic divisions.

And on the other, “recognition of formally external subjects by Moscow is not the same thing as joining new territories to the Russian Republic,” a step that would challenge the existing status quo across the region and raise questions among Russians foreign interlocutors about what Moscow might do next.

Indeed, Markedonov suggests, “a unilateral violation by Moscow of the status quo in the Caucasus could introduce new problems in relations with governments not only in the West” but also with those of Turkey and Iran, both of whom are also very much interested in maintaining the status quo.

Consequently, it is certain that Mamsurov was not speaking as Moscow’s representative but rather as someone forced to make such remarks given the political situation in his own republic which requires him to win legitimacy at a time when there are no elections and with a clear eye on his own political future, which will be determined by Moscow on June 7th.

. It is therefore not useful, Markedonov concludes, to view Mamsurov’s remarks as part of some sort of “big game” by Moscow officials, although he concedes that “it is impossible to exclude an interest on the part of certain highly-placed supporters of ‘a special path’” on this issue, whatever its consequences might be.


 Paul Goble is a longtime specialist on ethnic and religious questions in Eurasia. Most recently, he was director of research and publications at the Azerbaijan Diplomatic Academy. Earlier, he served as vice dean for the social sciences and humanities at Audentes University in Tallinn and a senior research associate at the EuroCollege of the University of Tartu in Estonia. He has served in various capacities in the U.S. State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the International Broadcasting Bureau as well as at the Voice of America and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty and at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Mr. Goble maintains the Window on Eurasia blog and can be contacted directly at paul.goble@gmail.com . 
Thursday, May 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Sen. McCain Criticizes Obama Over Georgia

(Civil.Ge) -- Republican Senator John McCain criticized the Obama administration saying that support for liberty and human rights is "mostly missing" from the U.S. foreign policy and as one of the examples, among others, the Senator brought situation in Georgia vis-à-vis Russia.

"Not only are Russian forces still occupying sovereign Georgian territory; they are digging in their military presence. But last week, the President resubmitted to Congress a civil-nuclear agreement with Russia, stating, and I quote, ‘the situation in Georgia is no longer an obstacle...’ And some wonder why the Georgians feel that Washington is selling them out to Moscow as the price of our ‘hitting the reset button’," Senator McCain, who visited Georgia this January, told a conference at the Nixon Center, according to his prepared remarks.

After the August, 2008 war between Georgia and Russia, the Bush administration froze nuclear treaty with Russia, citing that Russia's actions were "incompatible with peaceful relations with its sovereign and democratic neighbor, Georgia."

On May 10, in a message to the Congress requesting for the support to this treaty with Russia, President Obama said that he had reviewed the situation and concluded, that "the situation in Georgia need no longer be considered an obstacle to proceeding with the proposed Agreement."

"The sad thing is, it’s not just the Georgians. Ask the Poles, or the Czechs, or others in central Europe, and you’ll hear the same anxiety about American abandonment," Senator McCain said.

In the context of the Obama administration's stance on Syria and Lebanon, McCain said: "There is nothing wrong with engagement, but it’s a tactic, not a foreign policy, and we should never give the impression that engagement with our enemies comes at the expense of the sovereignty and independence of our friends."

On May 15 The Washington Post ran an op-ed under the headline "U.S. Abandoning Russia's Neighbors" by David J. Kramer, who is a senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund of the United States and a former deputy assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs in the George W. Bush administration.

"The administration seems to have moved toward a "Russia only" approach, neglecting and even abandoning other countries in the region," he wrote and suggested that "the most glaring example of this trend" was President Obama's message to the Congress.

"It would be one thing to resubmit the... treaty noting that the United States still has serious disagreements with Russia over Georgia. Instead, by stating so baldly that the situation in Georgia is no longer an obstacle to advancing Russian-American relations, the administration is essentially abandoning the Georgians and giving Russia a green light to continue to engage in provocative behavior along its borders," David J. Kramer wrote.

On May 18 the issue was further discussed in a piece published on the Huffington Post by Moscow-based TIME Magazine reporter, Simon Shuster, under the headline "Obama's Betrayal of Georgia Kind of Makes Sense". In the article the author, who interviewed President Saakashvili and some of his advisors more than a month ago, discusses the issue in the context of Georgia's internal developments, making focus on President Saakashvili's personality and looking into his alleged role in Imedi TV's notorious fake news report, suggesting that "Saakashvili showed himself to be impulsive, even erratic, and a dangerous partner for the United States.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...



Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search