In Turkey 'People Are Rebelling' Against Armenia Genocide Denial

Saturday, May 01, 2010

By Lou Ann Matossian

(The Armenian Reporter) -- As Armenians in Yerevan laid flowers at the Eternal Flame on the 95th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, Turkish citizens in Istanbul solemnly commemorated April 24 with candles and red carnations-despite protests from ultranationalists and the denial policy of their own government.

Seated on the steps outside Haydarpa'a Station, activists from the Istanbul Human Rights Association held carnations and posters of Armenian community leaders whose arrest and deportation from that very place had heralded the Young Turks' extermination campaign. "April 24, 1915-Never Again" proclaimed the organization's banner as human rights attorney Eren Keskin addressed the solemn group.

"The events of 1915 must not be repeated," Ms. Keskin was quoted in press reports. "We have gathered here to say no to genocide."

Turkish police stood guard at the peaceful demonstration of about 100 mourners, keeping counter-demonstrators at bay. As journalists' cameras clicked and whirred, Ms. Keskin and the others threw their flowers into the Bosphorus, closing the vigil on the Asian shore of Istanbul.

That same evening in the heart of downtown, on the European side, the Initiative to Say No to Racism and Nationalism held a peaceful sit-down demonstration in bustling Taksim Square.

A large black placard, inscribed "This is OUR pain. This is a mourning for ALL OF US," in Turkish, Armenian, and English, was placed on the ground with bouquets of red carnations and rows of votive candles resembling red apples.

"In 1915, when we had a population of only 13 million people, there were 1.5 to 2 million Armenians living on this land," an organizer proclaimed in Turkish. More than 200 mourners sat in silence as she named the cities and regions where Ottoman Armenians had lived, from Kars in the east to Thrace in the west.

"They were the grocer in our neighborhood, our tailor, our goldsmith, our carpenter, our shoemaker, our farmhand, our millwright, our classmate, our teacher, our officer, our private, our deputy, our historian, our composer...our friend," the statement continued. "Our next-door neighbors and our companion in bad times.

"On April 24th, 1915, they were ‘rounded up'. We lost them. They are not here anymore. A great majority of them do not exist anymore. Nor do their graveyards," the organizer read out, evoking "the overwhelming ‘Great Pain' that was laid upon the qualms of our conscience by the ‘Great Catastrophe'."

Clark University professor Taner Akçam, an endorser of the Taksim Square statement, called the April 24th commemorations in Turkey a "serious crack in the wall" of silence and denial. "The other Turkey-the Turkey that doesn't belong to denialists-is coming to the surface," he told the Armenian Reporter.

"People are rebelling," he concluded. "They are saying, ‘We want to learn the truth'."

Without identifying the Armenian Genocide as such, the statement urged "all peoples of Turkey who share this heartfelt pain to commemorate and pay tribute to the victims of 1915." (The full text, posted online at buacihepimizin.org with some 1,500 signatures, was endorsed by about 80 prominent intellectuals and activists in Turkish society.)

Shouts of "Death to the Armenian Diaspora!" could be heard from counter-demonstrators as the mourners paused in silent commemoration, reported an eyewitness, Armenian Weekly editor Khatchig Mouradian. "This is Turkey! Love it or leave it!" chanted a group of angry men from behind police lines, in a video shot at the scene and posted to YouTube. Haranguing the mourners as traitors, they extended their first and fourth fingers in the ultranationalist Grey Wolf gesture.

At the close of the vigil, the mourners tossed carnations into the air, reported Hürriyet. "The brotherhood of Armenians, Turks, and Kurds!" they chanted, marching down Istiklal Avenue. "Shoulder to shoulder against fascism!"

Additional public vigils were reportedly held in Galatasaray, not far from Taksim Square, by Kurdish mothers of "disappeared" children, and outside the offices of Agos Armenian newspaper, where editor Hrant Dink was gunned down in January 2007.

A reparations debate in Ankara

In Ankara, meanwhile, international scholars and writers participated in a two-day conference on "1915 within its pre- and post-historical periods," organized by the Ankara Freedom of Thought Initiative. Nearly cancelled due to political and bureaucratic obstacles, the panels were held under tight security, with no counter-demonstrations permitted. Unusually for a conference in Turkey, proponents of the government's "official history" were notably absent from the list of invited presenters.

Nevertheless, a panel on "The Armenian Issue: What is to be done and how?" sparked plenty of controversy as Worcester State University philosopher Henry Theriault called for genocide reparations. Turkey should return or compensate for Armenian property, wealth, slave labor, pain and suffering, and the loss of 1.5 million people, as well as cultural, religious, and educational losses, Prof. Theriault stated.

Although Sevan Nishanian of Agos newspaper flatly rejected these demands as unjust and unproductive, author Temel Demirer and Welsh writer-activist Eilian Williams defended them, according to The Armenian Weekly's Mouradian, who participated in the intense debate among the panelists and audience members.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Technorati
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • MySpace
  • LinkedIn
  • Live
  • Google
  • Reddit
  • Sphinn
  • Propeller
  • Slashdot
  • Netvibes

10 comments:

  1. Anonymous said...

    i say bravo to all these intelligent and fearless turks. the world has seen what some turks will do to anyone who mentions the word genocide (read: Hrant Dink), but these people have taken it upon themselves to rid the shame their country has accumulated by denying the death of over one MILLION people.

  2. Anonymous said...

    The ancestors of the Armenians who made their history are the main deniers of genocide.

    Remember that whoever tells about topics which obviously abolish the imaginary past of the Armenians are labelled as ‘deniers’, as ‘agents of Turkish government’, or ‘people hired by the Turkish government’ or ‘disingenous scholars/authorities’ Turkish nationalists’, ‘Turkish racists’.

    Here are a few of the Armenian ancestors who comply with all these terms:

    “Garo Pasdermichan (Pastirmaciyan), the Ottoman deputy of Erzurum and commander of all the Armenian officials and soldiers of the Ottoman Third Army which joined the Russian Army in 1914, was the main denier and Turkish racist.

    Because, he wrote in his book ‘Why Armenia Should Be Free’ (Boston, Dec.1918, p. 16-17) that annual Congress of Armenian Party Dashnagzoutiun was held in Erzurum in August 1914, before the war broke, and Turkish emissaries offered Dashnaks an autonomous Armenia (made up of Russian Armenia and the three Turkish vilayets of Erzurum, Van and Bitlis) under the suzerainty of the Ottoman Empire’, if they joined the Turkish side and stopped supporting the Russians.


    He also stated that the executive committee of the Dashnagzoutiun rejected the proposal! The Armenian members of this parley were the well-known publicist E.Aknouni, the representative from Van, A.Vramian, and the director of the Armenian schools in the district of Erzurum, Mr Rostom.

  3. Anonymous said...

    2
    Another main denier was Boghos Noubar Pasha, the Armenian National Delegation President in The Paris Peace Conference 1919 who also stated that the Turks offered them autonomy in August 1914, much before the deportation, but they rejected this proposal and placed themselves without hesitation on the side of the Entente Powers from whom they expected liberation


    [Papers relating to the foreign relations of the United States The Paris Peace Conference 1919 (United States Government Printing Office, 1948, Vol IV, p 139-157)].

    Armenian Boghos Noubar Pasha, who told that ‘150 000 Armenian volunteers in Russian Army were the only forces against Turks’ (Times of London , 1919 Jan 30 Link: http://armenians-1915.blogspot.com/2007/10/2013-150-000-armenian-volunteers-in.html) was obviously a denier and agent of Turkish government.

    Hovannes Katchaznouni, the first prime-minister of the Armenian state founded in 1918 and the prime authority of the Dashnagzoutiun Party who wrote a book ‘Dashnagzoutiun Has Nothing to do Anymore’ was also another chief denier.

    Because, in his book which is banned in Armenia at present, he stated that
    *it was a mistake to establish the volunteer units.
    *They were unconditionally allied with Russia,
    *They massacred the Moslem population,
    *The Armenian terrorist acts were directed, at winning the Western public opinion.

    *British occupation aroused hopes of the Dashnaks,
    *They were provoked by imperial Sea to Sea land demand,
    *They had not taken into consideration Turkey’s power,
    * They should have used a peaceful language towards the Turks but they (Armenian Dashnaks) rejected the Turks who suggested to negotiate with them and they went on making war
    *The decision of the deportation of Armenians was a rightful measure taken by Turks.
    *Turkey had acted with an instinct of self-defence.
    *Their government was a Dashnak dictatorship.
    *The fault was within the Dashnak Party. They should commit suicide. They had nothing to do.


    Vratsyan, the last prime minister of Dashnaks who wrote in an article published in December 3 1920 issue of Araç, that they transformed Armenia to an arenna of endless wars with its neighbours for the Entente Powers (RGASPİ fond 80, list 4, file 83, sheet 136) was another chief denier and agent of Turkish government.

  4. Anonymous said...

    3
    Armenian Messrs. Ahonian and Hadissian who were the spokesmen of the Armenian delegation of the New Armenian Republic and visited Sultan Mehmet VI, Vahdeddin in Istanbul on September 6, 1918 were also Turkish nationalists.

    See the telegram sent by Mr Ahorian to the Armenian Prime Minister Kachaznuni:


    ‘On September 6th, we presented our congratulations on his accession to the throne. We submitted our best wishes for the development of the Empire and its well-being and stated that the Armenian nation would never forget that it was the Ottoman Government which first conceived the idea of founding an independent Armenia, and recognized it, that the Armenian Government would do everything possible to protect friendly relations between the two countries and to strengthen them.

    His Majesty thanked and stated that he was very happy at seeing the envoys of independenbt and free Armenia, that he wished not only her development , but that she be strong in order to retain her independence.

    His Majesty is entirely convinced that friendly relations will always exist between the two neighboring countries, Turkey and Armenia, in order that both of them may develop.

    He concluded his remarks by stating that he was very hapy to see that Armenia had the strength to found an independent state which was able to send envoys to Istanbul, and repeated his best wishes for our country’. (

    Erich Feigl, A Myth of Terror, Edition Zeitgeschichte Freilassing, Salzburg, Austria p.97)


    The Armenian Soviet historian A.A.Lalayan who stated that the Dashnaks displayed extreme courage to massacre Turkish women, children and ill and old people and who also quoted the following report of a Dashnag officer, Aslem Varaam written in 1920, in Beyazit-Varan was an Armenian denier and he was also hired by the Turkish government . The report of Aslem Varaam was:


    "I exterminated the Turkish population in Bashar-Gechar without making any exceptions. One some times feels the bullets shouldn't be wasted. So, the most effective way against these dogs is to collect the people who have survived the clashes and dump them in deep holes and crush them under heavy rocks pressed from above, not to let them inhabit this world any longer. So I did accordingly. I collected all the women, men and children and extinguished their lives in the deep holes I dumped them into, crushing them with rocks."


    A.Lalayan, Revolutsionniy Vostok (Revolutionary East) No: 2-3, p.92 vd, Moscow, 1936; Istoricheskie Zapisky No 2, p.101, 1928 (Contrarevolyutsionnıy ‘Daşnaktsutyun’ İ İmperialisti-çeskaya Voyna 1914-1918 gg.’, Revolyutsionnıy Vostok, No.2-3, p.92, 1936)
    Armenian T. Haçikoğlyan who told that the Dashnaks eradicated thousands of Turks with their bloody hands

    (T. Haçikoglyan, 10 Let Armyanskoy Sttrelkovoy Divizii ,p4-6. İzdatelstvo Polit. Uprav. KKA, Tiflis, 1930) was also a denier and agent of Turkish government.

  5. Anonymous said...

    4
    The Armenian poet Mikael Nalbandyan who wrote these lines in his poem ‘The March of People of Zeytun, was another denier and Turkish nationalist:

    ‘..Şad ısdrugner yeğan azad/Miyayin menk mnank hılu hıbadag/Zeytuntsiner mer zposank/E baderazm yev arşavank/ Sur, tur, kıntag yev hıratsan/ Mer khağalikın en havidyan….’
    (A lot of slaves were set free/ Only we were left who were obedient/Amusements of us, people of Zeytun are/ War and raid/ Our inexhaustible toys are/ Sword, saber, bullet and gun…….) (Nor Knar, p99).
    Zeytun was one of the places where the Armenians rebelled and massacred the Turks and Muslims.

    The Armenian journalists of Armenian newspapers published in İstanbul, like Hayrenik, were also deniers, since they praised the Ottoman government for letting the relocated Armenians return their previous locations in 1918 and allocated 2 million liras for their return.

    They were deniers since they also critized the Russians and other states for using the Armenians as their tools.

    KS Papazian the writer of ‘Patriotism Perverted’ published in 1934, in Boston was also a denier. Because:

    Papazian critized A. Khatisian and the then prime minister S.Vratzian for not publishing the text of Treaty of Gümrü which they signed on December 2, 1920 to put an end to the war between Turkey and the Armenian Republic on December 2, 1920, which coincided with the entrance of Bolsheviks in Armenia.

    Papazian also stated that the Armenian prime minister Simon Vratzian applied to the Turkish government on March 18, 1921 and asked military help of the Turks against the Bolsheviks!

  6. Anonymous said...

    6
    Even Gourgen Mıgırdıç Yanıkyan (age 78), the Armenian murderer of Los Angeles prime consul of Turkey Mehmet Baydar (age 49) and the co consul Bahadır Demir (age 30) in Santa Barbara, in 1973, was a real denier, Turkish nationalist and agent of Turkish government.

    Because he admitted in his trial on June 13, 1973, via his attorney Lindsay that he (Yanıkyan) had been a member of an army made up of 10 000 volunteers to fight against the Turks in Armenia, in the beginning of March 1915 and in chief of this army had been an Armenian general called Andranik.

    This had been prepared as four parties and had started to battle with the Turks in Iğdır, under the leadership of Russian general Dron and had proceeded to Van, they had occupied Van and meanwhile had destroyed and had fired Turkish villages

    (Dışişleri Bakanlığı <Santa Barbara Suikasti. Telephone from Washington Embassy to the Turkish Foreign Ministry, 15.6.1973, No:220 and June 21, 1973. No:225)

    Of course, even these few examples give great harm to the present Armenian thesis and lead people to question the Armenian’s innocence, their predominance in Ottoman population, and most importantly their genocide thesis.

    Of course, the fact that Turks offered the Dashnaks an autonomous Armenia (made up of Russian Armenia and the three Turkish vilayets of Erzurum, Van and Bitlis) under the suzerainty of the Ottoman Empire’, if they joined the Turkish side and stopped supporting the Russians, the other fact that the executive committee of the Dashnagzoutiun rejected the proposal in August 1914 before the war broke and that they rejected all other Turkish calls of negotiations repeated during WWI too, are the major points that are not wanted by the Armenians to be known

    (Garo Pastırmacıan, Why Armenia Should be Free?, Boston, Dec.1918, Hairenik Publishing Company p. 16-17 and Papers relating to the foreign relations of the United States The Paris Peace Conference 1919 , United States Government Printing Office, 1948, Vol IV, p 139-157).

  7. Anonymous said...

    7
    Of course they fear a question of why the Turks did offer autonomy to Armenians if they decided to eradicate them.


    And they fear the question of why and how the Armenian prime minister Simon Vratzian applied the Turkish government on March 18, 1921 and asked military help of the Turks against the Bolsheviks, in spite of the fact that the Turks committed a (so-called) genocide and murdered 1.5 million Armenians!

    And they also are very frightened of the question how the Ottoman Government eradicated 1,5 million of Armenians but in spite of this it was the Ottomans who first conceived the idea of founding an independent Armenia, and recognized it first.

    Moreover, it was the Ottoman Sultan who first wished not only the development of Armenian Republic, but that she be strong in order to retain her independence!

    Astonishingly, it was the Ottoman Sultan, who stated that friendly relations would always exist between the two countries.

    That is, the Armenian ancestors who created their history (the top representatitives of the Ottoman Armenians, Dashnags and prime ministers of Armenia), the Armenian historians and poets who wittnessed this period and even the Armenian murderers of Turkish diplomats are the main deniers!

    So, it is not surprising that both the book of Hovannes Katchaznouni, the first prime-minister of the Armenian state, ‘Dashnagzoutiun Has Nothing to do Anymore’ and the book of K.S.Papazian ‘Patrionism Perverted’ are banned in Armenia. It is also a fact that all the copies of the book of Hovannes Katchaznouni, in all languages were collected from the libraries in Europe by Dashnags. The book is included in the catalogues but no copies can be found in the racks.
    It is not surprising either that, the Armenians even claim that nobody called A.A. Lalayan, the Soviet-Armenian historian, ever lived!


    Yes, they can ban the books of the makers of their history, they can buy politicians by their votes and urge them to accept historical resolutions and memorial laws in their parliaments,

    they can threaten the historians who do not support their thesis, they can sue them, they can even bomb their houses (http://209.232.239.37/gtd1/ViewIncident.aspx?id=56624),

    they can make the world opinion blind by their propaganda and may deceive some of them,

    but they can never ban scholar thought and silence all the historians of the world!


    Note that Pierre Nora, president of the association ‘Liberty for history’ founded in 2005, has recently stated that the history should not be a slave to currency or written under the dictation of competing memoirs; in a free state, it does not belong to any political authority to define the historical truth and restrict freedom of the historian under threat of criminal sanctions. In a democracy, freedom for history is the freedom of all (http://www.lph-asso.fr//articles/46.html, . http://www.lph-asso.fr//tribunes/49.html)

    Now do you understand why the Armenians vehemently resist the establishment of historical joint commissions made up of historians from Armenia, Turkey and other countries?

    Do you understand why Prof Richard Hovannisian from California University (the father of the first Foreign Minister of Armenia) said: ‘It is very dangerous to establish such an historical commission…’ in an interview with Armenian Reporter?

    Do you understand why the Armenians have not admitted to International Court of Justice for more than 90 years and why they urge politicians to write their history as they want?

  8. Anonymous said...

    1

    Gathering of hundreds of Turkish people at Istanbul's Taksim Square on Saturday for a tribute highlights the great contrast between the two nations before the sorrows they lived in the past.

    I present a few events and leave the decision to the readers:

    A group of Turkish intellectuals held an apology campaign last year.

    Likewise, a similar and mutual apology campaign was tried to be held by Dr. Armen Gavakian from the Macquarie University in Sydney, who is also co-chair of the Turkish-Armenian Dialogue Group. The prepared petition would read "I apologize to the Ottomans and Turks for murders committed in the name of the Armenian people and I empathize with the feelings and pain of the Ottomans and Turks’

    However just a few days later we learned that ‘Oath of Asala' which is a branch of Armenian terrorist organization Asala declared that they would spare GAKAVYAN's life in case he abandoned this apology project and disclosed the names of the people who urged him to do so, according to the Armenian newspaper "Azg",http://www.radikal.com.tr/Radikal.aspx?aType=RadikalHaberDetay&ArticleID=921474&Date=14.02.2009&CategoryID=98

  9. Anonymous said...

    2

    The Armenian criminal of Orly Airport massacre, Karapetyan, a member of ASALA, who was discharged from the prison in the end of 18 years’ imprisonment in France, returned to Armenia in May 2001, he was welcomed by the then Armenian prime minister A.Margaryan, the Armenian folk and journalists who applauded him as if he were a national hero.

    A. Margaryan told that he appreciated this hero’s service for his country.

    Armenian Yerivan municipality provided work and house for the MURDERER as a reward (www.prima-news.ru/news/articles/2001/9/13/15705.html.


    However, when Hrant Dink was murdered, Turkish people, president, all members of goverment, bureaucrats from all levels, journalists sincerely mourned and condemned the murderer.

    Millions of Turkish citizens gathered in his funeral ceremony and shouted as ‘we are all Armenian’ with tears.

    Including the annual Press Freedom Award of Turkish Journalist Association, Hrant Dink was awarded with many prizes, after his death.

    Additionally, 100 000 illegal Armenian immigrant workers who are Armenian citizens are working throughout Turkey, at present.

  10. Anonymous said...

    3
    Remember that the Armenians established outlawed terrorist organizations ASALA, JCAG (Justice Commandos for Armenian Genocide) and ARA (Armenian Revolutionary Army) and performed dozens of murders and hundreds of terrorist activities and gave rise to death of 70 people (39 of whom being innocent Turkish diplomats), made 524 people be wounded; pledge 105; bombed a lot of places for 208 times during 1975-1986.

    In neither of the funerals of the murdered Turkish diplomats, no Armenian held placards on which it was written:

    ’We are all Turks’ ‘We are all Kemal Arikan, Bahadır Demir, Selçuk Bakkalbaşı, Haluk Sipahioğlu, Galip Özmen’.

    None of our innocent diplomats were rewarded with ‘Annual Reward of Peace, Brothership or Friendship’ by the Armenians.

    No Armenian shed tears.

    Just the opposite, as we heard in a conference of Richard G Hovannisian, held in Florida Atlantic University, on April 2, 2008, Armenians did not hide their sorrow for not murdering more Turkish diplomats!

    http://armenians-1915.blogspot.com/2010/04/3060-white-paper-armenian-issue-v2b.html

Post a Comment




Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search