Russia Reiterates Support For Azerbaijan's Territorial Integrity

Moscow reiterated its support for Azerbaijan's territorial integrity on Monday in the wake of parliamentary elections in Nagorny Karabakh, a breakaway Azerbaijani region with a predominantly ethnic Armenian population.

The region, which has been a source of conflict between the former Soviet republics of Armenia and Azerbaijan since the late 1980s, elected its 33-seat parliament on Sunday.

"Moscow is not convinced that the peace settlement of the conflict might depend on the results of the Nagorny Karabakh elections," a spokesman for the Russian foreign ministry, Andrei Nesterenko, said.

Nagorny Karabakh claimed independence from Azerbaijan to join Armenia in 1988. In the early 1990s, a war broke out leaving over 30,000 people dead on both sides. A ceasefire was concluded in 1994, leaving Nagorny Karabakh in Armenian hands.

"Moscow supports the principle of Azerbaijan's territorial integrity, as well as other fundamental norms and principles of international law. As you know, we don't recognize Nagorny Karabakh as an independent state," he said.

The conflict is mediated by the OSCE Minsk Group, comprising the United States, Russia and France.

"We are convinced that the future status [of Nagorny Karabakh] should be defined without the use of force, as a result of political negotiations between all parties within the framework of the Minsk process," Nesterenko said.

Source: RIA Novosti
Monday, May 24, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

OSCE To Monitor Ceasefire On Armenian-Azerbaijani Border

Officials from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) will conduct ceasefire monitoring on Monday along a disputed stretch of the border between Armenia and Azerbaijan, the Azerbaijani Defense Ministry said.

The two countries have exchanged numerous allegations of ceasefire violations on the border near troubled Nagorny Karabakh, a region in Azerbaijan with a largely ethnic Armenian population which has been a source of conflict between the former Soviet republics since the late 1980s.

The previous monitoring on May 13 in the province, which has its own government and is de facto independent, did not reveal any violations of ceasefire in the mountainous area.

The conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over Nagorny Karabakh first erupted in 1988, when the region claimed independence from Azerbaijan to join Armenia.

Over 30,000 people were reported dead on both sides between 1988 and 1994, and over 100 others died after a ceasefire was concluded in 1994, leaving Nagorny Karabakh in Armenian hands, but tensions between Azerbaijan and Armenia have persisted.

The conflict is mediated by the OSCE Minsk Group, comprising the United States, Russia and France.


Source: RIA Novosti
Monday, May 24, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Parliament Lays Markers For Future EU Relations With The South Caucasus

By LINKS

The resolution on a future EU strategy towards the South Caucasus adopted yesterday by the European Parliament lays down a number of important markers that those in the region, and in the European Union and beyond working with the South Caucasus, should note and heed.

The resolution is a reflection of a realisation that has finally taken hold in Brussels that the South Caucasus is the next area that the European Union will have to engage with in a significant way over the coming decade and beyond. This engagement had felt for most of the past decade more as mission creep rather than a strategic choice. That is past. The strategy may not yet be fully mature, but the understanding that one is needed is now well and truly embedded. The reflexes of the European Commission have traditionally been to approach the region with caution. This could also be seen from the intervention of Commissioner Stefan Fule immediately prior to the vote, where he tried to argue that no new strategy was necessary because the EU Eastern Partnership and neighbourhood Policies already lay down strategies for engagement with the South Caucasus.

In a sense he is right. There is no need for another exercise that takes years in planning and creates a new bureaucratic layer at the end to implement its recommendations. What is required now is that what is already envisaged and decided in the Eastern Partnership and Neighbourhood Policy instruments be implemented strategically rather than as bureaucratic chore.

The Parliament’s resolution was diligently drafted by the rapporteur, Bulgarian MEP Evgeni Kirilov. It went through a rigorous process of debate in the Foreign Affairs Committee where a number of amendments were considered and adopted and where the text was tightened. The European Parliament is sometimes considered an ineffective talking shop. However this resolution has been able to capture the broad consensus of the European political leadership towards the South Caucasus, despite all the diversity, differences and nuanced approaches that exist in the 27 member states. Even for this alone it needs to be applauded.

The resolution contains a number of innovative ideas for strengthening peace and democracy in the region and about the facilitation of interaction between the EU and the three South Caucasus Republics

Some ideas included in the resolution may take time to implement. The proposal to establish a Conference for Security and Co-operation for the South Caucasus where the countries of the region, their neighbours and other interested party can start addressing some of the security concerns that have overshadowed regional relations over the last decade, is one that as yet has to find favour in many of the chancelleries of Europe. Its endorsement by the European Parliament however, takes it for the first time out of the realm of discussion of the think tanks and puts it for discussion in the political arena. Other recommendations should however be easier to implement. Extending an EU mandate to the French co-Chair of the OSCE Minsk Group that is empowered to facilitate negotiations over the resolution of the Karabakh conflict is something that is now widely considered expedient, and the fact that French MEPs have not opposed it indicates that there may be a certain amount of French convergence on this issue.

The EP resolution talks at length about the importance of the process of democracy, human rights and particularly media freedom in Armenia , Azerbaijan and Georgia. The message to the three countries is clear, you cannot avoid these issues if you want to do business with Europe. The Parliament has a duty to ensure that European institutions continue to put the human dimension agenda at the heart of the relations between the EU and the South Caucasus.

The resolution does not quite spell out what the EU’s end game in the region is. It states that “the EU’s main objective in the region is to encourage the development of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia towards open, peaceful, stable and democratic countries, ready to establish good neighbourly relations and able to transform the South Caucasus into a region of sustainable peace, stability and prosperity, with a view to enhancing the integration of these countries in European policies; considers that the EU needs to play an increasingly active political role to achieve this objective, by developing a strategy that would combine its soft power with a firm approach, in agreement with the countries of the region and complemented by bilateral policies”. Not quite membership perspective, but in fact to have tried to do so at this stage would have been counter-productive.

None of the three South Caucasus countries is ready for EU membership, politically, economically or socially. It is not clear if the leaderships of the three countries are even ready to embark on the long and difficult journey towards membership. What the EP resolution does however is it proposes a range of measures, that if properly implemented would in the end make EU membership for Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia, not only possible, but also desirable for both sides.

The European Parliament should continue to monitor the situation in the South Caucasus, and particularly its relations with the EU, holding the institutions to account but also ensuring that the message sent to the three governments remains clear and unambiguous.


LINKS is a British non governmental organisation working for the peaceful resolution of conflicts and in support of democracy and sustainable development in societies in transition, through dialogue and innovative initiatives.   
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Armenia Denies New 'Road-Map' In Turkey Relations

There is no new road-map for Armenian-Turkish rapprochement, the Armenian foreign minister said on Friday.

"This is false information," Eduard Nalbandyan told a news conference.

News about a new road-map appeared after a high-ranking official from Armenia's ruling Justice and Development party's said on Thursday in Washington that Armenia and Turkey would not comment on their relations as there was a new document on the agenda to be discussed.

Relations between Armenia and Turkey took a major step forward on October 10, 2009 when Nalbandyan and Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu signed protocols on establishing diplomatic relations and developing bilateral relations.

The documents, signed in Switzerland, have to be ratified by both countries to come into force.

But in April 2010 Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan signed a decree putting a hold on the ratification saying Turkey was not ready to continue the reconciliation process.

The Armenian-Turkish border was closed in 1993 on Ankara's initiative. Bilateral relations between the countries are complicated by Turkey's support of Azerbaijan in its conflict with Armenia over Nagorny Karabakh and differing positions on the killings of ethnic Armenians in the Ottoman Empire during World War One.

Source: RIA Novosti
Friday, May 21, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

South Caucasus: EU Must Help Stabilise Region, Say MEPs

The EU must pursue a strategy to promote stability, prosperity and conflict resolution in the South Caucasus, argues a resolution adopted by Parliament on Thursday.

The region is central to the EU's energy interests as it hosts the South Caucasus Pipeline, which transports gas from the Caspian to the Black Sea.

Although Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia have been partners of the EU's Neighbourhood Policy since 2004, a comprehensive regional strategy is still lacking for the region, says the resolution, which was drafted by Evgeni Kirilov (S&D, BG). MEPs want the EU strategy for the South Caucasus to concentrate on three areas: conflict resolution; promotion of democracy, human rights and the rule of law; economic cooperation and social development.

Europe faces a complex geopolitical situation in its dealings with this region, with conflicts in the Nagorno Karabakh area and Georgia as well as tensions between Armenia and Turkey.

The situation of conflict in the region is neither acceptable nor viable, say MEPs, who express concern at the recent increases in military spending and call for the withdrawal of Armenian forces from all occupied territories of Azebaïdjan. Another obstacle to economic and social development is the persistence of "frozen conflicts".

Energy security

Lastly, MEPs highlight the importance of the region for the EU's energy security and supply. They express support for the strengthening of EU-South Caucasus cooperation in energy projects and urge the EU to work firmly towards completion of the Nabucco pipeline.

Ahead of local elections in Georgia to be held on 30 May, MEPs insist that measures be taken to ensure that international electoral standards are respected. The EP's Foreign Affairs Committee will send an ad-hoc delegation of seven MEPs to observe these elections.
Thursday, May 20, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Russia Poised To Leapfrog Ukraine, Moldova In EU Visa Drive

By Ahto Lobjakas

(RFE/RL) -- Russia is putting pressure on the European Union to turn the next top-level meeting between the two -- the Rostov-na-Donu gathering on May 31 -- into a "visa summit."

Officials in Brussels say the EU and Russia will jointly sign a document at Rostov-na-Donu outlining "common steps" toward visa liberalization. This would represent a significant advance for Russia in its decade-long drive toward visa-free travel in the EU. At the same time, it would hand Russia a psychological and political victory over countries like Ukraine, Moldova, and Georgia, who have long awaited visa liberalization and have offered political reforms to get it.

If Russia, which has no obligations to reform, steps ahead of those countries in the visa-free queue, it will only serve to emphasize that the status of the EU's Eastern Partnership countries matters very little when it comes to strategic concessions from the bloc.

Diplomats say a majority of EU foreign ministers, debating the issue in Brussels on May 10, supported the plan. (Under EU rules, a qualified majority decision is sufficient.) A concession on visas is seen as essential to ensure the success of the Rostov-na-Donu summit on May 31.

There, the EU wants Russia to commit to a broad "modernizing partnership" by reaffirming its commitment to concluding a new strategic partnership agreement, joining the World Trade Organization, and cooperating on a range of issues from border management to trade issues.

Russia's champions in this debate are Germany, France, and most of the EU's southern member states -- along with, somewhat surprisingly, Finland. Poland continues to sound a cautionary note, but even the plan's detractors now see it as a foregone conclusion.

'Road Map' In All But Name

In all but name, the common steps constitute a "road map" -- the EU term for an agreement committing the bloc to dropping its visa requirement for short-stay visitors to its Schengen space (comprising all EU countries except Britain, Ireland, Cyprus, Bulgaria, and Romania; as well as Switzerland, Norway, and Iceland) once its conditions have been met.

So far, only countries in the western Balkans have been awarded such road maps. No ex-Soviet country outside the EU has managed to secure one.

A visa-liberalization road map sets out detailed requirements for reforms to be implemented in key areas. Chief among the EU's concerns are document security -- above all, the introduction of biometric passports; border management; combating illegal migration; and the fight against organized crime and corruption.

The road map does not fix the date when visas will be lifted, but it effectively commits the EU to doing so once all its conditions have been met. In the western Balkans, Serbia, Croatia, and Macedonia late last year became the first countries to complete a road map -- and are now seen as having set a precedent for others.

Top EU foreign policy official Hugues Mingarelli made the link at the European Parliament in early April, when he said a number of EU member states are reluctant to give Ukraine a road map for fear of making movement toward the abolition of visas a virtually "automatic process." Instead, these EU countries would like to retain what Mingarelli described as their "political discretion."

Most Desirable Goal

Visa-free travel in the EU has become the most desirable goal for all of the bloc's Eastern neighbors, who see in it great psychological, political, and economic benefits. Most EU member states, on the other hand, are fearful of greater immigration and crime, and generally do not want to send Eastern neighbors signals which could be interpreted as encouragement to pursue a course aimed at eventual accession.

As a result, movement toward visa liberalization has been a drawn-out process. Russia was the first to secure it as a "long-term" goal in 2003. Ukraine followed suit in 2008, and Moldova did the same earlier this year.

A number of ministers on May 10 warned that Russia is attempting to manipulate the EU, offering unenforceable promises of partnership and cooperation in return for what remains effectively the bloc's only real leverage.

Visa 'Currency'

Poland's Radoslaw Sikorski warned that visa liberalization is a "currency" the EU should spend wisely. Sikorski noted that the EU's visa policy "must not go against its foreign policy," with its declared aim of transforming Russia into a European society where the rule of law prevails. Talks on a new EU-Russia strategic partnership treaty have stalled, largely as a result of Russia's palpable lack of interest in saddling itself with further obligations.

Sikorski, along with the ministers of the Baltic and Nordic countries as well as Romania, also argued that Russia must not advance ahead of Ukraine, Moldova, and the EU's other Eastern neighbors, who this week celebrated five years of membership in the European Neighborhood Policy and last week the first year of their Eastern Partnership with the EU.

A number of ministers said the issued should be linked to Russia's cooperation on frozen conflicts involving Georgia, Moldova, Armenia, and Azerbaijan.

But the Friends of Russia club appears to have carried the day, supported by the EU's executive arm, the European Commission. France, Spain, and Portugal once again emerged as champions of "positive interdependence" between Russia and the EU. Greece and Cyprus highlighted the prospective benefits of visa-free travel with Russia. All were identified as primary targets for Russian foreign policy engagement in a memo published last week by the Russia version of "Newsweek."

Officials say the outcome of the Brussels meeting was decided by Germany. Traditionally skeptical of immigration, Berlin appears to have concluded that the economic benefits of improved ties with Russia will be sufficient to offset the downside.

After the Brussels meeting on May 10, Germany was described as the "swing state" by the Finnish Foreign Minister Alexander Stubb -- representing another country which has pursued an increasingly pragmatic course in its relationship with Moscow over the past few years.


Copyright (c) 2009. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
Friday, May 14, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Top 10 'Don'ts' For Diasporans In Armenia

By Dro Tsarian

(The Armenian Reporter) -- While the number of amazing "to do" things in Armenia are too long to list, below is a list of ten simple things each Diaspora visitor can do to be helpful to Armenia on his or her trip, and to also protect oneself.

If each visitor from Diaspora does his or her small part to set the right example and to also demand the same from locals, Armenia will improve a lot quicker.

So on your next visit, remember that you can not only have a great holiday but also give back to Armenia by helping make this place a better place to live for everyone.

1. Do not throw trash on the floor or leave trash outside of the city where there are no trash cans. Bring the trash back to the city and find a trash can to throw it in.

2. Do not allow anyone to cut in front of you in lines for any reason. Waiting in lines in an organized manner is lacking amongst many locals, so set an example of how people should wait their turn in lines.

3. Do not give bribes to anyone or for anything. You can get most everything done in Armenia legally only if you insist on your rights and do not take short cuts by giving bribes.

4. Do not give money to beggars who thrive on summer seasons scavenging of off tourists. Most of them work in groups or with sponsors and have their designated areas where they know the most money can be made. If you want to help beggars, buy them food.

5. Do not be fooled by sob stories from your driver or recently met friend in Armenia in order to convince you to give financial help. It's not atypical of some cunning locals to play on patriotic emotions of Diasporans in order to make a quick financial gain.

6. Do not buy any real estate or valuable items at anywhere near the listed price. Always offer half and up to 1/5 of the price you've been quoted. It's quite normal by locals to offer ridiculously high prices to Diasporans while they would never quote similar prices to other locals.

7. Do not allow taxi drivers to start driving without putting on their meter and do not sit in taxies that don't have official yellow license plates or are without meters. Ask if their meter works before you get into the taxi.

8. Do not cross intersections on red lights, wait until the light green and demand cars to stop for you to cross the intersection. Set an example for those pedestrians and drivers who have yet to learn the traffic laws.

9. If you are not a smoker, do not start smoking in Armenia because "everyone else" does. Set an example that smoking is not "cool" and that smoking is increasingly uncommon and looked down upon.

10. Finally, do not bring your black clothing with you to Armenia. There is a big lack of color in clothing in Armenia as vast majority of the locals wear mostly black specially in colder months, so bring your colorful clothing to add some color to the city.
Thursday, May 13, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Archbishop Aykazian: Azerbaijan Wants Dialogue

By Emil Sanamyan

(The Armenian Reporter) -- On April 26, Catholicos Karekin II traveled to Baku, Azerbaijan, to participate in the World Summit of Religious Leaders. His Holiness attended the summit at the invitation of its co-chairs Kirill I, Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia, and Sheikh ul-Islam Haji Allahshukur Hummat Pashazade, Grand Mufti of Azerbaijan.

Archbishop Vicken Aykazian, Legate of the Eastern Diocese in Washington, also took part in the summit in his capacity as the past president of the National Council of Churches in the U.S.

On April 29, The Armenian Reporter's editor Emil Sanamyan asked Archbishop Aykazian to share his immediate impressions.

Aykazian. The most impressive was the city of Baku. It is very beautiful, very organized, very clean. It reminded me a little bit of Istanbul. When you see the old city, of which I saw very little, you understand that there was a culture and it is not just the petrol money.

But from what I understand, a lot of work has been done under President Aliyev. Highways are extremely good, particularly the road from the airport to the city is very beautiful and along the road they have built walls with motifs [that block the view from the road].

So [when you arrive] the first impressions are very good, as opposed to Yerevan, say, where the road from the airport to the city is quite depressing.

The conference was also well-organized. I have to say much better than the conference held in Moscow a few years ago, which I also attended.

The security was very tight. As we arrived, the road from the airport to the conference venue in Baku was shut down and there were police on every street corner.

And same happened when Catholicos went to meet Ilham Aliyev at presidential palace.

Q. Was it a last-moment trip for you?

A. I had an invitation on behalf of the National Council of Churches, but I was not initially planning to go. But I spoke with the Catholicos, he told me that he received a personal invitation from the Russian Patriarch and Sheikh-ul-Islam and was planning to attend, and suggested that I come along.

So I went on behalf of NCC, but flew in with Catholicos from Yerevan directly to Baku. An Armenian businessman from Russian offered a plane to us and it took only 45 minutes to fly from Yerevan to Baku.

Q. There were reports just a couple of weeks before the conference which quoted Sheikh-ul-Islam as expressing doubt that Catholicos would be coming.

A. There was some doubt that the trip would take place, unless a joint statement from the Russian Patriarch, Catholicos and Sheikh-ul-Islam could be agreed on in advance. Catholicos wanted to have a balanced statement before he went to Baku. And when that was ready, the trip took place.

We arrived about 9 AM and left about 10 PM at night. In addition to the summit, we visited [the building of] the Armenian church of St. Gregory the Illuminator. There was a fire in 1990 there that destroyed the frescoes. The cross is missing and alter has been destroyed, but the premises have been renovated and now well-kept.

The building now stores books, including some 6,000 books in Armenian language as we were told. The lady who handles those books is an Azerbaijani from Yerevan and speaks perfect Armenian.

Q. What would you say is the significance of this trip?

A. Everyone felt it was a very historic event. We hope that it will diffuse tensions at least a little bit. I don't know how effective it is going to be. But at least we have shown that we are ready to talk and Catholicos has invited Sheikh-ul-Islam to come to Yerevan and he accepted.

Q. The image of the Armenian Church - anything Armenian really - in Azerbaijan has been very negative in how it has been presented over the years by state officials and media. There are also the frequent threats made by Azerbaijan of going to war with Armenia. How did that reconcile with the invitation for Catholicos to visit?

A. Religious leaders came together because we believe that we can play a very positive role in helping achieve a peaceful solution of the Karabakh conflict. The religious leaders may not have the political power but they can influence those in power.

It is important to note that already in 1993 through the World Council of Churches mediation, Sheikh-ul-Islam together with Catholicos Vazgen I issued a statement that noted that Karabakh was not a religious conflict. And the Baku communiqué reiterated that.

Q. But Azerbaijan has actively sought support for its position within the Organization of Islamic Conference (OIC) and has been backed by majority of OIC members at the United Nations.

A. That is true. But at the same time, Islamic groups or organization have never described the conflict as religious. Even Azerbaijani religious leaders have not issued calls for jihad. There have been statements that such a call could be issued, but it has not materialized and I doubt that it will.

Q. What is your sense of the role of Sheikh-ul-Islam Pashazade in Azerbaijan today?

A. It is hard to say. But I think he is respected and my impression is that he is a good man. I was impressed by his simplicity. He was very cordial and polite with Catholicos, leaving more than 100 guests at the conference to accompany Catholicos to the airport. So the impression was of a humble, simple person.

And of course the fact that he accepted the invitation to come to Armenia means that the dialogue would continue.

Q. There has been some criticism in Armenia that Catholicos agreed to go to a country whose government continues to target Armenian religious heritage sites, with the recent destruction of the medieval cemetery of Old Jugha perhaps the most prominent example. Were those issues raised in Baku?
Friday, May 07, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

The Road To Europe For The South Caucasus Countries Is Open

By LINKS

When the EU Commissioner for Enlargement and Neighbourhood Policy, Stefan Fule, addressed the Foreign Affairs Committee of the European Parliament on 28 April he referred to relations between the EU and the South Caucasus countries. Unusually, his tone was upbeat. He had just returned back from what by all accounts was a successful first trip to the region.

“There was a clear and loud message to Europe that I heard throughout my trip to Armenia, Georgia and Azerbaijan” Fule said. “Presidents, Prime Ministers, parliamentarians, opposition and civil society all confirmed that they wanted a closer, deeper and fuller relationship with the EU”. Fule said that his message to interlocutors in Yerevan, Tbilisi and Baku was that “the EU is also prepared to step up a gear and to develop concrete areas where a strengthened relationship can make a real difference for people in the South Caucasus and in the EU”.

EU membership is still something that neither Brussels, nor indeed the governments of the three countries are ready to talk about. Yet in the next weeks the process of negotiating and signing separate Association agreements will start. This is likely to be a long process stretched over as much as five years. But in the meantime various provisions can start coming into force which will help bring the two sides closer together as the negotiations continue. The principals that underpin the EU position in these negotiations are "inclusiveness, differentiation, conditionality and joint ownership”. Successful association agreements are considered as important prerequisites for full membership, though they do not automatically lead to it.

Over the next years the political elites in the three countries – and this will need a wider base of support than simply small groups around the three presidents, will have to decide if they have the will and the stamina to start, and to eventually complete the long journey on the road to Europe. This is by no means certain.

Although governments and civil society alike in the region like to wrap themselves in the European flag they do not always (some say they rarely) act in a way that is conducive to the European model.

There are four main areas where much work still needs to be done: in the area of reform and democratisation, the region still suffers from a serious democratic deficit and the reform process, political as well as economic is far from complete. Senior leaders in all three countries openly express disdain at Europe’ attempts to bring attention to shortcoming such as in elections, with regards to freedom of speech and corruption. Yet the Association agreements that will start to be negotiated soon envisage a “a close political association” built on “common values and shared principles”.

A second area is the resolution of the outstanding conflicts that impact the three countries very deeply. Armenia and Azerbaijan need to sort out the problem over Karabakh before full EU membership will ever be considered. EU membership may be part of the solution if they decide to go this way. With Georgia the situation is more complicated now that Russia is directly involved in the issues of South Ossetia and Abkhazia.

However the European dimension may help to focus minds in Tbilisi over the end game with regards to these territories. The third area for EU-South Caucasus interaction is Energy, Trade and sustainable development. The region is important for European energy security and this gives it clout in the Brussels corridors of power. Discussions are likely to start soon on developing “deep and comprehensive free trade areas”, in parallel with the association agreements. Finally the fourth area for the EU-South Caucasus interaction is in the field of human resources and human development. Here the EU has much to give and this is where the Union needs to be generous, creative and forward looking. It is the young and educated generation of Armenians,
Azerbaijanis and Georgians - not to mention Abkhaz and Ossetians, who need to be the instruments of change amongst their communities. More extensive contacts between universities and think tanks, deeper cultural contacts, and more importantly a freer exchange of information and knowledge is required. This will require European will and European money, but it will also require the will of the governments of the region to snap out of their isolated mental comfort zones and join the European process of openness. Europe needs a communications strategy for the region that talks directly to the populations.

The relations between the EU and the South Caucasus are entering a new phase. The Georgia-Russia war of August 2008 triggered a new sense of awareness in Europe of the region, its problems, but also its potentials. The future needs to be built on the positive and must not be crisis driven. The signs are that even though cautiously and with some trepidation the EU is now ready to turn its relationship with the region into something really meaningful.

The question remains are the governments of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia ready for this? The answer will not be in cheap rhetoric of which there has been a lot, particularly in Georgia. The answer must be in facts: in the willingness of these countries to continue and complete the reform process; in their willingness to find peaceful solutions to the regional conflicts; in their willingness to open up their economies and not least in their willingness to maximise the potential of their own people. The next few years will give us an answer.


LINKS is a British non governmental organisation working for the peaceful resolution of conflicts and in support of democracy and sustainable development in societies in transition, through dialogue and innovative initiatives. 
Friday, May 07, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Armenian Police In Rare Apology Over Torture

By Ruzanna Stepanian

(RFE/RL) -- In an unprecedented public apology, the head of Armenia’s police service has admitted misleading the nation about the recent death of a young man in police custody.

Alik Sargsian on April 30 said he was “deceived” by his subordinates into thinking that Vahan Khalafian was not ill-treated at a police station in Charentsavan, a small town in central Armenia.

“I am going to punish all of my employees who gave me incorrect information and thereby put me in an awkward situation,” he said in a written statement sent to RFE/RL’s Armenian Service through a spokesman.

His statement came one day after Ashot Harutiunian, a senior police officer in Charentsavan, was formally charged with torturing Khalafian to extract a confession about a theft committed in the town. The 24-year-old died in police custody, with his relatives insisting that he was tortured to death.

Armenia’s Special Investigative Service (SIS) said the charge is based on testimony given by other local police officers.

The police have previously denied mistreating Khalafian. “I want to make clear that there was no torture,” Sargsian insisted on April 20.

Suicide Claim

The police chief, who was promoted to the rank of lieutenant general by President Serzh Sarkisian shortly after the April 13 incident, said on April 30 he based those claims on assurances given to him by the police department of the Kotayk region, which includes Charentsavan.

“I am not going to defend anyone and all the guilty [people] will be punished,” said Sargsian. “I never encouraged beatings. There are more proper ways of doing the job.”

“Let those people whom I misinformed with my statements forgive me,” he added. “As for those who deceived me, they will be punished with all the strictness of the law. I am not going to forgive anyone.”

Sargsian, however, stuck to police claims that Khalafian grabbed a knife from a police officer’s drawer and stabbed himself to death after the interrogation. “I continue to insist that it was suicide,” he said.


SIS, which is subordinate to state prosecutors, said on April 29 that it will draw a final conclusion about what caused Khalafian’s death only after ongoing forensic examinations of his body are complete.

Artur Sakunts, a human rights campaigner closely monitoring the case, has backed the Khalafian family’s claim that forensic medics found at least two stab wounds in his stomach.

“How could a tortured and beaten young man quickly find a knife in a room totally unfamiliar to him?” Sakunts told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service. “How did he know where it was kept? Or did they put the knife on a table and tell him to kill himself?… So I believe what happened was murder.”

While welcoming the police apology, Sakunts said Sargsian should have gone further and stepped down.

“This is not an ordinary incident,” he said. “A person died in police custody. In normal countries, the police chief at least resigns in such circumstances. Not to mention bearing personal responsibility for his subordinates’ abuses.”

“A mere apology can not change the situation,” he added.


Copyright (c) 2009. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036. 
Monday, May 03, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Armenia Ex-President’s Wild Games

By Simon Maghakyan

Newly-revealed summer 2009 photos of ex-Soviet Armenia’s former president Robert Kocharian posing with hunted “wild game,” including a lion, in Tanzania have Armenian bloggers talking. Yet few seem surprised – a national reserve employee’s illegal boar hunting and an oligarchic donkey-lion fight were caught on tape the same year. One blogger, nonetheless, reads political overtones in the ex-president’s luxurious safari adventures.

The Armenian Observer Blog, Artur Papyan’s resourceful site, posts one of the controversial photographs with the following note:
Armenia’s second President Robert Kocharian is a big fan of safaris. Here he is proudly posing on a killed lion. Years of observing Kocharian have taught me one thing – he never does anything without a purpose. The fact he has posed on a lion means he wanted to let everyone know he is the lion killing kind.

Coincidentally, the animal’s name is synonymous to the name of Kocharian’s bitter political rival, Armenia’s first President Levon Ter-Petrossian. In a recent display of distaste for each other, Kocharian told an allegoric story about his African safaris, directing pro-Ter-Petrossian media to finding and publicising this very photo, which made a headline story on “Haykakan Zhamanak” today.
[…]
Ahuramazd, a pro-opposition Live Journal community member, posts four photographs without comment. But he prompts quite a discussion.

Fellow user Dabavog reacts in Armenian:
The lack of harmony between Armenians (especially the government) and nature requires a special study. (translated)

Pigh, a pro-government activist, defends the former president in Russian:
[Ara]mazd, what’s the crime? You don’t eat meat? (translated)

Simon Maghakyan is a native of Armenia and a graduate student in political science at University of Colorado Denver. He is also an alumnus of the International Institute for Genocide and Human Rights Studies. Connect to Simon’s blog at www.blogian.net.
Saturday, May 01, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

In Turkey 'People Are Rebelling' Against Armenia Genocide Denial

By Lou Ann Matossian

(The Armenian Reporter) -- As Armenians in Yerevan laid flowers at the Eternal Flame on the 95th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, Turkish citizens in Istanbul solemnly commemorated April 24 with candles and red carnations-despite protests from ultranationalists and the denial policy of their own government.

Seated on the steps outside Haydarpa'a Station, activists from the Istanbul Human Rights Association held carnations and posters of Armenian community leaders whose arrest and deportation from that very place had heralded the Young Turks' extermination campaign. "April 24, 1915-Never Again" proclaimed the organization's banner as human rights attorney Eren Keskin addressed the solemn group.

"The events of 1915 must not be repeated," Ms. Keskin was quoted in press reports. "We have gathered here to say no to genocide."

Turkish police stood guard at the peaceful demonstration of about 100 mourners, keeping counter-demonstrators at bay. As journalists' cameras clicked and whirred, Ms. Keskin and the others threw their flowers into the Bosphorus, closing the vigil on the Asian shore of Istanbul.

That same evening in the heart of downtown, on the European side, the Initiative to Say No to Racism and Nationalism held a peaceful sit-down demonstration in bustling Taksim Square.

A large black placard, inscribed "This is OUR pain. This is a mourning for ALL OF US," in Turkish, Armenian, and English, was placed on the ground with bouquets of red carnations and rows of votive candles resembling red apples.

"In 1915, when we had a population of only 13 million people, there were 1.5 to 2 million Armenians living on this land," an organizer proclaimed in Turkish. More than 200 mourners sat in silence as she named the cities and regions where Ottoman Armenians had lived, from Kars in the east to Thrace in the west.

"They were the grocer in our neighborhood, our tailor, our goldsmith, our carpenter, our shoemaker, our farmhand, our millwright, our classmate, our teacher, our officer, our private, our deputy, our historian, our composer...our friend," the statement continued. "Our next-door neighbors and our companion in bad times.

"On April 24th, 1915, they were ‘rounded up'. We lost them. They are not here anymore. A great majority of them do not exist anymore. Nor do their graveyards," the organizer read out, evoking "the overwhelming ‘Great Pain' that was laid upon the qualms of our conscience by the ‘Great Catastrophe'."

Clark University professor Taner Akçam, an endorser of the Taksim Square statement, called the April 24th commemorations in Turkey a "serious crack in the wall" of silence and denial. "The other Turkey-the Turkey that doesn't belong to denialists-is coming to the surface," he told the Armenian Reporter.

"People are rebelling," he concluded. "They are saying, ‘We want to learn the truth'."

Without identifying the Armenian Genocide as such, the statement urged "all peoples of Turkey who share this heartfelt pain to commemorate and pay tribute to the victims of 1915." (The full text, posted online at buacihepimizin.org with some 1,500 signatures, was endorsed by about 80 prominent intellectuals and activists in Turkish society.)

Shouts of "Death to the Armenian Diaspora!" could be heard from counter-demonstrators as the mourners paused in silent commemoration, reported an eyewitness, Armenian Weekly editor Khatchig Mouradian. "This is Turkey! Love it or leave it!" chanted a group of angry men from behind police lines, in a video shot at the scene and posted to YouTube. Haranguing the mourners as traitors, they extended their first and fourth fingers in the ultranationalist Grey Wolf gesture.

At the close of the vigil, the mourners tossed carnations into the air, reported Hürriyet. "The brotherhood of Armenians, Turks, and Kurds!" they chanted, marching down Istiklal Avenue. "Shoulder to shoulder against fascism!"

Additional public vigils were reportedly held in Galatasaray, not far from Taksim Square, by Kurdish mothers of "disappeared" children, and outside the offices of Agos Armenian newspaper, where editor Hrant Dink was gunned down in January 2007.

A reparations debate in Ankara

In Ankara, meanwhile, international scholars and writers participated in a two-day conference on "1915 within its pre- and post-historical periods," organized by the Ankara Freedom of Thought Initiative. Nearly cancelled due to political and bureaucratic obstacles, the panels were held under tight security, with no counter-demonstrations permitted. Unusually for a conference in Turkey, proponents of the government's "official history" were notably absent from the list of invited presenters.

Nevertheless, a panel on "The Armenian Issue: What is to be done and how?" sparked plenty of controversy as Worcester State University philosopher Henry Theriault called for genocide reparations. Turkey should return or compensate for Armenian property, wealth, slave labor, pain and suffering, and the loss of 1.5 million people, as well as cultural, religious, and educational losses, Prof. Theriault stated.

Although Sevan Nishanian of Agos newspaper flatly rejected these demands as unjust and unproductive, author Temel Demirer and Welsh writer-activist Eilian Williams defended them, according to The Armenian Weekly's Mouradian, who participated in the intense debate among the panelists and audience members.
Saturday, May 01, 2010 | 10 comments | Read more...

Distance Between Armenia And Turkey Too Far To Be Travelled In One Go

By LINKS

The President of Armenia Serzh Sargsyan, last Thursday addressed the nation in a sombre but calm tone, to announce that the process of normalisation of relations with Turkey that he had initiated soon after taking office in 2008 was being suspended. Sargsyan was accepting a reality that has been obvious for a number of months, namely that despite the political will in the leadership in both Armenia and Turkey to normalise relations, the distance separating the two countries was too long for the journey to be travelled in one go.
 
Neither Turkey nor Armenia are yet ready to take the last historic step that would see the two countries establish diplomatic relations, and the border opened. Admittedly, Sargsyan went further to stick his neck out in this process than did Turkish Prime Minister Tayib Erdogan, and so for the moment Armenia feels it has occupied the “moral” high ground in this affair, at least with the international community. Washington, Moscow, Brussels and other capitals rushed to heap praise on Sargsyan for stopping short of declaring the process dead. In his speech Sargsyan was even able to find words to praise Turkish President Abdulla Gul, who many see as being the main Turkish architect of the reconciliation process.

Today, Armenia, and Armenians in the diaspora, mark the 95th anniversary of the 1915 events in Anatolia, described by Armenians and many others as the “Armenian Genocide”. It is an anniversary that raises emotions on both sides. Its significance and implications have become deeply embroiled not only in the politics of modern day Armenia and Turkey, but also in the internal politics of the United States and a number of European countries, where diaspora organisations, lobbyists and interest groups are engaged in acrimonious exchanges.

Many people died in Anatolia in 1915 and the quicker their memory can be remembered by everybody in a dignified way that unites rather than divides the better for all Armenians and all Turks. One hopes that by the time of the 100th anniversary in 2015 this would be possible.

Much will depend on when the Armenia-Turkey dialogue process can be resumed. Both sides can build on the distance that they have already travelled. Domestic political factors in the two countries create serious obstacles for both sides. However the biggest obstacle that emerged over the last year was the opposition of Azerbaijan to the process moving separately from negotiations on the resolution of the Karabakh conflict. Armenia rejects the linkage, whilst Turkey now accepts that that is the case. Those who reject the connection argue that Armenia-Turkish relations are complex enough without adding Karabakh as a further complication on top of them. However there is a case to argue that introducing such a connection may not in the end be such a bad thing. It has introduced a sense of urgency in the Karabakh negotiations that some say is long overdue.

The international community needs to remain fully engaged in supporting both Armenia and Turkey and Armenia and Azerbaijan to resolve the problems between them. The journey is long, but it does not need to be endless.


LINKS is a British non governmental organisation working for the peaceful resolution of conflicts and in support of democracy and sustainable development in societies in transition, through dialogue and innovative initiatives. 
Wednesday, April 28, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Georgia MPs Say Ready For 'Broad Discussions On Circassian Genocide'

(Civil.Ge) -- A group of Georgian lawmakers announced on April 26 about the readiness to launch "broad discussions on cases of the massacres and deportations of Circassians" by the Tsarist Russia in the North Caucasus in second half of 19th century.

The announcement by the Georgian parliamentary group of friendship with the peoples of North Caucasus comes a month after Tbilisi hosted a conference, Hidden Nations, Enduring Crimes: The Circassians & the Peoples of the North Caucasus Between Past and Future. The conference was organized by Washington-based Jamestown Foundation and Tbilisi-based Ilia State University’s International School for Caucasus Studies with the participants including, among others, representatives of Circassian diaspora.

At the end of the conference, on March 21, participants made an appeal to the Georgian Parliament requesting to recognize deportations and massacre of Circassians more than a century ago as a genocide.

"You know that the international conference was held in Tbilisi in March with consequent appeal to the Georgian Parliament... We think that the first stage of these discussions should be an active consultation with our and foreign academic circles, political experts," a ruling party lawmaker, Nugzar Tsiklauri, who is a member of the parliamentary group of friendship with the North Caucasian people, said on April 26.

"We deem it necessary to further broaden scope of discussions on the matter both within and outside Georgia," he added.

The appeal also request the Georgian Parliament to declare May 21, "which marks the Russian celebration of the occupation of the North West Caucasus in 1864, as a memorial day of the victims of the Circassian genocide, and to recognize Sochi as the location and symbol of Circassian genocide and ethnic cleansing."

In mid-April, an anonymous YouTube user posted on its account, launched just a day earlier, several audio files of what is claimed to be recorded phone conversations between senior Georgian officials and diplomats, suggesting that Tbilisi is building contacts with representatives of North Caucasian communities living outside Russia.

In one of the audio files (several of them are of poor quality and inaudible), which is described as "a conversation between Georgian Interior Minister Vano Merabishvili and Georgia's ambassador to the United States Batu Kutelia", the man's voice which is very much similar to the one of Merabishvili tells interlocutor that there was a misunderstanding and no meeting of the Georgian President with an Ingush man, identified with a first name - Ibragim, was planned.

"Yes we meet with North Caucasians time after time, but not the President... We are summoning them separately and talking with them... Givi [apparently referring to a senior ruling party lawmaker Givi Targamadze] and [Gia] Tortladze [a lawmaker from parliamentary minority] usually meet them and I also meet them sometimes."

In another audio file, a man, porportadly MP Givi Targamadze, alledgeldy speaks with Georgia's ambassador to Egypt and Syria, Gocha Japaridze and tells him "to find as many as possible North Caucasian organizations - Circassian, Ingush, Chechen etc." in Egypt and Syria.

"To put it directly, in our Parliament we are intending to recognize thier genocide... So now we are intensively engaged in searching for these people everywhere, including in Turkey, Jordan; I have already spoken with ambassadors there... Now I'm with Vano, together discussing this matter," the man with voice very much similar to the one of MP Givi Targamadze tells the interlocutor.

On April 23, a day before the 95th anniversary of the start of the massacre of Armenians in Ottoman Empire was marked, a group of Armenian community in Tbilisi made a formal appeal to the Georgian Parliament - one of many other similar appeals made in previous years - requesting to recognize mass killings of Armenians century ago as a genocide. There has been no formal response by the Georgian Parliament to those appeals.
Tuesday, April 27, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Excluding Azerbaijan Can't Bring Stability To The South Caucasus

By Novruz Mammadov

The United States has recently stepped up efforts to repair relations between Turkey and Armenia. Turkey closed its border with Armenia in 1993 in response to the occupation of Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding Azerbaijani territories by Armenian forces. Lately, U.S. officials have been urging Turkey to ignore Armenia's continuing occupation and reopen the border. While Washington says that its aim is to improve stability and development throughout the region, in reality U.S. policies have become increasingly pro-Armenian -- and exclusive of Azerbaijan.

Washington believes that a Turkish-Armenian rapprochement could kill two birds with one stone. First, it might smooth over -- at least temporarily -- one of the major trouble spots in U.S.-Turkish relations: the issue of Armenian genocide claims. Second, some U.S. officials argue that improving ties between Armenia and Turkey will ultimately contribute to a resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. They appear to believe improved relations will lead to a moderation of Armenian policies and open the way to new initiatives on Karabakh.

However, we must disagree. Armenia continues to occupy almost 20 percent of Azerbaijan's internationally recognized territory. It is ironic that while claiming to be the first victim of genocide in the 20th century, Armenia itself carried out one of the century's major ethnic-cleansing campaigns in Europe -- a campaign that resulted in thousands of deaths and the displacement of nearly 1 million Azerbaijanis. Many members of the Armenian political elite -- including President Serzh Sarkisian -- rose through the ranks because of their personal involvement in the Nagorno-Karabakh war. They have used the war as a pretext for strengthening their own hold over Armenian politics, so it is not surprising that they have not been constructive in settlement talks.

Pretext For Occupation

Azerbaijan has proposed granting the highest form of autonomy to Nagorno-Karabakh and is prepared to invest heavily in the region's development once a peace deal is reached. Baku has been cooperating closely with the Minsk Group of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) to resolve the conflict peacefully.

However, Armenia remains intransient, and this creates the suspicion that Yerevan wants to keep the conflict unresolved as an excuse for indefinite occupation.

In this context, Armenia's closed borders are the main form of leverage that might compel Yerevan to engage seriously in the resolution of the conflict. There is no reason to believe that opening the borders will make Armenia more willing to compromise; on the contrary, removing this sole punishment will only increase Armenia's interest in further entrenching the status quo.

We understand that Armenia has a powerful diaspora and that justice does not necessarily always prevail. Over the last 15 years, despite maintaining the occupation of part of a neighboring country, Armenia has received preferential treatment from the West, which has actually punished Azerbaijan. The infamous Section 907 of the U.S. Freedom Support Act, which banned direct U.S. aid to Azerbaijan, is a clear example of this. Western governments and media have largely been silent on the plight of the nearly 1 million Azerbaijanis who were displaced by Armenian aggression. This has naturally led the Azerbaijani public to think that the West's talk of democracy and human rights is nothing more than a selectively applied method of promoting its own interests.

In Defense Of Justice

It is high time for the United States and Europe to adopt a fair position and to prevent the narrow interests of their Armenian lobbies from prevailing over justice and their own national interests.

In any event, attempts to pressure Ankara to abandon Azerbaijan are shortsighted and likely to backfire. Azerbaijan and Turkey are strategic allies with deep historical ties. Turkey has played an important role in Azerbaijan's partnership with the West on key security and energy projects. Azerbaijan spearheaded the opening of Caspian energy resources to the West and insisted that major oil and gas pipelines be routed through Georgia and Turkey.

Baku has also wholeheartedly supported U.S. security initiatives by sending troops to Kosovo, Iraq, and Afghanistan. Azerbaijan also provides supply-transit support for the NATO effort in Afghanistan. Those who know the region understand the significant risks Azerbaijan took and the pressure it overcame in order to pursue close cooperation with the West on energy and security issues.

Long-term peace and normalization of relations in the South Caucasus cannot be achieved by rewarding aggression and by excluding the region's strategically most important country. By pushing Turkey to abandon Azerbaijan, the United States risks alienating one of its most important and reliable partners in a critical region of the world.

Novruz Mammadov is head of the Foreign Relations Department of the presidential administration of Azerbaijan. The views expressed in this commentary are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of RFE/R, where this article was first published.

Copyright (c) 2009. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036. 
Sunday, April 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Statement Of President Barack Obama On Armenian Remembrance Day

On this solemn day of remembrance, we pause to recall that ninety-five years ago one of the worst atrocities of the 20th century began. In that dark moment of history, 1.5 million Armenians were massacred or marched to their death in the final days of the Ottoman Empire.

Today is a day to reflect upon and draw lessons from these terrible events. I have consistently stated my own view of what occurred in 1915, and my view of that history has not changed. It is in all of our interest to see the achievement of a full, frank and just acknowledgment of the facts. The Meds Yeghern is a devastating chapter in the history of the Armenian people, and we must keep its memory alive in honor of those who were murdered and so that we do not repeat the grave mistakes of the past. I salute the Turks who saved Armenians in 1915 and am encouraged by the dialogue among Turks and Armenians, and within Turkey itself, regarding this painful history. Together, the Turkish and Armenian people will be stronger as they acknowledge their common history and recognize their common humanity.

Even as we confront the inhumanity of 1915, we also are inspired by the remarkable spirit of the Armenian people. While nothing can bring back those who were killed in the Meds Yeghern, the contributions that Armenians have made around the world over the last ninety-five years stand as a testament to the strength, tenacity and courage of the Armenian people. The indomitable spirit of the Armenian people is a lasting triumph over those who set out to destroy them. Many Armenians came to the United States as survivors of the horrors of 1915. Over the generations Americans of Armenian descent have richened our communities, spurred our economy, and strengthened our democracy. The strong traditions and culture of Armenians also became the foundation of a new republic which has become a part of the community of nations, partnering with the world community to build a better future.

Today, we pause with them and with Armenians everywhere to remember the awful events of 1915 with deep admiration for their contributions which transcend this dark past and give us hope for the future.
Sunday, April 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Armenians Mourn World War I-Era Killings

Tens of thousands of Armenians gathered in the capital of Yerevan under cloudy skies Saturday to remember mass killings of Armenians by Ottoman Turks.

Rain fell as they placed flowers at a hilltop memorial on the 95th anniversary of the World War I-era deaths.

Armenian President Serzh Sarkisyan thanked countries all over the world, including Turkey, that "understand the importance of preventing crimes against humanity."

Armenia says the killings of an estimated 1.5 million Armenians between 1915 and 1923 constituted genocide, a charge rejected by Turkey. Turkey says the death toll is greatly exaggerated, and that the Armenians died in a civil war that accompanied the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.

U.S. President Barack Obama released a statement Saturday calling the killings "one of the worst atrocities of the 20th century" but avoided using the term, genocide.

Mr. Obama said he is encouraged by dialogue between Turks and Armenians, and within Turkey over what he called "this painful history."

Turkey briefly recalled its ambassador to the United States after a U.S. congressional panel passed a resolution labeling the World War I-era killings a genocide.

Turkish officials have also been pressuring U.S. officials to make sure the measure is not ratified by the full House of Representatives.

The killings, which Armenians call the Meds Yeghern, were also commemorated in several major cities around the world, including Moscow, Beirut and Jerusalem.

The day was also marked by human rights activists in the Turkish city of Istanbul. They gathered outside a railway station holding pictures of Armenians killed during World War One. They later threw flowers into the water a sign or mourning.

This year's anniversary comes as efforts to normalize relations between Armenia and Turkey have broken down.

Despite the renewed tensions, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said his government is committed to normalizing ties with Armenia.

Source: VOA
Sunday, April 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Obama Again Fails To Call Armenian Mass Killings 'Genocide'

U.S. President Barack Obama again did not use the word "genocide" in his statement to mark the 95th anniversary of the mass killings in Armenia, leaving both Turks and Armenians dissatisfied.

Instead, he described the tragedy as a "devastating chapter in the history of the Armenian people," and urged to "keep its memory alive in honor of those who were murdered and so that we do not repeat the grave mistakes of the past."

"I have consistently stated my own view of what occurred in 1915, and my view of that history has not changed. It is in all of our interest to see the achievement of a full, frank and just acknowledgment of the facts," he said in a statement, published on the White House website.

He called on the two countries to repair diplomatic ties, which were severed, among other things, over differing positions on the massacre, which Ankara denies was an act of genocide.

After the Turkish genocide in Armenia was first recognized by Uruguay in 1965, many countries followed suit, including Russia. It was also recognized in 42 U.S. states, by the Vatican and the European Parliament.

Obama repeatedly promised during his election campaign to recognize genocide of Armenians. Yet for a second year as president, he refused to do so and activists from both sides were quick to express their disappointment.

The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) said the U.S. president made "yet another disgraceful capitulation to Turkey's threats... offering euphemisms and evasive terminology to characterize this crime against humanity."

"President Obama faced a stark choice: to honor his conscience and commitment to recognize the Armenian Genocide or to remain an accomplice to Turkey's denial of truth and justice for this crime," ANCA Chairman Ken Hachikian said in a statement.

"Sadly, for the U.S. and worldwide efforts to end the cycle of genocide, he made the wrong choice, allowing Turkey to tighten its gag-rule on American genocide policy," he added.

Turkish groups in the U.S. have also been quick with a reply, reproaching the president for failing to mention "the equally tragic loss of even more Muslim lives in this turbulent period."

"Where does the ethnic cleansing of Ottoman Turks from the Balkans, Eastern Turkey and the Caucuses with 5 million lost and 5.5 million refugees come on the President's list of "worst atrocities of the 20th century"? Do they also deserve at least an annual presidential remembrance from him, as he dutifully makes on this occasion every year?" the Turkish Coalition of America said in a statement.

The organization called on to recognize these "not to diminish Armenian suffering, but to respect all human loss... and to place the Armenian tragedy in its proper historical context."



Source: RIA Novosti
Sunday, April 25, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...

Nancy Pelosi: “We Are All Armenians!”

By Emil Sanamyan

"Tonight we are all Armenians!" House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) declared as she began her address at the annual congressional commemoration of the Armenian Genocide on April 21.

"We are tired of the [Genocide denial] story being sold but we are not tired of the fight for the truth," Pelosi insisted as she spoke in front of some 200 people, mostly Armenian Americans.

Speaker noted the importance of last month's House Foreign Affairs Committee vote on the Armenian Genocide resolution that "insisted on the truth" and expressed hope that the vote was "of some comfort" to Armenian Americans.

Pelosi added that she and other supporters of affirmation would not rest until the federal government clearly recognizes the Armenian Genocide, but she made no specific commitments about bringing the House resolution to vote, a move that is opposed by the Obama Administration.

She also referred to last year's court decision in California that referred to the U.S. government position as justification for denying Armenian Americans an opportunity to collect on WWI-era insurance policies of their ancestors.

The event organized by co-chairs of the Armenian caucus Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) and Mark Kirk (R-Ill.), included House Majority leader Steny Hoyer (D-Md.) and Chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee Howard Berman (D-Calif.).

Other members included two Reps. of Armenian descents Anna Eshoo (D-Calif.) and Jackie Speier (D-Calif.), key Genocide resolution resolution sponsors Reps. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), Brad Sherman (D-Calif.) and Ed Royce (R-Calif.), as well as Reps. Lois Capps (D-Calif.), Jim Costa (D-Calif.), David Dreier (R-Calif.), Elliott Engel (D-N.Y.), Scott Garrett (R-N.J.), Rush Holt (D-N.J.), Dan Lipinski (D-Ill.), Ed Markey (D-Mass.), George Miller (D-Calif.), Steve Rothman (D-N.J.) and Bobby Scott (D-Va.).

The event also featured remarks by Armenia's Ambassador to U.S. Tatoul Markarian, Artsakh's Representative Robert Avetisyan, and invocations by the Armenian Church clergy, including Archbishop Oshagan Choloyan who offered an opening prayer for the House of Representatives earlier in the day.

This article originally appeared at The Armenian Reporter and is reprinted with permission.
Saturday, April 24, 2010 | 10 comments | Read more...

Armenia Suspends Reconciliation Process With Turkey

By Marianna Grigoryan


Two days before Armenia commemorates Ottoman Turkey’s World War I-era slayings of ethnic Armenians, President Serzh Sargsyan on April 22 called on Armenia’s parliament to "suspend" the process to ratify reconciliation protocols with Turkey.

Sargyan described the current stage of relations with Turkey as "exhausted." A senior Armenian politician, meanwhile, indicated that the agreement may be recalled from parliament.

In a televised speech to the nation, Sargsyan, who has long backed normalizing ties with Turkey, took issue with what he termed "preconditions" set by Ankara for a peace deal with Armenia. These preconditions, the president contended, caused the process to stall.

"Preconditions" refers primarily to recent comments made by Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who indicated that Turkey would not normalize relations with Armenia unless Yerevan made progress in peace negotiations with Turkish ally Azerbaijan concerning the future of Nagorno-Karabakh. [For background see EurasiaNet’s archive].

"Armenia shall retain her signature under the protocols because we desire to maintain the existing momentum for normalizing relations, because we desire peace," a transcript of the speech published on Sargsyan’s presidential website stated. "Our political objective of normalizing relations between Armenia and Turkey remains valid, and we shall consider moving forward when we are convinced that there is a proper environment in Turkey, and there is leadership in Ankara ready to re-engage in the normalization process."

Armenia’s governing coalition - Sargsyan’s Republican Party of Armenia, the Prosperous Armenia Party and Orinats Yerkir (Rule of Law) Party -- earlier in the day declared that Turkey’s refusal to ratify the agreement "without preconditions" means that "there’s no sense in further continuing the process of their ratification at this stage" in Armenia’s National Assembly.

Republican Party of Armenia spokesperson Eduard Sharmazanov told EurasiaNet.org that the April 22 announcement does not signal a break with the normalization process in full. "We are not withdrawing from the process; we are waiting for a real answer from Turkey -- yes or no, but not an imitation [of real steps toward reconciliation]," Sharmazanov said.

The chair of parliament’s European Integration Parliamentary Committee, Naira Zohrabian, told EurasiaNet.org that President Sargsyan’s recent meetings with coalition leaders suggest that the protocols will be recalled from the National Assembly. Zohrabian, who is also a senior member of the Prosperous Armenia Party, did not elaborate.

A Turkish Foreign Ministry spokesperson told reporters in Ankara that Turkish leaders were considering how to respond to Sargsyan’s announcement. Prime Minister Erdogan later repeated Turkey’s commitment to the reconciliation process.

Sharmazanov claimed that the international community will understand Armenia’s move. He suggested that the Turkish position had the indirect effect of complicating efforts by the United States, Russia and France, the three co-chairs of the Minsk Group, to make progress in the Karabakh peace process. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

"I think the international community will interpret our step as normal since the Armenian side does not recall its signature [of the protocols], but rather suspends the process," Sharmazanov asserted. "In this case, Turkey has no way to escape."

One Yerevan-based analyst questioned the government’s logic. "Trying to correct a mistake through another mistake is wrong," said Tatul Hakobyan, and analyst with the Civilitas Foundation and a former journalist who has written extensively on the Karabakh war.

"The Armenian side shouldn’t have removed discussion of the protocols from the National Assembly agenda, but should have left them there to turn into dust," Hakobyan said. "Now the Turks will start to blame Armenia for spoiling the [reconciliation] process, while Armenia won’t be able to persuade the international community that it’s not Armenia’s fault the process didn’t succeed."

Suren Surenyants, a senior member of the political board of the opposition Republic Party, also believes the international community may react negatively to Armenia’s move. Though senior Turkish officials have repeatedly made statements about "preconditions," the Turkish side never declared it had suspended parliamentary discussion of the protocols, he noted.

"Yerevan was the first to voice this statement," Surenyants said. "Actually, the Turkish authorities achieved their aim by driving Armenia to take an irrational position. It turns out now that not only Turkey, but the Yerevan government as well puts preconditions [on the deal by] stipulating ratification of the protocols based only on Turkey’s position."

A more understandable move for the international community would be if Armenia had allowed the vote on the protocols to proceed and succeed or fail based on the agreement’s own merits, he added.

Zohrabian said the Prosperous Armenia Party would have responded negatively to any National Assembly decision to ratify the agreement. "I think the coalition made a very correct move by suspending the process," Zohrabian said. "This is a political break for Turkey to determine its position, whether it wants to follow a civilized path, or whether it prefers irresponsible declarations and reckless schemes."

Marianna Grigoryan is a freelance reporter based in Yerevan. Copyright (c) 2003 Open Society Institute. Reprinted with the permission of the Open Society Institute, 400 West 59th Street, New York, NY 10019 USA, www.EurasiaNet.org or www.soros.org.
Friday, April 23, 2010 | 0 comments | Read more...



Search Eurasia Review

Custom Search